How Harvard Suddenly Discovered Free Speech...
HTML-код
- Опубликовано: 30 окт 2023
- Greg Lukianoff, First Amendent lawyer and President of the Foundation for Individual Rights and Expression (FIRE), unravels the double standards surrounding issues of free speech and political neutrality at Harvard and other prestigious institutions like it. The current public debate follows the harsh backlash against on-campus protests and public statements in reaction to the recent Israel-Hamas conflict. Lukianoff exposes how Harvard often exhibits a bias during turbulent political events but retreats to a guise of neutrality when convenient, rather than authentically committing to free speech and political openness.
Lukianoff co-authored "The Coddling of the American Mind" with Jonathan Haidt and recently released a new book, "The Canceling of the American Mind," co-authored with Rikki Schlott.
Check out the full episode when it comes out next week!
Subscribe and ring the notification bell so you don’t miss a single video!
Subscribe to the podcast: anchor.fm/emergent-order
Make a tax-deductible donation to Dad Saves America: secure.anedot.com/emergent-or...
"The Canceling of the American Mind": www.amazon.com/Canceling-Amer...
"The Coddling of the American Mind": www.amazon.com/Coddling-Ameri...
Foundation for Individual Rights and Expression: www.thefire.org/
_____________________________________
Our Website: www.dadsavesamerica.com
_____________________________________
Dad Saves America is a channel dedicated to celebrating heroic fatherhood while teaching the next generation of fathers strategies they can utilize in parenting their children. We believe strong children come from a strong family. We’ve had many experts in the studio, including Jonathan Haidt, Dr. Drew Pinsky, Troy Kotsur, John Mackey, Ben Askren, and Adam Carolla.
#freespeech #harvard #cancelculture
Hello friends and families! This is a clip from an upcoming interview with Greg Lukianoff that we wanted to share right away since it's a really good supplement to the video essay we published on our mothership channel, Emergent Order. Reading Greg and Nikki's book The Canceling of the American Mind was so deeply troubling as a parent of a high school senior that it frankly confirmed my worst fears about the state of academia... and that was all super-charged by the obscene explicitly pro-Hamas support that's broken out across these schools.
If you want to see the full essay/monologue, check it out here: ruclips.net/video/tST57kWTrlI/видео.htmlsi=JGPLj7cJjsf1yrLm
There's more of this kind of analysis as well as new documentaries coming soon too. - John Papola
If you say: "horrible terrorist attacks from Hamas" - that's absolutely fine. Not only that, but the US tyranny and MSM is FORCING people to say that"
If someone whould say" "horrible terrorist attacks from the ...." - and these are 20 times more horrible, kill 20 times more people, destroy everything - then you would be called an "anti-semite".
1- Hamas didn't kill 1,400 ... (I can't say it, if I do, "free speech" will be cancelled. Even the Israeli government recognizes that among the dead, only 1.200 were ...
2 - Several J... who were on the places of the Hamas attack, already testified that the IDF was shooting indiscriminately at the places, and killed several .... So, obviously, even blaming 1,200 deaths on Hamas, is a lie.
3 - Both numbers, 1,400, and 1.200 are "round numbers" which means, they aren't real. For now the Israel government should already know exactly how many of their citizens died there. But they don't tell; they stay with their fictitious numbers.
4 - It seems also, the whole burning of corpses was done by the IDF, that's why they weren't able to realize that at least 200 (another round number) of the bodies were supposed "Hamas fighters".
5 - About "accountability" - Neither the Israel government, nor the brothers in this video take accountability for their lies. The "free speech" idea defended by the two brothers above, obviously only reaches so far as they like it.
6 - So far, also not a single evidence of any "raping", but dubious "testimonies" from people with dubious character. About the killing and raping, the Israeli government isn't doing any investigation, and not allowing any independent investigation. There was never any talk about justice, only "retribution", and "revenge".
6 - The fictitious "raping" is "heinous and barbaric", but not a word about the "elimination" of 20,000 Palestinians. No comment about that.
7 - "Not acts of war, these are not true military forces". Well, with that argument, every civilian "eliminated" by the IDF is a common crime of m..., because, if it is not a war, it is simply m... and g...
8 - Over the last 15 years and before Oct. 7th, Israel "eliminated" over 6,000 Palestinians, stole their land, destroyed their homes, but, what their desperate victims did, "is not Israel's fault. Really "convincing"!
I could go on and on, this videos is .... from the start to the end.
After watching the recent D.C. hearings, this has sadly aged very well
Did u watch whole of it
So disgusting this cowardice is happening in academic institutions in America.
This has been building up for years. Before all this, many universities basically praise China and then think anything "Western" is bad.
Like BLM got support from lots of universities despite basically promote the Red Book.
"Those university presidents are knee-deep in cancel culture.
Harvard used to be the school to aspire to. Now it is a school to avoid.
no gain without pain
I think there should be an experiment, where people go to a campus and start chanting "from the Pacific to the Atlantic, America will be [insert marginalized group here] free!" And then see if this new "free speech commitment" actually sticks or not.
Ever since 2016, I was made to believe that Jewish Americans were at risk from Trump and his followers. I remember the days after the election results were very scary as people on social media were posting pictures of swastika grafitti and threats to synagogs were rising. This was all reason to resist against Trump and his voting base. Now? I guess it is okay to use swastikas, grafitti "gas the jews" and chant for the extermination of a Jewish nation because it is coming from the approved political group.
Free speech for Ms. Gay is the last refuge of a scoundrel.
This interview has aged very well- almost a premonition of current events
planned events
Claudine Gay lives in a plagiarism glass house and she threw context-dependent stones.
She also fired the best black professor at Harvard after a ridiculous meetoo witchhunt. Why, well he proved that the myth of police shooting african americans more often than whites. This did not fit her racist narrative so they discredited him to silence him.
All Americans should only be concerned about is our country period. Government leaders have failed horribly in only 50 year’s time. Extremely sad!
It’s not “cancel culture”. It’s “cancel, culture”. It’s not some slang term to describe radicals, it’s literally an international espionage tactic people are doing to American culture.
American culture: Genocide on indigenous people; Slavery; Apartheid; supporting terrorism over the entire world; supporting coups over the entire world; supporting coups over the entire world; waging wars over the entire world. Support apartheid and ghenocide in Israel; support to the biggest concentration camp the world has ever seen: Gaza; Making claims like "European Garden"; KuKluxKlan; Neo-Nazism; religious extremism; mass-shootings; druggies everywhere; homelessness; "White Supremacists", "Proud Boys"; Julian Assange in prison because he revealed horrendous war crimes committed by USA; LGBT; "civil forfeiture"; "FlatEarth"; "Aliens"; Hate-speeches; Calling a peaceful nation to be "USA's worst enemy". Destroying Libya, Korea, Afghanistan, Syria, from the top to the bottom...
Does anyone still wonder why reasonable people are not interested in the American culture?
Yes cancel western culture. That's what's happening. The perpetrators have been clever and insidious to start with and now that their useful tools are indoctrinated well, they're being used to push forward the eradication and gilification of western culture.
This is a fantastic comment. I 100% agree. I think this needs to be discussed openly and often. The truth is, these are highly strategic cultural warfare and espionage/saboteur campaigns that are being waged. The truth is being obfuscated by these notions that there is anything organic (whatsoever) about these highly organized campaigns.
watching this after the December 8th hearings- this has aged like fine wine!
like planned wine
Very good convo. Strange, still, that the most basic things are considered extraordinary these days, the bar has slipped so utterly and inexplicably low.
Appreciate it so much I even deliberately watched and listened to each full ad! Now there's a sacrifice for you..
When I was in collage the administration never really cared what I thought about anything. When did administrators start doing this?
Collage? How many collages did you make?
@@raumfahreturschutze Hey look, someone misspelled a word on the Internet. Now we dine!
@@glennwatson3313 I mean normally I wouldn't bother dealing with how defensive people get over it, but you were flouting your credentials are a college administrator so there was a certain humorous irony to it.
@@raumfahreturschutze I'm sorry. When did I flout my credentials as a college administrator? I was never a college administrator and I never said I was. I said, "when I was in college." Do you know what being in college means?
I avoid giving advice on the internet but for my part I try and focus on reading and comprehension rather than spelling.
This is what modern lockstepping looks like, folks. The fact that these institutions responded so quickly and in unison tells me they either already knew it was going to happen or were ordered to respond that way from, let's just say, higher up the food chain. Much higher.
Follow the money.
You mean the Zionist neocon war profit money, right?
Love your show. Just discovered it today ❤
Thank you! Caught your great dialog on emergent order. Wow really well put. Also thanks for highlighting FIREs and Gregs work for Free speech. The introductions to great people and organizations on this podcast has broaden my perspective on several subjects.
Is this guy in any way related to that Fire Festival fiasco?
@@busterbiloxi3833 Don't be daft. Btw, your bit is *Fyre.
1- Hamas didn't kill 1,400 ... (I can't say it, if I do, "free speech" will be cancelled. Even the Israeli government recognizes that among the dead, only 1.200 were ...
2 - Several J... who were on the places of the Hamas attack, already testified that the IDF was shooting indiscriminately at the places, and killed several .... So, obviously, even blaming 1,200 deaths on Hamas, is a lie.
3 - Both numbers, 1,400, and 1.200 are "round numbers" which means, they aren't real. For now the Israel government should already know exactly how many of their citizens died there. But they don't tell; they stay with their fictitious numbers.
4 - It seems also, the whole burning of corpses was done by the IDF, that's why they weren't able to realize that at least 200 (another round number) of the bodies were supposed "Hamas fighters".
5 - About "accountability" - Neither the Israel government, nor the brothers in this video take accountability for their lies. The "free speech" idea defended by the two brothers above, obviously only reaches so far as they like it.
6 - So far, also not a single evidence of any "raping", but dubious "testimonies" from people with dubious character. About the killing and raping, the Israeli government isn't doing any investigation, and not allowing any independent investigation. There was never any talk about justice, only "retribution", and "revenge".
6 - The fictitious "raping" is "heinous and barbaric", but not a word about the "elimination" of 20,000 Palestinians. No comment about that.
7 - "Not acts of war, these are not true military forces". Well, with that argument, every civilian "eliminated" by the IDF is a common crime of m..., because, if it is not a war, it is simply m... and g...
8 - Over the last 15 years and before Oct. 7th, Israel "eliminated" over 6,000 Palestinians, stole their land, destroyed their homes, but, what their desperate victims did, "is not Israel's fault. Really "convincing"!
I could go on and on, this videos is .... from the start to the end.
It's also happening in Europe, this antisemitic rhetoric. It is insane.
Palestinians are Semitic, and anti Zionist is not anti Jewish. Ashkenazi Jews who …..are the ones behind and running Zionist policy in Israel and abroad …. are at most 1/3 Levantine/Semitic. This is proven by dna.
'my disgusting, repulsive cowardice is really what makes me the tragic character in the story'--priceless.
Add that not even animals saved from being killed.
Ffs. Something has been very wrong in America for years. For the love of sanity.
Minor nit for the closed caption: It's Kelvan, not Calvin. Great interview.
10 different factions plus armed rabble…so who actually did what is questionable really?
For schools that wallow in and indulge concepts like "micro aggressions" they sure allow mega agressions against conservative speakers on their campuses.
Schools can easily create citadels of free speech by adopting very strict student codes of conduct and enforcing them through facial recognition technology. If you threaten, shout down, or otherwise misbehave, you will be kicked out of the school. It's not complicated or difficult. It might cause several tumultuous years but after that, a new normal (free speech) will be achieved.
More please!!
Oh boy... are you gonna get what you're asking for my friend. Stay tuned and be sure to subscribe! Coming soon. - John
Immediate similar replies suggest coordination. Follow the money.
Free speech when those in power agree with you.
I love watching the neocons and universities going at it.
Social Incoherence Warriors on the march... like they're right out of a 30s newsreel... Directly from the free-range D. E. I. farm to your plate.
If someone does trans erasure, that's something you should boycott someone for. If you're a professor, you should understand wjhat's the right thing to do, and trans erasure (e.g. saying that biological sex "is just a fact", which is hopelessly offensive to trans people and not the point of being transgender as gender is the social construct, which is different from one's sex) is not the right thing to do.
The history of Palestine didn't start October 7th
It started about 1500 years ago 3500 years after the Jews lived in Israel the first time and about 600 years after Jesus.
@@kenttappan1 what jews are you referring too? Modern day jews are not the same jews as 2000 years ago. Revelations 2:9 kjv
humans have inhabited that area for hundreds of thousands of years@@kenttappan1
I think one of those University Presidents is actually Jewish ??
I thought that the president of Harvard was Islamic. She looked and sounded the part.
There is no forgiveness in my heart for what the Arabs did to Israeli’s in their edition of an act of war against innocent women and children as well as men in October, none. I actually feel a rabid hatred for their acts and hope/pray that God has a way to sort this out but I believe hell for them is not out of the question. The people who support those Arabs after their execution of horror on those people… …let’s just say you do not want to meet me. You are actually more despicable to me than those who perpetrated that act of Satan upon those people.
I agree with you, but don't hate others for not seeing the world the way you do. Not everyone has the advantages of a good education. Hate is like its own class of opiate. It's a funny thing, but at first hate feels really good, like sitting next to a warm fire, and then that very same fire swallows you whole.
@@joshuafrank3803 I wrote that I have a rabid hatred for what they did to innocent people. That is a distinct difference from hating people. I despise them, they are rancid examples of humanity, they are as despicable and deceived as people can get but, I have to leave the hatred of persons to God. None of us are perfect.
Over 7000 children murdered by Israel and counting. Yes, satanic indeed.
At 2:06 the victims are the Israeli civilians that were targeted and the remainder of the population terrorized by these acts. Not sure anyone is blaming them.
What Did IDF Tell Snopes?
While Zedeck, Haddad and others claimed to have heard about the beheaded infants from Israeli soldiers, when Snopes reached out to the IDF about the stories, spokespeople did not confirm in so many words that the purported beheadings happened.
We asked multiple times if any children or infants were beheaded, and, if so, how many. We received the following response: “We cannot confirm any numbers. What happened in Kibbutz 'Kfar Azza' is a massacre in which women, children, toddlers and elderly were brutally butchered in an ISIS way of action," referring to the Islamic State militant group. "We are aware of the heinous acts Hamas is capable of.”
Like Snopes, other media outlets received the same statement from IDF comparing Hamas' killings to those of ISIS.
"The biggest insult to the memory of the holocaust is not denying it but using it as an excuse to justify the genocide of the Palestinian people."
- Norman Finkelstein
The lies start at 1:20. Stopped watching. Please get your facts straight. Your hate is so apparent.
And that is the host of the show who clearly has neither the ability or the will to find out the truth about Israel’s lies. Let’s face it, 2 zionists discussing free speech is not going ti go anywhere
Watching this video shows how the conflict won't end. If people sign a letter blaming the "jews" then that's wrong. But it's very interesting how he went out of his way to decontextualize the horrible oct 7th incident which btw by Israeli estimates about half of the casualties a civilians which makes it terrorism in my books but it doesn't do any good to ignore the fact that Palestinians Civilians have been killed this year before Oct 7th by the IDF. If you find the oct 7th attack horrible which make sense then you should find it horrible that the idf has been killing Palestinians before and after oct 7th. You can't start the clock at oct 7th without implying you value isreali lives more than Palestinians.
yes! “setting aside the whole israel/palestine” history, as if that’s not a monumental ask xD
also rather tone deaf to bemoan the asymmetry of the “free speech” response on US campuses, while at the same time setting aside the asymmetrical military response
OK terrorist supporter
BLAME THE ZIONISTS..........NOT JEWS. THERE IS A DIFFERENCE.
@imhere who's blaming the jews?
Remember the Alamo, Free Palestine 🇵🇸
That's five-word word salad.
Free pales from allah.
WTF does that mean?
@@robertbentley3589 A battle cry in the Texans' struggle for independence from Mexico, later used by Americans in the Mexican War. It recalled the desperate fight of the Texan defenders in the Alamo, a besieged fort, where they died to the last man. Now put the Palestinians in place of the Texans Jethro.
Stop all funding and donations, boycott.