It's impressive how both teams have been able to develop high-quality software in a relatively short amount of time. Both options are excellent and it depends on the type of project being undertaken to determine which one is more suitable. Ultimately, it's about choosing the tool that best fits the needs of the project and the team carrying it out.
I chose twinmotion for my work, if i want highly realistic i will use the path tracing on twinmo, but if i want fast work on 3d im just export twinmo. so D5 result is little bit better than twinmo export and twinmo path tracing is better than D5 so that make me still use twinmo. but its my opinion, and im still learning D5 now.
@@ssdesain1643 Makes sense :-) I also started with TwinMotion, but ditched it in favor of D5 Render because of Ray Tracing and better image quality compared to the native TwinMotion engine (non patch tracer). While I think the new path tracer looks very promising, D5 Render still is the only (real time) render that supports material ID-, ambient occlusion-, reflection passes, which are extremely important in my workflow, so I won't be going back to TwinMotion any time soon. But I do like that you have more control over the path tracer, which is really nice, there in D5 Render the only real thing you can do if something looks fuzzy, is render it in a higher resolution and then downscale the image to what your client wants.
Id still rather the result from d5 over waiting 6 hours for a path traced result when my cliets wont be able to tell the difference between them. 90% of the time when i see comparisons they can all be matched by matching contrast but nobody does that which makes everything look so different.
Even if D5 is better than Twinmotion, there is no way that I would subscribe to any piece of software regardless of how great it is. D5 could make a lot more money by offering perpetual licenses on top of their rental business. At the end of the day, a crappy design rendered with the best renderer is not going to fool a veteran in the construction/design business.
P.S. i know many veterans that own their own companies and guess what..... They cant tell the difference. You are just bitter because you are being left behind.
Sorry, but I actually don't see the point in doing a direct comparisson using same models if the mood, lighting and enviroment are different. I would do that, in this case, only with interiors and kepping exactly the same settings. Only like this we can have a fair comparison. See ya!
@@barakus7069 Wel they release 2023.2 I think I did play with it, I like Lumen its pretty good for realtime, but I like Unreal more because of the flexibility , its fun to work in Twinmotion but its pretty easy ,but I like kinda challange thats why Im using Unreal engine, now you have TM,Lumion,D-5 render they give you awesome result for e few clicks , Idkn maybe Im crazy🤷♂️
Welcome to try D5 2.4 to be released in a few hours. Hopefully you'll love the result😉
of course i will😊
It's impressive how both teams have been able to develop high-quality software in a relatively short amount of time. Both options are excellent and it depends on the type of project being undertaken to determine which one is more suitable. Ultimately, it's about choosing the tool that best fits the needs of the project and the team carrying it out.
Waa absolutely 100% agree with youu
Yeah but the winner is D5 render looks better
D5 looks better, It spend more time but result looks better for me. Thank you for video
Good for you,
Exactly
it looks perfect! if you only had the ambient occlusion turned ON that would be a lot better!
which one is more suitable for macbook air m1?
What gpu you use for d5 and twinmotion, how does it perform on large scene? thanks
RTX 4090 for twinmo it can work on 8k resolution, but take lil more longer to export. :)
I still wonder when TM will improve this their tree blurry
It is not a fair comparison. My opinion is that you did not make the settings for Twinmotion exactly right. Especially for the outside.
yes, you can check my other video about twinmo and d5 comparison.
awesome
thankyou 🤩
I wanna know why path tracer in Twinmotion seem burly
woh mantabbb,lanjutkan
Siapp kak terimakasih banyak kakk🙏
What program do you use for sketching? Revit or?🙏
Archicad
which render is better according to you?
I chose twinmotion for my work, if i want highly realistic i will use the path tracing on twinmo, but if i want fast work on 3d im just export twinmo. so D5 result is little bit better than twinmo export and twinmo path tracing is better than D5 so that make me still use twinmo. but its my opinion, and im still learning D5 now.
@@ssdesain1643 path tracing and ray tracing are same right?
@@ssdesain1643 Makes sense :-) I also started with TwinMotion, but ditched it in favor of D5 Render because of Ray Tracing and better image quality compared to the native TwinMotion engine (non patch tracer). While I think the new path tracer looks very promising, D5 Render still is the only (real time) render that supports material ID-, ambient occlusion-, reflection passes, which are extremely important in my workflow, so I won't be going back to TwinMotion any time soon. But I do like that you have more control over the path tracer, which is really nice, there in D5 Render the only real thing you can do if something looks fuzzy, is render it in a higher resolution and then downscale the image to what your client wants.
@@ssdesain1643😂😂😂 you still learning and you made this high quality render ? 😂😂😂 Please don't laugh at us.. you are a pro bro ❤❤❤❤
why twin motion is desaturated the blue look
Great comparison, but D5 is 5 times better.
Well thankyouuu 🤩,
boleh tau speck pc kamu ?
something in TM looks cartoonish I dont know... maybe the materials
Please do a d5 2.4 or include it in the list. Would be a great comparison.
Can you import D5 into Unreal engine? Is it the same as importing Chief Architect into UN?
lol what?! can you import a render engine into another render engine? did you evem watch the video? lol
great result in d5, what your machine specs?
i 7 gen 12
rtx 4090
Let's make video work flow how to do dis plss....
soon ✌
you did not use path tracer right. else its better than D5
ya, u can see my other vdeo using path tracing on this house.
Id still rather the result from d5 over waiting 6 hours for a path traced result when my cliets wont be able to tell the difference between them. 90% of the time when i see comparisons they can all be matched by matching contrast but nobody does that which makes everything look so different.
Even if D5 is better than Twinmotion, there is no way that I would subscribe to any piece of software regardless of how great it is. D5 could make a lot more money by offering perpetual licenses on top of their rental business. At the end of the day, a crappy design rendered with the best renderer is not going to fool a veteran in the construction/design business.
Is that you crying because you're poor?
It is free 🤷♂️
lol d5 is free, how are you mad about something when you dont even know anything about it
You sound bitter for no reason. You dont even know what you are talking about and you do it with all that passion lol
P.S. i know many veterans that own their own companies and guess what..... They cant tell the difference. You are just bitter because you are being left behind.
Sorry, but I actually don't see the point in doing a direct comparisson using same models if the mood, lighting and enviroment are different. I would do that, in this case, only with interiors and kepping exactly the same settings. Only like this we can have a fair comparison. See ya!
5 time faster karena gapake path tracing ya ? jadinya ga realistic
still prefer d5
betul gapake path tracing, kita ada video yg pake path tracing, cek aja hehe
d5 is so much faster, and better.. i left twinmotion for d5 and have no regrets
nice opinion, but i prefer with twinmo, u can check my another videos about d5 & twinmo comparison :}
Twinmotion is away sharper.
I disagree. Twinmotion always has an inherent "video game" appearance.
Yeah ..d5 is better
If you watched the entire video, you would discover that Twinmotion raytracing is better than D5 render
Twinmotion uses pathtracing, not raytracing.
Twinmotion path tracing WINNER no competition lol
Twinmotion render time is just absurd, takes waaaaay to long for animation, in path tracing btw
Nope 😊 better have something long but great results d5 is the best now
@@barakus7069 Wel they release 2023.2 I think I did play with it, I like Lumen its pretty good for realtime, but I like Unreal more because of the flexibility , its fun to work in Twinmotion but its pretty easy ,but I like kinda challange thats why Im using Unreal engine, now you have TM,Lumion,D-5 render they give you awesome result for e few clicks , Idkn maybe Im crazy🤷♂️
se compara com a versão d5 2.5 esta bem melhorado hdri , vegetação ...isso q o d5 é mais novo no mercado .