The immaculate conception dogma is missing from the earliest patristic sources. Mary didn’t even enter into the picture of theological disputes of the church fathers until the upsurge of Christological heresies and the impulse of asceticism and monasticism in church history. Catholic scholar, Ludwig Ott, admits: “Neither Greek nor Latin Fathers explicitly teach the Immaculate Conception of Mary” (Fundamentals of Catholic Dogma, Tan Publishers, 1960, p. 201) The New Catholic Encyclopedia (1967, 7:378-81) states that: “…the Immaculate Conception is not taught explicitly in Scripture … the earliest church Fathers regarded Mary as holy but not as absolutely sinless … It is impossible to give a precise date when this belief was held as a matter of Faith, but by the 8th or 9th century, it seems to have been generally admitted…” Even after then, controversies over this dogma raged on for a whole 1000 years with the Dominicans fighting the Franciscans over the issue. The so-called “infallible authority” of Rome was neutral on the issue. Even a 19th century Catholic bishop admitted: “The Church does not decide the controversy concerning the Conception of the Blessed Virgin, and several other disputed points, because she sees nothing clear and certain concerning them either in the written or unwritten Word, and therefore leaves her children to form their own opinions concerning them” (Cited in George Salmon, The Infallibility of the Church, 182) This proves that this dogma was a very late development and had just been around only about 150 years. It can’t be supported either with the Bible or traditions.
Omg Fr Alar , so sad to hear about grate mother of god, Devil hate women, & Blessed mother . Waiting eagerly to see this amazing movie, i had mother Saving a kid from an freak accident where he lost all his family , mother, father, sister , granny, that i was told in a vision, dream, Hail to Blessed mother of Mercy, Big Thank you Fr Alar and all the member of the movie crew!
The immaculate conception dogma is missing from the earliest patristic sources. Mary didn’t even enter into the picture of theological disputes of the church fathers until the upsurge of Christological heresies and the impulse of asceticism and monasticism in church history. Catholic scholar, Ludwig Ott, admits: “Neither Greek nor Latin Fathers explicitly teach the Immaculate Conception of Mary” (Fundamentals of Catholic Dogma, Tan Publishers, 1960, p. 201) The New Catholic Encyclopedia (1967, 7:378-81) states that: “…the Immaculate Conception is not taught explicitly in Scripture … the earliest church Fathers regarded Mary as holy but not as absolutely sinless … It is impossible to give a precise date when this belief was held as a matter of Faith, but by the 8th or 9th century, it seems to have been generally admitted…” Even after then, controversies over this dogma raged on for a whole 1000 years with the Dominicans fighting the Franciscans over the issue. The so-called “infallible authority” of Rome was neutral on the issue. Even a 19th century Catholic bishop admitted: “The Church does not decide the controversy concerning the Conception of the Blessed Virgin, and several other disputed points, because she sees nothing clear and certain concerning them either in the written or unwritten Word, and therefore leaves her children to form their own opinions concerning them” (Cited in George Salmon, The Infallibility of the Church, 182) This proves that this dogma was a very late development and had just been around only about 150 years. It can’t be supported either with the Bible or traditions.
The profound meaning of “I am the Immaculate Conception” goes unnoticed even by many of its proponents. By identifying herself in this way, aside from validating the doctrine of her sinlessness, it also declares to humanity that God’s plan for us in this world begins at our conception. This was a profound prophesy for a world gravitating towards increasing levels of crimes against the unborn throughout the history since her appearance at Lourdes when she equated her life with her conception.
The immaculate conception dogma is missing from the earliest patristic sources. Mary didn’t even enter into the picture of theological disputes of the church fathers until the upsurge of Christological heresies and the impulse of asceticism and monasticism in church history. Catholic scholar, Ludwig Ott, admits: “Neither Greek nor Latin Fathers explicitly teach the Immaculate Conception of Mary” (Fundamentals of Catholic Dogma, Tan Publishers, 1960, p. 201) The New Catholic Encyclopedia (1967, 7:378-81) states that: “…the Immaculate Conception is not taught explicitly in Scripture … the earliest church Fathers regarded Mary as holy but not as absolutely sinless … It is impossible to give a precise date when this belief was held as a matter of Faith, but by the 8th or 9th century, it seems to have been generally admitted…” Even after then, controversies over this dogma raged on for a whole 1000 years with the Dominicans fighting the Franciscans over the issue. The so-called “infallible authority” of Rome was neutral on the issue. Even a 19th century Catholic bishop admitted: “The Church does not decide the controversy concerning the Conception of the Blessed Virgin, and several other disputed points, because she sees nothing clear and certain concerning them either in the written or unwritten Word, and therefore leaves her children to form their own opinions concerning them” (Cited in George Salmon, The Infallibility of the Church, 182) This proves that this dogma was a very late development and had just been around only about 150 years. It can’t be supported either with the Bible or traditions.
Catholic and Orthodox agree with condemned book of Protoevengelium of James by early Popes even yet Dogmatized by later Popes Pius X11 in 1950 that Mary is called Sinless and Assumed to Heaven as Mediatrix nowhere spoken of in scripture but more contrary to it. See Matthew 1:25 Joseph knows Mary after Birth of Jesus and Jesus' Real Familial brothers and sisters ( adelphos and adelphi) while Elizabeth is cousin/relative ( sugenes) of Mary. Luke 1:36.❤
@@brianguglielmin2873 Amen! The immaculate conception dogma is missing from the earliest patristic sources. Mary didn’t even enter into the picture of theological disputes of the church fathers until the upsurge of Christological heresies and the impulse of asceticism and monasticism in church history. Catholic scholar, Ludwig Ott, admits: “Neither Greek nor Latin Fathers explicitly teach the Immaculate Conception of Mary” (Fundamentals of Catholic Dogma, Tan Publishers, 1960, p. 201) The New Catholic Encyclopedia (1967, 7:378-81) states that: “…the Immaculate Conception is not taught explicitly in Scripture … the earliest church Fathers regarded Mary as holy but not as absolutely sinless … It is impossible to give a precise date when this belief was held as a matter of Faith, but by the 8th or 9th century, it seems to have been generally admitted…” Even after then, controversies over this dogma raged on for a whole 1000 years with the Dominicans fighting the Franciscans over the issue. The so-called “infallible authority” of Rome was neutral on the issue. Even a 19th century Catholic bishop admitted: “The Church does not decide the controversy concerning the Conception of the Blessed Virgin, and several other disputed points, because she sees nothing clear and certain concerning them either in the written or unwritten Word, and therefore leaves her children to form their own opinions concerning them” (Cited in George Salmon, The Infallibility of the Church, 182) This proves that this dogma was a very late development and had just been around only about 150 years. It can’t be supported either with the Bible or traditions.
I can't imagine anyone calling Our Blessed Mother those names. It's sickens me to the core . I'm shocked. And I apologize dear Mother for those people who have hurt you in anyway.😢
HAIL MARY FULL OF GRACE, THE LORD IS WITH THEE, BLESSED ARE THOU AMONGST WOMEN 🙏, BLESSEDIS THE FRUIT OF THY WOMB JESUS , HOLY MARY MOTHER OF GOD, PRAY 🙏 🤲 FOR US NOW , AND AT THE HOUR OF OUR DEATH 😢😊🎉❤❤❤❤❤❤❤
✝️❣️All praise and glory to you Most Adored Holy Abba Heavenly God we adore, love and thank you for your loyal priest Chris Alar for sharing bravely your truthful Live Word. Thank you Father Chris Alar for your passion to help God Save Souls, may God bless you and your precious family abundantly ✝️🙏
Explaining The Faith was my go-to vid during c*vid. I tremendously learned a lot from Father's "seminary notes" - learned a lot amd my faith deepened because of that understanding. Thank you Fr. Chris. I also had the rare chance of seeing him in person when he came to Australia 2 years ago.
Such an inspiring interview with Fr. Chris Alar! His insights into the Immaculate Conception and the depth of Mary's role in our salvation are truly enlightening. May we continue to seek her intercession and grow in our faith. 🙏🌹
I LOVE your Explaining the Faith series Father!!! I have watched/listened to many episodes more than once!!! I’m also glad to hear about the other Mary movie, NOT to go!!! Thanks for all you both do and share, ❤ from Kristy in Missouri 🙏🙏🙏📿📿📿
Fr Alar love your explaning the faith, l diving mercy fathers, Fr Donald , Fr Mark appreciate the grate service to the church us, may god protect and bless you all.
Thanks Fr Chris. Following from Kenya, East Africa. You really teach us alot. My SCC is St Maximilian Kolbe and I got excited when you mentioned him.i am very much interested in this Films❤
Thank you for your explanation Father Chris, especially at the 14 minute mark where you prove this is in the Bible! That’s what my Lutheran friends ask when I tell them our Blessed Mother is the Immaculate Conception.
There was only 3 other women and me in the movie, before Christmas, sad and So close to Light Of The World? Really? I was saddened by that, the movie so moved me, I teared up and told my brother. Tell me I’ll be in DVD soon!
Our lady of the immaculate conception, pray for us all you are our spiritual mother forever n ever, amen n amen thank you somuch for posting this interesting video talk a good day to the host n to father chris alar, mic ❤❤❤❤❤❤
Mary~ GOD's Divine Masterpiece!✨🌹🕊️ St. Venantius Fortunatus said: "O Mother blest! And chosen Shrine wherein the Architect Divine, Whose Hand contains the earth & sky vouchsafed in hidden guise to lie; Blest in the message Gabriel brought; blest in the work, the Spirit wrought; Most blest, to bring to human birth, the long desired of all the earth!" On This beautiful & Holy Day of Our Lady's Immaculate Conception Today, from the Miraculous Medal~ "O Mary, conceived without sin, Pray for us who have recourse to Thee, Amen!
Father Chris Alar MIC when I look inside my heart Christ ☄️ true Lamb of God love God good father son holy spirit unnited with the blessed mother of perpetual light ☄️ true Lamb of love God good father son holy spirit ☄️ dove 🌹🌹🌹🙏🏻
Father: I have had this thought on my mind and heart for a number of years now. But to try to get someone to listen or understand or give a thought to it does not seem to be an easy project. So I will mention now what my thoughts are. And I’m only doing this and saying this because it is time for our Christian brethren to wake up and figure out that Mary is their mother whether they like it or not. She was given to each and everyone of us at the foot of the Cross! And you know how that goes …you can’t pick your parents. And you can’t pick the traits or the idiosyncrasies that are passed down from parent to child. So I typically would like to ask everyone, if I had a large platform as you do, to take a look at the palm of their hand. I would bet that almost 99%, probably even 100% have ‘M’ in the center of their hands/the palm of their hands. And, of course, this M represents Mary our most holy mother. So if everyone has that M it oughta to make people think twice. But then again, it probably won’t because they’re so stuck on their thought process of growling about her. The other thought they ought to run through their brain, as many of them are very good, good Christians !!! But, it makes absolutely no sense that someone that has a love for Jesus Christ cannot stand, with great vitriol, his mother. There’s no getting into heaven with this hatred towards others much less his mother! I truly hope that when you listen to this, you just don’t roll your eyes, or go through it and move onto the next thing you have to do in life, because this is serious, this is very, very very serious that people start talking about this, so that those that are stuck on stubborness, excuse theexpression, can maybe start mowing over the thought process! Oh, and one last thing, if you have trouble finding the M, it has nothing to do with the salvation of that person. The Emma’s probably there. It’s just sometimes hard to pick out. OK thank you for listening to my rant. Nancy Daumke
True Reformed in Christ honor Mary and her special role in bearing Messiah and raising Him up. Further steps such as praying to her as a Mediatrix is contrary to scripture, Jesus teaching as all prayer to the Father in Jesus Name in the Spirit or at times to Jesus or the Holy Spirit Directly in prayer, praise and song etc.❤🙏
@@MBuser4098 The film will be releasing only in the United States for its initial release. It’s quite possible the filmmakers and distributor will consider an international release at a future date in time. Be sure to check the official film website for details ImmaculateMovie2024.com.
Thank you Lady of the miraculous medal rosary Christ cross word love God good cherished in the risen Christ forever ☄️ prince of peace crown always wins the living IAM the Almighty God father son holy spirit ☄️ God's enabling power glory kingdom forever amen
Poor Chris I have to giggle when he comments on is wonderful teaching are so LONG,,, dear Father he repeatedly repeats things more than twice; lol 😂 love U father
MAR MARI EMMANUEL IS A HOLY MAN WITH THE MESSAGE IN HIS HEART, A BEATIFUL TALENT FOR SPEAKING, DONT LET THE DUMB CONSPIRACY THEROSIT PICTURES THEY USE FOR HIS VIDEOS AND CHANNEL, JUST WATCH A FEW AND I THINK YOULL UNDERSTAND WHAT I MEAN CATHOLICS 😉 🎉❤❤❤❤❤❤❤
O was just thinking about Immaculate, can I find out how her conception transpired? I guess I never knew whether hers is same as her Son Jesus or was it between her human parents?
Bl. Sr. Catherine Emmerich describes the manner of Conception occurring in a special chamber below the 'Holy of Holies' within the Temple of Jerusalem. She relates that this manner of Conception would have occurred if Adam and Eve had not fallen. Its worth reading.
Mary was chosen by God the Father to be the means by which God becomes man and walks amongst us.... This plan to save humanity from the SIN of Adam and Eve was in place before the foundation of the world... Most protestants dint know that.... Before Adam and Eve were even created God showed all of Heaven a vision of a woman and told them that He would be born through that woman and take on flesh.... That is why Satan tempted Eve and not Adam because he thought that Mary was Eve..... God already knew that Adam and Eve would sin so He divised a plan to save humanity.... And the plan was MARY THAT IS WHY MARY IS SO IMPORTANT.
By the way, I am teaching languages, and Catholic Philosophy class. If anyone's interested in learning Spanish, English, Italian, German, or Philosophy of metaphysical, logic, ethics morality (virtues), contact me. The prices are between two to six dollars, depending on what country you live in. Philosophy can help us strengthen our faith too.
Hi @janettewitte8868 this first theatrical release will be in the United States only, but there’s certainly a chance it could make its way to you if it has a successful release in North America. Stay tuned at ImmaculateMovie2024.com
Hi @@DanHusband-r6g, the film’s North American release will be in the United States only. But there’s always a chance it could be made available outside the U.S. market. Be sure to follow the film for updates at ImmaculateMovie2024.com
If Protestants say that Mary is not important; then WHY did God the Father, God the Son, Jesus and God the Holy Spirit CHOOSE Mary? When Protestants disparage Mary, they are disparaging the Blessed Holy Trinity.
Hail Mary full of grace! when is going to be the film available in Argentina? Palestine didn't exist in the first century. the Roman Empire rename Judea as Palestine after a jewish rebellion was defeated in the Second Century in the 135 year of our Lord. ❤🙏🙌
Hi I just saw the trailer. This movie looks very theologically rich. Enjoy it. It reminds me to the cartoon movie, "The Grreatest Miracle". Especially the part when the blood drop dropped on the Chalice. But here in this trailer of the "I am the Immalcutaee Conception", I can tell that the blood is time travelling through a warm-hole or such, and I bet that it will also fall on the chalice during the Holy Thursday last supper of Christ. But I might be wrong because in the trailer the blood drop seems to hit something round that looked like an ovarie which then explodes. LOL, But it wouldn't make sense if a blood enter an overie and moreover for the ovarie to explode, 😂. Now, what would makes sense, indeed, is if that blood is not really a blood drop, but a symbol of the Holy Spirit (in the form of a blood drop), entering the womb of Mary. If so, i don't understand why the symbol of a dove is not used for the Holy Spirit..... In anycase, there's only one way to find out, when I watch the movie!.🤪
The immaculate conception dogma is missing from the earliest patristic sources. Mary didn’t even enter into the picture of theological disputes of the church fathers until the upsurge of Christological heresies and the impulse of asceticism and monasticism in church history. Catholic scholar, Ludwig Ott, admits: “Neither Greek nor Latin Fathers explicitly teach the Immaculate Conception of Mary” (Fundamentals of Catholic Dogma, Tan Publishers, 1960, p. 201) The New Catholic Encyclopedia (1967, 7:378-81) states that: “…the Immaculate Conception is not taught explicitly in Scripture … the earliest church Fathers regarded Mary as holy but not as absolutely sinless … It is impossible to give a precise date when this belief was held as a matter of Faith, but by the 8th or 9th century, it seems to have been generally admitted…” Even after then, controversies over this dogma raged on for a whole 1000 years with the Dominicans fighting the Franciscans over the issue. The so-called “infallible authority” of Rome was neutral on the issue. Even a 19th century Catholic bishop admitted: “The Church does not decide the controversy concerning the Conception of the Blessed Virgin, and several other disputed points, because she sees nothing clear and certain concerning them either in the written or unwritten Word, and therefore leaves her children to form their own opinions concerning them” (Cited in George Salmon, The Infallibility of the Church, 182) This proves that this dogma was a very late development and had just been around only about 150 years. It can’t be supported either with the Bible or traditions.
Will you be giving Pope Pious IX credit for declaring the dogma of the Immaculate Conception? Also Fox Nation is putting out terrible films on Fatima and the saints. Very deceptive.
To think Mary is just a woman who was Jesus’ mom is insane. She literally carried the Son of God for 9 months and was His Mother. Of course God wants us to revere and praise Her. She is perfect and could sit and relax in Heaven but She prays and intercedes for us! She is appearing in country after country to warn humanity to repent and turn towards God. That Lady is busy!!!! ✝️🙏🏻🩷
@@markleakos3737 well.. just deliver some scientifically validated proofs.. that's all... nope, a man-made booklet won't count.. so ? got any to share, FlatEarthDave ?
@@kimnguyen-ne3hm 🤣🤣🤣 good one, karen... join a comedy tour.. prayers a colossal waste of time for the non-cult members.. are you also into the "thoughts" stuff.. like... "thoughts and prayers".. JFC.. naaa.. better with "apples and pears".. yea, karen ?? now.. is the cake ready ? you are in the kitchen, right ? and barefooted ?? - who is Mary ? is that auntie-Mary ?
Mary is our spiritual mother and we love her like own. Pray for protestants who think and say such horrible things about her.
Also for seven advent church poor people may God forgive them Amen to Jesus Christ Amen 🙏🕊️🙏
Mary...in you Alone...all mysteries of God and humanity is made manifest. Thank you Mary...thank you God.
Mary mother of God,l love you because you are the Immaculate Conception God have made.
The immaculate conception dogma is missing from the earliest patristic sources. Mary didn’t even enter into the picture of theological disputes of the church fathers until the upsurge of Christological heresies and the impulse of asceticism and monasticism in church history.
Catholic scholar, Ludwig Ott, admits: “Neither Greek nor Latin Fathers explicitly teach the Immaculate Conception of Mary” (Fundamentals of Catholic Dogma, Tan Publishers, 1960, p. 201)
The New Catholic Encyclopedia (1967, 7:378-81) states that:
“…the Immaculate Conception is not taught explicitly in Scripture … the earliest church Fathers regarded Mary as holy but not as absolutely sinless … It is impossible to give a precise date when this belief was held as a matter of Faith, but by the 8th or 9th century, it seems to have been generally admitted…”
Even after then, controversies over this dogma raged on for a whole 1000 years with the Dominicans fighting the Franciscans over the issue. The so-called “infallible authority” of Rome was neutral on the issue.
Even a 19th century Catholic bishop admitted:
“The Church does not decide the controversy concerning the Conception of the Blessed Virgin, and several other disputed points, because she sees nothing clear and certain concerning them either in the written or unwritten Word, and therefore leaves her children to form their own opinions concerning them” (Cited in George Salmon, The Infallibility of the Church, 182)
This proves that this dogma was a very late development and had just been around only about 150 years. It can’t be supported either with the Bible or traditions.
Great movie! It was also very factual, Fr. Chris was great as always.
Omg Fr Alar , so sad to hear about grate mother of god, Devil hate women, & Blessed mother . Waiting eagerly to see this amazing movie, i had mother Saving a kid from an freak accident where he lost all his family , mother, father, sister , granny, that i was told in a vision, dream, Hail to Blessed mother of Mercy, Big Thank you Fr Alar and all the member of the movie crew!
My blessed mother cover me with your mantle 🙏🙏🙏
WE THANKED GOD FOR WATCHING THE MOVIE, I AM THE IMMACULATE CONCEPTION. HOPEFULLY MANY WILL WATCH THE MOVIE. MOTHER OF GOD PRAY FOR US.
When and where?
Just bought two tickets for thursday for my fiancé and I , so stoked ! God bless you father Alar and all the marian fathers 🙏
Excited to see this!
The immaculate conception dogma is missing from the earliest patristic sources. Mary didn’t even enter into the picture of theological disputes of the church fathers until the upsurge of Christological heresies and the impulse of asceticism and monasticism in church history.
Catholic scholar, Ludwig Ott, admits: “Neither Greek nor Latin Fathers explicitly teach the Immaculate Conception of Mary” (Fundamentals of Catholic Dogma, Tan Publishers, 1960, p. 201)
The New Catholic Encyclopedia (1967, 7:378-81) states that:
“…the Immaculate Conception is not taught explicitly in Scripture … the earliest church Fathers regarded Mary as holy but not as absolutely sinless … It is impossible to give a precise date when this belief was held as a matter of Faith, but by the 8th or 9th century, it seems to have been generally admitted…”
Even after then, controversies over this dogma raged on for a whole 1000 years with the Dominicans fighting the Franciscans over the issue. The so-called “infallible authority” of Rome was neutral on the issue.
Even a 19th century Catholic bishop admitted:
“The Church does not decide the controversy concerning the Conception of the Blessed Virgin, and several other disputed points, because she sees nothing clear and certain concerning them either in the written or unwritten Word, and therefore leaves her children to form their own opinions concerning them” (Cited in George Salmon, The Infallibility of the Church, 182)
This proves that this dogma was a very late development and had just been around only about 150 years. It can’t be supported either with the Bible or traditions.
Father Chris praise God for your priesthood!
The profound meaning of “I am the Immaculate Conception” goes unnoticed even by many of its proponents. By identifying herself in this way, aside from validating the doctrine of her sinlessness, it also declares to humanity that God’s plan for us in this world begins at our conception. This was a profound prophesy for a world gravitating towards increasing levels of crimes against the unborn throughout the history since her appearance at Lourdes when she equated her life with her conception.
The immaculate conception dogma is missing from the earliest patristic sources. Mary didn’t even enter into the picture of theological disputes of the church fathers until the upsurge of Christological heresies and the impulse of asceticism and monasticism in church history.
Catholic scholar, Ludwig Ott, admits: “Neither Greek nor Latin Fathers explicitly teach the Immaculate Conception of Mary” (Fundamentals of Catholic Dogma, Tan Publishers, 1960, p. 201)
The New Catholic Encyclopedia (1967, 7:378-81) states that:
“…the Immaculate Conception is not taught explicitly in Scripture … the earliest church Fathers regarded Mary as holy but not as absolutely sinless … It is impossible to give a precise date when this belief was held as a matter of Faith, but by the 8th or 9th century, it seems to have been generally admitted…”
Even after then, controversies over this dogma raged on for a whole 1000 years with the Dominicans fighting the Franciscans over the issue. The so-called “infallible authority” of Rome was neutral on the issue.
Even a 19th century Catholic bishop admitted:
“The Church does not decide the controversy concerning the Conception of the Blessed Virgin, and several other disputed points, because she sees nothing clear and certain concerning them either in the written or unwritten Word, and therefore leaves her children to form their own opinions concerning them” (Cited in George Salmon, The Infallibility of the Church, 182)
This proves that this dogma was a very late development and had just been around only about 150 years. It can’t be supported either with the Bible or traditions.
I am SO glad this is coming out 🥰 It is an antidote to that evil Netflix movie on the Beata Virgo Maria. Benedictus Deus ✝️
Amen
Catholic and Orthodox agree with condemned book of Protoevengelium of James by early Popes even yet Dogmatized by later Popes Pius X11 in 1950 that Mary is called Sinless and Assumed to Heaven as Mediatrix nowhere spoken of in scripture but more contrary to it. See Matthew 1:25 Joseph knows Mary after Birth of Jesus and Jesus' Real Familial brothers and sisters ( adelphos and adelphi) while Elizabeth is cousin/relative ( sugenes) of Mary. Luke 1:36.❤
@@brianguglielmin2873 Amen! The immaculate conception dogma is missing from the earliest patristic sources. Mary didn’t even enter into the picture of theological disputes of the church fathers until the upsurge of Christological heresies and the impulse of asceticism and monasticism in church history.
Catholic scholar, Ludwig Ott, admits: “Neither Greek nor Latin Fathers explicitly teach the Immaculate Conception of Mary” (Fundamentals of Catholic Dogma, Tan Publishers, 1960, p. 201)
The New Catholic Encyclopedia (1967, 7:378-81) states that:
“…the Immaculate Conception is not taught explicitly in Scripture … the earliest church Fathers regarded Mary as holy but not as absolutely sinless … It is impossible to give a precise date when this belief was held as a matter of Faith, but by the 8th or 9th century, it seems to have been generally admitted…”
Even after then, controversies over this dogma raged on for a whole 1000 years with the Dominicans fighting the Franciscans over the issue. The so-called “infallible authority” of Rome was neutral on the issue.
Even a 19th century Catholic bishop admitted:
“The Church does not decide the controversy concerning the Conception of the Blessed Virgin, and several other disputed points, because she sees nothing clear and certain concerning them either in the written or unwritten Word, and therefore leaves her children to form their own opinions concerning them” (Cited in George Salmon, The Infallibility of the Church, 182)
This proves that this dogma was a very late development and had just been around only about 150 years. It can’t be supported either with the Bible or traditions.
Seen this today. A very good film. Beautiful depictions. Quite moving.
I can't imagine anyone calling Our Blessed Mother those names. It's sickens me to the core . I'm shocked.
And I apologize dear Mother for those people who have hurt you in anyway.😢
HAIL MARY FULL OF GRACE, THE LORD IS WITH THEE, BLESSED ARE THOU AMONGST WOMEN 🙏, BLESSEDIS THE FRUIT OF THY WOMB JESUS , HOLY MARY MOTHER OF GOD, PRAY 🙏 🤲 FOR US NOW , AND AT THE HOUR OF OUR DEATH 😢😊🎉❤❤❤❤❤❤❤
Very nice photo of you, Fr Alar. Thank you for your wonderful teaching. God bless and protect you always. Greetings from Australia 🙏🏻
Can’t wait to go see this with my sisters from the Blue Army💙🙏
✝️❣️All praise and glory to you Most Adored Holy Abba Heavenly God we adore, love and thank you for your loyal priest Chris Alar for sharing bravely your truthful Live Word. Thank you Father Chris Alar for your passion to help God Save Souls, may God bless you and your precious family abundantly ✝️🙏
Explaining The Faith was my go-to vid during c*vid. I tremendously learned a lot from Father's "seminary notes" - learned a lot amd my faith deepened because of that understanding. Thank you Fr. Chris. I also had the rare chance of seeing him in person when he came to Australia 2 years ago.
Such an inspiring interview with Fr. Chris Alar! His insights into the Immaculate Conception and the depth of Mary's role in our salvation are truly enlightening. May we continue to seek her intercession and grow in our faith. 🙏🌹
I LOVE your Explaining the Faith series Father!!! I have watched/listened to many episodes more than once!!! I’m also glad to hear about the other Mary movie, NOT to go!!! Thanks for all you both do and share, ❤ from Kristy in Missouri 🙏🙏🙏📿📿📿
I love your learning the Faith talks and have learned so much. Thank you! Dont stop!
Just bought my tickets!!! 💗
🎉🎉🎉
May the Lord God bless us always ✝️🙏❤️🙏
I plan on going tonight!
Thank you.
Please let this be shown in Canada , specifically in Calgary , Alberta Canada 🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏
London, Ontario , Canada too
@@doreenpodetz6573 Halifax Nova Scotia too
Mama Mary is the best...praise be to God
Blessings ☄️🌹🌹🌹🙏🏻
Fr Alar love your explaning the faith, l diving mercy fathers, Fr Donald , Fr Mark appreciate the grate service to the church us, may god protect and bless you all.
God bless ☄️ brotherly love
Our mother of the immaculate conception pray for us ❤️🙏my son Chris ❤️🙏
Thanks Fr Chris. Following from Kenya, East Africa. You really teach us alot. My SCC is St Maximilian Kolbe and I got excited when you mentioned him.i am very much interested in this Films❤
From Kenya too my favourite channel , God bless
AMEN LORD JESUS CHRIST 🙏
THANK YOU LORD FOR THE ANSWERED PRAYER.
Thank you for your explanation Father Chris, especially at the 14 minute mark where you prove this is in the Bible! That’s what my Lutheran friends ask when I tell them our Blessed Mother is the Immaculate Conception.
There was only 3 other women and me in the movie, before Christmas, sad and So close to Light Of The World? Really? I was saddened by that, the movie so moved me, I teared up and told my brother. Tell me I’ll be in DVD soon!
Soooo happy Father Chris mentioned Mary as Mediatrix of all Graces & Co-Redemptrix!! Love Father Chris & al Marian Priests!!❤❤❤
Co Redemptrix is heresy.
🙏🙏🙏❤️❤️hope its show n in the philippines
Hope we will see this film in Canada 🇨🇦
Will it be in the Phillipines?
Our lady of the immaculate conception, pray for us all you are our spiritual mother forever n ever, amen n amen thank you somuch for posting this interesting video talk a good day to the host n to father chris alar, mic ❤❤❤❤❤❤
Mary~ GOD's Divine Masterpiece!✨🌹🕊️ St. Venantius Fortunatus said:
"O Mother blest! And chosen Shrine wherein the Architect Divine, Whose Hand contains the earth & sky vouchsafed in hidden guise to lie; Blest in the message Gabriel brought; blest in the work, the Spirit wrought; Most blest, to bring to human birth, the long desired of all the earth!"
On This beautiful & Holy Day of Our Lady's Immaculate Conception Today, from the Miraculous Medal~ "O Mary, conceived without sin, Pray for us who have recourse to Thee, Amen!
Amen 💓 🙏
I love my blessed mother when I see her in the shadow of my car when my son die I build a grotto in my backyard 🙏🙏🙏
Hopefully it will be a dvd so I can see it. I don’t go out due to health 🙏
#PraytheRosary #PraytoEndAbortion #PrayforPriests #DivineMercy #Fatima #Confession #LegionofMary #Medjugorje ❤
❤❤❤amen❤❤❤
Father Chris Alar MIC when I look inside my heart Christ ☄️ true Lamb of God love God good father son holy spirit unnited with the blessed mother of perpetual light ☄️ true Lamb of love God good father son holy spirit ☄️ dove 🌹🌹🌹🙏🏻
Father: I have had this thought on my mind and heart for a number of years now. But to try to get someone to listen or understand or give a thought to it does not seem to be an easy project. So I will mention now what my thoughts are. And I’m only doing this and saying this because it is time for our Christian brethren to wake up and figure out that Mary is their mother whether they like it or not. She was given to each and everyone of us at the foot of the Cross! And you know how that goes …you can’t pick your parents. And you can’t pick the traits or the idiosyncrasies that are passed down from parent to child. So I typically would like to ask everyone, if I had a large platform as you do, to take a look at the palm of their hand. I would bet that almost 99%, probably even 100% have ‘M’ in the center of their hands/the palm of their hands. And, of course, this M represents Mary our most holy mother. So if everyone has that M it oughta to make people think twice. But then again, it probably won’t because they’re so stuck on their thought process of growling about her. The other thought they ought to run through their brain, as many of them are very good, good Christians !!! But, it makes absolutely no sense that someone that has a love for Jesus Christ cannot stand, with great vitriol, his mother. There’s no getting into heaven with this hatred towards others much less his mother! I truly hope that when you listen to this, you just don’t roll your eyes, or go through it and move onto the next thing you have to do in life, because this is serious, this is very, very very serious that people start talking about this, so that those that are stuck on stubborness, excuse theexpression, can maybe start mowing over the thought process! Oh, and one last thing, if you have trouble finding the M, it has nothing to do with the salvation of that person. The Emma’s probably there. It’s just sometimes hard to pick out. OK thank you for listening to my rant. Nancy Daumke
Pray for the conversion of all faiths to the one true faith, Roman Catholicism, in Jesus Christs name, Amen.
Pray for the unity of Christendom
🙏🙏🙏
🙏🏼✝️💜
True Reformed in Christ honor Mary and her special role in bearing Messiah and raising Him up. Further steps such as praying to her as a Mediatrix is contrary to scripture, Jesus teaching as all prayer to the Father in Jesus Name in the Spirit or at times to Jesus or the Holy Spirit Directly in prayer, praise and song etc.❤🙏
Hopefully we van ser it on EWTN prepay!
when will it be shown in the Philippines ????
YESHUA EMMANUEL BON YUSEF 🎉❤❤❤❤❤❤❤
Will this film come to Australia? Praise be Jesus and Mary.
Oh Father Chris when it will be shown in London I hope it will be asap thank you God bless! 🙏🏼🙏🏼🙏🏼❤️
When will it be shown in Australia???
Will the film be available worldwide?
Is this movie coming to Australia? I pray so….
Will the movie be shown in the Philippines?
I’m in Australia. Will it be in RUclips. So we can watch it too. Thank you 🙏🏻
Is it coming to Ireland
When will this film be screened in Australia?
@@MBuser4098 The film will be releasing only in the United States for its initial release. It’s quite possible the filmmakers and distributor will consider an international release at a future date in time. Be sure to check the official film website for details ImmaculateMovie2024.com.
Thank you Lady of the miraculous medal rosary Christ cross word love God good cherished in the risen Christ forever ☄️ prince of peace crown always wins the living IAM the Almighty God father son holy spirit ☄️ God's enabling power glory kingdom forever amen
Have not seen it yet in Caribbean Cinemas..Puerto Rico...can someone say when will it be showing?
Poor Chris I have to giggle when he comments on is wonderful teaching are so LONG,,, dear Father he repeatedly repeats things more than twice; lol 😂 love U father
I live in Canada …are they showing it here too?
Will it come to Ottawa, Canada?
Is there a chance it will be shown in the Philippines?
I am in Japan Tokyo how can I see this movie in Tokyo ?
What is the name of father’s what I learned in seminary RUclips channel?
When will this be out on DVD?
How can we from other countries watch and support this movie?
MAR MARI EMMANUEL IS A HOLY MAN WITH THE MESSAGE IN HIS HEART, A BEATIFUL TALENT FOR SPEAKING, DONT LET THE DUMB CONSPIRACY THEROSIT PICTURES THEY USE FOR HIS VIDEOS AND CHANNEL, JUST WATCH A FEW AND I THINK YOULL UNDERSTAND WHAT I MEAN CATHOLICS 😉 🎉❤❤❤❤❤❤❤
O was just thinking about Immaculate, can I find out how her conception transpired? I guess I never knew whether hers is same as her Son Jesus or was it between her human parents?
Bl. Sr. Catherine Emmerich describes the manner of Conception occurring in a special chamber below the 'Holy of Holies' within the Temple of Jerusalem. She relates that this manner of Conception would have occurred if Adam and Eve had not fallen. Its worth reading.
@margaretruiz9655 Hello, would you happen to know which book and volume which it mentions the above?
Mary was chosen by God the Father to be the means by which God becomes man and walks amongst us.... This plan to save humanity from the SIN of Adam and Eve was in place before the foundation of the world...
Most protestants dint know that.... Before Adam and Eve were even created God showed all of Heaven a vision of a woman and told them that He would be born through that woman and take on flesh.... That is why Satan tempted Eve and not Adam because he thought that Mary was Eve..... God already knew that Adam and Eve would sin so He divised a plan to save humanity.... And the plan was MARY
THAT IS WHY MARY IS SO IMPORTANT.
Which Greek Bible version do you recommend?
By the way, I am teaching languages, and Catholic Philosophy class. If anyone's interested in learning Spanish, English, Italian, German, or Philosophy of metaphysical, logic, ethics morality (virtues), contact me. The prices are between two to six dollars, depending on what country you live in. Philosophy can help us strengthen our faith too.
Will this movie open world wide on the 12th of December. I am in south Africa
Hi @janettewitte8868 this first theatrical release will be in the United States only, but there’s certainly a chance it could make its way to you if it has a successful release in North America. Stay tuned at ImmaculateMovie2024.com
Is this showing in Toronto Canada?
Hi @@DanHusband-r6g, the film’s North American release will be in the United States only. But there’s always a chance it could be made available outside the U.S. market. Be sure to follow the film for updates at ImmaculateMovie2024.com
If Protestants say that Mary is not important; then WHY did God the Father, God the Son, Jesus and God the Holy Spirit CHOOSE Mary? When Protestants disparage Mary, they are disparaging the Blessed Holy Trinity.
Hail Mary full of grace!
when is going to be the film available in Argentina?
Palestine didn't exist in the first century. the Roman Empire rename
Judea as Palestine after a jewish rebellion was defeated in the Second Century in the 135 year of our Lord.
❤🙏🙌
Hi I just saw the trailer. This movie looks very theologically rich. Enjoy it. It reminds me to the cartoon movie, "The Grreatest Miracle". Especially the part when the blood drop dropped on the Chalice. But here in this trailer of the "I am the Immalcutaee Conception", I can tell that the blood is time travelling through a warm-hole or such, and I bet that it will also fall on the chalice during the Holy Thursday last supper of Christ. But I might be wrong because in the trailer the blood drop seems to hit something round that looked like an ovarie which then explodes. LOL, But it wouldn't make sense if a blood enter an overie and moreover for the ovarie to explode, 😂. Now, what would makes sense, indeed, is if that blood is not really a blood drop, but a symbol of the Holy Spirit (in the form of a blood drop), entering the womb of Mary. If so, i don't understand why the symbol of a dove is not used for the Holy Spirit..... In anycase, there's only one way to find out, when I watch the movie!.🤪
The immaculate conception dogma is missing from the earliest patristic sources. Mary didn’t even enter into the picture of theological disputes of the church fathers until the upsurge of Christological heresies and the impulse of asceticism and monasticism in church history.
Catholic scholar, Ludwig Ott, admits: “Neither Greek nor Latin Fathers explicitly teach the Immaculate Conception of Mary” (Fundamentals of Catholic Dogma, Tan Publishers, 1960, p. 201)
The New Catholic Encyclopedia (1967, 7:378-81) states that:
“…the Immaculate Conception is not taught explicitly in Scripture … the earliest church Fathers regarded Mary as holy but not as absolutely sinless … It is impossible to give a precise date when this belief was held as a matter of Faith, but by the 8th or 9th century, it seems to have been generally admitted…”
Even after then, controversies over this dogma raged on for a whole 1000 years with the Dominicans fighting the Franciscans over the issue. The so-called “infallible authority” of Rome was neutral on the issue.
Even a 19th century Catholic bishop admitted:
“The Church does not decide the controversy concerning the Conception of the Blessed Virgin, and several other disputed points, because she sees nothing clear and certain concerning them either in the written or unwritten Word, and therefore leaves her children to form their own opinions concerning them” (Cited in George Salmon, The Infallibility of the Church, 182)
This proves that this dogma was a very late development and had just been around only about 150 years. It can’t be supported either with the Bible or traditions.
Give details of what you disagree with that Father Chris Alar is wrong about sir!
Fr. Alar - why do you call Mary’s lifetime Palestine and not Israel? You said “First Century Palestine”
Will you be giving Pope Pious IX credit for declaring the dogma of the Immaculate Conception?
Also Fox Nation is putting out terrible films on Fatima and the saints. Very deceptive.
It wasn't palestine. It was Israel. There never was a country called palestine.
Daily ☄️🌹🌹🌹✝️🐑🕊️🌹💦🩸🎇🙏🏻
To think Mary is just a woman who was Jesus’ mom is insane. She literally carried the Son of God for 9 months and was His Mother. Of course God wants us to revere and praise Her.
She is perfect and could sit and relax in Heaven but She prays and intercedes for us! She is appearing in country after country to warn humanity to repent and turn towards God. That Lady is busy!!!! ✝️🙏🏻🩷
Mark Twain - 'Religion was invented when the first con man met the first fool.'
God - 'Only the fool says there is no God.'
@@markleakos3737 well.. just deliver some scientifically validated proofs.. that's all... nope, a man-made booklet won't count.. so ? got any to share, FlatEarthDave ?
@@RotiJohnPrata-h9o look up Edward Feser: 'Five Proofs for the Existence of God'
Praying for the unbelievers…Blessed Mary bless them❤
@@kimnguyen-ne3hm 🤣🤣🤣 good one, karen... join a comedy tour.. prayers a colossal waste of time for the non-cult members.. are you also into the "thoughts" stuff.. like... "thoughts and prayers".. JFC.. naaa.. better with "apples and pears".. yea, karen ?? now.. is the cake ready ? you are in the kitchen, right ? and barefooted ?? - who is Mary ? is that auntie-Mary ?