Is Niqab Obligatory?
HTML-код
- Опубликовано: 29 июн 2024
- Sign up now to AMAU Academy: www.amauacademy.com/
00:00 Introduction
02:14 What is a hijab?
03:57 Is hijab a cultural practice or an act of worship?
07:18 The importance of intention
08:31 What is the wisdom behind women wearing the hijab?
13:41 The shyness of the righteous women
16:23 The hijab is a protection for women
27:11 The conditions of hijab
29:02 An important disclaimer
33:38 The first ayah to prove niqab is obligatory [Quran 33:53]
44:17 Summary of the first argument
45:30 Counter argument for this ayah
1:01:06 The types of awrah
1:10:53 The second ayah to prove niqab is obligatory [Quran 33:59]
1:16:06 What does the word ‘jilbab’ mean?
1:21:56 Counter argument for this ayah
1:25:50 The importance of context
1:33:22 Summary of the discussion so far
1:35:14 The third ayah to prove niqab is obligatory [Quran 24:31]
1:39:13 What does the word ‘zeenah’ mean?
1:44:17 What is the meaning of the phrase ‘illaa maa dhahara minhaa’?
1:56:11 What does the word ‘khimar’ mean?
2:11:26 Where did Shaykh al-Albani go wrong?
2:14:58 A response to the Mufti of Chechnya
2:18:14 The most beautiful part of a woman is the face
2:20:06 The fourth ayah to prove niqab is obligatory [Quran 24:60]
2:24:04 The fifth ayah to prove niqab is obligatory [Quran 33:33]
2:27:22 The prohibition of wearing the niqab in ihram
2:33:11 The hadith of ‘Aishah covering her face
2:39:00 The hadith of women going out for the ‘Eid prayer
2:42:24 The woman’s leg is awrah
2:45:08 Using logical arguments to prove rulings
2:51:03 The hadith - “the woman is awrah”
2:51:52 Awrah in prayer vs. outside of prayer
2:57:52 The hadith of covering the face in ihram
3:03:23 An important book for students of knowledge
3:04:36 The hadith prohibiting a woman from describing another woman
3:14:13 The hadith of looking at a woman before marriage
3:24:20 Ijma’ that niqab is obligatory
3:33:20 Evidences proving the niqab is not obligatory
3:34:20 The hadith of ‘Aishah and Asmaa bint Abee Bakr
3:47:03 The hadith of Fadl ibn ‘Abbas
3:56:02 The hadith of the woman at the ‘Eid prayer with her cheek uncovered
3:59:02 The hadith of ‘Aishah and the darkness
4:02:50 The hadith of Safiyya being “amongst those who veil”
4:07:24 The hadith of Subai’ah
4:09:05 The hadith of Sahl ibn Sa’d
4:11:48 The hadith prohibiting the lustful look
4:12:30 Closing questions
4:15:28 Summary of the argument that niqab is not obligatory
4:18:52 Final words from Ustadh Abdulrahman Hassan
You can also find us on:
AMAU Academy: www.amauacademy.com/
AMAU Junior: amaujunior.com/
Instagram: / amauofficial
Patreon: / amau
Telegram: t.me/amauofficial
RUclips: / amauofficial
Twitter: / amauofficial
iTunes: podcasts.apple.com/us/podcast...
Spotify: open.spotify.com/show/08NJC1p...
Get in Touch: amau.org/getintouch
BarakAllahu feekum.
#AMAU #AbdulrahmanHassan #TheHotSeat
00:00 Introduction
02:14 What is a hijab?
03:57 Is hijab a cultural practice or an act of worship?
07:18 The importance of intention
08:31 What is the wisdom behind women wearing the hijab?
13:41 The shyness of the righteous women
16:23 The hijab is a protection for women
27:11 The conditions of hijab
29:02 An important disclaimer
33:38 The first ayah to prove niqab is obligatory [Quran 33:53]
44:17 Summary of the first argument
45:30 Counter argument for this ayah
1:01:06 The types of awrah
1:10:53 The second ayah to prove niqab is obligatory [Quran 33:59]
1:16:06 What does the word ‘jilbab’ mean?
1:21:56 Counter argument for this ayah
1:25:50 The importance of context
1:33:22 Summary of the discussion so far
1:35:14 The third ayah to prove niqab is obligatory [Quran 24:31]
1:39:13 What does the word ‘zeenah’ mean?
1:44:17 What is the meaning of the phrase ‘illaa maa dhahara minhaa’?
1:56:11 What does the word ‘khimar’ mean?
2:11:26 Where did Shaykh al-Albani go wrong?
2:14:58 A response to the Mufti of Chechnya
2:18:14 The most beautiful part of a woman is the face
2:20:06 The fourth ayah to prove niqab is obligatory [Quran 24:60]
2:24:04 The fifth ayah to prove niqab is obligatory [Quran 33:33]
2:27:22 The prohibition of wearing the niqab in ihram
2:33:11 The hadith of ‘Aishah covering her face
2:39:00 The hadith of women going out for the ‘Eid prayer
2:42:24 The woman’s leg is awrah
2:45:08 Using logical arguments to prove rulings
2:51:03 The hadith - “the woman is awrah”
2:51:52 Awrah in prayer vs. outside of prayer
2:57:52 The hadith of covering the face in ihram
3:03:23 An important book for students of knowledge
3:04:36 The hadith prohibiting a woman from describing another woman
3:14:13 The hadith of looking at a woman before marriage
3:24:20 Ijma’ that niqab is obligatory
3:33:20 Evidences proving the niqab is not obligatory
3:34:20 The hadith of ‘Aishah and Asmaa bint Abee Bakr
3:47:03 The hadith of Fadl ibn ‘Abbas
3:56:02 The hadith of the woman at the ‘Eid prayer with her cheek uncovered
3:59:02 The hadith of ‘Aishah and the darkness
4:02:50 The hadith of Safiyya being “amongst those who veil”
4:07:24 The hadith of Subai’ah
4:09:05 The hadith of Sahl ibn Sa’d
4:11:48 The hadith prohibiting the lustful look
4:12:30 Closing questions
4:15:28 Summary of the argument that niqab is not obligatory
4:18:52 Final words from Ustadh Abdulrahman Hassan
السلام عليكم ورحمة الله وبركاته
When shahid kept asserting that the statement of Asmaa كنا نخمر على وجوهنا ونحن محرمات wasnt sareeh in its proving the obligation of niqaab, why did Ustadh not mention that the asl in ihram is to leave the face uncovered so only another obligation can remove the initial prohibition.
Am I missing a trick somewhere or is my reasoning valid?
I appreciate that me messaging here and expecting a reply is somewhat unlikely but I would really really appreciate it if I did get something back :)
Jazaakumallahu khayra
00 i
8 AM 888988888988I 6668898888 is 99 inches 897779999899998999am in
ineed niqaab is fard for all muslim women
Assalamualaikum sheikh is there any book on niqab for women and beard for for men?
This brother takes the religion so seriously that he dealt with this subject for four hours. It shows his sincerity in the religion of Islam. I think this brother will become one of the greatest scholars of modern times, with his eloquence and character. May we all benefit from this man, and may allah make his work be beneficial to us.
I also think he will become a great scholar of Islam, that’s why I want to learn from him lol. And Allah knows best.
Ameen
آمين
Bro what kind of extreme ness is this ? He is literally just another ant in the seas in the Muslim lands I see this every single day in madinah and I’ve seen 15 year olds with 10x more knowledge in Mauritania who will live and die and you’ll never even know they existed rather their status will be with allah. Correct your statement he will probably we one of the biggest students from the WESTERN non Muslim countries. This is the problem with the ummah they are so far connected from the ulema and the inheritors of the prophets knowledge
@@Islam.is.the.truth..
You don’t know how to respect other speakers?! Calling him an ant?!
please make dua that Allah gives me the strength to wear hijab.
You sis it's one of those things that you need to JUST START Sometimes. There's never a "right time" even if you feel conflicted in your heart about it (which I pray Allah removes it for you and makes it easy for you to obey Him, Subhana Watala. ameen ) Keep doing it, even if it feel uncomfortable or not sincere and in sha Allah The sincerity will eventually enter your heart.
It's kinda like FAke it til you make it.
Just as we leave off eating healthy or working out FOREVER, waiting for a Monday, next week or next month after this or that. Yalla JUST START. Bismillah. Allahu tala Alim
May Allah give you and every Muslim sister the strength and emaan to wear hijab and stay firm on the deen
May الله help you. However, you have to take the means of increasing your imān which will lead to you wearing Hijab. Doing good deeds and staying away from bad deeds is what builds your imān.
Do more righteous deeds and Allah will increase your piety. May Allah guide you to the straight path and help you establish the obligatory acts.
May Allah guide you to hijab and niqab. Ameen
But you have to work on it, inshAllah.
Alhamdoellilah i started covering my face without having any knowlegde but my gut feeling told me it would bring me closer to Allah swt and it did. Many people tried to change my mind by telling me it is not socially accepted. But living in the time we live in, the norm of being socially excepted is not something that brings anyone closer to Allah swt so i feel like i´m winning alhamdoellilah. I hope that Allah swt brings every woman and man closer to Allah swt, forgives our sins and increases our knowlegde In sha allah yaa rabbi.
Allahumma barik.
Same thing my aunt said to me when wearing the the jilbab, that it took time to accept amongst family, people etc. So even if it is not socially acceptable, you BECOME the social change until it BECOMES socially accepted. And all the reward would go to the first who revived the deen.
@@ObaidahNaseer May Allah swt bless you and your aunt, may he make the Ummah of Mohammed steadfast and devoted to our Deen and may he protect and forgive us!
@@safaeelhamouti5436remember to always send salawat upon the prophet saw
which country do u live in
How beautiful is a woman who humbles herself by submitting her will to ALLAH instead of being a slave of the trend! Humbleness is simplicity!
👍👍
Haqq
I LOVE these academic conversations - I think our ummah has been surrounded by fluff for so long.
That is the problem with the da'wah scene today. Heart softners after heart softners with some imān boosters and some drama without teaching the people about rulings and principles to gain knowledge.
Allahumma Barik,say this when liking something or someone.Assalamualaikum, Jazak Allahu Khairan
Lol I was expecting it to be a 5 min Q&A...not a hot seat discussion of 4hrs. SubhanAllah. May Allah bless our Ustadh n the host
انا كمان ههههه
Me too 😂
Allahuma ameen
آمين
Hahahaha hahahaha hahaha 😆😆🤣🤣🤣😂😂😂😂🤣🤣🤣😂😂🤣😂🤣🤣🤣🤣😂😂
Get really......
The only thing is not change in Islam is Qur'an and Makkah...........
See people in Haje/Makkah that's the real fashion acceptable by ALLAH j...
Who else watched the whole video? haha I started wearing niqab about 2 years ago alhumdulillah. Im in the US and alhumdulillah my experience had been really great. May Allah protect me. Many women hold fear that is only in themselves and will not be manifested in reality. Many women who wear niqab here have never if only once encountered a negative situation. Love these discussions thanks so much, may Allah reward you.
May Allah strengthen you and all of our muslim sisters. Ameen
Niqab is the symbol of radicalism and fundamentalist bigotry
Ameen.
this comment is so reassuring as a sister who wants to wear Niqab full time, Allahumma barik sister
@@Zzucia agreed subhanAllah ❤
I met Ustadh Abdur Rahman Hassan in 2015, he is a man of an extremely humble nature and by Allah he exceeded and surpassed many in seeking knowledge and spreading it. May Allah protect him, preserve him and further guide him. Anyone in capacity to help him in spreading the Deen should help him, and otherwise never forget to make Dua for him. People like him are rare
@@changinglifestyle6675 what are u talking about??💀
I agree I first met him in 2018, you can see humility in the way he carries himself in public and around him. اللهم احفظه و أمثاله و زاد امثالهم
What slave girls?
It took 4hrs plus to sit down to discuss this topic Subhanallah. Shows its seriousness and I think a lot of us are shocked because we didn't see the importance and seriousness of the dress code of the Muslimah.
As always these podcasts are full of benefits. May Allah elevate your status and reward everyone behind this channel 🤲🏾
Allahuma ameen
Ameen
as a male, wallahi the niqab, haya ,etc, are a blessing for you my sister.
Why emphasise you're a male.
Imagine if the talk was over and the cameraman says "Oops forgot to press record..once more please"
Oh maan😂😂😂😂
Can't imagine.. 😂😂😂😆😆😆
That would be just too much😆😆😆😆😆
Something tells me a man like Ustadh Abdur Rahman would still be dedicated to do the whole video again. His aspirations are lofty اللهم بارك
😂😂😂Mashallah may Allah bless you
Thanks to Covid we all Muslim women in western countries can start wearing niqab now that we and others are used to have the mouth and nose covered InshAllah
I am a revert, however when I was a teenager I watched many science documentaries on TV, ine of which was a sex psychology doscumentary. One of the things they mentioned from a study, of which they showed in practice, is that when a woman walks her hips go left-forward and right-forward. They had a woman walking on a treadmill. Then they introduced men into the room and her hips went from forward-motion to a swivel-motion, which the scientists dedict is meant to show off thr circumference of the womans hips which could aid in a man knowing the woman's fertility. Wearing loose clothing can aid in covering this subconscious behavior.
Another thing they had pointed out was that when a man is looking for a woman to simply satisfy his lust, he fosucses on her chest and backside. However, when a man is looking for a mate (of which to have children) he focuses on her face. Our face gives a summary of our genes and health based on symmetry. The more symmetrical, the more genetically healthy and, in a way, of "higher quality" that woman's genetic heritage is.
I have always gone back-and-forth on mustahaab and waajib on the topic of niqab, but that is simply because I cannot read Arabic for myself yet. I am only halfway finished but I am learning so many things pertaining to this topic as well as overall tools to help taking meaning out of the Qur'an.
May Allah bless all those that took part in this video and debate.
@@nobbynobbs8182
Firstly, since we all follow the same religious sources (Qur'an and Sunnah), one Muslim group cannot, therefore, be inherently more or less misogynistic than the other. All Muslims collectively are either all misogynistic or collectively not. So that statement is a logical fallacy.
Secondly, Islam isn't misogynistic at all. Feel free to quote what you will to argue your claim. I am studying to become a Sheikha (inshaAllah) so I am pretty well versed in many areas and I also write debates as if I am giving an argument essay to my Wnglish professor back in the US.
Thirdly, I am not part of any sect. The Qur'an is clear:
" Indeed, those who have divided their religion and become sects - you, [O Muhammad], are not [associated] with them in anything. Their affair is only [left] to Allah ; then He will inform them about what they used to do." (6:159)
So if I am part of any sect then I am out the fold of Islam.
@@asiyaheibhlin yessir may allah give u aafiya in this world and in the next.
This is all true I took psychology for further studies and we had to do an experiment on attractiveness and what denotes it and how to measure it. And everything you mentioned comes into play
@@asiyaheibhlin May Allah grant you success in your righteous aspirations and Jannahtul Firdaws
But if a man is looking for marriage, he is allowed to look at a woman's face?
I highly appreciate this podcast. As a sister that has been wearing the niqab for two years I have taken the same perspective as the ustadh I'm very glad he touched on the topic of hajj for the niqabi women! I have always wondered this. May Allah bless these brothers!! I pray that I can have even half of their knowledge. May Allah protect them. Is there a way we can send questions?
Hes a fraudster ignore him he's sent the same message to everyone. Please report him immediately on YT so others are warned too!!
@@changinglifestyle6675 yes I did ignore him and I did report him I noticed he commented on many others as well
@@josuegoncalves4321
Jazaakomollah khair
I am a high school student and i recently started wearing niqab. And its the best thing ever. The way the atmosphere around you changes and the way your peers know not to speak of ill things around you(backbiting etc). Its just so full of peace
At the beginning I just bought one and wore it because I found it really beautiful. Putting one on is easy but keeping it on is hard especially if the barrier is ones own family
I feel u sis. May Allah make it easy for us to wear it
May allah open the hearts of your family members to accepting and loving your niqab ameen
Same sis. May Allah make it easy for us allahumma ameen
Ahhhh cannot agree with you more
I’m in the same position! Some relatives are like this even with regard to hijab! I have some relatives telling me to remove the khimar and other relatives telling me I shouldn’t wear an abaya and to wear brighter colored clothes. Best part? I come from a Muslim background lol.
I just bought a niqab online so I’m a little scared to see what they say but Allah al Mustaan ❤❤❤
When I first saw this video I'd been wearing the niqab casually for about 2-3 months, because I knew it was at least mustahabb so may as well be rewarded for wearing it every now and then.
This was the video that convinced me of it being fard and I have now kept it on for over a year.
Jazakumullahu khair.
So there's a thing happened with me today.I'm from India.A hindu invigilator was saying me to remove my niqab(nosepiece) otherwise I will not be able to sit in the examination hall where boys were also present there.she was saying u are not the only special one whom we will allow to cover your face. You are not in the class u are in examination hall.She was continuously saying this to me and was not signing on OMR sheet.But Alhamdulillah I didn't remove my niqab☺️ and finally she's almost exhausted and at last signed and allowed me saying that u are very stubborn, didn't uncover your face.😂
Barak Allah sister❤
BTW which city in India?
@@a_MuslimahhhAssalamualaikum dear sister, I am also from India and I am in a problem related to you. The thing is that I am in 11th grade and going to be in 12th grade this year and as you know we have board exams which are held in different examination centre. I'm thinking of going as a private student for the board exams so that I can wear proper hijab clothing and give the exam directly without going to school. Now the thing is that I am not sure if they will let me wear the niqab or not as you know that people in India are being extra against hijab and burkha. So can you tell me what exam were you giving and what is your advice on my situation. As I do feel that it is obligatory. Also I admire your bravery and steadfastness, may Allah bless you sister.
@@user-xl8jy3xi8w وَ؏ـليڪم الســّــــلام ورحمـة اللَّـه وبـرڪاتـــــه
May Allah bless you for your efforts towards deen. Actually when I was in 10th grade I was just a hijabi,May Allah forgive me for my days of ignorance. So I gave 10th boards exam with only hijab on.Then after that Allah swt guided me Alhamdulillah & in 11th grade I started wearing proper hijab& niqab Alhamdulillah. As for 12th grade it was in lockdown covid time and I got promoted without board exam.Wallah I thank Allah for this blessing bcoz I was so concerned that how would I give the exams without hijab & niqab.If you'll go as a private student they'll allow you to wear hijab but I'm not sure they wouuld allow niqab.But I think it's better.Wallahu aalam. May Allah make it easy for you sister,accept it from you Ameen. بارك الله فيك
How do you verify identity if you don't show your face?
Does your admit card have a photograph?
Notice: They're talking about NIQAB.
Hijab is FARDH
Well said! The head and neck of a woman is no doubt part of the Awrah to be covered in front of the ghayr mahram man. The only part of the woman’s body that the scholars differed about being part of the Awrah is the face and hands and feet
Though another thing to note is that for the view that states covering the hand and face is obligatory, covering those two become apart of hijab. Niqab is a means of covering ones face.
Obligation from Allah is fundamental cant be NO
Obligation from a state/kingdom is not fundamental.
Iam not give up yet😢
@@sillybeans929 Yes it is according to consensus
@@sillybeans929 (Shaving the beard is haraam because of the saheeh ahaadeeth that clearly state this, and because of the general application of texts that forbid resembling the kuffaar. One of these reports is the hadeeth of Ibn ‘Umar who said that the Messenger of Allaah (peace and blessings of Allaah be upon him) said: “Be different from the mushrikeen: let your beards grow and trim your moustaches.”)
Podcast on if transactions involving riba in the west are permitted based off of dharura etc and the opinion of Abi Hanifa (ra).
yes.
@@UmmFatimah20 Evidence?
Jazak Allahu khayran for your efforts. May Allah reward you immensely.
BarakAllahufeekum , this was veryyy insightful , really needed a video regarding this topic jazakumAllahukhayra.
Learnt so much from this that I misunderstood previously , your efforts have not gone to waste الله يحفظكما
I cant thank you enough for this video
في ميزان حسناتك يوم القيامة. امين
2:11:26 This Brother, the amount he reads is incredible mashaAllah. May Allah increase him in knowledge, aamiin.
"The best woman is the one who does not see men and is not seen by men" [أحكام النساء]
Where is this quote from Jazakallahu Khair
Basically stay at home and never go out
@@waalidkagabdhihiisaguddaah63 Except for necessities + mosque
@@waalidkagabdhihiisaguddaah63 the home is her sanctuary not a solitude confiement. Different perspective. Abdullah ibn Masud was asked by his wife to buy her a Jilbaab, he said the House is her Jilbaab. The home is a peaceful abode where women can carry out their acts and get closer to Allah.
Please give me reference
A smart muslims is the one who rushes towards goodness, whether obligatory or not as long the evidences are in the Qur'an and Sunnah. May Allah grant us the strength and steadfastness to perform more good deeds.
Ameen ya Rabb
Finished it in one sitting alhumdulillah!! It was a lot but Jazakallah khair for representing the both side. Btw the question is not "should one wear niqab or not" , as a matter of fact both side concedes every woman should wear niqab. The discussion was about the ruling whether its an obligation or not.
So every woman should cut off all social interaction from society and be seen as an outcast?
@@MH-bf4uu What are you on about? I would not say that if I were you. You're implying that the wives of the Prophet were social outcasts, which is essentially an insult. Be very careful. Do not mock the religion of Allah by saying that his legislation makes women outcasts. It is consensus that Niqab is a recommended act of worship. Be careful, and respect the legislation of your Lord
@@MH-bf4uu . Fear Allah and delete your comments
Niqab is obligatory
So what is the conclusion?
SubhanAllah 4 hrs 30 mins, that’s how you know that this is going to be a good one
Ok somebody summarize what he said for me cuz I aint bout to watch all of this
@@ye23. read the time stamps, I have not finished it yet.
@@ye23. LMAOOO
Jazakallah for this video and its lengthy analysis.
May Allah preserve you both, ameen.
Jazakallah Ustadh ... this pod is an excellent resource for the english speaking world
Jazakallahu khairan for this informative and interesting episode. May Allah reward you brothers. Continue doing more episodes on important topics like this.
@@josuegoncalves4321
May Allah reward you both for sharing so much information alhamdulilah. Very educational.
JazaakAllaahu khair ustad abdul rahman al hassan ❤️ may Allaah bless u
Ustadh I really love your for the sake of Allah. May Allah bless you and keep you steadfast.
جزاك اللَّه خيراً
Subhana Allah there is soo much to learn from this and as a woman Alhamdulillah some companies allow us to cover our heads and i can testify to the fact that our faces can be a grt cause of fitna from men and fellow women subhana Allah, just with your face exposed men and women will complement you to the point that you will feel like your not covered at all (naked). As women we may deny this fact but our face does cause fitna and Allahu ya'alam, may HE(ALLAH) make it easy for us, guide us and forgive us all. ameen
Disclaimer: This is not to say that i'm saying niqab is wajib but i feels like its best for us as women. salaam
My parents definitely will kick me out if i use niqab😓
you don't need to work in a company unless its absolutely essential for you to
@@skyinuri8868 I doubt it it will be shameful in the community ppl will ask “where is your daughter “. Most likely they will make life difficult but they won’t throw you out .
I had a lot of abuse only when I got married they backed off from the abuse . Things get better with time
Yup!!! I thought it was only me that felt kind of naked and out in the open when people could see my face. This is just my personal experiences but it felt like it kind of nullified my hijab.
Been waiting for this, Alhamdulillah :D
Masya Allah, Jazakallah khoir ustadz
Jazakallahu khayran ustadhunaa ♥️
May almighty Allah perceive and Strengthen the brother. Beautiful explanations, proves from the Qur'an and Hadiths lastly, logic. That's enough to prove Niqab is compulsory. May Allah increase the brother in Knowledge of the Deen. Evidences from the Qur'an,Hadiths and logic is clear to proved it compulsory. The view here is, weather is directed to the wives of the prophet( SAW) or not, we should in any way follow them if we are true followers of the Qur'an and Sunnah. Another logic, if the time we are living now is worst that the time of the companions then, definitely Niqab should be compulsory.
This bout to be🔥
Let’s face it , if you carefully and objectively study the Quran , ahadeath and seera on the issue of covering the face you will find more evidence supporting niqab then hijab and it’s not just an extreme wahabi position like many muslims like to say, and Allah knows best
Its still not mandatory
@@sarakhreawish6322 okay ms. desires
Yeah that's deffo not true
@@MH-bf4uu do you know usul ul fiqh?
@@sarakhreawish6322 yes
As salaamu alaikum warahmatullahi wabarakhathu
ماشاالله
Akhi Allah has brought you close to him by giving you knowledge. May He accept your efforts in parting your knowledge with us
Wa alaykumasalm warahamatullahi wa barakatuhu
I like how they are matching, Allahuma Barik.
Allahu Akbar. Ustaz Abdulrahman, may Allah increase you in knowledge. The host is also very good. His questions were very hard walahi. May Allah grant you Jannah both. The best podcast out there.
Asalamualaikum. Subhanallah this was so informational May Allah swt bless the work you are doing. I did want to ask however, if you can inshallah make a video on men’s modesty and how they are supposed to dress as well. So that the women can know what to look for as well in regards to haya in a man. Jazakallah khair
Wa alaykumasalm
Masha Allah a very interesting talk.
Loved the way the discussion moved from one point to the other.
A question I was pondering over was on the two types of Awrah mentioned.
The same Aya used for obligation of veiling outside Salah by later scholars were used as proof for removing veil in Salah or Marriage by the Imams(like Imam Shafiee).
So how do we reconcile this?
Example:
ونقل المزني عن الشافعي أنه فسر الآية { وَلَا يُبْدِينَ زِينَتَهُنَّ إِلَّا مَا ظَهَرَ مِنْهَا } ، بأنها الوجه والكفان ، فقال : «قال : وإذا أراد أن يتزوج المرأة فليس له أن ينظر إليها حاسرة وينظر إلى وجهها وكفيها وهي متغطية بإذنها وبغير إذنها قال الله تعالى {ولا يبدين زينتهن إلا ما ظهر منها} [النور: 31] قال الوجه والكفان
Jazak Allah kheir
Subhan Allah may Allah reward you Ameen please simplify such women related topics for the busy sisters and mums. 4 hours!!!
Jazak Allah khairan yaa ustadh wa barakallahu fikum
Hes a fraudster ignore him he's sent the same message to everyone. Please report him immediately on YT so others are warned too!!
Does anyone know who the reciter is at the beginning of the video? MashaAllah it’s one of the most beautiful recitations I’ve heard. Jazak’Allah Khair.
Is Abdurahman Hassan himself
I actually love these hot seat podcasts and I love how the brother grills the ustaad. Not many people play the devil's advocate well.
Wouldn't use the term "devil's advocate" as no one wants to be associated with shaytaan. I fully understand what you mean, but perhaps its better to say something else like "
He clearly said he there as the 3rd party and he needed to show the ustadz the encounter opinions
Finally finished, alhamdulilah
الله يجزآك خير على المحتوى المثري
Next podcast, please on the beautiful names and attributes of Allah the almighty.
Those who say that shayk albani didn’t think it was obligatory let’s not forget that shayk albani recommended niqab in his books and his wife’s wore niqab too...
Yes. A person can hold the opinion it is not obligatory and still wear it hoping for more reward from الله.
He has more than one wife? Who?
@@sarakhreawish6322 Abu Hurairah (May Allah be pleased with him) reported:
Messenger of Allah (ﷺ) said, "It is from the excellence of (a believer's) Islam that he should shun that which is of no concern to him".
[At-Tirmidhi].
عن أبي هريرة رضي الله عنه قال: قال رسول الله صلى الله عليه وسلم : " من حسن إسلام المرء تركه ما لا يعنيه"
((حديث حسن رواه الترمذي وغيره))
Riyad as-Salihin 67
@@sarakhreawish6322 shayk albani had 4 wives
@@abuabdullah1972 ok then😳
باركم الله فيكم ويرعاكم ويسددكم...
الأخ ،عبد الرحمان الله يبارك فيه ... وينفع به الأمة ...
متمسك على العقيدة والمنهج السليم....
جزاك الله خيرا
Proud Niqabi here ☝
Who else 😊
Allahumma barik may Allah keep you steadfast
@WJ Sky
Alhumdulillah habibti
@@DryDownfall Ameen and sincere
Niqabi Inshallah💚
اللهم بارك. May Allah keep all my sisters steadfast especially in today's society
بارك الله فيكم.
Amazing & how clear it is to cover the women completely ! Those who oppose have no real proof really ! As a woman... I am proud of this & happy .
MashaAllah brother great work! I have a request please do add references on the screen.
May Allah allow me to wear the niqab someday ameen.
Ameen ❤
Ameen 💜
Ameen. Sister it is best to not have your picture on your account, scholars do not allow this. You don't want people to save your photo. May Allah bless you.
I started wearing niqab in 2023 this video makes me very confident about wearing niqab ❤
May Allah keep you steadfast sister
Thank you so much JasakAllahu khairun ❤@@bleekwater6176
@@bleekwater6176 💝ameen May Allah bless you♡
May Allah malik bless u n reward u brother for explaining in detail and women shld cover the face
Wearing niqab is not about beauty. Everyone finds beauty differently , it’s not about what people think , beauty is subjective ... all Muslim woman are beautiful in their own way , niqab is to please Allah , and it’s about Haya and modesty, bashfulness
Hes a fraudster ignore him he's sent the same message to everyone. Please report him immediately on YT so others are warned too!!
@changinglifestyle6675 why you said it
جزاك الله خيرا
We need to show this to Abu Layth .
Agreed
You bet he'll still add something dirty up and say naughty naughty 😒😒
@Abū AbdulRahmān al-Aqeeli agree
Abu Layth is not the type of guy who will take anything but his desires as a form of evidence, so don't bother.
Subhan'Allah how can anyone take abu layth serious lol clown
May Allah give him hidayah
I was convinced with the 7th point ❤️
May Allah reward you both iqwaan
Aameen
I hope those seats are comfortable 👀
Yes Abu Musa. You can try to sell them the chairs 😂🤣
Love the smile at the beginning :)
اللهم بارك عليهما
اللّٰهم بارك
4:15:32
The summary at the end given by the respected scholar who say that niqab is mustahab not obligatory, is that in Islam every thing is easy, so for working women niqab is a burden so it is mustahab.
I personally think this could be extended very badly in all teachings of Islam by saying that it is very difficult to offer all salahs punctually, especially during winters, it is very difficult to do wudu with cold water and vice versa for summers.
A lot of time is consumed by offering salah, people have to postpone their plans, students are affected by it, it is very unfair for labourers who work hard all day and they have to even offer their Isha prayer in this exhausted condition, and they have to wake uo again early for Fajar, it just makes life difficult for people.
It is very burdensome to have Soum especially during summers.
Ill people who doesn't have Soum are still liable to pay penalty for it.
During jihad people lives are at stake literally, why would Allah Tala order something very burdensome (life threatening) ??!!
Why would Allah Tala make such hard rulings ?!
Don't you think this is a very weak argument, and by this, every commandment of Allah Tala would seem burdensome to some extent ?
Obviously Heaven is not cheap, and the reward of Heaven is far much bigger than the burden of obligations.
Salam
Salaam, I don't want to get into a lengthy discussion or debate, I'm learning too, but just to add to your points. If we use that reasoning for things like Salah or Fasting, those things have been ordained very clearly as being obligatory, and are also pillars of Islam. No one would dispute that Salah and Fasting are obligatory, whereas with Niqab their is a difference of opinion regariding it. And when Salah becomes difficult, you need only pray the fard prayers, you can pray sitting or lying, with fasting, if you have a valid reason like ill health, you can skip the fast and do it later. So the exceptions and scenarios have been given already.
Also, I think regarding niqab, it's not just an issue of difficulty but of practicality, like if a woman was buying/selling outside, in some situations, if she concealed her identity then if there was a security issue we couldn't identify her. If all women in the world wore niqab, and were in the workplace for example, we wouldn't know who they were. There would be many times when a man would mistake a woman for another woman. I'm just imagining the scenario, but Allah knows best and I'm also learning.
@@RehmatDeen Wa Alaikum As Salam Brother
JazakAllah for your narrative brother.
I literally respect it.
@@RehmatDeenwallahi brother you are so on point. Even someone who wears niqab i am never able to convince myself it's obligatory for the fact that it's hard for security reasons. Like apart from all fitna discussion face is how we know other person. That's the core purpose of it and then of course it's also makes one beautiful because having one's unique identity is what really pretty. But that's the secondary purpose of it not primary.
Now, as long as someone isn't beautifying their face keep it natural as it is i only see face as how I identify other person. ( I'm not giving any fatwa just sharing few concerns) allah ho Alam.
And definitely fasting, praying is obligatory we can't compare this issue with pillar of islam.
Very important video but just advice wallahi these days people dont have attention span to last 4 hrs on 1 topic.
Iv seen other scholars cut their videos so they share like 10min snippets of highlights and very important parts.
You will reach more people that way InshaAllah
You can watch it in parts. I watch it in 10 minute parts and im nearly on 2 hours.. I agree with you but the issue of niqaab being wajib/recomended is a very in depth issue. Cutting it short doesn't really do it justice.. Wallahu a'laam.
I think if ppl don’t have the attention span they don’t have the commitment . If they really want to watch and really wish to learn they will watch it in segments?
BarakAllahu Feek
The gost should be applauded for presenting challenging questions to Ustad Hassan. The question of the bondswoman was very challenging, and the host kept pressing the ustad when he wasn't satisfied with the response. May Allah bless them both
it would be nice if there were timestamps in the description box
The first comment from the channel has a time map
@@perilouslambasting6816 thanks
Only English language UTube channel I trust to present authentic teaching of Islam and to translate the Arabic correctly. Many others are sincere but without enough learning or intelligence.Tbis doesn't mean I think he is 100 % correct about everything.
I would recommend Muhammad Huzaifah, Abu Muss'ab Wajdi Akkari (One Way to Paradise), and Ustadh Yasin Munye. There are others, but these three are very good. The first and last are very strong students of knowledge, and the middle is a very knowledgeable da'i. All three are either Arabs or very strong in Arabic after having studied with scholars
اللّٰه اكبر. ماشاء اللّٰه
From the context of 4:02:00 to 4:07:00. Here Hijab is used as an umbrella term to indicate the Niqab for Safiyyah. As it is mentioned in the previous hadiths that the women of the believers were ordered to wear the niqab and not the headscarf type of Hijab (Which is usual type of hijab).
question: the ustadh mentioned that there was a khilaf between the scholars if it’s wajib or not...however the ustadh brought many ijma’s. how can there be khilaf if there is an ijma’? can someone please explain
People are trying to erase modesty.. and funnily enough WOMEN are encouraging this, not knowing the consequences.
Absolutely. There are so many immodestly dressed men these days.
Nope Being to modest and looking like a ninja anyways and says its mandatory is dumb
Aselamualykum werahmetulah ikhwani
Nurhassen from Ethiopia
وعليكم السلام ورحمة الله وبركاته
Wa alaykum alsalam wa rahmatullahi wa barakatuhu from San Diego California
barakAllah feekum
The question to be asked is what benefit is there for the women to uncover their faces in front of strange non mahram men? If there is a need to uncover for security purposes for example, that is one thing. As for making the default uncovering it in front of thousands of men, many of which will be staring, goes against the point of the hijab.
( ٢/٧٤) يقول الغزالي: "لم تزل الرجال على مر الأزمان تكشف الوجوه، والنساء يخرجن منتقبات أو يمنعن من الخروج" إحياء علوم الدين
Al-Ghazali said: “Throughout the ages, men have been uncovering their faces, and women go out wearing niqabs or were prevented from going out.” Ihyaa Uloom ad-deen (2/74)
قال الإمام الجويني إمام الحرمين في موسوعته الفقهية " نهاية المطلب " (12/ 31 - 32):
(اتفاق المسلمين على منع النساء من التبرج والسفور وترك التنقب) انتهى.
Al Juwayni (d.478 H) said: The muslims have agreed on preventing women from tabarruj (adorned) and uncovering their faces and leaving the face veil
I would suggest everyone google "french algerian propoganda poster". You will see that the enemies of Islam for quite some time have been wanting the women to uncover their faces.
And also it's within a womans nature. Even non-Muslim women feel uncomfortable when men look at them.
Assalamoualeikoum,it's sufficient to know the dua that Muhammad salalahualeihiwasalam made for Ibn Abass radialaanhu to take his tafseer.
So true
Can our prophet's (saws) dua ever be rejected? Seems unlikely
Ma sha Allah
Allahumma Barik,say this when liking something or someone.Assalamualaikum, Jazak Allahu Khairan
Hes a fraudster ignore him he's sent the same message to everyone. Please report him immediately on YT so others are warned too!!
@@changinglifestyle6675 excuse me brother,are you referring to me or someone else? please clarify.
@@mgzs3073 no not you. The fraduster has deleted they post. Sorry to alarm you if you never saw the post. I wanted to warn everyone.
@@changinglifestyle6675 ya man,I know about that post.Crazy dude out there!May Allah guide us,ameen.
@@changinglifestyle6675 Assalamualaikum Wa Rahmatullahi Wa Barakatuhu, Jazakum Allahu Khairan
The verse 13:5 recited at the starting of video is mistakenly recited. It will be "hum fi ha kholidun" in stead of "fi ha kholidun".
Please check it.
He said hum fee ha Khalidoon listen carefully
I thought "Hum" was recited, but the sound of the animation makes it hardly to hear it clearly.
He did recite it, it's just the animation that fades it out
The recital is saheeh...the sound effects drown out the HUM of that ayat...
Allahuma barek 4hours
May Allah reward our ustadh
Could someone tell me the summary please
BTW I'm already wearing niqab Alhumdulillah
Mashallah May Allah preserve you sister
@@adnanalsarraj897
Allahuma Ameen and you and your family
They’re strong argument for both sides from what I have heard in the video .
@@nafisamohamed2851
Subhan'Allah wish it was more straightforward but nevertheless I love it and do feel closer to my Rab wearing it just gets abit hard when I get harassed even now after everyone is literally a niqabi I still get sworn at ect...by some ignorants but I don't really care anymore Alhumdulillah its my jihad
Jazakallahu khayran ukhti
@@stepstojannah8173 mashallah sister I’m literally inspired by you and other niqabis I’m 17 now I’m thinking about wearing a niqab one day. I think this video wasn’t just about giving a straightforward answer but to provide evidence for those who want change their particular stance or keep their stance on niqab and for those who claim it’s extreme or cultural they explain that in the video.
Alhamdulillah
Conditions of Hijab
1. Hijab must cover the entire body (the thought of it being just a head scarf gets wiped out by this)
2. It should be thick enough to cover what's underneath it
3. It should be loose fitting and not tight.
4. It should not be so attractive as to cause mens attention to it. (Make up, bows, headbands, Hair clips etc.)
5. It should not be perfumed.
6. It should not be a dress of fame or extravagant in any way
7. It should not resemble the dress of men.
8. It should not resemble the dress of men
9. It should not resemble the dress of disbelieving women
10. It should not be adorned with any religious symbols (crosses) or any being with a soul (animals, people).
4,5 hourssss 😱😱😱😱😱
If u wanna a str8 answer read the description of the video.
What was the take on
Shaykh Al Abani رحمه الله opinion on this discussion? He was of the position that niqab and covering of the hands isn’t obligatory for a woman but recommended
And he made his female family members wear niqab.
Subhanallah
When Ustad says 'blossom' he is referring to the word 'bosom' meaning a woman's chest/ breasts.
I had a feeling this was the case but I wasn't sure if he just meant blossom like beauty or adornment. Jazaakillahu khayraa
How do you know what is going through his brain when he said that?
Yes I’m sure it was an error in speech because blossoms pertain to 🌹
السلام عليكم ورحمة الله وبركاته
When shahid kept asserting that the statement of Asmaa كنا نخمر على وجوهنا ونحن محرمات wasnt sareeh in its proving the obligation of niqaab, why did Ustadh not mention that the asl in ihram is to leave the face uncovered so only another obligation can remove the initial prohibition.
Am I missing a trick somewhere or is my reasoning valid?
I appreciate that me messaging here and expecting a reply is somewhat unlikely but I would really really appreciate it if I did get something back :)
Jazaakumallahu khayra
وعليكم السلام ورحمة الله وبركاته
Imaam Malik's MUWATTA Book 20 Hadith # 20.5.16
Yahya related to me from Malik from Hisham ibn Urwa that Fatima bint al-Mundhir (Radhiallaahu Ánha) said, "We used to veil our faces when we were in Ihram in the company of Asma bint Abi Bakr As-Siddiq (Radhiallaahu Ánha).
"This proves that not only the wives of Rasulullah (Sallallaahu Álayhi Wasallam) wore the Niqaab and that even though in Ihram women are not supposed to wear Niqaab but if men are there they still have to cover the face.
Barakah'allah fiqhm