My stomach hurts from laughing so hard. I've only ever read the manga and these parts are so serious but the fucking pans being thrown down stairs kills me
the craziest part to me is that during the action this show actually can look pretty cool sometimes. and then there's every single other moment in this show that isn't action, it looks so balls.
I love the SFX of Gut's sword in this version. It doesn't sound anything like a sword, because, well, let's be honest. It's hardly a sword. "It was too big to be called a sword. Massive, thick, heavy, and far too rough. Indeed, it was a heap of raw iron."
But it doesn't sound like that either, it just sounds like a hollow pipe too close to the microphone. It's like they tried to add "weight" to it by just making it louder.
Honestly, I get what they were going for, and that's what makes it so terrible, because of what it could've been. Watch the guts versus nightmare death battle. It came out almost a year before this anime did, and they nailed it. The sound itself isn't the problem. It's the constant use of it, and dear God the volume!
The entire anime would look badass if some good studio took it. It's a manga masterpiece. I don't think I have read any more detailed manga anywhere else.
there was a 2d version of that scene that they used in the trailer of the season for whatever reason, they decided just to remake the entire scene in 3d
i was just thinking that. That eye getting smaller was tight, they should have just done the series exactly like golden age and profited while giving us something good.
Whilst I don't like it, I can see how it could potentially work. The main problem is that it's SO DAMNED LOUD! It's painfully loud and has way too high frequency, so it really ends up sounding like a bunch of pots falling down the stairs...
Man if this CGI is terrible then I suppose Houseki no Kuni, Fate/Zero, and Attack on Titan were terrible too huh? Drop your bullshit and just enjoy the anime you watch.
The problem is that the CG is bad, not necessarily for having it in general. Like with the clang noises, its just awkward and an alternative would be much better.
We can put this into some good perspective I suppose. Berserk is a decently old anime by now that didn't make a whole lot of money. However they did their absolute best to make these new seasons have a much higher quality, leading to CGI which is logically just the next step forward in quality for anime. They might not have done quite as good of a job as some anime, but I personally believe they still did fantastic. The effects are on par with RWBY (however it lacks the same quality in characters), and it still had me binge watching the entire anime. Sit back, relax, and enjoy an anime instead of everyone deciding to critique every little detail they don't like. I don't know why so many people are such sensitive, bitchy critics on the internet.
Not against bones, lol. Take a cleaver and chop a chicken leg in half. It's not going to make a "clang" sound. Even if they were too lazy to get a different sound, they should have doctored the sound to make the pitch much lower. A solid heavy piece of metal is not going to make a sound that high or resonant.
People are so god damn touchy about the sound effect. The point wasn't to be physically accurate, the point was to portray the correct feeling. Sound design isn't all about being as accurate as possible, I mean imagine how shitty some movies would be if all the sounds were accurate. For one you'd never be able to hear any of the characters talking easily in high action parts of the film.
I wonder, Does The Director want to Ruin Berserk? Did It trigger him as a kid? Does He Hate Berserk? Why. why you hate berserk Animation program director and team.... WHY?!?!
Because they had to cut a lot of corners in making it. They didn't want to make it look cheap, but they couldn't help it. Nevertheless it's a very enjoyable anime to watch in my opinion.
@D_ans Good to know, but your opinion is not objective fact so don't state it like it is. I think it's good enough in my opinion. At the very least I could enjoy it enough to watch it all the way through.
I personally feel that the clanging noise adds well to the idea that the Dragon Slayer has become more than just a sword -- it has become astral as well, which is why it is so good at killing apostles. It makes me think there is more going on than just 400 lbs of raw iron slamming into the enemy -- it's striking on an ethereal level as well.
The sound effect would sound completely dreadful if it were used in the appropriate way, like Guts smashing through metal. It sounds pretty silly when it’s through bone though, lol.
In my own imagination, Dragonslayer's sound effects could have been mixtures and/or remixes of thunderclaps, storms, waves, tornadoes, explosions, car crashes, airplanes, gunshots, cannons, whips, streams, waterfalls, bells, gongs, anvils, metals, and/or sledgehammers. I tried it so many times before, and most of the results were not bad or above mediocre. I deleted them all because I wasn't satisfied enough, so I couldn't show them, so I am really sorry. Maybe I should try again one day to remix the sounds I described earlier.
In my opinion, this is somewhere really close to the line between "completely stupid" and "so ludicrously stupid, that it is funny again". I can't make up my mind whether I like it or not. But it is really unrealistic.
*insert tf2 frying pan sound here*
*Trimping intensifies*
*bonk*
My stomach hurts from laughing so hard. I've only ever read the manga and these parts are so serious but the fucking pans being thrown down stairs kills me
The animation: shit
The music: amazing
The sound design: haha, big sword go C L A N G
more of a C L A N K if you ask me
lead pipe falling sound effect
Idc what anyone says its cool af
Actually, no i take that back
I change my mind, it's cool af
Clang
Keep that profile pic. Goes perfectly with the commnet.
Not liking your comment because its already at 420
ONE PUNCH MAN SEASON 2 SOUND DIRECTOR BABYYYYYYYYYYY
i wanna cry
One Clang Pan
NOO,PLEASE NO!!!
We already lost OPM when they replaced Shingo Natsume with some forgettable director from (lol) Boruto's Dad
What
*Highlander intensifies*
you mean "Eyelander"
D U N M A G L A S S
Aaaaaaa
DER KUD BEH OONNLLEEEHHH WWWAAAAAAAAAAANN
his sword is around 1.60(minion n PK height lol) and hes 1.76 (like kensei and warden)
the craziest part to me is that during the action this show actually can look pretty cool sometimes. and then there's every single other moment in this show that isn't action, it looks so balls.
I love the SFX of Gut's sword in this version. It doesn't sound anything like a sword, because, well, let's be honest. It's hardly a sword. "It was too big to be called a sword. Massive, thick, heavy, and far too rough. Indeed, it was a heap of raw iron."
Okay, but does a slab of metal weighing hundreds of pounds sound like that when clashing against bone? No because that’s stupid
But it doesn't sound like that either, it just sounds like a hollow pipe too close to the microphone. It's like they tried to add "weight" to it by just making it louder.
shut up dawg
I think the dreamcast and the PS2 games nailed the sounds for it, personally.
Honestly, I get what they were going for, and that's what makes it so terrible, because of what it could've been. Watch the guts versus nightmare death battle. It came out almost a year before this anime did, and they nailed it. The sound itself isn't the problem. It's the constant use of it, and dear God the volume!
0:07 that shot kinda look badass if only it was 2d
It was in the trailer lol
The entire anime would look badass if some good studio took it. It's a manga masterpiece. I don't think I have read any more detailed manga anywhere else.
there was a 2d version of that scene that they used in the trailer of the season
for whatever reason, they decided just to remake the entire scene in 3d
Why tf do they keep doing this 3d bullshit
i was just thinking that. That eye getting smaller was tight, they should have just done the series exactly like golden age and profited while giving us something good.
0:13 MY EARS
I just love the sound of the sword
I unironicaly love this fr
Australium pan.
XxxMLGASSADxxX the wahabbi slayer in 100x mode
As unexpected as the sound is, I honestly really like it stylistically and I feel like it adds a huge amount to the "weight" of Guts' weapon.
Whilst I don't like it, I can see how it could potentially work.
The main problem is that it's SO DAMNED LOUD!
It's painfully loud and has way too high frequency, so it really ends up sounding like a bunch of pots falling down the stairs...
Obviously it adds weight, the volume is so loud that the sound is popping
Just watched a video of a person who made a lore accurate Dragonslayer sword. And it turns out. The sound is accurate so. Damn.
Hopfully that Studio eclipse will give this arc its redemption
sounds like a steel beam being dropped into concrete actually.
pleure retroish yeah that shit sounds like its hollow or something
i love this anime
Yes the clang sound has become a part of the berserk legacy…. Love it or hate it…. They need to keep the clang sound the dragon slayer sword makes.
METAL PIPE FALLING SOUND EFFECT
The only thing we can recover from this wreck.
Berserk 2016-2017 logic Explained in a nutshell
This is 2016’s equivalent to the metal pipe sound effect
wait until they inserted metal pipe 💀
butwhere they insert metal pipe🤨
It sounds like a mix of frying pans and a guitar being bashed against the ground.
The accuracy of this vid is off the chart
I actually love the noise guts's sword makes.
In every episode of berserk 2016 a new born chinese child got a name
I like the sound effects for his sword.
Imagine this sound being used for "Sulfuras, the Hand of Ragnaros"
this one here, knows
david productions aint got nothing on this MASTERPIECE 😤😤
Wtf the clang sound effects is lit why does everyone think it sucks
I love that clang
hahhaahahahahahah x,D so true
Exactly. This is even worse than the CGI.
Man if this CGI is terrible then I suppose Houseki no Kuni, Fate/Zero, and Attack on Titan were terrible too huh? Drop your bullshit and just enjoy the anime you watch.
cgi is shit
Despite many great anime using it. If you stop to actually look at the anime that use it you'll realize it doesn't.
The problem is that the CG is bad, not necessarily for having it in general. Like with the clang noises, its just awkward and an alternative would be much better.
We can put this into some good perspective I suppose. Berserk is a decently old anime by now that didn't make a whole lot of money. However they did their absolute best to make these new seasons have a much higher quality, leading to CGI which is logically just the next step forward in quality for anime. They might not have done quite as good of a job as some anime, but I personally believe they still did fantastic. The effects are on par with RWBY (however it lacks the same quality in characters), and it still had me binge watching the entire anime. Sit back, relax, and enjoy an anime instead of everyone deciding to critique every little detail they don't like. I don't know why so many people are such sensitive, bitchy critics on the internet.
Oh no, the table, its broken
This show's sound design was so good
No
No
No
@@ludicrousswirl4364 the sounds is literally how studios make sounds for movies random items bones crushing is literally just cracking celery
@@magnusthered4973 no
brb guys I think my parents are having an argument
Yo elden ring looks good
You know what's sad? Thanos's sword made that same sound in Avengers Endgame!
I love the sound of this sword
the table its broken
Clang a day keeps the God Hand away.
The clang was made by just editing the sound from half life 2 when shooting metal
I actually liked the sound effects
Wtf other noise do ypu expect a heap of iron to make?
I epext a solid piece of iron to not sound like a hollow pipe/frying pan lol
the sound makers just dropped a pole and called it a day fr
Pantasia arc..
I heard the noise when you get downed in Fortnite
CLANG INTENSIFIES
But to be honest...A sword as big like that is bound to make "clang" sounds instead of "swish!"
Not against bones, lol. Take a cleaver and chop a chicken leg in half. It's not going to make a "clang" sound.
Even if they were too lazy to get a different sound, they should have doctored the sound to make the pitch much lower. A solid heavy piece of metal is not going to make a sound that high or resonant.
Except when he slashed that girl in half...it still made the clang sound on flesh....
I'm glad to know I'm not the only one who was bothered by this RIDICULOUS SOUND
its lowkey realistic even if it sounds horrible
a hulking mass of iron
*insert me getting hit with an armor on*
ZING ZING ZING
Well that sword not thick
The blackpansman
peak fiction
*C L A N G*
I kinda like it tho
*Guts theme*
But what would a sword that large being thrown around actually sound like though?
Give that kid a sword!
_ASMR_
Berserk 2016. They skip the Lost cildren.
If some studio make a better berserk anime and reboot it.
same sound director as Jojo's Bizarre Adventures
ok i really like the ost playing but the sound
BONK
*Random Crit*
FIlmacion?????????????????????????????????????????????????????
🤣🤣🤣
😂 KKKKKKKK impossível
People are so god damn touchy about the sound effect. The point wasn't to be physically accurate, the point was to portray the correct feeling. Sound design isn't all about being as accurate as possible, I mean imagine how shitty some movies would be if all the sounds were accurate. For one you'd never be able to hear any of the characters talking easily in high action parts of the film.
Alex Horner sounds like a large frying pan is what the problem is my friend
Evidently doesn't portray the correct feeling if it's so janky that it became a meme.
I know this comment is 1 year old but when he slices a little girls body with a big ass sword CLANG isn't what anyone expects
*cling clang intensifityes*. So cringy.
I wonder, Does The Director want to Ruin Berserk? Did It trigger him as a kid? Does He Hate Berserk? Why. why you hate berserk Animation program director and team.... WHY?!?!
He knows Berserk will never be concluded anywhere in our lifetime, so he's just taking the piss at this point...
@The Wolverine Well aren't you short-sighted and short-tempered.
And sound design team.
the eclipse traumatized him
@@blackheartzerotheundergrou3225 and now it will never be.
Why does everything in this show look like a cheap SFM animation test?
Κ ο μ ν η ν ό ς because the anime is bad and the manga is the best piece of fiction ever that’s why
Because they had to cut a lot of corners in making it. They didn't want to make it look cheap, but they couldn't help it. Nevertheless it's a very enjoyable anime to watch in my opinion.
@D_ans Good to know, but your opinion is not objective fact so don't state it like it is. I think it's good enough in my opinion. At the very least I could enjoy it enough to watch it all the way through.
Dude I’ve seen SFMs done better than this. The Epic scout and Rabid heavy taming enji vids were more visually appealing than this
Is it hollow? Its hitting fucking bone it shouldn't ring like a bell.
shit weights 500lbs what do u want it to sound like
Oof this physically hurts me.
Am I masochistic for having this as ringtone and alarm clock?
Mara yes.
Me in Dark Souls III:
its all cause guts goes so nuts
Guts is Demopan confirmed.
Stout Shako for Two Refined.
In the duch adaptation of the manga it used the sound *tonk* for the sword clashes
Idk, i don't feel like clang ruins it
Even when hitting skeletons?
That's me
Tonk
I personally feel that the clanging noise adds well to the idea that the Dragon Slayer has become more than just a sword -- it has become astral as well, which is why it is so good at killing apostles. It makes me think there is more going on than just 400 lbs of raw iron slamming into the enemy -- it's striking on an ethereal level as well.
it’s a fucking frying pan
A very badass frying pan, nevertheless.
@@nightbridge1027 All his enemies are made of frying pans.
Honestly its not that bad when you hear it not having watched the show
Bro if they wanted to add that idea they’d make it sound like like a laser sword or some magic shit. Not a fucking cabinet accident
The sound effect would sound completely dreadful if it were used in the appropriate way, like Guts smashing through metal. It sounds pretty silly when it’s through bone though, lol.
VALLAHI THIS IS PEAK FICTION, WHEN NEXT SEASON, I WANT TO DEDICATE MY LIFE TO THIS MASTERPIECE
In my own imagination, Dragonslayer's sound effects could have been mixtures and/or remixes of thunderclaps, storms, waves, tornadoes, explosions, car crashes, airplanes, gunshots, cannons, whips, streams, waterfalls, bells, gongs, anvils, metals, and/or sledgehammers. I tried it so many times before, and most of the results were not bad or above mediocre. I deleted them all because I wasn't satisfied enough, so I couldn't show them, so I am really sorry. Maybe I should try again one day to remix the sounds I described earlier.
Version 1997 🤤🤤🤤🤤
it sounds like hes using a frying pan
well he basically is
@@kaia-di4pq its just a huge and long frying pan
Ah yes, my favorite anime character
BlackMetalPipe man
I think it was cool...
Cuando mando a volar a collette no me pare de reír con el efecto de sonido 😭😭
You should have put the audio from the kid over the shot of Guts fighting Zodd.
In my opinion, this is somewhere really close to the line between "completely stupid" and "so ludicrously stupid, that it is funny again". I can't make up my mind whether I like it or not. But it is really unrealistic.
ghhhhhhhhhhhhhh
Hehe clang
bro u stole my profile xd
Just
CLANG
😂😂😂😂😂😂