I disagree...I love it how it is. It's sad that everyone loves Tool so much, yet fails to appreciate the things that the guys in Tool appreciate themselves.
Yeah even the dudes and Tool hate that. They are always like “ yo check out this artist we love!” And Tool fans are always like “yeah that sucks” I mean they booed David Cross off stage for fuck sake. I love Tool but honestly I feel bad for them. They deserve better fans
You all say that Tool's version is better,but if there wouldn't be Peach,there wouldn't be no Tool's version so show some appreciation. Especially that those two versions are very diffrent. You Lied by Tool is great,but by Peach in my oppinion is equally good:)
I don't think you can compare these versions. One is the original idea the other is one that's been worked through a lot and has a better vocal. I love both of them.
@@bkooo5363better vocals (technically) doesn't always work for a song I like Maynard's beautiful voice, but the song lost some of the rawness and darkness.
The guitars on Salival are played much better than here. As far as giving the original recording justice. There are blurbs/mistakes here too. But everyone makes those.
@@Toolmybassi feel exactly the opposite, the original guitar parts are better than what Adam and Buzz did Everyone is entitled to their own opinion tho
i dunno, we might not have the version on salival if it wasn't for these guys. i feel a bit bad even mentioning tool. these guys deserve a big up for writing a fucking cool song that was original.
I have all their songs and I can say they're fucking awesome. You guys should also check out songs such as Minus, Bottleneck, Biast Parts 1&2, Syzygy Parts 1,2&3 and Paper Wraps Stone.
Few month ago i make a translate not perfect but i make my best. And something why people always compare. Tool is tool, Peach is peach, Soat is Soat. Only thing is the music
Suns Of The Tundra is no fucking joke...they've made 5 albums after 'Peach' - here's their 2nd to latest last album. I don't care what bands you like, nut if you like prog rock and you don't follow this band, you're missing out ruclips.net/video/iiTW86FmlGw/видео.html
They are NO FUCKING JOKE!!! I had to do 50 hours community service a while back, and I downloaded as much music as I could to pass the time I DLed Tunguska from Peach, aka Suns Of The Tundra....and that album may be better than a few TOOL albums...no shit
i like both versions tools just alil bit more idky but hey good job honestly ididnt know tool remayd this until now and ive been listening to tool for along time
Hungarian :) I write what he spoke in Hungarian Évszázadokon át Vérrel és könnyel teli küzdelmek során A különleges kevés ki tovább vitte a szabadság zászlaját Könnyünek egyáltalán a küzdelmek során Sem a félelel zivatarába se nem elveszve söt összefogva erősítették egymást
MBloke>> I see what you mean by this version is better. I am, if nothing else, a huge TOOL fan, but the vocal harmonics on this, the fact that this is as close to the original version that you'll hear is mind numbing. Great song and I, being the TOOL fan, like this better. Cheers.
@Tarkarra Ha a szerző tudta volna, hogy Tool mit hoz ki ebből, akkor valszeg sose engedte volna megjelenni azt a feldolgozást. Azt az előadásmódot nem képesek felülmúlni. Azért gondolom, hogy a szerzők számára is kínos az összehasonlítás, mert Pallagi még a megafont is beveti + egy kis misztikusan hangzó szöveget, hogy legyen valami kuriózum -- legalább élőben. Éppenséggel nem rossz próbálkozás ez, csak kevés. Nekem.
Just because Tool is good doesnt mean theyve been good all the time.. listen to their first demos and judge.. They have done some covers and thats ok but dont judge other bands because of what tool have done. i like both of theese bands alot and ill hope they will come with good songs in the future too!
I agree with Jason, Tool did a great job with it, I would not like it otherwise. And jabuhrer, form your own opinions. Just because Tool are fans doesn't mean you have to be.
Uhh Huitzel...I would have to say it is very possible for other artists to cover an original and perform it better. As for what you are saying, the original is where the better performance spawned from of course. Still, I agree with Toolband420.Tool pulls this song off 10 times better in almost every way. The heavy part sounds almost identical on both performances, but when it comes to the more melodic parts and singing, Tool pulls it off like they are the originators of the song.
@GuruBabadesh That's cool bro. I like how we can meet on a Suns Of The Tundra video to discuss whether Tool or ledds version of no quarter is better.... lol face it.. we are cool!
Can somebody tell me that the singer with the long hair is hungarian or not? Because he speaks like a 100% hungarian, but i havent found anything of him... THX
Ok i make a Comment I live a little country In 2007.08.13 In Sziget fesztivál to see Tool (live) After that i go a homepage where link this video After that i download Peach - Givin birth to a Stone album I like Tool and Peach and both version of this song is good, but don't forget something Some one write the song first and someone make the music for first, The song originally version is 1996. Pls all hear the original version and make comment after that.
ITS Amazing how tool covers this song AND no quarter and makes the covers better than the originals... thats true talent.. and no quarter is a fucking zeppelin song nobody can cover them...
No. You're wrong. Zep's No Quarter is better than Tool's version. C'mon man, Tool's is amazing but you can't say shit like that and expect me not to set you straight🤣🤣
@@idigthat73 dude I get it you’re old. But you’re just wrong the Tool version wipes the floor with the Zep version. It’s just more intense. The zep version is good but does not compete. You just have bad hearing cuz you’re old
man peach original sounds fucking kick ass but tool yea they add a hint of perfection just me and yea maynard i heard these guys were pretty pissed when justin showed tool this song when he joined tool lol poor peach
I make a probe but i don't speak well for English For Centuries In a fight what is fill blood and tears A few who carry the flag of freedom Not easy do in the fight time Not in the rain of fear and not to lost But they stronger to united I repeat i don't speak well english and it's hard to translate the what is means one word Hungarian Hungarian is hard language
![Tool - You Lied [HD]](/img/1.gif)
I disagree...I love it how it is. It's sad that everyone loves Tool so much, yet fails to appreciate the things that the guys in Tool appreciate themselves.
jabuhrer1 I absolutely love what you said and agree wholeheartedly
I think Tool did it a bit differently for a reason and many preferred it, doesn’t mean they don’t like or appreciate this :)
Tool has a cleaner version...these guys are raw power!!! Love both ...
Yeah even the dudes and Tool hate that. They are always like “ yo check out this artist we love!” And Tool fans are always like “yeah that sucks” I mean they booed David Cross off stage for fuck sake. I love Tool but honestly I feel bad for them. They deserve better fans
@@chrisparker5356 yeah. I'm a tool fan but imo both versions kick ass in different ways 😂
Giving birth to a stone is an insanely good album
Tunguska is where Peach (SoTT) shines
@@itsageyserbones of brave ships 💪
Telling my kids this was Post Malone
…..before he got terrible.
Next level parenting 👏
You all say that Tool's version is better,but if there wouldn't be Peach,there wouldn't be no Tool's version so show some appreciation. Especially that those two versions are very diffrent. You Lied by Tool is great,but by Peach in my oppinion is equally good:)
I don't think you can compare these versions. One is the original idea the other is one that's been worked through a lot and has a better vocal. I love both of them.
@@bkooo5363better vocals (technically) doesn't always work for a song
I like Maynard's beautiful voice, but the song lost some of the rawness and darkness.
What a great tune! I love this version and TOOL's version. AWESOME!
I'm sorry to hear about your bumhole
Such a powerful performance, there is a lot of emotion that comes through it all.
I just found out that this is the real version and that Tool's is a cover I didn't know until today
OMG PEOPLE
I write before all hear the original song.
I hear first the Tool version but i think the orginal Peach version is the better.
i'm in love with this song!
very intense, very powerfull. the band are so tight it hurts!
Seriously
As a diehard Tool fan, this is the original and best version
The guitars on Salival are played much better than here. As far as giving the original recording justice. There are blurbs/mistakes here too. But everyone makes those.
@@Toolmybassi feel exactly the opposite, the original guitar parts are better than what Adam and Buzz did
Everyone is entitled to their own opinion tho
@@Toolmybassfor me the “you liiieed!” Part in the original is the best 😂
i dunno, we might not have the version on salival if it wasn't for these guys. i feel a bit bad even mentioning tool. these guys deserve a big up for writing a fucking cool song that was original.
omg... (Im harcore tool fan) but original sounds... you know... amazing... and really dunno... love it... had no idea =)
I have all their songs and I can say they're fucking awesome. You guys should also check out songs such as Minus, Bottleneck, Biast Parts 1&2, Syzygy Parts 1,2&3 and Paper Wraps Stone.
i like it a lot, i love Tool, and i dont understand time bashing the styles while you can just enjoy the music.
they are called backup vocals... they have a raw quality i think is good
Almost forgot to watch this today.
Thank you! Youre smart.
And have good taste in music!
love the vocals!
damn, bill hicks can sing
Guy shows up, hey i want join your band.
What instrument you play?
Vocals and megaphone.
Cool, come and meet the rest of the band.
Awesome 👍🏼
The lead singer was my Geography Teacher!
I believe you
Peach produced one of the best bass player in our era....salute to justine chancellor
FcKUCK YES!!! That scream ending .. epic. and he fixed his shit up, compared to studio~
Few month ago i make a translate not perfect but i make my best. And something why people always compare. Tool is tool, Peach is peach, Soat is Soat.
Only thing is the music
👊🏽YOU LIIIIIIIED🤘🏽
Suns Of The Tundra is no fucking joke...they've made 5 albums after 'Peach' - here's their 2nd to latest last album. I don't care what bands you like, nut if you like prog rock and you don't follow this band, you're missing out
ruclips.net/video/iiTW86FmlGw/видео.html
They are NO FUCKING JOKE!!!
I had to do 50 hours community service a while back, and I downloaded as much music as I could to pass the time
I DLed Tunguska from Peach, aka Suns Of The Tundra....and that album may be better than a few TOOL albums...no shit
i like both versions tools just alil bit more idky but hey good job honestly ididnt know tool remayd this until now and ive been listening to tool for along time
Lucky. I really wanna get a hold of one.
love it
agree
All hear the original Peach song.
And the guest vocalist name is László Pallagi.
And he speak hungarian in the song.
Gives chills btw...
Hungarian :)
I write what he spoke in Hungarian
Évszázadokon át
Vérrel és könnyel teli küzdelmek során
A különleges kevés ki tovább vitte a szabadság zászlaját
Könnyünek egyáltalán a küzdelmek során
Sem a félelel zivatarába se nem elveszve
söt összefogva erősítették egymást
Majdnem jó, bár improvizáció volt ;)
LOl the lead singer teaches geog at my school!
Oliver S For real ? Did you know he was in a band ?
@@MrZZsharka that comment is a decade old its dead
@@MrZZsharka here to make your question alive...
@MrZZsharka your question is still relevant till this day
well one of them is. i dunno which i version i like more, both are geat. and it looks like this one wins today !
Awesome
Just like with Tool, these guys sound way better live!
MBloke>> I see what you mean by this version is better. I am, if nothing else, a huge TOOL fan, but the vocal harmonics on this, the fact that this is as close to the original version that you'll hear is mind numbing. Great song and I, being the TOOL fan, like this better. Cheers.
@Tarkarra Ha a szerző tudta volna, hogy Tool mit hoz ki ebből, akkor valszeg sose engedte volna megjelenni azt a feldolgozást. Azt az előadásmódot nem képesek felülmúlni. Azért gondolom, hogy a szerzők számára is kínos az összehasonlítás, mert Pallagi még a megafont is beveti + egy kis misztikusan hangzó szöveget, hogy legyen valami kuriózum -- legalább élőben. Éppenséggel nem rossz próbálkozás ez, csak kevés. Nekem.
Look at the base player, I think he looks almost exactly like Jemaine Clement from "The flight of the Conchords". I love the song!!!
@Grafkores Yeah, somehow I prefer Peach's vocals on this song(not that MJK's a bad singer, he's brilliant, but his voice doesn't suit this song.)
The bass in this performance could be Fieldy's (Korn)
Ok, cool, but the silverburst Les Paul is out of tune
Well, it's a Les Paul... ^^
well, adam jones' les paul rarely sounds so out of tune
YOU'RE OUT OF TUNE!
@@BigStevie your face is out of tune
Prefer the original version here to Tool’s. Both are fantastic, but I like the vocals here more, even with how much I love MJK.
@Grafkores Grafkores got my back! He said this is better than my grandma's pancakes! And my grandma's pancakes are dope.
This is different
what happened to the les paul at the beggining, sounds pretty out of tune
Peach gb's version is simple the best...
El Calavero G That whole album is good!!!
William Nagel memories of utopia...indeed 👌
The singer reminds me of a young Giant Haystack! This is great!
you cant fail no nut November if you just put the nut back once your done
Just because Tool is good doesnt mean theyve been good all the time.. listen to their first demos and judge.. They have done some covers and thats ok but dont judge other bands because of what tool have done. i like both of theese bands alot and ill hope they will come with good songs in the future too!
i believe the answer is not a single person.
Christian Bale on vocals?!?
I agree with Jason, Tool did a great job with it, I would not like it otherwise.
And jabuhrer, form your own opinions. Just because Tool are fans doesn't mean you have to be.
yer i noticed it was outa time, tried to cover it with distortion to make it work
💣💥
Uhh Huitzel...I would have to say it is very possible for other artists to cover an original and perform it better. As for what you are saying, the original is where the better performance spawned from of course. Still, I agree with Toolband420.Tool pulls this song off 10 times better in almost every way. The heavy part sounds almost identical on both performances, but when it comes to the more melodic parts and singing, Tool pulls it off like they are the originators of the song.
@GuruBabadesh That's cool bro. I like how we can meet on a Suns Of The Tundra video to discuss whether Tool or ledds version of no quarter is better.... lol face it.. we are cool!
Lmaooooo
hungarian in it!!
That was a really awesome performance. Loved it as much as the Tool cover of it. Can someone tell me what language was being spoken at 6:20?
I don't know if you still exist, but i think it is arabic or somethingclose to it
hungarian
Tool version way better Maynard's vocals rock the song hands down
Nice song but, with proper respect to Peach....Carey and Maynard put sooo much more energy in it, it allmost feels like it has been written by them.
indeed
Yeah so uhm.... we'll call you guys if, if uhm, if something comes up yeah? Yeah?
Must be post 1995 Chancellor Era
Best
I mean the vocals and guitar are no where near as clean as Tool's version. But its still an amazing song with an incredible presentation.
i dnt care what anybody says. this is preety fucking awsome... i know they dnt compare to tool, but no band really does.
No but this is as close as it gets. You know you are a badazz when Tool, takes your guitarist then covers your song
Can somebody tell me that the singer with the long hair is hungarian or not? Because he speaks like a 100% hungarian, but i havent found anything of him...
THX
He is. Laz Pallagi
He is. Laz Pallagi
Tool makes everything sound better
@theleperaffinity88 bazz én nem értettem egy csomó részt belőle magyarul XD kösz így már visszakövetkeztetem :P
soooooo....who is the guy with the beard and the megaphone?
Laz Pallagi
the intro is played very shitty. sorry
10,000 Days was played very shitty.
@@BreathFreeAndRemainNameless ye but this isnt 10000 days
@@BreathFreeAndRemainNameless at least it was in tune lol
Drummer slams.
Ok i make a Comment
I live a little country
In 2007.08.13 In Sziget fesztivál to see Tool (live)
After that i go a homepage where link this video
After that i download
Peach - Givin birth to a Stone album
I like Tool and Peach and both version of this song is good, but don't forget something
Some one write the song first and someone make the music for first, The song originally version is 1996. Pls all hear the original version and make comment after that.
yeour mom, is the best band ever.
What language is it the "jesus" dude is using? Latin?
Hungarian
ITS Amazing how tool covers this song AND no quarter and makes the covers better than the originals... thats true talent.. and no quarter is a fucking zeppelin song nobody can cover them...
No. You're wrong. Zep's No Quarter is better than Tool's version. C'mon man, Tool's is amazing but you can't say shit like that and expect me not to set you straight🤣🤣
@@idigthat73 dude I get it you’re old. But you’re just wrong the Tool version wipes the floor with the Zep version. It’s just more intense. The zep version is good but does not compete. You just have bad hearing cuz you’re old
i think there is only one original member left lol
one recognizes differences when comparing the drums. danny carrey is upper class.
Is Justin here?
Yes, it is, is singing.
I wish I knew what he was saying in the foreign language part! I love this song so much!
man peach original sounds fucking kick ass but tool yea they add a hint of perfection just me and yea maynard
i heard these guys were pretty pissed when justin showed tool this song when he joined tool lol poor peach
Jeremy Kyle bullshit Lol
I prefer the original Peach version. back with Justin
Am i the only one that's bothered by the untuned guitar!?
Where is this show? Reading?
They're genious for creating this song.
Tool's genious for making a better cover than the original writers. Respect to both!
That intro was horrendous.
Also, how many go up to them and ask "Was that Tool you played?" 😂
Not many people had the privilege of owning the salival album unless they were old school tool fans and bought it back in the day
No! Tool Played Peach
I make a probe but i don't speak well for English
For Centuries
In a fight what is fill blood and tears
A few who carry the flag of freedom
Not easy do in the fight time
Not in the rain of fear and not to lost
But they stronger to united
I repeat i don't speak well english and it's hard to translate the what is means one word Hungarian
Hungarian is hard language
i CONCUR
PEACH the original TOOL
Window Licker Only one member.
Ugh... Yeah, my apologies... I read that wrong. I'm an ass. :)
@TheOtium I would like zeps more if they didnt use a fucking autowah on plants vocals. ruins the song.
napisali tak trudną do śpiewana piosenkę że nie idzie im śpiew na koncercie...
then please ask your teacher bout his bandmate, he sould no the truth... :)
that les paul either needs serious tuning or a good intonation check
You need a serious check
Respect, but... Tool killed it on this cover just like they OWNED LED in no quarter..... promise...
Chubby Chad Peachs version was better than Tools. Tools was better than LZ in no quarter.
How can you butcher the guitar part like this after hearing Adam Jones fix it