Either he ( Ro Khanna) or his ancestors must have arrived in the United States🇺🇸 through Visa of work or any other visa ( most probably). But now he himself is stereotyping, by his pro racist targeting & mediocracy on legal immigrants👎🏿☹️ ! America & it's actual culture 'The melting pot' is made up of & by immigrants! But his stance is opposite! What do you mean by specific 'American culture' ✌🏾, tell me??
Either he ( Ro Khanna) or his ancestors must have arrived in the United States🇺🇸 through Visa of work or any other visa ( most probably). But now he himself is stereotyping, by his pro racist targeting & mediocracy on legal immigrants👎🏿☹️ ! America & it's actual culture 'The melting pot' is made up of & by immigrants! But his stance is opposite! What do you mean by specific 'American culture' ✌🏾, tell me??
Americans voted for a president who ran on the promise to shut down the department of education. But the usa economy always needed educated people. Where did trump voters expect educated hightech workers to come from if usa doesnt educate anyone????
It's pro racist thought by you 👎🏿☹️!Either he ( Ro Khanna) or his ancestors must have arrived in the United States🇺🇸 through Visa of work or any other visa ( most probably). But now he himself is stereotyping, by his pro racist targeting & mediocracy on legal immigrants👎🏿☹️ ! America & it's actual culture 'The melting pot' is made up of & by immigrants! But his stance is opposite! What do you mean by specific 'American culture' ✌🏾, tell me??
@@dirkdiggler342 Obviously you don’t understand policy. Citizens of any country should have access to jobs first before foreigners and if they understand that in other countries we should here in the U.S. don’t be so quick to react but think instead.
yeah bring that all back u goof do understand we also benefit from outsourcing jobs overseas and alot of things have gotten cheaper? Whats a new iphone worth these days 1100? It costs currently few hundred dollars in china to make 1 and it goes around for what 1100 now? If american companies worked on iphones it would cost an estimated 1400 dollars to make one so what would the price be then for one like 2200? Same thing with clothes ect everything else. Yes we love jobs but we also gain someting in return and vice versa. 55 percent of billion dollar corporations that are in america and hire american employees were also started by immigrants also. Everyone has to look at the big picture here
One governor doesn't even think the kids in her state know what a computer is. I see kids with phones, tablets, and laptops everywhere. But the only thing they taught is how to use apps, not how to use computers.
Trump and JD need to remember we voted for them, not the other 2 getting all the attention. We want to hear from the 2025 POTUS and VP, unlike Biden and Harris cabinet, that ran this country to the ground.
Elon/Vivek wasted no time in pushing for H-1B foreign workers to replace the American workers at a lower cost. Trump needs to get rid of them and put Americans, with no conflict of interest, in DOGE.
Elon always talked about it when he was running to get Trump elected. He hid nothing and was open about his desire to being in more legal migrants amd eliminate illegal immigration.
Nah. If that's the case then Americans should be willing to work for cheap. You voted for trump, you need to have a capitalistic mindset and think like a businessman.
Can't agree more. America and Americans first. Fix our education system, teach kids to code by fourth grade it's honestly not hard. Invest in our people and the future of our children, not foreigners for cheap labor! This is not what we voted for.
@@dirkdiggler342 not at all. I'm a staunch conservative that worked as a cybersecurity software engineer writing code to automate and/or create hacking tools for pentesters. Ran and managed dev ops etc and spent a lot of time in public schools teaching kids how to code robotics. Silly to group people together based off political views like you just did.
Coding isn't hard but software engineering is. Especially by today's standards. Like any other high level work, if you don't have aptitude you're toast.
It’s amusing that even when discussing H1B and its issues, the references and conversations often center around individuals of Indian origin like Vivek, Nikki, Ro Khanna, and Patel. H1B is a significant issue, and it’s essential for other Congress members and people to address it as well.
Americans tend to forget Musk is South African and Vivek Eastern Indian! Both are focused on their profits first! Uhm, I guess Legal American Citizens already know who’ll be running the White House.
Americans voted for a president who ran on the promise to shut down the department of education. But the usa economy always needed educated people. Where did trump voters expect educated hightech workers to come from if usa doesnt educate anyone????
@@rob_barriecharles2042 Dept of Education is currently focused on socialism, gender ideology, and activism. If we want to focus on meritocracy, then we may need to respect the idea of foreign merit-based expertise. Just my humble opinion….
@cleggs318 did you google the department of education. Did you look up any interviews from members of the department of education. Why is it that the definition of socialism for the uninformed = "things i dont like". Im not sure why you replied to my message when you clearly dont have any real knowledge on the subject.
Ro Khnna just shifted the argument to Industrial jobs rather than the IT jobs, an industry America created, He needs to focus on that, as that is also a future job, but we also need our industrial base. America First means Americans First.
Get rid of the legalized indentured servitude aspect of H-1B and disallow all third party company "sponsorship" of these workers, especially foreign owned companies.
Let me ask you a question in good faith: why do you think companies would be willing to pay money to sponsor foreign workers if they aren't simply better than Americans at those jobs?
@@aman-qj5sx Your question is not in good faith. Just saying “in good faith” doesn’t suddenly make a stupid question that presumes someone has a ridiculous opinion, a good-faith question.
@@aman-qj5sx Lower cost and easier to control. Companies can pay them 25% or more less, provide no benefits, take part of their salary as "fees" and they know they can't quit and find a better job. Since they hold the threat of deportation over them, they can get them to work longer hours.
The problem with H1b abuse is not with direct employers hiring H1b workers. Meta, Google, Apple or Microsoft or any of the major tech companies aren’t undercutting anything by hiring H1b workers. These companies usually follow the laws. The loopholes are exploited by smaller consultancy companies which are primarily staffing companies masquerading as tech companies that underpay their H1b hires because they charge the end client top dollar but keep the difference by underpaying the H1b worker. A simple reform would be to eliminate H1b visas for jobs that aren’t direct employment where the job is being done and come up with a separate solution for the consultancies and their visa abuses.
@@aman-qj5sx if theyre better then wheres the results? Proof is in the pudding- skilled ppl build great countries, not flee theirs and try to take claim of someone elses’
Common sense has no party. Unfortunately they all disguise their true agendas behind common sense catch phrases. Now let's see how they really feel about.. America first Close the border Fix the economy No new wars
That is debatable and we legal immigrants/ non immigrants have and are equally contributing to the us economy in terms of creation of new jobs/startups and paying our taxes, being engineers, doctors. Foreign students come for studies in stem backgrounds, pay 10s of thousands thinking of American dream. In my masters program there were 10 americans, including 5 asian americans and 30 foreign asian americans. Its not just the tech companies are supporting indians, its also reflective of the number of students pursuing stem. You can talk all about americans not getting jobs giving excuses but I bet most of them you wouldn't be able to backup and are just claims.
Your stance is a hard liner racist & mediocre!👎🏿☹️ America & it's actual culture is 'The melting pot' which is made up of & by immigrants! But your stance is opposite! What do you mean by specific 'American culture' ✌🏾, tell me??
No, we need H1 VIsas. People from elsewhere have to do the tech jobs. How else are we going to go through the automated lanes at the supermarket? Who can make all the hardware for everyone's new Ford F-150's and Cadillac Escalades? What about when your spouse or significant other goes to the local nail salon to get her nails done and wants to show her phone to the cashier to receive a discout? The H1 Visa people operate all of the tech to make those things happen.
Make it easier for people to go to trade school and college. Why is it that these foreigners come over here and go to college and people that actually want to that are born and raised in the US have to pay hundreds of thousands of dollars in tuition and books
@@Mona1930 good luck getting corporations to pay for everyones tuitions. Corporations dont even give scholarships anymore, and if the goverment tries to for business to give to college they just send dark money to bribe politicians.
It is because most Americans don't want to go to graduate school. They would rather get out of high school or get a Bachelor's degree and start earning quickly rather than live off graduate school stipend.
Americans voted for a president who ran on the promise to shut down the department of education. But the usa economy always needed educated people. Where did trump voters expect educated hightech workers to come from if usa doesnt educate anyone????
@@rob_barriecharles2042 You don't need the department of education to teach kids I never felt their presence as a child studying in NYC . You need good education not a department of education.
@CHASE88888 who is going to regulate funds so that taxes go to students and not the pockets of private companies that do side work for the schools? Whos going to figure out which teachers are bad and which are good, who will make the learning content tough enough so that students are smart enough. Parents fail to make schools effective because parents water down the toughness of school so that their own kids cruise through incomplete education. Parents create weak students in college by bribing the college for entry AND graduation. If parents are ruining school whos going to fix it?????
So let me get this straight.. we’re letting millions of people cross the border undocumented with no idea of where they’re going or what they’re doing, but suddenly there’s a problem with workers coming on a visa? Make it make sense. Switzerland doesn’t allow third country nationals to come on a work visa unless the job is not able to be filled by anyone in Switzerland or the EU. So pretty much impossible unless you are very highly skilled.
This H-1B is corrupt and absurd for cheap labor and chain migration. Trump ran against it in 2016 because it is not America first and hurts the American workers. You are absolutely correct Biden let in millions of illegal alien criminals so why would we let anyone else into our until we rid ourselves of all the bad ones Biden let in?
H-1B isn’t about bringing in workers that are more skilled than Americans, it’s about bringing in a culture of people they want to work with. I’ve been in Business Intelligence and Data Engineering, send Americans to bootcamps like data science, not college. Worked with some of these highly skilled H-1B holders and the level of skill was not that great, very basic.
@@GameboyZoneRocks they can act like they are excellent.. cuse their job is done by the real talent who are stuck in india.. the telugu communites acting skills are awesome that they can fake an interview too.. not just the fake resume or fake experience.. 70 % H1-b are average people with bachelor degrees maybe masters(indian engineering colleges are like mushrooms, too many))u pay u get into the college , an average student gets engineering degree.. then find IT job in india , butter up your manager, buy drinks.. he will file for H1-B , the US client interview is a joke 50 percent of time.. not face to face means more faker the interview.. sometimes even client managers are indians they let this mediocre IT worker pass and get the H1-b.. coming to USA next thing this guy gonna do is jumb around to another company.. thus he pay money to agency to fake his resume, fake certifications then also agency have insiders who has leaked the interview questions… once they get job, they pay fraction of their salary to get the job done in india by another engineer ( mostly the real talented one, who was not a manger pleaser but the actual geek who knows the work , who is stuck in his fate) as for EAD visas ( dependands of H1-b) mostly ladies in IT field they been stay home mom for some time, so they will pay agency to run fake paychecks to show experience and then get job And as for me, my husband , our frnds , and many other indian origins who are actual American citizens sits at same low paying job, unable to switch.. we all have masters degree, with legit certifications from AWS/azure or snowflake , but we are citizens thus no American companies don’t even call for interviews.. we have over 10 yrs of experience willing to work long hours to feed the children still they won’t hire us.. now a days its not about talend or not about salary its about kinship.. telugu people who are hindus love each other and help each other.. so legit talends from other parts of India barely get to score anything
@ - Just because you have a low paying job and don't get interviews doesn't mean you attack Indians and H1Bs. The answer to your predicament is a bad tech job market, its really bad and is impacting everybody!
@debasismohanty please dont generalize few people to whole group, I'm indian student, came legally, for my studies, paid 10s of thousands to achieve my dreams. Also if policies are not inclusive to all, people opposing that can be debatable. I came like you and now you're a gc or us citizen, your decisions will affect students like me who will may be never be a us citizen but want to still achieve that dream. I have a indian in my team who got gc before h1b visa was started in 90s. When I talk to him, his overall response or attitude is disdain towards indians who are coming to USA now, and I can clearly see him butlicking (sorry for my choice of words but its true) european americans.
Either he ( Ro Khanna) or his ancestors must have arrived in the United States🇺🇸 through Visa of work or any other visa ( most probably). But now he himself is stereotyping, by his pro racist targeting & mediocracy on legal immigrants👎🏿☹️ ! America & it's actual culture 'The melting pot' is made up of & by immigrants! But his stance is opposite! What do you mean by specific 'American culture' ✌🏾, tell me??
My Sister LOST her JOB, because of H1-B‼️. She worked at her job for approximately 28 Years. And you know how many other of her co-workers lost their jobs, because. MANY!! And lost their homes. My sister n her husband just bought a house. Guess what?? This is so wrong 😑
I remember when Disneyland forced American workers to train H1B workers to train them to do their jobs because they were about to get fired, and if they didn't, they would lose all their severance pay.
It is harder to get. You’ll are absolutely unaware of H1B visas! You watch something on news channel brainwash yourself and dont use your brain and talk nonsense!
But how many Americans are enrolling for STEM degrees in college. Students belonging to the radical right say “College is a scam” and the students belonging to the radical left just enroll in Gender Studies. This creates a void for the STEM industry which requires a huge amount of workforce. Why don’t u fix the American education system first and bring disciplines to schools like the Christian convents in India of which majority of the H1B techies belong to? Why there isn’t a culture of having technological discussions in the American public schools among the students rather a discussion of race, gender, etc are dominating the public schools?
H-1B needs to be overhauled with a compromise. We do need to bring in the exceptional people, not the mediocre who are taking citizen's jobs. *and* We do need to step up education in our own country to prepare our students for future jobs.
Most companies try to hire a citizen first. But they don't get any... Then to resort to H1-B. If we fix the education system, we won't need H1-B anymore
believe me, they already know the problems from all side.s they intentionally keep the loop holes as such. the solution can be very simple: if a foreign expert is really good, and have an offer of 300+k, give him a H1B visa and that visa can turn into a greencard in 6 years provided he shows his tax document to USCIS that he makes 300+k every year. if someone graduates from a top school here in the US, give him the green card. they don't do this because they talk behind.
@@longbeach225 $300 k for software engineers isn't low wages. H1-B salaries are public. Go ahead and check it out. Stop blaming, study well and take an interview, you'll get hired.
This man is talking about when he was a student. The world back then wasn’t the same world that it is now where we celebrate ideology instead of intelligence. American students have to realize that their future goes beyond school and what they do in school now will affect their future
Finally, someone with sense... Yes, this dude is stuck in his old times. Back then, US education and work culture was really good among citizens. Now it is very hard to find science graduates.
Americans voted for a president who ran on the promise to shut down the department of education. But the usa economy always needed educated people. Where did trump voters expect educated hightech workers to come from if usa doesnt educate anyone????
@briancooper way to generalize things that are happening. People thinking that industries are replacing americans with cheap labor workers without backing their claims. Im sorry to know about your dad but do you really think indians are just cheap labor and are not working their asses to reach some of the highest positions in biggest companies in world. We are obviously better but also we are more in stem background. Why are more european Americans not in stem background thats the question. We should start calling you not americans but european americans since we will always be indian americans or indians to you.
Indian here… H1B visa had been abused by IT companies (both American and Indian companies) and the system should be reformed to attract the right kind of talent in America. Vivek and Elon understand these problems and they are right about it. H1B was never for jobs for ordinary Americans. But, if American govt doesn’t allow H1B visa at all then it will hurt American competitiveness at the global level and companies will be forced to relocate overseas.
Americans voted for a president who ran on the promise to shut down the department of education. But the usa economy always needed educated people. Where did trump voters expect educated hightech workers to come from if usa doesnt educate anyone????
Wealth elects our presidents, appoints our Supreme Court justices, and influences laws that benefit their wealth. Wealth has taken control of our country. *Did you vote for someone who represents you? …or someone who represents wealthy interests?* *💥Vote for your best interests! And, end “Citizens United!*
@@rob_barriecharles2042 Abolishing the DOedu just keeps the department from withholding funding from schools which refuse to go along with proposed diversity, equity, and similar requirements. Abolishing the department does not abolish education, if that is genuinely what you believe. Plus, it is not like we are getting tech workers directly out of highschool; I don't know what you even meant by that. Colleges are run privately, or publicly but at the local level, not at the federal level.
@@griffinarcher2911 so what you are saying is keep the same teachers, the same schools, the same funding, but less oversite and no standards and regulations and school will get better?
What about housing for US citizens with an influx of visa holders and migrants coming with their children? Their children are likely not English speakers so who pays the extra expense for their multicultural education as well?🤨
H1B Visas are like a form of indentured servitude. Your job is tied to your freedom in the U.S., income, and any potential remittance to the foreign worker’s family overseas. Maybe the H1B should be phased out within 3 years and place an emphasis in hiring American workers. Last point, Musk mentioned sports teams analogy for this program. If that is the case, why is this not the case during the U.S. Olympics?
Americans voted for a president who ran on the promise to shut down the department of education. But the usa economy always needed educated people. Where did trump viters expect educated hightech workers to come from if usa doesnt educate anyone????
@suesabalburo6235 so what you are saying is keep the same teachers, the same schools, the same funding, but less oversite and no standards and regulations and school will get better?
@WiscoFarm-z6j so what you are saying is keep the same teachers, the same schools, the same funding, but less oversite and no standards and regulations and school will get better?
Not just the H1 but also the L1 and L2 visas. Someone on the H4 spouse visa can do anything. Not just tech. Marketing, Sales, Customer Service, Hair, Retail, Waiting Tables, anything. The H4 spouse visa is not even shortage based.
Ramaswamy, Musk and Trump are fully aligned here in bringing in foreign workers on visas. With Trump stating, “I’ve always liked the visas, I have always been in favor of the visas. That’s why we have them. I have many H-1B visas on my properties. I’ve been a believer in H-1B. I have used it many times. It’s a great program,”
Trump at a CNN debate during his first run for president: “I know the H1-B very well, I shouldn’t be allowed to use it. We shouldn’t have it. It is very, very bad and unfair for our workers and it should be ended.” So much for "I've always been in favor of the visas"...
There is no such thing. Healthcare is a service performed by people. You have no claim or right on the labor of others, somebody must pay for it. If you force a doctor to perform free care on you, that is called slavery.
@@hej31gai4b57hsh They Already Let In 80,000 Bud, That’s Insane, That’s Replacement, 15,000 Is A Gigantic Cut, But Not Enough To Hurt Us. That’s A Reasonable Compromise 💯
I don’t know why people are so offended with what Vivek said. Nothing he said was anything bad about America, more so about our culture and education system not producing the most productive people over the past few decades. I think people need to stop being so easily offended so we can start debating this. This is getting ridiculous honestly.
We are putting Americans first. That’s what we won the House, the Senate, the Presidency, the popular vote. If a Dem cares about the USA they need to vote Republican.
Raise the minimum wages of H1B visa to for example $200,000 in mid west and $300,000 on east and west coast. No need for cap removal, H1B application will dramatically drop. No need for automatic green card, true talents can prove their value and earn their green cards. On the other hand, Morris Chang left when he hit glass ceiling and passed over for the CEO position at Texas Instruments. If we don't truly respect foreign born talents, sooner or later we will lose them. The key is to pick the real talents and retain them.
I can’t believe I’m saying this but I trust Khana more than Vivek. At least we know where he stands despite disagreeing with his principles. This is all about finding cheap labor not the best and brightest.
And in this case I side with the Democrats. In the past prior to Trump the Democrats generally sided with the oligarchs post 1968. Most all politicians were bought by the oligarchs both parties, post Nixon.
I hate to say this but I agree with Vivek... "generally" immigrants have the hunger to perform. They have the fear of not suceeding in a foreign country to perform. They generally bring a sharpness that is taught by foreign universities that is not brought about in the US.
I have worked with some Chinese and SW Asia Indians and they are trapped in our vicious cycles for degrees and visas. Some buy into the Amerikkkan dream for their children born here when the parents on visas are denied citizenship and are tethered to their employer (meaning no job searching for better pay and work/life benefits). Did not have the cold heart to let a coworker know why the snobby moms rejected her. Others working in labs are treated as slaves or free labor by faculty.😊
China and India are more competitive bc they are overpopulated with billion population. They are easily replaceable in the workforce and it’s indoctrinated in them in primary school. We are less populated and foster more individualism.
Americans voted for a president who ran on the promise to shut down the department of education. But the usa economy always needed educated people. Where did trump voters expect educated hightech workers to come from if usa doesnt educate anyone????
As a lawful immigrant and a genuine minority, I understand the concerns of locals regarding the rapid demographic changes in America. The current situation in the United States is creating divisions among communities, particularly due to illegal immigration, especially from the South, and the significant influx of Indian and Chinese expatriates utilizing loopholes in the immigration system to secure jobs and settle in the country. This trend is leaving many locals feeling alienated and exploited, as they perceive their openness to welcoming people from different parts of the world as being taken advantage of. Some of this sentiment can be attributed to political factors, with Democrats often being criticized for supporting both legal and illegal immigration to bolster their voter base. While the U.S. has historically been a nation of immigrants, it is important to remember that past migrations occurred during the Great Migration period under more controlled circumstances, unlike the present scenario, where over twenty million illegal immigrants-primarily from Mexico, India, China, South America, and smaller numbers from the Caribbean and Europe-are living in the country. Focusing on India, there is growing discontent about high-tech jobs being dominated by Indians. While their talent and expertise in science and technology are undeniable, there are ongoing issues with Indian consulting firms, such as the Infosys case, where low-paid Indian workers were prioritized over local Americans. Additionally, the increasing number of Indian HR managers hiring predominantly from their own community has raised concerns about bias in the hiring process. As someone who has experienced discrimination firsthand when seeking employment with an Indian company, I understand the frustration this causes. Some might label these views as racist or anti-India, but the statistics speak for themselves. According to recent U.S. research, there are approximately five million Indians in the country, with 1.5 million residing illegally. Ultimately, immigration should always respect the law. The growing unease among local Americans is valid, and they have every right to voice their concerns about the current state of affairs.
Imagine if the H1B visa was banned some years ago. Elon, Jensen, Pichai, Satya Nadella, and others would have stayed in their home countries, boosting their own economies. As always, we must ignore illegal immigrants through no boarders but cry on these talented individuals. Crazy, right? That's what we are doing now. Lets grow up & Skill up buds!
So what let em stay where they came from, tesla sucks, cars don't work in the cold, no charging stations, rapping the land n making it unlivable for the minerals to build em, n space x he can't move, America first
Americans feel the hearthburn, but the reality is significant numbers of the americans are not interested in working hard or working in challenging fields. Americans have too many problems at home front : divorce, single moms, parentless children, drugs, woke culture, wars, onlyfans, incompetent politicians, disinterest in STEM fields, greed to make money using h1b kind of programs, etc.
The jobs H-1Bs are taking are not capable only for specialized, educated people. They're ordinary positions that should be offered to Americans coming out of college or experienced
First Democrat I've heard that sounds sincere about America first. Talk is cheap what does he vote for? Democrats vote as a block. Even for toxic ideas.
It's all about money.. every word.. every pretend ethical evaluation or pretend moral lesson.. is just sleight of hand.. Get yours.. there are no rules or guiding principles... not even humanity.
The discussion around H1B visas must also include L1, L2, and H4 visas, as I firmly believe the broader work visa program has been significantly misused. Combined, these visa categories potentially account for 3 to 4 million jobs lost to the American workforce while also contributing to the inflation of the housing market. Reducing this dependency could help normalize the housing market over time.
Let them stay in India and make India great,I think that's how china became a superpower.America is not going to be a tech giant without Indians for sure
If you get all left wing Professors out of the colleges the entire Education space will be much more productive. Looks to me like all they learn in college these days is how to be an activists or gender study major.
The truth is they bring them by 10000, and I have a question why? Most h1 holders who we see in usa are mostly average technology professionals, and we have those in usa. Our graduates can not find job. Stop this froud we have O1 visa for gifted people from other countries
Poor and middle class Americans need to come together and not be distracted by the culture war BS
Either he ( Ro Khanna) or his ancestors must have arrived in the United States🇺🇸 through Visa of work or any other visa ( most probably). But now he himself is stereotyping, by his pro racist targeting & mediocracy on legal immigrants👎🏿☹️ ! America & it's actual culture 'The melting pot' is made up of & by immigrants! But his stance is opposite! What do you mean by specific 'American culture' ✌🏾, tell me??
What middle class?
It’s insane how fast MAGA became class conscious Marxists.
And then what? Another jan 6th?
FDT
This visa issue is looking like total betrayal of America first
Look again.
Why your stance is so racist duhh 🤷🏻♂️!??
Either he ( Ro Khanna) or his ancestors must have arrived in the United States🇺🇸 through Visa of work or any other visa ( most probably). But now he himself is stereotyping, by his pro racist targeting & mediocracy on legal immigrants👎🏿☹️ ! America & it's actual culture 'The melting pot' is made up of & by immigrants! But his stance is opposite! What do you mean by specific 'American culture' ✌🏾, tell me??
Trump doesn't care if he betrays his base. He can't run again anyway. He doesn't need you anymore. He (likely) only ran to stay out of prison.
Wow,finally realized Trump lied to you. 😂
People of America, it's time to unite against injustice.
Yes, Trump should face justice as everyone else.
It won't happen because you side with mythology and half the country doesn't. Belief just meant you didn't want to learn anything.
Americans voted for a president who ran on the promise to shut down the department of education. But the usa economy always needed educated people. Where did trump voters expect educated hightech workers to come from if usa doesnt educate anyone????
@@rob_barriecharles2042 PragerU is pumping out some preachers and priests.. they just tell stories like a televangelist.. but that's something, right?
That's adorable!
In Colombia all jobs have to be offered to Colombians first before they look to hire foreigners and they have to justify why
In Columbia??? Seriously??? Who gives afc😂😂😂
Sorry....you can't compare Colombia economy to the US
It's pro racist thought by you 👎🏿☹️!Either he ( Ro Khanna) or his ancestors must have arrived in the United States🇺🇸 through Visa of work or any other visa ( most probably). But now he himself is stereotyping, by his pro racist targeting & mediocracy on legal immigrants👎🏿☹️ ! America & it's actual culture 'The melting pot' is made up of & by immigrants! But his stance is opposite! What do you mean by specific 'American culture' ✌🏾, tell me??
@@dirkdiggler342 Obviously you don’t understand policy. Citizens of any country should have access to jobs first before foreigners and if they understand that in other countries we should here in the U.S. don’t be so quick to react but think instead.
@@s.tanh9818 they took er jobs
Bring jobs BACK! To AMERICA 🇺🇸!!
Its there for skilled Americans
Help the youngsters. Let them know they can reach somebody get trained.
Start from home for education importance
@@cowubl No, only for skilled H-1B-ers.
yeah bring that all back u goof do understand we also benefit from outsourcing jobs overseas and alot of things have gotten cheaper? Whats a new iphone worth these days 1100? It costs currently few hundred dollars in china to make 1 and it goes around for what 1100 now? If american companies worked on iphones it would cost an estimated 1400 dollars to make one so what would the price be then for one like 2200? Same thing with clothes ect everything else. Yes we love jobs but we also gain someting in return and vice versa. 55 percent of billion dollar corporations that are in america and hire american employees were also started by immigrants also. Everyone has to look at the big picture here
This isn't about turning away talent, this is about our system failing to educate our own people
Yes, education should be free and accessible for all Americans.
No its about our people failing to take advantage of the education given to them.
agreed
One governor doesn't even think the kids in her state know what a computer is.
I see kids with phones, tablets, and laptops everywhere.
But the only thing they taught is how to use apps, not how to use computers.
They make you take a foreign language, but not the language of our own technology
Trump and JD need to remember we voted for them, not the other 2 getting all the attention. We want to hear from the 2025 POTUS and VP, unlike Biden and Harris cabinet, that ran this country to the ground.
I 100% agree
Trump betrayed his supporters. He got our votes and broke his promises.
Who ever voted for trump should be very proud to have all of these Immigrants people R above trump, which trump is selling the country to foreigners.
They don't care. You can't take your vote back. All he cared about was winning.
you got what you voted for already
It is not about left VS right, it's all about rich VS poor especially now
Actually politicians makes these corrupt laws
@@Ap_twsh Yes, and they are rich. There are no poor politicians.
Which the left has been trying to tell you people on the right for the past 40 years.
Once trumpists see this oligarch disaster unfold, they will STILL try to say but but but Biden. It’s everyones fault but trump. Oh the irony😂😂😂
Google 573 New Billionaires And Learn These Facts About Covid & Biden Administration
Elon/Vivek wasted no time in pushing for H-1B foreign workers to replace the American workers at a lower cost. Trump needs to get rid of them and put Americans, with no conflict of interest, in DOGE.
Elon always talked about it when he was running to get Trump elected. He hid nothing and was open about his desire to being in more legal migrants amd eliminate illegal immigration.
I agree
agree
Trump sided with Elon and Vivek on this he himself uses H1B visas
Trump agrees with having H1B's though. He said that people who are H1B's are ones working in his various properties.
AMERICAN 🇺🇸 WORKERS 1ST.
The key word: AMERICAN 🇺🇸 🇺🇸🇺🇸
Too late 😅
Nah. If that's the case then Americans should be willing to work for cheap.
You voted for trump, you need to have a capitalistic mindset and think like a businessman.
🤣🤣🤣🤣
America does not have enough engineers. Can you and your friends do the job? You utter nonsense without knowing anything.
Can't agree more. America and Americans first. Fix our education system, teach kids to code by fourth grade it's honestly not hard. Invest in our people and the future of our children, not foreigners for cheap labor! This is not what we voted for.
MAGA cult dmfx hate the educated hate the education system then complain about a lack of engineers 😂😂😂😂😂
@@dirkdiggler342 not at all. I'm a staunch conservative that worked as a cybersecurity software engineer writing code to automate and/or create hacking tools for pentesters. Ran and managed dev ops etc and spent a lot of time in public schools teaching kids how to code robotics. Silly to group people together based off political views like you just did.
You want your cake and eat it to: My advice... don't have kids. If you have a brain.. That goes Bye bye with the first push.
@@knox1044 you mean like trump and MAGAcult dmfx mean son. I have no idea what you’re talking about but by all means you do you son
Coding isn't hard but software engineering is. Especially by today's standards. Like any other high level work, if you don't have aptitude you're toast.
It’s amusing that even when discussing H1B and its issues, the references and conversations often center around individuals of Indian origin like Vivek, Nikki, Ro Khanna, and Patel. H1B is a significant issue, and it’s essential for other Congress members and people to address it as well.
Refreshing to hear a Dem talk sense.
I never thought I would agree with a Democrat but this was well said!
😂😂
Ya I found it fairly surprising myself. 👍It's refreshing lol maybe he is new.
No, this isn't what I voted for. Americans first. There are talented people here. Why aren't those smart people building their own countries?
Trump says India first….
This is exactly what you voted for. Why are you surprised? What did you think would happen with Elon's donation?
Americans tend to forget Musk is South African and Vivek Eastern Indian! Both are focused on their profits first! Uhm, I guess Legal American Citizens already know who’ll be running the White House.
if musk stayed at SA?
IT IS WHAT YOU VOTED FOR
Start doing things FOR the American people, not TO the American people
Americans voted for a president who ran on the promise to shut down the department of education. But the usa economy always needed educated people. Where did trump voters expect educated hightech workers to come from if usa doesnt educate anyone????
@@rob_barriecharles2042preach brother
@@rob_barriecharles2042 Dept of Education is currently focused on socialism, gender ideology, and activism. If we want to focus on meritocracy, then we may need to respect the idea of foreign merit-based expertise. Just my humble opinion….
@cleggs318 did you google the department of education. Did you look up any interviews from members of the department of education. Why is it that the definition of socialism for the uninformed = "things i dont like". Im not sure why you replied to my message when you clearly dont have any real knowledge on the subject.
@ Shhhh…go to bed and do some reading first.
Ro Khnna just shifted the argument to Industrial jobs rather than the IT jobs, an industry America created, He needs to focus on that, as that is also a future job, but we also need our industrial base. America First means Americans First.
Get rid of the legalized indentured servitude aspect of H-1B and disallow all third party company "sponsorship" of these workers, especially foreign owned companies.
Let me ask you a question in good faith: why do you think companies would be willing to pay money to sponsor foreign workers if they aren't simply better than Americans at those jobs?
@@aman-qj5sx Your question is not in good faith. Just saying “in good faith” doesn’t suddenly make a stupid question that presumes someone has a ridiculous opinion, a good-faith question.
@@aman-qj5sx Lower cost and easier to control. Companies can pay them 25% or more less, provide no benefits, take part of their salary as "fees" and they know they can't quit and find a better job. Since they hold the threat of deportation over them, they can get them to work longer hours.
The problem with H1b abuse is not with direct employers hiring H1b workers. Meta, Google, Apple or Microsoft or any of the major tech companies aren’t undercutting anything by hiring H1b workers. These companies usually follow the laws. The loopholes are exploited by smaller consultancy companies which are primarily staffing companies masquerading as tech companies that underpay their H1b hires because they charge the end client top dollar but keep the difference by underpaying the H1b worker.
A simple reform would be to eliminate H1b visas for jobs that aren’t direct employment where the job is being done and come up with a separate solution for the consultancies and their visa abuses.
@@aman-qj5sx if theyre better then wheres the results? Proof is in the pudding- skilled ppl build great countries, not flee theirs and try to take claim of someone elses’
I like what a democrat said?!?!?!?!?!?!? 😳
Common sense has no party.
Unfortunately they all disguise their true agendas behind common sense catch phrases.
Now let's see how they really feel about..
America first
Close the border
Fix the economy
No new wars
Me too. I'm pleasantly surprised how much I fully agree with this guy. I work in CA tech and he is spot on.
His name is Ro Khanna and Indian immigrant.
Highly talented came via h1b visa
It's the first time you might have listened to what a democrat has to say.
No to H1B!
Really??? Oh god 😮 . Are you tech savvy enough?
That is debatable and we legal immigrants/ non immigrants have and are equally contributing to the us economy in terms of creation of new jobs/startups and paying our taxes, being engineers, doctors. Foreign students come for studies in stem backgrounds, pay 10s of thousands thinking of American dream. In my masters program there were 10 americans, including 5 asian americans and 30 foreign asian americans. Its not just the tech companies are supporting indians, its also reflective of the number of students pursuing stem. You can talk all about americans not getting jobs giving excuses but I bet most of them you wouldn't be able to backup and are just claims.
END the H1-Visa NOW!!! American Jobs for AMERICAN CITIZENS!!!
NATIVE AMERICANS FIRST .Rest came from somewhere else .
Where are you from buddy, you don't sound native
Your stance is a hard liner racist & mediocre!👎🏿☹️ America & it's actual culture is 'The melting pot' which is made up of & by immigrants! But your stance is opposite! What do you mean by specific 'American culture' ✌🏾, tell me??
No, we need H1 VIsas. People from elsewhere have to do the tech jobs. How else are we going to go through the automated lanes at the supermarket? Who can make all the hardware for everyone's new Ford F-150's and Cadillac Escalades? What about when your spouse or significant other goes to the local nail salon to get her nails done and wants to show her phone to the cashier to receive a discout? The H1 Visa people operate all of the tech to make those things happen.
Americans aren’t prepared… we are turning out of our schools, total idiots…. Can’t read, write.. math!!… we are 20 years behind in education!!!..
President Musk say's you're to stupid to hire🤣😂
I hate this whole premise. They laid off millions of tech workers to replace them. We can’t find jobs. They just want cheap slave labor.
I guess the illegal immigrants are no problem? Target only the legal migrants?
Bro u can't clear cache from the browser
@ thanks Ashish.
TOXIC??? MORE LIKE CRIMINAL!!! MORE LIKE TREASONOUS!!!
Yes
Trump is a traitor to America first
All caps, really?
Make it easier for people to go to trade school and college. Why is it that these foreigners come over here and go to college and people that actually want to that are born and raised in the US have to pay hundreds of thousands of dollars in tuition and books
God No!!! Im not paying for someone elses tuition.!!!!
Because US universities charge foreign students more than Americans 🇺🇲
@@rob_barriecharles2042 corporations can pay for it, they need to start recruiting in the USA not outside
@@Mona1930 good luck getting corporations to pay for everyones tuitions. Corporations dont even give scholarships anymore, and if the goverment tries to for business to give to college they just send dark money to bribe politicians.
It is because most Americans don't want to go to graduate school. They would rather get out of high school or get a Bachelor's degree and start earning quickly rather than live off graduate school stipend.
This is the problem with America when we think we can give citizenship to anyone and expect them to identify as Americans when they never will .
Americans voted for a president who ran on the promise to shut down the department of education. But the usa economy always needed educated people. Where did trump voters expect educated hightech workers to come from if usa doesnt educate anyone????
@@rob_barriecharles2042 You don't need the department of education to teach kids I never felt their presence as a child studying in NYC . You need good education not a department of education.
@CHASE88888 who is going to regulate funds so that taxes go to students and not the pockets of private companies that do side work for the schools? Whos going to figure out which teachers are bad and which are good, who will make the learning content tough enough so that students are smart enough. Parents fail to make schools effective because parents water down the toughness of school so that their own kids cruise through incomplete education. Parents create weak students in college by bribing the college for entry AND graduation. If parents are ruining school whos going to fix it?????
@@CHASE88888 Agree! Dept of Ed is a bureaucratic entity scarffing up the money that could and should be spent on teaching students.
Hey Chase! I enjoy watching your videos about Japan and Brazil. 😎
So this congressman has been there since 2017 and is worth over 20 million. Why doesn’t he step aside and give someone the opportunity?
Republican Grassly of Iowa 90 years old worth 50 million dollars.
So let me get this straight.. we’re letting millions of people cross the border undocumented with no idea of where they’re going or what they’re doing, but suddenly there’s a problem with workers coming on a visa? Make it make sense.
Switzerland doesn’t allow third country nationals to come on a work visa unless the job is not able to be filled by anyone in Switzerland or the EU. So pretty much impossible unless you are very highly skilled.
This H-1B is corrupt and absurd for cheap labor and chain migration. Trump ran against it in 2016 because it is not America first and hurts the American workers. You are absolutely correct Biden let in millions of illegal alien criminals so why would we let anyone else into our until we rid ourselves of all the bad ones Biden let in?
It's a Leftist ploy to divide the MAGA party. This issue is one big psyop!
It's not about legal or illegal it's in just about if you can assimilate or not
You don't know what H-1Bs are then. They replace average American hardworking jobs for lower wages
END H1-B NOW!
Yeah and US will go to dark age
Even Trump uses H1B visas for his staff
Yeah, and let the big companies move their bases to other countries.
That is not going to happen
Good. Then the American companies will shift their bases to other countries.
H-1B isn’t about bringing in workers that are more skilled than Americans, it’s about bringing in a culture of people they want to work with. I’ve been in Business Intelligence and Data Engineering, send Americans to bootcamps like data science, not college. Worked with some of these highly skilled H-1B holders and the level of skill was not that great, very basic.
anecdotes can't dictate policy
Unsure which company you were working for, most of FAANG companies have excellent engineers which are all H1Bs
@@GameboyZoneRocks they can act like they are excellent.. cuse their job is done by the real talent who are stuck in india.. the telugu communites acting skills are awesome that they can fake an interview too.. not just the fake resume or fake experience..
70 % H1-b are average people with bachelor degrees maybe masters(indian engineering colleges are like mushrooms, too many))u pay u get into the college , an average student gets engineering degree.. then find IT job in india , butter up your manager, buy drinks.. he will file for H1-B , the US client interview is a joke 50 percent of time.. not face to face means more faker the interview.. sometimes even client managers are indians they let this mediocre IT worker pass and get the H1-b.. coming to USA next thing this guy gonna do is jumb around to another company.. thus he pay money to agency to fake his resume, fake certifications then also agency have insiders who has leaked the interview questions… once they get job, they pay fraction of their salary to get the job done in india by another engineer ( mostly the real talented one, who was not a manger pleaser but the actual geek who knows the work , who is stuck in his fate) as for EAD visas ( dependands of H1-b) mostly ladies in IT field they been stay home mom for some time, so they will pay agency to run fake paychecks to show experience and then get job
And as for me, my husband , our frnds , and many other indian origins who are actual American citizens sits at same low paying job, unable to switch.. we all have masters degree, with legit certifications from AWS/azure or snowflake , but we are citizens thus no American companies don’t even call for interviews.. we have over 10 yrs of experience willing to work long hours to feed the children still they won’t hire us.. now a days its not about talend or not about salary its about kinship.. telugu people who are hindus love each other and help each other.. so legit talends from other parts of India barely get to score anything
@ - Just because you have a low paying job and don't get interviews doesn't mean you attack Indians and H1Bs. The answer to your predicament is a bad tech job market, its really bad and is impacting everybody!
He is the only Indian congressman who stay with humanity and justice and do the right thing for America.
Don't bring india, into your stupid fights. People from all around the world use H1-B. It's just that, India has most it professionals.
I'm an Indian and I am for America first and what's good for America
@@Rushmary2311 good job bro but these days people who come to the USA started to criticise usa policies
you are ei ther a paa kee para site or a k aanglu, no wonder you sp read li es and ha t aga inst Indians.
@debasismohanty please dont generalize few people to whole group, I'm indian student, came legally, for my studies, paid 10s of thousands to achieve my dreams. Also if policies are not inclusive to all, people opposing that can be debatable. I came like you and now you're a gc or us citizen, your decisions will affect students like me who will may be never be a us citizen but want to still achieve that dream. I have a indian in my team who got gc before h1b visa was started in 90s. When I talk to him, his overall response or attitude is disdain towards indians who are coming to USA now, and I can clearly see him butlicking (sorry for my choice of words but its true) european americans.
ELON MUSK IS A FOREIGN WORKER😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂
that 0.01% he mentioned. go to the visa website and its for ANY job....they seeking all-star janitors? I mean come on...all-star HR teams??? huh??
Either he ( Ro Khanna) or his ancestors must have arrived in the United States🇺🇸 through Visa of work or any other visa ( most probably). But now he himself is stereotyping, by his pro racist targeting & mediocracy on legal immigrants👎🏿☹️ ! America & it's actual culture 'The melting pot' is made up of & by immigrants! But his stance is opposite! What do you mean by specific 'American culture' ✌🏾, tell me??
at least he contributes to society LOL SpaceX is literally catching rockets with chop sticks!!
And you're a fool. What's your point?
@@r-leanmygirl-gj2kt he actually contributes to society, don't be so obtuse.
My Sister LOST her JOB, because of
H1-B‼️. She worked at her job for approximately 28 Years. And you know how many other of her co-workers lost their jobs, because. MANY!! And lost their homes.
My sister n her husband just bought a house. Guess what?? This is so wrong 😑
Awake America..
guess whats happening to canada? the same thing . lots of canadians are homeless due to immagration taking all the jobs
I remember when Disneyland forced American workers to train H1B workers to train them to do their jobs because they were about to get fired, and if they didn't, they would lose all their severance pay.
28 years at one place! That explains why she was let go. H1b had little to with it.
@@rickbart1H1B workers dont work at disneyland.
H-1B needs to be hugely limited, and it needs to be harder to get. Also, companies need to look at Amercans first before looking for H-1B.
It is harder to get. You’ll are absolutely unaware of H1B visas! You watch something on news channel brainwash yourself and dont use your brain and talk nonsense!
But how many Americans are enrolling for STEM degrees in college. Students belonging to the radical right say “College is a scam” and the students belonging to the radical left just enroll in Gender Studies. This creates a void for the STEM industry which requires a huge amount of workforce. Why don’t u fix the American education system first and bring disciplines to schools like the Christian convents in India of which majority of the H1B techies belong to? Why there isn’t a culture of having technological discussions in the American public schools among the students rather a discussion of race, gender, etc are dominating the public schools?
I agree it's time to take our country back from corporations that sell us out.
Never going to happen.
Esp when a wealthy man bought a presidency.
H-1B needs to be overhauled with a compromise.
We do need to bring in the exceptional people, not the mediocre who are taking citizen's jobs.
*and*
We do need to step up education in our own country to prepare our students for future jobs.
Most companies try to hire a citizen first. But they don't get any... Then to resort to H1-B. If we fix the education system, we won't need H1-B anymore
believe me, they already know the problems from all side.s they intentionally keep the loop holes as such. the solution can be very simple: if a foreign expert is really good, and have an offer of 300+k, give him a H1B visa and that visa can turn into a greencard in 6 years provided he shows his tax document to USCIS that he makes 300+k every year. if someone graduates from a top school here in the US, give him the green card. they don't do this because they talk behind.
@@thelastorca They offer low wage and get no takers then they come up with HB1 visa need.
@@longbeach225 $300 k for software engineers isn't low wages. H1-B salaries are public. Go ahead and check it out. Stop blaming, study well and take an interview, you'll get hired.
@@thelastorca Then explain why Disney laid off American workers and replaced them with HB1 vis workers? Again its all about cheap labor.
Masses are getting fooled by all this BS. In reality it's very simple issue, it's about greed. As simple as that and indifference on society.
Democracy demands accountability, but are partisan power plays destroying the very fabric of our republic?
@@LetsBeRealAboutItWell said. Culture war is a such a successful strategy for Wall Street and big corporations.
This man is talking about when he was a student. The world back then wasn’t the same world that it is now where we celebrate ideology instead of intelligence. American students have to realize that their future goes beyond school and what they do in school now will affect their future
Finally, someone with sense... Yes, this dude is stuck in his old times. Back then, US education and work culture was really good among citizens. Now it is very hard to find science graduates.
@ Where are young people that can actually tell time from a clock
This happened in the uk, most were not IT specialist….this is about cheap labour and long working hours
Its supposed to be 85,000 but in actuality its 850,000
Nailed it! System was completely manipulated. I looked in my daughters lunchroom at school and it was 90% Indian. No exageration. Wheres the balance?
No it isn't.
B.S. look at Govt. Data. It's 85000 per year.
85000 is the selection happening in lottery. Higher number you saw are the applications
Complete NONSENSE.
We The People! Term limits needed!
Americans voted for a president who ran on the promise to shut down the department of education. But the usa economy always needed educated people. Where did trump voters expect educated hightech workers to come from if usa doesnt educate anyone????
@rob_barriecharles2042 my dad lost his job of 30 years to India workers. Our education system has sucked for decades. Stop blaming Trump
@briancooper way to generalize things that are happening. People thinking that industries are replacing americans with cheap labor workers without backing their claims. Im sorry to know about your dad but do you really think indians are just cheap labor and are not working their asses to reach some of the highest positions in biggest companies in world. We are obviously better but also we are more in stem background. Why are more european Americans not in stem background thats the question. We should start calling you not americans but european americans since we will always be indian americans or indians to you.
@mohitshetty8535 making a hard worker for over 30 years and kicking him to curb to allow noncitizen take over his job is disgusting
@briancooper2112 im sorry, that shouldn't happen.
Can't believe Ro Khanna and Nikki Haley are people who actually made sense with something with the H1B issue right now.
they just say this to get some attention. if they are in the cabinet, they will say the opposite.
@yili9725 I understand. And who wants to hear s**t from them anyway. But them of all people make sense on this issue.
Because they think like Americans not globalists.
Indian here… H1B visa had been abused by IT companies (both American and Indian companies) and the system should be reformed to attract the right kind of talent in America. Vivek and Elon understand these problems and they are right about it. H1B was never for jobs for ordinary Americans. But, if American govt doesn’t allow H1B visa at all then it will hurt American competitiveness at the global level and companies will be forced to relocate overseas.
Some of these "CONservatives" such as Shapiro, Elon and Vivek need to either pick Israel, SA, India or America.
Americans voted for a president who ran on the promise to shut down the department of education. But the usa economy always needed educated people. Where did trump voters expect educated hightech workers to come from if usa doesnt educate anyone????
Wealth elects our presidents, appoints our Supreme Court justices, and influences laws that benefit their wealth. Wealth has taken control of our country.
*Did you vote for someone who represents you? …or someone who represents wealthy interests?*
*💥Vote for your best interests! And, end “Citizens United!*
@@rob_barriecharles2042 Abolishing the DOedu just keeps the department from withholding funding from schools which refuse to go along with proposed diversity, equity, and similar requirements. Abolishing the department does not abolish education, if that is genuinely what you believe. Plus, it is not like we are getting tech workers directly out of highschool; I don't know what you even meant by that. Colleges are run privately, or publicly but at the local level, not at the federal level.
DJT "putting the CON in conservative since 2015"
@@griffinarcher2911 so what you are saying is keep the same teachers, the same schools, the same funding, but less oversite and no standards and regulations and school will get better?
"The United States is a Huge Business, it's got a lot of Employees"
I am an American engineering student. These developments in the Trump administration are making me nervous.
You should be nervous is you're a woke, left liberal. You have no business trying to force the rest of the country to think like you people do.
@James-yb9kh no, and you are ridiculous 🙄
Why ?
What about housing for US citizens with an influx of visa holders and migrants coming with their children? Their children are likely not English speakers so who pays the extra expense for their multicultural education as well?🤨
None of that matters if tech companies cant get educated people locally or foreign.
Planning always matters.
H1B Visas are like a form of indentured servitude. Your job is tied to your freedom in the U.S., income, and any potential remittance to the foreign worker’s family overseas. Maybe the H1B should be phased out within 3 years and place an emphasis in hiring American workers. Last point, Musk mentioned sports teams analogy for this program. If that is the case, why is this not the case during the U.S. Olympics?
Maybe we should let Trump govern like you republicans said.
Americans voted for a president who ran on the promise to shut down the department of education. But the usa economy always needed educated people. Where did trump viters expect educated hightech workers to come from if usa doesnt educate anyone????
The Department of Education was started under the Carter Administration. Did it improve our education system?
The states would run their own departments of education.
@suesabalburo6235 so what you are saying is keep the same teachers, the same schools, the same funding, but less oversite and no standards and regulations and school will get better?
@WiscoFarm-z6j so what you are saying is keep the same teachers, the same schools, the same funding, but less oversite and no standards and regulations and school will get better?
@ Did I say that? I got a good education before they started this department! Why is it that our kids aren’t doing well?
Restricting H1-B visas will result in outsourcing of those jobs.
This man is absolutely 💯% correct. Push for our people to excel, and don't fish from a NON-loyal foreign pool🐟
Both parties are toxic.
Not just the H1 but also the L1 and L2 visas. Someone on the H4 spouse visa can do anything. Not just tech. Marketing, Sales, Customer Service, Hair, Retail, Waiting Tables, anything. The H4 spouse visa is not even shortage based.
Ramaswamy, Musk and Trump are fully aligned here in bringing in foreign workers on visas. With Trump stating, “I’ve always liked the visas, I have always been in favor of the visas. That’s why we have them. I have many H-1B visas on my properties. I’ve been a believer in H-1B. I have used it many times. It’s a great program,”
Trump at a CNN debate during his first run for president: “I know the H1-B very well, I shouldn’t be allowed to use it. We shouldn’t have it. It is very, very bad and unfair for our workers and it should be ended.” So much for "I've always been in favor of the visas"...
They hires workforce from overseas through connections rather than citizens.
We need free healthcare
Move to a civilized country…
There is no such thing. Healthcare is a service performed by people. You have no claim or right on the labor of others, somebody must pay for it. If you force a doctor to perform free care on you, that is called slavery.
I agree with Khanna 💯
Make those with H-1B visas have to temporarily stay in the United States until their visa or contract is up. Instead of them staying in their country.
so you want more immigrants now, what platform did he run for election on?
That's how it has been for along time
Elon wants deportation in agricultural and construction industries but then wants more visas that ONLY benefit him and trump😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂
President Elon and trump want indentured workers that ONLY benefit corporations but not in everyday industries like agriculture😂
@@arbetsklasswho cares if they have dentures? 😂
Number of H1b visas should be doubled to 170k to fulfill scarcity of skilled workers shortage in tech industry.
15,000 HB-1 Visas A Year, No More, No Less, There’s My Compromise, INVEST IN AMERICANS!!!
And all these 15000 is for US universities graduates.
@@hej31gai4b57hsh They Already Let In 80,000 Bud, That’s Insane, That’s Replacement, 15,000 Is A Gigantic Cut, But Not Enough To Hurt Us. That’s A Reasonable Compromise 💯
Raking 36 in the world on education you don’t need to be a rocket scientist it starts with education 😢fix the schools would be a start
😏…excuse me, but didn’t Trump just come out in FAVOR of H1B and the Elon/Vivek proposal?
He did but that’s inconvenient for MAGA to recognize, so they act like it didn’t happen
Any Corporation who hires foreign cheap labor should not get any tax breaks
Talent over politics-why can’t we find a balance between supporting innovation and protecting American jobs?
Agree with the guest. Americans first!
Definitely not the Republicans!!
This guy should be in charge of the dems.
His top 3 donors last election were Apple, Google, and Stanford, bros a suit.
His all talk, just trying to create the bipartisan narrative on immigration to peddle his amnesty so called bipartisan bill he has on the table.
Roo khanna I think most decent democrats in all democrats!
I don’t know why people are so offended with what Vivek said. Nothing he said was anything bad about America, more so about our culture and education system not producing the most productive people over the past few decades.
I think people need to stop being so easily offended so we can start debating this. This is getting ridiculous honestly.
Do some research on H-1Bs. It replaces Americans with cheap labor. MAGA is for Americans, not big corporations
Love and support for Elon Musk from Russia 🇺🇲 🇷🇺 It is great to you see you putting the American workforce first!!!
American workers can quit. He doesn't want that. The workers on visas can't walk off. He wants servants.
He's right ✅️
We are putting Americans first. That’s what we won the House, the Senate, the Presidency, the popular vote. If a Dem cares about the USA they need to vote Republican.
The Republicans care for the country so they voted for Elon and foreigners to run the country to the ground. 😅
R's need to align with D's like Khanna and Fetterman. These are sensical, caring, intelligent people.
Who else does not like Trickle Down Economics?
economists in general
It will never be a thing... The top of the pyramid is just a black hole to nowhere... So we print more.. and it goes right back up there to nowhere.
Asking this, hopefully you didn't vote in 15 billionaires to run America
@@milocagle4721 Hell no
Raise the minimum wages of H1B visa to for example $200,000 in mid west and $300,000 on east and west coast. No need for cap removal, H1B application will dramatically drop. No need for automatic green card, true talents can prove their value and earn their green cards. On the other hand, Morris Chang left when he hit glass ceiling and passed over for the CEO position at Texas Instruments. If we don't truly respect foreign born talents, sooner or later we will lose them. The key is to pick the real talents and retain them.
Thank goodness we’ll have brilliant,strong business minds in the WH for the first time, in probably forever!!!😂❤️💪🇺🇸
There's nothing wrong with H-1B visas.
Just fix the issues where they are abused.
I can’t believe I’m saying this but I trust Khana more than Vivek. At least we know where he stands despite disagreeing with his principles. This is all about finding cheap labor not the best and brightest.
You voted for it. Don't complain
For a California Democrat, this man seems to make some sense.
they just say this to get some attention. if they are in the cabinet, they will say the opposite.
@@yili9725 True!
And in this case I side with the Democrats. In the past prior to Trump the Democrats generally sided with the oligarchs post 1968. Most all politicians were bought by the oligarchs both parties, post Nixon.
I hate to say this but I agree with Vivek... "generally" immigrants have the hunger to perform. They have the fear of not suceeding in a foreign country to perform. They generally bring a sharpness that is taught by foreign universities that is not brought about in the US.
I have worked with some Chinese and SW Asia Indians and they are trapped in our vicious cycles for degrees and visas. Some buy into the Amerikkkan dream for their children born here when the parents on visas are denied citizenship and are tethered to their employer (meaning no job searching for better pay and work/life benefits). Did not have the cold heart to let a coworker know why the
snobby moms rejected her. Others working in labs are treated as slaves or free labor by faculty.😊
China and India are more competitive bc they are overpopulated with billion population. They are easily replaceable in the workforce and it’s indoctrinated in them in primary school. We are less populated and foster more individualism.
Stay in India fix it
H1b is about lower paid foriegn workers.
And DEI.
Trump just lost a lot of faith people had in him
Americans voted for a president who ran on the promise to shut down the department of education. But the usa economy always needed educated people. Where did trump voters expect educated hightech workers to come from if usa doesnt educate anyone????
@@rob_barriecharles2042 shut down federal control of education, the control belong to states. get it right
@@rob_barriecharles2042 That is the lie, there are plenty of American high tech workers, they just cost more.
@@Teaman596no one is ready to pay a starting salary of $100k for an entry level system analyst 😅
@@thelastorcathe expectation is not for entry level obviously even non entry level h1b are payed less that that
As a lawful immigrant and a genuine minority, I understand the concerns of locals regarding the rapid demographic changes in America. The current situation in the United States is creating divisions among communities, particularly due to illegal immigration, especially from the South, and the significant influx of Indian and Chinese expatriates utilizing loopholes in the immigration system to secure jobs and settle in the country. This trend is leaving many locals feeling alienated and exploited, as they perceive their openness to welcoming people from different parts of the world as being taken advantage of.
Some of this sentiment can be attributed to political factors, with Democrats often being criticized for supporting both legal and illegal immigration to bolster their voter base. While the U.S. has historically been a nation of immigrants, it is important to remember that past migrations occurred during the Great Migration period under more controlled circumstances, unlike the present scenario, where over twenty million illegal immigrants-primarily from Mexico, India, China, South America, and smaller numbers from the Caribbean and Europe-are living in the country.
Focusing on India, there is growing discontent about high-tech jobs being dominated by Indians. While their talent and expertise in science and technology are undeniable, there are ongoing issues with Indian consulting firms, such as the Infosys case, where low-paid Indian workers were prioritized over local Americans. Additionally, the increasing number of Indian HR managers hiring predominantly from their own community has raised concerns about bias in the hiring process. As someone who has experienced discrimination firsthand when seeking employment with an Indian company, I understand the frustration this causes.
Some might label these views as racist or anti-India, but the statistics speak for themselves. According to recent U.S. research, there are approximately five million Indians in the country, with 1.5 million residing illegally. Ultimately, immigration should always respect the law. The growing unease among local Americans is valid, and they have every right to voice their concerns about the current state of affairs.
Imagine if the H1B visa was banned some years ago. Elon, Jensen, Pichai, Satya Nadella, and others would have stayed in their home countries, boosting their own economies. As always, we must ignore illegal immigrants through no boarders but cry on these talented individuals. Crazy, right? That's what we are doing now. Lets grow up & Skill up buds!
So what let em stay where they came from, tesla sucks, cars don't work in the cold, no charging stations, rapping the land n making it unlivable for the minerals to build em, n space x he can't move, America first
We need more politicians like Sen. Khanna, who deeply thinks about our country. Not the politicians who take $$$ from other countries
Education, not indoctrination.
At this point cant believe musk as he is likley to cut and replace with what he will think is efficient
Americans feel the hearthburn, but the reality is significant numbers of the americans are not interested in working hard or working in challenging fields. Americans have too many problems at home front : divorce, single moms, parentless children, drugs, woke culture, wars, onlyfans, incompetent politicians, disinterest in STEM fields, greed to make money using h1b kind of programs, etc.
The jobs H-1Bs are taking are not capable only for specialized, educated people. They're ordinary positions that should be offered to Americans coming out of college or experienced
He spot on
First Democrat I've heard that sounds sincere about America first. Talk is cheap what does he vote for? Democrats vote as a block. Even for toxic ideas.
H1B s are working second jobs illegally as well, most of them drive Uber part time
Joe Manchin gets more corporate donations than any other Democrat 😂
He isn't a democrat
It's all about money.. every word.. every pretend ethical evaluation or pretend moral lesson.. is just sleight of hand.. Get yours.. there are no rules or guiding principles... not even humanity.
if Vivek feel Indians are talent and all that he should go and fix his country first...😂😂
The discussion around H1B visas must also include L1, L2, and H4 visas, as I firmly believe the broader work visa program has been significantly misused. Combined, these visa categories potentially account for 3 to 4 million jobs lost to the American workforce while also contributing to the inflation of the housing market. Reducing this dependency could help normalize the housing market over time.
Let them stay in India and make India great,I think that's how china became a superpower.America is not going to be a tech giant without Indians for sure
Change starts with kids; safe place to learn, safe place to grow. Well safe is not the first thing an any kids’ mind, is it?
If you get all left wing Professors out of the colleges the entire Education space will be much more productive. Looks to me like all they learn in college these days is how to be an activists or gender study major.
Yup
Who are you going to replace them with? HB-1 professors? If right wings wanted to be professors, there is nothing stopping them.
you are so beyond unreal if you truly believe that...
This is why we shouldn't be championing billionaires as heroes. But dumb people just love putting him on a pedestal
Why did you put an Indian on the news?
Apu?😂
Because people put him in congress
He is an H1B employee of fox News. 😂😂😂
We need TERM LIMITS…. Politician was NEVER meant to be a career 🚮💨
The truth is they bring them by 10000, and I have a question why? Most h1 holders who we see in usa are mostly average technology professionals, and we have those in usa. Our graduates can not find job. Stop this froud we have O1 visa for gifted people from other countries