I get that Sohye's not a great vocalist (with the level of experience she had here, at least), but 1 second? They could have given her at least a few seconds for the sake of her fans who voted for her...
The producers now distribute the lines based on who can actually sing, they don't care about the members, just who has talent. Produce101 was solely based on popularity, and now its the producers turn to do whatever they want.
It's just really frustrating. I didn't expect (or even want) her to have a lot of lines, but just one solid line would have been nice at least as a service to her fans.
she really does, i still think quite a few members voices are better but shes a really good vocalist, they lines should be distributed more evenly, like she should still be in the 2half but she should get more lines. It should just be more even, sole order but closer percentages. Well, Chaeyeon should be lower xD
Yeonjung has the most powerful. And I like Somi's voice. Sejeonng is so good too, her voice is so good here. Yoojung is so good at singing and rapping too.
I mean when they produced the song... it could have been a little more evenly distributed. Pretty much all kpop groups have a main vocalist, but though they usually have the most lines, its usually at most like 2 times more than the other members. And IOI has a lot of pretty good singers so it's not like she's the only one who can sing. Don't get me wrong, Sejeong is my favorite in IOI. I just felt like it was very very uneven compared to a lot of groups.
Ąurà - sure, anyone in the top 5 then? But I only said it because she had 10 seconds more than even 2nd. And everyone under 6 didn't even HAVE 10 seconds lol... no need to be rude.
they dont have the choice to choose or give away their lines, the agency chooses for them. knowing sejeongs personality im positive she wouldve given her lines to others if she could
i think the main issue w ioi is that there's such an obvious gap between the singer's ability. I'm not saying they can't sing, but yeonjung and sejeong obviously as such a higher level that the company probably feels they have to give them the most lines to keep the song alive (very very is a bit more even at least but its after a whole extra year of training almost). when you get a popularity based competition a lot of people got picked because of visuals and prehype i think and not talent in singing.
Sung Moon If we start to count the ad lips: 1:40-1:43/1:48-1:50/1:57-1:58/3:15-3:17/3:18-3:20/3:30-3:32 This does much more than just 6 seconds... Only say🙃
I'm not agree with this, you did not take the adlibs of yeunjung, and some parts of the members mismatch. i think you based only in the video. try to recognise their voice. just sayin
@ above commenter: mina isn't actually stable live. if you check jellyfish's audition and pay attention to mina's singing she isn't very stable especially while dancing. so that is probably why. as for doyeon, i think she is okay, but she is also not the most stable as i've observed in whatta man.
-they're not the best vocalists that's smth i know what im saying is they are not bad either. Dancing is mina's specialise so i don't think it's badly affecting her stability? idk if you followed her during gugudan debut promos but she's had the most lines n the title song and she did really well.. but anyway.
βlùe Ąurà i did watch some of gugudan's stages and there was a lot of playback that's why. and not saying theyre bad but im just saying theyre not stable. and compared to the others that got lines, they were kind of at the bottom of the list in terms of vocals. especially since during dream girls the girls would be tired, as they had a lot of CF, shows, brand deals and other schedules. so their voice and health wouldn't be at the best condition at this time.
Well actually line distribution was made by the producer of the song, not the choreographer, the company or the members themselves so it's just simple as the producer of this song bias some of the members' voice more than some others. That's all. He definitely would give more lines to those he thought suit the song more than those who did not.
It shows that the leader vocal has many advantages in girl groups. Image if IOI has only one leader vocal, add Sejeong's and Yoonjung's parts together, it will be almost 50% of the song. The leader vocal has more chance to show her gift even she is not the "center". Other groups are similar. The most popular member in the groups GG, Apink, Girls Day, AOA etc is the leader vocal.
Actully Sohye have more line in original Crush in P101 👁️👄👁️ it's feel Awkward that sejeong have more line than yeonjung i agree sejeong is better but YMC give some line on Sohye and Doyeon and Mina 🙄👀
Yeonjung sings a few small Adlibs during the bridge before each chorus. You didn't count them ;/; She also sings an octave adlib at the "Blah Blah blah jigeum nae shimjange crush boy"
Chia phần hát k đều :( bản thân t thấy I.O.I rất nhiều thành viên hát được như Doyeon, Pinky,... mà sao phần hát ít thế -.- người thì hát được mấy giây người thì hát gần như cả bàii
Yeonjung have second most line, that's why in the original Crush MV she have much screen time but people said she's greedy. Now look at Dream Girls and Very Very Very. I'm sad to see that.
![[MelOn Premiere Showcase] I.O.I(아이오아이) _ Crush](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/Ud5tjkuPbHE/mqdefault.jpg)
![Blox Fruits Dragon Rework Update [Full Stream]](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/EqDAp8udhm0/mqdefault.jpg)
![I.O.I - Whatta Man [Line Distribution || Color Coded]](/img/1.gif)
Sohye has only 1 word
Omg
Derp Bidoof That's the true
hi wangseng
Nguyên Nguyễn Lê Thảo its okay as long as she can dance like them . saranghae my penguin
She got more lines in the PD 101 version 😂😂😂😂😂
So surprised Yeonjung got the second most amount of lines since she gets the least amount of screen time.
she's the main vocalist of this group hahaha
she the main vocal
Actually, she got the most screentime in the m/v but it changed after alot of hate
K-POP ENTERTAINMENT yea an after that she's gotten less screen time in all other IOI Mvs
djChives95
Probably because the company wanted to avoid the hate
it is ioi ft doyeon&mina and sohye just passing by the recording studio
I love Yoojung's part after Nayoung. ❤
everyone here talking about sohye but hello? doyeon?
Look at Mina first
+Derp Bidoof same
poor Sohye, she is only got 1.3s, she deserve more lines
look at sohye 1.3s only!!
Al Furqan doyeon deserves more linea she can sing well, sohye doesn't
God Sejeong
Sejong slay
lol the 3 TOP vocalists of ioi as always at the TOP I agree but doyeon...her vocals are literally better than chaeyeon
bangtan love the top 3 vocalists are actually Sejeong Yeonjung and Chungha
@@abbcd True, even though its weird because like Somi and Chungha are a little interchangeable in the top three
I get that Sohye's not a great vocalist (with the level of experience she had here, at least), but 1 second? They could have given her at least a few seconds for the sake of her fans who voted for her...
The producers now distribute the lines based on who can actually sing, they don't care about the members, just who has talent. Produce101 was solely based on popularity, and now its the producers turn to do whatever they want.
It's just really frustrating. I didn't expect (or even want) her to have a lot of lines, but just one solid line would have been nice at least as a service to her fans.
@@Rynne_1 look at doyeon, she is good singer but just get 2 s 🤣🤣🤣 , sohye just cant sing.
It has 3 lines of I'm not mistaken
markus firmmansyah lol are you sure? Because she’s improving a lot and you should respect that, not downgrade her.
doyeon has a really good voice, i don't understand why she's so underrated !!!
she really does, i still think quite a few members voices are better but shes a really good vocalist, they lines should be distributed more evenly, like she should still be in the 2half but she should get more lines. It should just be more even, sole order but closer percentages. Well, Chaeyeon should be lower xD
Her voice is really good but sometimes she isn't stable
Because others are more popular so they keep giving them more lines so annoying... but in whatta doyeon got finally more line
Amii Nell *cough* Chaeyeon
+Kenneth Le 😂😩 yes
Yeonjung has the most powerful. And I like Somi's voice. Sejeonng is so good too, her voice is so good here. Yoojung is so good at singing and rapping too.
yoojung💕 yeonjung💕
You don't count Yeonjung's adlibs
Rahma Nur Islami I'm saying tho
yeaaaaa
Yeaahhhh😞
The 3 First that wasn't count is yeonjung and the others 2 os sejeong
Sohye worked really hard to make her dream come true, and she is getting just one word in a 3 minute song?
at the end yeonjung has adlibs (IF I RIGHT) when sejeong in the center
3:16 "its alright" is yeonjung
and 3:17 "...is crush" is yeonjung too
But Sejeong has adlibs that didnt count too, so stop non sense
Can't belive that Sohye just got 1 second to sing!
PARK TAEJUN y'know that "dot" makes a big difference
2, 1:23 . This distribution its wrong
I love Sejeong, but I feel like they could have given at least like 10 of those seconds to the other members?
The persom who did this was incorrect they didn't even put all of Yeunjungs adlibs there and some of chae's lines were actually minas
She's the main vocalist, so why would anyone give her lines to someone else?
I mean when they produced the song... it could have been a little more evenly distributed. Pretty much all kpop groups have a main vocalist, but though they usually have the most lines, its usually at most like 2 times more than the other members.
And IOI has a lot of pretty good singers so it's not like she's the only one who can sing. Don't get me wrong, Sejeong is my favorite in IOI. I just felt like it was very very uneven compared to a lot of groups.
she's the main vocal duh why only sejeong out of the top5?
Ąurà - sure, anyone in the top 5 then? But I only said it because she had 10 seconds more than even 2nd. And everyone under 6 didn't even HAVE 10 seconds lol...
no need to be rude.
We really need a duet with sejeong and yeonjung their voices are so good
Sohye , one word ? she should have more lines
She can't sing.
+Fai Tirado fys
Fai Tirado Is that all you can say?
강유나 that's all i need to say,
Fai Trbl she can sing, but not as good as the others. And this isn't a reason to give her one fucking line or word
Thank you so much. I've been waiting for someone to do this
- I like Yoojung and Somi voice !! Slayy
Love yoojung
at 3:18, that is Yeunjung's.
Won't change anything though.
mealis style you're right. It's yeonjung.
cliper same geez you're everywhere I swear I saw you in the comments of cosmic girls performances
God Sejeong😘😘😘
"urinen green light" and some parts are actually Mina's.. anyway Sejeong slaying.
a lot of chae's lines are actually mina's she's lipsyncing them & it happens that she's the centre
its Chaeyeon
nope.
Ąurà there are chaeyeon's line up i guess
@@jazmine5699 Just because someone doesn't know who sings a certain line doesn't mean that they are stupid or know nothing about kpop.
they dont have the choice to choose or give away their lines, the agency chooses for them. knowing sejeongs personality im positive she wouldve given her lines to others if she could
I knoe Sejeong has an amazing voice, but could a few of her lines maybe gone to Doyeon and some of Yeonjung's lines to Sohye and Mina?
Sejeong ❤️
Sohye almost didn't sing :c But I'm speechless with YeonJung ♥
Sejeong queen💗
vocal (1-3 is facts 4-11 just my opinion)
1.yeonjung
2.sejeong
3.chungha
4.yoojung
5.somi
6.pinky
7.doyeon
8.nayoung
9.min
10.chaeyeon
11.sohye
YoonLu _Emma420
Somi's voice is better than Jung. At "Yum-yum" song jung couldn't sing high note, so Somi had to take it.
Wow Yoojoong and doyeon Performed two songs named crush
sejeonggg 😍😍😍😍
Sejeong stan here and this song makes me happy
i think the main issue w ioi is that there's such an obvious gap between the singer's ability. I'm not saying they can't sing, but yeonjung and sejeong obviously as such a higher level that the company probably feels they have to give them the most lines to keep the song alive (very very is a bit more even at least but its after a whole extra year of training almost). when you get a popularity based competition a lot of people got picked because of visuals and prehype i think and not talent in singing.
actually Yeonjung has the most lines in this song
Nope. Sejeong does.
Ąurà - Nop its YeonJung
Sung Moon If we start to count the ad lips: 1:40-1:43/1:48-1:50/1:57-1:58/3:15-3:17/3:18-3:20/3:30-3:32
This does much more than just 6 seconds... Only say🙃
To be honest, yes, its Yeonjung. Whoever made this missed so many adlibs from Yeonjung even if most of them were pretty obvious.
Yeonjung is not the only one who sing the adlib.
Oh my god Sejeong is so beautiful 😍😍😍
Give the justice for my penguin sohye 😭😭
SEJEEOONNGGIIEEEE😍😍
sejeong!!!
Sejeong & yeonjung FT i.o.i
Sejeong is my bias too, but please acknowledge Yeonjung's adlibs, she could have ranked 1st in this video. This is meaningless if you're being biased.
Sohye, thanks for breathing
I'm not agree with this, you did not take the adlibs of yeunjung, and some parts of the members mismatch. i think you based only in the video. try to recognise their voice. just sayin
what adlibs? everything is alright except for Mina's lines that were given to Chae..
between 1:41 - 1:50 there is a second voice which is yeonjung part, and also 3:15 - 3:20 its yeonjung high notes not sejeong
i totally agree with u
Yeah, agree with you. Too much mistake here. Yeonjung got most parts in this song but got less screentime
try to watch the whole showcase and you will know that sejeong got less screen time then yeunjung's
7.2 sec for Doyeon, Mina and Sohye...
I can understand sohye but mina & doyeon!! need lines!
@ above commenter: mina isn't actually stable live. if you check jellyfish's audition and pay attention to mina's singing she isn't very stable especially while dancing. so that is probably why. as for doyeon, i think she is okay, but she is also not the most stable as i've observed in whatta man.
-they're not the best vocalists that's smth i know what im saying is they are not bad either. Dancing is mina's specialise so i don't think it's badly affecting her stability? idk if you followed her during gugudan debut promos but she's had the most lines n the title song and she did really well.. but anyway.
βlùe Ąurà i did watch some of gugudan's stages and there was a lot of playback that's why. and not saying theyre bad but im just saying theyre not stable. and compared to the others that got lines, they were kind of at the bottom of the list in terms of vocals. especially since during dream girls the girls would be tired, as they had a lot of CF, shows, brand deals and other schedules. so their voice and health wouldn't be at the best condition at this time.
Well actually line distribution was made by the producer of the song, not the choreographer, the company or the members themselves so it's just simple as the producer of this song bias some of the members' voice more than some others. That's all. He definitely would give more lines to those he thought suit the song more than those who did not.
소혜가.....ㅠㅠㅠㅠㅠㅠ
It shows that the leader vocal has many advantages in girl groups. Image if IOI has only one leader vocal, add Sejeong's and Yoonjung's parts together, it will be almost 50% of the song. The leader vocal has more chance to show her gift even she is not the "center". Other groups are similar. The most popular member in the groups GG, Apink, Girls Day, AOA etc is the leader vocal.
Sejeong...😍😍😍😌😌
OT22 versions of Crush and When The Cherry Blossoms Fade please? If you have time
Sejeong
at 3:18 you give the line dist. to Sejeong when we can clearly heard that it's Yeonjung's
프듀때 이 작곡가 유정이 잘한다고 엄청 칭찬하던데 그래서 그런가 파트 정말 많이 줬넹! 너무 죻양
RIP Sohye
Actully Sohye have more line in original Crush in P101 👁️👄👁️
it's feel Awkward that sejeong have more line than yeonjung i agree sejeong is better but YMC give some line on Sohye and Doyeon and Mina 🙄👀
Yoo Jung 😘😘😘
sejong 💗💗
now looking back at IOI they are all so good! and grown hahah
Somi High notes😍😍
1:23 its sohye
Yeonjung sings a few small Adlibs during the bridge before each chorus. You didn't count them ;/;
She also sings an octave adlib at the "Blah Blah blah jigeum nae shimjange crush boy"
Yeonjung 1:45 she Sing with Yoojung
Sejeong number 1 , no.1
Sorry but...
1. Yeonjung -
37s
2. Sejeong - 35.97s
My yoojung ❤
MINAAA
Sejeong
Chia phần hát k đều :( bản thân t thấy I.O.I rất nhiều thành viên hát được như Doyeon, Pinky,... mà sao phần hát ít thế -.- người thì hát được mấy giây người thì hát gần như cả bàii
OT22 Version pls.
Sohye
doyeon needs more lines
I don't get why people still say this a better line distribution then Dream Girls. Like what?
Yeonjung have second most line, that's why in the original Crush MV she have much screen time but people said she's greedy. Now look at Dream Girls and Very Very Very. I'm sad to see that.
I think at 1:24 is Sohye singing not Sejeong
Yoojung
😍❤
Yeonjung's line is 34.2s
sohye 😭
omg sohye got sooo many lines!!
damn vocal line really out there
I miss them
Yes finally 😌
Yoojungiiiieee
Can you please do Dream Girls the sub unit ver???
1:22 to 1:25 and 2:29 to 2:32 are Sohye's lines, but you give them to Sejung
It's obvsly sejeong's voice plus you think ymc would give that much lines to sohye? rather than to doyeon mina & pinky? lol ofc no they never did
meliissamg Yes! SeYeon don't sing in that parts
You miss Mina's line at 3'13 ^_^
Sohye 😍😍
Sony’s breathed in this.
It is so bad that Sohye only got 1.3 sec she has a great improvement :) I believe she will do better and better in the future
Poor Doyeon,Mina and sohye
this video make ioi stand misunderstanding. IOI we miss you buddies
*goo choi yoojungggg*
Sejeong yeonjung 🔫😍😍😍💗
Yeonjung vocal💕
The first song that made me love somi’s voice
The "Rush rush rush" part is Pinky and Nayoung
I miss ioi😭
메인보컬 2명 있어 같아요
ㅇ 3:26
I miss I.O.I OT11 ㅠㅠ
Somi
sohye 😢😢😢😢