winter is really a real ace..she's even very good in terms of vocal, dance, and rap❤😍even the visuals are amazing ❤I really like winter when singing live 😍😍
Winter is just incredible, her high notes even had the dance break in between but she still managed to pull off both singing and dancing her parts. So much stamina and stability.
aespa really need to make a comeback asap coz look at them slaying their stage performances since last year. The live vocals was insane my girls are so stable. They ate CDs!
Well of course there is going to be some flat notes because she is singing while dancing and she sang like 40% of the song. They all slayed though. 😍😍😍❤️❤️❤️💕💕💕
Its not live vocals. It's pre recorded raw tracks to make it seem different from the original. The hot mic is on 10% volume so that a slight amount of live vocal bleeds through but the majority is the track. That way if someone is slightly off key it shows enough to make it appear live but not enough to throw the key of the song off. This is how all k pop groups do it because actually singing on key while dancing like this is impossible. When they do performances in the west the sing live because the west is more about vocals than visuals. And they do sing very well there but you notice their dancing becomes incredibly reduced.
*AESPA 100% HIT IT WITH LIVE VOCAL.* 🎯💯 Everyone did amazing, but NINGTER again proved them as 4th gen's vocal queens. KARISELLE too surprised with their vocal & rap. AESPA REALLY IS STRONGEST LINEUP IN KPOP HISTORY
Wow aespa another great performance you can see there dance talent specialy the vocals and congratulations you win another award mys let's keep supporting them they deserve the wins and award ☺💙 I'm glad I'm became a mys too fighting 💪💪
@@soxee118 you can praise them without bringing down other members. do you want aespa’s fanbase to be like one of those toxic ones filled with akgaes? these type of comments only feeds that. be respectful
Aespa 100% top Girl Group! My 2 favorite songs sang with new flavor. Getting ready for their concert. These Girls are the IT!!! Winter and Ningning are cream of the crop. Karina the most beautiful Girl I have seen in ages. Giselle is so fine. Keep up the great work girls. I look forward to your syink concert!!!!
I said Giselle is so fine!! And I will add that her dancing skills are outstanding. Her rap style is hypnotic. What an outstanding style and skill. I’m the one who commented “stop picking on her and leave her alone” when others were speaking awful about her. There is no Aespa without Giselle. Is that good enough for you? Some people can be so mean!
@Lalisa yes,Agreed!! She was actually the first member I noticed as standout and Beautiful . I have been a fan of hers since the video when she was in that class and Ae appeared in the class room with her and we were introduced to all the girls and their powers. I fell in love with her first, then the others. Yes SM had treated her differently but now it seem it is getting better. I am a fan from the beginning and I want them to be the #1 Girl Group because they are Top of the pile and stand tall. I love the character Ae concept and want lots more of it. Giselle is so cool as I met her in that video first! I thought wow is she Gorgeous or what? Yep, I’m with you Lalisa!
Omygosh! I'm surprised, at first I thought it was pre-recorded but then I heard them slay all those high notes so yeah it's definitely live ya'll! Love hearing them this way when performing.
As always delivering vocals, dance and visual! They have improved so much and praise to my girl Winter having so many lines in these 2 songs and singing all of them + highnotes!
*ACE WINTER was Aespa's HIDDEN VOCAL for a reason!* ⭐🎤🎯 With unique, stable, strong & technical *LIVE VOCAL,* stole the show. *MVP here & only getting better!* 💕
![[제39회 골든디스크] aespa (에스파) - 'Intro + Set The Tone + Supernova' ♪ | JTBC 250106 방송](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/tFaRRPePyFc/mqdefault.jpg)
![[제39회 골든디스크] aespa (에스파) - 'Intro + Set The Tone + Supernova' ♪ | JTBC 250106 방송](/img/tr.png)
![[가요대제전] aespa - Illusion + Girls (에스파 - 도깨비불 + 걸스) FanCam | MBC Music Festival | MBC221231방송](/img/1.gif)
Winter is so stable and has so much power and intensity in her voice I love me a singer
winter is so pretty and stable
im fall for winter now
Winter's long black hair😍😍😍
Winter's voice damn perfect!!!!
윈터 목소리 딴딴한거봐라...너무 잘해ㅠㅠㅠㅠ
립싱크아니에요?? 라이브인가
@@JungOO-e3s its live you can clearly hear it
@@JungOO-e3s 라이브에요
THEY JUST SOUND SO GOOD LIVE😩🔥
its not live lol
@@bluespeed8900 You are so funny
@@bluespeed8900 are u joking rn 😑
@@bluespeed8900 well, it's live😂😂😂😂😂😂😽
@@jodohjaehyun_ril pre recorded lol
winter is really a real ace..she's even very good in terms of vocal, dance, and rap❤😍even the visuals are amazing ❤I really like winter when singing live 😍😍
Winter's voice is strong, stable, very thumping. Her technique is amazing. Winter is the perfect ace. Winter has taken her singing to a new level.
winter's vocals, dance, stage presence, visual. she's almost perfect omg 🤍
I'm stanning Winter _so_ much in this performance. Wow!! 😳
Winter today is 🔥🔥🔥🔥
Winter's 'hey' in Illusion. I'm on my knees
Winter is damn stable...aespa are the live queensss🙌
Minjeong omg so stable
There live vocals are a bless 🔥✨
Winter should sing in a live voice every time. Her voice is so strong!!
My girl winter’s vocal is heavenly🥰😍
THEY ATE SO HARD LIKE WOW, AND THE LIVE VOCALS!? WOWOWOW! ABSOLUTELY AMAZING!
im really like ACE Winter,,, brilliant
Winter is just incredible, her high notes even had the dance break in between but she still managed to pull off both singing and dancing her parts. So much stamina and stability.
Damn no wonder winter be getting those lines.. girly can def walk the talk...
THAT'S WHY I STAN WINTER
코첼라때도 느꼈는데 윈터 진짜 안정적으로 잘부른다..
Wintoo ate
Her visual, dance, rap, sp, live vocal, 👑👑👑🔥🔥🔥
Ninging is so good, omg, my girl slayed once again
YESS
6:25 여기 닝닝이 파트에 닝닝이 노래 집중하기에도 바쁠텐데, 춤 왤케 날아다녀?? 찰떡이야~ 너무 잘해 우리 막닝이ㅠㅠㅠㅠ 이렇게 춤,노래 완벽하면 세계최고아이돌 밖에 못해~~~~ 완전 멋지다 우리 닝깅이ㅠㅠㅠㅠ
aespa really need to make a comeback asap coz look at them slaying their stage performances since last year. The live vocals was insane my girls are so stable. They ate CDs!
I'm a Karina stan but I applaud Winter's live vocal so much! She's so stable and even though there are some flat notes, she did great saving them!
Agree but Karina did a great job too she is the main dancer and still manage to hit highnote in Girls so satisfies is really impressed me.
Well of course there is going to be some flat notes because she is singing while dancing and she sang like 40% of the song. They all slayed though. 😍😍😍❤️❤️❤️💕💕💕
@@bluebabypink OH, OF COURSE KARINA ALWAYS SLAY! And yes, she did amazing despite not feeling well she did great.
Its not live vocals. It's pre recorded raw tracks to make it seem different from the original. The hot mic is on 10% volume so that a slight amount of live vocal bleeds through but the majority is the track. That way if someone is slightly off key it shows enough to make it appear live but not enough to throw the key of the song off. This is how all k pop groups do it because actually singing on key while dancing like this is impossible. When they do performances in the west the sing live because the west is more about vocals than visuals. And they do sing very well there but you notice their dancing becomes incredibly reduced.
@@SpencyP92The Circle Chart Award perfs were live. If you watch the other groups' perfs you can tell.
My Winter are amazing here!!!
oh winter slayed that dance break so hard
Winter ya Allah, anak ini kenapa cantik dan berbakat banget, sooo stable ❤️❤️❤️❤️
MIC IS ON AGAIN 🔥
main event aespa slay with live vocals🔥😍
Their best performance yet!!! They are so stable live omg aespa is amazing
Winter’s high notes are insane
Love winter ❤❤❤
I like winter with long hair
bruh they improved so freaking much especially at the Girls Dance Break, my girl Gigi is on fire🔥
ㅈㄴ 이쁘다 진짜....
Wow live vocals are insane!!
Perfect stage to practice their Live vocals for their 1st Concert this month !! Absolute slayage !
WINTER IS SO DELICATE BUT WHEN SHE SINGS SHE'S A MONSTER!!!!
Ning Ning’s voice so freaking sweet and amazing 💖🥰😭
Damnn Winter sounds so good
에스파짱스파갓스파사랑해
WINTER'S VOCAL IS INSANE OH MY GODDDD!!!!
WINTER OMG!! VISUAL, DANCE, VOCAL WAHHHH DAEBAK!!
Ningning was mad during that dancebreak!! She slayed the whole performance.
YESSSS
favourite girl group . aespa i love you❤ winter i love you ⭐️
Live Vocals are so stable that I thought its lypsinc for a sec😭✨ slayyspa
WINTER VOCAL🔥🤟🏻
Please upload idol reaction to aespa performance.
7:41 SLAYYS THE VOCALS AND THEN DANCES LIKE ITS THE LAST 🔥🔥🔥🔥🔥🔥
So proud of these girls. Their live vocals just prove their haters wrong. Not many people sound this good, but aespa do it while dancing!
Ik I'm so happy n proud that they did haters r just jealous cause our girls 😁 r amazing
Yet some people say its not live jeez..society
slayed!!
I knew I had chosen my correct bias... Winter you are perfect~
짱스파 !!
we need idol reaction aespa 🥺
*Aespa just warmed up for Hyper Line and CB.* 🔥🔥🔥🔥🔥
Seeing how they slayed it, I BET AESPA GONNA MAKE HISTORY THIS TIME!!! 💕
my girls slay toooo hard, god they're sooo good, girls you're working really hard, thankyou
winter main slayer
닝닝 너무 예뻐 올빽머리 최고。。。。
so proud of aespa. all of them did great. they're all stable
민정이 언니 긴머리 미쳤다 ㅠㅠㅠㅠㅠ❤❤❤
Whenever aespa performing live, Winter always stood the most.
they sound so much like the studio ver my stable queen
Winter killed it
THE WAY THEY SING LIVE IN SOME PARTS AND HIGH NOTES 100%!!!!!
Now where the haters at, Cant hear them... Lmao
@@lonelust uhm excuse me?
@@lonelust one hater even said they are not singing cause they are using backtrack but not the other groups 😭😂 their hatred is really phenomenal 😂
@@lonelust yes 😂 they can't drag aespa about the live vocals they need to work harder 😂
Winter my bias 😍
카리나 윈터 진짜 예쁘다,, 다들 실력도 대박이고 빨리 컴백했으면
*AESPA 100% HIT IT WITH LIVE VOCAL.* 🎯💯 Everyone did amazing, but NINGTER again proved them as 4th gen's vocal queens. KARISELLE too surprised with their vocal & rap. AESPA REALLY IS STRONGEST LINEUP IN KPOP HISTORY
Hyperline is going to be sooo good, I'll make you cry dance performance and more!
Wow aespa another great performance you can see there dance talent specialy the vocals and congratulations you win another award mys let's keep supporting them they deserve the wins and award ☺💙 I'm glad I'm became a mys too fighting 💪💪
I think Karina and Winter really gained from performing alongside legendary performers in GOT.
Agreed - they've improved so much!
Karina , winter QUEEN 💖💖
facts everyone else is mid
@@TheRevoltecs YESS WINRINA DO B CARRYIN AESPA
@@soxee118 you can praise them without bringing down other members. do you want aespa’s fanbase to be like one of those toxic ones filled with akgaes? these type of comments only feeds that. be respectful
Ning ning is literally good at every thing her highnotes are next leverl and she killed in the dance break ❤
Finally the fresh live vocals that I want.✨
Aespa 100% top Girl Group! My 2 favorite songs sang with new flavor. Getting ready for their concert. These Girls are the IT!!! Winter and Ningning are cream of the crop. Karina the most beautiful Girl I have seen in ages. Giselle is so fine. Keep up the great work girls. I look forward to your syink concert!!!!
I said Giselle is so fine!! And I will add that her dancing skills are outstanding. Her rap style is hypnotic. What an outstanding style and skill. I’m the one who commented “stop picking on her and leave her alone” when others were speaking awful about her. There is no Aespa without Giselle. Is that good enough for you? Some people can be so mean!
Double Standard? Geez!!!!
@Lalisa read my reply to you. I’m sure you will understand what I was saying this time. Take care and have a beautiful day!
@Lalisa yes,Agreed!! She was actually the first member I noticed as standout and Beautiful . I have been a fan of hers since the video when she was in that class and Ae appeared in the class room with her and we were introduced to all the girls and their powers. I fell in love with her first, then the others. Yes SM had treated her differently but now it seem it is getting better. I am a fan from the beginning and I want them to be the #1 Girl Group because they are Top of the pile and stand tall. I love the character Ae concept and want lots more of it. Giselle is so cool as I met her in that video first! I thought wow is she Gorgeous or what? Yep, I’m with you Lalisa!
@Lalisa ot4 all the way
WINTER SLAY 🔥🔥
에스파는 신이에요❤
OMG I'M SPEECHLESS. AESPA SLAYS
Minjeong Sp 💖💖💖
윈터 라이브잘하는거 왜케 설레지
에스파 라이브잘한다 늘 응원해!!!
400% Live vocal WINTER KIM
Winter slayyy! Visual, vocal, dance stunning
Winter 🔥
Not many rapper can sing and singer can rap. But here is *KARINA & GISELLE who slayed both effortlessly.* Really,our *4 ACES NEVER DISAPPOINT!!!* 💙💯🌙
@@바보Queen no one need your opinion
@@shashuio yea roast him bro
@@바보Queen While noone care about you
Louder!!
@@바보Queen shut uo
Omygosh! I'm surprised, at first I thought it was pre-recorded but then I heard them slay all those high notes so yeah it's definitely live ya'll! Love hearing them this way when performing.
このいしょうときょくがピッタリでかっこよくてすてきっ(^O^)🎵💓
As always delivering vocals, dance and visual! They have improved so much and praise to my girl Winter having so many lines in these 2 songs and singing all of them + highnotes!
*ACE WINTER was Aespa's HIDDEN VOCAL for a reason!* ⭐🎤🎯 With unique, stable, strong & technical *LIVE VOCAL,* stole the show. *MVP here & only getting better!* 💕
her voice is sooo crystal clear
@@rosy8772 yes. Her vocal is most stable in Aespa. Really an ACE!
Aespa!!! Wowww
와 실력 대박이다 진짜 너무 잘해
Ningning and winter part back to back always be my fav
Vocal Queen Winter!! Yeoksii yyj's daughter
Ningning Really is an Ace 😍
The stage presence is 🔥
이번 무대 스타일링도 그렇고 라이브도 레전드…
aespa😍
*AESPA SLAYED WITH LIVE VOCALS!* ❤️🎯💘 Specially NINGTER's top vocal & KARISELLE's amazing presence just stole the show. JUST CEREMONIE'S MAIN EVENT!