Carly, you have an angelic voice. I actualy shed a tear and felt the shiver down my back listening to you. I knew youd make it when i saw you on Idol. Keep the faith girl!
I've been a huge Evanescence fan since I was 11, but these guys are good. She can sing great, the band makes good music. I don't understand why people think they have to hate one or the other. Like them both--it makes life easier.
She has an absolutely amazing voice. I love it. She was my favorite Idol contestant during her season. I'm glad she's found a home in this band. Did I say this was great?!
I don't see why people can't enjoy both Amy's and Carly's talent.Both are truly amazing singers. There is no real need to compare them. Amy is Amy (my rock goddess) and Carly is Carly (who is breath taking as well). I kind of wish they would sing a duet one day (think of how beautiful that would sound.. maybe?). Still, I love me my Evanescence, that doesn't mean I can't appreciate the music this band makes as well.. Give them both a try and learn to love.
Ok guys!...I'm not gonna lie.I absolutely love Amy Lee and Evanescence.I used to compare them by the past but I stopped.I realized that they may sound the same but they are very different.Let them live their lives!!...We Are The Fallen is a great band with a great music and has so much to offer to their fans.So stop comparing and appreciate and support them in what they are doing and help them to break through to much more success!
we can not have it all but live in this storm of ideas, we can not erase what has happened and not pretend that nothing is happening, but it's hard to stay that way .... both choices will cause pain ....
Carly is great....remember that she was one of my favorites when she participated in American Idol....so nice to hear her version of this wonderful song :) Love from Denmark
This is the direction you should go in. Drop the feud. Change your name and you will get re-signed. This cover was 100X more amazing than your first record.
*jaw drops*
hit the replay button
Best female version of this song !!
wooow!!! im speechless her voice is amazing .
This is one of the best covers of this song that I've ever listened to.
Yes it is!! 💙💙
Totally right!!!!! Hear it once and it erases the original
Yes you’re right Tatiane
the bass & acoustic guitar sounds are simply amazing
I miss this band.. 🌹🌹
I discovered them late af, in 2017. They were sooooo good, I wish they had released more music
ruclips.net/video/M55FY91e2ZQ/видео.htmlsi=V3qO2JAre0xhNKJw
Yes, a sweet version, well-played music and right on vocals. hey if it sends music down my spine that's enough for me.
Best cover of this song on the web.
This is an awesome cover. I really like the interpretation from the singer.
What a beautiful voice, she elevates this pop song.
🌎🌊🌲🔥🌪 ❤️
being a massive u2 fan I got to admit she naild it
first time i saw this group and their version of with or without you by U2, it's great. the acoustic is great!!! love it.
no words for her voice.... IT'S AMAZING!!!!!!
Blew my mind, man. Freakin awesome voice.
Carly, you have an angelic voice. I actualy shed a tear and felt the shiver down my back listening to you. I knew youd make it when i saw you on Idol. Keep the faith girl!
This is the most bad ass thing I've seen in 2020. Why haven't I seen this before?
I've been a huge Evanescence fan since I was 11, but these guys are good. She can sing great, the band makes good music. I don't understand why people think they have to hate one or the other. Like them both--it makes life easier.
so ive spent the past hour going through all the covers of with or without u, and this is undoubtedly the best.
Best cover of that song i've heard in a long time..
My GODS this woman's got lungs! LOVE LOVE LOVE HER!
In my opinion is the best cover. Beautiful 😍
Great voice - Fantastic cover!
Wow this is freaking awesome. Great job WATF, i love this band...
WOW!!! Amazing!!!!!❤❤❤❤❤
She has an absolutely amazing voice. I love it. She was my favorite Idol contestant during her season. I'm glad she's found a home in this band.
Did I say this was great?!
Brilliant! Just Brilliant!
my god she's amazing!!! I could listen to this all day
You guys are awesome thank you
loved this performance and mini interview!
very unique and neat :-)
WATF rocks the world!
she has the voice that gives me GOOSEBUMPS
What a breath-taking cover. Amazing, amazing amazing.
I don't see why people can't enjoy both Amy's and Carly's talent.Both are truly amazing singers. There is no real need to compare them. Amy is Amy (my rock goddess) and Carly is Carly (who is breath taking as well). I kind of wish they would sing a duet one day (think of how beautiful that would sound.. maybe?). Still, I love me my Evanescence, that doesn't mean I can't appreciate the music this band makes as well.. Give them both a try and learn to love.
Beautiful, chills!
It's a great cover :-) You are amazing
Gave me shivers. I really enjoyed there cover. Powerful
No words for this voice 🙌
That girl is astonishing.. she sings with amazing purity, simply beautiful :)
the second part is just unbelievable, i love it.
el mejor cover de esta cancion que haya visto jamas ...wooooow
awesomeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeee absolutelly perfect wowwwwww
Just great!!
Wow, such a nice performance!
Ok guys!...I'm not gonna lie.I absolutely love Amy Lee and Evanescence.I used to compare them by the past but I stopped.I realized that they may sound the same but they are very different.Let them live their lives!!...We Are The Fallen is a great band with a great music and has so much to offer to their fans.So stop comparing and appreciate and support them in what they are doing and help them to break through to much more success!
pretty awesome, first time i listen to this song too
Well done! You really made it yr own version and it is very nice. From a u2 fan.
Carly's voice made me shiver. amazing.
loving her voice.
Best Cover Ever !
She looks like Amy Farrah Fowler in this video!
Great cover, love it.
BIG BANG! YOU ARE MY NEW BEST FRIEND
Pretty! I love her voice, sounds so elegant.
we can not have it all but live in this storm of ideas, we can not erase what has happened and not pretend that nothing is happening, but it's hard to stay that way .... both choices will cause pain ....
That was amazing. Everyone did a great job!
She has a great voice! I can't wait to hear more from them!
una bella cover very nice!!!
wow! Carly's voice is amazing! :-) Loved it!
Beautiful cover. Loved all the accoustic guitars. Great job guys :-)
That's awesome!!!
increadible best passonate vocals ever love every second
Great cover ! I love the vocal performance !!!
These Mashup Monday covers are really hit or miss, but this one, my friends was a HIT. Fantastic. That song is really hard to cover in a female range.
I love watching her do covers, because she becomes more of herself when she is doing them. This cover makes me happy.
what a voice!
Very nice done. You're a group of fine musicians when performing this song this way.
Brilliant version......this is so good...
Fantastic... Hope she did stuff again
goosebumps.. so good..
wow what a voice.
Great voice, thanks!!!
she's awesome!
wow... i love her voice
This performance is perfect!
Dang Carly...your skills have matured and improved dramatically. Love the cover! Keep up the great work guys!
Dayum the Adams Family can sure Jam out! Good Job Wendy!
Best coverrr...
I love it!! ❤
omg i love it!
Carly is great....remember that she was one of my favorites when she participated in American Idol....so nice to hear her version of this wonderful song :)
Love from Denmark
is beatiful voice, wonderful.
her voice is amazing...
damn... i like it very much... good luck
love it!!
Excellent cover Carly Smithson...!!
I love it.
This is the direction you should go in. Drop the feud. Change your name and you will get re-signed. This cover was 100X more amazing than your first record.
Great vocals and the melodies are amazing XD
NÃO CONSIGO PARAR DE OUVIR!!!!
MISTURA PERFEITA!!!
sweet song with sweet voice ..
i really like this... it sounds so raw with emotion
I like the way she sing.
Brilliant Cover
The singer's feeling is nice!!!
Where o where are they? Why no more music? Come back!! Give 2020 something!! Please! Thanks
I have loved Carly since AI and I am so happy to finally see her in a band!! She has such an amazing voice,gives me chills everytime I hear it!!
I knew it! It's Carly Smithson. Damn, girl, that voice gives me shiver. Love ya! :D
Thank you for this. Honestly, thank you.
A Idol never gets it right,Daughtry,Carly,Adam..on an on...
Very nice!!
I like this song!
I can't get over how good they look playing their guitars and the singing is awesome!!!
This little girl will never replace Amy. Never.
Hey I am a bit Irish too, I love your accent and your singing voice. Super talented! :)
this was amazing =)