@@Spherz the physics are because of the dynamic friction plugin with ac1.5 I think and the gravity too high And the bugs is probably just them being lazy tbh, I'm making a game specifically to not fuck up as bad as they do and I can't even figure out how to fuck up as bad as them and I'm 256 hours in Weekly updates are feasible and a car takes like 2-4 hours to tune to near exactly what it is irl if you're a slacker (by one person)
@@User-ghcwvouvmgs the main problem with the physics is that Roblox servers are slow by default, and those dynamic frictions are FE+ which means the are influenced by roblox’s servers and therefore heavily unpredictable, hence why I made my own dynamic tire script based solely on the speed of the vehicle (and using throttle to naturally initiate oversteer) The other thing is, I spoke to a developer of the game and they said that the chassis is completely recoded to actually be powered by body forces instead of the wheels💀 Also it seems almost 0 Roblox games have realistic downforce for their cars
PTD is planning on adding more content this year beyond just vehicles I've been loaded onto the team for new maps of a higher quality standard too, hopefully 2024 will yield many great additions if all goes well! Great video
First time I’m watching a video on your channel and it was very accurate so congrats. For the games, I do play Project Trackday often and I appreciate driving gte cars because the sound is great just like physics of the cars. Also, I think I’ve played Apex one time but I should really try again Well it was nice to learn more of these games I’ve seen too many time in discovery without playing these that much !
Project trackday by far has the best handling system with very accurate over/understeer. Roblox rally is also accurate but less comparable due to a different nature of racing ION had realistic and logical handling albeit with too much traction on corner exit Apex feels like it has too much downforce at certain tracks, where sometimes corners can be taken faster than possible but works well in low speed corners
@RoArthur I think it's because the wasd controls can only control movement by going 100% on throttle, 100% on brakes, as well as left and right. If you use wasd keys for some other realistic games, such as beamng, it will become apparent that they oversteer as well. Its biggest problem is the amount of bugs it has
infact, Roblox Rally Racing is a rally game that is based on Real Life Rally Championship sport called "World Rally Championship" and videogames like WRC games or even Dirt series.
You should maybe do less f1 takes and branch out to some other pretty cool games like super cars 23 like endurance games and gt games bc their pretty cool! Awesome video btw! :)
@@RoArthurit’s just too bad that their all f1 games like no one ever makes any good gt or endurance games other than pt, same thing with off road racing games and MOTO games like I’m sick of just seeing all of the f1 games as much as I enjoy them there is 1 too many
I was a bit disappointed that MR:T was not on this list, even with the many quality updates I think they had this year. But I don't mind the list because a lot of good games I agree with are here. Look forward to the next review
Honestly project track day isnt really that bad but what i mostly prefer is Apex Motorsport as the steering is pretty okay and decent but a lot of updates will be coming this year for better handling and etc.
I think the devs of Project Trackday have pretty much abandoned it to focus on Midnight Racing: Tokyo. That game gets way more frequent updates and Indycars were leaked for PT years ago..
It sounds like you're experiencing an issue while playing ION Formula Racing on your phone. When you spawn any car and accelerate forward, the car doesn't move but only revs. However, when you accelerate backward, it moves, although it doesn't make sense to drive in reverse. If anyone knows a solution, please let me know.
I just wish there was a dedicated Indycar, IMSA, and WEC game. IMSA would have every GTP, LMP2, and GTD(P)/GTD car, WEC would have same for the WEC cars though. If only I could develop a game and get licensing rights (or knockoffs, kinda like BeamNGs Dead Bull for Red Bull).
Even though this game is technically not a racing game, shout out to Monster Trucks Overdriven to updating their hyper realisticphysics and new gui and somewhat similar arena layout
The PTD Indianapolis map had way more than just an oval, unfortunately the higher up devs didnt set up the inner circuit for racing & times but otherwise everything else is correctly said about the game
@@RoArthurOh the story of the Indy update was an absolute wreck, the only thing that was consistent was the Track being made (YK the thing that takes the most time to do) . It took about five months in which that time all the other Devs had to do was set up two cars, the timer, and corner cuts. At least the update had an upside which was just how detailed the new map was
Im sorry, but the level understeer on Project trackday and the fact it is very easy to oversteer from any angle out of a turn is a big no for me, especially the harsh penalty system (you get 7 seconds for just going a tiny bit outside of track sometimes). That makes the game easily go to a 3.5/10 overall.
Hi, I am an unofficial mapper working for Roblox rally! I'm here to say this year will be an interesting one for our game. As of the release of this comment we have 2 possible new maps in the making! I'm glad you enjoyed out game, and can't wait to see your reactions.
I don't know much about Midnight Racing Tokyo to tell you about it, however notice how the title says "Racing Games" and not "Car Games". Strictly basing this off Racing Games!
@@emilelabrie8247Hey, I don’t think you know how bad of a game Apex Motorsport is. ruclips.net/video/Wrj6VuBOiWw/видео.htmlsi=E0btKnsA-xZbuQPC Watch this video to understand more.
What is Roblox? Roblox is a global platform where millions of people gather together every day to imagine, create, and share experiences with each other in immersive, user-generated 3D worlds. The types of gameplay on Roblox are just as limitless as the imagination of the creators themselves.
When I play formula roblox, the game is not good, because I am always slower than other players. Why is it only me that my speed is slower than other players?
if im correct project apex was also the first race game to reach over 1k current player during a period as a og player who start playing project apex back in late 2021 when the game had 85 or so players i know one day this game will be on top with ion formula and it turns out i was right and now im more exciting to see what the furture holds for project apex and to me project apex had a more stable platform then ion formula so i dont think ion formula will fall in the same fate as ion formula did anytime soon
They were definitely not the first game to reach 1k. It was ION Formula but that was back in 2021. Also makes absolutely no sense what you said later down the line.
I personally think that Touge Legends is the best but thats just my opinion. - The sense of speed is amazing (for roblox) - You can blow your engine by overrevving or overheating -Tire wear is realistic -the sound is amazing (dont even try do drive the r32 it understeers like hell)
Lots of you asked why I didn’t include Midnight Racing: Tokyo. This video was just for racing games not for car games. Thanks for watching 🤙
The main problems with MRT are:
- Unpredictable physics
- Insanely grindey
- updates mostly add content instead of improve shortcomings
@@Spherz the physics are because of the dynamic friction plugin with ac1.5 I think and the gravity too high
And the bugs is probably just them being lazy tbh, I'm making a game specifically to not fuck up as bad as they do and I can't even figure out how to fuck up as bad as them and I'm 256 hours in
Weekly updates are feasible and a car takes like 2-4 hours to tune to near exactly what it is irl if you're a slacker (by one person)
@@User-ghcwvouvmgs the main problem with the physics is that Roblox servers are slow by default, and those dynamic frictions are FE+ which means the are influenced by roblox’s servers and therefore heavily unpredictable, hence why I made my own dynamic tire script based solely on the speed of the vehicle (and using throttle to naturally initiate oversteer)
The other thing is, I spoke to a developer of the game and they said that the chassis is completely recoded to actually be powered by body forces instead of the wheels💀
Also it seems almost 0 Roblox games have realistic downforce for their cars
@@User-ghcwvouvmgs MRT uses AC 1.2 as far as I remember!
mr:t is a racing game burh
Truly one of the most rankings of all time, 10/10
Truly.
Truly
"Truly an good fight,you fought well gojo" ahhh tipe of line
PTD is planning on adding more content this year beyond just vehicles
I've been loaded onto the team for new maps of a higher quality standard too, hopefully 2024 will yield many great additions if all goes well! Great video
Can’t wait to see what you guys have in store. Hopefully, better than last year!
amazing video once again mate! looking forward to what 2024 as in store for ro-racing!
Same here man, thanks for watching 🫡
Amazing video! I agree with your opinions and will try some I haven’t played
this is a masterpiece , well well well done brother
Woah, king absolutely appreciate it!
That's MAD (haha get it)
Nice Video, I really like the effort you've put in it.
W Video, watched to the end it was very entertaining. And yes PA ON TOP!
Thanks man, appreciate it!
Love the racing games you recommend and very well edited video!
Thank you! 👍
nice content king! keep up the reccomendation, this games are underrated and i haven't heard about any of them.
Are you new to Roblox racing games?
Project track day and RFA has to be my favourite games, i play these games A LOT and happy to see it’s getting recognised
Fantastic video! Big ups🙌🏽 '23 was definitely a little disappointing content wise but was still a great year🤝🏽
Indeed!
@@RoArthur yeah
10:40, well who's that fine gentleman?
anyways this is for sure one of your best crafted videos, almost flawless, good job mate.
Thanks man, appriciate the help with cutscenes as well!
First time I’m watching a video on your channel and it was very accurate so congrats.
For the games, I do play Project Trackday often and I appreciate driving gte cars because the sound is great just like physics of the cars.
Also, I think I’ve played Apex one time but I should really try again
Well it was nice to learn more of these games I’ve seen too many time in discovery without playing these that much !
Thanks bro, hope you enjoyed 🙏
Nice and well thought out video ;)
Appreciate it man 👍
Epic ranking of arthur 😎
Thank you for making this awesome video and i agree with your ranking 🐐
Thanks brother
I forgot about Sasy until I saw this video, Thanks for reminding me XD
Velocita autosport is gonna be fire when it comes out in like 2 years
Project trackday by far has the best handling system with very accurate over/understeer.
Roblox rally is also accurate but less comparable due to a different nature of racing
ION had realistic and logical handling albeit with too much traction on corner exit
Apex feels like it has too much downforce at certain tracks, where sometimes corners can be taken faster than possible but works well in low speed corners
PT in my opinion is a bit too oversteery but yeah everything else is solid. Thanks for watching!
@RoArthur I think it's because the wasd controls can only control movement by going 100% on throttle, 100% on brakes, as well as left and right. If you use wasd keys for some other realistic games, such as beamng, it will become apparent that they oversteer as well.
Its biggest problem is the amount of bugs it has
infact, Roblox Rally Racing is a rally game that is based on Real Life Rally Championship sport called "World Rally Championship" and videogames like WRC games or even Dirt series.
love your vids mate
Appriciate it dude!
This is a banger, and i know bangers.
Ws in the chhhhhatta
Ws in the shattt
You should maybe do less f1 takes and branch out to some other pretty cool games like super cars 23 like endurance games and gt games bc their pretty cool! Awesome video btw! :)
The thing is the games mentioned are way more advanced compared to Supercars 23.
It wouldn’t be fair to the games mentioned to not be mentioned!
@@RoArthurit’s just too bad that their all f1 games like no one ever makes any good gt or endurance games other than pt, same thing with off road racing games and MOTO games like I’m sick of just seeing all of the f1 games as much as I enjoy them there is 1 too many
I usually play rrr rally bc it’s the most genuine fun Motorsport game
Hey taxiboss is starting to become quite a good racing game I'd like to see a video about that if you could make it happen that would be killer
Great vid
Thanks dude!
Project trackday is my honest favourite for the one car not many car games have.
The Porsche 911 GT1 98
I was a bit disappointed that MR:T was not on this list, even with the many quality updates I think they had this year. But I don't mind the list because a lot of good games I agree with are here. Look forward to the next review
I didn’t include it beacuse this is a strictly Racing game list, not a car game list.
@@RoArthur So the list only counts on simulator-esque racing games? Ok, makes sense
great video
Thanks man, appreciate it!
Goated video
much better quality than last year nice
Watching back, I don’t know how you guys watched that video 😭
W a video but i have a question how do i modify my car in formula apex?
Go into the dealership, select the car and press on upgrade!
Honestly project track day isnt really that bad but what i mostly prefer is Apex Motorsport as the steering is pretty okay and decent but a lot of updates will be coming this year for better handling and etc.
I love that YT says ur playing F1 23
I think the devs of Project Trackday have pretty much abandoned it to focus on Midnight Racing: Tokyo. That game gets way more frequent updates and Indycars were leaked for PT years ago..
Unfortunately I am starting to think that as well.
@@RoArthurThe Indycar is also very low quality and independence isn't great.
@@TunaPlaysGames956 I know dude, I’ve expressed my disappointment especially for the indycars.
Love this vid!
Appreciate it dude!
Project track day is like Gran Turismo fr
It sounds like you're experiencing an issue while playing ION Formula Racing on your phone. When you spawn any car and accelerate forward, the car doesn't move but only revs. However, when you accelerate backward, it moves, although it doesn't make sense to drive in reverse. If anyone knows a solution, please let me know.
ION is currently a buggy mess, it has been discontinued and developers are developing the sequel, so I doubt there is a solution.
I just wish there was a dedicated Indycar, IMSA, and WEC game. IMSA would have every GTP, LMP2, and GTD(P)/GTD car, WEC would have same for the WEC cars though. If only I could develop a game and get licensing rights (or knockoffs, kinda like BeamNGs Dead Bull for Red Bull).
I got good news for you, just wait!
The beginning gave me flashbacks.
Same
Even though this game is technically not a racing game, shout out to Monster Trucks Overdriven to updating their hyper realisticphysics and new gui and somewhat similar arena layout
The PTD Indianapolis map had way more than just an oval, unfortunately the higher up devs didnt set up the inner circuit for racing & times but otherwise everything else is correctly said about the game
And the funny thing is, it’s probably just a few minutes to set up the timing. 😭
@@RoArthurOh the story of the Indy update was an absolute wreck, the only thing that was consistent was the Track being made (YK the thing that takes the most time to do) . It took about five months in which that time all the other Devs had to do was set up two cars, the timer, and corner cuts. At least the update had an upside which was just how detailed the new map was
about maps they are good on rrr but i can say more maps are coming with roblox voxel terrain
I am super excited for that
W vid
Project trackday, as of 3 months into the new year has dished out a ton of cars compared to last year.
I am so happy they finally stepped up.
Formula Apex cooking, they adding the RB20 in March 23 😭🙏
WRC roblox rally is too underrated
Im sorry, but the level understeer on Project trackday and the fact it is very easy to oversteer from any angle out of a turn is a big no for me, especially the harsh penalty system (you get 7 seconds for just going a tiny bit outside of track sometimes). That makes the game easily go to a 3.5/10 overall.
have u tried Midnight racing tokyo before?
Yeah but this video is for strictly racing games. Not car games.
If Project Apex would have F2 and F3 cars and performances and more tracks it would be the perfect game🤩
I’ve got good news for you, they are planning to add F2 very very soon! Check my latest video.
Hi, I am an unofficial mapper working for Roblox rally! I'm here to say this year will be an interesting one for our game. As of the release of this comment we have 2 possible new maps in the making! I'm glad you enjoyed out game, and can't wait to see your reactions.
Can’t wait to see what you guys have in store for us!
Yes!!! LET"S GO!! (My reaction when i see my beloved F1 game as the best one)
Greatt
Do you use controller? New sub
Mouse control
thoughts on apex motorsport 2 made by namco studios?
1/10.
@@RoArthur dam 💀
Facts
I tried project Apex and my laptop exploded well I tried with my old one a normal one my gaming one handles perfect
Is there any comment on Midnight Racing Tokyo? They made alot of progress this year though
I don't think that counts as the standard Roblox racing. It is good tho
I don't know much about Midnight Racing Tokyo to tell you about it, however notice how the title says "Racing Games" and not "Car Games". Strictly basing this off Racing Games!
How do i get the safety car in formula apex?
I think you need to have private servers.
I love PTD but it's laggy
Rfa is so good and Project trackday
i say, this video too good.
I say, thank you!
@@RoArthur I say, your welcome!
I was so mad at PDT when i was trying to load in it doesnt load but when i try again it logged me out for some reason 💀💀💀💀😡😡😡😡.
You ain’t getting outta hood with this one 🔥🔥🔥🔥🔥
project trackday is good but one major flaw is with the cars. steering gets stiffer the faster you go and the higher you shift up.
Cars work like that blud
What Editor Do You Use?
It’s called “shotcut”
@@RoArthur Thanks
@@RaptorZYT32 np
Ion formula is kinda weird on mobile like the turning is weird like tilting your phone or iPad left the tires are turning right
This is more of a PC rating, not other devices!
@@RoArthurohhhh sorry
i wouldve been so worried if rfa was on top 5 thank god
😭
do the new update in project track day they are coming back this year
Will do in the next couple of days (:
If there was a formula 1 game with crash physics ill be down to ruin some people’s records😂(just kidding but i will do to my friends!)
Soon enough bro. 😭
what is the karting game at the at 0:11
It’s ION Formula Racing
formula roblox is the most complete game. IT's easy and gives very nice and smooth racing. And it's also very competitive
try apex motosport 2 its so good
but dont have players
It's shit
Wait til you see apex motorsport
Are you joking or are you fr 💀
I think for the next one you should rank them mobile as well because some games especially are just awful on mobile
That is actually not a terrible idea at all, I’ll keep it in mind!
have you try Apex Motorsport 2
Yes
Oh but what track
@@emilelabrie8247 Just a few, all are really low quality.
Ok i was just asking cas there is colision with ather car and you talk abot that
@@emilelabrie8247Hey, I don’t think you know how bad of a game Apex Motorsport is.
ruclips.net/video/Wrj6VuBOiWw/видео.htmlsi=E0btKnsA-xZbuQPC
Watch this video to understand more.
5:42 that didnt age well cause they have been pumping a lot of updates since 2024
I have seen that, very happy about that!
Play midnight racing tokyo the dev is from DEVGAME
The best racing games in 2024 is
Apex Aoutosport coming soon
We will have to wait and see.
im in a RoAthur Video, MOM I MADE IT!!!!
Lmfaoooo
Indepence is not a custom track
how about midnight racing tokyo?!?!
This list only contains Racing Games. Not Driving Games!
YOU SHOULD ADVERTISE DILI'S STUDIO NOW!!!
YOU SHOULD!
I have ptsd from hearing it every single day of my life
You and me both buddy
one game i work for but no miata simulator... Man....
As much as the game has potential, it’s nowhere near close enough to the games showcased here.
Nah, two games are going to be discontinued, thats the saddest thing i have heard this 2024
Don’t worry bro, while some games are getting discontinued, new ones are coming!
dont you worry, by 2024 rfa will be higher up on that list!!
I wish for that also
are they multiplayer?
What is Roblox? Roblox is a global platform where millions of people gather together every day to imagine, create, and share experiences with each other in immersive, user-generated 3D worlds. The types of gameplay on Roblox are just as limitless as the imagination of the creators themselves.
What is the name of the kart game?
ION Formula Racing
@@RoArthur Thanks
When I play formula roblox, the game is not good, because I am always slower than other players. Why is it only me that my speed is slower than other players?
Uhm, maybe get slightly better?
Apex racing is best
How to play this game?
All links in the description
You have a Balkan maybe Greek English pronunciation
I am greek lol
4:35 pause bro💀
shut up 🤖
@@RoArthur nah fam I shut down like a laptop lol
Where is Nitro Rush?
I never heard of it
Midnight racing tokyo didnt make to top 5?
Look at pinned comment please 😭
It s all about racing.
Why no Supercars 23
Because it’s not near the levels of the games mentioned here.
Not there yet
if im correct project apex was also the first race game to reach over 1k current player during a period
as a og player who start playing project apex back in late 2021 when the game had 85 or so players i know one day this game will be on top with ion formula and it turns out i was right and now im more exciting to see what the furture holds for project apex and to me project apex had a more stable platform then ion formula so i dont think ion formula will fall in the same fate as ion formula did anytime soon
They were definitely not the first game to reach 1k. It was ION Formula but that was back in 2021. Also makes absolutely no sense what you said later down the line.
@@RoArthur whoops I meant project apex not ion formula my bad
Roblox doesnt have a wheel conection bullshit so i cant play ultimate driving with my friends on a wheel not that i need it
You can install 3rd party software to help you connect your wheel to roblox!
To bad some of them are not for mobile :(
I am pretty sure all are for mobile!
@RoArthur is it one of those games you have to join the group?
The one I'm instructed is in project trackday
@@Jairah0613 Project Trackday has mobile support, you don’t need to join a group just play
@@RoArthur I guess they updated it, last time it didn't allow me
@@Jairah0613 They got mobile support a whiiiiiile back
I personally think that Touge Legends is the best but thats just my opinion.
- The sense of speed is amazing (for roblox)
- You can blow your engine by overrevving or overheating
-Tire wear is realistic
-the sound is amazing
(dont even try do drive the r32 it understeers like hell)
sadly its dead tho max ive seen online is like 40
Roblox physics suck though, that’s why i never play their racing games and stick to more realistic sims/racing games
cool
you spelled ria wrong
I didn’t even mentioned ria in the video?