Brutus no.1, EXPLAINED [AP Government Foundational Documents]

Поделиться
HTML-код
  • Опубликовано: 18 сен 2024
  • GET FOLLOW-ALONG NOTEGUIDES for this video: bit.ly/3XMSawp
    AP HEIMLER REVIEW GUIDE (formerly known as the Ultimate Review Packet):
    +AP Gov Heimler Review Guide: bit.ly/3rfXr2Y
    Additional HEIMLER REVIEW GUIDES (formerly known as Ultimate Review Packet):
    +AP US History: bit.ly/44p4pRL
    +AP World History: bit.ly/46rfHH1
    +AP European History: bit.ly/3PCPyiw
    +AP Essay CRAM Course (DBQ, LEQ, SAQ Help): bit.ly/3XuwaWN
    HEIMLER’S HISTORY MERCH! / @heimlershistory
    Tiktok: @steveheimler
    Instagram: @heimlers_history
    Heimler's History DISCORD Server: / discord
    In this video Heimler walks you through the next required foundational document for AP Government: Brutus 1. This document was produced by the Anti-Federalists (probably Robert Yates, but the jury is still out on its true author) in order to persuade the New York public, and anyone else who happened to read it, that the people of the United States should not ratify the Constitution.
    Brutus argues that investing a central government with so much power would necessarily make state power irrelevant. On this count he is especially concerned about the necessary and proper clause and and the supremacy clause.

Комментарии • 138

  • @shoot2kill94
    @shoot2kill94 3 года назад +897

    this man is literally carrying class of 2022

    • @slashprime47
      @slashprime47 3 года назад +9

      Frrrrrrr

    • @alis9425
      @alis9425 2 года назад +40

      Shit im class 2024 and he has me on his back

    • @301ju
      @301ju 2 года назад +16

      @@alis9425 2025 and he’s gonna carry me through this class

    • @jaketheathiest3927
      @jaketheathiest3927 2 года назад +1

      2024

    • @nesryn5369
      @nesryn5369 2 года назад +2

      Very true- I had missed my lesson in the documents Brutus 1 and Fed 10 due to getting Covid and my teacher doesn't offer a lot of resources or reference material online, we are kinda just expected to find and learn the material by ourselves, so I'm currently using these videos to catch up- bloody life saver

  • @dinahsaurt1433
    @dinahsaurt1433 3 года назад +410

    literally don't know what I'd do without you King

    • @heimlershistory
      @heimlershistory  3 года назад +133

      I’m just glad to be here with you 😌

  • @foreverlearning6743
    @foreverlearning6743 2 года назад +272

    I used to be an APUSH and APGOV student many years ago. I’m coming back to encourage you all to take seriously what you are learning here. I wish I did back then instead of just doing it to get extra college credit and look good for college. A lot of our rights and luxuries are being stripped away and the general population doesn’t even know it or do anything about it. Even if 1 person out of 100 listens to this, please, understand how much this really does apply to our daily lives. - The Founding Fathers would be ashamed and would be actively trying to reverse what we’ve allowed to happen in this day and age.

    • @realmclassic51
      @realmclassic51 5 месяцев назад +4

      Correct

    • @DanielWang-nx9el
      @DanielWang-nx9el 4 месяца назад +2

      Factual

    • @spektree8448
      @spektree8448 4 месяца назад

      Like what

    • @FiftyfourFiftyFour
      @FiftyfourFiftyFour Месяц назад

      And all of these idiots are too busy blaming them for being racist. 🤦🏽 They just don’t have an appreciation for their differences and circumstances of that time.

  • @leynanguyen7750
    @leynanguyen7750 3 года назад +112

    literally posted this as my teacher gave me the document to read

  • @MazdaRX7brap
    @MazdaRX7brap Год назад +55

    Taking Ap gov in an hour, didn’t even take the class. This man is saving me. The Ap classroom videos are elongated wastes of your time. ❤️

    • @nighttt_.
      @nighttt_. 11 месяцев назад +5

      how’d it go?

    • @CJ_Walks
      @CJ_Walks 5 месяцев назад

      Hah. Did you pass?

    • @FiftyfourFiftyFour
      @FiftyfourFiftyFour Месяц назад

      I’ve always wanted to take an ap test without the class lol.

  • @AlexAsh25
    @AlexAsh25 4 месяца назад +14

    carrying class of 2024! binging every unit review video, foundational documentation, and cases, right before exam day!

  • @probablynot2217
    @probablynot2217 3 года назад +95

    You’re the reason I’m passing AP gov rn thank you 🙏

  • @fexilsehn6445
    @fexilsehn6445 2 года назад +27

    once again getting carried by Heimler, first for Euro, then APUSH, now Gov, huge thanks and much appreciation for all the work you do

  • @naseemkesse2279
    @naseemkesse2279 Год назад +41

    speed running for ap exams in 3 days this man is my king

  • @amaliavj
    @amaliavj 3 года назад +17

    i absolutely love this dude

  • @joshboevers7982
    @joshboevers7982 3 года назад +75

    Still carrying the class of 2023

  • @Kens-Music
    @Kens-Music Год назад +25

    POV: You're binging these videos the day before the exam.

  • @user-jb7pe7wf1z
    @user-jb7pe7wf1z 5 месяцев назад +8

    federalists in favor of new constitution
    fed 10: how to protect minorities
    - factions are dangerous (dominate govt and force ppl to follow their interests)
    - solution is to stop factions in the first place or lessen the effects
    - solution is a large republic cuz there will be more interests and it will be hard to get support across everyone
    - more factions = more compromises

  • @chrismitchell523
    @chrismitchell523 2 года назад +21

    Also kids, don't forget "Polis" that properly addresses the issues of "scale in greek democracy" if you want those bonus points.

  • @danielnunez3518
    @danielnunez3518 2 года назад +12

    I’m here because my teacher was like “Google Brutus 1, it’s on the test tomorrow”

  • @henrypark4356
    @henrypark4356 3 года назад +40

    School hasn’t started yet, but I’m watching these videos for fun! Maybe I should get a headstart …

    • @mimij3870
      @mimij3870 3 года назад +14

      It's been a month, how ya feeling?

    • @gideonsbible
      @gideonsbible 2 года назад +11

      It’s been two months, how ya feeling?

    • @puratanasu7605
      @puratanasu7605 2 года назад +11

      It’s been a five month, how ya feeling?

    • @venusie
      @venusie 2 года назад +11

      It’s been seven months, how ya feeling?

    • @jonahl6187
      @jonahl6187 2 года назад +11

      It's been eight months, how ya feeling?

  • @jarlynjordan8102
    @jarlynjordan8102 4 месяца назад +6

    Carrying class of 2024

  • @gabbywilson4681
    @gabbywilson4681 4 месяца назад +9

    Still carrying the class of 2026

  • @tianjunli1653
    @tianjunli1653 2 года назад +7

    Reserved for later. I missed my lecture on Brutus (I didn't physically miss it, but I did the wrong reading so I felt not emerged into class). Gotta check out later, thank you for uploading.

  • @slashprime47
    @slashprime47 3 года назад +5

    Great vid as always

  • @Μιαβ
    @Μιαβ Год назад +9

    14 more hours YALL 😍

  • @scrolly9038
    @scrolly9038 Год назад +11

    Taking the Ap gov test in an hour wish me luck 😭

  • @user-jb7pe7wf1z
    @user-jb7pe7wf1z 5 месяцев назад +8

    brutus: is it better keep the articles or adopt constitution?
    - articles of confederation is better
    - concerns about the supremacy clause and necessary and proper clause: if federal law>states, then states will have no power; if congress can carry out any action necessary and proper for an expressed power, it will be too powerful
    - concerns about taxes: how will the states tax if the federal govt already taxes? people will be unwilling to pay too much
    - large republic will not work because it can’t represent ALL of the people and it will be very slow and disfunctional

  • @vivsagworld246
    @vivsagworld246 Год назад +10

    i have a test tomorrow with an argumentative essay and im stressing

  • @cheekylix
    @cheekylix 3 года назад +12

    Yes, but Brutus (another one, more likely the one that the founders thought of), like Publius ("author" of the Fed Papers), is one of the founders of the Roman Republic.

    • @josephtwomey8566
      @josephtwomey8566 3 года назад

      CHECK OUT THE DAVID PAINTING ON
      BRUTUS

    • @cheekylix
      @cheekylix 3 года назад

      @@josephtwomey8566 Precisely

  • @FollowerofDuck
    @FollowerofDuck Год назад +7

    watching this for my midterm in three days 🕺

  • @kylagranville5449
    @kylagranville5449 4 месяца назад +4

    ap gov 2024 how we feelinggg (heimler i got a 4 on apush because of you i'm forever loyal)

  • @zacharybowers3
    @zacharybowers3 11 месяцев назад +4

    I named my first dog Brutus for this reason.

    • @BrandonBDN
      @BrandonBDN 11 месяцев назад

      Ah, so the average IQ of anti federalists has increased!

  • @vxarson4749
    @vxarson4749 2 года назад +4

    This guy is so clutch

  • @3111windyhollow
    @3111windyhollow 10 месяцев назад +2

    "The individual, unlike the corporation,
    cannot be taxed for the mere privilege of
    existing. The corporation is an artificial
    entity which owes its existence and charter
    powers to the state; but the individuals
    rights to live and own property are natural
    rights for the enjoyment of which an excise
    cannot be imposed." Redfield v. Fisher, 292 P
    813, 135 Or. 180, 294 P.461,73 A.L.R. 721
    (1931)

    • @nikey2110
      @nikey2110 4 месяца назад +1

      Now it’s the other way around. Corporations are taxed less than people.

  • @munintheraven8812
    @munintheraven8812 4 месяца назад +2

    Imma get my brain cow milked

  • @mariekuelbs7278
    @mariekuelbs7278 2 года назад +2

    Thank you so much!

  • @anishpaladugu7001
    @anishpaladugu7001 2 года назад +33

    Who else is cramming 3 days before the test?

    • @beavercontrol1743
      @beavercontrol1743 2 года назад +23

      bro like 1 day before lmao

    • @elenav.5470
      @elenav.5470 2 года назад +13

      more like 11 hours before 😍

    • @flare1216
      @flare1216 2 года назад +4

      @@elenav.5470 SAME LOL

    • @chrisc6989
      @chrisc6989 2 года назад +7

      I'm cramming 10 hours before lol

    • @okboomer6884
      @okboomer6884 2 года назад +1

      7 hours before

  • @kepp81
    @kepp81 9 месяцев назад +2

    Pretty wild how accurate the anti-federalists were in their concerns. Imho, what we have today is everything they warned against

  • @zaz4821
    @zaz4821 4 месяца назад +3

    My test is in four hours 💀

  • @michellem3548
    @michellem3548 2 года назад +10

    last minute studying 😛

  • @nathanhightower595
    @nathanhightower595 2 года назад +2

    thanks big man

  • @jimh3500
    @jimh3500 9 месяцев назад +1

    Imagine having newspapers with this quality of OpEd and that people would read and discuss them.

  • @randomkid874
    @randomkid874 4 месяца назад +1

    Thanks bro

  • @chrismitchell523
    @chrismitchell523 2 года назад +13

    and by 1916, Brutus was shown to be correct.

    • @aryzen2781
      @aryzen2781 2 года назад +1

      how so?

    • @RichPileofleaves
      @RichPileofleaves 10 месяцев назад +1

      @@aryzen2781 fed income tax, Sixteenth Amendment

  • @Josh-ij3xh
    @Josh-ij3xh 3 года назад +6

    Very based

  • @MrMan.64
    @MrMan.64 2 года назад +3

    i still dont get it

  • @killwzve6876
    @killwzve6876 Год назад

    u finna carry me all junior year 😭😭

  • @imperatorcaesardivifiliusa2158
    @imperatorcaesardivifiliusa2158 3 года назад +5

    Wasn’t Brutus named after Lucius Brutus, the founder of the Roman Republic?

    • @mujtab8siddiqu1
      @mujtab8siddiqu1 3 года назад +3

      The Brutus who killed Caesar is the descendant of and named after the Brutus you described.

  • @amybarnard6319
    @amybarnard6319 3 года назад

    love you king

  • @pieceaisa5046
    @pieceaisa5046 Год назад

    i took us gov over comp gov just for u

  • @user-vp2nx2is5z
    @user-vp2nx2is5z 2 года назад +1

    I wish I could subscribe twice

  • @Otamatone69
    @Otamatone69 6 месяцев назад

    My brain cows are so milked right now

  • @supersam1914
    @supersam1914 2 года назад +8

    Anti Feds looking real good right now lol

  • @bradyg2004
    @bradyg2004 Год назад

    thanks bro :)

  • @니모-b6w
    @니모-b6w 19 дней назад

    Anderson Michelle Jackson Anthony Gonzalez Margaret

  • @roseesegateret1013
    @roseesegateret1013 5 дней назад

    Gonzalez Barbara Anderson Dorothy Jones Richard

  • @shinedownracing425
    @shinedownracing425 Год назад

    5 days away…..

  • @alexreactzz8592
    @alexreactzz8592 Год назад

    the guy from fortnite?

  • @shreetanvuppu194
    @shreetanvuppu194 3 года назад +1

    Fourth

  • @crispyein8601
    @crispyein8601 2 года назад

    Sixty forth

  • @thebcwonder4850
    @thebcwonder4850 4 месяца назад +1

    Brutus was right

  • @evelinmendez2795
    @evelinmendez2795 Год назад +5

    Good luck to everyone who’s takin the AP GOV test this month 🫡