This was without a doubt one of his best performances. What I admired most about Elliot Yamin and what made him in a class all by himself was the degree of complexity in the songs he chose. His vocals were always impeccable but the songs he chose like Melinda Doolittle were always tougher than those chosen by the other contestants.
Beautiful Person inside and.Out! Loved.his Mother.!!!!. Very Emotional journey! He sang.two.Elvis.Presley Song's blew.them Away!! Should have.won.Idol! Seasons with Kelly!.Rubin/and Clay! Fantasia! !Elliott.Yamin! !And Melinda Doolittle! We're the.best idol.years to me!.Talent.Overload! This is my Opinion!! Beautiful and Talented young people!
You heard Tommy Mottola...raspy and rough & tumble. See,this is why Elliott does it for me. He sings like a man oughta. He can tear the lid off a rowdy-ass number like this then turn around a break your heart with a soul searing ballad. So many of the greatest singers have this special quality.
Still to this day I have not heard a singer that makes me feel the way he does when he sings... he just does for me... I’m still hooked like I was when I first heard Big Momma Thornton
I'm sure many won't agree with me, but I think Elliot Yamin is the greatest contestant ever! He was robbed of the AI title. I really am shocked and amazed that America let him down in the end. I voted so many times for him, and ever since this show I've always thought Katherine or Taylor could shine his shoes. Certainly, I think in the end America really let him down. Why didn't you vote for him, America? Why?????
Make your music like this Elliot!! Yes love songs are great and you are superb at singing them, but you need your hit to be a song that can make people feel upbeat and dance to it. Awesome performance!
Not so much as stage presence, but more importantly, he has, hands down, better vocals than Taylor and McPhee. Without votefortheworst website, Taylor might not have been in the finals, or indeed the even top 5.
Omg that was SOOOO awkward when stupid ryna seacrest made that incredibly sexist and offensive remark towards paula! 😳 kudos for both randy and simon calling him out hard core! esp since theres always some weird dynamic between simon and paula maybe cause she was always loopy while on the show. ~ And what a lame ass for trying to defend himself and shut simon down. so fucked up. Kudos to them though.
i think carroe nailed this one, but he also did a good job, but carrie's version of this song is one of the best performance ever that happened on the idol stage...
This was without a doubt one of his best performances. What I admired most about Elliot Yamin and what made him in a class all by himself was the degree of complexity in the songs he chose. His vocals were always impeccable but the songs he chose like Melinda Doolittle were always tougher than those chosen by the other contestants.
Beautiful Person inside and.Out! Loved.his Mother.!!!!. Very Emotional journey!
He sang.two.Elvis.Presley Song's blew.them Away!! Should have.won.Idol!
Seasons with Kelly!.Rubin/and Clay! Fantasia! !Elliott.Yamin! !And Melinda
Doolittle! We're the.best idol.years to me!.Talent.Overload! This is my Opinion!!
Beautiful and Talented young people!
You heard Tommy Mottola...raspy and rough & tumble. See,this is why Elliott does it for me. He sings like a man oughta. He can tear the lid off a rowdy-ass number like this then turn around a break your heart with a soul searing ballad. So many of the greatest singers have this special quality.
I had so much hope he'd make final 2 after this. He should have won this season. Biggest injustice ever on Idol.
this performance still gives me goosebumps!! It still is kinda mind boggling where he suddenly pulled out all that (insanely attractive) attitude!
by far hes my fav idol. Amazing voice.
Elliott makes magic , just like Elvis did. Not many have that gift of electric vibe, and Elliott got his portion of it.
Still to this day I have not heard a singer that makes me feel the way he does when he sings... he just does for me... I’m still hooked like I was when I first heard Big Momma Thornton
Best. Contestant. Ever.
Better than Fantasia? Stop it✋ get some help.
I think he is the best male vocal in AI.He has an absolutely brilliant voice. He should have won season 5.i think he did wrong song choices on top 3.
+이이미란 He didn't pick 2 of the songs for top 3. Clive and Paula are the ones that screwed him over.
@@Jojo-bk2pq i know that.paula doesn't have musical sense.He should have met Simon as his song picker.
@@versavice5293 He didn't get to choose who picked his song. lol
I had never been so obsessed with a persons well being... but Elliott was worth it!
The Good ol days of american Idol
i think he should have won too. He was one of the best kept secrets.
Never watched American Idol again after he got kicked off.
Me either!!! I cried real tears!
blues rock rendition pulled it off!
I'm sure many won't agree with me, but I think Elliot Yamin is the greatest contestant ever! He was robbed of the AI title. I really am shocked and amazed that America let him down in the end. I voted so many times for him, and ever since this show I've always thought Katherine or Taylor could shine his shoes. Certainly, I think in the end America really let him down. Why didn't you vote for him, America? Why?????
Make your music like this Elliot!! Yes love songs are great and you are superb at singing them, but you need your hit to be a song that can make people feel upbeat and dance to it.
Awesome performance!
luv him so much! he rocks and should have won
his best performance
This was soo good , Oh the memories !
lord have mercy..the yamin machine..
I really like Elliot and really loved his rendition of this song. Felt bad when he got voted off. He seems like a real nice guy too.
Nailed it!
I cant help the fact that he is the love child of Billion's Bob Axelroad and Derek Zoolander... google it... ill wait
AWESOME
That voice!
Explosive.
I like this version better than Carrie's
he so should of won. why why why
That was so fun!
Aw i really liked elliott, but really like carrie underwood too. She's an awesome vocalist!
Not so much as stage presence, but more importantly, he has, hands down, better vocals than Taylor and McPhee. Without votefortheworst website, Taylor might not have been in the finals, or indeed the even top 5.
Omg that was SOOOO awkward when stupid ryna seacrest made that incredibly sexist and offensive remark towards paula! 😳 kudos for both randy and simon calling him out hard core! esp since theres always some weird dynamic between simon and paula maybe cause she was always loopy while on the show. ~ And what a lame ass for trying to defend himself and shut simon down. so fucked up. Kudos to them though.
i think paula and simon were flirting as usual but it was a joke between them but then ryan made the awful comment
Well, it's a really simple explanation...the producers select the "winner" of the show.
I could never figure out why elliot didn't go farther with his professional career.
KILLLLER band
i think carroe nailed this one, but he also did a good job, but carrie's version of this song is one of the best performance ever that happened on the idol stage...
Give Paula a dollar
and then seacrest called paula a stripper...
if this comment was made today it would bring a lot of controversy... back then it was "funny" and paula had to deal with it
TROUBLE is the wrong song with poor arrangements! Great talent going nowhere! He's really a jazz singer - if only he would realize it!