im not sure but i think they were not expecting their mics to be so loud and the back track so low. This is preatty much acapella o.o they are amazing!
Crying while watching this, every second of that era comes to my mind right away and I miss myself at that time so much.. the young me, and the happiest me🩷 thank you Apink for being with me all this time, from those times until now🩷🩷🩷🫶🏻🫶🏻🫶🏻
From girls to confident women. You can see they are so assured and secure, not worrying about a missed tone, or a wrong step. The "so what if I made a mistake" vibe is what makes Apink so....relatable.
As a GFriend fan, I'm quite jealous. Apink is the better version of GFriend. The concepts, growth of concepts, agency, fandom, career stability and career journey 👍
This should be the standard for the new generation Kpop girl groups. Though some groups are good at live singing but their vocal skills are no where near these 2nd and 3rd gen legends when they were still at the debut/rookie eras.
@@Lululemon-d3h if you are a 2nd and 3rd gen era stan you would have already known, how important for an idol to be a strong vocalist at the time. People were so engaged with singing competitions and vocal battles. Unlike now there used to be numerous vocal battle shows back then. So that’s how important it was during that time. Though people are still talking about the importance of vocal skills but it leans more towards how stable they can sing live than their vocal abilities and skills. And 3rd gen was the last era we had many good vocalists with actual skills. 4th and 5th gen are nowhere near the same level as them during their debut days. 1st Gen was not completely Kpop it was just a beginning. Kpop took shape after years of evolving during 2nd gen undergone so many changes and modernisation. 3rd gen was the most stable era for Kpop with balanced talents in all aspects. 4th gen took a slight downfall and 5th gen hit the bottom hard (still there’s hope for 5th gen as there are still more years). 1st Gen vocal skills are powerful but still the quality of their singing are more influenced by Korean trot singing very different from the pop singing style adopted by 2nd gen. Since the standards changed they might sound very old fashioned many don’t like it unless they release the appropriate music to this modern world, but 2nd gen still might survive with their pop style singing.
@@Lululemon-d3h also be polite to others, don’t judge people like you do. What do you mean by low comprehension skills? Are you a highly educated scholar or what? “Not all” is not applicable since the people who can’t sing or rap in the 3rd gen left the music industry long long ago”. So the 3rd gen idols still standing strong on the stage are highly skilled and well experienced artists. Name atleast five active groups that have poorly skilled main vocal members, can you?
Seeing 2 Panda bong waving, First time not hearing the crowd sing the last line of Mr. Chu, and them singing their own fan chants after that at least 2 fans shouted. I've never hated a crowd so bad.
Sweet song and talented girls. They're singing voices are incredible and the teamwork is amazing. The energy's insane and the girls love for eachother, music and performing truly shows. Love the positive energy and they're livesinging is absoulutly perfect. Love these girls so much❤❤
![[열린예술무대 뒤란] 에이핑크(Apink) - Mr. Chu | ubc 241025 방송](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/bkqwKyz5FWU/mqdefault.jpg)
k-pop idol should sing live like this!!!
FR 2000 kpop idols sings live. Modern kpop don't sing too much live now.
This is so refreshing to hear live vocals 🥰 Apink jjang
im not sure but i think they were not expecting their mics to be so loud and the back track so low. This is preatty much acapella o.o they are amazing!
Her don't have in ear monitor
Crying while watching this, every second of that era comes to my mind right away and I miss myself at that time so much.. the young me, and the happiest me🩷 thank you Apink for being with me all this time, from those times until now🩷🩷🩷🫶🏻🫶🏻🫶🏻
I can feel you. Because I'm crying too
This is what we call sing . They make their song alive since 2014 until now
its so nice to see that they are still performing together after all these years
From girls to confident women. You can see they are so assured and secure, not worrying about a missed tone, or a wrong step. The "so what if I made a mistake" vibe is what makes Apink so....relatable.
This is a live performance so perfect❤❤❤
오랜만에 5명이서 무대하네ㅜㅠ
10년전 군대에서 많이 듣던 미스터츄ㅠㅠㅜㅜ
그리고 노래소리는 엄청작고 마이크는 엄청 커서 완전 생라이브네ㅋㅋ
woaaaah chorooong live so well
진짜최고!!!!
우와 ㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋ 츄 오랜만에 듣는다 최고!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
에이핑크 언니들이 너무 많이 귀엽고 좋아해요 🩷
Wow this is like the most live live idol dance performance 😮
I love it this performance live Queen APINK Mr Chu,l luv my Apink
Apink so stable 😭 new gen could never
Stream Mr.Chu it's already 98M we need 2M for 100M before this year ends❤😊
That’s why I stan Apink.
It’s good to hear live vocals. 💞
라이브 최고잖아...🫢🫡
음향상태도 별로고 보미 목컨디션도 안좋아 보이는데 라이브 정말 잘 하네요.
They are good at singing live
Omg so stable their live❤
Apink, we need everyday!
This is bringing me back to my college days ❤ always happy to see them together
They are all pretty ladies. ❤❤❤❤ their voices never make fans disappointed
We miss you all !! ❤❤❤
벌써 그리워요
会いたいよー！！
은지언니ㅠㅠㅠ❤❤
One of my favourite songs ever. So happy to see this! ❤
WE MISS YOU, APINK!
I am sssoooo happppppy to see them together ❤🎉🎉🎉
이정도면 걍 mr제거 수준 아니냐고ㅋㅋ 이렇게 팀으로 활동 오래 자주 해주는 2세대 아이돌 참 귀하다😢
Wow APINK!!!
OH MY CHU APINK 🩷✨
와 에이핑크 설레 ❤
사랑해 apink
They soo prettyyy
Yoon Bomi still so beautiful
EUNJI IS SO STABLE ATEEE
Vocal Queens❤
Thank you
어머나ㅏㅏㅏㅏㅏㅏㅏㅏ 😭🥺😭
Apink❤❤❤❤
APINK!!!!!!!!!
Hayoung's voice is so sweet
mr로 라이브하네 ㄷㄷㄷㄷ
普美 又爱了❤
It feels like it was yesterday the mr chu meme 😂 now I just realised it has been 10 years ago 👏👏👏
I’m so happy to see them ❤❤ I really miss Apinkkkkkkk💗💗
Eunji ❤
Legend 😮❤
We miss you, our Apink ❤
As a GFriend fan, I'm quite jealous. Apink is the better version of GFriend. The concepts, growth of concepts, agency, fandom, career stability and career journey 👍
คิดถึงมากๆ❤
i miss apinkkkkkkkk aaaahhhhhhhhhhh
Wow the mics 😮🤯
Apink sempre divas ❤
Comebackk pleasee
I really love older kpop groups like Apink ❤ Amazing songs, amazing skills and interacts very well with audience ❤
❤️🐼❤️ Love you Apink Forever ❤️🐼❤️
Pink pandaaaaaaaaa ❤
OMG!
This should be the standard for the new generation Kpop girl groups. Though some groups are good at live singing but their vocal skills are no where near these 2nd and 3rd gen legends when they were still at the debut/rookie eras.
Not all 3rd gen groups can sing live. 1st & 2nd gen should be standard of idol performance.
@Lululemon Yeah right GFRIEND, REDVELVET, MAMAMOO, WJSN, OH MY GIRL, AILEE, CLC, EXID, LOVELYZ,… all are bad vocalists. Exactly you are so right.
@@AP-fi2di I said NOT ALL. Do you understood it, or you have a low reading comprehension? It seems that you didn't know the meaning of NOT ALL.
@@Lululemon-d3h if you are a 2nd and 3rd gen era stan you would have already known, how important for an idol to be a strong vocalist at the time. People were so engaged with singing competitions and vocal battles. Unlike now there used to be numerous vocal battle shows back then. So that’s how important it was during that time. Though people are still talking about the importance of vocal skills but it leans more towards how stable they can sing live than their vocal abilities and skills. And 3rd gen was the last era we had many good vocalists with actual skills. 4th and 5th gen are nowhere near the same level as them during their debut days. 1st Gen was not completely Kpop it was just a beginning. Kpop took shape after years of evolving during 2nd gen undergone so many changes and modernisation. 3rd gen was the most stable era for Kpop with balanced talents in all aspects. 4th gen took a slight downfall and 5th gen hit the bottom hard (still there’s hope for 5th gen as there are still more years). 1st Gen vocal skills are powerful but still the quality of their singing are more influenced by Korean trot singing very different from the pop singing style adopted by 2nd gen. Since the standards changed they might sound very old fashioned many don’t like it unless they release the appropriate music to this modern world, but 2nd gen still might survive with their pop style singing.
@@Lululemon-d3h also be polite to others, don’t judge people like you do. What do you mean by low comprehension skills? Are you a highly educated scholar or what? “Not all” is not applicable since the people who can’t sing or rap in the 3rd gen left the music industry long long ago”. So the 3rd gen idols still standing strong on the stage are highly skilled and well experienced artists. Name atleast five active groups that have poorly skilled main vocal members, can you?
Apink ❤🇸🇦 المملكة العربية السعودية
Park cho rong always preetty and agelesss
yay! 1st!
Waw ❤❤❤
Nice
❤❤❤❤❤❤❤
음향 무슨일이야 코첼라도 이정도는 아닐듯 기진 라이브 확인사살ㅋㅋ
Missナイト & Missデイ
😘😘😘😘🥰😍
😊😊❤❤🎉🎉
1st 2nd and 3rd generations of idols are the best of all!!
hayoung stable ❤
이래서 에이핑크 에이핑크 하나 봅니다ㅠㅠㅠㅠ
Seeing 2 Panda bong waving, First time not hearing the crowd sing the last line of Mr. Chu, and them singing their own fan chants after that at least 2 fans shouted. I've never hated a crowd so bad.
😍😭😭
❤❤❤🇵🇭
jung eun ji🎉
I can't believe it's been so long since this song was released.
🐼❤
While the video appears to have been edited in a rush, the vocals prove the worth of APink!
Sweet song and talented girls. They're singing voices are incredible and the teamwork is amazing. The energy's insane and the girls love for eachother, music and performing truly shows. Love the positive energy and they're livesinging is absoulutly perfect. Love these girls so much❤❤
이젠 다들 풋풋함은 없지만 러블리한건 여전하네
ㅇㅇ 서서히 이모 이미지로 변하고 있지. ㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋ
@@차승현이돌아왔다 이렇게 예쁜 이모 본 적있냐 아직도 막내가 20대인 그룹에 이모 드립ㅋㅋ 딴 데가서 찾으이소~
@@차승현이돌아왔다 님은 점점 아저씨로 가고 있을 것 같은데요?
@@차승현이돌아왔다악플 다실 때마다 고소 당하는 거 조심하세요 댓글기록보니까 가관이네요
@@zzkiki조심할 필요 없을듯요 어짜피 고소당할 운명인데요 뭐
🩷🩷🩷🩷🩷
Eunji😂
ar없는 완전 생라이브네 요즘 이런 라이브 듣기힘든데
These are the skills, confidence, and stability of a 13 year girl group 🥰
Waiting apink comeback in 2025😅😅😅
apink legend ❤
윤봄 이 최고
보미랑 은지 마이크 음량이 왜 이렇게 크냐?
Apink is soooo talented ✨️ 💖 Love Apink Forever 💖 Proud USA Panda 🐼 💖
idol new generation doesnt have good vocal to sing live like this
와 쌩라이브를 해버려뿌노 ㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋ지금 걸그룹들은 후보정아니면 아무도 못할껀데
라이브 와 동시 녹화 가 삐끗 삐끗 삐끗 인가모ㅡ?
😢😢😢😢😢😢
원저케이 가 웬일로 소리가 작나요오?🗣🗣🗣🗣🗣🗣🗣🗣😡😡😡😡😡😡😡😡😡😡
Is this a new performance?
it is obvious there is no naeun
@@naadjii5352 That is true.
mothers
이런가수들 모셔두고 MR나오는게 왜이러냐