Something from Nothing by Richard Dawkins

Поделиться
HTML-код
  • Опубликовано: 8 сен 2024
  • In this thought-provoking video, we delve into the profound question that has puzzled humanity for millennia: How did something arise from nothing? Renowned biologist Richard Dawkins, alongside esteemed physicist Lawrence Krauss, embark on a captivating exploration of the universe's origins.
    Dawkins' sharp wit and incisive commentary blend seamlessly with Krauss's expertise in cosmology as they unravel complex scientific theories into understandable concepts. From the Big Bang to quantum mechanics, the duo navigates through the frontiers of human knowledge, challenging our preconceived notions about existence.
    "Something from Nothing" isn't just a scientific discourse; it's a philosophical journey that invites viewers to question the very nature of reality. Dawkins and Krauss masterfully bridge the gap between science and spirituality, offering a compelling perspective on the interplay between faith and reason.
    Whether you're a seasoned science enthusiast or simply curious about the cosmos, this video promises to ignite your imagination and expand your understanding of the universe. Join us as we explore the mind-bending possibilities of a universe that emerged from nothingness.
    #SomethingFromNothing #RichardDawkins #LawrenceKrauss #Cosmology #Physics #Science #Atheism #Philosophy #BigBang #QuantumMechanics #Universe
    Join this channel to get access to perks:
    / @logicity00
    If you like what I do, Buy Me A Coffee!
    buymeacoffee.com/logicity
    Follow Logicity on Instagram :
    logicity.info
    Interested in Astrology? Know whats going to happen in your life in the coming month : 89eafbx5kypmdb...

Комментарии • 445

  • @juliandunn8412
    @juliandunn8412 16 дней назад +9

    In my opinion, even if you don't believe in God, something from nothing is an absured proposition.

    • @patriciadechamps3169
      @patriciadechamps3169 13 дней назад +4

      @juliandunn8412 This is NOT what they're actually saying.
      "Extreme simplicity evolved into more and more complexity".
      The so-called Big Bang marks the limits of the observable Universe. What was before that, nobody knows (and maybe ever will).
      "Nothing is created, nothing is lost, everything is transformed" (basic law of chemistry).

    • @DocReasonable
      @DocReasonable 6 дней назад +3

      You believe life was created FROM NOTHING by a magical god.

    • @captainnemo9742
      @captainnemo9742 6 дней назад

      Such as God.

    • @oneoflokis
      @oneoflokis 3 дня назад

      Why is there something, rather than nothing?? 🙂

    • @Korosensei5891
      @Korosensei5891 3 дня назад

      Maybe it's not absurd . How are you so sure your mind can process complicated matters like this ? It is proven that we see the world in a view which is best suited for our survival so you can't really say it's absurd

  • @coachbrendan
    @coachbrendan Месяц назад +20

    WELL DONE for reposting a super informative discussion between Lawrence Kraus and Richard Dawkins. Huge Thanks for not including background music .

    • @logicity00
      @logicity00  Месяц назад +2

      Glad you enjoyed it!

    • @jmp01a24
      @jmp01a24 28 дней назад +1

      Well we got to hear that Aliens are 100% sure to exist. That's a good start.

  • @281992pdr
    @281992pdr 2 дня назад +2

    I am a man and I will walk out of any medical or health provider if I am asked - as NHS staff have to do with everyone between the ages of 14 and 55 - "Are you pregnant?"

  • @MyDunu
    @MyDunu Месяц назад +8

    Nothing means" not a thing as we know"😊

  • @markfromct2
    @markfromct2 Месяц назад +10

    Great discussion. Agreed with comments about being thankful for no background music

  • @FrederickTheGrt
    @FrederickTheGrt Месяц назад +20

    Getting something for nothing and chickens for free. Such dire straits to be in.

    • @FeminineHandMasculineHand
      @FeminineHandMasculineHand Месяц назад

      Fuck you! The answer is 12. For it is less than the devil's (oven) dozen. Solved much!?

    • @ankyspon1701
      @ankyspon1701 Месяц назад

      That's the walk of life, these brothers in arms are getting money for nothing (Kraus is a theoretical physicist so is paid to day dream 24/7) and they're both making it up as they go along.
      They're so far away, from the truth, and for his latest trick Dawkins wants a self replicating molecule!
      Why worry, they'll never find it...
      They're both wasting their lives and being unable to prove their scientific claims, they're attacking theology, how sad...

    • @tomgreene1843
      @tomgreene1843 12 дней назад

      Yes a load of post modern new toys!

    • @TheMargarita1948
      @TheMargarita1948 6 дней назад

      @@FrederickTheGrt That’s the way to do it.

  • @apparentbeing
    @apparentbeing Месяц назад +10

    "You can never truly have nothing but you can believe you have nothing."
    Particles come and go from "nothing" and that proves that there is something rather than nothing.

    • @tommyheron464
      @tommyheron464 Месяц назад +2

      The fact that you are able to ask a question or that there is even a you to begin with should be more of a hint for you.

    • @westy-fo1ek
      @westy-fo1ek Месяц назад

      ​@@tommyheron464can u collaborate on that? Cheers ✌️

    • @newtonbelieved
      @newtonbelieved Месяц назад

      Dawkins will always be remembered as the naive Aries who threw God out with the orthodox religion bathwater. Naive not because his intentions were sincere, yet ineffective, but naive because he thought he could change the simple fact that people believe what they want to believe. He should rather have spent his life trying to get the different faiths to accept each other. If you look at Google Trends for the search word 'God', you will see that it has steadily risen since 2004. In other words, Dawkins, the naive Aries, has changed nothing. Sad but true, nothing has come from his everything.

    • @tommyheron464
      @tommyheron464 19 дней назад

      @@westy-fo1ek asking a question is something. The brain that pondered that question is something. The lips or fingers that spelled out the question are things.
      Therefore something must be asking the question therefore of course something exists.

    • @westy-fo1ek
      @westy-fo1ek 18 дней назад

      @@tommyheron464 yep that kinda makes sense I'm getting there..there is alot going on from when you first think of an idea,say,from processing it, reacting to it,or not,it goes deeper and deeper,but errrm,I'm starting to come to the thinking of the universe itself is conscious,and it's learning from us,or flip it the other way,we are all creating the universe,that make sense!! What's your thoughts on are we still evolving,and and have we started to realise that we have involved as we speak,right now,the here and now, either we will master telepathy or something of that ilk! Interesting times for sure! Regarding reaching and inhabiting other planets,multi planetary species Mr elok musk speaks off, be it space x, NASA, whoever,we are at least,as members of 'society' the general public,are at least 5 if not 10 years behind to what the technology in reality,or whether we have colonized mars or not,we know nothing really,but we are getting there,in a way.. anywaze hehe,, I'll leave that with you to pondor for a bit! I think u know your shit and look forward to your thoughts and knowledge on my queries..🤗✌️🇬🇧👍

  • @Crazy-inventor
    @Crazy-inventor 17 дней назад +2

    I’m really bothered on how people nowadays became brainless. It sounds true on how they talk it’s actually convincing specially if some of the listeners are ignorant about science and religion. The way they talk , it seems like they really know what they’re talking about, when in fact they’re just talking out of thin air.

  • @darialaskowska
    @darialaskowska Месяц назад +5

    Just like stars are born then life starts. Seems like life in certain conditions, not necessarily same as on Earth, is inevitable part of the living cosmos process. Life is meant to happen, to evolve.

    • @briansmith3791
      @briansmith3791 23 дня назад

      The universe is set-up for Life. "Our conclusion is that the fundamental properties of the universe appear to be fine-tuned for Life" - Physicists Geraint Lewis and Luke Barnes. ( A Fortunate Universe).

  • @hyperhybrid7230
    @hyperhybrid7230 20 дней назад +1

    Approx 08:30 Origin of life unexplained, if we can not explain it on a single habital planet earth, then this sequence occurs many times, hence lifeforms, aliens, civilizations are abundant in our Observable Universe. The pattern sequence of life.

  • @zacsamuel7295
    @zacsamuel7295 Месяц назад +2

    The theory of everything seems hauntingly there? Interesting talk.
    IMO we may not have the brain power in evolutionary time to even get there.
    Happy to be able to kind of sense what this discussion is about.
    You go RD and LK, more power to deeper understanding

    • @zacsamuel7295
      @zacsamuel7295 Месяц назад

      On a side note, if there is nothing that creates something then even 10 trillion years from now when what we see as the beginning will be nothing...that creates something. On and On and On!

  • @dianahill5116
    @dianahill5116 27 дней назад +4

    Science: 1.4 billion years ago, the Earth had 18 hour days.
    **Could it be said: 5 billion years ago, the Earth had 4 hour days?

    • @herbcachia
      @herbcachia 23 дня назад

      A very good question! I would like to know the answer to that.

    • @CliffSedge-nu5fv
      @CliffSedge-nu5fv 22 дня назад

      4.5 billion years ago, the days were 8 hours long.

  • @PossumKing94
    @PossumKing94 Месяц назад +5

    anyone else listening to this while high?

  • @Kazbek-oo3yx
    @Kazbek-oo3yx Месяц назад +2

    Very very in real good times. Thanks for speaking out

  • @Otto-mq8lg
    @Otto-mq8lg 21 день назад +3

    I really hate when the words "almost nothing" are used in the same sentence to describe something..

  • @tomasp2899
    @tomasp2899 Месяц назад +3

    Brilliant debate.

  • @user-hu1ii6os6q
    @user-hu1ii6os6q 13 дней назад +1

    So life is pointless then? No meaning. No point. And ultimately going back to nothing.

  • @stevenotte3447
    @stevenotte3447 Месяц назад +4

    Dire Straits, he says, though, as random mutation has always led out from, children need exposure to the esoteric. These two men have allowed exposure to questions, so needed for life, on this planet that young and fresh minds are really awaiting to resolve when truthfully and reasonably shown without mythical and fictional distractions !

  • @matthewbrownlie4577
    @matthewbrownlie4577 Месяц назад +9

    Not believable. It is interesting to ponder...however no one knows. Nothing in and of itself remains nothing. Almost nothing is something.

  • @jayvincent1865
    @jayvincent1865 Месяц назад +5

    Why is this so chopped up? 1:07:31

  • @robertmcclintock8701
    @robertmcclintock8701 Месяц назад +2

    (..) This is an artistic proof of a created universe. When you paint a shadow it's the opposite color of the object that made the shadow. Nobody knew what the opposite color of white was so the artists avoided painting white on white. The opposite color of white is baby blue and baby pink. The first artist to figure it out was Norman Rockwell. I was the second artist to figure it out. I saw it in the corner of a white room. The lighting was perfect to see it

    • @wheresthecomedyspiritualit7113
      @wheresthecomedyspiritualit7113 22 дня назад +1

      Are you a little mental? You should know as a artist colours do not actually exist, they are chemical, chemicals hit our eyes and our eyes perceive it as a colour tone. Black isn't actually classed as a colour at all and how is it the opposite of white wouldn't the opposite be transparency?

    • @robertmcclintock8701
      @robertmcclintock8701 22 дня назад

      @wheresthecomedyspiritualit7113 pigments have their own rules that not like light. You can't make a shadow by adding black. It usually makes a muddy color.

  • @a.gwhiteley1855
    @a.gwhiteley1855 Месяц назад +1

    The problem here is that "nothing" is a very slippery word which can be used in different ways. It can mean: a) empty space, as in "there's nothing in the room"; b) the scientific sense of the quantum vacuum, a state of seething potential subject to random fluctuations; c) the philosophical sense: non-existence, non-being. Dawkins and Krauss are using "nothing" in sense b), emphatically not sense c). In other words, in this fascinating discussion, we must not imagine they are answering, or attempting to answer, the age-old question: why is there something rather than nothing? However we conceive of the quantum state from which the universe may have sprung, it is certainly not non-existent, otherwise the universe could not have sprung from it. This is not a universe from nothing.

  • @jillbarrett2576
    @jillbarrett2576 9 дней назад +1

    A bad design is having air and food intake down the same pipe. An intelligent being would not make such a potentially fatal mistake.

    • @briansmith3791
      @briansmith3791 7 дней назад

      We are a result of a free-running process, evolution by natural selection, within what appears to be a universe fine-tuned for Life.

  • @jayvincent1865
    @jayvincent1865 Месяц назад +7

    23:19 Just look up
    Day or night. Proof that religion is invented. Mainly to try to influence and control the majority of people. The people who choose not to think or question. The "Lazy and Ignorant" , Vastly outnumber the ambitious inquisitive.

    • @canoeman1961
      @canoeman1961 3 дня назад

      Another thing to observe is that the higher you go on the IQ scale, the more evolution is assumed to be the only option. As you wander the other direction on the IQ scale, the less evolution is an option. Of course small groups within those samples would believe the opposite (after all, it is a bell curve), but by far the majority would follow that trend.

  • @ronaldbailey3350
    @ronaldbailey3350 Месяц назад +1

    If you can encourage someone to do something you would not do or sell something you would not or can not buy it stands to reason you can teach something you do not believe for survival .

  • @bryceeh2080
    @bryceeh2080 6 дней назад +1

    It takes more faith to NOT BELIEVE in a Creator/Designer than the alternative proposition. Information within DNA definitely didn't originate from nothing. A super intelligent Designer/Programmer put it all together. Well done to the Creator.
    He (Christ) is the Image of the Invisible God, the firstborn of all creation. For by Him all things were created, in heaven and on earth, visible and invisible, whether thrones or dominions or rulers or authorities-all things were created through Him and for Him. And He is before all things, and in Him all things hold together. (Colossians 1:15-17)

  • @user-us5pp7tg6i
    @user-us5pp7tg6i 22 дня назад

    The thing about this is that, in order to make, you need a maker, and that maker must start or let us say starts with a simpler thing and so on, but that will reach to say, there was never nothing

  • @omrak2000
    @omrak2000 18 часов назад +2

    God of Gaps 🫴🏻

  • @keithmartin6815
    @keithmartin6815 Месяц назад +5

    Except the complex motors inside the very cell are irreducible. (Meaning they needed to be compleat otherwise wouldn't function) And.. the organs inside life have different DNA (meaning separate organs can't function without a body but replicating cells don't become organs ever) and Except 100s of billions of year is not the same a 5 distinct fossil records (meaning the sudden emerging of new life 5 times has a different timescale them 100s of billions of years) except

    • @jamiekeller3109
      @jamiekeller3109 Месяц назад

      It's spelled 'complete'

    • @CapelAdventurer
      @CapelAdventurer Месяц назад

      Learn to put forward a coherent point. Grammatical structure and syntax will need to be worked on for you to get your point across..

    • @tommyheron464
      @tommyheron464 Месяц назад

      By that logic an archway would be an impossibility.

    • @itscali619
      @itscali619 Месяц назад

      They aren’t irreducible .. there’s evidence of primitive forms of these “motors” and then things evolved …

    • @keithmartin6815
      @keithmartin6815 Месяц назад +1

      Ok consider 3 impossible situations development. 1) a oxygen nitrogen atmosphere with both carbon dioxide and phosphorus in balance which is all required BEFORE animals and vegetation which creates these elements ( life under any circumstances needs these fist in balance) 2) structure and form. (In the record of fossils we see repeated life emerging. The idea they all mutated from a single cell can't account for new lifeforms because any scientific truth must be reproducible . And if it happened 5 times in archeological findings it's something that should be reproducible. But every experiment with mutation hits the limits built into the DNA which prevents the exact type of mutations that would allow evolution (DNA is repairing mutations as a rule. self regulation.) mater is breaking apart and decaying as a rule. Science proves DNA and Matter it's comprised of work in opposite directions. What makes DNA work contrary to the very matter it's using? 3) any process of fitness and survival in a scientific publication leads to 1 truth. Evolution does not grant us ability to see truth. Truth itself as something looked for by humanity would carry no weight in evolution. There's no reason truth should be valued by the most abundant life form on earth. So without a transcendent being of truth your life is only survival of the fittest . It's impossible for humanity to develop such appropriate standards through evolution alone.

  • @oliverjamito9902
    @oliverjamito9902 17 дней назад

    Remembering the Flood from before have tilted my dry grounds!

  • @oliverjamito9902
    @oliverjamito9902 17 дней назад

    Students shared "i" AM will say, HE CAST liken unto WORMWOOD upon HIS WATERS! RIFFLE EFFECTS

  • @toddduchesne1749
    @toddduchesne1749 Месяц назад +3

    Something from nothing! 😂😂 Happens all the time. Tell your boss you want to do nothing and still get a paycheck. 😂

    • @mostlysunny582
      @mostlysunny582 Месяц назад +1

      Lmao. They'll argue: but wanting to do nothing is wanting to do something. Meaning of words and logical thinking is out of the window with this crowd.

  • @fr.anthonysabbagh4854
    @fr.anthonysabbagh4854 16 дней назад +1

    May be! Maybe! Maybe! Probably, probably, probably! No reality !

  • @ivanbessonov5405
    @ivanbessonov5405 Месяц назад +2

    What happens at around 1:06:00? Parts of video are missing

    • @silvershadow013
      @silvershadow013 Месяц назад

      They said they were taking a 20 min break

  • @oliverjamito9902
    @oliverjamito9902 17 дней назад

    The OLIVE wash HIS FEET! To be given New feet and wiping HIS sincere tears from HIS EYES!

  • @fr.anthonysabbagh4854
    @fr.anthonysabbagh4854 16 дней назад +1

    Empty space is a space. It is something. The origin of the existence is the existence it self . We call this God.

    • @tomgreene1843
      @tomgreene1843 13 дней назад

      Tommy Aquinas I think ... a very smart man indeed!

  • @jasonshapiro9469
    @jasonshapiro9469 Месяц назад +1

    Simple things for simple folks, ive always said....and I feel like a.i is somehow the next step in human evolution, whether it helps us become something different or maybe we merge with it

    • @westy-fo1ek
      @westy-fo1ek Месяц назад

      Intreaging! We think we are learning from our smart phones with Google and suri etc etc when actually our phone is learning from us in my opinion! But the question that's bothered me for years is this,is flash Gordon still alive!

  • @phantomblindsight907
    @phantomblindsight907 Месяц назад +1

    something doesn't have to come from nothing, nothing already is something.

    • @user-ci7vu7eo9w
      @user-ci7vu7eo9w Месяц назад +1

      Not true.from nothing never can be something

    • @seabud6408
      @seabud6408 Месяц назад

      @@user-ci7vu7eo9w It’s well known that Neo Darwinism doesn’t add up. They should talk about that … those. .. the unaccounted for anomalies rather than patting themselves on the back for what they already think they know and what is certain for them.
      The Universe appears to be conscious and organismic. It just doesn’t look like an organism from our perspective of its infinity ♾️
      How do we “know”? Without a single human thought or theory from science .. it grew Einstein from plasma .. via the four forces, information, entropy, transcendent geometry/the territory of mathematics. All inherent in that. Consciousness has always been . Like the cyclic Uni-verse (all that is was and will be ) it has never not existed. No more crazy than .. something from nothing .
      Egg 🥚 to chicken 🐓
      Seed to tree 🌳
      Big Bang Boom 💥… to ME 🕺
      Same process .. just doesn’t look like life .. as known . However google this .. do any group of scientists agree what constitutes / defines life .. no
      No one knows no one ! .. how chemistry 🧪 became conscious 💡 biology 🐸 .
      The dead Lego atoms of materialism can’t make CONSCIOUSNESS.
      Computers can’t become conscious because they AREN’T ALIVE.
      The infinitely simple AND complex and actually unknowable (completely) UNIVERSE is as alive and conscious as you are
      How else would it be able to grow you from 💥 plasma /energy
      Science doesn’t know what energy IS .. Google it … but it KNOWS … energy is dead
      Where is this sample of dead energy
      What does that even mean ?

    • @thomeilearn
      @thomeilearn 27 дней назад

      @@user-ci7vu7eo9w
      No science claims to have the ability to explain nothing completely. That's why we have "void", "non-material", etc. The "nothing" in the absolute state of its meaning is yet to be defined. That might be where everyone's God came from. That might be the source of life where all of this began billions of years ago, or even further. And OP's claims can be true as well. Everything is in speculation realm for now.
      Making any positive claims about "nothing" is a silly move, unless you have evidences to back it up.
      At least we can put all those ancient religious bs to rest at this point, with all those "interpretation from the books". A creator failed to explain one single mechanic that's beyond ancient ppl's understanding in literal sense can only mean one thing: the whole thing's man made.

    • @thomeilearn
      @thomeilearn 27 дней назад

      @@user-ci7vu7eo9w Science doesn't claim to have the ability to explain nothing completely. That's why we have "void", "non-material", etc. The "nothing" in the absolute state of its meaning is yet to be defined. That might be where everyone's G came from. That might be the source of life where all of this began billions of years ago, or even further. And OP's claims can be true as well. Everything is in speculation realm for now.
      Making any positive claims about "nothing" is a silly move, unless you have evidences to back it up.
      At least we can put all those ancient religious nonesense to rest at this point, with all those "interpretation from the books". A G failed to explain one single mechanic that's beyond ancient ppl's understanding in literal sense can only mean one thing: the whole thing's man made.
      Time to move on.

  • @fr.anthonysabbagh4854
    @fr.anthonysabbagh4854 16 дней назад

    It is more wiser realistic and simpler to say I do not know. I know that I existed , live and I think .

  • @habbzougasy
    @habbzougasy 3 дня назад +1

    Nothing from even less

  • @MikaelDorfer-ub9ci
    @MikaelDorfer-ub9ci Месяц назад +3

    Nothing is impossible it can't be all other possibilities are probably possible and that's why we need so much space no space is waste. There must be some intelligence behind it.

  • @Knaeben
    @Knaeben Месяц назад +4

    There has never been a thing that has arose from nothing.

    • @DaniAlbaracin
      @DaniAlbaracin Месяц назад +1

      God always existed.

    • @westy-fo1ek
      @westy-fo1ek Месяц назад

      Maybe a thought, idea, perhaps?

    • @westy-fo1ek
      @westy-fo1ek Месяц назад

      ​@@DaniAlbaracinhow's that then pal? Go on, enlighten me?

    • @DaniAlbaracin
      @DaniAlbaracin Месяц назад

      @@westy-fo1ek How evolution would predict that a human would die without a mouth? God created the first mouths. How would evolve without reproduction? Did u compare the reproduction to machines by the complexity of reproduction? Wasnt machines created? An hurricane in a junk yard would create a Playstation? God created the first animals.

    • @DaniAlbaracin
      @DaniAlbaracin Месяц назад

      @@westy-fo1ek How evolution would predict that a human would die without mouth and created it? How would evolve without reproduction? Did u compare the reproduction to machines by the complexity? Wasnt machines created??

  • @dudleyfoster8263
    @dudleyfoster8263 Месяц назад +4

    Ah huh, what is God, who is God, God can be perceived as nature, the creator of life and it does not have to be a living being or does it

    • @Sci-Filip
      @Sci-Filip Месяц назад

      God is the Eternal Spirit of Truth and Love.
      He is not comprehensible for our mind, because He created everything out of his Overflow.
      Therefore, we are not like him.
      On the other Hand, there was some Guy, who was predicted to come someday centuries before he came and live a morally perfect Life, never saying anything wrong about Life, wisdom and moral.
      Although he lived without any falsehood, people hated him, because he showed through his behavior, that Moral perfection exists, therefore proving ideals exist.
      He got crucified, fulfilling all Jewish Prophecies for the God-Send Messiah and by the claims of His own disciples, resurrected from the dead on the third day.
      He told by himself to be the only way to the Eternal Spirit of Truth and Love, who is in Christianity the so-called Father.
      His existence is proved by other known writers from his lifetime and scriptures from his words are the most archaeologically spread literature from this time.
      Although nobody can prove His existence, their are a lot of signs, that either Jesus was for real morally perfect, what makes him unique and proving through dualism that there has to be God in Human, or he is the Initiator of the greatest lie which conquered billions of people on Earth.

    • @herbcachia
      @herbcachia 23 дня назад +3

      Einstein had exactly the same idea. God to him was whatever started life. Not a "devine" being that one prays to.... But an action of nature that is still to be understood.

    • @paullawson7546
      @paullawson7546 22 дня назад +1

      ​@@herbcachiaSpinoza's god.

    • @paullawson7546
      @paullawson7546 22 дня назад +1

      In this context, Dudley, I think one could presume the "common" god. The god of Abraham etc. A personal god that interacts with humans in indecipherable ways. But you're right.

  • @oliverjamito9902
    @oliverjamito9902 17 дней назад

    So small! In front of all professors came with their CLIPBOARDS!

  • @townsquarecoach
    @townsquarecoach Месяц назад +4

    Regardless of how much Dawkins argues and cracks jokes, the cosmic creators will not appear in front of him and take him on a tour of their divine manufacturing/design factory. A creator has to be believed/understood as existing somewhere from the living products that have been released, just like we know that a creator/manufacturer exists somewhere for our smartphones, cars, etc.

    • @tomgreene1843
      @tomgreene1843 13 дней назад

      Well analogy works but as Aquinas might say as analogy not as a full description .

  • @adolfkoehler110
    @adolfkoehler110 7 дней назад

    The laws of physics, how did they come about?

  • @jayvincent1865
    @jayvincent1865 Месяц назад +1

    On a noticeable time scale

  • @robertmcclintock8701
    @robertmcclintock8701 Месяц назад +1

    ( ´⊇`) consciousness is the particle and wave double slit experiment. The cones and rods of your eyes preserve the particle and wave duality so your vision don't look like a flat screen television. It's supposed to be a violation of physics but it is the only exception in the whole universe.

  • @donreising2676
    @donreising2676 12 дней назад +3

    Richard Dawkins knows everything and knows nothing 😂

  • @oneoflokis
    @oneoflokis 3 дня назад +1

    Ah yes - but why is there something, RATHER than nothing? 🙂

  • @jayvincent1865
    @jayvincent1865 Месяц назад +1

    18:27 Some brown Bears and river dolphins seem to be evolving their hunting.

    • @westy-fo1ek
      @westy-fo1ek Месяц назад

      Mad innit,I see a bear the other day sitting on my fucking fishing stool with his rod in the lake! Cheeky fucker he didn't even have a fishing licence! And river dolphins cohhh! Took the kids up to the splash park yesterday and there's only 2 fucking dolphins messing about under the water jets,I mean there wasn't many families there but they were smoking something what smelt like weed to me,I said oi,u taking the piss guys,go back to your river man,they replied with they tried to but some random bear took the gaff over so they can't go back now! Unbelievable what's the world coming to!!?

  • @oliverjamito9902
    @oliverjamito9902 17 дней назад

    My shared "i" AM HOSTS and my Beautiful will say, unto all who have an Ear let them hear

  • @oliverjamito9902
    @oliverjamito9902 17 дней назад

    Students will say, why all professors came before HIM?

  • @knkimmel7409
    @knkimmel7409 Месяц назад +7

    Less cynicism, more facts please.

  • @oliverjamito9902
    @oliverjamito9902 17 дней назад

    Pilot will say, what is TAILS IN FRONT OF HIM?

  • @oliverjamito9902
    @oliverjamito9902 17 дней назад

    Resting upon my LORD sitteth upon the Clouds resting upon the NEW Permanent Foundation!

  • @robertmcclintock8701
    @robertmcclintock8701 Месяц назад +1

    ( ´_ゝ`) A human body is burly, gnarly and surly like a fractal.

  • @ahmedshahimi9483
    @ahmedshahimi9483 6 дней назад +1

    There is no way that we came from nothing, and the way our bodies are designed to function and how we replicate. Some intelligent being must want us to replicate for us to continue to exist. This suggests that there must be an intelligent being behind it

  • @JeanMarcelino-qr9ju
    @JeanMarcelino-qr9ju Месяц назад +2

    From nothing to something 😂😂😂

  • @oliverjamito9902
    @oliverjamito9902 17 дней назад

    Remember becareful!

  • @wisammoeali
    @wisammoeali 23 дня назад +1

    I am so confused I need someone to explain because what I understand from Krauss is; that before the birth of matter, energy, space, and time there was a vacuum of constant nothing, which means infinite ∅ (phi) in Math. We know that ϕ is a set containing no element at all. And {0} is a set containing one element, namely zero 0. Also, 0 is a number, not a set. Hence ϕ,{0}, and 0 are all different since 0∈R,, which means zero is still a value of a magnitude I.e. zero of apples is not ∅ (phi)because there is a magnitude possibility of a matter before zero apples.
    but the gentleman in the video suggested F(x) =0 which is not an infinite ∅ (phi); in other words, the gentleman defined Krauss's "Nothing" as a zero which can be a value of something such as matter, energy, time or space, etc.

    • @CliffSedge-nu5fv
      @CliffSedge-nu5fv 22 дня назад +1

      You sound very confused. 1, phi is not the symbol for empty set. 2. You are just mashing together mathematical-looking gibberish.

    • @wisammoeali
      @wisammoeali 22 дня назад +1

      ​@@CliffSedge-nu5fv gibberish? ok define emptiness, nothing, and zero in math I wanna see symbols not words, and prove to me a constant nothing is zero

  • @oliverjamito9902
    @oliverjamito9902 17 дней назад

    Cleaners will clean my FOOTSTOOL in front!

  • @oliverjamito9902
    @oliverjamito9902 17 дней назад

    Beloved remember "it" from all thy shared Mouths will be determined resting upon in front

  • @oliverjamito9902
    @oliverjamito9902 17 дней назад

    Complex can be soothe!

  • @fr.anthonysabbagh4854
    @fr.anthonysabbagh4854 16 дней назад

    Most of those who have a problem with the creator, has a problem with their own parents! Abused and an abusers.

  • @PariahDice
    @PariahDice 25 дней назад +1

    Lawrence 'in fact' Krauss 😅

  • @LastDays77
    @LastDays77 6 дней назад

    The question is not answered at all. Where does the beginning of all things come from? How can everything be from absolute nothingness?

  • @oliverjamito9902
    @oliverjamito9902 17 дней назад

    Why pilot will never wash HIS HANDS SECOND TIME?

  • @oliverjamito9902
    @oliverjamito9902 17 дней назад

    Documents sent forth!

  • @oliverjamito9902
    @oliverjamito9902 17 дней назад

    Keep watch!

  • @oliverjamito9902
    @oliverjamito9902 17 дней назад

    Beloved remember my CLEANERS Meeks upon my Footstool!

  • @oliverjamito9902
    @oliverjamito9902 17 дней назад

    Time what is ancient of days in front?

  • @oliverjamito9902
    @oliverjamito9902 17 дней назад

    From us but not of us!

  • @fr.anthonysabbagh4854
    @fr.anthonysabbagh4854 16 дней назад

    Man and his mind is diversified like his created diversified universe and is not one member” the scientist”.

  • @sameerbhat2599
    @sameerbhat2599 Месяц назад +3

    I just started to watch the video but only after seven minutes i closed it, because it seems to me a wastage of time,just believing everything from nothing

    • @zachdonabedian7828
      @zachdonabedian7828 25 дней назад +1

      Way to be open minded 😂

    • @patriciadechamps3169
      @patriciadechamps3169 24 дня назад

      RD doesn't claim that Nothing produced Something, he clearly said that extreme simplicity evolved into more and more complexity (over 13.5 billion years). At a certain time non-life evolved into living material. It's very complicated stuff and you need to study biology, chemistry, etc to understand better. Which is not easy, of course. Science doesn't have all the answers (yet) and probably never will. Doesn't prove that religions are right by giving simplistic and primitive answers to very good questions. Obviously, gods (thousands of them) were made up by civilisations who were hardly educated and didn't understand the world around them. Death and disease, natural catastrophes, even the weather, etc. were mysteries to them. So of course they made up answers and that produced religious thinking. Today we have scientific methodology and therefore any kind of theism should disappear in the end.

    • @CliffSedge-nu5fv
      @CliffSedge-nu5fv 22 дня назад

      You are allowed to remain ignorant. Your attitude is childish, cowardly, and dishonest.

    • @tomgreene1843
      @tomgreene1843 13 дней назад

      Agree to a point but it can be useful to listen to a viewpoint ...it may sometimes spring remarkably obvious leaks !

    • @patriciadechamps3169
      @patriciadechamps3169 13 дней назад

      Extreme simplicity evolved into more and more complexity is actually what they mean. It's not sth evolving from "nothing" in the way you may think.
      "Nothing is created, nothing is lost, everything is transformed".
      Using a "god-explanation" does not solve the problem at all anyway.

  • @oliverjamito9902
    @oliverjamito9902 17 дней назад

    Why a lame has for the pool to be stirred in front of HIM? Remember thy shared "i" AM

  • @user-tp6ky8wy8q
    @user-tp6ky8wy8q Месяц назад +3

    Confusion worse confounded. These two geniuses don’t have even a lame hypothesis about origin of life and yet have the audacity to abuse other intellectuals.

    • @juliandunn8412
      @juliandunn8412 16 дней назад

      They are just smelling their own farts.

  • @oliverjamito9902
    @oliverjamito9902 17 дней назад

    Who can interpret therein?

  • @oliverjamito9902
    @oliverjamito9902 17 дней назад

    Keep watch my beautiful!

  • @kevinbill9574
    @kevinbill9574 Месяц назад +4

    The political digs are just tiresome. I would say unnecessary too, but given the kinds of people involved I can see why they do it

  • @oliverjamito9902
    @oliverjamito9902 17 дней назад

    Remember who among tails to wag Who?

  • @fr.anthonysabbagh4854
    @fr.anthonysabbagh4854 16 дней назад

    Is the created becoming the creator of its own creator?

  • @oliverjamito9902
    @oliverjamito9902 17 дней назад

    Angel come here and remind why stir the pool? The WORD the "i" AM in front of ALL ANGELS AND MY SHARED "i" AM HOSTS!

  • @oliverjamito9902
    @oliverjamito9902 17 дней назад

    Yes, bring the Angels to stir the pool?

  • @Hambastegy
    @Hambastegy 4 дня назад +1

    🙏

  • @robertmcclintock8701
    @robertmcclintock8701 Месяц назад +1

    ( 。゚Д゚。) The universe was created in 1976. It is too hot to make a universe at the time of the big bang. It can be created at anytime. God is slow and easy. A human can do a lot with their lifespan. I got the hunk. God got the chunk. Everyone else can have the rest. That is song spirit of ''76 by The Alarm.

  • @oliverjamito9902
    @oliverjamito9902 17 дней назад

    Yes, HE can command HIS TAILS TO BOUND HANDS AND FEET! IN FRONT OF HIM!

  • @tomgreene1843
    @tomgreene1843 22 дня назад

    Mr D might try again ....well something from very little ....like a painting ?

  • @bluegtturbo
    @bluegtturbo Месяц назад +2

    Darwin doesn't explain the origins of life or indeed why evolution occurs

    • @mobilegamereviewer.1936
      @mobilegamereviewer.1936 Месяц назад

      Why denotes purpose. If there is no purpose then your question about the nature of the purpose is useless.

  • @johnjoseph2890
    @johnjoseph2890 Месяц назад +1

    From Richard Dawkins what if your wrong!

  • @heyhandersen5802
    @heyhandersen5802 19 дней назад

    A myth is just a God.

  • @oliverjamito9902
    @oliverjamito9902 17 дней назад

    Is like hold tight my Waters have to go through the Filter.

    • @ferbre3520
      @ferbre3520 12 дней назад

      STOP BEING A PARROT... WHAT YOU LEARNED IS NOT THE WHOLE THING... JUST PART OF IT... PUTTING ALL THE LITTLE YOU LEARNED IN A PEDESTAL... IS NOT THE WAY TO GREATER WISDOM

    • @oliverjamito9902
      @oliverjamito9902 12 дней назад

      @@ferbre3520 what is greater wisdom? Who can obtain greater wisdom without shared "i" AM come forth!

    • @oliverjamito9902
      @oliverjamito9902 12 дней назад

      @@ferbre3520 remember thy shared "i" AM only thy name exist in front!

    • @oliverjamito9902
      @oliverjamito9902 11 дней назад

      @@ferbre3520 beloved what is the Fowl of the Air in front?

    • @oliverjamito9902
      @oliverjamito9902 11 дней назад

      From sent forth to look for dry grounds? From ancient of days Flood came to clean! A Fowl of the Air sent forth to look for DRY grounds. Where all shared clay FEET MIXED WITH IRON can rest upon HIS FOOTSTOOL

  • @joshymathew2253
    @joshymathew2253 Месяц назад +25

    God is just a myth

    • @user-bq8ok6pz2n
      @user-bq8ok6pz2n 17 дней назад +3

      Well said ❤

    • @juliandunn8412
      @juliandunn8412 16 дней назад +3

      Prove it.

    • @FollowJesusChristfirst
      @FollowJesusChristfirst 10 дней назад

      Wrong Josh......Funny Darwin was a mason....mason's doh! satan's bitch again.
      this say's it all in that vid......Bible easy to prove with simple math,Your great grandfather Noah parked his boat 4500 years ago 3 son's 3 wives 1% growth 1/2% death = 8 Billion people.Oh and DNA prove we come from 3 women.Oh and the Bible tells you where the ARK is parked.Now if you want me to destroy the mason evolution con with simple math I will.You need 2 always did.God Bless you Josh..... God tried to make it as easy as he could, repent and be saved. Plunder satan's kingdom...... I do....Lord Steve.

    • @DocReasonable
      @DocReasonable 6 дней назад

      @@juliandunn8412 Creation of life from nothing (as in the bible) is supernatural magic. It therefore cannot be explained and is NOT science.

    • @thunderous-one
      @thunderous-one 6 дней назад

      Such a myth that with every breathing moment you live your life by the very moral code that came from a God that you call a myth and deny exists.
      Scooby Do was not this confused.
      Oh, did you choose to make you comment or was it mere chemical impulse given your high priest Dawkins denies free will exists?

  • @Anubhavsengupta1902
    @Anubhavsengupta1902 Месяц назад +2

    Sir I have a criticism for you that you should make long form video essays because your videos gets extremely less views and subscribers,just look at the amount of views and subscribers that German Shephard gets!,at first it's going to be hard for you but once you make long form video essays then more and more people are going to watch your videos!🙏🕉️

    • @logicity00
      @logicity00  Месяц назад +1

      We are working towards it. Thank you so much for your support, absolutely helps us improve!

    • @entropy5431
      @entropy5431 Месяц назад

      ​@@logicity00Poor and inaccurate title. Great content which you stole.

    • @DouglasBrooker
      @DouglasBrooker Месяц назад

      Oh shut up

  • @oliverjamito9902
    @oliverjamito9902 17 дней назад

    Lord ye will Visit! Very tip of time will say, what is far generations?

  • @oliverjamito9902
    @oliverjamito9902 17 дней назад

    What is not clear enough?

  • @TheMargarita1948
    @TheMargarita1948 11 дней назад +1

    If God designed everything, why did it design the pelvis of the human female with design flaws that put the lives of both the mother and the baby at risk during every single human birth?

    • @DocReasonable
      @DocReasonable 6 дней назад

      That's explained in the story of Adam and Eve. It's punishment for Eve eating the apple. The Bible has an answer for everything -- although those answers are invariably insane.

    • @TheMargarita1948
      @TheMargarita1948 6 дней назад +1

      @@DocReasonable Thank you. Is there an explanation for the human knee in there, too?

  • @donreising2676
    @donreising2676 12 дней назад +1

    After listening to these great men, I am more convinced that God created the universe 😃🎉

  • @marcdewey1242
    @marcdewey1242 3 дня назад +1

    If this man wants to believe his ancestors swung in trees that's his choice,as for me ill stick with creation,God created man the earth and everything else that is.

  • @user-ll2ed3lt4g
    @user-ll2ed3lt4g Месяц назад +1

    BS. A vacuum by definition means nothing so if virtual particles appear then it's not a complete vacuum.