How Did Everything Start From Nothing?
HTML-код
- Опубликовано: 25 фев 2024
- What does nothing really mean? How did everything start from nothing? This is a topic that goes beyond scientific inquiry, touching on what it means to exist, what nothingness is, and how the universe could emerge from it. Join us on this journey as we delve into the most mysterious thing we know and don't know, nothing.
Subscribe → @SpacedustDOC
#Spacedust #Space #Universe 
Наука
It's ok to say... we simply don't know.
Awesome answer. I believe God's work cannot be explained.
@@RodSanAgustinAnd I believe Zeus and Athena work in mysterious ways. 😂
Which doesn't imply we should refrain from trying to know. Shame is though , this "trying to know" brought death and destruction.
@@RodSanAgustin That's cuz gods are imaginary. Imaginary things can never be explained because there's no tether to reality with them. No physical measuring, no senses contacting. But real stuff can be figured out. We don't know a lot of cosmic facts *now*. But we will know *one day* if we keep searching. Because the cosmos is real - unlike gods. And unicorns. And magical wizards attending prep schools lodged in a magical neverwhere. And Spider-Man.
(Every single time we've ever figured out a mystery, like where the sun goes at night, it's always turned out to be a perfectly natural phenomenon. Isn't that wild? It's never turned out to be Apollo on his chariot or a wizard casting a spell or whatever. Stuff humans blamed on demons for eons turned out to be diseases and mental illnesses that can be treated - like leprosy and schizophrenia, both of which Jesus blames on demons in the NT. If "God's work" were real, we would be able to engage with and study it exactly as we do black holes and cancer. But it isn't, and so we can't.)
@@PAULLONDEN
The deeper or higher the thought - the deeper the need for even subtler knowledge - for the mind - towards infinity.
Knowledge without a sense of the Divine - as Goal or Base - becomes mere foolishness (Raja yoga meditation). We should try to share in the revelation - we have the tools and now the courage and love - raises itself in flame.
Fare thee well
I admit is was me . I’m always sitting around “doing nothing”.
...now look what you've done...
😟
The problem with doing nothing is that you never know when you are done!
😂😂😂😂😂 Lmao at 1 am after reading this😂😂😂😂
And they said u would never amount to anything. Please accept my thanks for doing nothing
@@waterthugsbut the universe inspite coming from nothing amounts to something
There can never be “nothing” because the potential of “something” always exist which means “nothing” cannot. The energy of our universe came from this potential energy.
Where did the potential energy come from, and what is potential energy and when was it factually discovered?
How am I existing right now? You. Me. Us. How are we floating about in outer space? How can we exist? How did all of this come from nothing? Where was the start? How can a start even exist? It's truly out of the realm of imagination. If it all came from energy, how can the first energy arise from nothing? If Our Creator (assuming we have one) came to us with an explanation, I wonder if we'd have the intelligence to understand such a question.
The only way to attempt to grasp this, is to first admit that time and nothing does not exist. We simply can't think "outside" the code of reality we were created inside. Our perspective is limited. I wonder if this will one day change? If it's possible to ever expand consciousness to solve the mystery of our genesis.
Been listening to these videos to get to sleep. Great narration. Cool subjects. Thanks Spacedust!
Thanks for watching!
Sounds like an insult at first lol (i.e. you find it so boring it sends you to sleep). But I agree, great video. A shame you're missing out on the quality visuals of it but the narration is amazing also so you're still winning in my book.
@@Silks-I have to watch it first and then I can sleep to it lol.
OMG, I thought I was the only one who nerds-out and goes to sleep with this stuff! My self esteem is not broken any more.😄
@@yaksak2706 me too. I fall asleep questioning reality every night. Lol.
There is a creator out there. Nothing can create itself from nothing. The earth itself is too perfect to have been born out of a coincidence.
Failure of imagination
I agree totally. Nothing can be created from nothing. The Williams telescope is proving that the Universe has always existed, and that there are no visible boundaries. Difficult concepts for most human beings, but nevertheless the most likely explanation. No need to make up supernatural creation theories.
arguments from ignorance and incredulity. Just because you don't understand how something works doesn't mean a god did it
@@peteworthy8322 True
Nothing creates nothing if someone is creating nothing it means that there is something.
[...if someone is creating nothing it means that there is something]
Assuming that is correct, it in no way implies or proves the existence of a god, and certainly does not support Christianity in particular.
@@OldMusicGuy99 if you believe in God question arises who create God. God means something advanced according evolution such a big structure created
God created first and small created after God it doesn't satisfy evolution.
My mind is blown. WHY DOES ANYTHING EXIST... including nothingness? They are both perplexing. Does nothingness exist as empty space? Isnt space itself SOMETHING? SO is nothingness a solid? Nothing makes sense anymore.
na
There is something that always exists. Even supposed empty space is filled with virtual particles popping in and out of existence. It's like nothingness is trying to become something all the time, and true empty nothingness cannot be a state of existence. When I ask the big question "Why does anything exist at all?", I try to console myself with the answer: "Because it has to. Because nothing is impossible."
Ice pack - on the bean - or a nice warm dark coffee - is quite helpful
Fare thee well.
@@BlastHardcheeseableso existence is in essence eternity we are in.
@@BlastHardcheeseable Yup. The only thing we can truly know is that there's something rather than nothing, and therefore something has to exist for some reason.
The simplest answer is usually the correct one. There has always been something. Einstein called it space time. It has always existed. We know matter is just a state of energy and particles can appear and disappear without leaving a trace. Space wasn't empty to begin with. The concept of Infinity is the bit people can't accept.
Because it’s terrifying, even if there is an afterlife, wouldn’t there have to be an after AFTER life, and so on? Anything we believe in, fact, or fiction, is just something we use to put a period at the end of a sentence, we’re probably forever going to learn more and more, just to have more questions to ask
The concept that has always intrigued me is there something & not empty space (or nothing) ?!
@caroleannekerr708 even if nothing exists just blackness it is still something it's mind blowing
But the fact that life was created from all this is hard to grasp.
@@Reyna_Aleese Life, as biologists define it, began 3.7 billion years ago, beginning with complex amino acids and eventually becoming single celled bacteria. Our present knowledge, in virtually all branches of applied science, has revealed that Darwinian Evolution is 98% accurate. Molecular genetics continues to support that theory with very detailed factual evidence.
We certainly weren't "created" in some magical place, no matter what people desperately want (or need) to believe.
The problem is that we humans learned to think in time. When I was stoned 50 years ago, I told my friends and friends, that we are only energy. We are only a fantasy and illusion of ourselves.
when i was stoned 25yrs ago i crashed my car. if i was just energy, then i wouldn't have hurt my knee, it's a good thing my Honda preludes chassis was made from reinforced steel and remained intact even though i went into the back of a rover 200 at 60mph (at point of impact, was doing about 85 before the knob pulled out in front of me). it was a 1 day bolt on repair.
anyway, matter is made from energy in a different state, we are in the matter state, not energy state.
if we are just energy, is it ok to use humans as fuel for a tandoori chicken??
@@chozusmakavelli
That's why. Its proves my statemet we are only energy.
Welcome to what Hindu sages discovered .. just read Hindu philosophy. It is all there
the comment threads on these types of science or philosophical videos tend to be more useful than the videos themselves
But videos make think about these matters
This is the question I was asking myself from my childhood which often turns my mind into emptiness
Like the sun shining on a bright hot day then out of nowhere a drop of rain baffles you
It’s our experiences of life that cause us to demand that everything have a beginning, a time before it existed, with the means by which it was created being discoverable. But in fact, there is nothing to say that it hasn’t always existed, our inability to comprehend it notwithstanding.
Idk, I think it's fascinating that there are only two known examples of singularities, the big bang and blackholes. Could they be related? Could the Big Bang actually be a super massive blackhole in reverse. Perhaps the whole universe is inside a blackhole, and blackholes are nurseries for universes.
yes hyptothetcslly the idea would be everything that goes into a black hole goes to one point in space and time this may also happen to gravity causing dark energy or anti gravity which is the force possibly currently pushing the expansion of the universe
“we us all” ?
We dont know. But based on data, no they are not.
@vonborgah what "data"?
@@vonborgah?
The fascinating thing about this question is that whatever answer you have ends up being paradoxical. Either an entity without a beginning , or an ongoing evolutionary process without a beginning, it just doesn’t really make sense from our perspective.
It's sort of like wondering if the size of the universe is infinite or finite. Either possibility ends up with insane implications. Existence is truly bizarre.
In deed without a beginning sounds more rational than from nothing, because only nothing can come out from nothing. The most viable instrument used to unravel the paradox of the universe is human consciousness, hence reasoning. Lets try and understand this tool first because it's much more closer to home. We may be surprised the riddle have been under our nose all this while.
Can you imagine the race of beings that CAN figure out what happened?
@@rwarren58 of course it's possible to figure it out. Our spices have the capabilities to do that, though we need to develop into that capabilities. We're not currently there at this moment yet we've made remarkable progress.
One can still imagine there are other civilization out there in the cosmos who can fixe this enigma. I also feel we can do better if we start looking inward at the functioning of our consciousness. From my point of view they seem to be similarities, of course I can prove it.
@@Nnamdi-wi2nu what spices do you have?
We are right now inside the black hole of another Universe.
And you should be kept at least 5 AU away from children upto age 18.
Contained within the infinite consciousness of GOD are multitudes of world upon worlds of which our entire universe is but a grain of sand✨♾️😉
@@ossiedunstan4419 What are you talking about?
@@user-Zachary123 An AU is an "Astronomical Unit" and we all know what young children are like. 🤣
Maybe it's time to accept that perhaps we will never know how it all started but we definitely know how it will end for us...
It may not last long, but I am really glad that I have the chance to exist at all! 🤔
If there's a god, who created god?
You are the god, now tell me the answer!
Fun thing is, we will never actually know.
Until we die according to Near Death Experience
@@2pacaveli257 Why is it that most people who claim to have had a near death experience always have a book to sell?
Why not? Im certain our understanding in physics will have a breakthrough, just like it’s always done. The only real question is “when”
@@Jay-nj1rq we would need to go faster than the speed of light, which is not possible for a physical object.
True ‘nothing’ is implausible, because once contemplated becomes ‘something’
My thoughts exactly!
1 nothing is still 0 anything. Nothing is "not anything" which is not, nor will it ever be something.
I think in the infinite everything is possible and one of those is something rather than nothing and once there is something nothing is impossible
@@AndyFurze Great point, thank you for sharing!
@@supreme11505 true in regards to general computations, but not with spacial awareness
The issue is that we think that something has to originate from nothing but this I think is a flaw because every observation we’ve ever seen things have came from previous states of something
Nothing starts from nothing. There was no start and there is no end.
Bingo!✨♾️😉
It’s like you didn’t even watch the video! Or at least, did not UNDERSTAND it!
@@mamavswild What goes up must come down..... but then it BOUNCES back up... BIG BANG!!!
BUT I STILL DONT GET WHY WE ARE HERE NEITHER DO ANY OF YOU!
the CMB, expansion, fission, fusion, radiation all tell this story. entropy.
Or at least our brains can’t comprehend that
- if nothing existed, there would be no logic or laws of physics
- if there are no laws of physics or logic, there is nothing to prevent things from popping into existence without a cause
- since there would be no time, you don't have to wait for this to happen. It could just.. happen
You know what, damn this make sense
@@quasarqatar5129 I've spent a long time thinking about this topic, and this is the only conclusion that my fragile human brain can comprehend. Sadly, I haven't really found any philosophers who talk specifically about "something from nothing" in this manner.
Outstanding answer
I don't blame you but the big bang hypothesis.
I would add to this that I don't think we can say "Nothingness" ever had a chance to exist, as existing requires the passage of time. "Nothingness" thus never was, not even for a microsecond. Since time is interwoven with space, spacetime was a brute requirement.
But even if nothingness is impossible because time and space MUST exist, one could imagine a universe that exists with nothing special going on it at all (ie. no life). That's the real mystery to me. Why a universe like ours came to be, instead of something completely uninteresting and void of life.
When you live in a simulation, there is nothing until they hit the start button.
If so, where did those come who does this simulation?
@@Fiilis1 obviously a place where their reality doesn’t appear to have come from nothing like ours does.
there is nothing... except the the entire universe the simulation is running in. 🙄
@@audiomaker1 And where did there's come from is a great question. But it isn't.
@@joppadoni Pretty sure the point was “how do you get something from nothing”.
It would be impossible to speculate what is known about the origins of other realities by their occupants.
Maybe…just maybe they know….unlike us.
Nothing was everything until there was something. Let that sink in.
Too deep for me. Read a few books on quantum physics and get back to us.
If it all begins with particles....then who/what created the particles
Allah
If you want to go down that line of thought, then who created the entity that supposedly created the particles? That's the basic fallacy of all faith based religious arguments.
Given enough time, quantum mechanics (physics) may likely answer the question of "creation", which may reveal that there never was a need for a "supernatural" explanation for our existence.
@@theprinceof2004 An ignorant peasant did it all. Yeah ... of course! 🤑
I think there is no start or finish hard to imagine
Those white dots are killing my TV🙉
Personally I think "nothing" is what I call "neutral vacuum energy" or "empty space" from which we get "positive light energy" or "electromagnetism" which creates any "charged" matter and antimatter including bosons, and "negative dark energy" which creates "dark' energy and matter with the expansive force also compressive gravity.
Back in the 70's when I was in high school, we would get stoned and talk about the origins of the universe. The general consensus back then was that we were figments of our own imaginations and that all of us could very possibly be simply one imagining the rest. Then I went to college and got a job.
And stopped thinking. Nearly everyone does. What if the answer is of the greatest importance to you (and all of us)?
Order came forth from Chaos. Beyond the order of the universe lies the chaos of all possibilities
Very interesting idea
Agree, very likely a Kuhn level 8 nothing.
But why is there this chaos of all possibilities, instead of nothing at all. Not even possibilities, or the concept of possibilities, or even the concept of a concept. True nothing.
Chaos is order tho
Energy rested - but had to move forth - to actualise itself - or become dormant.
Some mystics say - the creation is part of God - realising Himself.
Humans realise themselves - by going back to that place of Divinity - and where space time and intention - become one.
Only if one - is fearless enough and love has absolutely - suffused the heart - as to merge wholly - with the Beloved. (So the mystics teach by their existence).
Fare thee well.
If before there was something there was nothing. Who created nothing? Then who created the creator?
Exactly, it's endless
Well if the hen came before the egg how did the first hen get here
Its a conscious universe. You are a part of universe itself
No creator. Bubble burst!!!
Every time the narrator says "Hot Dense State" I think of the Big Bang theme song.
I know I can never be answered.
But for as long as I can remember
I've always wanted to know how it started where did the first particle come from
Allah
How does something come from nothing? It's an impossible concept. It's like imagining a colour that resembles no other colour or a sound that resembles no other sound.
You must be a Khruangbin fan...
Even God is in awe of its own infinite mystery✨♾️😉
I think a universe always existing is just as incredible as nothing. I have come to the conclusion that trying to understand this is a waste of time. studying the universe is great, but this particular question can only lead to insanity
The answer appears to be in the quantum world
@@garyk1334 YES !!!. You're the first person to say that. More people should read about the amazing things happening in the quantum world. The experiments will defy everything you presently believe about the visible world.
It doesn't matter what its all about ..
Just enjoy the day
Make hay while the Sun shines
😂😂
Did you typed Lady Gaga and came here by mistake. 🤔
"charged" particles and waves are made of electromagnetic strings and membranes or branes, while "dark" matter and energy have strings and branes which we can call negative mass, negative energy, or negative matter or exotic matter, which could be the basis of loop quantum gravity
In the realm of thought, we can never find an answer to the question of existence. Whatever humans do is the movement of thought and it's a hamster wheel. The more the thinking, more momentum to the thoughts. But when this movement stops, there will be no 'you' to tell the truth, because 'you' is a thought too.
who typed that comment?
The universe can never be understood without factoring the time of it's origin as infinite
There is not a problem with that in science.
Have you ever think that the answer may be in your mind. The human imagination is infinite just as the cosmos prove to be infinite
Nice formulation!
@@Nnamdi-wi2nu I am now being suggested videos that believe we are in something's brain. Infinite has no boundaries
@@charlesbaldo we may be at a point, something or somebody's head. One thing we must accept going by scientific discoveries is that we don't exist the entire physical world do not exist. What actually exist don't have substance, "weird isn't it." We'll catch up with this mess one day just keep looking up and follow validity.
We came from G O D. Nowhere close to nothing. Facts 💯
Absolutely fantastic. So inspiring. Thank you!
But there also could be strings and branes of neutral vacuum energy, which could also be linked to quantum loop gravity, the strings and branes of neutral vacuum energy as particles of spacetime creating a spacetime warping leading to what we could call gravity
A very VERY good question! The universe is pulsating with approx. 50billion years between every pulse.
I'm obsessed with this question, what could have caused it all?? I don't believe in nothing. Another great video and I really like this narrator. To add, surely a hot dense state must have been caused by something, not nothing!
Well there is more mind blowing question. What is nothing? Was there "nothing" or did something or someone create "nothing" ? What is nothing? 😂
It makes me kind of sad. Thinking we won't ever really know. It's time. Our perception of time is so limiting. Billions of years. What if a billion years felt like a second feels to us? There could be a god. It's space and time that is so limiting to us.
Might be a black hole from a previous universe. Singularity of infinite density and planck temperature sounds like both big bang and black hole. Imagine it's rather like a fractal: black holes all the way down...
@@jessicaheger1880 I feel that too.
why not nothing? the total energy of universe is good evidence to be 0 (positive radiation, negative gravitation) - and it makes sense so we are in a flat space on global scale, otherwise our space time would be curved either convex or concave .. the real question is where the all antimetter gone
Nothing seems to be impossible .
Actually, that's one of the most significant revelations of quantum mechanics. Given enough time, everything is possible. In addition, experiments have revealed that every moment of time in the world (as we perceive it) is infinitely connected ("entanglement") and a function of mathematical probability.
@chrisgardner4222 that is so interesting. I wish I could understand all of this topic.
WOW Fantastic ❤
Realy I like this video so so much
Something can not be created from nothing.
There are things happening in the quantum world that you might want to delve into.
We are the Universe contemplating itself.
The chance is we are completely wrong about everything so far . Universe probably way older than we can imagine or has always been.
Darkness was the nothing. And from nothing, darkness became space. Space forms cold making the darkness tightly squeeze which make it dense and hot. And thats where cold and hot collides resulting into a lightning. Thats where all begun..From sound, fire, energy, smoke, colors etc. Each combinations had form some new elements like matters, gasses etc.. Then our Heavenly bodies is born and that is our creator.
Where did darkness come from?
The Book of Genesis. 🤣 Pick up a book on Quantum Mechanics and open your mind.
This is so scientific educational.
Educational with no answer. This question is better left to philosophers
Power is something, it’s just something you can’t see. It behaves a particular way
Trick question. Everything didn’t come from nothing. It came from a different state of everything.
Where did the different state of everything come from ?
@@charlesbaldo From nothing. 😆
@@dickjones4912 good answer but RUclips doesn't like you and deleted it
@charlesbaldo Yeah for some reason it's not in the top comments sorting, but it shows in new comments 🤷♂️
Are you creating nothing, or is nothing creating you?
Who says it came from nothing anyway?
Very good,
Thank u 🙏
There has been no scientific finding that everything started from nothing.
There has never been a time when there was nothing. There has always been energy .
Maybe
I don't think energy is without a beginning. I don't think it makes logical sense to have an infinite past of anything, otherwise it would require an infinite amount of time to reach the start of our universe. I do believe everything had a beginning, including time, and there is no before the beginning of time itself. Thus nothingness never was, existence is a brute requirement.
Probably not. What we know about the universe is better understood if it emerged from an infinity of nothing, such as a Kuhn level 8 nothing.
An infinity of nothing being infinite, is replete with possibilities. One of these is the emergence or creation of our universe.
The creation event itself had to be very simple in nature so that it became not just a possibility, but also probable.
The universe we experience today is as a consequence of decay from that creation event. Ultimately (in trillions of years) the universe we know and love will decay back to nothing, no particles, no fields, nothing at all.
However, along the way it may go though a number of trillion year long 'events' as dark energy rips apart black holes.
The concept of absolute nothing is flawed, as even the act of imagining it imbues it with some form of existence or definition.
@@jokerhaha5123 if level 8 creates problems for you, try level 9
Don't forget about Hugh Everett III
WTF is "nothing?" I keep hearing people ask how everything started from nothing, but I've never seen any evidence that there was ever nothing... Or even a clear explanation of how "nothing" could have ever been the state of the universe or whatever.
God!
Which one???
@@johanrodriguez8051 not yours apparently
In the beginning GOD created the Heavens and the Earth. Genesis 1:1
Questions that make questions may not be a question at all.
The Absence (vacuum) is needed for the matter to flow.
The answer is God.
You're welcome 😊
It is a good one
- have a theory - based on experience - that if one only thinks - deeply enough - God reveals Himself - in final answer - to perhaps most questions.
Fare thee well.
God reveals himself - but different prophets, saviours and gurus saw different gods. So god needs to get himself a good communications consultant to put out a coherent message. @@user-hy9nh4yk3p
It's god's work ok
You’re a caveman believing in a supernatural I suppose you believe in Santa Claus two
With infinite Bigness MUST come infinite smallness! Now focus within your existence.....
Science says "give us one free miracle and we'll do the rest."
I create nothing every day at work. I’m good at nothing.
It is the proper of humankind to put a beginning or an end to everything. The concept of infinity or eternity is too much and cannot be comprehend.
As long as people deny a creator God, no one can possibly understand this incredible, diverse and beautiful earth.
Now that there is something, can we ever return to a state of nothingness again?
Latest Big Bang temperature estimate is Cooler than earlier thought thus the "Pre-Bang" core size is computed to be around 1.75 cu feet (50 liters) or average Human body size.......
Thanks
Something created nothing.
Decay and laws of thermodynamics
Something turns into nothing, but nothing could really mean transformation into something else...and when see something coming from nothing is actually something transforming into something else...
So something created nothing.
What we say is nothing could be something and the error that hinders us from our wording in our discoveries and Rediscoveries is when we try to identify anything and how it works to answer our whys and how's and whens.
8:15 Why is gravity called weak force when it's clearly so strong that it condenses lightweight gasses and ignites fusion within creating stars, and keeps super heavy dense black holes, neutron stars, pulsars, etc revolving around each other. It's more like a strong force, but slow. The Slow-Strong force is more like it.
Look at the size of the earth. It takes little force for us, small human beings to jump into the air.
The title of this video has been my biggest question since the Universe, I mean me, began. Actually the way I phrased it is, 'Was there ever nothing?'
It was done by a time travel from the future. The whole mass was as small as a pea, and evolved to a planet 2x as big as the Universe, 100x as far as the size of the Universe. The Universes were made, and the mass was delivered by a cargo ship into the universes.
Universes at the size of a pea also exist.
The transition of energy into mass does not contradict physical laws; for example, the birth of a particle-antiparticle pair from a vacuum can still be observed in scientific experiments.
How come Andromeda is coming towards us and will eventually collide when the universe is expanding and all galaxies are moving away from us?
Perhaps the universe is infinite and has always existed even though our level of understanding cannot comprehend. I speak for myself of course.
Why do ads exist
Our universe is just a drop in the endless infinity.
.. if photon is redshifted due to space expantion then it looses energy, so if traveled far enough its energy become 0, e.g. gone, vanished, e.g. from far enough distance our universe doesn't exsist
From our perspective the universe exists, and nothing does not exist here. To be or not to be, that is the question.
Try not to be: it's harder than you think!
Reminds me of the concept of the astronaut as he approaches the event horizon: gravitationally red-shifted into invisibility - and beyond!!!
Enters a different quantum state. Different dimension if you will, and pops out of our existence
There was a living mass of energy that transformed itself (or part of itself) into all the matter.
Question: How much time had passed before you were born? This question drove a physicist insane. True story. Don't get to thinking about it. It almost drove me mad.
Isaac Newton “This most beautiful system of the sun, planets and comets, could only proceed from the counsel and dominion of an intelligent and powerful Being. ” Principia Mathematica
July 05, 1687
He stated an opinion , nothing more. It cannot be backed up with facts.
The uncaused cause the creator of life.the one who made your organs before organs even existed bringing all things from nothing which really is everything
It wasn't a big bang, it was a big flash.
The absurdity is the presupposition that is possible for something to come from nothing.
Actually where was that nothing even situated so the nothing that creatrd everything also had to be created by something and that something also had to exist somewhere so where did that somewhere even exist if there was NOTHING
IK MY BRAIN DOESNT UNDERSTAND MY OWN SENTENCES
Nothing = antimatter ... the end is new begining...
The present future and past are just temporal... present can be change ,future can be change ,past also can be changed...
Time is relative and just on earth mean something...
The universe never had a beginning, and will never end....😊
Please make a video of you recieving the Nobel prize for your findings.
If the universe or multiverse is eternal then the question is absurd, the universe is equivalent to the concept of existence, and existence is self-necessitating and self-justifying.
lets not make assertions about it, it just is.
See, if opposites attract, I've actually got to be my opposite self sometimes. I make big decisions all the time.
By definition, everything can not start. Think about how should time start? There is no time to go from "no time" to "time". There can not be nothing and there has never been absolute permanence. The universe is eternal and has always existed and changed. There can be no cause for the universe as any possible cause is part of the universe. The universe is unconditional.
Me, personally. I think it could be possible for time to spontaneously start nowhere and from the absence of anything as there seams to be a natural tendency for time to progress, but then light speed and singularity also offer an impression of some ability for time to stop and lay dormant. In either scenario we appear arrive at a proposition of either infinite universes from nothing, or infinite universes within infinite universes. For me some infinities appear more plausible than others though.
From the state of rest (no time) - an order to movement - and the duration - from rest to the Stir - is first moment of time. More movement - more time expressed.
From Raja yoga meditation.
Fare thee well.
According to Bhagavad Gita (Hindu Philosophy) universe is cyclic. It is ALWAYS there. It cycles from Avyakta (unmainifest, or not seen) to Vyakta ( manifest or visible) state like the present state!!!
Big Bang to Singularity to Big Bang cycles?
Do HINDUS know more....??? Or just more gods....with more elephant head (maybe therefore bigger, smarter brains...haha )???