Amid growing migration crisis: SOS Méditerranée receives 'alternative Nobel Prize' | DW News
HTML-код
- Опубликовано: 6 июн 2024
- The winners of this year's Right Livelihood Award have been announced. The award - known as the alternative Nobel Prize - honors activists and organizations making the world a better place. It's gone to two people and two organisations.
The people are Eunice Brookman-Amissah from Ghana, whose pioneering discussions on women’s reproductive rights in Africa paved the way for improved safe abortion access. And Phyllis Omido from Kenya, who fights for environmental protection.
The groups are the environmental advocacy group Mother Nature Cambodia, and SOS Mediterrannee - for its rescue missions in the Mediterranean off of the coast of Libya. The NGO says it has saved tens of thousands of migrants from drowning this year alone. We take a closer look at their work.
At the same time, Interior ministers from European Union members states are meeting in Brussels to discuss asylum and immigration. They're trying to make progress on long-stalled reform of the bloc's policy on the issue.
EU countries have so far failed to find a common position. Leaders of frontline states including Italy and Greece say they can no longer deal with the large numbers of people arriving on their shores. Destination countries like Germany say they're also struggling.
One of the countries saying they can no longer deal with the number of people arriving is Greece. The camp on the Greek island of Lesbos has become a symbol of the difficulties facing the EU's migration policy. Our correspondent Emily Sherwin met with some of the people there.
For more on this we talk to Marie Walter-Franke, Research Fellow of Migration Management at the German council on foreign relations.
And we talk to SOS Méditerranée’s executive director Caroline Abu Sa’da.
#migration #eu #mediterranean
Subscribe: ruclips.net/user/deutsche...
For more news go to: www.dw.com/en/
Follow DW on social media:
►Facebook: / deutschewellenews
►Twitter: / dwnews
►Instagram: / dwnews
►Twitch: / dwnews_hangout
Für Videos in deutscher Sprache besuchen Sie: / dwdeutsch
As long as we are taking in and spreading them across Europe, they will never ever stop coming! This system looks like an invitation for many others to come
Mate…that’s exactly what it is and what these politicians want lol I think the worse is yet to come, this is a controlled takeover
They come because Turkey organise them
You forgot about the wars and weaponry we spread out to them?
The utter contempt of you
Exactly. We need to put enough pressure on Italy, Greece, Spain and the others to protect their own borders. It is unfair, but life is unfair, and nobody else can do it.
@@toyotaprius79
I dont think anyone wants to deny ukrainian immigrants, who flee war, and are mostly women and children. The rest dont flee war, they want to enter Europe for economic reasons, and are mostly young men - exactly the people who should take their responsibility and build up the countries where they come from.
The reason Europe is having this problem is because they have made it clear that everyone who wishes to come, can come. In other words the borders are wide open so,of course, if this will improve their standard of living, people will keep arriving, wouldn’t you?
Yes a lot of it is Merkel`s fault.
Why IS that problème for you ?!
They will keep coming until they decrease the standard of living to that in their home countries.
@@aghileshemdani3144Immigration creates polpulation explosion and overpopulation. Crreating poverty. Which is a problem all over Europe.
@@aghileshemdani3144for one he never said it was. For two. It’s men of military age not men and their families, these men have no interest in integrating to the culture and language of their destination nation. They bring extreme ideology’s they commit crimes they drain local resources, they require investment and education to become productive members of society but that will be the burden of the local tax payer… return on that investment is questionable. I’d say I personally have many issues with that,
DWs narrative of presenting Italy as far-right for not wanting to bear all the weight of the illegal migration from Africa is just out of touch with reality. Europe has been living in it's own buble in regards to the migration and energy policies, it's time to wake up and push back. Both the migration and the Russian/Chinese aggression.
Have any western counties the guts to stop migration?
We have. But it means war
They don't have the guts to stop exporting war for their resources
Poland is.
The people would have the guts the politicians don`t.
they'd have to stop the exploitation and start investing in those countries and yea no western countries want to do that. but when China does it they spin it as debt slavery.
SOS Méditerranée & others helping smugglers making the journey without having to waste resources on such petty things as sea-worthy boats, is making the human trafficking industry boom like never before.
“Helped rescued” = Aid and abetting people smuggling
Only 10% of the boats are intercepted by NGOs. Hardly a boom.
And I've seen plenty of boats reaching Lampedusa. You can go there and inspect them yourself. Find out how these "not sea-worthy boats" worth their way to the island.
@@nevarran That statistic does not reflect the enormous rise in absolute numbers.
Yeah, after the boom in business, entry-level obstacles such as client's fear for their life removed, smugglers now have a deluxe human trafficking line with a huge success rate and better boats who go in coordinated waves, as newcomers to the business take over the bigger demand dinghy low-cost travel (which still has a very good success rate, thanks to NGO taxiing).
Tell me, if you start seeing a few of these come in actual millions-worth very comfortable ferry boats or yachts, will you still argue that there hasn't been a rise in the trafficking business?
I don't know what the solution to this problem is. It's impossible to enforce the needed political reforms in authoritarian african countries, so they stop warring and stealing from their own people and develop beyond a need of constant aid, beyond uneducation fueled overpopulation, without somehow being called out for colonialism.
But to deny the current consequences of the "solutions" found by NGOs is to deny reality, and perpetuate what we can both agree is a problem; people leaving their poverty ridden homes and making refugee programs in Europe democratically unsustainable (programs not meant for economical migrants willing to ignore the host's laws and attempt to dupe good-will programs).
SOS Med should be blacklisted for assisting criminal organisations.
@@BernasLL There's no enormous rise. The numbers have been relatively steady in the last several years. And in 2015-16 there was a much bigger spike.
And again, you're blaming the NGOs, whose role is next to insignificant. You can stop all the NGO ships tomorrow and nothing will change. There may be a couple thousand more people drowning in the sea per year, but the overall numbers will barely reflect that. And even that sounds like an overestimation, the majority of the boats they intercept would have arrived anyway.
Giving accolades to NGOs who act like people smugglers is scandalous
They are working well for those who give them money.
she has to be prosecuted. enough problems in her own country France.
Yes, Tony Blair was awarded with the Charlemagne Prize for opening Britain's borders.
@@careytitan9097 Like Britain ever cared about other's border... And why is Britain in this discussion anyway?
@@vladn. EUs open borders and their funded NGO's are responsible for the mass immigration they are sending through Europe into UK via France. That is why!
The EU is being gradually destroyed.
Please DW, do a report on the latest situation in Sweden.
I disagree....It's not gradual😅
Trump called out the Sweden problem years ago.....and was called a liar/crazy by the MSM.
colonialism strikes back I guess
@@asoret9026 not all EU countries were/are colonialists!
Europe is allowing this, just as here in the US the current government is allowing the same thing
it is plain and simple destroying our countries to buy illegal votes for the left using our tax dollars
I live in Turkey and I want Syrian Arabs living in our country to go to Europe, especially America, Italy, Germany and France. Europe is a rich and safe region. Syrian Arab immigrants in our country are already constantly traveling to Europe via the Mediterranean and the Greece-Bulgaria border. Hopefully, we will send all Syrians to Europe as soon as possible. Turkey is not a suitable country for immigrants because there is no freedom here and human rights are violated. We will send all immigrants to Europe.
Yes, it is all done on purpose.
@@oktaytopal1064They are your neighbors. You can care for them.
EU is incapable to deal with illegally immigration problem.The never ending talks is riducilus.The unger among EU citizens is growing...
I live in Turkey and I want Syrian Arabs living in our country to go to Europe, especially America, Italy, Germany and France. Europe is a rich and safe region. Syrian Arab immigrants in our country are already constantly traveling to Europe via the Mediterranean and the Greece-Bulgaria border. Hopefully, we will send all Syrians to Europe as soon as possible. Turkey is not a suitable country for immigrants because there is no freedom here and human rights are violated. We will send all immigrants to Europe.
@@oktaytopal1064 Turkey is a great and rich country. You can keep your brother sunni muslims
@@taxidriver1972The whole world knows about inflation in Turkey. Our currency has lost a lot of value. Immigrants who come here complain about this situation. As Turkish people, we do not want to see immigrants among us. They are Arab, we are Turkish. Our cultures are very different. And because we don't want them, hundreds of immigrants flee to Europe every day. Europe is rich enough and cares about human rights. Now it's time for you to welcome these Syrian Arabs into your country.
We are heading for far right governance in the EU if its not stopped .Europe is overcrowed as it is
In Sweden even the center left wants to stop migration, and without doubt the center right. At this part any reasonable political party should want to stop it. But the far right will probably take the lead. This is the situation here. They propose, the center right implement, the center left agree.
There’s very little population growth in Europe. If not for migration, it would already be in decline.
@@wyganter
We need policies to increase fertily and we need migration. But we dont need illegal immigrants without skill, and from cultural contexts colliding with everything Europe is. We need high quality, educated and civilized people from the middle class in the countries they come from, who understands and supports the concept of liberal democracy.
@@wyganteri am perfectly fine with that....... Is that clear? The choice is between survival or not and I am very willing to return to the 30s to ensure survival and I can assure a lot are and their numbers are growing..... Also we can always choose who enter. Why not take Argentina, Chile ecc?
@@30yoboomer .....you need i llegal immigrant for l abour ...
This can be stopped in one day with some balls
Fair share is 0 immigrants. Not one more than 0 immigrant.
All young men!
Trojan horse is what it is!
France, Germany and Italy - all housing HQs for Mediteranee - can pull corporate charters and start prosecuting these NGOs as the people smugglers they are.
Stop the boats from setting sail in first place. Jesus Christ do we not a navy in Europe?
The NGO's are exacerbating this problem 😮
They’re struggling because in 2013-14 they opened the flood gates so now that they wanna close them again the flow isn’t slowing down
Can Western countries stop bombing their countries ?
They opened and then, they posted them back to Turkey
My right arm will be strained on the next voting round. I almost understand how Germany ended up in the situation it did in the 30’s. What is the endgoal of all of this ? Everyone racist ?
Germany in the 1930s had nothing to do with immigration, just say you don’t like seeing Africans in your country, both Legal and Illegal.
Everything is racist.
@@SuperKillerdogWoosh.
So at very least they'll get 2 year's warning to get here. Just an absolute act of treason
@@factsoverfear9771 They don't look like people bringing civilization to savage, quite the opposite...
Abolish the right to Asylum now. Cancel the Geneva Convention. Let‘s have a referendum about those two laws NOW.
Just put them on the next ship back. Sooner or later they don't have enough money to pay for another travel.
The EU is a clown show.😊
Exactly like america and russia. Literally same
Like you 😂
That's why we left, unfortunately some clowns got into Parliament and won't leave.
@@BlackGriffin195 you left coz you don’t want immigrants. European ones. You preferred the rest of the world. Look where this decision brought you. Economic collapse and social instability. It’s really break my heart to see England choose other rather than us. We was your best choice for doing business with…
Corruption must be at all time high in Europe.
Unbelievably high. Trafficking is bringing loads of money.
10 out of 10 friend
Germany is funding a lot of NGOs. The globalists are screwing Europe. If there is no borders then there is no country.
It's not just the EU region, the US has also got a huge influx mostly from Venezuela. Even though I dislike Trump, but I somehow agreeing with him on this issue, because there should be a limit to this. Additionally, EU's frontline is very difficult to defend.
Trump 2024
Every time there's an increase in immigration in U.S., legal or illegal, two years later the economy *increases* by 2%.
The US has the money honey
@@sadimasson8734I thought the US is going to have a gov shutdown after September 30th.
Usa entire population is emigrants native American are very few
Fly them home problem solved
They are too relaxed in handling this situation… i would arrest them all and turn them back to their country of origin. It would be effective
The winds of change are blowing mighty strong
Yes Wind of change by kicks out france from Africa
u have no time. Do or die. Protect Europe , else it would turn into Somalia or Uganda.
@@susudarakelol
They could try and turn the boats back or attack the people smuggling gangs from the start and surely that would reduce this
Simple reason, that is where Father Christmas lives.
Only people fleeing war should be allowed in, the rest depoted
The anger has not reached the level of Germans in the 1930s
Muamar Gaddafi had told the US and Europe that if he were deposed from power and Libya destabilized, this exact thing would happen. And now Europe is struggling with the mess my American government and NATO created.
Perhaps now that France Afriqe is being dismantled by Africans themselves, the African countries can work amongst themselves to solve the problems, economic cooperation to eliminate poverty and bring prosperity to the peoples of Africa.
You just forgot to mention that Africa is in this situation because of 300 years of EUROPEAN colonialism and imperialism. Europe deserves to deal with this issue.
It's not Libyans fleeing to Europe, and they are travelling through many, many routes not even touching Libya!
@@sacul220 You forgot to mention Africa was a mess before the Europeans came.
Oh yeah. Then instead of letting them sort things out on their own, the best course of action was to kill, rape, enslave, kidnapp and rob them of everything. Congrats on the flawless logic, bro. Plus, what you say is absolutely not true. Africa was the center of science and research for millenia before Europe even could feed itself. Step down from your entitlement high horse and go learn about the world. And by world I mean the actual world, not just EU-USA.@@eminencerain848
@@eminencerain848You forgot to mention that Europe extracted huge amounts of wealth from Africa. The dividends should be reinvested into the continent.
I have a serious question. Is it not too late already? The damage has already been done to Europe?
Because it's being done by design
Capitalism wants to minimize the cost of labor. What’s wrong with that? You a communist?
Fitting avatar.
One World Government, One World Religion, has been in the planning since 1971.
By the World Economic Forum.
SOS Méditerranée - a €10m profit making human trafficking organisation receives an 'alternative Nobel Prize' - LOL
11:09 Can someone explain what exactly a push back is and why is it not allowed?
Japan don't have this problem. Despite Pakistan and the Philipines have their greedy eyes on the japanese labour marked. Japan still keep them out. And nobody drowns between Vladivostok and Japan. What is the japanese secret success formula?
Balls and firm law and memorandum enforcement. Theyll let in who they think will be valuable to their society.
Well, the main problem right now is the Polish visa scandal
what is it?
@@mistrzwewszystkim oh, Polish embassies in non-EU countries had sold work visas to people at a bribe of 5k€ a person. That's why they issued more work visas over the past years than the rest of the EU combined. Hundreds of thousands. And those people then go over the border to the west (which they're not allowed to with a work visa but there are no border controls in the Schengen area) to apply for asylum. This got discovered recently and might make the Polish government lose the coming election.
@@MrTohawk That's utter BS, there were like 200 illegal visas total and perpetrators apprehended. Poland did issue over 300.000 proper visas mainly for Turks, Ukrainians, Kazakhs and such, only around legal 2000 visas for people from African countries. This lie is perpetrated to hurt our gov't in the coming elections. Some feebs fall for it LOL.
@@mistrzwewszystkim Nothing we have elections coming so a "visa scandal" was invented. There were 200 illegal visas but they talk about 350.000 LOL These 350.000 are normal documented visas for countries like Turkey, Ukraine, Kazakhstan etc. only 2000 legal visas for documented, Africans.
@@MrTohawk ..then you are not againt illégal immigration you againt immigrant as whole ??
They keep talking about spreading, but it should be stopped.
HELP ..!
WE ARE ..FULL .!
Cyprus, is already with more than 6% of the population loaded by ..emigrants .
Not to mention , a bout the north occupied areas of the island, been occupied by Turkey since 1974 .
HELP .!
Solve the problem permanently ❌. Postpone the problem ☑
EU don’t know the power of no.
Ship them back. But on a safe ship that wont sink
Looks like u don’t need a passport or anything to arrive in Europe anymore, this is caos
People who try get visa the legal way get denied. People who jump in back of a truck get EU citizenship simple...
This wont work and will create very very many problems. Of course its totaly understandable for people to come here.. but everybody wants to come.. but everybody cant.. so the doors will stay open till the problems get too big. We cant solve the worlds problems by inviting everybody! Personal opinion of course. I think we need to help the people to help themselfs.
Africa need capitalism, industry, jobs, production and real export. Migration is not a legitimate export industry.
Africa is the most Capitalist continent on the planet. Lol
@@SuperKillerdogyeah guess who turned them capitalist
USA
Africa needs Birth Control. End of discussion!
Schengen is doomed
Uk is copping it too
They can just stop asylum programs, and take it case by case. Send everyone back. Sure we feel bad for them in their countries, we can help fix it at the cause it's not a solution to absorb them all. It'll never end since there's always people that want to leave their country.
we already have a system to take it case by case, it's called legal migration! 😂
@@ziriwalker1032So true, I mean .. you're right just cancel asylum all together. I remember reading that the EU are more open to asylum because they have an aging population and lacking workers. We should really look into why people aren't hving kids and why it's so difficult to be alive and why these poor countries can still have kids ..
the UN charter on refugees was written by Europe .
Because nobody want them atm
@chilloutcentral2907 From ChatGPT; Britain is part of Western Europe. The United Kingdom (UK), which includes England, Scotland, Wales, and Northern Ireland, is located in the western part of the European continent. It is an island nation that is geographically situated in Western Europe. Western Europe typically includes countries such as the UK, France, Germany, Spain, Portugal, Belgium, the Netherlands, and others in the western part of the European continent.
Glad the nordic countries isnt included in this mess. 😅
We are glad to have our own little club.
What about Britain? This is about EU. Britain not minding it's business again?
@@30yoboomer You are clearly not, since the ship's name is Ocean Viking.
@@vladn.
...what? I just meant that I am glad that the Nordic countries (with its own distinct culture and sense of being very closely related) is its own part of Europe. Not western, southern, central, eastern, etc.
The part about mess was mostly a joke.
@@30yoboomer I thought you implied migration is not their job. But what's the point of these divides? We could debate for hours what Central Europe means.
Deport deport deport
They have taken from the public vs helping. Do they don't know how to.
The Nobel Prize is a bad reference.
Saudi Arabia has it the best way, huh? xd
I think the North Sentinelese have a good immigration policy
That’s a lot of doctors and lawyers 🫠
Why they swim even to Italy instead of Libia, if it’s closer! They work as smuggles.
Before 1983, there were few Nigerians in Europe until the oil deal that put the country into financial slavery.
Before 2023 there were fewer Iraqi, Afghanistanis etc,..
Before 2011 there were fewer Syrians, Yemanis and Libyans etc, ..
You get the picture??
Europeans nowadays have no interest in history. They genuinely think the world has always been like this and they deserve all the riches their ancestors spent hundreds of years stealing from the world. Spoiled people have no notion of merit.
The oil deal? Nigerian oil is state controlled.
Meetings after meetings why keep talking about it just DO SEND THEM BACK.
How are the companies going to cut cost caused by Russian sanction? by flooding labour market with supplies!!
Why they don't go to Spain and Portugal which is even closer?
Why are human trafficking criminals awarded? Who fund them?
USA, thanks to neocons, Gaddafi was killed... The EU is the nearest destination from Africa😅😅😅
Insane europeans favoured Hilary Clinton over Trump. That was her war, it was personal for her because she didnt like Gaddafi. Trump didnt start any way, and did what he could to stabilize the region. He also told Germany to stop buying russian gas, and he told us we couldnt rely on them forever for military protection. The best president in a long time for Europe
What has happed to Gaddafi bank account?
Circus and chaos
Um, Italy is anti-immigration? Their birth rate isn't so high, unemployment is out the roof among the able-bodied, healthy, employable age
range, such that the smart ones leave the country for greener pastures (don't get me wrong, Italy is a beautiful country), the society & economy can't go on the way it does forever.
Why no families..???
Eu needs deeply Nigel farage
LOL, the wanker that sunk the UK? No thanks.
Because some minority groups are convinced that a larger population is great for economic growth and contraception is discouraged.... Problem is that it doesn't work when population growth outgrows its finite resources.
Well you decided Turkey should host these ''so called victims'' (somehow 99% of them are middle aged single male) instead of making Turkey another barrier.
It was your own lack of vision. No need for further explanation.
Thats the price to pay when YOU intervene other countries business..
Think about Libya,
European Union is Finnished .
No, it is Sweded.
Hahahah😂😂😂😂😂 who cares😂😂😂
European Union is turning into mongoloid countrys , one wonders why all the soldiers died in WW just to give the whole place for free in 2023
It's unstoppable.
Oh yes but it means wayyy harder actions to do. In the end more fear than they are started.
Not at all we will start showing them what real far right means.
Have you tried far right? (especially genuine one, not just wimps who are being accused of being such by some ragebait hungry media)
Why are you even asking the question, just look at the facts they all in plain sight, skyrocketing costs, lack of infrastructure, this is what you get when its a free for all.
“The Strange Death of Europe” by Douglas Murray
Prognosis for Europe anyone???
Doomsday
They do not appear to have what is now required to save themselves.
It’s a problem because Italy has failed to deal with the root of the problem Which Tunisia Europe needs a deal with North Africa to stop them getting in to Europe
Why not work with the countries and help fix the overal problem?
Muammar Gaddafi: Missed me? 😂
Remember the Arab spring? Europe destroyed their home, now they are coming to Europe!
They destroyed their own home, self inflicted problems.
Imagine migrating to Europe legally is harder than illegally
These good doers won't look after its if it's own people ..let the boats sink .. it will soon stop this nonsense. . Australia did it
What is the plan EU?!
How long can this go on for before every system stops working.
Surely everyone can see this is totally unsustainable and will eventually lead to catastrophe?!
The key solution lies in Indonesia's political view of the world because Indonesia is the political beacon of Asia, the Middle East, and Africa. I don't know why Indonesia is so politically powerful in the eyes of the world but it is a fact. When Indonesia speaks, Asia along with the Middle East and Africa listen.
My deepest apologies for the inconvenience. 🙏🙏
Army should get involved and strict them with and be armed then we see how all will turn back
Why tf is Romania shown as part of the migration route when it’s not true ? 💀
We must stop this war in Ukraine
Arm Ukraine so they can kick out the Russians and go back to feeding the world.
Arrest the crew immediately and destroy the vessels
Shout up madam... EU are looking for people to work in your company...
The common solution they will come up with is amnesty
iberia not an option anymore?
Omg 1 million migration only one years😮
Smugglers are doing flash deals........
10 males for the price of 1
Somebody needs torpedo that damn ship.
😂
There is route from Belarus to Poland that is missing from your map. Oh it is not a problem Polish people took care of it issue, despite EU objections. This is all planed, mix all of Europe with immigrants. No more nationalities, easy to control member states.
Turkey organise the islamization of Europe 🇪🇺
our reporter talks like Arnold Schwa
an agreement without involving all of the north African countries is a waste of time.
Why's the EU and NATO still occupying most African countries and stifling economic growth?
The only thing that is stifling the economic growth in Africa is their low intelligence and lack of knowledge and education. Combine that with the typical African greed and selfishness and you have exactly the mess they deserve.
Occupying? LOL. Yes they should be left to prosper like Zimbabwe. L
No sound