Libya After Gaddafi: Nato’s Failed State (Documentary)
HTML-код
- Опубликовано: 5 сен 2024
- Since the removal of Muammar Gaddafi in 2011, Libya has plunged into relentless turmoil, unable to establish stable political structures. The initial attempt to overthrow Gaddafi’s regime spiraled into a complex civil war with multiple phases.
From 2014, Libya has been divided between rival administrations, leading to the rise of numerous militias and a pervasive state of lawlessness. In this episode of African Biographics, we explore the intricate web of conflict and instability that has defined Libya's landscape since Gaddafi's fall.
**************************************************************************
Sources:
ULF LAESSING Understanding Libya Since Gaddafi
Laessing, Ulf. Understanding Libya Since Gaddafi . Hurst. Kindle Edition.
www.dandc.eu/e...
reliefweb.int/...
www.africanews...
blogs.timesofi...
researchcentre...
en.minbarlibya...
www.bbc.com/ne...
www.reuters.co...
www.cfr.org/gl...
www.aljazeera.... - 2015 Article
www.bbc.com/ne...
www.arabnews.c...
sg.news.yahoo....
www.aa.com.tr/...
www.britannica...
www.gisreports...
www.swp-berlin...
****************************************************************************
Map Graphics: vecteezy.com
***************************************************************************
Music:
RUclips Studio
Epidemic Sound
*****************************************************************************
Videos:
Obama: • Obama's biggest mistak...
Migrants: • Migrants being sold as...
• Libya floods: No easy ... - Floods
• Libya 'Winning The Fig... - isis/dignity
• Libya: Cameron's Warni... - cameron warning for gaddafi
• David Cameron's disast... - cameron error
• Libya: A decade on the... - introduction, 10 seconds, then obama?
• Ten years on since the... - instability
• How Libya spiralled in... - quick summary
• Clinton on Qaddafi: We... - hillary clinton, we came he died
• Hillary Clinton on Libya - hilary on obama’s interview - 1:00 - 02:00
• Libya’s Haftar announc... - khalifa haftar presidential election nomination nov 2021
• Libyans celebrate 13th... - anniversary
#Gaddafi #NATO #KHALIFAHAFTAR
Very educative. Thanks
Thank you for your kind words
MUSLIM TRAITORS AND COWARDS HELPED KUFAR DESTROY THEIR OWN COUNTRY
Thank you for this video. I am Egyptian and my mother and her family lived in Libya for decades. My grandmother passed away during the coalition bombings of Tripoli.
Gaddafi was no saint but the majority of Libyans lived very well under his regime... It is a real shame to see what Libya has become since...
MUSLIM TRAITORS AND COWARDS HELPED KUFAR DESTROY THEIR OWN COUNTRY
Can you name any leader of a nation dead or alive who is/was a Saint? - why is always being painted as or implied to be some sort of monster?
What a "fantastic success" the overthrow of Mummar Gaddafi was for the people of Libya. A country that had the lowest crime rate and the best living standards in the continent of Africa. The people of Libya will never forgive Cameron, Sarkozy, Obama and NATO.
True
are you a Libyan ? did you felt what Libyans felt under forty years under the rule of
Gaddafi ?
@murcusblue4212 they felt alive and not running from thugs on the street when trying to go to supermarket lol
USA destroyed and colonized Lybia it will take many generations to recover from this imperial aggression.
@@murcusblue4212I think people forget that the Arab Spring wasn't western propaganda and a lot of people hated Gaddafi at the time, even if they now view his rule with some rose tinted glasses. It wasn't some small group opposed to him and NATO did oppose Gaddafi but they instituted the no fly zone at the behest of the large group of people opposing him. Gaddafi and his administration didn't really hold a sizeable majority from the start of the Civil War. Lydia wasn't alone either, similar was happening across the Arab world in part due to global issues with oil based economies and thanks to the great recession
I'm sure many will hold it against the western powers in general. Although I do wonder how many supported Gaddafi while he was on the run? While he was in power?
and Europeans said that they don't want refuges, so don't create them then
Now they about to get more Palestinian diversity
Should tell other dictators in Africa to stop then.....Islamic extremists also. 🤷
@@billyyank5807 tell dictators to stop what ?? U invade their countries and create refuges , those extremists who fund them ?? Be real
@@billyyank5807 stop creating wars and invasions, because they displace the unarmed civilians, who then flood your civilization as immigrants
Well said. The terrible irony.
I am so happy to listen to an african voice giving a nuanced, fact-based telling of these complex conflicts. I bow my head. Kudos, Sir!
MUSLIM TRAITORS AND COWARDS HELPED KUFAR DESTROY THEIR OWN COUNTRY
This is hard to watch. This and many such NATO casualties are the reason why I hate US foreign policy so much
Then please stay away from the U.S. 😊
Nato isn't the U.S. ....the U.S
Isn't nato.
@@billyyank5807 US is a major part of NATO and is hugely responsible for large scale genocide is multiple countries
But the USA sponsored the Nato and he who calls the piper plays the tune.
They control Nato
@@billyyank5807 Gladly, if you people don't interviene in every conflicts that occurs in the 21st century
Since the fall of Libya there has been an increase of Jihadist in the Sahel specifically in Niger ,Mali and Burkina Faso ,more migrant getting trafficked and enslaved.
I'm not surprised the West did this but the fact the African Union couldn't do anything is annoying.
Part of the reason it got so bad was thanks to Gaddafi. Not only did he back a bunch of terrorist groups but he also used tribal groups in the Sahel as mercenaries and the collapse of his regime lead to his supporters fleeing to the Sahel with weapons they got from Gaddafi. Much like in Iraq a lot of formerly government people like soldiers and police took their weapons with them when the regime collapsed which ended up either being used by former police/soldiers but also by the terrorists those weapons got sold to.
I also wonder how much the African Union gets blocked by outside powers. France has long been the peacekeeper in west Africa ans across the Sahel, they use military interventions to curry favor with their puppets and Russia has been similar since their Soviet days through today only they use mercenaries like Wagner. If the African Union kept the peace then Russia wouldn't get control of useful mines and France would lose control of their puppets and that could threaten their neocolonial empire
The West intentionally did it.
who are you blaming it on? Have you not Read the Documents,Footages that came out of there, Lots of Whites Contractors were doing Slavry they had the Africans in outside jails.
@@arthas640how very interesting, which way did the Sahel escape Libya. My friend is a mercenary who was there when Gaddafi fell. He was telling me there was a 3 day convoy out of Libya. The Arabs were marching certain black men into the desert and shooting them for siding with Gaddafi. He was also in Congo when Ebola hit and got dropped on a runway picked up by men in a BMW with AKs and lead to a jungle camp to train a Milisha. Think he's in Mali rn 🤔
I can't stand the sight of Obama and his husband Ɓig Mike. He's the 2nd worse president after Biden and Jimmy Carter would be the third worst.
Very similar thing happened to Iraq after Saddam Hussein was removed.
There are a lot of things about Gaddafi l didn't care for, but Libya was far better with him than without him.
The revolution was highjacked. I bet they are regretting ever doing now. Gaddafi was no saint but he looks pretty good now as things stand. Lord help Africa.
Exactly 💯 majority of them regretted i was there before
Hijacked by what? Ever since the 80s the us has been funding and arming these people, they helped most of them flee the country and provided them with all the support they needed in the us of a. Something most americans don't get. Not only did the us prioritze destroying other countries rather then helping their own, during a time where wealth inequality drugs and crime were a major problem for the citizens of their own country, they actively tried to make another country worse of then them with the money they should have spent on healthcare, rrcovery programs and opening up opportunities for troubled children and young adults.
Yes I'm libyan and I can reaffirm.
Make no different he now in hell for his sins
He has no sins@@justiceriser8970
It seems that America is happy to spread democracy in Libya
Now we in Libya live under the mercy of the militia
I remember Boris Johnson was caught on film speculating that his rich friends could move in and set up luxury resorts similar to Dubai in the Sirte region, once all the local population had finished killing each other and cleared away the dead bodies. He laughed as he was saying it.
It proves that Arab spring was engineered by Britain and America
I was on a destroyer launching star shells rounds over the battlefield in Sirte, Libya in October 2016. When I came home years later no one had heard about the battle. It was one month before our elections in November 2016 and Libya had Hillary Clinton’s foul stench all over it. Our corrupt press didn’t want to make her look bad so they ignored it. Oh I almost forgot, we came across people on rafts floating hundreds of miles away from shore on our way to go fight.
He said that?
Post a link to the clip here.
Smh 🤦🏽♀️
Was literally just interested in learning about Gaddafi today and this video popped up. Bless this channel and Africa
This statement has never left my mind ever since i heard it
"no matter how bad things could be, there is always something people can do to make it worse." And that's what happenes to Libya. Sometimes we complain about things with a utopian vision only to face the harsh reality.
Tatenda, Proud of you Homie!
Ramba wakadzvanya, vazive zvavakaita muAfrica!🌍🌍🌍🇿🇼
They should talk abt gukurahundi
Representing Botswana 🇧🇼
This is amazing
Powerful documentary
Basic True Story
My Prayers For Libya 🙏🙌
Keep Bringing More
Its not the true story
love this channel man, there arent even that many good books on current libya. Well done!
Thank you James
I saw this was premiering but waited to watch it on playback. As a Briton (English) I feel ashamed for my country's "intervention" in Libya and appalled at the results. Thank you for another great video.
there is nothing to be ashamed of , Gaddafi has to go and we as Libyan failed to build a modern country and we only to blame
@@murcusblue4212 Thank you for saying that, but we just roared in there and tore everything down and left chaos behind us. It's easy to tear things down but so hard to build them up.
@murcusblue4212 he was a autocrat, he wanted to get rid of the world bank and use a gold standard for money. If he'd of got his way and sold off the oil you'd probably be one of the richest countries. It's a funny one his goal was quite good but he was fairly brutal to the people but he kept it better than the last 10+ years
You shouldn't. You didn't do it. Don't let these propaganda bots shame you.
The Western hypocrites murdered Gaddafi, only to plunge Libya into chaos😂😂
And complaining about migration
Fact 😢
Gaddafi killed by his own people and you know that.
@@wrestlinganime4life288they deserve the immigration! I hope they get replaced with the new diversity
They will never allow an African country to succeed.
This chaos i noticed in Libya 🇱🇾 was this democracy they West wanted for the Libyans peoples?? 😳
This is really sad and heartbroken 💔.
It's what Libyans wanted. Out from under Gaddafi. Not our fault ya'll can't get along.
These horrors happen every time a stabilizing dictator is taken out of the picture without any regard to leaving behind a power vacuum or what happens after the dictator is gone. And to think he was brought down to "protect" the Libyan people. No matter what you or I think of Gadaffi and the difference between his earlier years and the later ones, foreign intervention invariably makes things worse; the only ones who can liberate a people are that people themselves.
Thank you for yet another quality, informative video.
Sometimes it fails, sometimes it succeeds. Look at most revolutions and you'll find the same happening where someone opposed to the regime backs the rebels: even for the US the revolutionaries were heavily backed by the French and others. When the Soviets took over eastern Europe they'd just put the local communist party in power the same way the US puts their allies and/or local democratic reformers in power.
The problem is in some countries theres massive problems making a dictatorship necessary: Saddam for example had been carefully co-opting and/or crushing Islamist groups and kept minorities weak and scattered, once he was taken down the religious and ethnic problems came rising to the surface. Same story in Afghanistan where even the Taliban is having issues with ethnic conflicts which the Soviets and monarchy also had to deal with but got pushed aside when the squabbling ethnic groups united against a common foe.
I think the presence of a strong, centralized and very popular revolutionary movement that has wide spread support usually is more likely to succeed similar to the soviets than most rebellions which are a scattered group of grievances coming together against a common foe.
This usually happens when a dictator completely takes all the power. With him gone it creates a vacuum as everyone wants to control and rule. That's why dictatorship isn't beneficial for long term. Empowering people lessens chance of creating a vacuum
Libya was no longer stable by the time of his death. The country had fallen into a civil war.
@@juliankraus1011 as a libyan let me tell u that its Not a civil war its a proxy war among Nato nations since each of them has his own goals.
Great stuff so far!
Thanks
الرجل لا يموت
الثوري لا يموت
الشجاع لا يموت
والبطل لا يموت
يموت الجبان
يموت الخائن
ويموت المرتد
ويموت العميل
اما الشجعان
هم احياء
Yes Gaddafi is very close to Gaddar. His parents gave him the perfect name.
My mans last words were, "What did I do to you?". Nothing. Nothing at all.
A great loss for Africa, may His soul rest in peace ❤❤❤❤❤
Libyan people are very clever 😂😂😂 ... they are now enjoying the Democracy after bringing down Gaddafi 😂😂😂
Love your documentaries ❤
Thank you so much
NATO offered Libya the poisoned apple decorated as "Democracy and Human Rights"
Thirteen years later, Libya is still choking on the apple while NATO is cashing out on the cheap cheap oil.
The problem is no accountability for 'mistakes' and 'intervention'.
Try to prosecute a U.S. president. They have immunity now, thanks to our Supreme Court 😊
History is a circle, it goes round and round until we learn from it..... I wish Africa can learn from the past
Lybia should sue nato
Please and please, US and NATO agitated the war in and destroyed Libya. Since then Libya is in state of chaos to the advantage and interest of the West not the Libyans. It has become very difficult to correct. Stability, prosperity and peace in Libya is very distant.
Exactly it's the west who created unrest in Libya contrary to what's being explained here
If Gadaffi was alive, Africa would have been in a better place by now, like Bank of Africa, currency, defense, and many developments to make Africa independent of the West.He was a threat to the west
Bruh
Other major African leaders didn't like him and especially after the stunts he did in Chad and Uganda.
@@SLDFMechWarrioryou lying Jew
Dude, Africa would've remained the same way it was.
If he couldn't bring African leaders together for over 30 years what makes guy think anything would've changed?
@@Chrome_008xGadaffi was no less bad as other African leaders, these people that believe that Gaffi nonsense of a united Africa was feasible plan are surely living in lalaland
@@Chrome_008x he was the Pan-African visionary leader more than any African leader, and this was the major threat to the west, just think outside the box unbiased, u ll see
Gaddafi was the best leader Africa could ever had...yes, he was eccentric and little crazy, but the man loved Africa and africans from above everything. Libya was strong african country...after him, Libya died...so, well done libians...
He loved African that’s why he was in conflict over land with Chad right? Sponsoring rebels against the Chad government because he wanted a strip of land? Is that who you call the “the best leader Africa could ever had”
He even supported Nelson Mandela when no one else would. When Mandela fought against apartheid in SA, and the uk, Israel and the US designated him as a terrorist
@@warh1story563 is that why he was held bent on seizing Chadian land?
I wonder people like op who comment this know what Gaddafi did in Africa or just ignore it
He supported conflicts in Liberia and Sierra leone
What Africa is going through in the hand of America, china , Russia and west is terrible.
And you not talk about what it is going through with its own leaders blacks to be specific. The likes of Mugabe, M7, Paul Biya and many other autocratic politicians around the continent
Africa was doing it to themselves long before the U.S. was even formed.
@@billyyank5807
Exactly.
Why isn’t no fly zone imposed to isreal if the US care so much about civilian lives?
Well, that's the thing isn't it. They clearly don't. They're just pure evil liars.
Wtf are you talking about? This is about Gaddafi and Libya. Not Israel.
Are you a member of the Israeli military being a troll? Go elsewhere. Stop spreading genocide.
3:11 there's your answer
Thanks for putting the truth out there . This video was. so informative and very well made. I look forward to watching many more of your videos. Thank you!
I really sympathise with the Libyans. The downfall of Libya was of 2 reasons.
1. The Libyan people did not believe in their leader Col. Muammar- Al Ghazzafi.
2. They believed some other foreign Country's ĝovt. ie.USA.
Ireally pity the Libyans. They had a Gem of a President (Col. Muammar Al Ghazzafi )
But some Libyans believed in the hypocracy of America. Now what is the state of that progessed country.
May Allah bless Libya and restore Libya to a prosperous country.
Libyans will feel it for long time. They were so successful and wealthy.
"We came, we saw, he died." What message is this sending to us as Africans. A man who had ideas of taking his country to the next level, is brutally killed and someone starts laughing. And they say they supported human rights.
Your videos are consistently excellent. Very thorough.
The Libya people will never forget what west had done to there own country but it's too late
I hope the people of Iran will never going to do the same mestake
But I think the people of Iran had already done the same mestake in 1979 Islamic revolution
Good, let them remember what happens when they support terrorists against us.
Iranian don't want a revolution. They just want more freedom which the ulema doesn't wants to give. Iranian also don't want infighting with their neighbours that's why they choose reformist president
The Libyan people are the ones who started a civil war with the aim of overthrowing Gaddafi.
@@LunaticTheCatThey were mercenaries who were paid to fight, most of them non-Libyans
@@user-tr9th6pc2ySource? Go ahead.
Oh Tatenda. The knowledge i receive everytime i come across your videos is fulfilling..
What a well put rich piece. Gaddafi's death still remains a big blow. Kudos for the unbiased information.
Why does US want to intertere in other countries.
Do you understand history as far back as we humans have kept records? The US is an infant on the grand scale of things compared to most nations and their history of interference and conquest over each other.
There's nothing new under the Sun.
Oil habibi
Just to show the world that you can do anything against the illiterate people.
Marvelous Documentary ❤
Great leader Nice person Lion King gadaafi rip 😢😢😢 long live Libya ❤❤❤❤
But you great leader died like a poor stray dog.
@@timirbiswas3834 Indian Hindus cartoon character Indian Hindus cartoon network shows Indian Hindus servant in my country Indian Hindus servant in the whole world modi butcher modi cartoon character 😂😂😂😂 from Saudi Arabia
Thanks 😊
In that 2009 marathon speech by Gadaffi at United Nations he endorsed Barack Obama and even said that if it was up to Africa Barack Obama should be the president tull eternity and few years later the very same Obama eliminated Gadaffi in a literal sense and that should be a lesson to everyone that not the person or people you back up might be the same person who puts a knife in your back. May Gadaffi's soul rest in peace and fact of the matter is that Africa is poor without Gadaffi and we need someone like Gadaffi but not as a dictator just a good and juts human being who looks after his people. Gadaffi and Mugabe had Africa's interests at heart even though they might have been brutal to their opponents but Africa came first for them and the same can't be said about the current bunch of African leaders who are nothing but puppets of the west.
Dear Humans, we will all die, so please help each other stay long on this heartless, greedy planet as long as you can, because you have a reason to be alive, my friend.
Another great video! I really enjoy watching these as Africa and it's complexities are rarely presented without a bias in the western world.
As for Libya, what can you say? I hate to say this but some countries deserve a dictator (looking at MENA) else this is what happens. Whatever vested interest the west has they are one of the parties who have blood in their hands for causing this mess. At the same time the various political parties and factions within Libya are also responsible for this mess.
Best wishes, i hope Libya and Libyans find peace soon!
Thank you,well explained
This channel is a school,,, thanks comrade
I’m quite the fan of the Reagan - era Qaddafi, in the years when Abu Nidal ran an entire base camp in the Libyan Desert,Muamar had emerged from organising the murder of Lebanon’s greatest Shia / Amal cleric,..and he used to sport an impressive hairstyle seemingly modeled on Jermaine or Tito Jackson. Or Albert Collins..
What
Another Great video but is it possible in the future we get a video about Isaias Afwerki or the birth of Eritrea from Independence. Keep up the great work
I think you should make a documentary on King Idris of Libya
That would be interesting
Thank you very informative
One thing that was not discussed in this video is the precarious loyalties of the tribal leaders in southern and central Libya. The nation has essentially separated along its old provincial lines. Whoever can consolidate power with the tribal leaders will have the advantage. The GNU is also backed by Qatar, Turkey, and Italy. France is alleged to support Haftar.
Tatenda we appreciate your trailblazing work never stoop what youre doing
How feeling Libyan all people’s right now?
Democracy is so good for humanity. Congratulations Libyans 🎉
Libya is going through a “phase”. In a few decades everything will be sorted out. One way or another.
This is why i didn't want us to join a club like nato, i don't like how they do things.
Very informative , I hope the 🇱🇾 people get a united country 🖤💚❤️
How much these people have accumulated libyan gold, through its bank reserves and oil refinaries? Any answer to that!! Its all about the money.
There is an arab economic channel. If I remember correctly, hey mentioned lots of undeclared oil was leaving Libya unfortunately.
Thank you bro your content is top notch👍
0:00~ 0:15 The Moments of War Criminals.
They are why the Ukraine war was started against Russia
Well it is sad that we are being taught bad things about Gaddafi and I don’t understand why the western media tells us bad things about Gaddafi as if they are Africans so I don’t listen to what Americans have to say about him because they are not Africans we know who this man was as Africans so my best advice is that when ever being taught about African history you must consider learning about it from African people who would know what they are talking about and we need to understand that the bad things said about him where just signs of propaganda against him because he knew their plans to use Africans for labour and wealth gain, and he challenged that which led to his death, for those who don’t know the western countries used Libyans to turn against Gaddafi and wanted a democracy, not understanding that the America and Libya have different dynamics, it does not mean that democracy works for other nations it would also work For Libya
Long live Gaddafi viva
Thanks for your nice videos
Could you list some useful books and materials to read about Libya?
Living in Brazil is pretty hard to find good books about Gaddafi without the "west point of view".
Great great material! Congrats! 🎉
"We came.We saw. He died." They laugh and Lybia cry.
Thank you
So, please dear America, is Libya better off with Gaddafi dead? I'm a former Lost Boy of Sudan and I hate Human pain. Is Libya better off without Gaddafi today? Only God knows because we are too busy working to survive here in the west.
Something reminds me about South Sudan when I keep listening to this video. Oil, gold, diamond, etc are why some African Governments have fail, some shaky and some strong. Holly Mama Africa, we MUST all get educated and informed.
The matter of concern now is not 'what happened' but 'what's going to happen?" in Libya. Political stability is the most essential requirement for being a peaceful member country of the present peace-loving comity of Nations of the world.. Enough is enough, this is high time for Libya to dig out its way to progress and prosperity through peaceful efforts to development and construction. Islamic jurisprudence and legal framework is always there to mark the Libya as the growing economy in the continent like The Africa.
Everybody who participated in the destruction of other countries
That are still alive need to be held accountable
Come across the oceans and make us......😊
@@billyyank5807 you don't make any sense why would I want to come make yall 🤔
great video :)
Sad😢
Why is America 🇺🇸 so much into African affairs?
Fero Mummar Ĝàddafi hes one of the Lion King of Libìya , watching from Fiji .
The Libya people are paying for what they deed, you can never understand the blessing you have until you lose it
At the truth came out, the whole world can see who the real DVEL is or are. The darkest pit of hell is waiting for them all. GOD bless good people!
Libyan should have defend and protect Gaddafi.
You are too wise, but you are too late to show your wisdom. You could be the teacher of all the people of Libya. Then Gaddafi could survive till your grandchildrens' death.
Libya is the perfect example of what not to do with the west. You want a revolution fight for it by yourself never involve foreigners especially the west in your country affairs. It would have been better for Libya to stay with Gaddafi rather than live in after Gaddafi
Who really was behind the Arab spring?
It was on of the best country in Africa during Gaddafi's time
It's very sad indeed 😢😢
Like they say the past repeats itself.
Great video! How safe is it to travel through Libya atm? I'm planning a motorcycle trip across North Africa but Libya is the one that has me worried.
It's safe , everyone was surprisingly shocked when they visited.
@@MrHtjetwhat? Who is everyone?
@@Dan16673 sorry I should've elaborated , but a few youtubers , while I was in Spain met some British folks who were there for work. But yeah
@@MrHtjet no shit? Hmm interesting
I highly recommend watching travel vloggers on RUclips. Many have visited Libya in the past year and their experiences were great.
United Africa is what the western world don’t want to see😢
A wealthy country before under the great kadaffhy, what happen in Libya now😢😢😢 in times of kadhafy free hospital , free school, free electricity's, etc etc...
An amazing video as always 💪🏿
U.S France,U.K guilty of atrocities against Libyan people, should pay for damages and lost of thousands of innocent lives
Haven't watched yet. I'm sure it ends positively, right?
atl east they have democracy now
Kenya be careful watch and protest with respect
They diminished lybia to the core all of these imperialists and colonialists
During the time of kadafi Libyan was being progress and stable but the American destroy the progressive country and the other Libyan are being deceived by American and now what happened in Libya..
R.I.P brother
That is what Obama gave African,Gaddafi was our hope.
Even Obama was chosen by the club
From good life to war.sad
The main thing to blame for the current state of Libya is Gaddafi himself. Libya was literally in a state of civil war before NATO even entered to conflict. Libya was headed towards a state of anarchy regardless of whether NATO entered the conflict or not.
Libya was a personality cult.
Only the king of kings