Magewell Director Mini • PROS and CONS

Поделиться
HTML-код
  • Опубликовано: 1 фев 2025

Комментарии • 63

  • @PeteBreen
    @PeteBreen Год назад +7

    Have to admit as a Yolobox Pro user - I love the menus on this unit. Curious to see what the Ultra brings. Magewell did a solid job on this from the looks of it.

    • @aaronpk
      @aaronpk  Год назад +6

      Keep an eye out here, I've got a video about the Ultra coming out shortly! 👀

  • @Sand10.
    @Sand10. Год назад +1

    This device is on a whole other level😳

  • @estherzong0987
    @estherzong0987 Год назад +3

    What processor does it have, and how does its processing power stack up against the YoloBox Ultra?

  • @IEBATechThoughts
    @IEBATechThoughts Год назад

    Great into video Aaron!

  • @TheOutdoorsStation
    @TheOutdoorsStation 10 месяцев назад +2

    On paper it looks as if this has a reliable consistent video output frame rate, unlike the Yolo series which notorious for not posting any output details on their website and many complaints. I also like the remote control app which is perfect for a solo operator facing the camera. I see it also accepts 4K input so the ability to set the scene showing different camera angles from one inout is great. I was going to buy a Yolobox but I think this is a better option.

  • @KevinLe
    @KevinLe Год назад +1

    Love seeing new entries into this space! Do you notice any bottlenecking when it comes to performance when you have "too many sources"?

    • @aaronpk
      @aaronpk  Год назад +1

      So far I haven't noticed any slow down, and if you watch my live demo from a week or two ago I had a ton of sources connected. but I'm going to try to push it harder to find the limit.

    • @joelkrauska
      @joelkrauska Год назад

      One great thing is that you can watch the CPU % in the web interface, so you can tell how much load each source takes. I was able to do 6+ inputs with overlays and never went over 60% CPU.

  • @i360MediaInc
    @i360MediaInc Год назад

    The Device is a great portable streaming tool, the major con for me is the 1 ndi out restriction. 1 ndi out with recoding enabled and another regular rtmp/srt destination would be perfect since it has two encoders. I hope it can be fixed via an update. a few things i wish can be added either as addon service would be some sort of bonding and may be replay option. but its a lot promising. Even Yolobox didn't start off this strong.

  • @hhel3169
    @hhel3169 4 месяца назад

    Hi AAron! Nice review! Can I do a triple composition ( 2 HDMI plus NDI cam ) on a scene? or scenes have a 2 input limitation? Thanks!

  • @TheTechnoPilot
    @TheTechnoPilot Год назад

    Wow! This looks SUPER interesting as a filmmaker with an Atomos Connect and Atem Mini ISO!

  • @OrenArieli
    @OrenArieli Год назад

    Thanks for the great review. I've got a specific use case and I'm wondering if I could accomplish it with this unit: I need to bring in a camera feed, shrunk and cropped as well as a laptop feed, shrunk over a still image. In essence, a double PIP. Can it be done with this unit?

    • @aaronpk
      @aaronpk  Год назад

      Yes it can! You can crop and resize multiple video sources in a scene. Definitely one of the great features of this device.

    • @OrenArieli
      @OrenArieli Год назад

      Awesome! Thanks for the quick response. I might have to pick one up eventually. It's a shame you can't treat it like a traditional t-bar switcher via the web interface. The older I get, the smaller these screens seem to get...and the fatter my fingers behave.
      @@aaronpk

    • @aaronpk
      @aaronpk  Год назад +1

      Yeah the screen is definitely small. But you can also connect a large touch screen monitor to use with it!

    • @OrenArieli
      @OrenArieli Год назад

      Still need my sausage fingers to interact with the UI though, by the looks of it.@@aaronpk

  • @JeanLaValley
    @JeanLaValley 10 месяцев назад

    This is a great video. K am enjoying your reviews.

  • @lastsonofthewest2444
    @lastsonofthewest2444 6 месяцев назад

    Great video. Does anybody know how the CPU/GPU in the Magewell Director Mini compares to the Qualcomm in Yololiv Ultra? I am really stuck on which to buy, and while I like the Magewell for scene customization, am also concerned about overloading it with scenes, 3 NDI sources, etc. Typically we stream with vMix in studio, and I can bomb that with inputs, angles, camera shots, but worried about either the Magewell or the Yololiv. Thanks!

  • @TheTechEffect_
    @TheTechEffect_ 7 месяцев назад

    Great video Aaron. Is the Magewell Director Mini able to output two concurrent LinkedIn Live streams via two separate accounts?

    • @aaronpk
      @aaronpk  7 месяцев назад +1

      If you can get the RTMP address for each account you could definitely do that as two separate RTMP destinations

    • @TheTechEffect_
      @TheTechEffect_ 7 месяцев назад

      @@aaronpk Thank you Aaron. We will test this out when it arrives and let you know if it was successful or not.

  • @LloydDunlop-jz5vp
    @LloydDunlop-jz5vp 5 месяцев назад

    Is the stearm output switchable. 480 ,,720,,1080p

  • @mica333
    @mica333 Год назад

    Thanks for you review, but what about the output side on the device, is the PRG OUT via USB-C reliable for another seperate encoder?

  • @sibertiger17
    @sibertiger17 Год назад

    From someone who is using Mevo Multicam app this looks insane!!
    How dies it stream out wirelessly...needs a sim csrd.. can use a cell hotspot..? Does it use a HEVC codedc? Have you tested it's wireless streaming?
    What's the price? Up here in Canada this stuff is outrageously over priced

    • @joelkrauska
      @joelkrauska Год назад

      $1300 USD on B&H in US. No internal SIM/Radio. I pair it with a GL.iNet and SmoothWan/Speedify. Currently H.264 only.

    • @sibertiger17
      @sibertiger17 Год назад +1

      @@joelkrauska ah ok that's what I use, the GL SlateAx1800 with my cell hotspot...so that should work.
      But it's $2000 up here in Canada...that's insane and way out of what I'm willing to spend...these companies are ridiculous with their prices these days

  • @idjmic
    @idjmic Год назад

    This unit seems more similar to OBS on PC with its scenes. Where as Yolobox is more a “Apple” version where what you see is what you get.

  • @GregTerryExperience
    @GregTerryExperience Год назад

    Hey there Aaron, Thanks for the GREAT video! I am actually hunting a mobile encoder for use in Ukraine. I work there and leave again soon and am trying decide what is the BEST portable encoder to grab, learn and carry with me for Live Streaming from Ukraine. Any thoughts you can give me would be great! Love your stuff.

  • @lsmith77
    @lsmith77 11 месяцев назад

    Does it offer a replay feature like the Yolobox? according to the website it does have a scoreboard feature.

  • @keithbennett5179
    @keithbennett5179 Год назад

    Great video!

  • @kayizijoel1167
    @kayizijoel1167 Год назад

    Am curious if this device could stream SRT output in 24/7 operations

    • @aaronpk
      @aaronpk  Год назад

      It almost certainly can, although you might want to look for one of the simpler Magewell encoders that is just the encoder part, because there's less that can go wrong with those.

  • @JerimiahBorkowski
    @JerimiahBorkowski 7 месяцев назад

    Are you able to use a Streamdeck to control it?

    • @aaronpk
      @aaronpk  7 месяцев назад

      There's a beta version of a Companion module for it now!

  • @grandstyle9702
    @grandstyle9702 10 месяцев назад

    possible to get speedify apk running on this device?

  • @idjmic
    @idjmic Год назад

    How many NDI cameras can you add?

  • @krishnansrinivasan830
    @krishnansrinivasan830 Год назад

    Awesome & Thanks :)

  • @Agoradessavoirs
    @Agoradessavoirs Год назад

    Hi again Aaron, was my previous comment automatically hidden or it's your choise ? (If I say something wrong, I need to know ;) )

  • @leekadie
    @leekadie Год назад +1

    I was told that the screen display is not very bright and it lacks an integrated SIM card, which are significant drawbacks for my work in outdoor environments!

    • @RadCameraMan
      @RadCameraMan 23 часа назад

      you can connect one or more 4G/5G USB dongles to the USB ports on it

  • @christopherdoyle8081
    @christopherdoyle8081 Год назад

    Is that truely the response time of the Director? That seems awefully low latency for such a device.

  • @frankferrer
    @frankferrer Год назад +1

    I guess price is also on the cons side, however, the pros are really really good.

    • @mthelisi
      @mthelisi Год назад

      I agree. The price tag is quite steep. I want to get one soon.

    • @joelkrauska
      @joelkrauska Год назад +1

      It's similar in price to the yolobox, but offers a much cleaner interface, more protocols and remote control capabilities. I wish it was cheaper too, but if you add up all the stuff it has, it's pretty cheap. (Atomos Ninja + ATEM Mini?)

  • @alan730605
    @alan730605 10 месяцев назад

    Can this device stream on Facebook ?

  • @emmanuelbouteiller
    @emmanuelbouteiller Год назад

    NDI is output , problem is same with Ninja V witht module Connect NDI
    and Director no output Hdmi ..

  • @Fishandspaghettishow
    @Fishandspaghettishow 7 месяцев назад

    This or a yolo liv ?

    • @RadCameraMan
      @RadCameraMan 23 часа назад

      This, because it has way too many additional features as well as the external batteries are really useful.

  • @beam-a-live
    @beam-a-live Год назад

    The NDI limitation is the only serious con... for the time being.
    As for the power - there are quite a few 5V to 12V adapters for around 8-12 bucks.
    I got myself one and managed to run the DM for more then 10 hours on a 20000mAh USB backup battery.
    So that's not an issue at all.
    And... "too thick"? seriously Aaron? That's the first CON you managed to find? 🤣
    You have a full featured all-in-one production beast smaller (and apparently even lighter, including batts) then a BlackMagic Pocket Cinema,
    and it bothers you that it's too thick? come on man.
    Nonetheless, thanks for your professional reviews 🙏

    • @aaronpk
      @aaronpk  Год назад +1

      I just really like tiny things! But yes the 5V to 12V is a good plan!

    • @beam-a-live
      @beam-a-live Год назад +1

      @@aaronpk
      It makes the two of us - Compact, portable, and multi-purpose things, indeed 🤩
      The thing I love the most about the DM is that once you finished designing your show,
      You can parctically "throw it under the table" (even short-press the power button to lock it and blank it's screen)
      and run the whole show from your browser, connected wirelessly and sitting at the hot spot of the arena.
      (such workflow mainly suits freelance live streaming producers giving on-site services, like me, and less studio-based one person show content producers)

    • @RadCameraMan
      @RadCameraMan 23 часа назад

      @@aaronpk you can get a trigger cable for USB-C to 12V barrel connector which is essentially the same size and weight of a normal USB cable.

  • @violinjohn1331
    @violinjohn1331 Год назад

    Does this device have green screen capability?

    • @joelkrauska
      @joelkrauska Год назад

      Yes. www.magewell.com/files/documents/User_Manual/Director_Mini_User_Manual_en_US.pdf Page 58 "Keyer"

    • @RadCameraMan
      @RadCameraMan 23 часа назад

      Yes

  • @mvmv5883-e3g
    @mvmv5883-e3g Год назад

    $1,299.00
    If I were a rich man
    Ya ba dibba dibba dibba dibba dibba dibba dum.....