Suddenly, Last Summer (1993) starring Maggie Smith and Natasha Richardson (Complete)

Поделиться
HTML-код
  • Опубликовано: 21 дек 2019
  • This fantastic 1993 BBC production (aired on PBS in the US) adheres closer to the original Tennessee Williams text than does the 1959 feature with Elizabeth Taylor and Katherine Hepburn. Featuring Natasha Richardson, Maggie Smith, Rob Lowe and Richard E. Grant.
  • КиноКино

Комментарии • 155

  • @jmd26
    @jmd26  9 месяцев назад +10

    I'm so pleased to see so many still engaged in this play I posted 12 years ago on a lark. I don't like seeing people argue about Dame Maggie vs. Kate the great! Both women are fantastic in the role. Hepburn is ICONOC, and Maggie does a fantastic job as well. She wasn't able to make the legendary entrance that Hepburn did, but her LEAPING from her wheelchair makes up for it! Both performances are LEGEND. Both women are!

  • @kathleendinsmore7588
    @kathleendinsmore7588 11 месяцев назад +32

    Maggie Smith is phenomenal. From Lady Violet of Downton Abbey to Violet Venable she is a force to be reckoned with!

    • @roberttyran3813
      @roberttyran3813 10 месяцев назад

      AMEN!! I met her once in New York City! What an Amazing Woman. Bob.

  • @samosullivan1744
    @samosullivan1744 2 года назад +25

    Violet Venable’s cry at the end is ICONIC!
    Maggie Smith is the Best of the Best!

  • @Countplato
    @Countplato 2 года назад +45

    This is my all time favorite drama. I enjoyed this version with Maggie Smith, who is always captivating. Natasha Richardson is (RIP) absolutely convincing as someone who has been close to being driven insane after seeing the hideous death of her cousin. This was a remake in 1993 following the exact stage play written by Tennessee Williams. In 1959, the first filming was rewritten by Gore Vidal, with much more disturbing drama, which I was more pulled into the mystery of Sebastian Venable's death. Both Katharine Hepburn who played Mrs. Venable with a style that is only hers (confession-she's my all time favorite actress - RIP) and Elizabeth Taylor were both nominated for Oscars, however, due to the subject matter, neither of them won despite their sublime performances.
    I was pleasantly surprised to see the remake, and I thought Rob Lowes performance of the doctor was amazing, one of his best parts in a role where he wasn't portraying a sex symbol.
    I can't say enough here about how this movie affected my life. I can say I wrote quite a lot about it in my recently published memoir, "Alive After Dying."

    • @simonjones7727
      @simonjones7727 Год назад +8

      I come round to Suddenly. Last Summer. In my head I tend to think of it as just a piece of Grand Guignol, but I was at a production of The Milk Train Doesn't Stop Here Anymore recently, and I see some parallels in the themes. The writing is very fine.

  • @craigmills3583
    @craigmills3583 3 года назад +68

    Such a dark and disturbing play by Williams. Maggie Smith is superb playing this absolutely monstrous woman, though she manages to find some vulnerability in the heart of her too. I even felt sorry for her at times. Quite an acting achievement. Great performance from Natasha Richardson too.

  • @blanchefan
    @blanchefan 9 месяцев назад +3

    A mesmerizing production of an utterly fascinating play that often seems like a poetic nightmare. Superb lighting and setting of mood. Magnificent acting from all. People like to squawk that this play is not one of Tennessee's best, blah, blah, etc...That may be true, but it's obvious we are in the hands of a genius, imaginative writer. I find it quite hypnotic--"total theatre," as one critic said. Such exquisite language! Williams won a lot of awards in his lifetime, but he definitely should have also won the Nobel Prize for his body of work--no question.

  • @sandrayow7578
    @sandrayow7578 2 года назад +25

    Several years ago , I saw the 1959 version of this movie with Katherine Hepburn and Elizabeth
    Taylor. It was well done yet as disturbing as this . However, in my opinion , it just cannot compare in story or performance to this latest version with Maggie Smith and Natasha Richardson, The
    writing is amazing and their delivery of such dark irony was heart wrenching . It validates the
    greatness of the original writer - Tennessee Williams.

    • @jeanettesdaughter
      @jeanettesdaughter 2 года назад +13

      Idk. I liked Hepburn better. She was more frightening than this hysterical woman, and Taylor was equally magnificent because she was an incredibly beautiful contrast. Taylor looked much more fragile playing this tiny turtle of a girl surrounded by carnivorous birds. Besides Williams was a Southern writer,,telling an overheated tale of claustrophobic families devouring each other with vicious self deceiving lies. Nothing more carnivorous than a plantation where wealth has inbred indolence and generations of slavery! The Brits may lend a polished performance but this is a sweaty tropical tale. It is meant to feel clammy and a touch sweetly sickening like the scent of certain fleshy orchids. Visit the French Quarter in New Orleans in August.

    • @Countplato
      @Countplato 2 года назад +5

      @Jeanettesdaughter that is a wonderful description. It really explains how Gothic the story Gore Vidal rewrote for Hepburn, Taylor, and Clift.

  • @margaretfarquhar9567
    @margaretfarquhar9567 3 года назад +27

    Fabulous acting from Maggie Smith and Natasha Richardson, superb performances
    from all.
    Thank you for posting

    • @michelleregis6181
      @michelleregis6181 3 года назад +2

      I beg to differ, the role belonged to Taylor, Hepburn, and M Clift with kudos to M Mc Cambridge

    • @Countplato
      @Countplato 2 года назад +6

      @@michelleregis6181 I agree, however, since this followed Williams' exact script differing from the added frightening version by Gore Vidal in the 1959 film, I believe they both have merit.

    • @jmd26
      @jmd26  9 месяцев назад

      Thank you for enjoying it!

    • @jmd26
      @jmd26  9 месяцев назад

      ​@@CountplatoI agree with you.

  • @BlueSkyLtd.
    @BlueSkyLtd. 11 месяцев назад +6

    Outstanding!
    Thank-you for this television adaptation of the classic Tennessee Williams play. 📺

  • @rayjeeves8000
    @rayjeeves8000 2 года назад +9

    Thank you for posting!
    27k views on RUclips, but a guy getting hit in the nuts will garner millions. How did culture get so lost?

  • @mattdeans9873
    @mattdeans9873 10 месяцев назад +4

    Image the possibilites if Natasha Richardson had been taken from us so early in her life. Great performances from all. Thanks for this post.

  • @Zihannya
    @Zihannya 10 месяцев назад +6

    Incredible performances by Natasha Richardson and Maggie Smith. Riveting.

  • @gregoryambres1897
    @gregoryambres1897 2 года назад +22

    Maggie Smith doing a Southern accent?! DIVINE 🏆

    • @chopin65
      @chopin65 2 года назад +4

      No. She is trying to do one.

    • @rodhatte
      @rodhatte Год назад +3

      @@chopin65 ...struggling to do one!

    • @Theaddora
      @Theaddora 10 месяцев назад +3

      British people are very good at Southern accents. My uncle, who was born and raised in Alabama, was even mistaken by Brits as being one of them because of his particular Southern accent.

    • @LadyBug1967
      @LadyBug1967 10 месяцев назад

      ​@@TheaddoraCould u explain. A Brit who is a born n bred Southern American was thought a Brit due to his Southern accent? I do not understand.

    • @Theaddora
      @Theaddora 10 месяцев назад +1

      @@LadyBug1967 I did not say my uncle was born and bred in Britain. I said he was born and raised in Alabama but he had a British type accent!!

  • @gregoryambres1897
    @gregoryambres1897 2 года назад +13

    🏆 Rob Lowe is a fine actor. 🏆

  • @simonjones7727
    @simonjones7727 Год назад +7

    "Let's just say that he was interested in sea turtles" Well, that is one way of putting it...

  • @zharapatterson
    @zharapatterson 3 года назад +19

    Unpopular opinion, I prefer the 1959 film with Katherine Hepburn, and Elizabeth Taylor, Montgomery Clift. I know this is closer to the original Tennessee William's play but, I like the haunted performance of Katherine Hepburn along with the dramatic film music, and Elizabeth Taylor performance towards the end of the film.

    • @masongraves4228
      @masongraves4228 2 года назад +3

      That’s not an unpopular opinion at all everyone prefers that film over this

    • @Countplato
      @Countplato 2 года назад +2

      @@masongraves4228 agreed.

    • @zharapatterson
      @zharapatterson 2 года назад +2

      @@masongraves4228 Thank you, very much glad to know I'm not alone.

    • @rodhatte
      @rodhatte Год назад +1

      I can't help but think Kathrine Hepburn must have felt a bit vindicated if she saw Maggie Smith fail so terribly at her accent. Hepburn had been approached to do Travels With My Aunt but she felt the script was mediocre, so she rewrote it. The studio then rewrote the script she had made and gave the role to Maggie Smith, who got nominated for an Academy Award for it. She didn't even get mentioned for the work she did, as she wasn't in the Screen Writer's Guild. I love Maggie Smith, but she shouldn't have been cast in this.

    • @nancymcmonarch
      @nancymcmonarch Год назад +2

      I think the black and white film added to the creepiness of the 1959 film. Also, back then, unjustified lobotomies were far more of a real life horror. By 1993 everyone had seen One Flew Over the Cuckoo's nest and heard about Rosemary Kennedy, along with other ghastly stories about the results of such a sketchy operation. Patients' rights had also become a more powerful force, and the whole lobotomy trend seemed rather an ancient nightmare.

  • @GriffGriffith
    @GriffGriffith Год назад +8

    "I came out in the French Quarter years before I came out in the Garden District." Tennessee speaks!

  • @TammyBundleballs
    @TammyBundleballs 9 месяцев назад +1

    I was looking for plays at a used book store and found a great book of plays by Tennessee Williams 1957-1980. Suddenly, Last Summer was the second play, and I just finished it. I really enjoyed it.
    Thanks for uploading this.

    • @jmd26
      @jmd26  9 месяцев назад +1

      Thanks for taking the time.

  • @slcRN1971
    @slcRN1971 Год назад +8

    I had to watch the 1959 film version, a couple more times to get a better understanding of what was happening. The censors really limited what could actually be filmed and at times hampered this production. I believe that if it hadn’t been for their interference, more would have been filmed - - rather than just talked about (for instance, shown how Sebastian’s mother looked, when she accompanied her son on those summer vacations). This version didn’t show that Sebastian’s book of poems, was actually completely blank pages. I did like this version too. I hadn’t known of its existence, until I was searching for the movie.

  • @nunosimoesrodrigues1543
    @nunosimoesrodrigues1543 2 года назад +5

    Great text! Great performances! Great Tennessee Williams!

  • @maryvalentine9090
    @maryvalentine9090 8 дней назад

    Rob Lowe was LITERALLY outstanding in this!😂

  • @patriciagriffin1505
    @patriciagriffin1505 10 месяцев назад +5

    Such a brilliant cast

  • @Canerican.
    @Canerican. Месяц назад

    The acting is fantastic!

  • @wandajames6234
    @wandajames6234 7 месяцев назад

    Dear Natasha. What a powerful performance. What a loss of a talent barely uncovered. The superb Maggie Smith. So moving. They did this play justice which is saying a good deal.

  • @renanciane3372
    @renanciane3372 Год назад +2

    Thank you 👏👏

  • @FishFeelPain
    @FishFeelPain 10 месяцев назад +2

    Maggie Smith is (always) amazing--TY

  • @nonenoneonenonenone
    @nonenoneonenonenone 4 года назад +14

    By far, the best production. Maggie Smith's control is formidable. And Natasha finally conquered her tense jaw habit. Still, I kept seeing the images of the Hollywood version that acted out the rioting, yet this made sense of it.

  • @azizaibrahim1155
    @azizaibrahim1155 10 месяцев назад +1

    Superb cast !

  • @gregoryambres1897
    @gregoryambres1897 7 месяцев назад

    "A Perfect Day" followed by Tennessee Williams' "Suddenly Last Summer" with both Maggie Smith and my man Rob Lowe, just before Christmas, is, indeed, a perfect day.

  • @henrikechers9995
    @henrikechers9995 Год назад +7

    Both versions are great, and the acting is fantastic. Hard to choose between Hepburn and Smiths version, but considering that Maggie is British, I would call her performance the best. As has been said before: No one was better, at playing Kathrine Hepburn, than Kathrine Hepburn herself. Interesting, that Natacha, also is British, both playing Americans.

  • @dianeburr5441
    @dianeburr5441 4 года назад +22

    Love this and the earlier 1959 version. 1959 was slightly more edgy and disturbing, i think that was probably Hepburn's brilliant casting & contribution. Thank you for this. Anymore hidden US/BBC gems?

    • @Countplato
      @Countplato 2 года назад +6

      @Diane Burr Take a look at Hepburn's performance in "The Lion in Winter."

  • @eveyh333
    @eveyh333 Год назад +9

    Love Maggie Smith. I had the opportunity to meet her once and she was so unassuming and kind. To me Elizabeth Taylpr was not a great actress, though a great beauty. Her voice was a bit annoying at times. Yes Montgomery Clift an mesmerising actor in everything he played.

    • @evelynwaugh4053
      @evelynwaugh4053 10 месяцев назад +1

      It's hard to tell, because melodrama was the fashion in the 40s and 50s, as opposed to today's more natural style, so much acting of that era seems like overacting. I did really love her in Who's Afraid of Virginia Wolfe and an odd black comedy, directed by Peter Ustinof, called Hammersmith Is Out.

    • @christinepaige2575
      @christinepaige2575 10 месяцев назад

      Yes, Taylor’s voice was rather inflexible and tended to shrillness, which is an awful handicap to an actress. I think that “Who’s Afraid of Virginia Woolf” was the only performance in which she managed to overcome this problem.

  • @christinehall6441
    @christinehall6441 9 месяцев назад +1

    I saw this with Elizabeth Taylor starring.

  • @tonigillette9217
    @tonigillette9217 11 месяцев назад +4

    Smith understood Williams well. The fragility of the cannibal, as is the shadow of the narcissist. All pain and weakness behind the monster. Hepburn could only do the monster mask.

  • @patshaw51
    @patshaw51 2 года назад +2

    Magnificent!

  • @charlottezgoda3248
    @charlottezgoda3248 6 месяцев назад

    Loved this❤

  • @gimbutas1
    @gimbutas1 4 года назад +8

    Loved it. The jungle garden is so big. Gore Vidal says they were restricted by the Motion Picture Production Code on the script for 1959 film. Was this filmed in Vaso-Vision with Vasoline on the lense ?

  • @timlewisjazz
    @timlewisjazz 3 года назад +1

    tremendous!

  • @BrianJosephMorgan
    @BrianJosephMorgan 3 года назад +1

    Bravo!

  • @franklowe2472
    @franklowe2472 2 года назад +7

    la actuacion de rob lowe es muy buena como siempre

    • @Countplato
      @Countplato 2 года назад +1

      I have to admit, he was amazing in this film, and I'm not a fan of most of his other work.

  • @gentillydanny
    @gentillydanny 4 года назад +8

    The accents were distracting at first but I got over that quick enough. Excellent. Much better than the Hollywood version.

    • @WCaron23001
      @WCaron23001 4 года назад +4

      I agree, more faithful to the play.

    • @randywhite3947
      @randywhite3947 4 года назад +3

      Absolutely not this is nowhere the 1959 version that one was one of the best films ever this is solid however

    • @gentillydanny
      @gentillydanny 4 года назад +4

      @@randywhite3947 I agree that the '59 version was very good but this seems to flow whereas the '59 version seems a bit disjointed and choppy with the ending hurried and trite.

  • @clareomarfran
    @clareomarfran 3 года назад +3

    Wonderful! I’m curious. Is this TW’s original version, or the 1957 version of it Gore Vidal adapted to get past the censors for the movie with Katherine Hepburn, Elizabeth Taylor, and Montgomery Clift?

  • @eshaibraheem4218
    @eshaibraheem4218 10 месяцев назад

    I thought this was very good. Thank you, jmd26.

    • @jmd26
      @jmd26  9 месяцев назад

      You're welcome!

  • @-Reagan
    @-Reagan 15 дней назад

    Her southern American accent is phenomenal. She pronounced one word differently “elixir” putting the emphasis on the syllables in an English way though, with a Southern American accent. It caught me off guard.
    It wasn’t correct though, it was lovely. It seemed an eccentricity of the character. Perhaps, picked up on her “grand tour of Europe” as the young people of her generation would have taken, before the turn of the 19th century. When Violet Venable would have been a young, unmarried woman. Or, perhaps on an extended honeymoon with her husband, still young then, whom Sebastian resembled and she lost both of them, so recalls that other trip when ruminating on her travels with Sebastian.
    The elixir of life that wasn’t available to save them, while yet, it sustains herself. Rather than a mispronounciation, it felt right and fitting with her character.
    I didn’t have much interest in a remake of the movie, based on the play, a copy of a copy. Comparing rather than enjoying. Not after Katherine Hepburn’s and Elizabeth Taylor’s performances. However, it’s amazing so far that it stands alone, convincing of the characters as whole and original unto themselves. Never so much as rocking the rope bridge on which disbelief is suspended, as over a rocky precipice of the Encantadas.

  • @worrywart1311
    @worrywart1311 10 месяцев назад +2

    Shame about the poor quality of this video print here but overall much better than the movie. Being half an hour shorter tightened the tension, better acting all round except for the doctor, a sharper script made the plot clearer. Conceived as a play and better to leave the horrors of the ending to our imagination than show them. Smith was able to show two sides of the dragon, Hepburn only showed us one. Grant carved a niche for himself. First time I realized there is something special about Suddenly, Last Summer.

    • @jmd26
      @jmd26  9 месяцев назад

      I wish they would broadcast this in HD at some point.

  • @simonjones7727
    @simonjones7727 Год назад +2

    Such an outrageous play, and I long to see a version one day that injects a little more Joe Orton into proceedings. The final act, in particular, seems to cry out for that (but perhaps that is just me), In the opening scenes here, Maggie Smith seems to be wearing a massive poppadom on her head.

  • @cornbreadhead7197
    @cornbreadhead7197 4 года назад +5

    Rob Lowe played Dr. Sugar.

  • @gooberz19
    @gooberz19 4 года назад +9

    I think Cousin Sebastian is going to give me a nervous breakdown too.

  • @jennklein1917
    @jennklein1917 Год назад +2

    Natasha's southern accent is good, tho😏

  • @christinepaige2575
    @christinepaige2575 10 месяцев назад +2

    Hey but it doesn’t make sense that Sebastian would use his alluring female cousin as his “procurer” when the guys she would be “procuring” would be straight.

    • @jmd26
      @jmd26  9 месяцев назад +1

      Sometimes, just getting them together in one place is half the battle

  • @lynettestuart6368
    @lynettestuart6368 10 месяцев назад +2

    PERFECTION 🎉 This is what TENNESSEE WILLIAMS intended! This movie is much better than the Original, simply because the actual story is clearly told, plot-wise, script-wise....and so genuinely, effortlessly portrayed by the Late, Great NATASHA RICHARDSON✨🦋 I finally understand what the hell happened to Sebastian! Liz Taylor, I love you but your performance had to be contrived thru Flashbacks, since you weren't that as capable an actress at that time, early in her career. But THIS movie is true story-telling, bolstered by Dame Maggie's scene- stealing and Rob Lowe's sultry, sexiness, young doctor that MONTGOMERY CLIFT wasn't able to portay like he used to. A nuanced, artful Film, shot in a haze, just like a hot, humid Southern Gothic movie should!💨💖

    • @parstl3739
      @parstl3739 10 месяцев назад +1

      A great live play version is being performed now during the Tennessee Williams Festival in St Louis. They plan to post later. COCA Arts. Excellent portrayal of Aunt Violet and Catherine by young African American actress Naima Randolph. Sept 16 2023

    • @manita2653
      @manita2653 9 месяцев назад +1

      @@parstl3739 Thank you for mentioning the Tennessee Williams Festival. I look forward to seeing the performance you mention.

    • @jmd26
      @jmd26  9 месяцев назад

      ​​@parstl3739 Oooh that sounds amazing!

  • @stevenkeller8042
    @stevenkeller8042 4 года назад +8

    Lovely performances, but needs to be restored in HD. I like Maggie Smith, but I prefer Katherine Hepburn’s more restrained performance as Violet.

    • @gloriamontgomery6900
      @gloriamontgomery6900 10 месяцев назад +2

      It really helps if you increase the picture quality to 360p-as high as it goes. Really sharpens it up

    • @manita2653
      @manita2653 9 месяцев назад

      @@gloriamontgomery6900 thank you...

  • @SFKelvin
    @SFKelvin 3 года назад +7

    This production haunted me so much as a (secretly) gay teen in Los Angeles.

    • @TheTurkaderr
      @TheTurkaderr 3 года назад +4

      Me too,this was the first movie version of a Tennessee Williams work that I ever saw growing up. I remember watching it the night it first aired in the US. I taped it on our VCR.

  • @stevenwood8665
    @stevenwood8665 2 года назад +7

    The original has always been one of my favorites films..this version had me weeping for everyone involved.. Catherine telling of the dismissal of cousin SEBASTIAN and his mother going totally insane with TRUTH is more disturbing than the original. DR. SUGAR part is or could of been more dramatic but ROB LOWE was still eye candy for the viewers. Isn`t that what LOVE is..when we use people..Hate is when we are not allowed to. I will close with this thought on both versions.. think the lines should of said ' SEBASTIAN who was always good and kind saw something in the universe that wasn`t good and kind..the doctor responds..."A GOD" ..instead of ' A GOD' the line should of been "human race' BECAUSE we all prey on one another like the hungry black birds!

    • @joexuereb607
      @joexuereb607 2 года назад +4

      '(should)of been'?! Tut! Tut! You mean 'should have been'.

    • @JavierGonzalez-ss9es
      @JavierGonzalez-ss9es 11 месяцев назад

      the original!!!????... the film was not the original

    • @LadyBug1967
      @LadyBug1967 10 месяцев назад +1

      The commenter's last phrase is quite interesting because unfortunately I believe it's true. I have learned to never expose any vulnerability to anybody who is EVIL or of two sides--ONE being extremely dark & the other relatively light. Recently I went to the library as I needed to get a very important letter to a business and the librarian usually helps me with no problem. I know she has a very dark side which I saw when I took a couple classes with her that were craft projects. She was very talented but I could tell she was very very dark. As a librarian she has to hide that side but this time I'd just returned from a vacation and I had fallen due to a crack in the sidewalk that I didn't see as I wasn't paying attention. I fell very hard and I had a lot of different aches and pains due to it. I had begun wearing a brace on my hand etcetera so I mentioned that to her my fall. I didn't really expect sympathy because that's not how people are nowadays and I knew she was not of that nature but when she went to help me she became very antagonistic and criticized me unjustly for being too slow or not doing something correctly that I had no knowledge of because it was a brand new program I was being trained to do in order to create this document for this business.
      When I left the library she was once again sitting at her desk and I said to her quite clearly: BEFORE you were hired, I was using a different program and it was easy. AND then I left. THIS is the south so the statement would have resonance with a southerner. She's a Midwestener.
      I pondered her negative actions and wondered what I would do in the future if she got even worse because I often do need help of a technical nature to get documents out to different businesses. Then I realized that I had shown vulnerability to her due to telling her I had fallen which for most humans would elicit sympathy or at least a quiet listening to the other's misfortune but in her case it revealed a vulnerability that I had not exposed before and so she pounced on me like a rabid animal. SO YES the comment made by this person is more than apropos it is absolutely the TRUTH 💀

    • @stevenwood8665
      @stevenwood8665 10 месяцев назад +2

      @@LadyBug1967 thanks for commenting on my post. So sorry you were exposed to someone` dark side. Think maybe..if there is someone else there that could help you..I would try to go that route. The film does show how selfish human nature can be. I am also guilty. Karma is real.. when you release negative energy..it comes back to you..same for postive. Just always remember that is what we all are..a body of energy. I has a co-worker,,,,older lady who was downright awful and hateful to me..been employed by the company over 30 years..so management would do nothing.. I was always trying to show her kindness. well.. 1995..hurt my leg.. have 2 pins and a plate in my knee. off work 3 months.. believe it or not.. she would stop by apartment and bring me fruit.. juice.. softdrinks..etc twice a week. she was the only coworker who reached out to me. I found out later.. she` had been used and abused most of her life.. she was bitter.. we became good friends..she always smiled when she she me when I returned to work. I bought her some luggage cases for her to travel after she retired. ^ months or less after retirement..she had a heart attack. everyone talked about how everyone hated her.. but me.. knew there was a kind person who been stepped on. Maybe that is the woman`s problem. wishing you both postive thoughts. thanks again

  • @beckygarcia4416
    @beckygarcia4416 10 месяцев назад

    Have you seen the version with Elizabeth Taylor?

  • @frankpeter6851
    @frankpeter6851 7 месяцев назад +1

    Smith and Hepburn are neck and neck. Richardson is refusing to compete (even wisely paying homage to Taylor here and there)
    Lowe is left in the dust by Clift.

  • @gloriamontgomery6900
    @gloriamontgomery6900 10 месяцев назад +1

    I think the speed needs to be reduced to .75.

  • @angie7533
    @angie7533 10 месяцев назад +1

    What a nightmare for the young girl!

  • @valmarsiglia
    @valmarsiglia 10 месяцев назад +2

    I really want to enjoy this, but as a New Orleanian I just can't get past those Hollywood Suhthuhn accents. New Orleanians don't sound like that.

  • @rosemaryallen2128
    @rosemaryallen2128 10 месяцев назад +2

    I've not yet seen a play by Tennessee Williams which had the clarity of realism about it. Instead, we get a disgruntled gay cobbling together bits of nastiness to produce what he thinks is a true vision of human hell. It's a whole world away from the elegance of Oscar Wilde, who, God knows, handled his difficulties with grace.

    • @patbnj
      @patbnj 9 месяцев назад

      Never heard of Southern Gothic?

    • @rosemaryallen2128
      @rosemaryallen2128 9 месяцев назад +1

      @@patbnj Thank you! I've looked it up. But my problem with Tennessee Williams is not the genre, it's the subtle inaccuracy of the psychology.

  • @chopin65
    @chopin65 2 года назад +4

    Wow, bad accent. I am a huge fan of Maggie Smith, but she is sliding here and there on her Southern accent.

  • @Steve-km3nt
    @Steve-km3nt 4 года назад +10

    Too bad they didn't use this text for the 1959 film.

    • @johndalton3180
      @johndalton3180 4 года назад +1

      I agree. While having an azing cast, the film is a bit overstuffed

    • @fuzzballzz36
      @fuzzballzz36 2 года назад +3

      They always bowdlerised Williams in films then. The things he said on the stage were too raw for film, apparently.

    • @slcRN1971
      @slcRN1971 Год назад +3

      @@fuzzballzz36 : the censors were very difficult about this subject matter. Their interference limited what was allowed to be put in the 1959 film version.

    • @fuzzballzz36
      @fuzzballzz36 Год назад +2

      @@slcRN1971 I'm sure that's true. He wasn't able to say half of what he could in the theatre.

    • @unowen-nh9ov
      @unowen-nh9ov Год назад +2

      It was severely censored, like Williams usually was on film.

  • @tomsparks6099
    @tomsparks6099 10 месяцев назад +1

    Dame Maggie Smith -- note an English actress mastering the accent of a distinguished American southern lady. All of the characters are despicable, even the nun. Williams wrote some disturbing stuff that highlights the worst in human nature.

    • @christinepaige2575
      @christinepaige2575 10 месяцев назад

      Yes, I think this is an example of that - a monstrous fantasy from his “dark side” that threw a bone to his demons (we all have them). I wonder if in this instance, he just wanted to see what his genius could enable him to get away with. Were it not for the gorgeous, spell-binding language that flowed from his pen, I don’t think this play would ever have seen the light of day. But I think Williams also was capable of writing characters and stories of real nobility; “Summer and Smoke”, I would say, is an example of this, and “The Glass Menagerie”. It is the beauty and poignancy of his writing when it is at the service of nobility, that makes him my favorite playwright, by miles.

  • @stevehinnenkamp5625
    @stevehinnenkamp5625 3 года назад +1

    Too tell you the truth I am indebted to TW for making homosexuality an issue in many of his plays. However 50 years later, i find the script indulgent, to the pount of being ridiculous. I doubt everything about it except it's self- indulgence.

  • @dianeshannon7988
    @dianeshannon7988 10 месяцев назад

    The dark soft mean underbelly of class miney and family tension.

  • @normanseagull4027
    @normanseagull4027 10 месяцев назад

    Lighting is off. Looks misty.

    • @manita2653
      @manita2653 9 месяцев назад

      i believe this is purposely done...to give the sense of a humid oppressive atmosphere.

  • @terryhammond1253
    @terryhammond1253 Год назад +6

    Thanks to Gore Vidal, who re-wrote Williams play, the film is vastly superior. Throw in Hepburn's mezmerizing performance, Liz Taylor's hysterics and a brilliant score and the
    Movie gets 5 stars.

    • @remomazzetti8757
      @remomazzetti8757 10 месяцев назад +1

      This isn't the Hepburn version: this is a 1993 remake with Maggie Smith.

    • @gloriamontgomery6900
      @gloriamontgomery6900 10 месяцев назад

      Liz Taylor’s performance was Oscar worthy

    • @nannettefreeman7331
      @nannettefreeman7331 7 месяцев назад

      This version doesn’t hold a candle to the original.

  • @emillion4470
    @emillion4470 3 года назад +6

    Incredibly talented cast but very uneven results. A clash of acting styles; stage vs. film , the beat of the production was off - the director just lost control. Natasha' s nimble acting is impressive, Rob is miscast as usual, Richard owns his space but we're all here for Maggie aren't we?
    Still... Maggie's acting choices were unfocused. Katharine Hepburn originally played Vi as predatory Queen of the Jungle (a tense anaconda in the garden of Eden, waiting to strike). In part one, Maggie's effectively plays Vi like a transplanted withered Magnolia in a primordial forest - out of it's element. Later, her transitions and outbursts where too abrupt and ill timed. She didn't portray the manipulative power that the character inherently weilded all her life but rather a fellow player who lost her mojo. I blame the the direction, a missed opportunity.

  • @angie7533
    @angie7533 10 месяцев назад

    Money😊

  • @donallen1384
    @donallen1384 10 месяцев назад +1

    Maggie Smith is an exellent actress,such a shame her fake American accent spoils this movie.🤨🤬

  • @anairenemartinez165
    @anairenemartinez165 10 месяцев назад

    Why is grainy and discolored? It is hard to watch, on top of the subject matter.

    • @manita2653
      @manita2653 9 месяцев назад

      i believe this is purposely done...to give the sense of a humid oppressive atmosphere.

    • @jmd26
      @jmd26  9 месяцев назад

      I agree. I wish they would broadcast this or stream it in HD.

  • @user-gz9sy8rh6f
    @user-gz9sy8rh6f 10 месяцев назад +1

    Blurry!

    • @manita2653
      @manita2653 9 месяцев назад

      i believe this is purposely done...to give the sense of a humid oppressive atmosphere.

    • @jmd26
      @jmd26  9 месяцев назад

      Unfortunately, this was never broadcast in HD. I wish they would.

  • @orlandobabe
    @orlandobabe 5 месяцев назад +1

    So this mother is obsessed with keeping her son's homosexuality a secret?

    • @beeztrapp1612
      @beeztrapp1612 5 месяцев назад

      Yep. Very, very emotionally incestuous.

  • @vinniecasqer840
    @vinniecasqer840 11 месяцев назад +2

    Maggie highlights what an awful actor Hepburn was. One dimensional histrionics.

  • @giovanna8187
    @giovanna8187 4 года назад +1

    Natasha's lovely. Is her mother supposed to be this phony and stifling? Sorry, I haven't read the play, only seen the movie decades ago.

    • @unowen-nh9ov
      @unowen-nh9ov Год назад +2

      The mother is most intentionally the monster of the piece.

  • @marysmith8876
    @marysmith8876 9 месяцев назад

    Not for me thank you

    • @jmd26
      @jmd26  9 месяцев назад

      What do you mean?

    • @marysmith8876
      @marysmith8876 9 месяцев назад

      Too sad for me to watch.

    • @jmd26
      @jmd26  9 месяцев назад

      @marysmith8876 Ohh I hear you Mary. But you know, in some ways it's so over the top that you almost want to laugh, if that makes sense. It's a thick Southern Gothic, so dark as to almost be satirical. Hard for me to put into words. Like those dark fairy tales where the grandma gets eaten by a wolf and then cut out of its belly, you know? Oddly, I think you're supposed to have fun with it. Which comes across more in this version than the feature film from 1959. Maybe give it another chance with that in mind.

    • @marysmith8876
      @marysmith8876 9 месяцев назад

      Mmm, you may be right. Peace be with you 🎉

  • @nedludd7622
    @nedludd7622 10 месяцев назад

    Smith and Lowe are totally unconvincing. Lowe has no personality and Smith has a sort of Southern accent, but it has an underlying British enunciation. Words are not flowing but sharply cut.
    Decades ago when I was young, I played the doctor role in a small professional stage production. All the actors in it were more believable, perhaps even me. But I doubt that I could have been as bad as Lowe. None of us tried to put on fake Southern accents.
    This film is totally missable.

  • @franceleeparis37
    @franceleeparis37 2 года назад +1

    Cannot believe that Maggie smith agreed to be part of this dark and sinister story… it does not matter that Tennessee William was exploring the dark side of human nature, it does not matter that he was a great playwright.. this sordid tale should have been left to a less discerning actress… maybe Maggie Smith needed the money.. maybe she was contractually obliged to do it, maybe she wanted to better Katherine Hepburn…. Just hope that there isn’t a dark side to Maggie Smith😏

    • @unowen-nh9ov
      @unowen-nh9ov Год назад +3

      Yes, god forbid our idols be human. Great actresses don't stay that way by not working & Williams is famous for his female roles. Aren't villains the most fun to play? Dame Diana Rigg played the role on stage & she did some of the most challenging female roles in middle age, won awards for Medea, Mrs. Danvers, Mother Love, nominated repeatedly for Olenna in Game of Thorns.

  • @michelleregis6181
    @michelleregis6181 3 года назад +5

    Liz Taylor s version Is the only version, no one can ever take that away from her. This remake does not have 1/2 the drama or class, the acting is quite weak in theyre potrayal by comparison plus it has maggie smith attempting to play a role thats already been iconise by K Hepburn.... ms. smith s acting is rather irritat5ing at best ....of course most of her roles are irritating to me. ms.Richardsons attempt to recreate l Taylors role i must admit, was interesting

    • @dadodydo
      @dadodydo 3 года назад +9

      Why did you watch, then?

    • @unowen-nh9ov
      @unowen-nh9ov Год назад +1

      ​@@dadodydoTo learn? Don't know what you're getting unless you WATCH it.

    • @unowen-nh9ov
      @unowen-nh9ov Год назад +1

      Like many of William's classics, Suddenly has been revived many times.

  • @indrekkpringi
    @indrekkpringi 10 месяцев назад

    The art industry is based on self-advertising. That means that most famous plays and movies are about: da great artiste, da great poet, da great writer, da great painter, da great singer, da great movie star, da great actor, da great composer, da great conductor, da great opera singer, da great dancer, etc., etc. ad nauseum.

  • @MitchBast-xu7jg
    @MitchBast-xu7jg 10 месяцев назад +1

    Rape, incest, child molestation and cannibalism, not exactly wholesome topics when this film was originally made in 1959. Liz Taylor was the protagonist, Montgomery Cliff was the Doctor, and in the original, the Aunt was trying to bribe the doctor to LOBOTOMIZE miss Katherine to shut her up to protect her degenerate cousins reputation.
    Watch the ORIGINAL.
    LIZ TAYLOR, KATHERINE HEPBURN AND MONTGOMERY CLIFF.
    I believe both Taylor and Hepburn were nominated for Oscar's for their performances.

    • @anairenemartinez165
      @anairenemartinez165 10 месяцев назад

      Where Tennessee got this nightmare from? One of his drunken episodes?