I say it every time they perform at Immortal Songs, but this might be my favorite performance ❤ That raw emotion in their voices, the perfect harmonies and Byuls heart wrenching rap that feels like a poem... My goodness, Mamamoo, you managed to blow me away once again. Never letting go 😚
Rapping and poetry are both forms of lyricism, and even if a poem isn't read as rapping, it still has a rhythm. So it's not too surprising that you'd think it was like a poem. It'd be more surprising to me if you felt like it wasn't.
Werewolf211 Right :D I was merely pointing out that her rap in this performance felt more like a recital of a poem rather than what is considered to be the more "traditional" rap. Especially with the emotional delivery of her very touching lyrics and the ongoing story that she's telling. It's a quality that is really rare among idols and that I really appreciate 😄
I LOVE Byul's raps in this, when she raps as vocal line are harmonizing, it's so emotional and moving. Great performance, as expected from idol queens of IS2 :D
Mamamoo has always been delivering impressive stages, touching performances on Immortal Songs 2 but this stage particularly, is just full of raw emotions. This performance is by far the best I've seen from them (although their other performances are all legendary). I'm really proud to call myself a moomoo.
Yeah this one is really good although "Flying into the night sky" still remains my favorite to this day. That seemed like it was cut straight out of a musical performance. So awesome. This one was pure emotion on the other kind. Very impressive especially considering their age. God I shutter with excitement to think what heights they might yet reach in the future.
When you understand barely any word, but the ballad get's your tears flowing anyway - then they did everything right. That performance is so beautiful.
you can see that immortal songs is really mamamoo's stage. they thrive here and they belong here, like it's their home. they always manage to move me everytime they perform. even though i don't understand the words, the way they convey the feelings and emotions of the songs through the way they sing and perform touch me everytime and make me feel like i actually understand the lyrics. i'm so lucky to know them. i'm so lucky to be able to see them perform on stages like this. they are simply raw talent and no one can take that away from them. it's always a privilege to witness them in their element like this. i will always root for them and they will always have my heart. thank you, mamamoo. 💜
Anyone teared up at 0:00? damn the way the piano came in was- and then the way byul was just like narrating with her like this sorrowful voice- but then hwasa's voice was just too emotional- then the members harmonizations- and, and solar's highnotes- then wheein's EVERYTHING- CLEARLY I'M NOT OKAY AND I FEEL LIKE CRYING DONT TOUCH ME
One of my favourite things is watching the small clips of the original artists' reaction when they get hit with the MMM power, and this was very satisfying.
Tidak hanya sekedar bernyanyi... tp penghayatannya dalam membawakan setiap lagu menjadi nomor satu... maka dari itu setiap lagu selalu berkesan jika didengarkan... ekspresi mereka juga selalu mendukung... apa lagi lagu melow gini... beeeeh....❤❤❤❤
This performance brought me to tears just by listening to the raw emotion in their voices. Wheein, Hwasa and Solar are such amazing vocalists, I love all their voices. Let's stop comparing who's better because my girls came through and delivered. Our precious rapper Moonbyul was so passionate and commanded so much attention in this performance and i'm so happy she got a lot of parts :') My favourite immortal songs 2 performance from them has always been 'Backwoods' but hands down this performance takes the crown. I have so much love and respect for this group, it would be such an honor to see them live one day. Mamamoo please come to Australia
Dear Ilhan I am Thai-MooMoo and i love Mamamoo so much💜 My life after knowing Mamamoo has been full of joy and of course whenever Mamamoo needs us, we are always there for them too 💜 I am really glad i got to know them 💜 Nice to meet u my fellow MooMoo 😌
Dear Ilhan Me too! I hope they have a world tour soon. Hope they come to Indonesia. Actually, I'm a little bit jealous with Korean Moomoos who have much time and event with them kekeke Let's support them keep growing up ✌😉
I really love when they all harmonize, but I feel something special when wheein and hwasa harmonize together. Like, you could feel their connections and love that bound by years together.
I've been into kpop since 2008. I'm into many groups. MANY. And honestly I've never been blown away like these girls have blown me away. Their talent is just OUTSTANDING! Omg! I've only been a fan since 2016 but I'll continue to support.
FIRST NOTE FIRST RAP FIRST HARMONIZATION FIRST EVERYTHING IM ALREADY IN AWE OF HOW BEAUTIFUL THIS IS thank you for existing mamamoo, please continue to bless us with your incredible performances
This is such an amazing performance. I can say this is another one of the best they have. Byul's rap, their harmonies, the emotions. They delivered it well. I actually teared with this performence. They did not win but for moomoos, mamamoo will always be the winner of every show. I promise you mamamoo I'm never letting go. *tears*
Nikita Kumari I know.. I saw the live stream. I was expecting for them to win but they still did their best... I'm so proud of them... 😢 GASH I'M SO EMOTIONAL RIGHT NOW 😭
love how they always invited as a whole group, thank you immortal song 2 for never getting tired to show how talented mamamoo , my queen is back everyone, RELIABLE-MAMOO IS BACK!
I'm so proud of my girls. They literally left me speechless. You can tell the audiences we're having a religious experience with their expressions. That's what Mamamoo does to you! Like if you agree. Let's continue on supporting these beautiful humans 💜 MooMoos are so proud.
The thing I like a lot about mamamoos immortal song performances (aside from the superb musicality) is watching the original singers react. You can tell that they really enjoy and appreciate it too
![MAMAMOO - Love | 마마무 - 사랑 [Immortal Songs 2 / 2017.07.01]](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/jFDNt54IsO4/mqdefault.jpg)
이 영상의 진가는 반주 다 멈추고 멤버들 목소리만 나오는 부분에서 잔잔하게 깔리는 아카펠라와 마이크에서 손떼고 계시는 코러스분들임...
알려주셔서 감사합니다.. 감사합니다...
현재 인기1위는 블랙핑크지만..실력은 압도적으로 마마무가 1등이지
코첼라 서기로했는데 코로나때문에 무산됨ㅠ
To this day, I still can't find any 3rd/4th generation gg who can even come close to mamamoo's talent/versatility/vocals. Forever queens.
Their voices melt. Please bring Mamamoo back!!!
Byul got so many parts 😍 Get it, girl 😗
i hope have one day ,she just not rap in the song , i want to hear she sing
BlackCaTTss you can listen her solo:)
BlackCaTTss your wish come true! She got so many singing part in spring fever! Also sing in paint me!
Well she has a solo ballad last month..check out Snow MV/her perf at Music bank few days ago..
@@BlackCaTTss you will hear solo album in 14 friday!!
내가 마마무를 사랑하는 이유
엄마가 없어서
마마무 화음 너무 조아여ㅠㅠ
The harmonies are everythinggggggg. Hyejin's voice just has a tone thats so emotional omg :'(
Jayel i think she almost cry
Agree.. she can add tons of emotion in a song.
Mamamoo is a interpreter and good storyteller ! They bring out the emotions within the song so well. Also their insane harmony! 🤯✨
I say it every time they perform at Immortal Songs, but this might be my favorite performance ❤
That raw emotion in their voices, the perfect harmonies and Byuls heart wrenching rap that feels like a poem...
My goodness, Mamamoo, you managed to blow me away once again. Never letting go 😚
Wish I could like this video 5000000000 times 😅
Bloodorange5000 I feel you....
You and me dear moomoo, you and me. And thousands of others. :) ❤️
Rapping and poetry are both forms of lyricism, and even if a poem isn't read as rapping, it still has a rhythm. So it's not too surprising that you'd think it was like a poem. It'd be more surprising to me if you felt like it wasn't.
Werewolf211 Right :D I was merely pointing out that her rap in this performance felt more like a recital of a poem rather than what is considered to be the more "traditional" rap. Especially with the emotional delivery of her very touching lyrics and the ongoing story that she's telling. It's a quality that is really rare among idols and that I really appreciate 😄
저 무대 실제로 봤었는데 그 여운이 아직도 잊혀지질 않음 그리고 휘인 ㅈㄴ 예뻐서 놀람 실물 갑임. 웬만한 아이돌 공연 다 따라 다녓는데 마마무 성량은 ㄹㅇ 탑급 이런 실력파 여돌이 또 나올까 싶다
좋았겟음
나도 휘인 실물 보고 싶다..ㅠ
@@파덕-m1e 아 근데 ㄹㅇ 휘인은 코가 진짜 개이쁜듯
부럽습니다
휘인이 몇번째인가요?
한 소절 한 소절 진심으로 소중하개 부른다 어쩜 이렇게 찐으로 부를 수 있을까?
i'm here for a high quality music..don't touch me..
Thats what U get when U stan Mamamoo. 😁
yeah man...
even KBSKPop is sooo... ready for their comeback...look at their new logo 😎💜 #PURPLE
same
Same
SO PROUD OF MAMAMOO
They got 430 point and got one win over the act before them, but lost to the last act, who were right after them, sadly
jtsbbsps8000 not many idol can even beat their next competitor, so regardless I'm still proud of them 😄😄😄
Miraaa 14 exactly! And me too!
Miraaa 14 they won one round with 430 points tho...thats quite high for an idol group...
Nikita Kumari it really is. I think it's one of their highest scores ever, if not THE highest, on the show
용선.혜진.휘인.문별 이 노래에 대한 진심이 넘 고맙다
I LOVE Byul's raps in this, when she raps as vocal line are harmonizing, it's so emotional and moving.
Great performance, as expected from idol queens of IS2 :D
amethyste just Here for your profile picture xd nice to meet you Fellow Baby...I wish Our Boys collaborate with these amazing girls^^
"Idol Queens of IS2" I like it!
벌써 몇칠째 자기전에 듣고있지만 지루하지가않네요
저 다른 목소리와 개성들이 저런화음을...........믿고 들을수밖에 없는 마마무네요
Its their 11th perf and each one became legendary ❤
ellen chen i think its 12th
Anil Shah it's 11th actually
ellen chen it's the 11th
아쉽게 우승은 못했지만 개인적인 생각으론 진짜 완벽했던 무대였다..ㅎㅎㅎ
Mamamoo has always been delivering impressive stages, touching performances on Immortal Songs 2 but this stage particularly, is just full of raw emotions. This performance is by far the best I've seen from them (although their other performances are all legendary). I'm really proud to call myself a moomoo.
I AGREE !!!!!!!!!! I am so proud. By the end of the song I was cried so much. Thank you for such a BEAUTIFUL song.
Yeah this one is really good although "Flying into the night sky" still remains my favorite to this day. That seemed like it was cut straight out of a musical performance. So awesome. This one was pure emotion on the other kind. Very impressive especially considering their age. God I shutter with excitement to think what heights they might yet reach in the future.
I started crying when Moonbyul started rapping and the members are harmonizing.
와 소름 ㄷㄷㄷㄷㄷ 마마무 대단하다 진짜
Watching this in 2023. They just keep getting better.
When you understand barely any word, but the ballad get's your tears flowing anyway - then they did everything right. That performance is so beautiful.
I am ready
make the vocalists react to this pleease. and anw, good luck for school, umu!
waiting for your reaction
ReacttotheK yes :) I am waiting for u Umu😊 thx so much 😃
ReacttotheK i miss the old crew... When can we expect new reactions...?
Nobody ever is ready for this amount of sheer beauty, of harmony, of presence...
맘 불명 최애곡ㅜㅜ
중간중간에 조용해지면서 화사목소리 진짜 어울리고 휘인이랑 화사화음도 완벽하고
문별이는 랩에 진심이담겨있어서 보는내내찡하고 솔라는 진짜 더 폭빌힐수엤는데 조금 자제한느낌
진짜 너무좋다ㅜㅜㅜㅜㅜ
They will always be our #1. I'm so proud with these women. *tears*
OMG Hwasa's voice is very emotional,... they all seemed about to cry T T
they did cry after performing :(
byulddongbyul any fancam??
byulddongbyul what episode is this one ?
AyAReI00 i live streamed this but idk what ep im sorry :(
Good
마마무가 최고다 들어도 들어도
질리지가 않아요
4명 다 특색이 있어서 매력적이네요♡
TALENT TALENT TALENT
Vann Maxine and Talent (one for each member) 😆
4명의 천사들 아님????.......천국 그 자체다
이런 코러스 많은 무대 볼때마다 휘인이 참 중요한걸 다시 깨달음.. 언니 사랑해...
난 솔직히 마마무 불후의 명곡 노래 중 이 노래가 최애임 화사 보컬도입에 넋 나감
아니 이 노래는 들을 때 마다 왜 이렇게 짠하지...?
Moonbyul's rapping style is very unique. It sounds so raw, emotional and very poetic.
휘인양 노래 정말 잘하네요
화사 목 메이는 목소리 치인다....너무 좋다
queens of immortal songs 2 are back and they did it again! mamamoo always get me shook and i'm so proud to call myself a moomoo
is it me or did hwasa looks like shes gonna tear up at 4.01
I think so too. Her voice was cracking up at that point as she was about to cry on stage but she calmed herself down.
nana 26 yes, she held her tears.. I am crying too
surat Suriyaket aren't we all *sniffs*
buy the mozzarella I was wiping my running nose and tears tbh T T
byul already almost shed a tear
마마무 최고의 보컬이야~~ 감동이다
Sometimes, I really can't find words to describe Mamamoo's talent. They are just amazing.
They sing like angels, they contain their tears. I love them so much.
Im so proud of them.. they sing with full of soul.. its perfect there are no words to describe it... it made me cry.
you can see that immortal songs is really mamamoo's stage. they thrive here and they belong here, like it's their home. they always manage to move me everytime they perform. even though i don't understand the words, the way they convey the feelings and emotions of the songs through the way they sing and perform touch me everytime and make me feel like i actually understand the lyrics.
i'm so lucky to know them. i'm so lucky to be able to see them perform on stages like this. they are simply raw talent and no one can take that away from them. it's always a privilege to witness them in their element like this.
i will always root for them and they will always have my heart. thank you, mamamoo. 💜
Agree and queendom to mamamoo r queens when its come to talent this generation
Their renditions of these classics are always so freaking spectacular
Moonbyul's rap part :(((
So proud of MAMAMOO :((((
Anyone teared up at 0:00? damn the way the piano came in was- and then the way byul was just like narrating with her like this sorrowful voice- but then hwasa's voice was just too emotional- then the members harmonizations- and, and solar's highnotes- then wheein's EVERYTHING-
CLEARLY I'M NOT OKAY AND I FEEL LIKE CRYING DONT TOUCH ME
this comment made my day, seriously
Same
마마무 최애 노래중 하나... 진짜 ㅜ
QUEENS SLAYYYYY
at 3:10 the original singer(right?) looked so impressed/touched ahhhhhhh proud of my babies
Yep, that'S Noh Sa Yeon, the original singer. She really seemed to like Mamamoos interpretation of her song, she's so moved.
Hulan Musiclover she said "she was jealous of the version that mamamoo sang n wished she could have sung like that"... m proud of ma babies...
One of my favourite things is watching the small clips of the original artists' reaction when they get hit with the MMM power, and this was very satisfying.
Now i can loop this till the end of my days :p
Tidak hanya sekedar bernyanyi... tp penghayatannya dalam membawakan setiap lagu menjadi nomor satu... maka dari itu setiap lagu selalu berkesan jika didengarkan... ekspresi mereka juga selalu mendukung... apa lagi lagu melow gini... beeeeh....❤❤❤❤
역시 마마무는 다르다 ㅠㅠ
솔라님 목소리에 눈물 버튼이 있는 것처럼 눈물을 자극하네요. 대단한 목소리.
This performance brought me to tears just by listening to the raw emotion in their voices. Wheein, Hwasa and Solar are such amazing vocalists, I love all their voices. Let's stop comparing who's better because my girls came through and delivered. Our precious rapper Moonbyul was so passionate and commanded so much attention in this performance and i'm so happy she got a lot of parts :')
My favourite immortal songs 2 performance from them has always been 'Backwoods' but hands down this performance takes the crown. I have so much love and respect for this group, it would be such an honor to see them live one day. Mamamoo please come to Australia
Dear Ilhan I am Thai-MooMoo and i love Mamamoo so much💜 My life after knowing Mamamoo has been full of joy and of course whenever Mamamoo needs us, we are always there for them too 💜 I am really glad i got to know them 💜 Nice to meet u my fellow MooMoo 😌
Surat Suriyaket I'm glad to hear that, likewise! 😌 I've been a MooMoo since 2015 and Mamamoo is definitely my favourite girl group.
Dear Ilhan Me too! I hope they have a world tour soon. Hope they come to Indonesia. Actually, I'm a little bit jealous with Korean Moomoos who have much time and event with them kekeke
Let's support them keep growing up ✌😉
레전드가 레전드 노래를 부르네...
현존최상!
이번이 솔라 눈동자 보기 쪼매 힘드네ㅋㅋㅋ계속 눈 감고있엉❤️
ㅠㅠ 너ㅜ무 좋아
I clicked because of Saeyoon Noonim. But leave with an even greater respect for Mamamoo. This is their best Immortal Songs performance.
mamamoo is the best vocal group...just my opinion
Rizki Zen every moomoos opinion ;)
where's the lie tho😂
That's a fact, sis!
화음 실화냐? 진짜 개소름;; 실력 원탑임
The moment Hwassa sing, I cried already. Awesome as always my mamamoo
불명 최애곡 중 하나...ㅠㅠ 들을 때 마다 울컥함 ㅠㅠㅠㅠ
I really love when they all harmonize, but I feel something special when wheein and hwasa harmonize together. Like, you could feel their connections and love that bound by years together.
kathkhaye30 they're bff from teens!
Omg omg..I just woke up and found out they're back at immortal songs. Life is good.
Stan talent stan Mamamoo
It is out in melon, the audio is so clear and sounds even better.
thank you!!
11dmnsn Thanks!!
어벤져스네..
hiks...
mamamoo ... angels voice
my queen
솔라 진짜 예쁘지만 노래도 최고👍
마마무는 장점이 정말 많아
마마무 사랑해
the queens
THIS IS STANDARD
들어도들어도반해요마마무너무좋아요말로표현못하겠어요당신들목소리는정말천상의목소리예요♡♡♡♡
One of my all time favorite performances - and I am 65 years old! But this is a classic.
2:28 화음 진짜 미첫 도랏다 너무좋음 진짜 쌀뻔한정도가 아니라 진짜 쌋음 긴장 너무풀려서 쪼금 소량쌈...레알임.. 천상의 목소리임..
의미는 알겠는데...ㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋ 소량 쌌다니까 상상되고 더럽다...ㅎㅎㅎㅎ
@@밤하늘멍멍이먹어줘잉잉ㅇ 아잉
These girls are just amazing ... they are really into the song /me TEARS TT
I love them so muchh
진찌 ㅁ치쳤다..
I've been into kpop since 2008. I'm into many groups. MANY. And honestly I've never been blown away like these girls have blown me away. Their talent is just OUTSTANDING! Omg! I've only been a fan since 2016 but I'll continue to support.
Me after fofobebe era.
이 노래는 주는 의미가 크다
잘 들었습니다.
OMG OMG OMG
FIRST NOTE
FIRST RAP
FIRST HARMONIZATION
FIRST EVERYTHING IM ALREADY IN AWE OF HOW BEAUTIFUL THIS IS
thank you for existing mamamoo, please continue to bless us with your incredible performances
This is such an amazing performance. I can say this is another one of the best they have. Byul's rap, their harmonies, the emotions. They delivered it well. I actually teared with this performence. They did not win but for moomoos, mamamoo will always be the winner of every show. I promise you mamamoo I'm never letting go. *tears*
Cow goes moo they only won one round with 430 points but lost to a guy who took the trophy with 438 points
Nikita Kumari I know.. I saw the live stream. I was expecting for them to win but they still did their best... I'm so proud of them... 😢
GASH I'M SO EMOTIONAL RIGHT NOW 😭
love how they always invited as a whole group, thank you immortal song 2 for never getting tired to show how talented mamamoo , my queen is back everyone, RELIABLE-MAMOO IS BACK!
Vocals on point
Visuals on point
Harmonies on point
Rapping on point
Emotions on point
Mamamoo you never fail to amaze and make me cry
Omg this is the best perfomance in immortal song.
They great as always. Perfect is only word I can use to describe mamamoo 💕
Thats my mom... all 4 of them...💃
따라하고 파요 ~내 젊은시절이 되돌아 옵니다~ 지금의 그대가 그리워 져요♥️🤠💞🧏🏻♀️🌻🍒🌷🌷♥️💝💙💚🦋🪂
역시 마마무.... 안좋아할수가 없음..
this is really heartbreaking
When I streamed this live the moment Hwasa started singing, my heart started beating fast
Rj t when Hwasa started singing her voices got me cry right away😩
I'm so proud of my girls. They literally left me speechless. You can tell the audiences we're having a religious experience with their expressions. That's what Mamamoo does to you! Like if you agree. Let's continue on supporting these beautiful humans 💜 MooMoos are so proud.
진정한 가수
최선을 다하는 가수
감사합니다
solarbeautiful voice
최고 ㅠㅠ
wow wow wow. T.T i love you my queeeens
The thing I like a lot about mamamoos immortal song performances (aside from the superb musicality) is watching the original singers react. You can tell that they really enjoy and appreciate it too
Believe and listen to MAMAMOO 💜💜💜💜
마마무 외국가수입니까 당최 한글 댓글 찾기가 한강모래밭에 바늘찾기보다 더 힘더네?
그러게요😅
I am revisiting all the Mamamoo immortal songs performances. It’s so healing to listen to them and appreciate talents.