for the ones asking for moonbyul to sing remember she takes time to write her own raps for some of these songs. so appreciate her efforts in rap instead of bugging them for her to sing. she has an entire song to herself on the purple album so go listen to it
still moonbyul is so vocally talented too rbw is wasting so much talent, now of course byul can’t hit high notes like the others but at least give her some singing parts she’s just standing there while the others are singing their hearts out it’s not fair at all
Solar:"usually groups appear on some variety shows before comeback to promote their album, for us that show is immortal songs".... damn right... these ladies have made immortal songs their second home....
The thing about Mamamoo that I love the most is that they don’t try to outshine one another. They complement each other’s voices so good like omg. I feel like they are the epitome of how women can be the best version of ourselves when we stick together. 💕💕💕 omg.
Yes!! ❤️ They don’t outshine one another, love that about them. but some of the fans always pit them against each other. Especially Wheein stans always replying to comments that Wheein is better. sigh
I have a theory on their default positioning and it has to do with this. When there are 2 part harmonies it is either Solar and Wheein or Wheein and Hwasa. It's like a baton hand off with their voices. Solar and Wheein hand off at the higher register going into a belt while Wheein and Hwasa hand off on the breathy tones. In the middle, each have their own lanes.
i love how they will never leave moonbyul. She's not the strongest singer but she has meaningful rap which shows so much and they always include her in the performances here i love it.
But also she’s so important in a lot of their harmonizations and backup vocals. And her singing voice is actually very strong, in my opinion. More soul and strength than other main vocals in other girl groups.
Im a Blink too, and I agree. but our Blackpink girls also have talent of their own. but vocal-wise, n live performance-wise, Mamamoo are on the league of their own, they're amazing, no one can top them!
@@k-musictrash356 sure. im supporting every single group, im supporting talent, n hard work. it aint easy to be debuted, it aint easy to get into an agency. those idols have been thru a lot to be where n who they are right now. so one hate comment could affect their self-esteem, they're human just like us, who can get upset, sad, etc.
There is no other idol group that has performed at Immortal Songs as much as Mamamoo (they went around 13 times, second is Gfriend with only 4 appearances). This is what a group full of talent looks like, they are acknowledged as singers not just idols they are admired even by non- Kpop fans
Lily Christina I never knew how much Mamamoo loved immortal songs compared to regular groups. Thank you for shining the light on how talented and loved they are 😊 Reading the comment made me cry in happiness
I'm a moomoo, and I love Mamamoo, but technically speaking, if you add up all the members appearing individually, Super Junior has them beat with 16 appearances and 5 wins.
Hwasa's husky and emotion-filled voice Wheein's stable and clear vocals Solar's incredibly high notes Moonbyul's passionate rap I guess I just found the formula to goosebumps....
i think that Mamamoo redefine the meaning of this song, rather than singing to the lover, they sing for their dream for being singer.... they are like they hope that people can heard their voice, talents and dream.... I can really feel their enthusiasm...
i watched this performance for god-knows-how-many-times, i just realized that harmony or whatever that is on 6:20 was pure solar & wheein's voice, without the backup singers. goddammit mamamoo.
omfg i love when songs get super loud at the climax, and then drop to silence for a while. Or when it gets loud then super soft suddenly, always gives me chills! Amazing job, MAMAMOO!
@@ciskajoylufranco4750 i'm glad to know that they by their own capability could pull out this amazing perf.. I mean if they perform this on award show or any shows involving another kpo idol anytime they want they change the game
Moonbyul's parts just made the song a lot better and more passionate. And of course they slaaaaaaayyyyy. Hwasa really has that super emotional and husky voice, wheein's voice was super super clean and clear and quite angelic while solar's voice was really powerful and gives a very large impact. This just gave me the goosebumps especially at their harmonies. Its too perfect
it's too fully emotional😭 moonbyul rewrote the lyrics for add on Rap inside was amazing . solar seriously was the main vocal of mamamoo. whee in voice was amazing too 😭hwasa and moonbyul look like wanna cry at the end 💔💔 their voice deeply crush in my heart , well i was proud to be a moomoo ♥️😭
Sammichi sure fam! its bc in korean, 4 (사=sa) + with (랑=rang) + sun(해=hae) = saranghae (사랑해) means 'i love you' also the original lyrics in the song was "Me, me 4 with the sun" Me= 나 (na) when you add 나 to 사랑해 it changes meaning "나사랑해" means "i love myself" that was what Hwasa was actually saying hahah there ya go welcome to the moomoo fam btw :)
Solar's voice is so under-appreciated. I love what she does with her voice - how it can be so delicate, then powerful, and in some other songs, even guttural. Mamamoo's performances are just insanely good.
I'll tell you what... She was born with a gift... That really comes from heaven, that voice of hers. And we are all just as gifted to be able to listen to her!
Solar, "All singers and idol groups start on certain programs before their new album are released. For us is Immortal Songs" Of course, and we moomoos are always waiting for new performances! Keep slaying Mamamoo! 😙💕💕💕
The only kpop GG i find (until now) that all member with powerful vocally talented in their unique way every each one of them....not to mention solar ability to pole dance
listening to mamamoo singing this song is like sitting in a valley. hwasa's voice is like the warm fresh breeze sweeping trough, wheein's voice is like a stream of water in the river passing by, solar's voice is like seeing a wild baby deer from afar, moonbyul's voice is like a good memory with hopes of a good future. they always sings with their emotion. it's memorable. I've been listening to this song since this video came out on youtube, and I still get a shiver.
Performing live is the actual measure of pure talent. No studio enhancement, no autotune. Just golden voices full of emotions which make you cry even if you don't understand the lyrics. Love you mamamoo
I always come back to this performance...its just so satisfying. Their vocals here are top notch!. Hwasa with that depth and emotion in her vocal tone, pulling me in. Wheein with her clear and soft voice opening up my ears. Solar and her powerful piercing voice just hitting me where it hurts. Moonbyul with her poetry and rhythm capturing me to the story she's laying out. ugh. and then the harmonies!. Eargasms!
As an old man, (well, old enough), Mamamoo is the only girlsband (and Boysband too) I can listen too : these young women have very great singing skills. They need not to do sexual dances and show their bottom. Talent is enough... Of course they're very cute, but that's for younger people. Music is enough and their music is great.
O.K.Thanks a lot... There are a lot of very good Korean singers but you can't guess, hearing boysbands or girlsbands : all from the same pattern, and their companies prefer they learn dances by hearth than they improve artistic personalities. K-Pop is a sad industry, in fact : average life of such bands, three years, then, the biggest part of young boys and girls are alone, without money, trying to find any kind of job. They lost four or five years, running after dreams which often are nightmares...
CecildeMille1 if you like this kind of music with full of harmonization , check BTOB appearance in immortal song recently they sang 'under the sky'. you re gonna love it, i guess..
I don't know if any of y'all have ever seen Noh Sayeon on Running Man but she is honestly the sweetest, funniest, and most humble person. She's been in the industry 40 years and it hasn't changed her.
Recently, on Queendom, when AOA was picking an MMM song to cover, Jimin noticed that Moonbyul always has narration lines in the intro or the bridge. I never even realized that unique Mamamoo feature.
Men, someone told me in random comment section.. They said dont dare to watch mamamoo performance first cause it will never be the same. They put the bar to high and its already 2020 and im still agree
6:46 I know moonbyul's rap is so awesome and meaningful but... I just keep thinking back to the time she said she didn't like being in the vocal group because sometimes when she only has 2 or 3 or 1 parts, all she does is stand there... I'm glad she's started singing more so people can hear her incredible singing voice and she doesn't have to feel that way anymore 😊
I remember reading somewhere that in covering a song, you have to put your own twist in it. Performing a song just like how it was performed by the original artist is not cover at all, its called *KARAOKE* . So Byul rapping is like a Mamamoo signature. They showcased their artistry 💜
No Sayoun's reactions: 3:45 [smiles and leans forward] "Hey, they're not making a hash of my hit song" 5:27 [brought to tears] "That was a _gorgeous_ harmony!" 8:00 [big smile] "Mamamoo is awesome!"
I never Stan any kpop idol until I saw Hwasa's Maria dance with the best dancer month ago . From then on I watched all their vids in youtube and I am stanning them hard now. Why I only know them now? Why why why I am addicted to them.
There is really something special about solar's high notes, wheein's sweet voice, hwasa's sweet potato voice and moonbyul's passion in rapping and underrated amazing vocals. The energy of this group is making me emotional. I just love them so much!! Mamamoo makes me feel a lot
Pa Ba i'm annoyed too lol, if Byul isn't that comfortable, i will not force her to sing and i know the members will always support her if she wants to sing 😊
She didnt have the confidence to sing but recently she started singing and had a solo stage in one of the music shows which was something big for her and us moomoos!! Her album is coming out soon please support it hehe
She sings in a few songs in their albums i think like waggy and also the commercial song gleam. A throwback song would be um oh ah yeah where solar and wheein switch parts with byul and all of it portrays her voice when singing which is super unique like 😍😍😍🤩🤩🤩
Love is Mamamoo's best ballad (it's a cover, but they rearranged it and made it their own) I miss you, backwoods, Sting, Love story of a girl may have overflowing vocals, but this one right here, the girls continuosly harmonising, Moonbyul's anguish filled rap, the emotions they convey through this ballad, I really can't stress just how much of a masterpiece this is
When you realize that Solar is the pillar of the harmony in MMM... the way she switch from high to very high notes then suddenly lowers it down is amazing that's why Wheein and Hwasa gets there harmony right on point was also because Solar is leading them. Simply amazing ✌🏻✌🏻✌🏻
That little harmonization at the beginning with moonbyul’s rap literally gives me chills everytime 😭 someone should make a video with just that and I’ll be happy.
@@rhyasella she's basically good at everything, has a very stable voice whether it's low range or high, she's good at almost every music genre, she supports hwasa and solar's high notes since her voice can melt into anybody's, her singing technique is very different than the other members, plays instruments ( piano and drums ), paints and draws really well, dances , her style sense ( rocks casuals) also has a beautiful cheerful personality, she's the energy that charges the members and mamamoo's unofficial maknae. Cute like a puppy with mesmerizing DIMPLES. I love all mamomoo members but wheein hits differently.
@@rhyasella all of the above, plus wheein is often overlooked by new fans or casual listeners in group activites since she rarely does the belts or standout stuff in their group music as shes usually supporting everyone else but if you listen to her solo stuff once I swear you fall in love immediately lol
@@_mollusc_lover_1509 I was one of the guys that overlooked her. But when killing voice ver hit, I understood her role. She's a good dang sturdy bridge. If this is a band, she's a solid bass player. Its not the flashiest but a must to have. All 4 of them complimented each other well. I have tons of respect to their company.
When you know how beautiful Moonbyul's voice is and you've seen the video where she explains she often felt bored and left out because she had to just stand there for most of the songs during these live performances and your heart just breaks when you see exactly what she meant So proud of her for finally breaking out of her shell and starting to sing now. She doesn't use a powerful voice like Solar and Wheein but there's something about her voice that, even though it isn't crazy belting vocals, it's inexplicable and mind-blowing and you can't get enough of it once you hear it
I got the chills as soon as they started but starting from 4:08 i felt passionate. Mamamoo slayed this performance- from such soulful vocals to moonbyul's hard hitting rap and the beat drops complimented their talents all together.
i don't think I've ever actually cried watching a MAMAMOO performance, but this one really made me cry--I don't know if it was Hwasa's first few notes or what cause she looked like she was going to cry but the song was so beautiful and perfectly sung by MAMAMOO~
these four young ladies are so talented and each of their voices are so strong and stable and unique. moonbyul has improved since her debut, im so proud. i get goosebumps every time i listen to this, i cry when byul raps, solars high notes are perfect, wheein looks so gorgeous and hwasa is so into the song, you can see the emotions shes emitting every fucking time she sings. mamamoo needs more attention, mamamoo is art.
![MAMAMOO - You, In My Fading Memory | 마마무 - 흐린 기억 속의 그대 [Immortal Songs 2 / 2017.01.14]](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/hrRbLFCFXBA/mqdefault.jpg)
![MAMAMOO - You, In My Fading Memory | 마마무 - 흐린 기억 속의 그대 [Immortal Songs 2 / 2017.01.14]](/img/tr.png)
![MAMAMOO - Love Story Of A Girl | 마마무 - 어느 소녀의 사랑이야기 [Immortal Songs 2]](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/Tn7yICySgpA/mqdefault.jpg)
I seem to find myself on a mamamoo marathon every day or so now
I’m on Mamamoo marathon for three years already
me too
bruh same
Same here, so addictive that it always the first time I hear them sang these songs
I've been doing this every day for the past several months since quarantine started.
Solar was like "We always go to Immortal song to 'warm up' before our comebacks" *proceeds to slay the stage*
When their "warm up" is another group's greatest performance. But for mamamoo, it's just a WARM UP😂 SLAY QUEENS👑👑👑👑
@@chaengpeng9563 you mean mamamoo playground 😂
@@welcomingday2821 Nah, Mamamoo's home.
바보 what do you mean they are baking cake
Wowowo
MAMAMOO DEFINITELY RAISED THE BAR IN KPOP. THESE GIRLS DON'T DESERVED TO BE CALLED IDOLS. THEY'RE DIVAS!
They are called artists more than idol group. best compliment
They're idol with 4 main vocalis, 4 main dancer, 4 rapper 😍😍😍 they are truly entertainer
I have been saying this since I started my interest in them last week lol They are not kpop. They're ARTISTS.
Accurate af!
ARTISTS 😍
for the ones asking for moonbyul to sing remember she takes time to write her own raps for some of these songs. so appreciate her efforts in rap instead of bugging them for her to sing. she has an entire song to herself on the purple album so go listen to it
They probably just want other people (for those who didn't know she can sing) to acknowledge her singing skills 😍
@@honneurauventi Yes she said. Please stream her new song "Snow" 💜💜💜
still moonbyul is so vocally talented too rbw is wasting so much talent, now of course byul can’t hit high notes like the others but at least give her some singing parts she’s just standing there while the others are singing their hearts out it’s not fair at all
she should do both in the songs. i just feel she doesnt shine at all if she exclusively raps because it feels that she's pushed into the background.
I think whatever she decides to do and feels comfortable with, we should give her all the support :3
The fact that Mamamoo promoted their album on Immortal songs shows that they're on a completely different level
So agree. I love mamamoo.
They're beyond the K-Pop genre, they are real artists.
Gosh, yes
swag
Solar:"usually groups appear on some variety shows before comeback to promote their album, for us that show is immortal songs"....
damn right... these ladies have made immortal songs their second home....
The original singer looked so proud 😭💜
Cause they give justice to the song❤💙😭
Whereeee
This performance is a slap in the face for anti's.
yaAhne10 well every performance is😂 I just don’t understand how they could have antis🙄
DO THEY EVEN HAVE ANTIS, rofl.
After looking at every comment in a mamamoo vids i can say they had no antis.
unfortunately we do have some antis that go after the little things cause they can't find anything else :( they need to disappear asap
Wait they do have an anti?
Moonbyul's rap took the performance to a whole new level of perfection.
Like a spoken poetry
She's so talented😭
All of them. The flow was perfect✨
The thing about Mamamoo that I love the most is that they don’t try to outshine one another. They complement each other’s voices so good like omg. I feel like they are the epitome of how women can be the best version of ourselves when we stick together. 💕💕💕 omg.
Yes!! ❤️ They don’t outshine one another, love that about them. but some of the fans always pit them against each other. Especially Wheein stans always replying to comments that Wheein is better. sigh
UP
I have a theory on their default positioning and it has to do with this. When there are 2 part harmonies it is either Solar and Wheein or Wheein and Hwasa. It's like a baton hand off with their voices. Solar and Wheein hand off at the higher register going into a belt while Wheein and Hwasa hand off on the breathy tones. In the middle, each have their own lanes.
Hwasa looks like she was trying to hold back her tears. This performance was beautiful as always. :)
K T Endorsed👍👍👍
I feel that emotions too.. their emotions tho'
Am I the only one who love Wheein voice ??
Lisa Scarlette youre not alone
Lisa Scarlette you're not alone (2)
I'm glad
Lisa Scarlette you're not alone (3)
Seems like
i love how they will never leave moonbyul. She's not the strongest singer but she has meaningful rap which shows so much and they always include her in the performances here i love it.
best comment I have read so far ♡
But also she’s so important in a lot of their harmonizations and backup vocals. And her singing voice is actually very strong, in my opinion. More soul and strength than other main vocals in other girl groups.
@@mincloudmincloud i agree with you. She actually has a special flavor to her voice
In most of the other groups, she would be the main singer xD
I agree, her raps are always so awesome
I'm a blink, but I have to admit Mamamoo is on a different level of talent compared to other groups out there. ☺☺☺
I respect you for liking a and not hating them
Im a Blink too, and I agree. but our Blackpink girls also have talent of their own. but vocal-wise, n live performance-wise, Mamamoo are on the league of their own, they're amazing, no one can top them!
@@nuckesantiago Wow, thank you for supporting our girls
@@k-musictrash356 sure. im supporting every single group, im supporting talent, n hard work. it aint easy to be debuted, it aint easy to get into an agency. those idols have been thru a lot to be where n who they are right now. so one hate comment could affect their self-esteem, they're human just like us, who can get upset, sad, etc.
@@nuckesantiago I feel the same way =)
There is no other idol group that has performed at Immortal Songs as much as Mamamoo (they went around 13 times, second is Gfriend with only 4 appearances). This is what a group full of talent looks like, they are acknowledged as singers not just idols they are admired even by non- Kpop fans
Lily Christina I never knew how much Mamamoo loved immortal songs compared to regular groups. Thank you for shining the light on how talented and loved they are 😊
Reading the comment made me cry in happiness
Lily Christina
"Matilda" have been two times, they are really good for a rookie
I'm a moomoo, and I love Mamamoo, but technically speaking, if you add up all the members appearing individually, Super Junior has them beat with 16 appearances and 5 wins.
John Hackett "individually"
Update: they had their 14th show in immortal songs few days ago!
Hwasa's husky and emotion-filled voice
Wheein's stable and clear vocals
Solar's incredibly high notes
Moonbyul's passionate rap
I guess I just found the formula to goosebumps....
I am ur 1.1k like😃
I ALWAYS GET GOOSEBUMPS FROM MAMAMOO SKSKSKSKSK ❤❤😭
@@woozihae same !!
@@moonsunmichaengisthegayest177 ugh yes Moonsun really is the gayest ship 😭❤❤
@@woozihae YEAH !! 😁😍❤
Someone said: Mamamoo set the bar so high for any girlgroups who want to join Immortal song (y)
YES THEY DO!
They really sets the bar...
Stan our QUEENS!!!
any group in general tbh
OMG. They slayed the performances and got second place with 430 votes!!
Nurzawanah Anuar II who came first????
Lee Bong Geun. he is a pansori singer
they were only 8 votes away from winning
Nurzawanah Anuar II 430 is a really high score duhh
It seems that they are the first gg that managed to get such score! There's not many K-Group that can beat pro singer.
they just keep getting better and better with each immortal song performance they're unreal
thatsbombyo I KNOW OMG
I need MAMAMOO to appear on Immortal Songs again.
Hwasa gives the feels
wheein gives the balance
solar gives the punches
moonbyul bring the story alive with her rap.
FUCKING PERFECT!
this performance made me cry
Same
Same here. Just absolutely beautiful!!
Just can't hold my tears. Love Mamamoo!
aigoo.. uljiman ! uljiman ! ;D
Me too. 😭
i love how emotional hwasa is already at the start my queen 😭😭😍😍
it's been 6 years but this performance still makes me tear up.. moonbyul's rap really made it more emotional 😢❤
MAMAMOO - these ladies are something really special - they each bring so much talent to the stage. World-class performers.
Craig Winstanley 🙌🏻
To me, Moonbyul's rap is like poem reading. Each words that came out of her mouth is beautiful.
i think that Mamamoo redefine the meaning of this song, rather than singing to the lover, they sing for their dream for being singer.... they are like they hope that people can heard their voice, talents and dream.... I can really feel their enthusiasm...
Actually I think they dedicated this song their parents, Solar also said she was thinking of her mom then.
i watched this performance for god-knows-how-many-times, i just realized that harmony or whatever that is on 6:20 was pure solar & wheein's voice, without the backup singers. goddammit mamamoo.
omfg i love when songs get super loud at the climax, and then drop to silence for a while. Or when it gets loud then super soft suddenly, always gives me chills! Amazing job, MAMAMOO!
ThatAsianGuy try BTOB appearance in immortal song recently they sang 'under the sky' and it's amazing too..
lea ghandi still can't beat Story of a Girl performed by Mamamoo
Remember, our dear mamamoo girls arranged this perf❤
@@ciskajoylufranco4750 i'm glad to know that they by their own capability could pull out this amazing perf.. I mean if they perform this on award show or any shows involving another kpo idol anytime they want they change the game
I came here to watch a simple video. Then at 0:30 they hit me with harmonization, and I became a fanboy.
키난 Blakey this is just they introducing themselves as always haha
Welcome. 😁
Oh fuck you watch boyoung too
That was their introduction, lmao. "I say Mama, Mama, Moooo~"
키난 Blakey that’s how I became a fan girl
Their Immortal Song performances deserves more views.
idk yess, they give me chill everytime i heard all of their performance
Moonbyul's parts just made the song a lot better and more passionate. And of course they slaaaaaaayyyyy. Hwasa really has that super emotional and husky voice, wheein's voice was super super clean and clear and quite angelic while solar's voice was really powerful and gives a very large impact. This just gave me the goosebumps especially at their harmonies. Its too perfect
Mamamoo and BTS are amazingggg
it's too fully emotional😭
moonbyul rewrote the lyrics for add on Rap inside was amazing . solar seriously was the main vocal of mamamoo. whee in voice was amazing too 😭hwasa and moonbyul look like wanna cry at the end 💔💔 their voice deeply crush in my heart , well i was proud to be a moomoo ♥️😭
#4withthesun = *LOVE*
MOO to the ARMY technically its "I love you" tho
Sammichi sure fam! its bc in korean,
4 (사=sa) + with (랑=rang) + sun(해=hae) = saranghae (사랑해) means 'i love you'
also the original lyrics in the song was "Me, me 4 with the sun"
Me= 나 (na)
when you add 나 to 사랑해 it changes meaning "나사랑해" means "i love myself" that was what Hwasa was actually saying hahah there ya go
welcome to the moomoo fam btw :)
Sammichi 4 in korean is sa, with in korean is rang and the sun is hae. If u put it together it becomes saranghae
Sammichi as far as I know, the syllables of saranghae (which means I Love You) represents 4 with sun. 4=sa, with=rang, sun=hae
Sammichi multer
THEYYY SLAYYYEDD!!! ALSO MOON BYUL's RAP...OMG i don't know how much appreciation I can give to these girls...
Solar's voice is so under-appreciated. I love what she does with her voice - how it can be so delicate, then powerful, and in some other songs, even guttural. Mamamoo's performances are just insanely good.
wear earphone 6:20 my precious 10 seconds of angelic voice send from heaven 😭😭😭
I'll tell you what... She was born with a gift... That really comes from heaven, that voice of hers. And we are all just as gifted to be able to listen to her!
Yulia van Persie you know I rise my voice
Solar, "All singers and idol groups start on certain programs before their new album are released. For us is Immortal Songs" Of course, and we moomoos are always waiting for new performances! Keep slaying Mamamoo! 😙💕💕💕
the emotion they deliver and their voice. i cried
The only kpop GG i find (until now) that all member with powerful vocally talented in their unique way every each one of them....not to mention solar ability to pole dance
listening to mamamoo singing this song is like sitting in a valley.
hwasa's voice is like the warm fresh breeze sweeping trough,
wheein's voice is like a stream of water in the river passing by,
solar's voice is like seeing a wild baby deer from afar,
moonbyul's voice is like a good memory with hopes of a good future.
they always sings with their emotion. it's memorable.
I've been listening to this song since this video came out on youtube, and I still get a shiver.
I love this analogy
I love these humble talented girls so much. They deserve nothing but the best.
omg. i cried. mamamoo really deserved all the love. my humble ladies. ❤❤❤❤
Performing live is the actual measure of pure talent. No studio enhancement, no autotune. Just golden voices full of emotions which make you cry even if you don't understand the lyrics. Love you mamamoo
The amount of goosebumps I had while watching this though. I love Immortal songs for giving chance to artists who deserrve to be noticed.
I always come back to this performance...its just so satisfying. Their vocals here are top notch!. Hwasa with that depth and emotion in her vocal tone, pulling me in. Wheein with her clear and soft voice opening up my ears. Solar and her powerful piercing voice just hitting me where it hurts. Moonbyul with her poetry and rhythm capturing me to the story she's laying out. ugh. and then the harmonies!. Eargasms!
As an old man, (well, old enough), Mamamoo is the only girlsband (and Boysband too) I can listen too : these young women have very great singing skills. They need not to do sexual dances and show their bottom. Talent is enough... Of course they're very cute, but that's for younger people. Music is enough and their music is great.
Try SPICA. Those women also are incredible singers.
O.K.Thanks a lot... There are a lot of very good Korean singers but you can't guess, hearing boysbands or girlsbands : all from the same pattern, and their companies prefer they learn dances by hearth than they improve artistic personalities. K-Pop is a sad industry, in fact : average life of such bands, three years, then, the biggest part of young boys and girls are alone, without money, trying to find any kind of job. They lost four or five years, running after dreams which often are nightmares...
CecildeMille1 if you like this kind of music with full of harmonization , check BTOB appearance in immortal song recently they sang 'under the sky'. you re gonna love it, i guess..
Thanks a lot.
but, i thought spica disbanded? well he can try to listen to their songs they are good like mamamoo.
I don't know if any of y'all have ever seen Noh Sayeon on Running Man but she is honestly the sweetest, funniest, and most humble person. She's been in the industry 40 years and it hasn't changed her.
may9950 tuna noona
Yes tuna noona is one of my favorite guests!! 💕
Recently, on Queendom, when AOA was picking an MMM song to cover, Jimin noticed that Moonbyul always has narration lines in the intro or the bridge. I never even realized that unique Mamamoo feature.
Imagine how much more impressive if RBW had let Moonbyul join in the singing!
7:30
MAMAMOO: Are you listening?~ 🎤
Me: Hell yeah *cries*
Solar's high notes in this stage is really😍😍😍
I just realized that the song's meaning can be about a parent's love specially it's written in formal korean...and guess who's crying?
I FUCKING LOVE MAMAMOOOOOOOOOOOOO
It's hurt
Can still have this kind of stage from them again. I really miss acapella/harmony kind of performance from 4 of them😭
Men, someone told me in random comment section.. They said dont dare to watch mamamoo performance first cause it will never be the same. They put the bar to high and its already 2020 and im still agree
6:46 I know moonbyul's rap is so awesome and meaningful but...
I just keep thinking back to the time she said she didn't like being in the vocal group because sometimes when she only has 2 or 3 or 1 parts, all she does is stand there... I'm glad she's started singing more so people can hear her incredible singing voice and she doesn't have to feel that way anymore 😊
7:44 As you can see the last perfect harmony was solely from Mamamoo without backup vocalist… Incredible, just incredible.. Shivers down my spine
I keep coming back to this performance. I feel this is one of their most soulful performances. So underrated 🥺🥺
omg same
yeah same
This is the best stage of MAMAMOO in all their appearance at Immortal songs
To all the haters, this is talent. They deserve all the wins and attention they got rn.
This is a really heartbreaking song
I really felt their performance here.
I almost cry because of moonbyul's rap is like a spoken poetry each words has meanings and feelings
#4withTheSun #NeverLettingGo #KimYoungSun #MoonByulYi #JungWheeIn #AhnHyeJin #Mamamoo #ProudMooMoo 💜💜💜💜
I love how the original singer looked so proud of the fact that her song was justified by Mamamoo😭😭😭
No Sayeon is such a fluff
I remember reading somewhere that in covering a song, you have to put your own twist in it. Performing a song just like how it was performed by the original artist is not cover at all, its called *KARAOKE* . So Byul rapping is like a Mamamoo signature. They showcased their artistry 💜
You always make moomoo's proud! #4withsun
I feel mamamoo is so underrated. Mamamoo is my favourite girl group. They are not the stereotype group. They deserve more recognition....❤️❤️❤️
Mamamoo is indeed more than a girl group.. more than idols.. they're beyond the stereotype kpop idol.
Most talented girl of k pop
No Sayoun's reactions:
3:45 [smiles and leans forward] "Hey, they're not making a hash of my hit song"
5:27 [brought to tears] "That was a _gorgeous_ harmony!"
8:00 [big smile] "Mamamoo is awesome!"
I never Stan any kpop idol until I saw Hwasa's Maria dance with the best dancer month ago . From then on I watched all their vids in youtube and I am stanning them hard now. Why I only know them now? Why why why I am addicted to them.
i am same, once I started watching their videos...i realized and never thought I actually became a momoo without being official about it lol
I have been a SONE since 2009 Gee Era, I just became a MOOMOO since last year with White Wind Era, but guess what? *THEY ARE NOW MY STANDARDS*
Me too
Forever the girl group with the most vocal talent
There is really something special about solar's high notes, wheein's sweet voice, hwasa's sweet potato voice and moonbyul's passion in rapping and underrated amazing vocals. The energy of this group is making me emotional. I just love them so much!! Mamamoo makes me feel a lot
Omg moon's rap makes it on a anlther level
People, if Moonbyul wanted to sing they would let her, stop trying to stir controversy and create a fight between members...
ikr, they act like Mamamoo left Moonbyul out of the group or something, i'm so annoyed lol
Pa Ba i'm annoyed too lol, if Byul isn't that comfortable, i will not force her to sing and i know the members will always support her if she wants to sing 😊
Watch mama 2019 she sang there with jyp... She also sang in their new song ten nights 😊😊😊😊
She didnt have the confidence to sing but recently she started singing and had a solo stage in one of the music shows which was something big for her and us moomoos!! Her album is coming out soon please support it hehe
She sings in a few songs in their albums i think like waggy and also the commercial song gleam. A throwback song would be um oh ah yeah where solar and wheein switch parts with byul and all of it portrays her voice when singing which is super unique like 😍😍😍🤩🤩🤩
Love is Mamamoo's best ballad (it's a cover, but they rearranged it and made it their own)
I miss you, backwoods, Sting, Love story of a girl may have overflowing vocals, but this one right here, the girls continuosly harmonising, Moonbyul's anguish filled rap, the emotions they convey through this ballad, I really can't stress just how much of a masterpiece this is
Stan talent, stan Mamamoo 💜
7
The voice quiver Hwasa does when she’s holding back the tears 😭❤️
When you realize that Solar is the pillar of the harmony in MMM... the way she switch from high to very high notes then suddenly lowers it down is amazing that's why Wheein and Hwasa gets there harmony right on point was also because Solar is leading them. Simply amazing ✌🏻✌🏻✌🏻
Cassidy Skye I think the pilar MMM is wheein and they had said in radio
Yeah, I also remember they said Wheein is the foundation for their harmonies. :)
wheein (backbone/support)
+ solar (consistency/coverage)
+ hwasa (rear/power)
+ moonbyul (ground/stabilizer)
i think their harmony goes this way.
it's wheein
Watching one Mamamoo Immortal song performance always leads to a marathon . I always end up watching all the performances.
Me right now
That little harmonization at the beginning with moonbyul’s rap literally gives me chills everytime 😭 someone should make a video with just that and I’ll be happy.
That individual are you listening shows different mamamoo's style
Moonbyul - Charisma
Hwasa - Emotion
Wheein - Technique
Solar - high notes
How to spot a non-fans/casual listener/newbie:
1. Thinks Hwasa is all intimidating.
2. Neglect the existence of MMM's perfect child, Wheein.
Why only Wheein is perfect? Asking out of curiosity (since I am indeed just a casual listener)
@@rhyasella she's basically good at everything, has a very stable voice whether it's low range or high, she's good at almost every music genre, she supports hwasa and solar's high notes since her voice can melt into anybody's, her singing technique is very different than the other members, plays instruments ( piano and drums ), paints and draws really well, dances , her style sense ( rocks casuals) also has a beautiful cheerful personality, she's the energy that charges the members and mamamoo's unofficial maknae. Cute like a puppy with mesmerizing DIMPLES.
I love all mamomoo members but wheein hits differently.
@@rhyasella all of the above, plus wheein is often overlooked by new fans or casual listeners in group activites since she rarely does the belts or standout stuff in their group music as shes usually supporting everyone else but if you listen to her solo stuff once I swear you fall in love immediately lol
@@_mollusc_lover_1509 I was one of the guys that overlooked her. But when killing voice ver hit, I understood her role. She's a good dang sturdy bridge. If this is a band, she's a solid bass player. Its not the flashiest but a must to have. All 4 of them complimented each other well. I have tons of respect to their company.
Wheein voice is so soothing. She can hit high notes too i love her voice and also hwasa husky voice ❤️
When you know how beautiful Moonbyul's voice is and you've seen the video where she explains she often felt bored and left out because she had to just stand there for most of the songs during these live performances and your heart just breaks when you see exactly what she meant
So proud of her for finally breaking out of her shell and starting to sing now. She doesn't use a powerful voice like Solar and Wheein but there's something about her voice that, even though it isn't crazy belting vocals, it's inexplicable and mind-blowing and you can't get enough of it once you hear it
wheein voice bring me to another world its soooo beautiful. the part when solar and wheein harmony make my heart melt~~
I got the chills as soon as they started but starting from 4:08 i felt passionate. Mamamoo slayed this performance- from such soulful vocals to moonbyul's hard hitting rap and the beat drops complimented their talents all together.
I thought I was dead when I hear wheein's voice. She shows me a glimpse of heaven for a moment.
wowww i love how excited the audience when mamamoo was called
when Byul asked, 'Are you listening?'
i felt that
Independently strong voices... these 4 ladies are awesomely talented..
2:25
Moonstar rapping with such emotion while the others harmonize is one of the most beautiful thing I've heard in kpop.
i don't think I've ever actually cried watching a MAMAMOO performance, but this one really made me cry--I don't know if it was Hwasa's first few notes or what cause she looked like she was going to cry but the song was so beautiful and perfectly sung by MAMAMOO~
these four young ladies are so talented and each of their voices are so strong and stable and unique. moonbyul has improved since her debut, im so proud. i get goosebumps every time i listen to this, i cry when byul raps, solars high notes are perfect, wheein looks so gorgeous and hwasa is so into the song, you can see the emotions shes emitting every fucking time she sings. mamamoo needs more attention, mamamoo is art.
Wheein looks like an angel, seriously her best look ever ❤️❤️❤️❤️
02:41 God! Hwasa's voice is incredibly amazing. I already started crying from that part.
moonbyul's rap is perfect!
Moonbyul's rap just added a new flavor to the song and emphasizes the meaning of the song.