The Balfour Declaration: the High Point of British Zionism?

Поделиться
HTML-код
  • Опубликовано: 19 ноя 2024

Комментарии • 105

  • @anhenovember8043
    @anhenovember8043 7 лет назад +25

    This is extremely insightful, well spoken and relevant! Thank you Melanie Phillips for speaking truth, making sense, bringing clarity and not giving up! No matter what people say.

  • @jebjeb1498
    @jebjeb1498 4 года назад +10

    Long live Melanie Phillips from a British citizen.Her fearlessness is an utter breath of fresh air.Thank you.

  • @scampuss1974
    @scampuss1974 7 лет назад +15

    I am one British lady who is still an evangelical Christian and a minority in London my heart is with you .

    • @rtlinson
      @rtlinson 7 лет назад +6

      You must be a religious nutter

    • @etc6615
      @etc6615 6 лет назад +5

      M an evangelical from the Philippines. I am with you. Let's continue to pray.

    • @MegaTRUTH007
      @MegaTRUTH007 5 лет назад

      RGTsilversteam , Since when does believing in a Creator & life having a divine purpose makes you mad ?

  • @andrewjackson7014
    @andrewjackson7014 4 года назад +3

    Simply wonderful talk about a sobering and tragic history.

  • @scampuss1974
    @scampuss1974 7 лет назад +21

    My god this woman tells truth bless her

    • @XtreemMetalManRedToTheBone
      @XtreemMetalManRedToTheBone 4 года назад +3

      The British had no right to violently occupy the Middle East and make a Jewish State.

    • @Petal4822
      @Petal4822 3 года назад +1

      @@XtreemMetalManRedToTheBone It was the promised land of the Jews. The Bible told me so .

    • @coalyboi7939
      @coalyboi7939 3 года назад

      @@Petal4822 why are you everywhere

    • @everythingandmore5537
      @everythingandmore5537 Год назад

      ​@@Petal4822 it appears investigation by the British colonial admin always show Jewish provocation followed by riots. Melanie like to pont out the Jews who died leaving out the Arabs who died. Arabs here are both Muslim, christians and arabized Jews. She is selective in her talks.

    • @everythingandmore5537
      @everythingandmore5537 Год назад +1

      She said basically kill the Palestinians until they bow down and say uncle. Also she demands the west support Israel in this venture as Israel is a vanguard of western values. Back to the colonial days. It's us against the savages / terrorist.

  • @scampuss1974
    @scampuss1974 7 лет назад +17

    History is my passion its a shame what's going on in the schools sad very sad.

    • @shuttlefeather
      @shuttlefeather 5 лет назад +2

      @@thebestofallworlds187 Benjamin Harrison[1] Freedman (October 4, 1890 - May 1984)[2] was an American businessman, Holocaust denier,[3][4][5][6] and vocal anti-Zionist.[7][8] Born in a Jewish family, he converted from Judaism to Roman Catholicism.[9] Outside of political activism, Freedman was a partner in a dermatological institute and investor for small business escort.

    • @XtreemMetalManRedToTheBone
      @XtreemMetalManRedToTheBone 4 года назад

      The British had no right to violently occupy the Middle East and make a Jewish State.

    • @afritimm
      @afritimm 3 года назад

      Ottomans had no right to steal it from the Jews.

    • @afritimm
      @afritimm 3 года назад

      Most of North Africa was stolen by Arabs.

    • @carlroberts4540
      @carlroberts4540 Год назад

      ​@@thebestofallworlds187 Qq❤q@The.jews.gets..settelers.land.in.palistine..not.in.isreal.❤I sreal❤.Did.not.exsist.until.the.u.s.a..called.the.settiers.so..palistians.jews

  • @kymvanderkaag1474
    @kymvanderkaag1474 6 лет назад +11

    Brilliant and clearly well researched. Thank You.

  • @vman9591
    @vman9591 3 года назад +3

    Thank you, Melanie, for your courage to tell the truth in the world blinded by lies.

  • @21CENTURYLIVE
    @21CENTURYLIVE Год назад +2

    Excellent

  • @bonniebluebell5940
    @bonniebluebell5940 4 года назад +1

    Lay it all at the feet of the British...if anything, they should have stayed out of that war period....great historical analysis.

  • @nozislam
    @nozislam 4 года назад +10

    Some of the darkest chapters in the history of our world involved the forced relocation of a small group of people to satisfy the demands of a large one. I'd hoped that we had learned from our mistakes, but it seems some of us haven't.

    • @gadifhff4023
      @gadifhff4023 4 года назад

      thank you !!!

    • @afritimm
      @afritimm 3 года назад

      After WW2 millions of people were relocated across Europe, South Asia and East Asia. Only the fanatical Palestinians Arabs are still fighting over a tiny sliver of land. The only explanation is anti-Senitism.

    • @nozislam
      @nozislam 3 года назад

      @@afritimm Stay off the drugs.

    • @coalyboi7939
      @coalyboi7939 3 года назад +1

      @@afritimm Naive thing to say. The historical value of this land trumps most other if not all places in the world and who wouldnt fight over thier home?

    • @leawright563
      @leawright563 2 года назад +2

      @@coalyboi7939 is it theirs tho

  • @ungrateful-66
    @ungrateful-66 4 года назад +6

    What a great history lesson! Never knew about how the British police had aligned with the NAZIs while serving the British Mandate in Palestine... I’m not surprised at this though.

  • @harveygoldberg5730
    @harveygoldberg5730 7 лет назад +8

    Brilliant as always.

    • @newmoon54
      @newmoon54 6 лет назад +1

      Oi veyyyy Harvey!~!~! Such a mushnik you are!!! Phillips is as brilliant as a match light in a windstorm!!! She assumes (incorrectly!!!) that Jews are something special, or ABOVE everyone else in the world,, a world that God made for US,,,, the entirety of human beings,,,,, NOT Jews alone!!! Fact!!! Adam and Eve were NOT JEWS~!~ ABRAHAM WAS NOT A JEW,,, HE WAS AN ARAB,, FACT!! He was circumcised at nearly 100 years of age!!! His firstborn was Ishmael,, born before Isaac. And sadly,,, you egoshitstical jews (and you may be one yourself!) deny that Arabs are blood-relatives of the jews!!!! Palestine was once owned by the Canaanites, fact, as the bible plainly says! And so, jews are NOT the OWNERS OF PALESTINE!!! For 2000 years Arabs have lived and died on land that was actually theirs by historical record,, and for them to be brushed aside, AGAIN,,, is immoral, indecent, and cowardly!!!!! jews cause their own persecution~!~!~!~

  • @scampuss1974
    @scampuss1974 7 лет назад +11

    Love ISRAIL much love shalom

    • @dingdingdingding2871
      @dingdingdingding2871 5 лет назад

      Haspigbara

    • @gomezesmorticia
      @gomezesmorticia 5 лет назад +1

      ISRAIL? Israel!!!!! Idiot!!!!

    • @michaellamont2605
      @michaellamont2605 4 года назад

      @@gomezesmorticia ישראל
      Idiot

    • @michaellamont2605
      @michaellamont2605 4 года назад +1

      Israel needs allies. Not many good people left.
      Israel is a litmus test for morality
      only ignorant, stupid or EVIL people hate Israel.

  • @margaretvaughan8203
    @margaretvaughan8203 7 лет назад +10

    Well said Melanie!!!

    • @afritimm
      @afritimm 3 года назад

      He’s a self-hating Jew.

    • @everythingandmore5537
      @everythingandmore5537 Год назад

      ​@@thebestofallworlds187 Melanie says Israel always acts within international law. That a joke. UN, ICC and the ICJ decisions on Israel are cast aside by Israel all the time. Also the current ratio agreed by the US and Israel is that the IDF can kill 20 Palestinians for every Jew killed before the US administration will tell the IDF to stop. Apparently the kill ratio is in the Jewish Bible.

  • @noneofyourbusiness9635
    @noneofyourbusiness9635 2 года назад +1

    @10:33 return God’s chosen people
    @16:31 race and home purposes
    @36:10 Hitler Arabs on British payroll
    @38:30 British stopped “Jews” from escaping slaughter into Palestine

  • @scampuss1974
    @scampuss1974 7 лет назад +15

    Long live Israel and the Jewish people.

    • @newmoon54
      @newmoon54 6 лет назад +2

      What about everyone else,,,, asswipe?!?! God created the Arabs as well as jews! You are an ignoramus!!!

    • @afritimm
      @afritimm 3 года назад

      Arabs are racist. Entire Arab world is 99.9% Judenrein. Israel has 2 million Arab citizens.

  • @mc-lb9dk
    @mc-lb9dk 2 года назад

    nothing against the public in the room, but where are the young people to learn about what world they are living in?

  • @vikashhemakumar4081
    @vikashhemakumar4081 Год назад

    Knowledgeable lady

  • @MsJoybird1
    @MsJoybird1 Год назад

    In God’s timing, what God foretold knowing the end from the beginning…Israel became a nation after two thousand years!

  • @liguten
    @liguten Год назад

    It was not a Declaration but a letter. It's so different!!

  • @stuartcrossland1746
    @stuartcrossland1746 7 лет назад +3

    Yt, Albert Pike and the 3 world wars.

  • @scampuss1974
    @scampuss1974 7 лет назад +3

    God is with me but religion is not.

  • @fico97
    @fico97 5 лет назад +15

    Freedom for Palestine 🇵🇸🇵🇸

    • @faithalonekjv5123
      @faithalonekjv5123 5 лет назад

      ruclips.net/video/tMxe1JMeeRU/видео.html

    • @MegaTRUTH007
      @MegaTRUTH007 5 лет назад

      Zeljis li Jesenovsc opet ?

    • @PineapplePineapple-qc3ze
      @PineapplePineapple-qc3ze 4 года назад +2

      Did you not listen or understand what Melanie was saying.

    • @michaellamont2605
      @michaellamont2605 4 года назад

      @@PineapplePineapple-qc3ze you can't win an argument with an idiot.
      Islam has shown how important boarders are.

    • @afritimm
      @afritimm 3 года назад

      It’s already free. The 20 Arab dictatorships are not.

  • @danielmoshejohnson
    @danielmoshejohnson 6 лет назад +4

    I want to first start off by saying thank you for the opportunity to offer a perspective from my angle of this conflict. Each person has an important voice in the world, if it’s positive and adds to peace not war.
    Although, it is written” we fight not against flesh and blood, but against powers and principalities”, the Kabballa calls it the opponent.
    What ever it is, it has many faces, flags, doctrines, ideologies and principles, that all indicate, stagnation!
    Why stagnation in human relations, for earth hovers in full circular space time suspension, which should require all intention,, for this is prevention, from the psychological mental lynching, a reason for the body detention.
    Religious dogma, representatives of free speech, sovereign free will, true purpose documented scientifically in democratic zones and international law must be even and just for all who live ethically.
    This should be the peace plan for any region of this temporal construct we call Earth. We did not build this planet, this makes everything and everyone in potential debt, and that debt payment must resemble purpose, planetary positioning and the process of sharing as one.
    All planet operations should reflect a world from a leaser perspective, where the owners world is treated with respect by the human occupancy, whose lease is temporary.
    Now, we don’t reside in such a world, as of yet, but we do live in a world with great potential. We can nearly reach the next planet, yet we can’t fully make peace among created nation states.
    Peace in the Middle East can only be maintained if the rights of the existence of the state of Israel, already established over 60 years plus, is accepted and respected. One would think that a governing body would help maintain law and member opinions, round table negotiations where all nations who have input can speak and religious opinions should never override the right to exist.
    Since we occupy a planet measured in war capability, economical obtainment, currency and consensus popultation growth and development, war victory in mandating terrortiry must have rules, and where Israel is concerned, rules have been applied, wars have been secured and won, but not respected.
    So the answer is, where lies the biased world governing body or universal planetary order, that can make rulings fairly based upon system rules agreed upon by all participants whose choose to be a member of a nation where each participant can have the opportunity to excel if potential lies in that individual.
    Israel, like any other nation, was recreated based upon, first, the rights of the Allied Powers to so so, after the Ottomans operate a tyrannical empire for 400 years, an empire where a non globally agreed upon ideology was the judge and jury.
    During that empire many people suffered and wete murdered, and there was no one in the region challenging their abusive rulership and ownership of the people. Now today, we have a legitimate Israel, which conducts it’s nation as a member of a plan called democracy, where no Sultan, or Ottoman court or Iman controls your life.
    This thing called democracy, has attracted millions of Muslims to democratic zones, they understand that Islamic States are nor essential in a world where free will is nor something that should take order from a system controller, if you will….
    With an Allied power team that consisted of top world brokers who made an agreement, and recreated nations, then why of all the nation’s recreated and zoned, the tiny Jewish state is not accepted.
    Imagine if the Allied Forces were men who were familiar with the original map of Israel, the border would stem up into modern day Iraq.
    The answer to peace is simple, to clear out, relocate and evacuate all non Jews from the area ordered to the Jewish homeland. And then the neighboring Arab states, whom were recreated on Jewish land apprehended by previous wars, would be told that they should be grateful.
    History is important, but we need a governing body that operates in merit and war rule rules. …..
    Daniel Moshe Johnson

  • @godsdice911
    @godsdice911 3 года назад

    Britian is up to date a Zionism homeland

  • @michaellamont2605
    @michaellamont2605 4 года назад

    Earnist Bevin LABOUR
    Minister for Clement Attlee
    Aided the Start of NATO.
    Ended the mandate of palistine

  • @Speak-The-Truth-Now
    @Speak-The-Truth-Now 7 лет назад

    This is how Muslims view the Balfour Declaration:
    ruclips.net/video/wxlKbYL8VLc/видео.html

  • @pauljamessquibbs.3945
    @pauljamessquibbs.3945 5 лет назад +3

    What's wrong with Uganda?

  • @ThePantygun
    @ThePantygun Год назад

    Scottish, not british. Balfour's seat isn't english. Not even by support.

  • @allgood400
    @allgood400 Год назад +1

    U know if on the wrong side when ur backed by evangelists.

  • @pauljamessquibbs.3945
    @pauljamessquibbs.3945 5 лет назад +5

    Only a Jew can make a career out of complaining.... Lol!!

    • @faithalonekjv5123
      @faithalonekjv5123 5 лет назад

      Squishing Crisps the problem is “Jew” isn’t a race. That explains why you have this stupidity of “chosen race” which is merely a pretext for elitist war profiteering disguised as “bible prophecy” supported by colonists slave traders countries-US, Britain, etc. it’s so obvious this is all smoke and mirrors.

  • @mildred4016
    @mildred4016 6 лет назад

    up mi