Has The Constitution Failed Us, Or Have We Failed The Constitution?

Поделиться
HTML-код
  • Опубликовано: 1 фев 2025

Комментарии • 84

  • @amitprakashsingh5940
    @amitprakashsingh5940 Месяц назад +4

    The discussion is very important. But the problem is that nobody is worried about poor old people, the widows,and the handicap people who are forced to stand in lines to get some coins to add up to some rupees .The problem of shelter is another problem. Then it is often said that poors are being looked after under some scheme. But any leader from opposition has not checked the govts' claims. I hope kapil ji would pay attention to down to earth topics too.

  • @mithunbarua9871
    @mithunbarua9871 Месяц назад +4

    I see Four Great Leaders and Elder's, where our Country Rest in Justice.

  • @joshuacherian6718
    @joshuacherian6718 Месяц назад +3

    The constitution of India drafted by Ambedkar was ahead in 1947 and continues to be ahead of Indians even in 2024. India should shed it's cosmetic religious bias and adhere to the constitution. This alone will ensure India becomes ahead of the entire world.

  • @ravishankar-x1w
    @ravishankar-x1w Месяц назад +2

    When you have a person like Kalyan Bannerjee, you are failing us on a healthy debate about constitution.
    Karti C remained a silent spectator when Kalyan criticised the congress party...
    Kindly bring in knowledgeable and mature people for such discussions, Kapil Sab.

  • @metamotsu1792
    @metamotsu1792 Месяц назад +3

    I am fed up if democracy . Too much corruption.

  • @ameyadoijad3199
    @ameyadoijad3199 Месяц назад +3

    The term "Socialist" was added in the preamble through the 42nd Amendment Act. It was never a part of the idea of Constitution makers.
    Indira Gandhi forcibly penetrated it in the preamble during the emergency.

  • @Rohanm005
    @Rohanm005 Месяц назад

    Sir thank you for this meaningful discussion mein dhundne to ek ncert ka question ka ans aaya tha ki jo mene likha h wo shi h ya nhi prr gyaan ka sagar mujhe mil gya iss video se thank you so much sir

  • @geetharangarajan55
    @geetharangarajan55 Месяц назад +1

    Sir please save the demicracy, save the Constitution and the save the fundamental rights of the people.

  • @azeezkhan5965
    @azeezkhan5965 Месяц назад

    Excellent meaningful discussion

  • @roshnidadachanji2062
    @roshnidadachanji2062 Месяц назад

    Very true what they spoke about.

  • @uppaijohn8770
    @uppaijohn8770 Месяц назад +2

    Who mixed relegion with politics? Remember Shah bano case?

  • @mohammedgayasuddin6502
    @mohammedgayasuddin6502 Месяц назад

    Greetings 🙏

  • @sriprakashhr9578
    @sriprakashhr9578 Месяц назад

    NEITHER. i read a translation of the ARTHASHASTRA,pinlished 1904 many years ago in a library. But this question asked by CHANAKYA has stuck in mh mind.
    In a discussion, Chanakya asks, what is the ONE MOST IMPORTANT in these - Raja ( ruler) Rajyaanga, (rules of governance) Rashtra ( stste or coumtry).
    We sjould ne asking this question agaim to ourselves.
    Chanakya explains. The Ruler can be changed, The Rajyaang can be changed but THE RASHTRA's interedt CAN AND SHOULD NEVER BE CHANGED.

  • @lawrencekelman1473
    @lawrencekelman1473 Месяц назад

    I've listened to everyone on the show . The PM Modi and law Minister Kirinriju are to blame for the failure of parliament . The members of the BJP are illiterate about what politics is all about . Some of them are class 5 to 8.but have been elected. Some of the minister's never stood for MP election but still holding ministerial posts. Today none of the Institutions are running successfully. This is because the are politically appointed people as they listen to their their political
    Boss.

  • @rmhosamani
    @rmhosamani Месяц назад

    💐

  • @Lobaniodyuo
    @Lobaniodyuo Месяц назад

    We the upright thinkers never failed but section of the people right from British rule who are doing dalal with the British India were still destroying the very fabric of democracy and the constitution.

  • @subbiana3611
    @subbiana3611 Месяц назад

    Sir 75 years: For these two questions; Let us reread the Kolaknath SC verdict and the Marathon Kesavanantha Bharati Supreme court proceedings and the verdict the crystal clear answers are there.and let us visit the book by By
    Justice Dr VR.Krishna Aiyar's Half Hidden Justice ------" 90 percent answers were there.
    Thank you.Professor Dr A Subbian Formerly Emeritus Professor Annamalai University From Thanjavur

  • @knnpillai7438
    @knnpillai7438 Месяц назад

    Our Constitution is an ideal one. But to some people, the words secularism and socialism are taboos. It is they who denounce the Constitution.

  • @rajamin4367
    @rajamin4367 Месяц назад

    These lawyers have made lots of money by defending the most corrupt and terrorist, shame on these guys.

  • @user-fj3ic5kt3fakv
    @user-fj3ic5kt3fakv Месяц назад

    It has been told that indian constitution is "rigid" one that can't be amended easily. But how has it been amended more than hundred times? What are the draw backs in our Holy Constitution!

  • @drmlbhatia
    @drmlbhatia Месяц назад

    I fully agree with Mr Dave. Of course it is easy to blame the Politicians. But it is US, the people, who elect these politicians?

    • @drmlbhatia
      @drmlbhatia Месяц назад

      People get the Government they deserve and Government gets the people they deserve.
      Franz Fanon
      "Wretched of the Earth"

  • @uppaijohn8770
    @uppaijohn8770 Месяц назад

    Observation on ED , I too agree!.

  • @GopalTayade-e2e
    @GopalTayade-e2e Месяц назад

    Do you think that we have hopeless judiciery?

  • @rmhosamani
    @rmhosamani Месяц назад +1

    Stereotype broken discussion.
    Rock solid constitution n we have failed manipulated the constitution.

  • @ravinderpalsingh4225
    @ravinderpalsingh4225 Месяц назад

    Political leaders in every state have failed in not educating the people on the values of constitution to the ordinary people.
    Unless the Constitutional principles and values are taken and explained to the people, these chats between intellectuals will not help the people

  • @uppaijohn8770
    @uppaijohn8770 Месяц назад

    Judges are identified by collegium. Is govt responsible for their actions?

  • @aakashsingh409
    @aakashsingh409 Месяц назад

    An individual can never make affidavits for 1.5 billion

  • @NandKumar-qq3xk
    @NandKumar-qq3xk Месяц назад

    Constution" and what should be and should not remove ?

  • @yoganandasarma7771
    @yoganandasarma7771 Месяц назад

    Judicary and the people at large are successful in maitaing the sanctitity of the constitution .some of the aberrations are corrected some will be corrected in coruse of time .Todays discussion itself is an ample evidence of sucess of constitution.
    cotinuation of some addtions to the con

  • @Shankar-zs5ce
    @Shankar-zs5ce Месяц назад +1

    You are prejudices men , how you expect good things in society.

  • @123456789049058
    @123456789049058 Месяц назад

    When Zinna divided this country, why islamic followers remained in Hindustan by not going to Pakistan. Who added secular with ulterior motives of vote bsnk. There the constitution did not shine to the articles enshrined in the constitution.

  • @uppaijohn8770
    @uppaijohn8770 Месяц назад

    Congress dismissed stateb govts 10 times. But more democratic...?

  • @NandKumar-qq3xk
    @NandKumar-qq3xk Месяц назад

    Till naw What is Basic Defination of your ?

  • @aakashsingh409
    @aakashsingh409 Месяц назад

    Show this message to Hon'ble Kapil, if he thinks he can change my opinion I am ready for a paid Internship

  • @aakashsingh409
    @aakashsingh409 Месяц назад

    Well being honest, Hon'ble senor Kapil, needs to get his words in parallel with his narrative, it seems so treacherous to us who were not a part of the Raj until 1857, also we do not resonate with your Fabian sense of constitution. Babasaheb, didn't anticipate that it would be enforced by a British carcass.

  • @veerappadevaru3574
    @veerappadevaru3574 Месяц назад

    Who wrote BHARATH CONSTITUTION...::-
    Dr. B. R Ambedkar or
    Jawaharlal Nehru.. Karnataka Government High school social Science (10 Standard)
    Teaches::- Jawaharlal Nehru.. give Clarity with Correction

  • @arunavadasgupta2147
    @arunavadasgupta2147 Месяц назад

    ICJ
    Received
    19
    Doctorate Degree
    Confirm

  • @jatinshah3566
    @jatinshah3566 Месяц назад

    Talk of lower courts gone to nuts due to bjp.
    Most judges in search to please state for promotions i.o. serving law,justice after ex cji puja and accepting NHRC.

  • @uppaijohn8770
    @uppaijohn8770 Месяц назад

    Good fun. Can last for another 25 years, minimum.

  • @Dadasahab1234
    @Dadasahab1234 Месяц назад +1

    Discussion among Congress bhakts. 😅

  • @aprbala4332
    @aprbala4332 22 дня назад

    Was Nehru (Neero) selected as PM on merit?

  • @uppaijohn8770
    @uppaijohn8770 Месяц назад

    Poweful leaders are a must to catch the ex finance minister who has got assets in many countries

  • @vishpatel802
    @vishpatel802 Месяц назад

    RSS made our Courts Shakhas.

  • @विधीमंथन
    @विधीमंथन Месяц назад

    Adv. Kalyan's opinions are very funny 😂......

  • @srsays
    @srsays Месяц назад

    Crying wolf gang! India's Constitution and democracy is rock solid!
    Where were these gangs during UPA when we had a non-function govt and managed by Congress chairperson instead of prime minister? Where were they during congress ruled emergency?
    Secular was never part of initial constitution and only added later as amendment.
    Kalyan is a joker and his discussion shows the quality of people we send to parliament.

  • @AmbSanma
    @AmbSanma Месяц назад

    Many time Congress destroying construction during indira Gandhi now Hindus can sleep peaceful with BJP government handles

  • @RabinderSharma
    @RabinderSharma Месяц назад

    They are a syndicate fooling all of of, just polishing each other. I am sure they have deal among themselves for such show.

  • @pratyushsinha1297
    @pratyushsinha1297 Месяц назад

    Dave also sometimes cries u forgot to mention watch papad show

  • @jayanandparande7108
    @jayanandparande7108 Месяц назад

    Way of success we have our brain power use it to solve all trouble easily.
    Ek bano Nek bano.
    Rajghatna ko rastradharm ka darja deke usake antargat jatidharm bhedmukt nagrikta ke madhyam se jatidharm bhedmukt sanwidhan. Is an official realign for citizen.
    Nagrikta ko ghatnacuakra ke dayare me Lana .
    Global conference party for global citizen act only. Maintain Global standerd. Devolopment of citizen.
    Their is no detachment on the base of cast and realign between citizen ship policy.
    Responsibility of nation against citizens first and responsibility of citizens against nation first. That solve.

  • @NandKumar-qq3xk
    @NandKumar-qq3xk Месяц назад

    Sambida ? Aapke paash kya likha hai ? Dharan kya nahin karnan hai ? Karnen ko hi chuuki Sambida = Samadhan likhit " auur alikhitt kya ? Chahiye ,

  • @uppaijohn8770
    @uppaijohn8770 Месяц назад

    After all this is an elected government. People decided in favour of results or improvement to their life. We saw UPA, a fully democratic fully corrupt . This is better.

  • @aprbala4332
    @aprbala4332 22 дня назад

    Why this hue and cry now? What you did when you were in power?

  • @ravinder5874
    @ravinder5874 Месяц назад

    KS ur a great lawyer of sc and currently Head of Bc ,do u support that no practising lawyer in SC n HC should be part of the govt ,second do u support lawyer also should have retirement age so that new generation will get chance like judges have retirement age .Then only we will things of ur balancing act otherwise ur pushing one family prty agend nothing else nd 3rdly ur knowledge should be with building nation not with breaking forces.Constitution will run country by making fair balance

  • @chaitanyasharma1927
    @chaitanyasharma1927 Месяц назад +3

    Theives are discussing about safety of a locker!! What an Irony!! 😂 People who facilitated and felicitated Islamism over constitutionalism throughout their life are discussing feasibility of Constitution.

  • @popatbhaimoriya
    @popatbhaimoriya Месяц назад

    Articul.7b.what.is.this

  • @lawrencekelman1473
    @lawrencekelman1473 Месяц назад

    I've listened to everyone on the show . The PM Modi and law Minister Kirinriju are to blame for the failure of parliament . The members of the BJP are illiterate about what politics is all about . Some of them are class 5 to 8.but have been elected. Some of the minister's never stood for MP election but still holding ministerial posts. Today none of the Institutions are running successfully. This is because the are politically appointed people as they listen to their their political
    Boss.