"I'd DEFINITELY Take Isak Over Haaland!" Final Whistle Panel ARGUE Over Who's The BETTER Striker!
HTML-код
- Опубликовано: 9 фев 2025
- The Final Whistle discuss Alexander Isak's superb run of form and debate how he compares to Erling Haaland.
Subscribe: / talksport
Enjoyed this RUclips video? 😍
🖥️ talkSPORT's Website: talksport.com/
📲 talkSPORT's Twitter: / talksport
📷 talkSPORT's Instagram: www.instagram....
👤 talkSPORT's Facebook: / talksport
📱 talkSPORT's Tik Tok: / talksport
🔴 Download the talkSPORT app HERE! - talksport.com/...
🔎 Want to see if you feature on our RUclips channel? Check out our Best talkSPORT callers playlist: • The BEST talkSPORT Cal...
#talkSPORT
#PremierLeague
#alexanderisak
#isak
#newcastle
#newcastleunited
#spurs
#tottenham
#tottenhamhotspur
#haaland
#erlinghaaland
#mancity
#manchestercity
As a Toon fan I wouldn't swap Isak for Haaland. Isak is more versatile and a better all round player.
Stick Isak in that terrible City squad and he wont even see 15 goals in a season
@@Kat-jk7zqHaaland only scored 6 more than Isak last season in a season where city won the league and Newcastle struggled most of the season with Isak playing off scraps 😂
@@Lootzuh yeah and that ws considered an off season for Haaland. Go figure
@@Kat-jk7zqare you dumb isak scoring 15 goals this season at Newcastle put him in Man City he score 30
@@Kat-jk7zq He scored 21 for us last season even though we had to field weak teams due to injury and finished 7th. That was only 6 less Haaland in one of the best teams ever.
I'm a huge fan of Isak but all of a sudden they've got a shiny new toy and they've tossed Haaland away.. Who's next? Delap? 😂 Haaland is a generational striker. these RUclipsrs have no idea about football..Their knowledge comes from FC25 and FPL and they keep proving me right
I wonder how many accounts you really have
Haters gonna hate Haaland is already one of the greatest strikers of all time at 24 there is no debate 😂
Agreed, on his day...Haaland is the best striker I've seen in the Prem and I'm a liverpool fan!
Isak has always been quality from his debut game, we all seen it that he was going to be special, to other fans they were too busy hoping Newcastle fail instead of watching him, haaland has dropped off a bit isak hasn't and now everyone is seeing it , we've always seen and said it for months
Isak is generational aswell. He's doing things not 9s do. Infact no one is doing what he's doing. Isak could get 30 goals and 10 assist in a good season. Haaland would get 50 goals. Why we talking like isak can't score goals. Shots to goals ratio he's up there aswell... real finisher it's just haaland is alien, no one is where haaland is but let's not ignore someone that can get 25, 30 a season
Isak is a better footballer. Haaland is a better goal scorer. I say that as a Newcastle supporter.
How? haaland is a pro footballer so how
Haaland is so underappreciated by some people. If Aguero in his prime was Man City's main striker right now I don't think people would put Isak over him. And Haaland straight up dwarfs Aguero's numbers in the same team. If Isak can score 36 league goals for City then Aguero should have done it. The most Aguero got was 26. He averaged 18 Premier League goals a season at City. Haaland is just a lab created goal scoring machine. All the stuff people say he lacks he doesn't need. All the stuff he has is elite for scoring goals. That's why he gets so many.
Haaland will probably get over 30 again this season.
@@SonnyK248 Aguero in his best season did score 27 goals for City!
@@runefredriksen9336 Aguero's best was 26. 10 less that Haaland's best season. and we have no idea what Haaland's absolute best will be. He got 36 in his debut season. Even last season when Haaland was having a supposed off season he beat Aguero's best ever season with 27. Aguero is fifth all time in Premier League goals and the highest scoring non Englishman. One of the best we've ever seen. Isak will be lucky if he gets to his level. Saying he will match or better Haaland is a massive reach.
This doesn't say as much as you think it does. If you're only gonna talk about net goals, then the whole team and manager comes into the discussion.
@ net goals?
Isak over any PL striker at the moment
Which striker in the world is better than Isak?
@arshavindrameh32
The irony of this comment is Haaland would score even more goals at Newcastle than he would at City. Far too many Premier League fans don’t realize Haaland is the single most dangerous striker in open space and on the counterattack. The idea that he’s just a penalty box poacher is complete nonsense. City’s extreme possession system made it really easy to figure out who has actually watched Haaland only at City versus those who watched him at Dortmund and Salzburg as well.
@@HaalandFCTV Isak would score in any team he would start over haaland if he was at city fact.
Stop this myth. Newcastle don't need to sell. We just can't spend large amounts of money like people expected us to do.
Personally, I would prefer Isak. While Haaland is undoubtedly the better goal scorer, I believe Isak is the more complete footballer, which I value more. If Haaland doesn’t receive proper service, it can feel like playing with 10 men, which I think limits the team’s tactical flexibility.
@@sarahashun1180 Haaland hasn't had any help this season! And the style of play at City is no help for him either! He didn't have anything special with help in the Norwegian National Team, Salzburg, Dortmund but still scored goals and broke more records than anyone in football history! and in less time!
@@runefredriksen9336I agree with everything you’ve said. My first comment emphasised that he is the better goal scorer of the two. However, I prefer Isak because he’s an all round better footballer and gives a team much more flexibility.
And i forgot he had 17 assist in dortmund So that he is not more involved is how he gets told to play because he has been and is much more involved in all other clubs and national teams!
@@runefredriksen9336 Yes but not in the PL. There are many players who look like world beaters in the Bundesliga but never carry their form over to the PL. Until he post those numbers in the PL, I’m not convinced. Furthermore, Norway has a really good team. But surprisingly they don’t seem to qualify for anything.
@sarahashun1180 But he is a world beater Infact!
I think we should appreciate them both and stop arguing like children about who’s the best.
These clowns clearly don't watch Newcastle. Ever since they got 4th, every team bar Spurs, Liverpool and City comes to SJP with a low block. Newcastle also barely created anything for him at times last season due to their injury crisis and Isak still got 21 goals and created chances for himself out of nothing
Isak vs haaland is the perfect example of a forward vs striker. Lol it's hilarious to realize most people didn't know haaland needs service to function
this happens when you have no marks talking about football
Did you watch Haaland at Dortmund? And by the way all strikers need service to “ function”
Isak needs service every striker needs service Haaland is the best striker of his generation no one is even close
@@Downtown7637Isak doesn’t need service, he also creates goals
@@Downtown7637 You really are a special kind of stupid
Haaland clears Isak Haaland would have scored more goals for Newcastle than for City btw
No he wouldn’t, isak does a lot off the ball, Haaland doesn’t
@jordanb966 There is no one better off the ball than Haaland his positioning is second to none the problem is that Man City doesn’t play to his strengths Haaland would've scored 40+ goals in the prem alone if he was in Liverpool under slot
Hahahahahahahahahaha@@Downtown7637
Haaland has superstars feeding him.
The opposite. Haaland wouldn't score 10 a season with NU.
150m minimum
Haha that woman really said Isak deserves a move to a Top 4 team. Newcastle are just 1 point off top 4. What's she on about?
I mean they are almost top 4 because of Isak, she means a team team that's already top 4.
Like Nottingham Forest 🤣
Haaland is a flat track bully, and an immense finisher. Isak is imo a far more well rounded player and would make any team better, not sure haaland without all the service (he gets at man city) would do the same. Both quality players though
Some do say that Harland only scores all these goals because he plays for Man City. But he has an exceptional goal scoring record for his previous clubs and for Norway. His record indicates that this is a guy who could score goals anywhere, for any team.
@@georgesimmons9775 He's a great striker but have a look at who he scores against. For Norway, when they play the best like Spain, he doesn't score. He fills his boots against weak countries like Kazakhstan with hatricks which pads his international numbers and he does the same domestically. I don't believe he's scored in CL semi's and beyond nor many against quality opposition e.g. Inter, RM etc. Let's see if he scores against PSG next because Man City need something.
Isak gets nowhere near as many chances as haaland, Isak would bang goals for city. Look at conversion percentage etc
Isak gets more chances Haaland's conversion rate is better. Haaland is already one of the greatest strikers of all time at 24 Isak is not worthy to be in the same sentence with Haaland but here we are
@@Downtown7637the issue with haaland is he goes through patches he can score 5 in one game then none in the next 6
@@Jaxel1926because Haaland plays for fra udiola fra udiola holds everyone back literally and figuratively with his slow possession style just look at Cole Palmer after leaving. And look at Salah under real genius manager Haaland would've scored 60+ goals if he was in Liverpool under Slot or Real or Barca because unlike City and Pep those 3 Clubs i mentioned and their managers play to Haaland's strengths
@Jaxel1926 how many goals did Isak score in his first 8 games🤷♂️
As a Newcastle fan, Haaland is clearly the most prolific striker on the planet BUT that doesn't make him the best. He's not a big game striker.
Two seasons ago, blanked in CL semi's against RM and the final. Blanked in semi finals and finals of the cups.
Last season, blanked 2x against Arsenal (title matches) and 2x in CL against RM - he only scores against rubbish teams like RB Leipzig.
This season, again, didn't score against the 2 decent teams (Inter and Juve) in the CL and he may well blank again against PSG. 14/16 of his league goals are against teams in the bottom half of the table (many in the relegation zone).
He's a great striker but he's also a bully of weak teams and his goal come in spurts. He won't be an all time great until he starts scoring in big games and winning goals in knockout games against good opposition.
He's also more injury prone than Isak - 20 injuries in one fewer year than Isak's 13. Missed a few more games because of it too. Although both are usually available for 85% of a season which is good enough.
Compare that to Isak. Scored this year against all of the big 6 except Man City (because he didn't play), including a winning goal to knock out Chelsea of the Cup.
Scored against PSG away last season. In his Real Soceidad days scored against Athletico Madrid and Barcelona. He even scored against RM x2 with an assist in a Copa del Rey QF to knock them out! Haaland has never scored against RM! Isak's a big game player.
If you just need someone to put the ball in the back of the net, choose Haaland but most teams need a striker who does more. Haaland won't fit into most EPL teams while Isak would fit into most.
Isak wins you games by 1 to 2 goals, Haaland on his day can win you games by 3 to 4. But Haaland isn't as effective against the very best teams e.g. CL and top 4 in the league simply because he won't be given the space he can get against weaker opposition.
@phoenixfire6559
I appreciate your detailed analysis. But you have to look upstream at City to understand Haaland much more. Opponents have figured out that City have no wide threat when the likes of Grealish and Silva play out wide. Because Grealish and Silva have no pace, can’t beat defenders 1v1, never provide first time service, and always pass backwards and sideways. The end result is opponents funnel everything inside, let City have as much predictable possession as they want, and destroy them on the counter because City have no pace in transition.
Pep needs to stop playing Grealish and Silva out wide and actually let Doku and Savinho take on opposition defenders. Like we saw yesterday with Savinho beating his man and whipping in a quick cross to Haaland on his first goal. And on Haaland’s 2nd goal when he drove at the defense and slipped Haaland in behind. Pep needs to let Savinho and Doku be much more unpredictable out wide, take opponents on, and provide quicker service to Haaland. Instead of turning both of them into predictable sideways and backwards possession players like Silva and Grealish. Because City’s attack has become far too predictable and toothless with Silva and Grealish on the wings. And Haaland is constantly making runs off the ball that are going unrewarded because Silva and Grealish are afraid to lose possession instead of playing threatening balls in the final third to Haaland.
Finally, Haaland would be lights out with Liverpool, Newcastle, or Tottenham. His style of play fits in much more with all three of those teams then at City. Far too many people never saw Haaland at Dortmund and Salzburg. And they don’t realize Haaland is the most dangerous striker in the world in open space and on the counterattack. With all due respect, what a lot of people like you miss when talking about Haaland going "missing" against the likes of Madrid and Inter is you aren’t discussing the very obvious reality that sides like that, even as elite as they are, just bunker for 90 minutes against City on the edge of their own box. They don’t even try to play a back and forth match with City. And Haaland not only has next to no room in which to operate in those matches but his wingers have repeatedly failed to provide quick and decisive first time service when the ball is on to him. Instead, they’ve done their endless extreme possession nonsense that plays right into the hands of disciplined sides like Madrid and Inter who just shift side to side for 90 minutes. Instead of defending running back toward their own goal, which no defender likes doing. Again, I appreciate your analysis. But something I’ve noticed with far too many people critiquing Haaland is they only focus on him in their analysis.
Deluded
Excellent point and very well written. Isak is by far the better GOAL scorer when it really counts - against the best of the best. He is also the the best overall player. Better technique and superior vision. Did You know that he speaks five languages fluently as well.
Haaland misses a lot. Just check stats. Isak has far higher percentage based on chances
Isak would offer more to City than Halaand is doing. He's sensational.
Ars fans, Isak is going nowhere 😂. Don’t know when or why the media have pushed this agenda.
Isak is better this season. Just look at their xG vs actual goals
They will never take less than 150 million for isak why would they take 80-90 million what a stupid thing to say , then they should of took 30 for guehi 😂😂 are you that silly , arsenal can’t afford isak that’s a fact and Newcastle is only 4 point behind arsenal, another arsenal fan that thinks they can just click their fingers players want to come 😂🤣
Isak all day
Isak 100%
Isak has always been an incredible baller and prolific striker if you followed him since his Real Sociedad days.. He's growing exponentially..But the fact that you've quickly disregarded Haaland all of a sudden is hilarious.. Clearly depicting the fickle and Reactionary modern fans are
Test our resolve with £80m -£90m ??? If I was Newcastle’s CEO or Paul Mitchell getting that call I’d laugh and put the phone down
Like JK Simmons as J Jonah Jameson in Spider-man. Isak is not going anywhere for less than £150mill
like a 'wait, you're serious? *laughs even harder*'
Btw to suggest that Newcastle don’t play against low blocks is nuts
Isak is valued at 150m but he isn't for sale!!
Isak is a better player but not a chance he out scores Halaand ever! In any team.
Weird. This convo. Quite disrespectful to Isaks teammates. We play unbelievable football. He doesn’t need to be at big 6 team. We’re very close to be competing for trophy’s year on year.
For the record isak has actually won copa del rey trophy with real socidad 😅😅 he was actually the one that sended them to the final
Knocking out RM with 2 goals and an assist!
I don't remember Haaland helping City in the cups and he just fills his boots against weak opposition. 14/16 league goals this season against teams in bottom half of the table. He has never scored against RM afaik nor Inter for that matter. Where was he when City needed him against Man Utd in FA Cup final? Haaland goes missing in big games.
@phoenixfire6559 listen to the girl saying isak still hasn't won anything just Harry kane that's why I commented if u don't know anything about isak why do u mention stuff like that he been grinding he has over 5 major trophies
Isak would outscore Haaland easily if he played in City or Arsenal
Isak is better because how Eddie developed him. EH can even turned Murphy into a better player. You don’t need Isak, you just need a better coach
Wouldn't swap Isak for anyone.
Isak 💯% sure.
Final Whistle Panel , combined IQ of a Carrot
Newcastle fan who loves Isak, but he isn’t better than Haaland in front of goal. 1 on 1 he often bottles it. Amazing overall player though in terms of holdup, carrying the ball, bringing other players into play, and of course still scoring a bagful of goals.
He's miles and miles ahead of haaland in overall football play. Haaland needs one on one's or tap ins. The most overrated player to ever grace the premier League is haaland.
@@darraghsheehan9467 nunez is ahead of haaland in terms of all around play so it isn't much to go off
Newcastle fan for the last month only? He’s only been struggling 1 on 1 recently.😂
Whatever we value isak, if arsenal or any other Premiership club want him you need to double it 😂😂😂
In my opinion Isak is much better player than haaland.. isak was playing with longstaff and J. Willock which are championship players and Manchester City players can't not be compared to Newcastle and if isak get the same services as haaland he will score more
As a Swedish fan of Isak, and as a AIK-supporter, he’s first professional club, I think Isak has come a super long way. To be mentioned in the same breath as Haaland is big compliment, albeit deserved one. Personally I think Haaland’s goal scoring record speaks for itself. Whether or not there are things Isak can do that Haaland can’t (or is not allowed to in Pep’s system) is an interesting debate, but it doesn’t end with Isak over Haaland. They have different qualities and both are currently helping their clubs. Isn’t it interesting though how many top strikers and offensive players the Nordics is producing at the moment? Haaland, Isak, Gyökeres, Kulusevski, Ödegaard. Hopefully can add Elanga, Bergvall and Ayari (AIK fostered) to that list soon as well.
Isak with mancity 100000 goals
I agree Isak is better. Imagine he gets top players around him
Who is this clueless pundits thinks that Isaac is even close to Haaland
Isak is better footballer than H.
U right he is better than HalDump
I hope city end up with isak if we are to lose him. Anywhere but Arsenal
Haaland £51million, Isak £68Million , this panel now thinks spending £100million plus on either player is a good decision….as long as they stick to talking nonsense on a radio show every PL club is better off !!!
Isak is the better Footballer, Haaland is just a Goalscorer.
Newcastle created the most big chances in the league last year, no idea why you think playing for someone else would would yield so many more goals.
As a Newcastle fan I would take Haaland at a heartbeat! Haaland is a goal machine! Get a grip.
Finally somebody speaking sense
I'm a Newcastle fan and even i know Haaland is a better finisher than Isak the rest of him game isak is better.
Halaand is a 6 yard box striker who needs the ball put at his feet. Isak can assist, create and score goals from anywhere around the whole box. Isak is the more complete player for me
Sweden or Norway. When it comes to Alexander Isac, I am happy a good scorer can just be a nice man.
What an absolute horrible take. Haaland has scored some outrageous goals in the last 2 seasons that only haaland could score. And to say Issak is a better finisher than someone who broke the goal scoring record in his first season is ridiculous 😂
YES Isak any day 💯👌
Isak going no where
Like comparing Henry and Shearer …A lot of people would say Henry was the best striker despite Shearer outscoring him
Sitting and listening to people without knowledge of the facts is a waste! Isak has 14 goals for Sweden in 48 matches! Haaland has 39 goals for Norway in 38 matches! It is not possible to compare.
Haaland is a great striker, good at scoring goals when he's getting the service but he needs a team and system that plays around him.
Isak is a world class striker, he can go into almost any team and make a much bigger impact while still scoring goals.
"If you put Haaland in Newcastle he wont be as good as Isak there" tells the story enough.
Haaland would've scored more goals for Newcastle than for City, Haaland is already one of the greatest strikers of all time you cant even mention them in the same sentence one is a generational talent the other one is not
Isak at football manager says enough a few seasons back what a talent!
Big teams don't need a striker to create their goals. Liverpool and Madrid have players who can feed Haaland
Osaka is all round player than Haaland. Isak makes goals by himself unlike Haaland.
Isak won’t go to any other team unless Newcastle start to consider a £150m offer or more for him, btw Isak is also happy at Newcastle right now.
Get Keir Starmer out of 10 Downing Street right now
Get you off the internet would be better.
Time you disappeared bot you are becoming so boring now
Haaland is better finisher but Isak has more attributes to his game.
mans a liverpool fan fr talking about isaks better than halaad
Idk in his dreams isn't even close to haaland.
I'm a geordie and love isak for isak to be considered the best ST out the two he needs to start converting one on one chances better and could do with working on his team mates awareness more. He gets that right you could argue hes in haalands level till the im sorry harrland is the best in the world and will go down as one of the best ever
Both are quality and both deserve there flower's 👏 👌
Haaland is a beast bro coz he can score a goal in any style depends on how the ball comes so please don compare him with Isak at all
He deserves to go to a top 4 side don’t write the toon off yet
y would isak go arsenal??
Those fans and pundits shouting for Isak ? How many trophy he.has.won in Laliga or Epl ? Give us a break.
Aguero was 10x the player Isak is or ever will be, even he didn't get Haalands numbers
Haaland is going into th books as one of the greatest (Ronaldo, Henry, Romario, Messi, CR7) etc that's generational. Isak is definitely levels lower
Isak's 1 on 1's are probably his weakness.
This guy hasn't watched him play much. Or he'd know that.
Good job I scrolled through, I was about to mention that. They clearly don't watch us in depth.
On Isak, he needs to stop attempting those dinks, when through on goal.
For me Isak is best 💯
What a ridiculous opinion 😂😂😂
Haaland is better than Isaak....facts and goodnight.
There are many excellent strikers in the world than isak and haaland. We are preoccupied with looking within small circles in EU.
That's why teams are fooled, conned to buy players at extremely insane prices.
The toddler in the black jacket needs to relax.
Haaland is taking golden boot back to back what about Isak??so you'll know the difference between him en Isak
This is the top 6 media bias again... everyone talks pike everyone outside the top 6 is not relevant or not worth mentioning. KDB giving isak the ball... all day long he would bang for fun aswell. Haaland plays like a Shearer during the end of his career
Whats this 120 bs our price is 150 to start conversations
Isaaaaaaaaak Great player
Ppl needs to wake up, im a nufc fan i love isak but haaland is a monster. ya moan about haaland scoring for city etc. but look at how many goals he has for norway and they are shite...
Against Slovakia and other great nations
@@lakabaka How did england do against slovakia? haaland has a goal per match in all comps he play no other strikers has that
Did he say 80/90 million 😂😂😂😂😂
Love the prem! Best league in the world! Makes players go from balondor to out the door in 1 season
Move to a top 4 club like who? 😂
Who is this Isaac person bro keeps talking about?
That Kwayku is a 🔔end
Insufferable Southern nonsense.
Isak was awful today
Isak far supirior striker/Footballer thn Haaland all day long..
Haaland the tap in specialist or isak who can score from anywhere yeah ok . I’m with the host put and out isak is better
Isak is a purple patch striker. Apart from the freakish goal the Spuds non-defense kept him quiet for most of the game.
Clown
Its actually the opposite, Isak scores consistently. He rarely gets more than a goal a game, so to get 20+ a season means he's scored against 20+ opponents. Haaland on the other hand can score 3+ against one team so if you look this season, Haaland scored 10 of his 16 goals in just FIVE games. He's scored 14/16 goals against bottom half teams.
@@phoenixfire6559 his current purple patch would be over soon ...let me know if I am wrong.I can see he has already started to flag.
200m at this rate
Isak looks too physical weak, the favour of the month.
Haaland is boring straight up boring tap in man . Show me some screamers from Haaland lol😅
It's pronounced Eezak FFS 🙄
City back to winning ways so must have a pop again?
Who are these 🔔's
Loooooo fuckin’L!