Disney's 1950 is my favorite, great choice for you to have it at number 1, Ever After is a close second, another Cinderella story and once upon a song are great as well, Ella enchanted is also a very entertaining movie, a bit of sarcastic on the fairy tale 😅😊
My favorite one is the 2015 version with Lily James and Robb Stark. Those two had great chemistry and I feel that movie is a modern day reminder of what the original taught us. Despite being abused, Cinderella was still able to "Be kind and have courage." With this movie I also felt that the Prince truly loved her as a good person instead of a pretty girl.
My list: 1. Ever After 2. Disney 1950 3. A Cinderella Story 4. Rodger and Hammerstein Cinderells 5. Ella Enchanted 6. Disney remake 7. A Cinderella story: Once upon a song 8. The prince and me 9. Cinderella 3: a twist in time 10. Into the woods
I think my top 4 are the original 1950 movie, "A Cinderella Story" with Hillary Duff, "Ever After" and Rodgers and Hammerstein's version with Brandy and Whitney Houston.
Step mother : The twins are turning 16 next week Cinderella: Didn't they turn 16 last year Step mother: Yes and they'll keep on turning 16 till I tell them to stop 👏👏👏👏
@@karenkavon6957 How right you are. A favourite book of mine. But the movie was nothing like the book in my opinion. It was so over the top, so loud, so childish, so unfunny, so wanna-be-modern-to-make-it-more-attractive-to-teenagers. I couldn't watch it to the end and I think it hasn't got anything to do with the book whatsoever.
My top 5 are 1. Rodgers and Hammerstein's Cinderella 2. A Cinderella Story 3. Ever After 4. Ella Enchanted 5. Cinderella (2015) Honorable Mentions: Disney's Cinderella and Julie Andrews' Cinderella
Ella Enchanted is not a Cinderella story. It a story a girl named "Ella" who is crused to obey every command she is given so she goes on a journey to break the idea than a perfect girl is one who is the inbody of other ideas but rather one who could think for herself.
My absolute favorite one is “The Three Nuts for Cinderella”. It was made in Czechoslovakia and East Germany in 1973 and OH MY IT’S EVERYTHING. Cinderella is an awesome badass who saves the servants from her stepmother’s wrath and than all but showers her stepmother and stepsister with ash when they’re being bitches to her. And she meets the Prince long before the ball and she kicks his ass SO MANY TIMES!!! If you’re able to find it go watch it! It’s a traditional Christmas TV-fairytale in some European countries as I know and I ALWAYS re-watch it around New Years bcs MOOD
The 1997 version, while prettier, is NOT the best version. The absolute best, which didn't even make HM (crime!), is the 1965 live-TV version, starring Leslie Ann Warren as an almost swan-like Cindi, Stuart Damon as the prince, and Celeste Holm as the Fairy Godmother. It is, was, and probably ever will be, my favorite version. It should have replaced any of the "A Cinderella Story" entries, at least.
@@WrenFaithBridger That was my first exposure to the Roger's and Hammerstein version! I love that one too. FYI, did you know that the actress who did Prunella was the same person who voiced Ursula in the Little Mermaid?
@@Zodia195 You bet! You should have seen my daughters' faces when I told them! (I have very early memories of being maybe 2 or 3 and singing ALL of the songs with my older sister, who was 10 or 11, before going to sleep. Oh, and my younger daughter was in a production of it just last year.)
I can't believe that Cinderella: once upon a song is above Another cinderella story. But my favorit is the Lily James version followed closely by the 1950 version and then A cinderella story
1. Cinderella (1950) 2. Ever After (1998) 3. A Cinderella Story (2004) 4. The Slipper and the Rose (1976) 5. Rodgers & Hammerstein’s Cinderella (1997) 6. The Glass Slipper (1955) 7. Ella Enchanted (2004) 8. Cinderella (1957) 9. Cinderella III: A Twist In Time (2007) 10. Cindy (1978)
The Slipper and the Rose wasn't a good movie. The glass Slipper was much better. I have watch all the different typex of Cinderella movies. Cindy was ok. But Cinderfelow was funny but not the too ten. Rags was ok too. But the top ten
@@asherikamichaela8425 Same here! I was kind of appalled that the live action Cinderella from 2015 ranked about it. It's like did you watch both of them? Are you getting paid by Disney to make those two number 1 and 2? Ever After is the best one hands down!
@@mffmoniz2948 Not to mention... she saves her friend/substitute father figure, inspires Henry to open an inclusive univesity, floors that wench Marguerite, makes friends with Jacqueline AND holds that creep Le Pieu at swordpoint to gain her freedom! _Absolute_ badass!
Yeah maybe at 10 or 9 removing Once Upon a Song (it sucked) and putting Rogers and Hammerstein's version higher then 10. Never actually saw Rags but the idea is good.
Such a major cop-out to give the two Disney movies top spots. Ever After is way, way better and deserved the #1 spot. And another great Cinderella movie that beats several of the crap ones on the list is Three Wishes for Cinderella (but I understand why it hasn't been included since I suspect Watchmojo hasn't even heard of this Czech/East-German production - while it's shown at Christmas every year where I live)
Oh my gosh thank you!! They’re both decent movies but in Once Upon a Song the main couple completely lacked any real substance. Not to mention, there were so many innuendos that I can’t tell what age group the producers were targeting. It was an absolute mess
While I personally think Ever After is the absolute best, I can agree that the animated Disney movie was very important. However the remake does not deserve number 2. Number 10 at best.
@@ddthewolf True. I love the live action Disney remake too; but it's not as good as Ever After. Ever After did a better job of fleshing out the characters.
I do like Ever after. Bit I love the live action Cinderella. Drew Barrymore did great job. I guess she last of Barrymore Dynasty. She comes a long line a terrific actor's and actresses. She had overcome alot. She did great job. It was the spoiled sister that kinda set me back Anjelica Huston did a great evil stepmom
Ever After is my all time fave version. Historical with a splash of fantasy, the girl isn't actually named Cinderella but has a real name, she rescues herself in the end before the prince even shows, and I just love how grimey and realistic everything looks. I could go on about the costume design as well but this post would extend by paragraphs.
Her rescuing herself kinda ruins the point of the prince, tbh. But the movie thankfully has him on his way to save her and just happens to lose the race, so he is still the sort of man who would save her. I would have preferred her to escape 90% of the way but encounter a smart henchman (smart villain underlings are always a refreshing sight) and need the prince to cross the final obstacle.
@@michaelmccabe3079 no it doesn't. Having a friend and love interest isn't only for the sake of being rescued. She is strong without him but she loves him. Codependency is not romantic.
@@BoxOKittens Perhaps in another story, but in the Cinderella story she needs the prince to save her. The Cinderella story is not about a woman freeing herself, it is about someone who can't escape being saved for no other reason than love. In many ways, it's a reflection of the story of Christ- humanity can't save itself, but Christ came down from heaven to save us. It would be equally as problematic if the Prince had to save her for any other reason besides love (say, money or political advantage). There were plenty of other old stories (particularly among the Irish) of women who were more assertive and could pull themselves out of trouble, but Cinderella's story is not one of them.
@@michaelmccabe3079 If you think that Cinderella's story MUST include her being saved by a prince, then you must not enjoy many of the different versions of the story where that doesn't happen. Saying something like "Cinderella has to be about a prince saving her" is kind of restrictive, because there have been many different version throughout decades. But I digress, we'll have to agree to disagree on this one, it seems.
@@BoxOKittens Most versions involve her being saved, and the clever ones come up with creative ways to do so. Otherwise, the character could have simply left and walked up to the palace/prince by herself and he wouldn't have needed to seek her out.
The ones you've only placed at 7, 8, 9 and 10 should have been the top. i love those films. i do love the original and the fecent remake though so i agree they should be high on the list. Also Ella Enchanted is the best filmever.
This list is INVALID for having Brandy’s Cinderella as #10! You have Whitney Houston, Bernadette Peters, Whoopi Goldberg, Victor Garber, Jason Alexander, and a damn beautiful Filipino prince Paolo Montalban.
The live action Cinderella rocks! It's so underappreciated. I literally get my lifes motto from it "Have courage and be kind" I'll say it, I love it more than the original.
I can't believe the Brandy version was #10! I wasn't crazy about "Into the Woods." There were several on the list that I haven't seen cuz they're older, so I can't judge them, but some of the versions that just made the Honorable Mention list got totally jipped in my opinion.
I loved 'Cinderfella' as a child but Ever After is my eternal favourite version 😊 I think I've seen nearly all the versions, including obscure TV versions and foreign/European versions.
My top 3: 1) Three Wishes for Cinderella (1973) This Czech fairy tale is the greatest adaptation of the story ever. And by far. The beautiful setting, music, costumes, witty dialogues and charming playfulness of Cinderella and her prince only add to the fairy tale magic. 2) Ever After The costumes and setting are breathtakingly beautiful. The story is amazingly well written and works wonders with the historical references. 3) Cinderella (2015) This Disney live adaptation elevated the popular Disney animated version significantly by evolving the story and giving the characters actual personalities.
"Roger's and Hammerstein's Cinderella 1997" and "Ever After" are number 2 and 1 in my book! Fabulous costumes and casts alike and the "ever after" story are superb! Also Bernadette Peters and Angelica Houston as the respective stepmothers are extremely tough acts to follow!
@@nerdyblackkid9878 my point exacrly. The trash music in the Cinderella stories and the trash acting. I'm so confused. Brandy's Cinderella deserves betrer than this!!!!
"The Prince and Me" and "Rags" are 2 movies I can watch over and over without getting tired of. I also love all 3 of the "Another Cinderella Story" movies.
@@carlottarobbins7005 it sucks compared to there other musicals. I know the wrote for younger audiences but I grew up watching Oklahoma l. South Pacific, and Courasel. I do believe Brandy did a better job then the OG. Brandy was the only good on in the movie. Sorry Disney Cinderella 1950. Basically saved the company. The animation was incredible. I love the live action.
That might be the sentimental part of me, but I shall forever honour "Drei Nüsse für Aschenbrödel". It has a lot of snow, ridicoulus outfits, amazing animal friends, and just about every christmas of my life that I can remember going for it.
While you can’t compete with both the OG and live action Disney adaptations, I love Ever After and The Slipper and the Rose. If they decide to remake R&H’s Cinderella with the recent Broadway tweaks, it would work too.
My Top 5: 1. Disney's Animated Cinderella (It has a weaker script than Ever After, and weaker characters, but it is inarguably ICONIC, beautifully animated, Academy-recognized, and has withstood the test of time better than any of the other adaptations.) 2. Ever After (Hands-down the best adaptation in terms of story, characters, themes, and romance. If it had garnered the same critical acclaim as the original Disney version, I'd put it as #1. As it is though, it's my favorite, but I can't say it's objectively the "greatest.") 3. R & H's Julie Andrews version (It's aged surprisingly well, and some of the silliness of the Brandy version is toned down to make the shift from comedy to romance less jarring. It's very heartfelt and Andrews makes for a very charming Cinderella ♥) 4. R & H's Brandy version (It's VERY silly, but the aesthetic, music, and cast help make up for it. The two leads have chemistry, but you can tell the script is difficult for them to play straight without sounding cringey. It does some things fantastically well, but I feel like the original came together as a story more seamlessly.) 5. Cinderella 2015 (It *looks* beautiful, but comes across as... sorta meh? The characters are okay, but other versions do them better; the script is okay, but the story has been told better. I can't help but feel it's a weaker Ever After, with less charm than the R & H's movies.) I was gonna do the whole list, but honestly, are the others even worth comparing to these? The Slipper and the Rose might be an exception, but I've never seen it so I don't feel qualified to rank it...
I AM SO HAPPY. All of my favourite Cinderella films made it onto the list. 1. Another Cinderella Story 2. A Cinderella Story: Once Upon a Song 3. A Cinderella Story 4. Rags 5. Disney’s Cinderella 6. Cinderella (2015) 7. Cinderella (1997)
Ever After is my all time favorite version of Cinderella. Its the most realistic and doesn't have Cinderella as a singing goddess damsel in distress. Although unusual for the time, Danielle has a spirit that I have other Cinderella adaptions fail to capture.
And all you people don't know the treasure that is ''3 Haselnüsse für Aschenbrödel'' (3 hazelnuts for Cinderella), a german/czech production from 1973. It is one of the best Cinderella-Films and in Germany we watch it every year around christmas.
I came here for this :'D The best cinderella-version hands down, beautiful cinematography, wonderful music and great acting! Also one of the rare versions where both cinderella and the prince seem like actual people with distinct personalities
The 1965 'Rogers & Hammerstein's Cinderella' starring Lesley Ann Warren deserved to be in the top 10 much more than the original 'A Cinderella Story'. It didn't even get mentioned.
you are absolutely right, I was trying to look it up (couldn't remember the actresses' name) and it doesn't even come up in the search engines. Thanks for mentioning it because I was sharing my experience of watching this with my grandchild
You completely overlooked the best ‚Cinderella‘ adaptation of all times - if not the best fairytail movie ever made as far as original „non-Hollywood-style“ is concerned- 1972 czech film „Three nuts for Cinderella“❤️
@@yinloveyang I'm from Switzerland and here it's a very popular Christmas film. It's shown on tv every year. And I watch it every year. It's such a beautiful film. :)
For me, the best Cinderella story is Lily James' film. I think she gives the character a new light and a lot of wonderfull things. Lily James is just the best of all. And for me the second one is a film that isn't on the list. Is an italian version made on 2011 based on the 50'. A very beautiful history that for me is just behind Cinderella (2015), thanks to Lily James.
I’m glad to see you included the Slipper and The Rose, and Ever After has good placement, but why on earth is the Rogers and Hammerstein version at #10? It should be #2 or #1. Come on!
My Favorite Cinderella Movies; Cinderella (1950) Ever After: A Cinderella Story Ella Enchanted Cinderella (2015) A Cinderella Story Rodger & Hammerstein’s Cinderella(1997)
![Summer Walker - Heart Of A Woman [Official Lyric Video]](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/SFddctbZzw8/mqdefault.jpg)
![Yeat & Summrs - GO2WORK [Official Music Video]](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/NEFEwfPcXRA/mqdefault.jpg)
What's your favorite Cinderella movie? Let us know below!
All!!!
Cindrella 2015 The best!
My personal faves are Rags and Cinderfella! (Just me? Okay-)
A Cinderella Story
Disney's 1950 is my favorite, great choice for you to have it at number 1, Ever After is a close second, another Cinderella story and once upon a song are great as well, Ella enchanted is also a very entertaining movie, a bit of sarcastic on the fairy tale 😅😊
a Cinderella story, I still ship Chad and Hilary
I see people saying they "ship" people.. what does that mean?
@@HjCrawford It means that you want them to be a couple
@@fernandac6494 thank you!
What's the ship part about? How did that word become that meaning?
@@HjCrawford Relation"ship" ;)
@@christiella8233 ah that makes sense, thank you!!
My favorite one is the 2015 version with Lily James and Robb Stark. Those two had great chemistry and I feel that movie is a modern day reminder of what the original taught us. Despite being abused, Cinderella was still able to "Be kind and have courage." With this movie I also felt that the Prince truly loved her as a good person instead of a pretty girl.
Prince Charming in the 2015 adaptation of Cinderella was played by Richard Madden.
@@thelmaterai7431 Late reply but Richard Madden also played Robb Stark in Game of Thrones. That’s why OP called him that.
cinderella story with hillary duff will always be the best up against the selena gomez and lucy hale ones.
invisiblesoup hilary duff is my favorite Disney princess
Good taste I see
Same
Chad Michael murray
Yesss
My list:
1. Ever After
2. Disney 1950
3. A Cinderella Story
4. Rodger and Hammerstein Cinderells
5. Ella Enchanted
6. Disney remake
7. A Cinderella story: Once upon a song
8. The prince and me
9. Cinderella 3: a twist in time
10. Into the woods
Agreed!
Yesss Ever After deserves to be number one! It’s such a great movie and it’s so underrated!
Ever After ever after!
Ever After will always be my favorite version of Cinderella.
Mine too!
THANK YOU!!!!
I think my top 4 are the original 1950 movie, "A Cinderella Story" with Hillary Duff, "Ever After" and Rodgers and Hammerstein's version with Brandy and Whitney Houston.
Same!
Mine too.
Step mother : The twins are turning 16 next week
Cinderella: Didn't they turn 16 last year
Step mother: Yes and they'll keep on turning 16 till I tell them to stop
👏👏👏👏
1) original disney
2) a cinderella story (hilary duff)
3) ella enchanted
disney's is not THE original
Pretty sure they meant the original Disney (animated) to clarify that it was not the 2015 live action version
Ella Enchanted was a lot of fun, but read the book by Gail Carson Levine- it's even better.
@@karenkavon6957 How right you are. A favourite book of mine. But the movie was nothing like the book in my opinion. It was so over the top, so loud, so childish, so unfunny, so wanna-be-modern-to-make-it-more-attractive-to-teenagers. I couldn't watch it to the end and I think it hasn't got anything to do with the book whatsoever.
My favourite is the Hillary duff and Chad Michael Murray version. It will forever be one of my favourite movies of all time
Yes!!!! Best version!!!
Hey now, hey now! This is what dreams are made of!
Chad and Hilary!!!! My favourite 😍
@@siyasarkar5285 its too nice to me
My top 5 are
1. Rodgers and Hammerstein's Cinderella
2. A Cinderella Story
3. Ever After
4. Ella Enchanted
5. Cinderella (2015)
Honorable Mentions: Disney's Cinderella and Julie Andrews' Cinderella
Julie andrews' cinderella is the original rodgers and hammerstein cinderella. It was written with her in mind
Samantha Ramirez Woah Woah Woah,
DISNEY’S 1950 animate Cinderella is only an honorable mention???
I like your top five but mine are in a different order
Ella Enchanted is not a Cinderella story. It a story a girl named "Ella" who is crused to obey every command she is given so she goes on a journey to break the idea than a perfect girl is one who is the inbody of other ideas but rather one who could think for herself.
You’re right and you should say it
#1 Ever After
#2 Roger and Hammerstein ('97)
#3 A Cinderella Story
The rest are pretty accurate after that
Roger's and Hammerstein's Cinderella (1997) deserve's to be at least at in the Top 5
Word, I'm so mad wtf.
Yes!! Both versions.
Agreed!!!
It was. The Julie Andrews version was #4
Honestly the Brandy version was my least favorite of the Rogers and Hammerstein Cinderellas.
Ever After is just a masterpiece. Always number one for me🥰
Ever after with Drew Barrymore will always be my favourite such an amazing movie.
Love that movie the ending is the best part
@@apriltownsend9026 I agree just found her to be such a strong role model when I was younger and I have so much more respect for it as I get older.
@@carlene.simpson1997 me too when I get marry I want look and feel like Cinderella and stay at the castle
@@apriltownsend9026 sounds lovely:)
@@carlene.simpson1997 Ikr
My absolute favorite one is “The Three Nuts for Cinderella”. It was made in Czechoslovakia and East Germany in 1973 and OH MY IT’S EVERYTHING. Cinderella is an awesome badass who saves the servants from her stepmother’s wrath and than all but showers her stepmother and stepsister with ash when they’re being bitches to her. And she meets the Prince long before the ball and she kicks his ass SO MANY TIMES!!! If you’re able to find it go watch it! It’s a traditional Christmas TV-fairytale in some European countries as I know and I ALWAYS re-watch it around New Years bcs MOOD
Rodgers and Hammerstein's version is grossly underrated.
Its the best
@@makangajulius98 It's definitely my fav movie adaptation, but I didn't know about the Julie Andrews version. It's also one of my fav musicals too.
The 1997 version, while prettier, is NOT the best version. The absolute best, which didn't even make HM (crime!), is the 1965 live-TV version, starring Leslie Ann Warren as an almost swan-like Cindi, Stuart Damon as the prince, and Celeste Holm as the Fairy Godmother. It is, was, and probably ever will be, my favorite version. It should have replaced any of the "A Cinderella Story" entries, at least.
@@WrenFaithBridger That was my first exposure to the Roger's and Hammerstein version! I love that one too. FYI, did you know that the actress who did Prunella was the same person who voiced Ursula in the Little Mermaid?
@@Zodia195 You bet! You should have seen my daughters' faces when I told them! (I have very early memories of being maybe 2 or 3 and singing ALL of the songs with my older sister, who was 10 or 11, before going to sleep. Oh, and my younger daughter was in a production of it just last year.)
“#10. Rodgers & Hammerstein’s Cinderella (1997)”
Me: *closes video and questions every single MsMojo video I’ve ever watched.*
Me too
Truth. It should at LEAST be top 5
Honestly same smh
They literally put those knock off Hilary Duff movies ahead of that. How?
Ikr.
I can't believe that Cinderella: once upon a song is above Another cinderella story. But my favorit is the Lily James version followed closely by the 1950 version and then A cinderella story
Another Cinderella Story didn't really have villains as compelling as Once Upon A Song. They just seemed more stupid than anything
Lara Duff Yeah but the main couple in Once Upon A Song lacked any real substance. MsFriendsfan4ever completely read my mind though
They a both good, they both should have been higher
Ever After will always be my favorite. Thanks for calling her "badass" - because she was.
And the only version with only one evil stepsister-I loved that Jacqueline was kind to Danielle and help in their plot to bust her own mother
My fave scene is when the bandits allow to only take what she can carry. And she goes... hold my beer, come here prince!
I feel like Cinderella: If the Shoe Fits should have been on that list
it's better than both versions selena's and lucy hale's but well i guess sofia carson is not famous enough
Right!
@@marialuisamoraes5694 no, it's definitely not better and Sofia is kinda famous
No. It's way worse than Lucy Hale's and Selena's. I really didn't like that movie compared to the others
Ikr
1. Cinderella (1950)
2. Ever After (1998)
3. A Cinderella Story (2004)
4. The Slipper and the Rose (1976)
5. Rodgers & Hammerstein’s Cinderella (1997)
6. The Glass Slipper (1955)
7. Ella Enchanted (2004)
8. Cinderella (1957)
9. Cinderella III: A Twist In Time (2007)
10. Cindy (1978)
The Slipper and the Rose wasn't a good movie. The glass Slipper was much better. I have watch all the different typex of Cinderella movies. Cindy was ok. But Cinderfelow was funny but not the too ten. Rags was ok too. But the top ten
I wouldn't really consider Cinderella III a Cinderella movie
1. After after
2. Cinderella with brandy
3. Another cinderella story
4. Into the woods
5. Cinderella story with Hillary duff
Ever after, hands down, best Cinderella story ever. Danielle was so badass. My favorite scene is when she decks her evil stepsister. Love it.
Mine too and I personally think it is one of the films made.
YAS!
OMG that scene was AWESOME
Sorry, I have to argue that Ever After is number one.
Same! Much more depth.
@@asherikamichaela8425 Same here! I was kind of appalled that the live action Cinderella from 2015 ranked about it. It's like did you watch both of them? Are you getting paid by Disney to make those two number 1 and 2? Ever After is the best one hands down!
@@Cmoore-Books Definitely. Ever After is at least plausible, and far better in characterization.
Ever After is definitely my favorite one, but Ella Enchanted also lives in my heart
Ella enchanted 😍😍
Ever After should have been #1.
She carries the prince! Number one!
@@mffmoniz2948 Not to mention... she saves her friend/substitute father figure, inspires Henry to open an inclusive univesity, floors that wench Marguerite, makes friends with Jacqueline AND holds that creep Le Pieu at swordpoint to gain her freedom! _Absolute_ badass!
Brandy and Whitney's Cinderella is the best Cinderella ever. PERIOD.
My favorite part of that movie is the diversity of the cast.
@@RosieHip24 THANK YOU!! That's what I was saying. The Cinderella stories were trash compared to Brandy and Whitney's Cinderella
It deserves better than 10th
Yes!!!
I was shocked that it was 10th.
Omg the slipper and the rose! What a movie! That and ever after are definitely my fav adaptations!! So glad it got a mention!
There's another version of Cinderella I think it's quite good: A Cinderella Story If The Shoes Fits
You've never seen "Three gifts for Cinderella" (1973). The movie with Libuše Šafránková? That's some Cinderella magic.
rags definitely should’ve made it on the actual list. i mean cmon, it’s a boy version of cinderella!
D'Aujah Marie I love rags
Yeah, it's not only girls who need saving from their terrible lives!
Yeah maybe at 10 or 9 removing Once Upon a Song (it sucked) and putting Rogers and Hammerstein's version higher then 10. Never actually saw Rags but the idea is good.
Paige Bradley oh yea no you need to watch rags then, it’s really good!
Yes. Rags is my fav!
The original 1950 animated version and the 2015 live-action remake of Disney's Cinderella will always be my most favorite versions of Cinderella
Such a major cop-out to give the two Disney movies top spots. Ever After is way, way better and deserved the #1 spot. And another great Cinderella movie that beats several of the crap ones on the list is Three Wishes for Cinderella (but I understand why it hasn't been included since I suspect Watchmojo hasn't even heard of this Czech/East-German production - while it's shown at Christmas every year where I live)
Ever After is the best version, although the others are fabulous, too.
ms mojo, since when is Lucy Hale’s Cinderella story better than Selena’s🤔
Yes thank you I am not liking this list.
I agree.
I agree. Once Upon a Song sucked in comparison to the rest
Never that's why. This list is wrong.
Oh my gosh thank you!! They’re both decent movies but in Once Upon a Song the main couple completely lacked any real substance. Not to mention, there were so many innuendos that I can’t tell what age group the producers were targeting. It was an absolute mess
The cartoon Cinderella will always be number one forever it's the first one I've ever watched and I didn't know it was made in 1950
Walt Disney made" Cinderella 1950" and i really like it. 🧚♀️🧚♀️🧚♀️🤘🤘🤘✌️✌️✌️👌👌👌👏👏👏👍👍👍🧜♀️🧜♀️🧜♀️.
While I personally think Ever After is the absolute best, I can agree that the animated Disney movie was very important. However the remake does not deserve number 2. Number 10 at best.
Yeah they should have placed one of the Roger and Hammerstein versions at #2 or 3 or move Ever After up to #2 at least.
Rags was amazing and is one of the most underrated nick movies I have watched it so many times I even put up with fake Jedward
Man, you did Ella Enchanted dirty.
Cinderella from 1965 with Stuart Damon and Lesley Ann Warren should be on this list!! It is wonderful.
Even though the top 3 are the best, Ever After should’ve been #1.
Ever After will always be my favorite!!!!❤️😄
Ever after 2nd Roger and hamerstiens deserves 3rd not gosh damn 10th place ! It's the most musical Cinderella movie of them all !
The Rose and the Slipper is fantastic and I definitely recommend it to those that haven't seen it. Ever After is probably my personal top favorite.
I knew that 1950 Disney Animated Film would be on #1!
I don't have a specific order, but my faves are: Cinderella (1950), Ever After, Ella Enchanted, and A Cinderella Story
Just gonna throw it out there that Ever After shoulda been #2 🤷🏼♀️
I personally think it deserves number one
Kiersten Slater yes!!!
Thank you! Why is there so much hype for the live action remake?
@@ddthewolf True. I love the live action Disney remake too; but it's not as good as Ever After. Ever After did a better job of fleshing out the characters.
I do like Ever after. Bit I love the live action Cinderella. Drew Barrymore did great job.
I guess she last of Barrymore Dynasty. She comes a long line a terrific actor's and actresses. She had overcome alot. She did great job. It was the spoiled sister that kinda set me back
Anjelica Huston did a great evil stepmom
Ever After is my all time fave version. Historical with a splash of fantasy, the girl isn't actually named Cinderella but has a real name, she rescues herself in the end before the prince even shows, and I just love how grimey and realistic everything looks. I could go on about the costume design as well but this post would extend by paragraphs.
Her rescuing herself kinda ruins the point of the prince, tbh. But the movie thankfully has him on his way to save her and just happens to lose the race, so he is still the sort of man who would save her. I would have preferred her to escape 90% of the way but encounter a smart henchman (smart villain underlings are always a refreshing sight) and need the prince to cross the final obstacle.
@@michaelmccabe3079 no it doesn't. Having a friend and love interest isn't only for the sake of being rescued. She is strong without him but she loves him. Codependency is not romantic.
@@BoxOKittens Perhaps in another story, but in the Cinderella story she needs the prince to save her. The Cinderella story is not about a woman freeing herself, it is about someone who can't escape being saved for no other reason than love. In many ways, it's a reflection of the story of Christ- humanity can't save itself, but Christ came down from heaven to save us. It would be equally as problematic if the Prince had to save her for any other reason besides love (say, money or political advantage).
There were plenty of other old stories (particularly among the Irish) of women who were more assertive and could pull themselves out of trouble, but Cinderella's story is not one of them.
@@michaelmccabe3079 If you think that Cinderella's story MUST include her being saved by a prince, then you must not enjoy many of the different versions of the story where that doesn't happen. Saying something like "Cinderella has to be about a prince saving her" is kind of restrictive, because there have been many different version throughout decades. But I digress, we'll have to agree to disagree on this one, it seems.
@@BoxOKittens Most versions involve her being saved, and the clever ones come up with creative ways to do so. Otherwise, the character could have simply left and walked up to the palace/prince by herself and he wouldn't have needed to seek her out.
The ones you've only placed at 7, 8, 9 and 10 should have been the top. i love those films. i do love the original and the fecent remake though so i agree they should be high on the list. Also Ella Enchanted is the best filmever.
This list is INVALID for having Brandy’s Cinderella as #10!
You have Whitney Houston, Bernadette Peters, Whoopi Goldberg, Victor Garber, Jason Alexander, and a damn beautiful Filipino prince Paolo Montalban.
Elizabeth Gonzalez 👏🏾👏🏾👏🏾
Just tells what they know! #10...pssshh! 😒
Preach sis ! 👏🏽
Damn right! And putting that insipid animated thing in first? Bleh!
1. CINDERELLA 1950
2. HILLARY DUFF CINDERELLA
3. BRANDY CINDERELLA
PERIIIIIIODT!
Watch Slipper and the Rose, you might be surprised.
The live action Cinderella rocks! It's so underappreciated. I literally get my lifes motto from it "Have courage and be kind"
I'll say it, I love it more than the original.
Same I preferred it over the original too
"My favourite moto too".
I also prefer the Live Action Cinderella to the Animation.
Same it's also my motto!!
Whitney Houston
Rip🙏💔
I can't believe the Brandy version was #10! I wasn't crazy about "Into the Woods." There were several on the list that I haven't seen cuz they're older, so I can't judge them, but some of the versions that just made the Honorable Mention list got totally jipped in my opinion.
I loved 'Cinderfella' as a child but Ever After is my eternal favourite version 😊 I think I've seen nearly all the versions, including obscure TV versions and foreign/European versions.
My top 3:
1) Three Wishes for Cinderella (1973)
This Czech fairy tale is the greatest adaptation of the story ever. And by far. The beautiful setting, music, costumes, witty dialogues and charming playfulness of Cinderella and her prince only add to the fairy tale magic.
2) Ever After
The costumes and setting are breathtakingly beautiful. The story is amazingly well written and works wonders with the historical references.
3) Cinderella (2015)
This Disney live adaptation elevated the popular Disney animated version significantly by evolving the story and giving the characters actual personalities.
Tree nuts for Cinderella! 🇨🇿🇩🇪
"Roger's and Hammerstein's Cinderella 1997" and "Ever After" are number 2 and 1 in my book! Fabulous costumes and casts alike and the "ever after" story are superb! Also Bernadette Peters and Angelica Houston as the respective stepmothers are extremely tough acts to follow!
Bro how the hell did those abc family remakes get ahead of brandys cinderella story
Right?! Literally everything ranked higher, which is practically a crime. 😕
I think Ever After should've switched rolls with Cinderella (2015)
I think my mom would agree with you - she likes "Ever After"
Agreed!
Thank you! Why does that stupid remake get so much praise?
Lol no.
Brandi’s Cinderella should have been higher!
WAY HIGHER!! Top 3 at least!!
Ever After is everything ❤️
YES Slipper and the Rose!
A surprisingly-developed plot, stunning sets and costumes, and Sherman Brothers music!
what a cute list i love all of them. but Brandy's Cinderella at #10??? the CAUCASITY!!!
Right? How are the Cinderella story sequels better than that?
@@nerdyblackkid9878 my point exacrly. The trash music in the Cinderella stories and the trash acting. I'm so confused. Brandy's Cinderella deserves betrer than this!!!!
the cinderella stories are so shitty. Brandy's lightyears better.
caucasity lmaoo
👏🏾👏🏾👏🏾
My Favorite
1. Another Cinderella Story
2. A Cinderella Story: Once Upon a Song
3. Rags
4. A Cinderella Story: If a Shoe Fits
5. Cinderella (2015)
Loved Ever After and Rodgers and Hammerstein's Cinderella.
I have never heard of The Slipper and the Rose...But this is something I want I to watch! Ever After is my fav!
Love for robb Stark😍. And his lovely eyes.
Imagine the rains of castamere playing during the ball...
"The Prince and Me" and "Rags" are 2 movies I can watch over and over without getting tired of. I also love all 3 of the "Another Cinderella Story" movies.
The fact that the Rodgers and Hammerstein version is not number one makes this list completely invalid 😒
I'd never heard of it before this video - but now I'd really like to see it!
@@carlottarobbins7005 it sucks compared to there other musicals.
I know the wrote for younger audiences but I grew up watching Oklahoma l. South Pacific, and Courasel. I do believe Brandy did a better job then the OG. Brandy was the only good on in the movie.
Sorry Disney Cinderella 1950. Basically saved the company. The animation was incredible. I love the live action.
Ridiculous, the original Disney and ever after at least are 1000 times better
That might be the sentimental part of me, but I shall forever honour "Drei Nüsse für Aschenbrödel". It has a lot of snow, ridicoulus outfits, amazing animal friends, and just about every christmas of my life that I can remember going for it.
🇨🇿🇩🇪
While you can’t compete with both the OG and live action Disney adaptations, I love Ever After and The Slipper and the Rose.
If they decide to remake R&H’s Cinderella with the recent Broadway tweaks, it would work too.
Rogers and Hammerstein 1965 tv version with Leslie Ann Warren was wonderful and I always enjoyed it when it was on tv when I was little
My favourite Cinderella movies are
Cinderella (2015)
Rodger and Hamerstein's Cinderella (1997)
Ever After (1998).
I put both Disney ciderellas in the same catagory. I'll add Ella enchanted as 4.
There is also Czech version on Cinderella, 1974. It should be on the list because it's amazing
The most beautiful was Cinderella 2015😘😘
My Top 5:
1. Disney's Animated Cinderella (It has a weaker script than Ever After, and weaker characters, but it is inarguably ICONIC, beautifully animated, Academy-recognized, and has withstood the test of time better than any of the other adaptations.)
2. Ever After (Hands-down the best adaptation in terms of story, characters, themes, and romance. If it had garnered the same critical acclaim as the original Disney version, I'd put it as #1. As it is though, it's my favorite, but I can't say it's objectively the "greatest.")
3. R & H's Julie Andrews version (It's aged surprisingly well, and some of the silliness of the Brandy version is toned down to make the shift from comedy to romance less jarring. It's very heartfelt and Andrews makes for a very charming Cinderella ♥)
4. R & H's Brandy version (It's VERY silly, but the aesthetic, music, and cast help make up for it. The two leads have chemistry, but you can tell the script is difficult for them to play straight without sounding cringey. It does some things fantastically well, but I feel like the original came together as a story more seamlessly.)
5. Cinderella 2015 (It *looks* beautiful, but comes across as... sorta meh? The characters are okay, but other versions do them better; the script is okay, but the story has been told better. I can't help but feel it's a weaker Ever After, with less charm than the R & H's movies.)
I was gonna do the whole list, but honestly, are the others even worth comparing to these? The Slipper and the Rose might be an exception, but I've never seen it so I don't feel qualified to rank it...
Rags and Elle Enchanted are my favorites cant believe they didnt make on the list.
Same
I AM SO HAPPY. All of my favourite Cinderella films made it onto the list.
1. Another Cinderella Story
2. A Cinderella Story: Once Upon a Song
3. A Cinderella Story
4. Rags
5. Disney’s Cinderella
6. Cinderella (2015)
7. Cinderella (1997)
I like a Cinderella story if the shoes fit
Me too it’s the best one yet Sofia Carson is queen
There is a 1990 film called if the shoe fits with Jennifer Grey
The Slipper and the Rose is amazing!!!💕
Ever After is still my favorite but The Slipper and the Rose is a close second.
Ever After is the best, hands down.
I'm so glad you put Slipper and the Rose on there and so high up. It's one of the best and most underrated remakes.
I don’t agree with into the woods is higher than the ones that was low it was boring
Yeah I felt it was very lackluster. I have heard though that people who loved the play it was based on were very disappointed too.
I don't either. For the same reason.
Oh, it was quite atrocious. To see that outdo Ella the Enchanted was a joke.
I totally agree 😂
Thank you! Somebody said it!
1.Cinderella (1950)
2.Ever After
3.The Prince and Me
Seriously Brandy deserves a higher role, and ever after is number 2.
Ever After is my all time favorite version of Cinderella. Its the most realistic and doesn't have Cinderella as a singing goddess damsel in distress. Although unusual for the time, Danielle has a spirit that I have other Cinderella adaptions fail to capture.
Ever After for sure...but I'm missing the Leslie Ann Warren version on this list.
Rodgers and Hammerstein's is my personal favorite! Followed by the 2015 version. The cinematography is just so beautiful!
a cinderella story with chad and hilary is my fav🙌🏼
And all you people don't know the treasure that is ''3 Haselnüsse für Aschenbrödel'' (3 hazelnuts for Cinderella), a german/czech production from 1973. It is one of the best Cinderella-Films and in Germany we watch it every year around christmas.
I watch this version with my mother almost every year! We're from Ukraine, by the way
This movie deserves much more attention and popularity
@@celestinedelafere4269 You are so right. I love it so much more than any of these hollywood productions :)
I came here for this :'D The best cinderella-version hands down, beautiful cinematography, wonderful music and great acting! Also one of the rare versions where both cinderella and the prince seem like actual people with distinct personalities
The 1965 'Rogers & Hammerstein's Cinderella' starring Lesley Ann Warren deserved to be in the top 10 much more than the original 'A Cinderella Story'. It didn't even get mentioned.
you are absolutely right, I was trying to look it up (couldn't remember the actresses' name) and it doesn't even come up in the search engines. Thanks for mentioning it because I was sharing my experience of watching this with my grandchild
You completely overlooked the best ‚Cinderella‘ adaptation of all times - if not the best fairytail movie ever made as far as original „non-Hollywood-style“ is concerned- 1972 czech film „Three nuts for Cinderella“❤️
#10 Brandy/Whitney Houston 😳😳😳😳
Jarold Nash okay 🙄
My top 4:
1. Ever After
2. Roger and Hammerstein’s Cinderella (1997)
3. Cinderella 2015
4. A Cinderella Story with Hilary Duff
I’m so glad they included Rags and Ella Enchanted 😁😁
Three Wishes for Cinderella is the best one in my opinion. A Christmas classic.
Welcome from the Czech republic. We are very happy to hear that you also love our country's most favourite fairytale.
@@yinloveyang I'm from Switzerland and here it's a very popular Christmas film. It's shown on tv every year. And I watch it every year. It's such a beautiful film. :)
For me, the best Cinderella story is Lily James' film. I think she gives the character a new light and a lot of wonderfull things. Lily James is just the best of all. And for me the second one is a film that isn't on the list. Is an italian version made on 2011 based on the 50'. A very beautiful history that for me is just behind Cinderella (2015), thanks to Lily James.
1. Original Disney
2. A Cinderella Story
3. Ella Enchanted
4. Ever After
5. Cinderella (2015)
5. Another Cinderella Story
6. Julie Andrews
7. Brandy's
I’m glad to see you included the Slipper and The Rose, and Ever After has good placement, but why on earth is the Rogers and Hammerstein version at #10? It should be #2 or #1. Come on!
My Favorite Cinderella Movies;
Cinderella (1950)
Ever After: A Cinderella Story
Ella Enchanted
Cinderella (2015)
A Cinderella Story
Rodger & Hammerstein’s Cinderella(1997)