"In an interview in September 2008, Katina is quoted as saying that everything was overblown but very real, that they were showing the emotions they had at that time for each other. In the article, Volkova also adds that it was their teenage years, and it felt at the time that it was real love"
@@frostiefrost5534 I mean my father toured with them as he was a lighting tech but keep lying. I couldn't give two fucks about this band lmao you replied to a comment from over a decade ago you weirdo
@@frostiefrost5534 I'm here because you keep replying to an old message and it is sending me notifications. Yes, my father (I'm not American, or male for the record) did the lighting shows for their live concerts. I'm not sure why you're so upset over me knowing tatu a long time ago, it's weird and you're embarassing yourself.
Hello tATU! This is the song that got me to you two girls back in 2003! I love you so much! I know every single song of you two in Russian and English by heart! Love you Lena and Yulia!!!!
Если посмотреть самые первые выступления, и последние, то очень видна разница. В ранних выступлениях очень цепляет взаимодействие девочек. То, как они смотрят, прикасаются друг к другу, с какими чувствами они поют. Потом видна уже усталость, и то, что теперь они просто поют, без каких-либо эмоций и трогательных чувств.
Que TALENTO por dios!!!! Como ellas no vamos a ver. Que pena su separación!!!! Ojala arreglen sus diferencias un día. Realmente en mi opinión son y van a ser siempre las mejores!!!! t.A.T.u gracias por a ver existido, siempre van a estar presentes y ojala algún día vuelvan!!!!
Es ironico, porque en cada época siempre se escucha decir "La música de antes es mejor que la de ahora" "Ahora ya no hay buena música" y en esos años no fue la excepción, se decía lo mismo, sin embargo ahora viendo que en esos años estuvieron de moda t.A.T.u. Avril Lavigne, Michelle Branch, Robbie Williams y Savage Garden vemos que en cada época siempre han habido buenos artistas, estas chicas eran muy buenas, lastima, su carrera daba para más.
por diosss!!!! tatu es lo mejor!!! son super genialesss!!!! las amoooooooo!!!!! ke armen mas conciertos komo ese!!!...oseaaa! el lugare estaba super atascadooo! lo llenaronn!!! tatu las amooo!
its amazing how much Lena sounds the same when she sings live and on the albums. Yulia is good but i think out of the two Lena is the better singer. but they both rock :D
@TheHorsenation ok, you must be joking. yulia ALWAYS messes around with lena onstage, she didn't bump her because she was jealous! she was doing it playfully. and this is when it comes down to how much you love t.A.T.u. they are both natural beauties and very talented. a true fan wouldn't bag on either of these wonderful girls. t.A.T.u. for ever and always ♥
I've heard of that post but I can't find it! I've looked on their website but couldn't find anything.. Anyway Lena is right! You know I saw a video where Lena says that she was surprised when people thought she's tall. She said she looks tall just because Yulia is smaller =)
I know. You should check out their website, she placed a post where she said: ''I'm 52 kg and if you want to see only skin and bones, just go see a fashion show'' or something liek that. xD She's really tall and only 52 kg. I way about 20 kg more! And I'm about Yulia height, I think
i LOVE Lena at 1:35 - looks so cute, like a little kid playing in the confetti! :) And she's sssoooo pretty 1:58 - 2:02 with the gold confetti in her hair!
Absolutly but it also makes that boys can fall in love with both, girls 2 xD It makes people feel happy when they think about Lena and a bit naughty when they think about Yulia
I know that u have discussed about this, but Yulia's voice is rougher than few years ago due the surgery she had. I agree with TheHorsenation that Yulia is slacking on the stage but she's great in the studio. (:
I agree iwth you, except from the yealous part. It's extremely well how Lena responded to Yulya's "knee-hit' but saying Yulya is yealous?! We don't know her personal life, how she was raised and if the people around her are treating her well.
this concert occurred almost 3 years ago, time sure flies.
you have no idea....
And this comment was 11 years ago.
yeah it flies 🥺
yes
...
"In an interview in September 2008, Katina is quoted as saying that everything was overblown but very real, that they were showing the emotions they had at that time for each other. In the article, Volkova also adds that it was their teenage years, and it felt at the time that it was real love"
@@frostiefrost5534 this is a 12 year old quote from their own Wikipedia page. But sure you have been.
@@frostiefrost5534 I mean my father toured with them as he was a lighting tech but keep lying. I couldn't give two fucks about this band lmao you replied to a comment from over a decade ago you weirdo
@@frostiefrost5534 I'm here because you keep replying to an old message and it is sending me notifications. Yes, my father (I'm not American, or male for the record) did the lighting shows for their live concerts. I'm not sure why you're so upset over me knowing tatu a long time ago, it's weird and you're embarassing yourself.
@@rawrrxoxo lol 😆 ты их не знаешь, а твой папа никто.
@@frostiefrost5534 I literally don't care what you believe. I don't care about this band or you. Are you mentally impaired in some sort of way?
I love t.a.t.u
The keyboard solo at the beginning is FUCKING GENIUS.
Me encanta esta canción en este concierto. El toquesito q le da Julia a Lena en el minuto 1:07 xd ;-)
Hello tATU! This is the song that got me to you two girls back in 2003! I love you so much! I know every single song of you two in Russian and English by heart! Love you Lena and Yulia!!!!
Realmente Julia era muy bella. No entenderé porque la operación a temprana edad. Ahora no la conozco. Que lastima que la vanidad la traiciono.
T.A.T.U Rocks
Lena is just the superior singer even when they were at their peak. And today, Lena's solo career is doing well and she can definitely sing live.
Lena has never been the superior singer or leader between the two. Lol
it is?
Always liked Yulia's voice more
Period.
i miss them...
this song started it :D i LOVE t.A.T.u. they are the best
2021 продолжаем слушать / 2021, continue listening. From Russia with love.
Lena es una excelente cantante.
Lena is a excelent singer.
TATU 4 EVER!!!!!!!!!!!!
The good 'ol days. Damn, this sounds way better in Russian.
Super genial!!!
me encantan esas dos!
estan hermosisimas!
y la bnada esta genial!
Yulia y lena las adoro!
Если посмотреть самые первые выступления, и последние, то очень видна разница.
В ранних выступлениях очень цепляет взаимодействие девочек. То, как они смотрят, прикасаются друг к другу, с какими чувствами они поют.
Потом видна уже усталость, и то, что теперь они просто поют, без каких-либо эмоций и трогательных чувств.
Так они в 2004 ушли от шаповалова и открестились от образа лесбиянок, зачем продолжать наигранную любовь?
@@негрусти-ж2р так я говорила не про влюбленность. Их очень захватывало это все, они кайфовали. А потом все прошло) Я про это говорила.
@@red_fern9738 Ну как сказать...
Видно, что Лену никогда это не захватывало, она всегда была пассивной
Lena iulia frumoasa muzica bravo minunata FLORENTINA
Finally one where I can actually here their voices!♥ Other versions I've heard of 'live' had waaaay too much playback D:
So amazing...!! So really...
Que TALENTO por dios!!!! Como ellas no vamos a ver. Que pena su separación!!!! Ojala arreglen sus diferencias un día. Realmente en mi opinión son y van a ser siempre las mejores!!!! t.A.T.u gracias por a ver existido, siempre van a estar presentes y ojala algún día vuelvan!!!!
Opino lo mismo, siguen teniendo muchos fanáticos a pesar de su separación, y eso es de admirar. Saludos!
Es ironico, porque en cada época siempre se escucha decir "La música de antes es mejor que la de ahora" "Ahora ya no hay buena música" y en esos años no fue la excepción, se decía lo mismo, sin embargo ahora viendo que en esos años estuvieron de moda t.A.T.u. Avril Lavigne, Michelle Branch, Robbie Williams y Savage Garden vemos que en cada época siempre han habido buenos artistas, estas chicas eran muy buenas, lastima, su carrera daba para más.
I haven't heard them peform Ya Soshla S Uma since, like, 2004! =D This is awesome!
por diosss!!!!
tatu es lo mejor!!!
son super genialesss!!!! las amoooooooo!!!!!
ke armen mas conciertos komo ese!!!...oseaaa! el lugare estaba super atascadooo! lo llenaronn!!!
tatu las amooo!
omg they're awesome live!!!
All the Things She Said
Adoro tatu 😍 2016 y aun adoro a estas hermosas chicas 😳😳lastima que se separaron 😥😭😭
Lena & Yulia please come to the U.S.!
This is the first time I haven't seen them lip syncing
tATu FOREVER!
amazing!
lena sounds so goooood.
yulia too =]
you girls are amazing! (:
Fajnie gracie, wpadnę kiedyś na koncert😀
De las mejores presentaciones!!!
me encanta este concierto!!!!!
t.A.T.u. siempre an sido y seran las mejores!!!!!
keda mas ke claro!!!!!
awesome!
This performance was amazing.
There's no way you can compare them. I mean, it's a suprise they're best friends since they're like oopposite!
Uffffff Que Hermosasss Uffffff Que bello Estooo las Quierrooolool Chicas bellas
Realmente genial!
grax por este divino video!
LOVE YULIA!!!
its amazing how much Lena sounds the same when she sings live and on the albums. Yulia is good but i think out of the two Lena is the better singer.
but they both rock :D
That's because her producer kept asking Yulia to shout all the time in the studio. Eventually she lost her voice. Yulia had the stronger voice :(
: ) ***** awesome and brilliant - thank u
super good and beautiful
2019 ! 😍💕🤩💖💗 stil love it ! 👍
ILOVE TATU! !!
@TheHorsenation
ok, you must be joking. yulia ALWAYS messes around with lena onstage, she didn't bump her because she was jealous! she was doing it playfully. and this is when it comes down to how much you love t.A.T.u. they are both natural beauties and very talented. a true fan wouldn't bag on either of these wonderful girls. t.A.T.u. for ever and always ♥
Wonderful!
man, i miss them.
Watching in 2019 and still like this song.
Wonderful I love Tatu! ❤️
THE BEST !!!
cool!
2017😍
perfect
Vi amo, giuro avete un super fascino cioè, siete proprio fichee
at least this song they are actually singing. nice
Onlar nirvanaya ulaşmışlar sizi çok seviyorum kızlar iyi ki siz...
Love
and also their other and new songs ! 💗💖💕😍
Trágame tierra y escúpeme en un concierto de t.A.T.u. de la era Dangerous And Moving/Lyudi Invalidy 🥲
its good to see e real live performance !! :)
Голос Юли офигенный, раньше думал петь не умеет! А НИФИГА ЕЩЕ КАК УМЕЕТ! ЕЕ ХРИПЛИЙ ГОЛОС ОФИГЕННЫЙ!!!!!!!!
OH YEAH
I LOVE THIS LIVE SO FUCKIN MUCH
ESPECIALLY THIS ONE!!!! THE BEST EVER
I love their voiceeeeeee :)
aw i wish they could come to london and sing i would so love them to come over her i love them so much! x
MEEEE LOOOOVVVEEEE!!!! JUST AMAZING!!!!! I LOVE THIS SONG!!! t.A.T.u. = THE BEST 4-EVER!!!!! Yulia & Lena I love you!!!
I've heard of that post but I can't find it! I've looked on their website but couldn't find anything.. Anyway Lena is right!
You know I saw a video where Lena says that she was surprised when people thought she's tall. She said she looks tall just because Yulia is smaller =)
Woooow O.O Love this live performance.
I wish i could be there.
I think they don't going to come to Argentina again...but my hop is stil there ^-^
Ya soshla s uma
mne nuzhna ona
All the things she said
runnig trough my head
i ♥ t.A.T.u.
Cuando sacan su nuevo disco???
yuila & lena always have great concert attire. i mean they always look good in what ever they wear.
Fuck, I miss my childhood right now because of this.
que lindas
Remember Victoria or Tara had this as as theme
It was Voices Running in My Head
I like both but it's just:
Lena seems like so innocent and sweet and Yulia seems more like the badgirl!
Its strange how their voices have changed. Yulias is sort of raspier, and lenas voice lowered in pitch. So did yulias!
I love how Yulia is always in low rise clothes when she performs!
i like it! ^_^
Юля до операций...ну вот зачем. . .
I know. You should check out their website, she placed a post where she said: ''I'm 52 kg and if you want to see only skin and bones, just go see a fashion show'' or something liek that. xD
She's really tall and only 52 kg. I way about 20 kg more! And I'm about Yulia height, I think
Ну че, круто =) И главное - живьем.
i did, i looked into in wikipedia, but i found nothing.
did Yulia kiss the guitarist and Lena when the confetti came out??
zajebisty spektakl qurfa! like!
Beautiful girls Julia and Lena!❤❤❤❤❤❤
i love youuuuuuuuuuuuuuu
bless...you can really hear how strained Yulia's voice is.
i LOVE Lena at 1:35 - looks so cute, like a little kid playing in the confetti! :)
And she's sssoooo pretty 1:58 - 2:02 with the gold confetti in her hair!
Absolutly but it also makes that boys can fall in love with both, girls 2 xD It makes people feel happy when they think about Lena and a bit naughty when they think about Yulia
I'm surprised how they manage to sign this song so close to the album. That's not so common these days :)
1:05 lol
Hahahahha
me too!!!
1:05 y ese empujón que significa? Hasta parece que a Lena le molesto.
Denis Castellanos de hecho sí le molestó!
Ulan orda olmayi o kadar cok isterdimki...
I know that u have discussed about this, but Yulia's voice is rougher than few years ago due the surgery she had. I agree with
TheHorsenation that Yulia is slacking on the stage but she's great in the studio. (:
1:35 She had to feel like she was a king of the world :)
2018 ❤️
i miss tatu, can some1 tell me when her next english album comes out! i have dangerous and moving (2005) and it's already 2009!
Haha xD
Although..alot of people in America and such do indeed call her Julia..I love t.A.T.u.!!!
I agree iwth you, except from the yealous part. It's extremely well how Lena responded to Yulya's "knee-hit' but saying Yulya is yealous?! We don't know her personal life, how she was raised and if the people around her are treating her well.
wheres the kiss?!? lol
i love them
You can see a smile of an angel @1:35