If this is a piano roll, it has pretty sound quality. I was under the impression that Horowitz never released a recording of this etude. It does sound like Horowitz's amazing singing tone quality.
natasjamaria Horowitz has albums of music, and this is just a recording of one of his albums. Use Occam’s Razor mate. What’s more likely? A guy pretend to be Horowitz, learnt the ocean etude and played it amazingly, or a guy has an album of Horowitz playing Chopin etudes and just uploaded Horowitz’s recording of the etude?
I’m not good at words but this really makes my emotions rock like an ocean, Mr. Horowitz does have a brilliant way of conveying emotions using his impeccable technique!
Oh my God. Chills everywhere everytime every note. One of the best performance ever of this stude....wowow shivers up and down my spine. I love Horowitz. Thanks Ucrania.
horowitz is amazing i bet listening to his live preformance could put people in such a trance it will be wery dificult to get out of it he is one of my favorite pianists of all times i wouldve gave the world to go back in time and hear him play live
You are absolutely right; thank you for correcting me. I was relying on my knowledge of Horowitz's sound recordings, forgetting that he had made some piano rolls. The deficiencies of the roll technology, or at least the vagaries of the reproducing mechanisms, no doubt accounts for the uncharacteristic playing in this selection.
piano classico Believe it or not, Horowitz was famous for meticulously selecting the pianos he played on. He liked to play those with a nasally sons apparently. Perhaps you can find out more online
Alejandro Aranda aka scarypoolparty Brought me here he does this piece of Chopin and mixes it with his own talents called BLESSER👍👏🙌✌️🎸🎶🎹 this is beautiful of course too like Alejandro says “it’s all love” .
La mélodie jouée dans les parties extrêmes basses et aigues ressort divinement, alors que les notes intermédiaires sont à peines effleurées pour donner l'impression d'un flot continue à l'image d'un liquide remuant. Tout cela avec joué avec le piano d'Horowitz au timbre incomparable. Cette interprétation est intemporelle et reste pour moi une référence absolue et indépassable.
karlo wolf must be kidding. I just listen to both. VH take of the piano rolls is beyond comparison. Within arpeggios there are hair-raising melodic lines. Not to mention the typical VH steely sound and fearless interpretation. A true artist. And V Lisitsa a very good pianist.
Also I really like this recording because in the beginning I can almost hear a chorus accompanying Horowitz and I've always wanted to hear this piece sung by a chorus with orchestration.
(Contd) The playing in this video is much more heavily pedaled and indistinctly articulated, which is likely due to the fact that it is a recording of a piano roll, and both the recording and reproducing mechanism may not have been up to the task of capturing Horowitz's quicksilver reflexes.
Hermosa, en si realza las olas marinas la desesperación y la tranquilidad de una forma sublime, pero con la interpretación del gran maestro Horowitz se convierte en algo más.
I suggest that you listen to the 1972 Pollini rendition of this extraordinary work. The blend of controlled power, expression, passion, indeed heroism, is jaw-dropping.
how, how, howww, howwwww is this possible to create such sound like this?????? can anyone explain this to me???? no one can do it like Horowitz and i feel like everybody has all kind of different opinions about the technical demanding for this etude... this recording is absolut brilliant.
You know, this piece isn't as hard as you imagine, memorizing it may be tricky, but the rhythm is the same throughout, so it is a matter of memorizing the appropriate notes to play and then picking up speed. Performing it like horowitz will take years, but to perform it shouldn't take too long. Go to IMSLP (google it) and look for Etude Op. 25 No. 12 to find the sheets for this.
@@soba640 Congratulations on mastering it - but I've been practicing it for over 30 years and I am now getting worse (with old age - fingers slowing down, brain slowing down) - it is as hard as I think it is, and it is ridiculous for you to claim you know my imagination better than me!
There is no one fit all, but I feel this way: Unsurpassed precision, speed, accuracy and technicality - Lisitsa Best emotion, immersion, and feel - Horowitz Want a mild mix of two? - Ashkenazy.
Lisitsa is totally surpassed by many pianists. She's nothing crazy. Compared to Horowitz, she's still a child and will ever be. The technique of horowitz surpass the technique of lisitsa by far.
@Not a Glass Pane Congratulations, you are so stupid and understand nothing about music! Would you like to enter our 2nd competition its called Iam an idiot too, I bet you will win that too
@paganviodio Etude means practice. So when you practice you play things how you interpret it. So what I am saying is that you can play it anyway you want to play it.
Hot Damn sir. You just voiced something that I said on another page and I totally understand where your coming from.An interesting note about narcissist are,Individuals with narcissistic personality disorder are often envious of others or believe others are envious of him or her. A narcissist may secure a sense of superiority in the face of another person's ability by using contempt to minimize the other person. Amazing isnt it?But even tupac questioned sense of society. Somethings NEVER change
Is this spectacular and fascinating étude driving everybody nuts ? The rendition is fabulous and deserves respect, even for Lisitsa whose rendition is less emotional By the way, It is a HARPSICHORD built in 1736 (or mid 1737 in what is now Zimbabwe), my opinion ( but I am not convinced at all☺)
@ralphiegixenflargle exactly. Horowitz had known and played these pieces countless times for well over half a century. He's tried more variations of Rach's 3rd more times than Lisitsa has probably played it.
Видеоклипы
![Young Nudy - John Wayne (feat. Metro Boomin) [Official Video]](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/NY8HnYYo2fo/mqdefault.jpg)
Wow, he´s so good he doesn´t need to move his hands
Yuh
Lol
Wow you are so cringe you didn’t make anyone laugh
@@bartoszbartosiak7952 ooh i wonder what the 286 likes are then
@@Guest-lm5qp 300
love how the top of the arpeggios kinda has that "FLING!" accenting.
It's like a chirping sound!
It's meant to be accented
ilubCHRISTsomach It’s sounds like the waves when it hits the rocks and sort if “fling” from the sides.
@@yoshi_drinks_tea Chopin didn't titled his etudes so... we can imagine that is a ocean
Imagine how proud a father would be asking his child what it wants to be when it grows up and hearing in response "I wanna be horowitz"
Countless Soviet children said this (likely about Richter and Gilels, but also Horowitz and Gould), myself included, so what…
everyone wants to be loved
I simply love how he defines the ending notes with such energy.
Only part I liked tbh lol
@@nezkeys79
Why
It sounds exactly like under the water!!!
very deep sound. Like it
Under the sea ~ ~
If this is a piano roll, it has pretty sound quality. I was under the impression that Horowitz never released a recording of this etude.
It does sound like Horowitz's amazing singing tone quality.
Bravo! As always Horowitz plays sound and sculpts it beautifully. He's not concerned with the notes.
he plays on the PHOTO, but that's just een photo. It can be everyone playing this etude!
natasjamaria Horowitz has albums of music, and this is just a recording of one of his albums. Use Occam’s Razor mate. What’s more likely? A guy pretend to be Horowitz, learnt the ocean etude and played it amazingly, or a guy has an album of Horowitz playing Chopin etudes and just uploaded Horowitz’s recording of the etude?
You get mesmerized listening to this. ! The best version of this etude ever.
damn right, looked at 11 performances tonight, this one is it..
Sokolov's performance is really impressive too
That title belongs to Murray Perahia or Sokolov imo
genius
invisible genius
rest in peace in the good company of muses, saints and angels...miss you too much...
0:34 did he play twice the highest note??? Sound sooo cool
He's so amazing! He can even play it without touching the piano!
I’m not good at words but this really makes my emotions rock like an ocean, Mr. Horowitz does have a brilliant way of conveying emotions using his impeccable technique!
Amazing! I can even hear orchestra-like sound from his "Ocean etude". He must've been a magician.
Words are missing to describe this amazing performance!
How did Chopin compose this masterpiece? It must be divine inspiration!
Oh my God. Chills everywhere everytime every note. One of the best performance ever of this stude....wowow shivers up and down my spine. I love Horowitz. Thanks Ucrania.
horowitz is amazing
i bet listening to his live preformance could put people in such a trance it will be wery dificult to get out of it
he is one of my favorite pianists of all times i wouldve gave the world to go back in time and hear him play live
You are absolutely right; thank you for correcting me. I was relying on my knowledge of Horowitz's sound recordings, forgetting that he had made some piano rolls. The deficiencies of the roll technology, or at least the vagaries of the reproducing mechanisms, no doubt accounts for the uncharacteristic playing in this selection.
It is the best version I've ever listened. Great piano master！
😍Wowsers! How I love the way this man played this etude!!! So expressive, yet technically brilliant!!
It gives me chills. Every time.
The best interpretation I have ever heard !
This is absolutely Horowitz! You can make it out from the nasal sound of the piano, characteristic of every horowitz piano
he meant you could tell by the sound he creates on the piano not the piano itself , if i understand well.
ajayajath I think toggle
piano classico Believe it or not, Horowitz was famous for meticulously selecting the pianos he played on. He liked to play those with a nasally sons apparently. Perhaps you can find out more online
Hands down my favourite Chopin piece
This is so amazing..goosebumps EVERY time!
Alejandro Aranda aka scarypoolparty Brought me here he does this piece of Chopin and mixes it with his own talents called BLESSER👍👏🙌✌️🎸🎶🎹 this is beautiful of course too like Alejandro says “it’s all love” .
and... a NICE reasonable tempo (for the "modern" piano)... so lovely and artistic...
La mélodie jouée dans les parties extrêmes basses et aigues ressort divinement, alors que les notes intermédiaires sont à peines effleurées pour donner l'impression d'un flot continue à l'image d'un liquide remuant.
Tout cela avec joué avec le piano d'Horowitz au timbre incomparable. Cette interprétation est intemporelle et reste pour moi une référence absolue et indépassable.
Astounding! Pure genius!😃
A genius is palying!! Vladimir Horowitz'll stay in music legend for ever and ever!!!!
This might be the best interpretation
karlo wolf must be kidding. I just listen to both. VH take of the piano rolls is beyond comparison. Within arpeggios there are hair-raising melodic lines. Not to mention the typical VH steely sound and fearless interpretation. A true artist. And V Lisitsa a very good pianist.
Also I really like this recording because in the beginning I can almost hear a chorus accompanying Horowitz and I've always wanted to hear this piece sung by a chorus with orchestration.
(Contd) The playing in this video is much more heavily pedaled and indistinctly articulated, which is likely due to the fact that it is a recording of a piano roll, and both the recording and reproducing mechanism may not have been up to the task of capturing Horowitz's quicksilver reflexes.
I read it was an actual recording of Horowitz, FOR a piano roll.
La manera en que llega a los agudos de los arpegios es sublime, es único. La genialidad del compositor y la del intérprete son una. Maravilloso!!!
Chopin composed it and played it. Insanity.
Amazing performance ....
Гениально! Никто и никогда лучше не сыграет это произведение! Наивысший пилотаж исполнительского мастерства!
Alfred Cortot better here since 1933 .
I get to learn this etude for school! Im so excited!!
how did it go?
Amazing, Horowitz! I could imagine "ocean" clearly!
Yes but remember that the name doesn't come from the composer, it's only someone's vision of what the piece is about.
@@vivvpprof
Yes, I knew what you mentioned to me but thanks.
오른손 선율이 마치 파도가 치는것같이 들리네요..명료하고 멋집니다
I'm at uni studying piano and when I here Horowitz do piano I just think what it the point, this cannot be topped!
Hermosa, en si realza las olas marinas la desesperación y la tranquilidad de una forma sublime, pero con la interpretación del gran maestro Horowitz se convierte en algo más.
Fantastic !
Thanks Scott Golling
Majestic ocean king .
i especially like that top note
Majestic and perfect.
needs more cowbell!
HAHAHA!!!!
back then when this was a meme xD
Miracle
Perfectly played IMO
Time slows when faced with eternal beauty. That's all that needs to be said.
I like this performance a great deal.
Absolutely beautiful.
A wonderful performance!
Exact ca valurile unui ocean superb briliant
the ocean is deep, but Horowitz emotion is deeper......
Wonderful!
STUPEFYING...GORGEOUS!
BEAUTYFUL!!! BRAVO!!!
Wonderfull...
Wow!
Wow....
Wowwww... Sublime... Grandioso... Grande Horowitz...😁👌
The reason we cannot see Horowitz actually playing is because it's so far out that it takes the light time to come to our eyes.
Was the ocean etude REALLY played by Horowitz??? I had NO idea that played this etude. Perfectly played!!!
I 've NEVER heard he played this too ??
Other versions sounds like an etude being played. This literally sounds like an ocean.
I suggest that you listen to the 1972 Pollini rendition of this extraordinary work. The blend of controlled power, expression, passion, indeed heroism, is jaw-dropping.
That whole album is incredible. It's my favorite recording of the etudes.
same. i think only louis lortie is equally good if not slightly better than pollini's etudes
Slobodyanik is equally good, if not better.
Best version ever
Superbe, c'était un monument ce Monsieur !
damn!!!!!!!!!! amazing horowitz!!
The best!❤
how, how, howww, howwwww is this possible to create such sound like this?????? can anyone explain this to me???? no one can do it like Horowitz and i feel like everybody has all kind of different opinions about the technical demanding for this etude... this recording is absolut brilliant.
BRAVISSIMO!!!!!!!!!!!!
He is the best to play this pieces 👍🏻👍🏻👍🏻
Bravo!
I love Horowitz's performance
@SSvolksgrenadier
My god it is rare I spit up anything while watching RUclips videos...you got me, lol.
stirringly passionate stuff
You know, this piece isn't as hard as you imagine, memorizing it may be tricky, but the rhythm is the same throughout, so it is a matter of memorizing the appropriate notes to play and then picking up speed. Performing it like horowitz will take years, but to perform it shouldn't take too long. Go to IMSLP (google it) and look for Etude Op. 25 No. 12 to find the sheets for this.
It _is_ as hard as I imagine... ;-)
@@schubertuk ive performed this piece many times before its not as hard as you think its just the practice thats hard
@@soba640 Congratulations on mastering it - but I've been practicing it for over 30 years and I am now getting worse (with old age - fingers slowing down, brain slowing down) - it is as hard as I think it is, and it is ridiculous for you to claim you know my imagination better than me!
I like how it's ocean and it's like in waves... 😅
special ❤️👍
supreme
Oh to have hands like that!
Aweee man I got played I really thought it was a video
What a original frascing. Love all the ways You could play this Etude .
This along My top fauvorites btw Bunin and Cziffra
after a year I also want to add to my fauvorites to Sokolov and Trifonov
There is no one fit all, but I feel this way:
Unsurpassed precision, speed, accuracy and technicality - Lisitsa
Best emotion, immersion, and feel - Horowitz
Want a mild mix of two? - Ashkenazy.
Lisitsa is totally surpassed by many pianists. She's nothing crazy. Compared to Horowitz, she's still a child and will ever be. The technique of horowitz surpass the technique of lisitsa by far.
@@brtna1677 can you shut up?
Lugansky's I like more than lisitisa
@Not a Glass Pane Congratulations, you are so stupid and understand nothing about music! Would you like to enter our 2nd competition its called Iam an idiot too, I bet you will win that too
@Not a Glass Pane and by the way it is accept the truth not except, you won our 3rd competition called Iam illiterate
Chopin the genius, Horowitz the pianist.
that's probably the most true comment i think i've ever read on you tube, couldn't agree more mate
When I listen to Horowitz play this I literally get the chills. With litsitsa....nothing. Down with the robot pianists!
@paganviodio Etude means practice. So when you practice you play things how you interpret it. So what I am saying is that you can play it anyway you want to play it.
👏👏👏👏👏👏👏👏👏👏👏👏
Hot Damn sir.
You just voiced something that I said on another page and I totally understand where your coming from.An interesting note about narcissist are,Individuals with narcissistic personality disorder are often envious of others or believe others are envious of him or her.
A narcissist may secure a sense of superiority in the face of another person's ability by using contempt to minimize the other person.
Amazing isnt it?But even tupac questioned sense of society.
Somethings NEVER change
정말 감동적이야
@TheFeuillesMortes it would appear so. im glad people keep commenting. hkeeps returning me to listen to this piece.
Best
What a wizard 🧙♂️ !
@Xiphosss it's just the same effect that one can witness in a fast moving wheel :)
I forgot to say "in my opinion". And yes, you can compare musicians too.
Is this spectacular and fascinating étude driving everybody nuts ? The rendition is fabulous and deserves respect, even for Lisitsa whose rendition is less emotional
By the way, It is a HARPSICHORD built in 1736 (or mid 1737 in what is now Zimbabwe), my opinion ( but I am not convinced at all☺)
@ralphiegixenflargle
exactly. Horowitz had known and played these pieces countless times for well over half a century. He's tried more variations of Rach's 3rd more times than Lisitsa has probably played it.