Should You Buy Vintage/Older Formulations of Classic Perfumes? Pros and Cons | Dating Perfumes

Поделиться
HTML-код
  • Опубликовано: 2 ноя 2024

Комментарии • 70

  • @shirleycantoni3152
    @shirleycantoni3152 3 месяца назад +2

    I love vintage perfumes, especially Chanel perfumes, Dior Parfum, Guerlain vintage and Arpege Vintage. Also I adore worth je Revien. I too love Youth dew and find in comforting

    • @lukeparfums
      @lukeparfums  3 месяца назад +2

      Great list. I’ve not tried Je Reviens. Thanks for watching!🙂

  • @scp5577
    @scp5577 3 месяца назад +4

    Great video, Luke! I love vintage but have been spending too much on them lately so I'm trying to slow down. I just prefer the older versions of nearly everything...🤷... what can I do?

    • @lukeparfums
      @lukeparfums  3 месяца назад +2

      Hi there! Thank you. The fragrances I’m interested in also tend to be better in their older versions, but I’m happy with some new formulas as well. It’s good to have variety.🙂 Thanks for watching!

  • @eauceylon1891
    @eauceylon1891 3 месяца назад +3

    Oh I love the hunt for vintages 😅

    • @lukeparfums
      @lukeparfums  3 месяца назад +1

      Oh, yes! It can be so exciting, especially when you accidentally come across something rare and affordable.🙂

  • @Brandee1218
    @Brandee1218 3 месяца назад +3

    Hello from Colorado! I just purchased a vintage (I believe) bottle of Dolce Vita because of your reviews. Hope it hasn’t gone off, no way to know until I get it. I found it on eBay for $70USD. So we’ll see. I’ve had some luck in purchasing vintage bottles, Champs Elysees, L’Interdit 2002-03 version, and Amarige. I bought a 15mL of L’Interdit 1978, but it had gone off completely. Wish me luck on DV! Love your videos!! ❤

    • @lukeparfums
      @lukeparfums  3 месяца назад +1

      Hi there! I think that’s a great price for a vintage bottle of Dolce Vita. Fingers crossed it’s in excellent condition! Thank you so much for trusting my opinion.🧡🙂Personally, I wouldn’t buy anything pre-'90s.

  • @n_a_phillips
    @n_a_phillips 3 месяца назад +4

    I enjoy buying used vintage bottles of perfumes. I find it's usally a much more cost-effective way to try a fragrance!

    • @lukeparfums
      @lukeparfums  3 месяца назад

      Second hand bottles are usually a great way to save money. Thanks for watching!🙂

  • @MyPerfumeMap
    @MyPerfumeMap 3 месяца назад +2

    I am excited to try the most current version of Spellbound. I really like both modern and vintage Estée Lauder. Great video!

    • @lukeparfums
      @lukeparfums  3 месяца назад +1

      I hope you enjoy it! I’m also really impressed with Estée Lauder’s classic fragrances that are still in production, especially Youth Dew, Cinnabar, and SpellBound. Thank you for watching!🙂

  • @fluffffyheart
    @fluffffyheart 2 месяца назад +2

    Sorry for the noob question when you say vintage you mean it was opened years ago,then never used? Or new but old formulation? Also, how many years can I keep my bottle?

    • @lukeparfums
      @lukeparfums  2 месяца назад +1

      @@fluffffyheart Don’t apologise, it’s a great question. Vintage perfumes and vintage bottles/formulas are not the same. In the video, I showed some actual vintage bottles which I bought sealed (some people buy them used, partial bottles), as well as some modern formulations of classic, “vintage” scents. I hope that explains it. Thanks for watching!🙂

  • @Zepster77
    @Zepster77 3 месяца назад +2

    Really love your clear & informative videos. Of course I’ve subbed ❤ keep up the good work 💪 you’re one of the few real ones

    • @lukeparfums
      @lukeparfums  3 месяца назад +1

      I really appreciate that. Thank you for subscribing!🙂🧡

  • @ednaquintana6201
    @ednaquintana6201 3 месяца назад

    Hi Luke. I like vintage perfumes like you. I have been watching a few videos from you and I just Subscribed to your channel. I own Ysatis and have a 1.7 oz. Vintage bottle. I have about 400 perfume bottles and have been collecting for four years since COVED started in 2020. I enjoy using them and learning about them. I like E-Bay as the Sellers pack the perfumes very carefully, and the come safely to my house with USPS. Take Care. 😊

    • @lukeparfums
      @lukeparfums  3 месяца назад +1

      Hello there and thank you so much for subscribing!🙂 400? That’s a huge collection. I like buying from eBay too but I always do a background check on the seller. Thanks for watching!🙂☀️

  • @brandusacatalinagrigore8017
    @brandusacatalinagrigore8017 3 месяца назад +2

    I have some a vintage bottles, and I like because classic perfumery is my favorite.

    • @lukeparfums
      @lukeparfums  3 месяца назад

      Classics are the best!🙂 Thanks for watching!

  • @lidypeters1813
    @lidypeters1813 3 месяца назад +1

    Thanks for this interesting video Luke, you've got a beautiful collection. I considered buying a vintage bottle of Dior Dune, and perhaps Y from YSL. After watching your video I realise I'm happy and satisfied with my current formulations from Dune, Allure etc.
    SOTD Dune, and Casmir in the evening after watching your video! I bought Casmir after you've talked about it in your video's. Greetings from the Netherlands.

    • @lukeparfums
      @lukeparfums  3 месяца назад +1

      Hello Lidy! Thank you for trusting my opinion. I’m glad you’re enjoying Casmir!🙂 I think that Dune and Allure are still beautiful; I wouldn’t go out of my way to acquire vintage bottles, but that’s just me. Thank you for stopping by today!🙂☀️

  • @Indecencealicia
    @Indecencealicia 3 месяца назад +1

    Love vintage and whatever smells good thanks for sharing

    • @lukeparfums
      @lukeparfums  3 месяца назад

      Me too! Thank you for stopping by today!🙂

  • @julieschnorenberg5370
    @julieschnorenberg5370 3 месяца назад +1

    Yes! I have vintage bottles of Paris YSL, tiny bottles of Yvresse, Miss Dior Cherie, Tresor. I feel lucky. I also have a vintage tester of Stella, which is one of my absolute favorites. Thanks so much, Luke!❤️🌹

    • @lukeparfums
      @lukeparfums  3 месяца назад

      Thanks for sharing!💖 I love or loved most of the ones you mentioned. You’re so lucky to have Stella! Thanks for watching!🙂

  • @ninosays
    @ninosays 3 месяца назад +3

    hm... i buy vintage bottles also because they can be cheaper than the new versions if you know how to look. it also depends where you live, i am certain. europe is just more expensive than the US and/because it is less saturated with older products. the new trade regulations, concerning shipping to and fro btw europe and the US, also make the market difference greater.
    true, some beloved older fragrances are so rare these days that the prices are crazy overinflated.
    i hope you don't mind if i point out that chopard's Cašmir is just a different spelling of Kashmir, and should be pronounced as such, as the diacritic on the 's' indicates. i also think it's fine getting the newer version of it. it is still beautiful if you like that scent profile.
    :-)

    • @lukeparfums
      @lukeparfums  3 месяца назад

      Hi there, I agree that the US market is more saturated with vintage products because certain perfumes may not be as popular here, but in my experience vintage bottle are usually not cheaper unless you’re really lucky and know where to look. But you never find what you’re looking for.
      I pronounced Cašmir the French way because Chopard is a Swiss company.
      Thanks for watching!🙂

    • @ninosays
      @ninosays 3 месяца назад +1

      ​@@lukeparfums​I can speak french and I normally pronounce french words as they should be pronounced (including dior's poison). Casmir is not a french word or spelling while it obviously refers to Kashmir, or shall i say Cachemire. again, the diacritic on the 'S' is clearly marked for a different pronunciation. my french friends in pondichery, india, 20 yrs ago pronounced it Cachemire. anyhow, this frag by Chopard is mofo legendary!!!

    • @AlliBaba1234
      @AlliBaba1234 Месяц назад

      @@ninosays ahem, it’s actually “Puducherry.” (I’m being facetious, Nino. She knows. It’s OK.)

  • @leahmiranda8359
    @leahmiranda8359 3 месяца назад +1

    Hi Luke!
    I got sidetracked in the middle of the video. 😢
    I have vintage bottles of Poison, Ysatis, Yvresse, and Dolce Vita. I have the current version of Tuscany.
    I’ve been very lucky with my vintage purchases. I’m not sure if I would risk purchasing vintage perfumes in the future. If I had never smelled the original, I wouldn’t know if my purchase was authentic, or if it had gone off.
    I’m going to enjoy both the vintage perfumes I have, and the other, more current perfumes that I love.
    Thank you for another unique, informative and enjoyable video. I always know I’ll have an interesting video to explore. 😊

    • @lukeparfums
      @lukeparfums  3 месяца назад +1

      Hi Leah! We’re definitely on the same page about vintage bottles. I love my vintage bottles but I’m not sure I’ll get any more anytime soon for the mentioned reasons. Thank you for your inspiring words!🙂🧡

  • @annoleary387
    @annoleary387 3 месяца назад +1

    Oh I remember Spellbound and Tuscany per Donna 😊 I didn't know that they still sold these. They are now on my wish list.

    • @lukeparfums
      @lukeparfums  3 месяца назад

      Hi there. Tuscany has been discontinued just recently, but SpellBound is still sold. Thanks for watching!🙂

  • @Aussiegirl1972
    @Aussiegirl1972 3 месяца назад +1

    I’d love to get a vintage formulation of Trésor as I have the reformulated bottle. it’s ok but it does not smell as good or the same as the old formulation. You’ve got some good ones there Luke. 😊

    • @lukeparfums
      @lukeparfums  3 месяца назад +1

      Hi there! I heard that the vintage formula is much nicer but I do like the reformulated Trésor as well. Thanks for watching!🙂

  • @laurieeyebee
    @laurieeyebee 3 месяца назад +2

    I think you did great. Hypnotic Poison was my signature scent and after I used it up, I kept the bottle for a long time just so I could sniff it. I am going to try to get one on ebay also, if I'm going to spend big money I'd like vintage.

    • @lukeparfums
      @lukeparfums  3 месяца назад

      Thank you! Hypnotic Poison is absolutely gorgeous. If you really love a certain fragrance, might as well get the vintage formula.🙂 Thanks for watching!

  • @neekromancer
    @neekromancer 3 месяца назад +1

    I neeeed to try that Tuscany. I have a .5 oz dabber of Tuscany Per Uomo from 1990 and it's my favorite with a capital avorite.

    • @lukeparfums
      @lukeparfums  3 месяца назад

      That’s amazing! Not many people know about the two versions of Tuscany. Thanks for watching!🙂

  • @H.A.-zr2wc
    @H.A.-zr2wc 3 месяца назад +3

    Again a lovely video💖💖 I'm often happy perfumes i love still excist but i would never buy current Samsara. I also am going to cherish my OG Jil Sander No4 and use up my current bottle instead. I wont buy it again. Estee Lauder does a good job!

    • @lukeparfums
      @lukeparfums  3 месяца назад +2

      Hi there! Thanks🧡 I know you love your vintage Samsara and Jil Sander No. 4. My supply of Samsara has run out and I really don’t know what to do.

    • @H.A.-zr2wc
      @H.A.-zr2wc 3 месяца назад +1

      @@lukeparfums The only perfumes i wouldnt recommend to you are ashtray chypres because now i know you struggle with that note, but maybe you should try Samsara and decide for yourself. All i can say is please dont blind buy.

    • @lukeparfums
      @lukeparfums  3 месяца назад +2

      I do struggle with ashtray chypres, but I enjoy Cabochard from time to time. I really liked it when I got it in January but I wouldn’t wear it in the summer. I’m not sure we understood each other - I love Samsara! I used up two bee bottles, a 50ml and a 30ml. I also have a small decant of the vintage. Does the new version go ashtray on you?🤔

    • @H.A.-zr2wc
      @H.A.-zr2wc 3 месяца назад +2

      @@lukeparfums No no i meant i would try my best to advice you because apart from ashtray chypres (i absolutely love them) we share a similar taste in perfumes. But i really dont like current Samsara, it really needs the oldschool sandalwood. To me its just not worth the money anymore

    • @lukeparfums
      @lukeparfums  3 месяца назад +2

      @@H.A.-zr2wc I misunderstood, sorry. You’re so right. The real sandalwood extract was replaced by a synthetic alternative. Did you like the one in the bee bottle?

  • @evelynschau229
    @evelynschau229 3 месяца назад +1

    Hi Luke , I'm looking for a dupe of Fendi ..do you have any ideas?

    • @lukeparfums
      @lukeparfums  3 месяца назад

      Hi Evelyn! I wish I could help you. I’ve not tried that one, but I know it’s very sought-after.😕

    • @evelynschau229
      @evelynschau229 3 месяца назад +1

      @@lukeparfums thanks Luke . It's from the 90's but sadly discontinued. I'll keep my nose at it , keep on looking!

  • @Hogyisne
    @Hogyisne 3 месяца назад

    If I could I would buy mostly vintage. I have problems with the reformulated Casmir's longevity and projection, unfortunately. I have the reformulated Yvresse, and I love it. If I come across the vintage for a reasonable price, I will buy it.

    • @lukeparfums
      @lukeparfums  3 месяца назад +1

      On me it lasts quite well. Vintage Yvresse is glorious. Thanks for sharing your thoughts.🙂

  • @L-Ondee
    @L-Ondee 3 месяца назад +1

    Oh yes, definitely! I do own vintage perfumes. Classic perfumery is my favourite. But I have to say if I can get a classic in an acceptable modern version I usually prefer that one. All perfumes change with time, even if they have been stored properly. Their performance often weakens they don't last as long as a newer version and the top notes often loose their sparkling qualities. I still am very happy about some discontinued gems I own and which are in pretty good shape. Dior Dior, My Sin and Après l'Ondée extrait being the biggest treasures, and all 3 are in very good shape considering their age. I am also longing for the original version of Byzance which was the first perfume I ever wore, but prices have skyrocketed so much that I will probably not find one which I will want to buy.

    • @lukeparfums
      @lukeparfums  3 месяца назад +1

      When something is discontinued, there’s no other option but to get a vintage bottle. I also prefer acceptable modern versions if I can find them. Yes, that sparkling opening often disappears completely with age. You’ve got some amazing gems! I’ve noticed the same about Byzance; prices on eBay are crazy! I wish I bought it 5 years ago when they were still normal. Thank you for sharing your thoughts on vintage formulations.

  • @Abeautifultorch
    @Abeautifultorch 3 месяца назад

    Your voice and accent simply beautiful ❤

    • @lukeparfums
      @lukeparfums  3 месяца назад

      You’re so kind. Thank you!🧡

  • @ednaquintana6201
    @ednaquintana6201 3 месяца назад

    Hi. I own Casmir also. You like it, but it is not my favorite. Thank you for talking about Alyssa Ashley Vanilla, and I just bought two bottles from E-Bay for a very good price. I have bought in the last few days about 6 perfumes that I am looking forward to receiving them from E-Bay. I have been enjoying vanilla fragrances lately. I have a few bottles of Alyssa Ashley Musk, which I wore when I was younger and wearing it, brings back memories. Take Care. 😊

    • @lukeparfums
      @lukeparfums  3 месяца назад

      I love Alyssa Ashley vanilla. It’s sweet, soft, and comforting. The musk one is said to be similar to Jovan Musk. How exciting! Have a great weekend!🙂

  • @singerstylistjennifer1654
    @singerstylistjennifer1654 3 месяца назад +2

    Hey there Luke- so I acquired a vintage bottle of Betsy Johnson's original perfume... Hello Girlfriend. It may have gone off but I put it in my fridge to try and save or bring back that original memory!! Have you had luck "bringing back" an expired scent?

    • @lukeparfums
      @lukeparfums  3 месяца назад +2

      Hi there! That’s a great tip. Were you successful? No, no luck. The only expired fragrance that I had was Miss Dior Chérie. I noticed that it started to smell a little musty, so I used it up before it went off completely.

  • @dr.claire.perfume
    @dr.claire.perfume 3 месяца назад +1

    My own experience has been mixed; most really great, others missing top notes. I'd not hesitate buying vintage if I knew there had been changes.

    • @lukeparfums
      @lukeparfums  3 месяца назад

      @@dr.claire.perfume It’s always a bit of a gamble, isn’t it? I think I got lucky with all the vintage bottles I bought. Yes, I agree; even if it means only getting the previous version. Thanks for stopping by!🙂

    • @lukeparfums
      @lukeparfums  3 месяца назад

      @@dr.claire.perfume It’s always a bit of a gamble, isn’t it? I think I got lucky with all the vintage bottles I bought. Yes, I agree; even if it means only getting the previous version. Thanks for stopping by!🙂

  • @sophialee2630
    @sophialee2630 3 месяца назад +4

    No, I don’t buy vintage bottles but I still miss those oldies but goodies.

    • @lukeparfums
      @lukeparfums  3 месяца назад +1

      Oldies but goodies they are indeed. Thanks for watching!🙂

  • @sueparnell3818
    @sueparnell3818 3 месяца назад +1

    I purchased 2 old school perfumes on the grey market, recommended by influencer, not original vintage, I think the current reincarnations are heavily watered down and don't smell anything like the originals, I will not purchase again no smell whatsoever, I've been told that perfumes lose their performance after about 5 years, so I wouldn't risk a vintage.

    • @lukeparfums
      @lukeparfums  3 месяца назад

      Wait, you received fakes? That’s awful. Yes, many scents have been reformulated and watered down, unfortunately. Thanks for watching!

    • @sueparnell3818
      @sueparnell3818 3 месяца назад +1

      @@lukeparfums No sorry not fakes, perfumes that are still available but the DNA or original formulation much weaker.