@@AdamHill1234 lol WOT books where way ahead of their time in terms of female characters, magic system and world building above all. Whilst a few books in the middle messed up the story a good wee bit, and the characters where a bit too simple and black and white, - the ambition and scope of this series will place it in the history books forever. Only thing that has made fantasy progress since then has been Steven Erikson and most people don't even know who he is. Sanderson is an unreal author but unoriginal and his romance and relationships are so bad.
@@AdamHill1234I have an honest question for you. No ill will intended. Why did you feel the need to say ASOFAI is better than WOT? It serves no purpose other than to put something else down after he expressed his wish for a premium WOT edition. I hope you respond but if not, no worries.
I hate these moments! Knowing I have enough money in my account to afford these works of art, but debating back and forth with myself about whether or not to buy it.
I know the exact feeling.. I debated this for about 5 months. A moment ago I saw it secondhand for a very high price, which gave me a scare that it might have been sold out. The scare I felt convinced me that I simply needed to buy it. (i justify it that it may be more valuable in 30 years. Its an investment.. xD) Did you buy it yet?
@@michielsoons2560 I understand what you mean. I meant to buy the first book when it got released in July 2019 but then I cancelled my pre-order to buy other things. But now I will buy them, one per month for the next three months. I fear they might be discontinued and they clearly are an investment. They won’t lose value over time, quite the opposite. And they look majestic.
You've convinced me to get this. I already have two copies of A Game of Thrones, but this one looks very nice. The binding is reminiscent of their Call of Cthulhu edition.
I have the book in my lap right now, but I had to watch your presentation on it. I actually like the illustrations - especially the Dany horse heart one. I hope they keep him on for continuity, and I hope all the books have the same or similar price range. I can’t go much higher.
Apparently these were Folio’s best selling books last year in 2019. I have my copies of this and Clash of Kings, they’re beautiful but I’m afraid to scratch the foil inlays on the front!
The letters in this book are so crisp they actually bring me joy! Curious to hear your thoughts on it, Pontus, but that'll have to wait till tomorrow ;-)
Excellent review and production 👍 Wonderful series, one of my favorites of all time. The illustrations where not as gritty as the writing. The illustrations for "Fire and Blood" and the 20th anniversary of GOT by Bantam are superior.
Should I go with this or the leatherbound Harper Voyager editions? I love Folio Society, and would've definitely bought this as soon as it came out if not for the fact that I just decided to pick up the leatherbound version of _A Game of Thrones._ I think that one is a really nice edition, despite pages being a bit thin, but I'm unsure as to whether I should stick with the leatherbound books or drop those and go with Folio Society. On one hand it would be really nice having a series of real classic-looking books in red leather, as I don't have or plan on getting any other leatherbound books anytime soon (though I don't know how the books will age), on the other hand... Folio Society. I love everything they do, all their books, their passion... and I think the book itself _does_ look rather nice too, of course. Harper Voyager/Collins (I believe they're practically the same, no?) I don't really have any experience with, but I'm thinking they've gotta be a reputable/good publisher if they're the ones publishing Tolkien and ASoIaF.
You could do what I did and get both! The red leatherbound editions are high quality and look and feel great. The paper stock is much thinner than folio, but that isn't a bad thing in my view. They also have some nice illustrations. Overall the Folio edition has more bells and whistles, but then it's nearly 3 times as expensive.
Have not bought either but I'm leaning towards the Harper Collins since I prefer the more simple title text on the spine more than the stylistic font on Folio's, for when they are displayed on the shelf. But I suggest you wait till the other books are announced as a month or two ago, I emailed Harper Collins and they are unsure if the last two books will be in the same red leatherbound design. And if you recall, Harper did a blue slipcase version prior to the red ones.
In my experience of buying many editions of the game of thrones has always met me with disappointment. The Leather ones are not real leather and contain thin paper. These are not the quality of the Children of Hurin in leather. Folio is more expensive but the paper quality and its textured surface is organic enough for me. Wonderful design with my only critique being the cloth bounding. But as they are doing the full series and making it affordable it is understandable. If money is not object you could go for the Subterranean books signed and numbered. I had a copy but sadly sold it. The there is the holy grail. The Meisha Merlin lettered edition. Now i have not seen one of those on ebay for a long time.
@@andyrobinson2653 one thing I like about these editions is they fit the books in one volume rather than split them. To do that you need thin paper. It's a design decision, nothing to do with paper quality.
@@Uppernorwood976 A design decision for yourself. But the Harper cannot match the paper quality and text of the folio. If you want it in one volume then fine. But this is about cost not design. Hence price difference. I like Harper but for the edition mentioned I would pass.
The book in itself is mazing! I'm so undecided about this one tho, because the series is not finished so I'm hesitant, not sure whether to buy it or not
I understand you, though Folio has said they have the rights to print all of A Song of Ice and Fire, including the unpublished sixth and seventh books. It is likely a book per year given the time for illustrations, etc., so book six won't be published by Folio until 2024. Of course, that is if the sixth book is out then. The big worry is book seven, but I fear one more book might be needed as well.
Really debated getting this edition but i already have too many editions of the series! I have a full set of the Deluxe Red Slipcases which give me a great shelf presence, and the illustrated edition(s) are just packed with quality illustrations. Still, I am glad you picked this up and were able to share. I love books printed in multiple ink colours.
Great video (with perfect music). Is the cloth (on the spine and back) reflective? It looks as if it is shimmering between two colors (a wine red and a bluish silver).
Really torn about this. The edition looks amazing and I enjoyed GoT very much. But I found the later books (especially starting from A Feast for Crows) to be impossibly tedious so I can't see myself wanting to buy more than the first few in the series. Do I really need the first quarter of a series of £125 books I read before?
I couldn't agree more! I loved the first book, and enjoyed the series less and less as it went on. I think that he lost control of his vision and over-complicated it, going on and on and on....By about the fourth book I just didn't care what happened to any of the characters any more so I gave it up. No way I'll be investing in this series, however nice the edition is.
Just curious do you know if this is a limited amount printed or will there be more than the first run printed?? Just ordered this version as I love it but I am hoping I get a first printing but I don't know if they were planning on more than just the first print run. I tried googling but couldn't find any info. Do you have any ideas on this please?? I didn't know about it till today when I came accross it by accident. Thanks so much for your help!
Hi there! I'm sure that they will do more print runs in the future, but I don't know how large the first one were (I'd assume rather large). I doubt Folio Society would allow this edition to run out of print before the whole series is completed (assuming once again that it is selling quite well). :-)
@@PontusPresents Thanks that totally makes sense! Hoping I get a first edition but we shall see when it arrives as its been posted out to me now. So excited for this and can't wait to hopefully preorder each of the series in advance in the future. Guess you could say I am a bit of a collector of books and only just discovered folio society by accident :)
@@RebeccasColouringArtandCrafts Make sure to check out my other Folio Society Reviews then for insipiration! I have uploaded a lot of different editions. :-)
@@PontusPresents Thanks will do. My edition is a second edition so you were right. Was kinda hoping for a first edition but guess they will keep printing them for now till the rest are all released. Going to try and save so I can preorder the second when it comes around :) Thanks
Also check out the 20th Anniversary edition of A Game of Thrones if you haven't already. Those illustrations are gorgeous. Especially the ones by Magali Villeneuve. They're following suit with Clash next albeit with a new younger talent.
I agree. And I’m not a big fan of the close up of the faces. I feel they should be left to the reader to imagine and might at worst clash with ones interpretation and distract from the story. Some of the illustrations also remind me of the Harry Potter illustrated editions. Probably because of the “cartoonish” vibes. The illustrations for Lotr are often aerial and doesn’t show the characters too clearly, with obvious exceptions, and I think this would have been a better way to illustrate these books as well. Still very beautiful books and I’m thinking about getting these.
Hm...I dont know 8:55 Daenerys looks fucking creepy. Sure you probably dont look most attractive while eating a raw heart but still. Shes described as the most beautiful woman in the world, but here she looks like the creepy girl from a horror movie
oh god, why the fuck must I be from a third world country!!!! Hahaha, that just looks so incredible buy I sure as shit can't afford it, unless I don't buy any other books or games or films the rest of the year. I also really like the American gods edition, they're so beautiful.
I've just completed reading the 3rd book in the series. I must say that FS seems to have put a lot of creative effort in designing the books. The various illustrations, detail of imagery, envelope on top of another envelope and a map booklet??! Yes, the hype. As an avid fantasy reader in my youth mostly, I can say A Game of Thrones makes for a decent reading here and there, some nice moments of good writing in otherwise a desert of the mediocre. FS edition looks better and surely more magical than the story itself.
They are beautiful but this review says nothing about the price. At close to £100 per volume with single books split into two, for a large and unfinished series, I'm out. If you have £1,500+ to throw at it then go for it but I'm not paying that much for ANY books. At least they didn't make them Folio numbered editions which would have made them about £500 for each slip case.
They’re beautiful, I wish I could spare the money to buy them. Though if Folio ever did The Wheel of Time I don’t think I could pass that one up.
I would buy too.
Same with stormlight archive
ASOIAF is far superior to Wheel of Time anyway. Phenomenal books
@@AdamHill1234 lol WOT books where way ahead of their time in terms of female characters, magic system and world building above all. Whilst a few books in the middle messed up the story a good wee bit, and the characters where a bit too simple and black and white, - the ambition and scope of this series will place it in the history books forever. Only thing that has made fantasy progress since then has been Steven Erikson and most people don't even know who he is. Sanderson is an unreal author but unoriginal and his romance and relationships are so bad.
@@AdamHill1234I have an honest question for you. No ill will intended. Why did you feel the need to say ASOFAI is better than WOT? It serves no purpose other than to put something else down after he expressed his wish for a premium WOT edition. I hope you respond but if not, no worries.
I hate these moments! Knowing I have enough money in my account to afford these works of art, but debating back and forth with myself about whether or not to buy it.
Even harder when the series isn’t finished
I know the exact feeling.. I debated this for about 5 months. A moment ago I saw it secondhand for a very high price, which gave me a scare that it might have been sold out. The scare I felt convinced me that I simply needed to buy it.
(i justify it that it may be more valuable in 30 years. Its an investment.. xD)
Did you buy it yet?
@@michielsoons2560 I understand what you mean. I meant to buy the first book when it got released in July 2019 but then I cancelled my pre-order to buy other things. But now I will buy them, one per month for the next three months. I fear they might be discontinued and they clearly are an investment. They won’t lose value over time, quite the opposite. And they look majestic.
Some of those illustrations are gorgeous. I've yet to read the sONG OF fire and Ice series.
You've convinced me to get this. I already have two copies of A Game of Thrones, but this one looks very nice. The binding is reminiscent of their Call of Cthulhu edition.
I have the book in my lap right now, but I had to watch your presentation on it. I actually like the illustrations - especially the Dany horse heart one. I hope they keep him on for continuity, and I hope all the books have the same or similar price range. I can’t go much higher.
Apparently these were Folio’s best selling books last year in 2019. I have my copies of this and Clash of Kings, they’re beautiful but I’m afraid to scratch the foil inlays on the front!
This edition is lovely! Thank you for doing a review!
And thank you for watching! )
I have all 4...amazing. Trying different ideas to display them.
I'm just waiting for Brandon Sanderson to finish this series in 2124 before I commit to buying this full set.
I'm waiting to see how George R.R. Martin ends the series.
The letters in this book are so crisp they actually bring me joy! Curious to hear your thoughts on it, Pontus, but that'll have to wait till tomorrow ;-)
aah yea.. I was waiting for this one ;) even tho I already received my own. Your vids make them look even better haha
Excellent review and production 👍 Wonderful series, one of my favorites of all time. The illustrations where not as gritty as the writing. The illustrations for "Fire and Blood" and the 20th anniversary of GOT by Bantam are superior.
Just.. beautiful.
Should I go with this or the leatherbound Harper Voyager editions? I love Folio Society, and would've definitely bought this as soon as it came out if not for the fact that I just decided to pick up the leatherbound version of _A Game of Thrones._ I think that one is a really nice edition, despite pages being a bit thin, but I'm unsure as to whether I should stick with the leatherbound books or drop those and go with Folio Society.
On one hand it would be really nice having a series of real classic-looking books in red leather, as I don't have or plan on getting any other leatherbound books anytime soon (though I don't know how the books will age), on the other hand... Folio Society. I love everything they do, all their books, their passion... and I think the book itself _does_ look rather nice too, of course. Harper Voyager/Collins (I believe they're practically the same, no?) I don't really have any experience with, but I'm thinking they've gotta be a reputable/good publisher if they're the ones publishing Tolkien and ASoIaF.
You could do what I did and get both! The red leatherbound editions are high quality and look and feel great. The paper stock is much thinner than folio, but that isn't a bad thing in my view. They also have some nice illustrations. Overall the Folio edition has more bells and whistles, but then it's nearly 3 times as expensive.
Have not bought either but I'm leaning towards the Harper Collins since I prefer the more simple title text on the spine more than the stylistic font on Folio's, for when they are displayed on the shelf. But I suggest you wait till the other books are announced as a month or two ago, I emailed Harper Collins and they are unsure if the last two books will be in the same red leatherbound design. And if you recall, Harper did a blue slipcase version prior to the red ones.
In my experience of buying many editions of the game of thrones has always met me with disappointment. The Leather ones are not real leather and contain thin paper. These are not the quality of the Children of Hurin in leather. Folio is more expensive but the paper quality and its textured surface is organic enough for me. Wonderful design with my only critique being the cloth bounding. But as they are doing the full series and making it affordable it is understandable. If money is not object you could go for the Subterranean books signed and numbered. I had a copy but sadly sold it. The there is the holy grail. The Meisha Merlin lettered edition. Now i have not seen one of those on ebay for a long time.
@@andyrobinson2653 one thing I like about these editions is they fit the books in one volume rather than split them. To do that you need thin paper. It's a design decision, nothing to do with paper quality.
@@Uppernorwood976 A design decision for yourself. But the Harper cannot match the paper quality and text of the folio. If you want it in one volume then fine. But this is about cost not design. Hence price difference. I like Harper but for the edition mentioned I would pass.
AM stoked, I don't even like Game of Thrones but if I can get others who do into FS editions I'll be happy
The book in itself is mazing! I'm so undecided about this one tho, because the series is not finished so I'm hesitant, not sure whether to buy it or not
I understand you, though Folio has said they have the rights to print all of A Song of Ice and Fire, including the unpublished sixth and seventh books. It is likely a book per year given the time for illustrations, etc., so book six won't be published by Folio until 2024. Of course, that is if the sixth book is out then. The big worry is book seven, but I fear one more book might be needed as well.
@@Markadown that's my logic also
I just ordered mine 🤩
Really debated getting this edition but i already have too many editions of the series! I have a full set of the Deluxe Red Slipcases which give me a great shelf presence, and the illustrated edition(s) are just packed with quality illustrations. Still, I am glad you picked this up and were able to share. I love books printed in multiple ink colours.
Well if there ever existed such thing as book porn, this would probably be it
*Wolf whistles* Oooh baby, look at that binding! TIGHT!
This is the edition that I love the most. Wont be able to afford it tho :(
Great video (with perfect music). Is the cloth (on the spine and back) reflective? It looks as if it is shimmering between two colors (a wine red and a bluish silver).
It does, yes! It’s a duo-tone cloth. :-)
stunning!
Really torn about this. The edition looks amazing and I enjoyed GoT very much. But I found the later books (especially starting from A Feast for Crows) to be impossibly tedious so I can't see myself wanting to buy more than the first few in the series. Do I really need the first quarter of a series of £125 books I read before?
I couldn't agree more! I loved the first book, and enjoyed the series less and less as it went on. I think that he lost control of his vision and over-complicated it, going on and on and on....By about the fourth book I just didn't care what happened to any of the characters any more so I gave it up. No way I'll be investing in this series, however nice the edition is.
Thx for this. At least we get to see it if a lot of us aren't prepared to shell out £125.
I have this, it is a pleasure to read it!
do a video review of a clash of kings when you buy it!!
Next Saturday :-)
@@PontusPresents nice! thank you!
@@PontusPresents nice! thank you!
Just curious do you know if this is a limited amount printed or will there be more than the first run printed?? Just ordered this version as I love it but I am hoping I get a first printing but I don't know if they were planning on more than just the first print run. I tried googling but couldn't find any info. Do you have any ideas on this please?? I didn't know about it till today when I came accross it by accident. Thanks so much for your help!
Hi there! I'm sure that they will do more print runs in the future, but I don't know how large the first one were (I'd assume rather large). I doubt Folio Society would allow this edition to run out of print before the whole series is completed (assuming once again that it is selling quite well). :-)
@@PontusPresents Thanks that totally makes sense! Hoping I get a first edition but we shall see when it arrives as its been posted out to me now. So excited for this and can't wait to hopefully preorder each of the series in advance in the future. Guess you could say I am a bit of a collector of books and only just discovered folio society by accident :)
@@RebeccasColouringArtandCrafts Make sure to check out my other Folio Society Reviews then for insipiration! I have uploaded a lot of different editions. :-)
@@PontusPresents Thanks will do. My edition is a second edition so you were right. Was kinda hoping for a first edition but guess they will keep printing them for now till the rest are all released. Going to try and save so I can preorder the second when it comes around :) Thanks
Also check out the 20th Anniversary edition of A Game of Thrones if you haven't already. Those illustrations are gorgeous. Especially the ones by Magali Villeneuve. They're following suit with Clash next albeit with a new younger talent.
I really like it
The Covers of this editon look amazing, but I'm not a fan of the illustrations. Maybe I don't get it but they look like fan art and amateurish to me.
I do share your opinion on the illustrations to a degree. Some of them look good while others come of as "amateurish".
I agree. And I’m not a big fan of the close up of the faces. I feel they should be left to the reader to imagine and might at worst clash with ones interpretation and distract from the story. Some of the illustrations also remind me of the Harry Potter illustrated editions. Probably because of the “cartoonish” vibes.
The illustrations for Lotr are often aerial and doesn’t show the characters too clearly, with obvious exceptions, and I think this would have been a better way to illustrate these books as well.
Still very beautiful books and I’m thinking about getting these.
This guy is wrong about the art
Some of the best I have seen. Great layout. The night king looks cool..
Best 195$ I've ever spent
Hm...I dont know 8:55 Daenerys looks fucking creepy. Sure you probably dont look most attractive while eating a raw heart but still. Shes described as the most beautiful woman in the world, but here she looks like the creepy girl from a horror movie
oh god, why the fuck must I be from a third world country!!!! Hahaha, that just looks so incredible buy I sure as shit can't afford it, unless I don't buy any other books or games or films the rest of the year. I also really like the American gods edition, they're so beautiful.
I've just completed reading the 3rd book in the series. I must say that FS seems to have put a lot of creative effort in designing the books. The various illustrations, detail of imagery, envelope on top of another envelope and a map booklet??! Yes, the hype. As an avid fantasy reader in my youth mostly, I can say A Game of Thrones makes for a decent reading here and there, some nice moments of good writing in otherwise a desert of the mediocre. FS edition looks better and surely more magical than the story itself.
😱😱😱😱😱😱
They are beautiful but this review says nothing about the price. At close to £100 per volume with single books split into two, for a large and unfinished series, I'm out. If you have £1,500+ to throw at it then go for it but I'm not paying that much for ANY books. At least they didn't make them Folio numbered editions which would have made them about £500 for each slip case.
But they are so worth it because of the quality.
Overpriced