A New PS3 Controller That's Actually Good?
HTML-код
- Опубликовано: 18 фев 2023
- For a while I've been looking for an alternative controller for the PlayStation 3 and today we're looking at one that has the same functionality as the original but with better ergonomics and feel. Do we finally have a solid replacement for the DualShock 3?
PS3 Defender Controller: retrofighters.com/our-collect...
Spawncast Jerseys: bit.ly/3sZKrgj
Spawncast Spotify: open.spotify.com/show/41qKKRu...
News Wave edited by: @KimerexProjekt
Second Channel: / @spawnwaveplus6991
Spawncast Clips: / @spawncastnetwork
Twitter: @SpawnWaveMedia
Spawn Wave Merch: teespring.com/stores/spawnwav...
Consider Supporting Us On Patreon: / spawnwave
Follow Us On Twitch: / spawnwavemedia
Listen To Our Weekly Podcast: / spawn-wave
Like Comment and Subscribe!
Thanks for watching!
#PS3 #PlayStation #Sony 
Игры
I don’t think enough people realize how much of a game changer this might be. DualShock 3s that are in good condition and work are hard to come by. The best 3rd party controller for it(the ps3 afterglow) doesn’t even have sixaxis. Making it impossible to play some games. Just ordered. Hope it’s good.
You opinion?
Was it?
Did you get it?
How is it?
@@Jahycore Imo it's not worth the money. The design is terrible and it doesn't function nearly as well as an actual DS3. (e.g sticks have noticeably bigger dead zones)
What I don’t like about the ps3 controller is how you can’t charge it with the ps3 if the system is off/on standby since it had to do the data handshake too
It depends on the type of charger. I have the stand and can charge it that way. It's dependent on the type of cable input going into the controller.
I remember there being a lot of complaints about the DS3 back in day. Sony had been using the same controller virtually unchanged for a decade and three console gens at that point, so it was getting a bit long in the tooth. Most of the gripes seemed to have been around it being too light and too small. I personally didn't have a problem with it, other than the thumb sticks not being indented. That and it has to be plugged into a USB with an active data signal, or else it won't charge. With third party controllers, I distinctly remember Sony pushing out a firmware update that broke a lot of them. I had a third party Rock Band guitar that stopped working after that.
I've been considering the brook since it allows you to use dualshock / dualsense with these same features. This looks like another great option as well. Nice to see more options for PS3 since the dualshock 3 genuine controllers can be somewhat expensive
I have a brook it's absolutely the best! It allows all functions even backwards compatibility with PS2 games works! The only thing you can't do is power on the PS3 with it
I also recommend it. I hate that it is pink and is a bit loose when plugged in, but it works with all games, XMB works, and it feels great playing a DS4 on the PS3 wirelessly.
I would want to get the Brook since I have a few controllers I like to use on PS4.
@@dolurosu there amount of games that actually require pressure sensitive buttons is minuscule. You can beat like 95% of ps2+ps3 library without it.
DS3 (for those 5%) + Brook adapter and a PROPER controller (ds4 or ds5) is a and more versatile better option.
@@Psmgamer You can get the Magic-S adapter, same thing and alot cheaper
This is a remarkably impressive effort; great that it has sixaxis and pressure sensitivity support - there are plenty of games that are actually unplayable without those features.
Impressive compatibility, too.
Definitely room to expand that battery dramatically, though, and it's lacking nice extra features like mappable back buttons... and the big one, not using Hall Effect sticks.
Hopefully if they don't improve this further, it will be the catalyst for someone like 8bitdo to bring out a competitor that does make those changes.
hall effect sticks are a reddit trend
@@zkdr6278 Hall effect sticks are a solution to a mechanical problem that I and others had been advocating for WELL before the first current ones hit the market. Not just a "Reddit Trend"... whatever that's supposed to mean.
@@TheDanaAddams I know I was just joking. I want them on everything too. I don't know why it isn't easy to just make a replacement for several different types of controllers that uses hall effect instead of potentiometers
@@zkdr6278 The primary issues are going to be interfacing and fitment. To make a drop-in replacement for old pot-based sticks, you need a piece with the same footprint and range of motion. From my understanding, it's reasonably simple to convert the signals from Hall sticks to what is expected from the pots, so that's not a huge problem... but it's not very practical for a business to manufacture a new Hall stick unit to the larger standard of older controllers, and making the smaller ones designed for modern controllers work in the space that expects a larger unit and greater travel is going to require complicated calculations of unit placement and adaptor interfaces to raise the distance from the pivot and correct the arc of the stick so it works without shell modifications or just feeling awkward and uncomfortable to use.
@Dana The Elf It's literally just a marketing buzzword. Not because it has hall effect sticks, it means the controller will never drift.
Glad to hear all the features work properly. I just got their Brawler64 NSO controller and I'm pretty happy with it, and your review makes me even more confident in their products. Gonna have to snag me some of those Defenders at some point.
Thanks for showing this controller been trying to find a solution for the PS3 six axis. I've had so many PS2 PS3 controllers break down from analog issues. I'll be looking into getting one of these next month along with the n64 replacement.
Did you get it?
I had a Ghost Recon theamed controller, it had a dongle but the thing i liked about it was the extra programable back buttons meant in twisted metal I could spin on the spot and shoot missiles at the same time giving me an unfair advantage over my friends.
Thanks for this Spawn Wave. good functional PS3 controllers have been very hard to find for the past two decades. I will be picking these up for my PS3 and thr older n model version for my ps1 and ps2
FINALLY! A decent PS3 controller and it only took 16 years! I just wonder how long those sticks will hold up before stick drift sets in.
*I had 3 different PS3s from day 1 of release up until now. I've only owned 6 controllers. 2 for each console. I've only owned 3 after-market controllers for the PS3. NONE have given me stick drift.*
@asmongoldsmouth9839 correct sir. 1 thing all PS3 controllers suffer with is massive dead zone on the analog sticks
Damn, fully compatible? Makes me wish I waited for a 60GB replacement back in 2009. When I talked to Sony on the phone, they said the wait for a refurbished 60GB like my launch one, would take 5-6 months. I was addicted to CoD back then and couldn't afford buying a new one.
The wait for a 80GB at the time was 1-2 months which ended up being a lie. I went for it since it was quicker but it arrived in 5 days! I should've chose a 60GB. But at least I still own my 80GB. So beautiful. I keep it boxed as I have a PS3 Slim I bought years later.
I backed this on Kickstarter (2.4GHz) and like it a lot. Downfalls are that the d-pad is just ok and the trigger buttons are way too sensitive. The dongle will allow you to play wirelessly on the PC too, where I use it a lot. Don't think it has Sixaxis though.
The 2.4 GHz with the dongle doesn't, but the new bluetooth model does.
I use this Retro Fighters controller for the PS2.
It has USB C and very nice in my hands.
My only problem is that it feels way too light, after gaming on the Dualsense so much, its definitely noticable how light the PS2 retro Fighters controller feels.
could do what some cheap speaker companies do and hot glue some weights inside XD
@@VEN0M415 I put clay inside my cheapo controllers that I smash every month or two when they die. (Cheapo as in 2.50-3.00 $ cheapo controllers)
That's the thing isn't it, what is it about weight that makes a controller feel more premium. I feel the exact same but I can't explain what it is other than the fact that anytime I've used a basically light seemingly empty controller it's almost always garbage.
Then get an adapter and use your PS5 controllers with it, it's only like $20/$25
@@JohnDoe-wq5eu Dualsense feels amazing..it has just the right amount of weight to feel great in my hands.
The retro fighters controller feels empty.
Thats the best way I can describe it.
Dude! You have no idea how long I have been looking for a controller like this! Thank you so much!
You literally did the review i always wanted on this controller and awnsered every question i had for it thank you
I will definitely buy 4 of these now
I’ve a huge fan of your channel for like a year or so, and I’ve been searching for a PS3 controller for almost 3 years now. Decided to search RUclips on a whim and found this and I am so thankful I could cry 😭 I have almost 40 PS3 games from my teenage years I’ve been trying to play with no success… very excited!
Honestly, I've been waiting for a good dualshock 3 replacement since both of mine stopped working. All I've had for the last 6 years is a wired power A controller with pressure sensitive buttons, which is nice, but it doesn't have sixaxis or rumble make some games less enjoyable. I might give this controller a shot when I get the chance.
I'm just glad it has pressure sensitive buttons. That's something that these retro controllers tend to miss like the last controller that had PS1/PS2/PS3 Defender controller and not the new bluetooth one. I'm glad they came out with this bluetooth one for real
I have the original Defender and I love using it on my PS2 and PS3. They sit side by side so it's easy to have a dongle in each and it just connects to what is powered on. I don't necessarily need six axis
The most important thing does it have Sixaxis without that you can't play some games.
Seems like a great option for emulation. I love playing PS2 games on my PC and Steam Deck but the lack of pressure sensitivity makes it a bust, and the fact that I'm not so hot on the feel of the PS controllers for the most part makes me not want to buy a (likely used, and in need of repair) DS3 controller just for emulation compatibility
The controller is HORRIBLE, the bumpers are 99% unresponsive, it’s harder to press the analog sticks, and sometimes the analog sticks bug out if u move them too fast
😬😬
7:10 I remember you perform aereal combos and direct projectiles in Heavenly Sword via sixaxis.
Some games released early in that generation tried to implement "the novel" function the PS3 had (I wish they didn't, it ended up being a mistake). So even though it's really not relevant nor appealing, if you don't have a controller with a sixaxis you miss part of some game's experience.
now this is something i could see getting in the future, since my ps3 will be played after i go through homebrew on wii. ima need more space on ps3 tho, tb or 2
If anything I would probably try to hunt down a later revision PS3 Controller to gut the insides and put into a nicer shell.
Later revisions of the Dualshock 3 had magnetic sensors instead of the standard potentiometer.
Finally a reliable youtuber covering this controller! Nice!
I'd love to see Retro-Fighters or 8bitdo do a modern reimplementation of the Gamecube controller, fully bluetooth & authentic to the original
Same, as 8bitdo has the BEST switch pro-like controller and could make the best gamecube or wii u, or even a xbox 360 controller.
I already have the first release of this controller with the PS2 and USB dongles, but the fact that it turns on the PS3 and works with backwards compatible games is a big win. Gonna go ahead and order them.
@Real_spawn_wave
Dude. Stop already. No one is falling for this BS scam.
I'm actually in the works of trying to find that Perfect Replacement for a PS3 controller so this sounds up my alley! Thank you for this review spawn wave.
Did you try one of these? Was curious if its good or not
@@LowestDifficulty yes
I do like the controller for PS2, but one grip that's stopping me from really loving the controller is the fact that I can't rest my fingers on the triggers without pressing them. It has very sensitive triggers and it's caused quite the annoyance for me personally, I'm not sure if it's just my controller or it's just how they are.
I've always felt that the PS controllers improved with each generation. I still like all of them because they fit my hands well, although I am more used to the newer models. The original bulky xbox controller was the first thing that made me a PS guy back in the day.
Same! I hate this bulky ass shit controllers. You don't have the control over Xbox controllers. They control YOU...
alright but what about people who ain't built like a 14 y/o vietnamize kid? Is there other alternatives besides microsoft's stupid clicker controllers? Like I was hoping he would compare size differences, but he gave the same info for 5 mins
There are still many PS3 games I haven’t play, trying to get a DualShock 3 in good condition is very slim, thanks for the review
Excellent TechWave Video Jon(SW).
This Retro Fighters Defender Controller for the PS3 is looking top notch, the Dualshock 3 isn't bad and is very much usable but it isn't the best either.
I do still have a PS3 Console, I might check this Controller so I can Play all the Games on the System better.
Yeah ever since I got my PS5, I've been using the dualsense on PS3 with a wire. It's really wacky because the share button is select and you can't use the PlayStation button.
Nice, I bought one of the older versions of this controller and was upset to find out that I couldn't use it to play PS2 games on my PS3. Glad to hear they improved it.
You can gain this functionality by updating the controller firmware! Available on their website
@@1swhile that's great to hear
I love it with the exception of the Dpad but is a non issue since I bought this for PS2&3. Smooth sticks with nice rubber grip (Think PS4), great ergonomics, and the most responsive 3rd party triggers I’ve played with. Looking forward to going though the Resistances and Killzones with it.
Did you find that the Killzone games were super sensitive when aiming with the dualshock 3? I played them for the first time not too long ago and thought I must have lost all my first person shooter skills lol. My crosshairs were flying all over the screen. I just ordered this controller, hopefully it's good!
@@professoroak9721 Had to turn it down sensitivity if I remember correctly. This controller is better but does not fix how wonky/janky part 2&3 are. Resistance 2 was spot on so am assuming 1&3 are also. I hope the new "Hunter" for the OG Xbox is as good as this one in Oct.
This video answered all my questions.
I've a backwards compatible Frankenstein PS3 (40nm RSX, official Sony refurb)
Can't wait to get this
I love the defender, had some small problems when using it on ps3. Definitely picking 1 of these updated ones up.
fun fact smackdown vs raw 07 is kinda rare as its the last game with chris benoit
I bought a Retro Fighters DC controller and a trigger broke within a month. I emailed them and they immediately sent me a new one.
Now that I also have my PS3 up to spec I'm gonna grab this as well, they deserve the money and the product's been great so far.
I have the original defender and the only issue i have with it is related to the super sensitive L2 and R2 triggers.
I JUST yesterday started going into backlog on PS3 with FF XIII-2 and had some controller issues. Less than 24 hours the man posts a new controller review for it. Are you magic
Awesome stuff!
I’ve always wondered why no one tried making a real improved PS3 controller. It was good for its time but going back to it is tough. I don’t like the stiff triggers, convex sticks, or small size
I have the non Bluetooth version and I love it for PS1/PS2 and PC, looking forward to picking this one up for the PS3 because I never liked the Dual Shock 3 controller it always felt cheap and brittle with bad shoulder buttons.
SvR 2007?!!!
Where did the years go?
😟
Thanks for the videos my dude
Every single one of my dualshock controller for this system have always ended up broken in one way or another. Always sooner than I would expect. Wether it has to do with the battery, analog, or problems with connectivity.
Hmmmm. Before I commit to it as a full replacement, I'd check to see how the rumble feedback is with Metal Gear Solid 4 specifically. I never see it get brought up at all, but that game delivered perfect feedback from everything in game that *really* made you feel immersed when paired with the sound design.
If this controller can give the same experience with all the subtle touches that the first party dual shock 3 does...then I'd say this controller seems perfect.
(I don't suppose you could test this out yourself?)
2:40
Spawnwave: "Ontop we do have our USB type _C_ "
Controller: .-.
You're my hero John. I haaaaate the ds3. Gonna have to try this badboy out. Thnx 🙌
How are deadzones? Most adapters ive used make deadzones square
Do you or does anyone here know or can test if this controller works in the PS3 Recovery Menu that you typically need to use and access with a controller connected via USB Cable to the system? Thanks!
That is awesome.. I might have to pick one up for my ps3
*it's still pretty cool that ANY wired controller works on the ps3, i use a powerA wired xbox one controller on mine, PS4 controllers also work wired or wireless through the Bluetooth settings (:*
Yeah, I don't like the Dual Shock 1-3. I got the Retro Fighters Defender for my PS2 and it's a dream. I'd like to get the PS3 controller as it has the same design/layout and it has the sixaxis as you mentioned. Right now I'm using an imported Hori FPS Plus. It's wired with no sixaxis or rumble, but it feels great to use.
Got back into my PS3 and this controller is gonna be cool. Thanks!
Interesting, but try brook wingman, its an adapter that is used to connect nearly all controllers to a specific console, i have two of those, one i use with my ps3 and dualsense controller and the second one with my ps2 and dualsense😀, really amazing technology, works wirelessly
How do the triggers feel? The previous version gave me issues with how sensitive they were.
How is the input from the sticks? I returned my original Defenders because the sticks didn't provide smooth rotation in-game; when rolling the stick in a circle, it would "snap" between the 8 cardinal directions, it was terrible.
Thank you Jon, I just bought one in black
Sounds awesome, do you know of any ps3 controllers that may incorporate the hall sensor analog sticks that prevent drifting issues. My old ps3 controller started to drift, so any info would be great.
I finally bought this controller. It's probably the best option out there as third party PS3 controllers go.
I definitely have to try one of these out! I've mainly been using a PS5 controller for my PS3s.
I'll have to look into this since I need a couple of good controllers for my PS3. I actaully need some PS2 controllers since I did the fan/SSD upgrades from your previous video.
Retrobit has a model that works on PS1/2/3 - just doesn’t include motion controls on PS3 and uses a dongle. I love mine.
I got the the brawler64 wireless edition retro fighters controller recently. Absolute must have for NSO N64.
PS3 controller was a great controller I don’t know what you’re smoking dude
I’m getting massive The Office flashbacks just from some of your wording. *Urkelnomically* and *X-axix* come to mind 😅
I got a voyee a few years ago. Was fairly cheap and can wake up the console and play ps1 games with no issue. I also have a bootleg playstation branded that does these things fine. I believe six axis works as well, at least with the voyee.
I’ve been needing a ps3 controller that has motion controls and pressure sensitive buttons. Finding official ones have been a nightmare.
Edit: Smackdown vs Raw 2007 was my childhood
Still using a ribbon connector for the rest of the buttons? I am getting a little tired with all my controllers dying because some foam is getting deteriorated. Still looking for a full board controller for my PS3/PS4...
i actually back them on kickstarter for the ps 1/ps2 controller and i love it .
Good vid @SpawnWave as always great vid quality and well written scripts man even if I don't always agree
This is pretty cool. I always use my ps5 controller on ps3 which works great most of the time, but a few issues like motion and home button don't work (and I guess the Rumble would be an issue but I never use Rumble and hate Rumble on older consoles)
You can't connect it to ps3 wirless right?
@@M.sami12 I believe you actually can. you just have to go into the ps3 settings and manually pair it I believe.
Is this going to be available in the UK?? Its way too hard to find a genuine Dualshock controller here that isn't broke in some way.
Does the middle ps button working? Back the meny...on/off?
I'm bald
I just got a $20 wireless adapter and I use PS5 controllers on my PS3, you can use nearly any of them though with it, PS4, Xbox, switch pro controller, PS4 fight sticks, etc, can use wired ones as well. It's called the Magic-S , I also use this adapter to properly use the PS5 controller with the PS4
Yep picked one of these up fairly recently and love it, I picked grey to suit PS1, if I got another one I'd consider one of the cool clear colours, blue or teal probably. My only 'compliant' isn't legitimate, the Xbox doesn't pick it up since it's D-Input so I can't play PS1/PS2 games on Xbox with it.
I really need this. The original is too small and my Arkham controller is falling apart
When Retro Fighter announced three years ago that they are making PS2 wireless controllers I have been following their news and development very closely! I didn't have a good PS2 controller and I couldn't find one that works well, third party or any other wireless options! Finally one year ago they have finished controllers and they have started selling it! I have bought one controller to try it first! It works flawlessly! I have ordered three more in different colors! Works well for PS One, PS2, PS3 and Nintendo Switch but I have good controllers for those systems already so I am using it for my PS2 only! Battery life is around 10 hours or little more on my PS2! Excellent controllers
Was going to buy two of these but their shipping costs are expensive. Only expedited and Rush shipping? Cmon RetroFighter
Mine shipped today so hope to get it by Thursday.
Does the homebutton work within PS3 games?
Using it on your PC or if it has switch compatibility is just a bonus over its intended function.
I actually thought that the PS4 controller had enough extra features that if I needed a PC controller that the PS4 controller look like the one to pick up but I instead went with an 8-bitdo SN30Pro + because I could use that on the Switch and it's cheaper than getting a PS4 controller and an adapter for Switch.
I'm curious to know if you can somehow place the original ps3 controller buttons in that controller.
On their website the Bluetooth version says its not compatible with PS1/PS2 whereas the normal Defender is but doesn't have six axis support.
Gonna have to pick this up now
I agree! fantastic controller.
The negatives however, are substantial, and you didnt seem to notice or simply didn't have them in your unit.
The thumbsticks are 3rd party execution; they feel great but do not control as accurately as SONY always somehow achieves.
Then the worst is the R/L 2 buttons being too sensitive and getting accidentally pressed. The Sony controller is fine with similar triggers because they arent designed for you to rest your fingers on them; this controller does do that so I pressed those on accident a lot when I first got kt
This is cool kinda wish this was a thing a year ago cause i have the Brook Wingman XE dongle to connect my ps4 controller to the ps3 for it to somehow mimic a legit ps3 controller and give me full functionality of one but I dont think the ps4 controller has as many pressure sensitive buttons as this not that it matters much but its nice to have
My favorite PS3 controller is the Dual Shock 4 paired with a Mayflash Magic/Brooks adapter. You can use it without the adapter but the home button doesn't work, and it doesn't work with every game.
So the older Defender model with the dongle won't support all the PS3 features? Six axis? I do have a Mayflash converter
I use the ps5 controller for ps3 with the brook wingman adapter. Motion controls, battery percentage and home button all work with the ps5 controller. I bought a universal remote to turn on the system tho
Just noticed there's no headphone jack, thats a big selling point for me if it also works for ps4 as stated on the website.
1. Does SixAxis and especially button sensitivity work with PCSX2 (PC/Steam Deck)
2. Is there any jank to the SixAxis controls or is it smooth?
3. How quick is the auto turn off, if it has one? 3a. Can you change this timing, lights, or rumble to increase battery life?
4. How strong is the rumble? Reason I ask is GCBattler has weak rumble.
Wait…. every PS3 will play PlayStation one discs???????
I have the previous Defender for the PS1 & PS2, I’m wondering how much different this one is?
Just ordered one of these. I’ve always said that Sony put all their money into the PS3 console itself and skimped out on the controller.
I've had two of these controllers (and two PS2 versions) & they all had drift issues. If they had hall effect sensors then they'd be perfect ❤
fun fact: you can use Power A's wired switch controller on the ps3. You don't have analog triggers though :)
Still love my Playstation 3 and this is awesome this control works for it
Looks cool!! Can you turn the vibration off?
DualShock 3 is cool but I hate that the matte finish goes away after heavy use
I still have a new one that I used from time to time