Very nice list! I'd also recommend Awkward Guests, which feels a lot more like Clue(do) on steroids, where the suspects wander around the house and you need to figure out how they got to the crime scene as well as the usual who, what, and why.
Absolutely…Awkward Guests is Clue on steroids. The brilliant deck systems makes every play so much fun…and with the different difficulty levels so rewarding if you get it to the table more often. Although the art work fits the theme very well I wouldn’t mind a little more color…
Came across this channel in RUclips recommendations. Brilliant video that brought new titles to my attention with fun and concise information abundant. Makes it no mystery why I subscribed, thank you dicebreaker team for all your hard work keeping us table top sleuths entertained as well as informed.
Cluedo would be OK if the movement system was better. The main deduction side of it isn't bad, it's just the torture inflicted by the role and move mechanic that kills it. There is a really cool family game Small Detectives where there is a pool of movement cards, so as you use a card, you know you're handing it to an opponent for them to move. I'd also back the other people who are bringing up Awkward Guests - it also strips the movement system out of Cluedo, and then adds some nuances to the cards which is genius
Consulting Detective and Chronicles of Crime are both fantastic, my wife and I have enjoyed many an evening solving their mysteries. Micro Macro is also good, although as you say play on hard mode otherwise it’s just too easy. I would add TIME Stories to the list, although more mystery solving than a true detective game, it’s a lot of fun. Quantum Leap meets Groundhog Day in this great game.
Sherlock is my favourite board game of all time. Was a wonderful 2 player with my partner. Definitely recommend! (Also fyi, think the description links need updating :) )
Something I've enjoyed lately is Cat Crimes. I bought it from a charity shop just for the name, but it was a real hit at a recent family gathering. It's a solo game, but easy to make it co-op.
221b baker street was so much better than clue(do). My dad can win clue within a few turns with just lucky guesses. We switched it up and played 221b baker st where you have to actually use clues and i won. He was mad because he was trying to play it like clue
Q Why isn't there 7 detective "video" games bettter than cluedo ?...it seems imo that the premise, of what makes a great detective game, is completely lost when converted to a video game, but why is that?... pc crime games are nearly all linear, all scripted have zero replayability and only ever concern themselves with finding out a pre detrmined assailant, motive, and method, where are the open world dynamic freeflow crime games?...i only know of 2 recent ones Unheard and LA Noire and before that they were decades ago....real crime solving is never linear it's never scripted, yet that's what developers come up with time and time again
What would you want to see added to the shelves of our new set?
Most of those game sadly cannot be replaid that once you solve it you forever know.
Very nice list! I'd also recommend Awkward Guests, which feels a lot more like Clue(do) on steroids, where the suspects wander around the house and you need to figure out how they got to the crime scene as well as the usual who, what, and why.
Absolutely…Awkward Guests is Clue on steroids. The brilliant deck systems makes every play so much fun…and with the different difficulty levels so rewarding if you get it to the table more often.
Although the art work fits the theme very well I wouldn’t mind a little more color…
Definitely liking the new set, has a bit more character. Hoping it is a permanent change
There are many detective games the last couple of years. City of Angels sounds right up my alley, but I think I would enjoy all of them.
I don't know how but somehow the set change makes the video so much more interesting. Love it.
Loving the new set! Gives the video more personality
Can't wait for "The Dark Quarter" to come out (from the designer of "Detective: City of Angels") - it's absolutely my jam :D
Oot but for a second i thought the first presenter is Elizabeth Olsen. Nice recommendations btw.
Came across this channel in RUclips recommendations. Brilliant video that brought new titles to my attention with fun and concise information abundant. Makes it no mystery why I subscribed, thank you dicebreaker team for all your hard work keeping us table top sleuths entertained as well as informed.
I’ve missed this sort of video! Also, loving the new set guys
I would recommend Awkward Guests as the best and most direct replacement to Cluedo
Cluedo would be OK if the movement system was better. The main deduction side of it isn't bad, it's just the torture inflicted by the role and move mechanic that kills it. There is a really cool family game Small Detectives where there is a pool of movement cards, so as you use a card, you know you're handing it to an opponent for them to move.
I'd also back the other people who are bringing up Awkward Guests - it also strips the movement system out of Cluedo, and then adds some nuances to the cards which is genius
Consulting Detective and Chronicles of Crime are both fantastic, my wife and I have enjoyed many an evening solving their mysteries. Micro Macro is also good, although as you say play on hard mode otherwise it’s just too easy.
I would add TIME Stories to the list, although more mystery solving than a true detective game, it’s a lot of fun. Quantum Leap meets Groundhog Day in this great game.
Sherlock is my favourite board game of all time. Was a wonderful 2 player with my partner. Definitely recommend!
(Also fyi, think the description links need updating :) )
Mystery games are fantastic since they both stimulate and entertain my thoughts. I really appreciate the suggestions. 🤓
Something I've enjoyed lately is Cat Crimes. I bought it from a charity shop just for the name, but it was a real hit at a recent family gathering. It's a solo game, but easy to make it co-op.
Awkward Guests should definitely be on this list. I'd also include Inkognito and Obscurio.
@Dicebreaker Fine selection! (and very well done video) Ever heard about Midnight Murder Mysteries?
Another game I would recommend is T.I.M.E Stories. It's like quantum leap meets Sherlock Holmes.
Sabotage at Lucky Llamaland is also excellent for families
Ty for this
221b baker street was so much better than clue(do). My dad can win clue within a few turns with just lucky guesses. We switched it up and played 221b baker st where you have to actually use clues and i won. He was mad because he was trying to play it like clue
Mysterium is rather good.
Q Why isn't there 7 detective "video" games bettter than cluedo ?...it seems imo that the premise, of what makes a great detective game, is completely lost when converted to a video game, but why is that?... pc crime games are nearly all linear, all scripted have zero replayability and only ever concern themselves with finding out a pre detrmined assailant, motive, and method, where are the open world dynamic freeflow crime games?...i only know of 2 recent ones Unheard and LA Noire and before that they were decades ago....real crime solving is never linear it's never scripted, yet that's what developers come up with time and time again
Hitting my thumb with a hammer is better than playing a game of Cluedo.
…also Monopoly.