An Unexpected Conversation With A Boy Genius: What Are The Limits of Science?
HTML-код
- Опубликовано: 25 дек 2023
- This is one of Peter’s favorite conversations.
In Regent’s Park, London, Peter Boghossian conducted a Spectrum Street Epistemology with two children, a twelve-year-old boy and his younger sister. Peter began with claims about science, a topic both children preferred. After the young man demonstrated an extraordinary intellect, Peter upped the ante, presenting complicated claims regarding the limits of science and its relationship to morality and emotion.
At the end of the discussion, Peter asked the young man if he would rather have a life guided by reason or emotion. He responded, “If you just have cold, hard reason without any emotion and human feeling, what does that make you? You won't be able to make kind decisions; you'll just be essentially a robot.”
⸺SUPPORT MY WORK⸺
Newsletter | boghossian.substack.com/
Donate | www.nationalprogressalliance....
⸺LINKS⸺
Podcast: "Conversations with Peter Boghossian": pod.link/1650150225
Website | peterboghossian.com/
National Progress Alliance | www.nationalprogressalliance....
Resignation Letter | peterboghossian.com/my-resign...
⸺BOOKS⸺
“How To Have Impossible Conversations” | www.amazon.com/dp/0738285323/...
“A Manual For Creating Atheists” | www.amazon.com/Manual-Creatin...
⸺SOCIAL MEDIA⸺
Twitter | / peterboghossian
Instagram | / peter.boghossian
TikTok | / peterboghossian
All Socials | linktr.ee/peterboghossian
__________
#peterboghossian #science #streetepistemology #thoughtexperiment
If you want to watch another young guy engage in a Spectrum Street Epistemology exercise, watch this one next: ruclips.net/video/VMwoVMIaeU8/видео.html
I'm sure it wasn't intentional, but your tone, and manner of speech was so patronizing as to be irritating, near insulting. This is a pet peeve of mine. I cannot stand when people talk to kids as if they're puppies anymore than I do when a nurse walks into a patient's room as does the same.
@@stevegee7623👀
@@stevegee7623try to add-lib this sort of stuff in an open-ended way that’s stimulating, keeps a child interested, and is age-appropriate. It’s tougher than it looks. He got the boy engaged. Everybody has a complaint about something online but I’m not seeing what could be different. I’m into this stuff for my own kids and I suppose there is material somewhere on how to do this for various ages. Anyway, I thought this was great!
@drpeterboghossian - Did you know beforehand that this boy was particularly bright? (ie: Were you in front of a school where gifted kids were walking out the door or something?) I've seen a few 'on the street interviews' in the states asking high school and college age kids the most basic of questions, and they had NO idea of the answer. "What country was the Queen of England from?" "When was the war of 1812?" They couldn't tell the time on an analogue clock. Depressing as could be; I couldn't finish listening.
I was just going to make this same comment... lol
I am impressed with this young man.
This kid is more articulate than 95% of adults i speak with on the regular.
@@L_Martin sure, but it's not enough: I'm pretty sur his friends are not as bright as him. He is an exception.
Ansolutely.
@@L_MartinI know a lot of rich private school kids. Trust me… not much smarter or more knowledgeable than public school kids. In fact, at private schools they boost the poor performers’ marks because rich parents are not going to pay a school that doesn’t give high enough marks for their kids to get into university.
@@karagi101 Eh, I know a lot of kids going to these types of schools, I grew up with them myself, I have friends who are teachers at these schools, and this kid does not stand out from many I have known growing up / know currently. Part of it is having that international background as well, where the parents speak another language, and the kids already have 2 languages if not more. Home life and holidaying abroad in the types of places they do, being surrounded with literature and music, etc. I'm not talking about general grammar school education.
I don't think he is exceptional among his cohort, which again, I'd guess is much wealthier than even grammar-school kids. But hey we can disagree on that.
@@L_Martin I live in Toronto. Half the population are immigrants, including myself. Half the population speaks at least one 2nd language. We are all taught French in school too. We travel back to home countries all the time. Still… see little difference between public and private school kids’ knowledge. Perhaps the issue is with the quality of the public schools in your area.
Wow! Give their parents an award... these kids are brilliant.
Noice Woyk
Some good parenting happening there!
Brilliant and lacklustre are RELATIVE. 😉
Incidentally, Slave, are you VEGAN? 🌱
Probably the dad. The mom seemed to disagree with the boy at the end
Gotta nip those utilitarian tendencies in the bud
Absolutely love this - a twelve-year-old kid with more powers of reasoning than the bulk of adults that tend to participate in Peter's street epistemology. Just wow
It's not adults who participate in Peter's street epistemology. It's adults in general.
Most adults (Not just the ones Peter talks to) turn off the inquisitive /introspective side of their mind.
It is that or a private school in which they already had at length this exact same conversation. It is really improvable that he deduced it all by himself
@@cristianproust I agree. I work at lot in london and the kids of the very wealthy clients i work for are all like this.
They all have private tutors and private schooling.
The difference between them and the kids in the working class town i come from are huge
Unlike some Supreme Court Judge, I'm sure he knows what a woman is. Their mother is doing a great job - none of these skills develop without good parenting.
@@saltburner2 80K a year would get you that kid without even passing for home. That has nothing to do with good parenting
The best part was how plainly the little girl loved her brother.
I saw to too, so cute. She definitely looks up to him.
we adore thems that does the protectin'
The radical feminists haven't got thier claws in yet.
She has no idea that her brother is part of the tyrannical patriarchy.
Yes I want to say that how she listens what he said etc.
It was very cute but I do think the wisdom was the best part as it's the less common. But it's different focuses, I agree it is lovely to see an older brother standing into his role as a guide and protector for his little sister for sure, beautiful ❤
This kid is undoubtedly a better thinker than the vast majority of “educated” adults
No Indoctrinating that kid😎👍
Brighter than I could ever hope to be.
Ive was like that as a kid too its strange to be a kid like that around so many kids and people unlike you
If those adult were "educated" at a place that has safe spaces then you can assume they never left the toddler phase of their life.
What does your education consist of?
Peter just showed us that Street Epistemology can-and should-be conducted in public education.
It could be used as a foundation for critical thinking.
While in theory it could be a great exercise in developing critical thinking, keep in mind that Peter, or whoever is conducting the activity, very much steers the direction it akes with the questions. Given the capture of education by woke ideology in most cases you wouldn't achieve much. It's very much reliant on a gifted and open-minded teacher, not a common thing sadly.
Absolutely. The only problem is “Public Education” has nothing to do with critical thought or educating. I wish it did though.
And before that, Socrates, who lived in ancient Greece around 469-399 BCE, did the same. He engaged in open dialogues with people from various backgrounds, questioning and discussing fundamental ideas such as ethics, justice, and the nature of knowledge.
Socrates' approach (known, unsurprisingly, as the "Socratic method") involved asking questions to stimulate critical thinking, and to encourage individuals to examine their own beliefs and assumptions. By engaging in conversations in public spaces, such as the agora in Athens, Socrates played a crucial role in making philosophical inquiry accessible to a broader audience. His method of philosophical inquiry and the public nature of his discussions laid the groundwork for the later development of Western philosophy.
This doesn't take away from the value of what Peter is doing. Instead, and perhaps somewhat disappointingly, it speaks to the long history of humans who've had access to philosophy for at least 2,500 years and yet, even today... despite primary and even some university level learning, we still see a ghastly deficit in critical thinking among the general population.
One of my favorite statements of 'the problem' was by Asimov in his 1980 essay titled "A Cult of Ignorance". There are several juicy bits worth focusing on but the one I imagine most familiar to people is where he wrote this:
_"There is a cult of ignorance in the United States, and there has always been. The strain of anti-intellectualism has been a constant thread winding its way through our political and cultural life, nurtured by the false notion that democracy means that _*_'my ignorance is just as good as your knowledge'._*
British education would not allow for open and honest dialogue. Its like indoctrination in that sense.
“My son is showing very worrying utilitarian tendencies.”
That shows you all you need to know. What an amazing mom. I loved watching this.
I was looking for this comment
Lol i wonder where she's from as doesnt sound English. Ends justify the means rhetoric is quite common in practical academics that are truly welded to Scientism. So she's probably right and has to keep a close eye on this fella haha.
Next stop Schopenhauer then Nietzsche. I dread the Rousseau and Deconstructionist phase of his education but if it means we can all have the benefit of his mind later on, alls the better. What incredible parents.
That comment shocked me. It's so bizarre to me when people get alarmed by objectivity. I hope that kid ignores that comment from his mom and continues to analyze things for himself.
@@jasondashney I think she was teasing him.
I want to be this kid when I grow up
Me too!
Me too, and I am 76
😂
😂
these kids usually grow up with zero people skills and have trouble working a washing machine
"My son is showing very worrying utilitarian and relativist tendencies" I'm dying bro.
I commented on that before reading your post. (I couldn't decipher what the mother said initially because my volume was too low). She's dead right and is a very impressive woman, to even take note of that.
I vehemently disagreed that she's dead right, I found it quite concerning that the mom would say that so I'm interested to know what it was that impressed you about that comment. Why do you feel that she was correct? Cheers. @@johndickson9542
compared to what? that was my question as a layman.
@@CleverGirlAAH moral relativism seems to be slightly implied by the kid’s reference to people’s differing gut feelings, and gut feeling as the (partial) source of morality.
Contrastingly, moral realism argues there is a “true” morality out there, regardless of our gut feeling.
Could be something religious, or more akin to math, or both.
Utilitarianism turns morality in a partially empirical question: whatever leads to the most good for the most people, must be moral.
So the kid’s reference to science helping us decide moral questions might suggest he has a utilitarian position, but that’s not explicit in the video.
Summarizing
Moral realism: moral facts exist, independently of our feelings and perceptions.
Moral relativism: there are no moral truths, just claims dependent on culture or feeling.
Utilitarianism: there is one moral law, we can use science and reasoning to apply it.
Hope this helps and doesn’t come across as condescending, which happens quickly when writing about topics like these.
Great response
Peter, I think you should interview this boy, every three or four years, for the next 12 years to see what he says as time goes on. And the little girl too! lol
Like the 12+Up longditudinal TV series in the UK.
I hope this kid dont becone a pink haired soyboy Commie by going to Uni for Science and coming out a gender studies activist. 👀
Brilliant idea.
Amazing. I’m 63, have 3 uni degrees and try to imagine how I’d answer these questions and realise how basic my answers would appear when compared to this 12 yr old
Wow, 3 degrees. You are amazing too :)
Oh dear… I’m going to go there…
How much of that “basic” can be attributed to the 3 degrees, I wonder?
@@stvbrsn very little
This was like getting "hope for the future" mainlined directly into my eyeball.
I sure hope so. Let's hope the next 10 years of emasculating and screaming about his white privilege don't break him down. I have a feeling he'll be able to take it. :)
We have embryo selection now too.
As a person of faith, I do see a trend that science is being taught as the new God. Also, the illusion that if you master the understanding of science, it gives you some sort of control over things.
Incredibly intelligent kids. I hope the boy realizes that if science lets him down, God will still be there. Seems a bit like we are now worshipping the creation, and not the creator.
Romans 1:25 “Who changed the truth of God into a lie, and worshipped and served the creature (creation, the earth) more than the Creator, who is blessed for ever. Amen.” If this verse piques your interest, go read the accompanying verses. This is just a little snippet 😉
@@Diametricallyopposed00 I think it'd be nice for schools to stop omitting the religious aspects of scientific discovery, such as noting that the man who theorized the famous Big Bang Theory was a Catholic priest. It leads to students believing that science and religion are separate categories, but they have both been intertwined since the beginning and go hand-in-hand with one another.
I don't remember the exact quote, but:
A little science estranges one from God, but a lot of science brings one closer to Him.
@@microsoftpain well, said. Better than my original comment. Couldn’t agree more. God made this system in which we exist. They dovetail into each other. You do not have to choose one or the other.
Lol I love the moms banter at the end, giving her son shit for being too utilitarian. You can tell shes proud of him but can still joke around in a sophisticated way. No wonder the kid's smart, so is his mom.
That was exactly my take on it. He may be showing different view points and her teasing shows she loves him for that!
I'm glad you could see it was banter. Plenty on these comments couldn't.
This young fella already understands more about how things work than most adults.
So, you’re impressed by circular definitions like he gave for what a “moral problem” is?
@@davidmajor1508 More impressed than with someone trolling on semantics of a 12 year old who clearly gets the distinction, but may have not mastered the language yet.
@@HomesteadDNA
Oh, so pointing out circular definitions is “trolling” now.
Wow. I feel bad for you- so irrational.
@@HomesteadDNA
Yes, let’s give circular nonsense a pass because he’s “12”- that’ll really help raise a generation of thinkers. Ha. Unfortunately not. It’ll raise yet another generation of your ilk: irrational individuals who think pointing out illogic is “trolling” precisely because they ARE irrational and can’t think logically. Like it I say: it’s sad.
@@HomesteadDNA
Yes, let’s give circular thinking and definitions a pass because he’s “12”- that’ll really help raise a generation of thinkers. Ha. Unfortunately not. It’ll raise yet another generation of your ilk: irrational individuals who think pointing out illogic is “trolling” precisely because they ARE irrational and can’t think logically. Like it I say: it’s sad.
Feed a child's curiosity and look at the results. The boy knows how to think.
I can tell by the way his mom spoke to him at the end that she is very wise. The apple doesn't fall far from the tree indeed.
Perceptive. When parents take an interest in their kids, great things can happen. Helping a child achieve its unique potential is the best job a parent can do, aside from love. Great Mom.
What did she say though? I have hearing loss so sometimes certain accents with certain words can’t get into my brain 😂 thanks to whoever clarifies
@@SmartAmericanKids Funnily, she (jokingly) seems to disapprove of his politics/outlook.
@@L_Martin that's how I heard it...
@@L_MartinYes!!! She scolded him a touch for being too utilitarian & relativistic with his responses...lol. (And I agree with her.)
These kids have great parents! Or at least someone dedicared & fairly wise spending time being real with them.
People who have not bought into modern, swayable concepts of morality
@@Ruby_Villain yes, people with principles and not trendy whims.
Indeed
@@drpeterboghossian what part of the world are these kids from?
@@john12152England
Love how the sister follows him. It shows how kids look up too and copy people. Makes it even more scary when you realize what's being taught in schools or online.
I noticed that too.
Is it also a gender thing? Do females just follow men, especially when feeling vulnerable or when younger etc? Is it a throwback to evolutionary development? Interesting observations.
@SarcasticPlotRecaps yeah, of course, I have a younger brother and sister. There are people about who would like to destroy all of that though and replace with government demagogues.
@@SarcasticPlotRecapsoh come on. She’s clearly much younger- of course she follows her big sib. It’s how kids learn at that age. Get out of here with your sexism.
no.@@SarcasticPlotRecaps
What a wonderful representation of British children. It's so refreshing to see how precocious they are. I am sure that their parents are incredibly proud of them.
As a Millennial, these kids have given me hope for Gen Alpha. This young man's ability to ponder what we would be with only reason & no emotion was a true pleasure to listen to.
Thank you to all involved. Happy holidays! ☃️
having a laugh if you think this pair are representative of Britain or generation alpha
@@Eilfylijokul Well…I’m little Miss nobody from the arsehole of the west of Scotland and my ‘Gen Alpha’ son, who’s a little rough around the edges and not quite so articulate, has very similar views.
He's the exception not the rule. Its amazing what 1 million dollars invested into a kid can do for them by the time their 12. But the kid is also very smart/bright, I don't want to take away from his inquisitive mind, but its more that it compounds with good environment.
His mother sounds German, and his accent does not entirely sound local, so I wouldn't be surprised if he lives part of his life in Europe and part of it in England. I think there's a high chance his parents are rather rich and sending the children to very posh private schools.
@@Eilfylijokul If any kids were going to be represented, I'm pleased it was these two. Being British though I'm sure it's wishful thinking on my part that they are true reps of our society here! :)
These children have caring parents. They've raised such well mannered, smart and educated children and they're still so young. Truly incredible.
This kid is 1000x more thoughtful (afa his ability to think reasonably) than your average adult. Wow.
What an amazing example of rational mind ❤ he is more educated than any politition I've heard 🙏
God bless
You should listen to Bernie.
Bernie is very well-educated with facts to back his views.
@@malirk Are you referring to Bert & Ernie?
@@AndyFromBeaverton
You confused them with their Spooner cousins.
I bet he can spell "politician" too!
@@AndyFromBeaverton Nope. Bernie Sanders.
I do kinda love that she looks to her brother. Its adorable. Hopefully he leads in good directions
From what we saw here he's definitely off to a good start!
I wish more adults were even a fraction of as articulate and reasoned as this young man is.
Unfortunately we currently live in an age where idiocy is celebrated
I think Peter did a great job asking challenging questions and listening to the answers from this young man.
For the non-British viewer, this accent indicates that this boy attends a private school in the south east of England. That's one reason for this child's eloquence.
Yes, I fear so. This reasoning ability should be the target outcome of all our impoverished schools, but I'm afraid it gets pushed out in many cases.
It could be a product of a private education, though his speech patterns and other behaviours would indicate that he's on the autistic spectrum, more specifically Aspergers Syndrome. We typically have an advanced vernacular, which is more apparent at younger ages where this differs from many of our peers, which when combined with his South-East England accent does smack of "Private School". I would hope that his reasoning skills and evident knowledge are at least in part attributable to his formal education, but I think both he and his family deserve some credit. I don't say this to be contentuous, but purely to highlight that these (rightfully) praised behaviours are as attributable to autism, regardless of socio-economic factors. People hear "autism" and immediately think we're mentally deficient. It would be nice, and reflective of reality, if people were as quick to think "Gee.. he's intelligent! Maybe he's autistic."
So it's the curriculum, the staff, the standards, the students themselves or the parental involvement that separates the the outcomes, not the location of the school.
Really? I wouldn't have known that as an American. Thanks for sharing :)
Maybe. I would imagine he goes to a good school, though not all of those are private. And many private schools produce accents that are similar, wherever they are in the UK.
The world needs more of these kids.
We are getting them...african and indians are doing this incredibly well !
Such good parenting. She's really paying attention to who they are and nurturing their evolution. And they are loved and happy. This made my day!
My favorite part was the playful "tough love" at the end. Hahaha. Proof she doesn't treat them like fragile butterflies. Something you don't see a lot from those who would likely claim some form of higher intelligence in their parenting.
It was interesting too to see how the little girl was often concentrating intently on what was being said, even though she didn't join in.
Letting the participants pick the topic is a nice change of pace. 👌🏼
They usually do choose, it's just not always shown in the video.
@@drpeterboghossian why not show the whole process as a teaching tool?
And to think that this wonderful boy is someone that DEI seeks to exclude and disadvantage in the name of "justice".
Oh no we have to give the kids that are told being lazy and ignorant is a cultural trait, a helping hand.
That boy was nothing but a carbon emitting imperialist standing on the shoulders of cultures of color. Same for the girl, but she may grow up to be a strong independent boss babe. Happy solstice.
@@MIKE_THE_BRUMMIE Is it not a cultural trait? So it's inherent/genetic? I'm not really sure what your argument is here...
@@gabeo9474 I think it's become an accepted cultural trait that should have been beaten out of anyone exhibiting it.
I'm saying DEI takes the worst of any culture and venerates it as a virtue but it's clearly to subvert and further degenerate groups culture so as to keep the majority culture at odds and not unified.
If we were a unified people, we'd easily spot subversive, degenerate behavior and root it out.....THEY can't have that
How will this boy be excluded, if you don’t mind me asking?
I am so impressed by these sidewalk conversation activities. They are so absolutely unique and revealing. It shows the intelligence and creativity of true thinkers, while exposing the sheep-like, unintelligible nonsense of activists. I wish more people would do this exact thing you are doing. Keep it up and thank you!
And to think Critical Thinking class and Debate class were removed from the high school curriculum decades ago. Makes you wonder....
Well said, Ruby.
_“Governments don't want a population capable of critical thinking, they want obedient workers, people just smart enough to run the machines and just dumb enough to passively accept their situation.”_
-George Carlin
That little comment at the end 😄Seems like Mum is doing her best to feed his curiosity and yearning for learning while making sure she raises a compassionate/empathetic human being
He very clearly addresses that during his talk, so I hope his mom doesn't spend all of her time, trying to turn him into a typical campus leftist. The world would be a much better place if we could be much more objective about things.
Seeing such mature well articulated views and words coming from a child of this age gives me hope for the future of humanity
It's interesting that his mother recognizes and shows at least mocking concern over his "utilitarian" approach. Their family's dinner conversations must be fascinating.
gonna say the Son n daughter are more similar to their dad
@@npcimknot958 Yeah, he's probably the conservative in the family.
This boy's mom and I live in two different universes. How she can hear that, and her response is that he's to utilitarian was something I certainly didn't expect. He consistently talked about how morality was important, but you need something to back it up or else you can get behind things that are just crazy. If the sky is not red, you can't correctly say the sky is red. When the evidence changes, your gut feeling has to change lest you be actively wrong in your feelings. Her finding that concerning is quite concerning to me. It's awesome that she takes the time and worries about how her son is coming along, but she sounds like a typical university campus leftist.
Not so far left that she believes in the state education system, at least not in ours here in the UK. What does 'left and right' even mean politically anymore?@@jasondashney
@@MrVorpalsword left and right? Practically nothing, haha. If I asked you 10 years ago how somebody would vote if they were pro censorship and pro pharmaceutical industry and pro massive international billion dollar corporations that are all partially owned by the same groups that like to push a narrative on media, sometimes by literally paying them to do so, while a billionaire tech guy would become the largest farmland owner in America, and they would support him, for damn sure you would assume that they were right leaning. If you were very adamant, that rules should be created equally for everybody, and that you should not be allowed to discriminate based on any intrinsic characters, it would be assumed you were left, leaning, If you quoted Martin Luther King Jr. about the “content of their character“, you would probably have been left, leaning. Some things have stayed the same though. The left is not nearly as big into organized religion, and they are the first to call for medical system reform (in America), and are more sympathetic to socialist and communist movements. They are also far more likely to be involved in creativity and the arts.
Another interesting difference though, is that the left has completely abandoned the working man. It seems like each side flipped about half of their values.
"Boy Genius" indeed. Very astute and aware for a 12-year-old. Quite amazing. He should go far in his life. He certainly has great parents to guide and teach him.
Seems parents or school has had him wrestle wit these questions b4. He is very advanced
Id think wed need people willing to push the boundaries of norms, in every regard. Not just wasting smart people on conforming to the same old mundane way of "how smart you are might depend on how big of a paycheck you might earn, but ultimately doing the same old work a useless job, doing the same old family routine and then dying, only for their child to repeat the process" shpeel.
And we live in a society that doesnt reward those who work against it, its systems, its mentality. It gets harder for people of substance, not easier. Being stupid is what makes life easy.
Give those kids parents a standing ovation 👏🏼
In the beginning, I was sure he was just parroting phrases he'd heard, but I very quickly realised that these were his own internalised thoughts. He's clearly thought about this topic before, his answers were measured and well-reasoned. Let's hope that one day, kids like this will be the rule, not the exception.
Gut feeling vs. fact-based reasoning, coming from someone so young, floored me. Peter is brilliant, but the kid is even more so. 😃
it's been said already in the comments - but I'll say it again. Huge kudos to the parents of these kids. That young boy is such a breath of fresh air compared to the apparently endless stream of woke ninnies we so often see on the net. Great conversation Peter - and to you too Young Man!
Oh no! Not the dreaded woke!
If our leaders had even an ounce of these kids' thinking process we'd be in such a better place as a country.
He has the perfect balance of compassion and reasoning! Incredibly articulate young lad, his parents should be very very proud!
I bet his mother is incredibly intelligent!
The system is going to tax the living shit out of that poor kid.
Science without heart is nothing. His sister is in great hands following this young lad.
"my son is showing very worrying utilitarian and relative tendencies" 😂😂😂
We can see one of his influences for sure.
compared to what? that was my question as a layman.
Isnt utilitarianism one of the relativist moral theories? She spoke of them as different branches. I think she, like me (😁), picks up bits and pieces and spouts it out, sounding more intelligent than in reality.
Wow what a well spoken kid
Right?! Get that kid into office stat!
Very well spoken
So refreshing to not hear kids speaking like roadmen these days. Well i suppose they were in Regent's Park so probably a well off area.
The world needs more people in the world like this boy (and his sister)...such brilliant critical thinkers who are kind and empathic too🤓💕
So wholesome, healthy and smart. These two are like my children and most of the children I know but we never see them represented on social media which makes the whole world look a lot more grim than it clearly is!
Impressive young man. If there are more like him, humanity might just make it beyond lunchtime.
12 years of age and the epistemology of a very reasonable adult. Amazing.
That Kid did a Great Job!! He showed some pretty good Critical Thinking skills.
Amen😎👍
Another great one Peter! That kid is amazing!
Thanks for watching!
The kid juxtaposed intuition with Socratic methods so wonderfully. I could tell that he has an intelligent mama, based on her quips about Kantian maxims. I have a 5 year old and she’s so, so smart. I’m really doing my best to culture her capacity for discourse.
Brits have the built-in advantage of a set of schools founded in the 1500s that have been fine-tuning how to properly educate. Using 500 continuous years of results of what and how to best produce a critical thinking individual with historical knowledge and perspective.
Many of them go on to Oxford University for its special major: Philosophy, Politics, and Economics (PPE), which equips them to be capable of running a country sometime in the future.
(Note: Virginia Tech has a PPE major, and some of their students have either transferred to Oxford, or spend a semester/year there.)
@@kevinkasp I really like this.
@@adamc436 It's now gotten to the point that Oxford PPE graduates predominate at the top of the government, media, and business. They've been three of the last six Prime Ministers.
@@kevinkasp that is not a glowing endorsement of the University, ha ha.
@@jasondashney Yeah, a university having a program from which its graduates get the skills to rise to the top in business or government in countries around the world is evidence it’s a useless program.
Wait. What?
"They should realign their gut feelings based on the facts". Brilliant!
she's the cutest thing always following her brother
What a lovely new demographic to add to these interviews! And much appreciated in how you tuned in with them Peter!
Thank you. More SSE with children incoming!
He's being brought up well! So is his little sister - how patient was she!!
I am a teacher at an ALE (alternative learning environment) in Spokane, Washington. We are a project based school that promotes solution based thinking and a growth mindset. This is right up our alley. I will be using this for sure.
I’m impressed with the boy’s ability to articulate concepts which elude many adults. He may grow up some day to really solve some of societies biggest problems.
Wow, what a Legend. I jope that lad embraves his current personality and doesnt get corrupted or pursuaded away from it.
I jope so too
Crazy how he grasps an understanding of the philosophical limits of science at such a young age
Well done to the parents of these two, for raising them so well to be polite and well educated, a job well done... They give hope for the future 🙏
He just gave me hope for the future
Wonderful, bright articulate kids. I'm sure that their parents are very (and justifiably so! ) proud of them, and of the way they conducted themselves in this interview. Great job, you brilliant kiddos!
mom at the end pinpointed some key epistemological and moral thoughts patterns in her brilliant son and then walked off like it was just another day in the park.
I know for a fact that their mother and father are damn proud of these two. If this is our future, NURTURE!
These children are the best contestants that have ever played - street epistemology.
Normal science.
I didn't fully understand what a moral issue is until I was almost thirty. Embarrassing.
Man, this was interesting.
Good one.
You should go Live
Absolutely fantastic! That young man was able to articulate his answers better than most adults. Their parents must be so very proud of them both.
I would really love to see more younger ppl involved. ❤❤
He’s not a young man.he’s still a little boy. I don’t understand why people do this. It’s actually quite dangerous to mislabel because it allows society to get used to it and when something bad does happen to a 12 year old boy there’s no empathy or justice applied to him or whatever crime befalls him and we go on today he was a young man.
@@ricardocastro6320 ok weirdo! I hope you have a better new year!
Can’t believe his mum dressed him down slightly at the end. The young man is going places.
That kid is amazing. I'm impressed with his critical thinking skills at his age.
PLAY this for your kids. This is an excellent example of the type of content I like to share with my homeschooled kiddos. I would list this video under CRITICAL THINKING 101 high school level in their portfolio and transcripts. This could also be categorized under DEBATE 101: Learn to see all sides of a subject and argue logically for either. Debate and Critical Thinking were classes in school until just several decades ago. I wonder why they removed them from the curriculum? Nice that mom gave him a moment to really shine. I wonder where this will take him? Really cool video.
Based on his mom's comments, it will get him to a bit of new education from his mom to get beyond the excessive utilitarian tendencies.
Peter’s conversations are so illuminating. This format, generally, is extremely constructive intellectually. These children are such a joy. The little boy is very gifted and a wise soul. I wonder if his parents are proponents of a classical education.
Also, although Peter begins to focus exclusively on the boy, the young girl stays with the conversation and is listening intently as far as I can make out. This was exactly the environment I was raised in in a neighboring country - it was thrilling to hang out with the adults and hang on their words through their intellectual conversation.
What's interesting is that as you grow up, things you heard of those conversation start to makes sense much later. Sometimes not for 10, 20, 40 years, and you still remember the things that were said that didn't make sense to you at the time.
Breath of fresh air.The inteligence and family bond was so beautiful to see.
Loved the way the mum playfully fought her son at end .
What a beautiful family
Haha this is great. I know his mother too. She’s a fantastic law academic.
Then maybe you are in the perfect position to expand on her comment at the end about his utilitarian tendencies. Most people in the comments are talking about how wonderful that is, and I find it quite concerning. He clearly is not a psychopathic robot, so I don't understand why what he said requires some "deprogramming". I've been trying for years now to understand why people have such a visceral opposition to objectivity. I encounter this constantly and it's so frustrating. People actually get upset when you want evidence before you make opinions, and that the evidence takes priority over your feely-feels about a subject. The mom comes across as a slightly more grounded version of a typical campus leftist.
‘Utilitarianism does not take seriously the distinction between persons’.
Theres no way man just picked out one of the most inteligent and well spoken kids in london 🤣 hope that kid keeps it up, because hes going places ❤ awesome role model for his younger sister.
These two children give me a glimmer of hope for the future.
There is hope for this world.
The mom, "my son has some utilitarian and relativistic tendencies, we have to work on you." Hehe. Awesome. Great mom!, from the 11 min window we had into her life.
She didnt seems to fond of that
what an unbelivable video. i'm glad i clicked on this. I'll be honest, I was most blown away and how perceptive he was. The way he asked his sister about following him was mind boggling. Because He didnt say it in a playful way, he was completely perceptive of what she was doing. Incredible child.
I just love listening to British children. They get a great education.
Brilliant! Had to laugh at Mums comments about her son at the end as she pointed the finger. 😂 Got a feeling he's gonna do well.
what i was glad to see was that they still... "rough housed" for lack of a better term. She doesn't treat them like fragile butterflies, which is SUCH a difference from the typical "enlightened parent" that fits the stereotype.
@@CleverGirlAAH Agree completely. It was good to see 👍
The kid is awesome, Im truly amazed
I'd really like to see schools implement Peter's Street Epistemology exercise in their classrooms, or at least talk about it. This is my favorite series from this channel.
Let’s hope they do. It’s 100% free and easy to implement!
Oh my God! Such a smart boy! If adults would have just 1/3 of his reasoning... Amaizing. And the mother... Great! Congrats
The best epistemology str
you can tell their mother talks to them like real people, which is really beneficial for growth i think ❤
Such smart children❤ best wishes for them and their future,home fully they can spread their intellect to others
This kid is more articulate than I ever was or will be.
His explanation for not choosing between reason or feelings was unexpected and so impressive to me. Well it all was but that one got me 😮
Wooooooah, I want to be as articulate as this boy 😮
What amazing kids! Must have some amazing parents!
😲 🤯 Blimey ! who else feels inadequate after that ?
This perfectly illustrates the benefits of multi generational quality education.
The parents have the ability to guide and assist the childrens learning, which appears to be based on questions and considered thought, rather than being told what is correct, studying dates and so forth.
Private schooling allows children to challenge an idea in a meaningful way, giving them understanding of a topic, reasoning, logic, the use of critical thinking, much better than your standard highschool/comprehensive model can deliver.
Philosphy as a standard teaching tool in state schools? One can dream!
Children ARE brilliant the education system in the US crushes that by disempowering them and hyper focusing on route memorization and social nonsense. Preparing children for factory work and consumerism is not in alignment with critical thinking, or inspiring strength based learners.
Omnipresent Greetingz
This kid is so reasonable. His answer on decisions based on reason and emotion was so thoughtful and deep.
This kid would make a good judge.
There actually may be hope for the world with kids like this. Clearly his mother (or parents) have invested in their education, most likely at home and at school. I had to laugh at the end as their mother is clearly not a fan of Utilitarianism.
Very intelligent young man, most people don't reason that well until well into their 20s. If at all lol.
Luckily i was a gifted child too
"If at all" being the most likely outcome for most, unfortunately
I think the brightest part of this video was how the mom was joking with her kids at the end. To raise such a bright young mind and still be able to jest and mess around is a beautiful thing in my opinion
Strangers and different generations engaging in topics that capture their imaginations, bridging the previous lack of connection. Unplanned. Outdoors. Love it!
This kid would put the Woke North American university students to shame simply by using common sense.