Aapka konsa video hai Jo ummido pe khara nahi utar pata??? Har ek video aur topic is work everyone should appreciated. Great Work.. Keep it up.. New Topic for you 1. Misuse of RTI to pressurise govt. Servent. 2. Truth of Matrimonial Sites.
I'm a Goan and I thank you for this video. We goans sometimes feel left out from general discussion about Bharat as a whole. Our land is much more than just a party destination. We have suffered, we have struggled and we have prevailed. If you ever visit Goa feel free to say hello, I'll personally show you the real Goa. Cheers mate.
@@AdrenergicSquad @AdrenergicSquad well that's a little complicated to answer. Everyone is aware of everything. On one hand there is the obvious brainwashing that has been done over the period of generations at a point where it's not a very uncommon sight to see Christians car owners having Portuguese flags on their cars. But on the other hand you need to understand that the Christians enjoyed a lot of benefits under the Portuguese. Also, we are a small state and a very prosperous state at that but over the past 20-25 years we have had massive immigration from every corner of the country which honestly our state cannot handle and this has significantly changed our society and lifestyle for the worse. This has got to a point that if you come to Goa as a tourist you might stay in Goa and go back without even meeting a single real Goan. So this also plays a role of further solidifying the pre conceived notion that Christians have about India and Portugal. As a Hindu I feel connected to dharmic roots when we think about India but I feel the Catholics feel a bit left out. Like I said it's complicated and not black and white like most things in life but that's as much I can type 😄. cheers.
Some of you maybe unaware of post liberation mass migration of Goans into Karachi. Approximately 10K Goans unhappy with Indian annexation migrated to Karachi in 1964 via passenger vessels. Due to strong relationship of Pakistan with western nation these Goans anticipated better future in Pakistan compared to India. Looking at current state of Pakistan we all can understand that they made biggest mistake of their life yet they never admit.
@@sigma_sniper6141 Haa kuch Muslim banne par zada tar waha se America Europe bhag gaye. Kuch Jo bache hai unko waha secular show piece ke tarah rakha hai.
@@opvideocreator8469isiliye dual citizenship kabhi nahi Dena chahiye govt ko. In logo ki koi aastha nhi thi bharat me lekin bharat ka fayda aaj bhi uthana chahte hain
I am a konkani from Karnataka but my ancestors were from Goa. Our ancestral temples are still in Goa. We visit there few times a year. My father used to tell me how these Portugeese people tortured ur ancestors so much that many people had to run away to nearby states. You will find konkani people in Karnataka, Kerala, TN and Maharashtra. Our ancestors had to sacrifice their wealth, homes and even gods to escape. After independence from Portugeese, the newer generation rebuilt our temples and dig out our god's idols from wherever they were hidden.
Portugese inquisition was also another dark Chapter in Indian history which is not much talked about. They tortured, killed many Hindus and converted them to Christianity, destroying many temples. Shame to our history writers hiding the torture of Indians in Goa.
Indigenous Goans are the most patriotic people and I had the good fortune of visiting Goa during Dussehra celebrations! All vehicles were decorated which was unique to see!
@@srikrishnak196There is a mass immigration of people of UP and Bihar in Goa.....in state politics government criticise these immigrants for crimes which is 100% true and is facts....most of the crimes are commited by immigrants who came their from different states cause of job opportunities from tourism...
Which chapter of goan history was dark? The present or the past? As a goan Looking at what is happening in our goa today it looks like the darkest chapter of goan history is going on now.
@@Myworldisgoa really? Court of inquisition, forced conversions, ban on speaking native language, ban on singing folk songs, ban on taking bath in the morning, our temples were demolished and entire communities were forced to flee. Being a Hindu was a curse.
@@name.iz.blurryface from where you heard all this nonsense? From rss whatsApp university? Are you a goan were your ancestors present in goa during that period of time? An which folk songs were banned can you name any one folk song. Now tell me how will anybody come to know that you are having bath in the morning or night?
@@name.iz.blurryface what you know about inquisition? Can you tell me, can anybody be forcefully converted in catholic faith? This proves that you are a ghati from maharashtra who entered goa as beggars during Portuguese rule in such of employment.
@@Myworldisgoa my last name is literally Panjikar. Meaning people from Panjim. My ancestors were natives of Panjim. They had land, houses, farms etc. They were made to forcefully convert by Portuguese missionaries. They were deprived of basic needs. They had to run from Panjim leaving behind houses, farms, properties and livestock. You are being pure ignorant. Get out of the echo chamber and atleast acknowledge all the wrong that Portuguese done.
Very interesting video. Thanks for making this. So, we basically missed the bus by 1949 when Portugal became a NATO member and then had to wait for 10 years till taking military action was feasible. If we had done for Kashmir and Goa, the same we did for Hyderabad and Junagadh at the same time, the other two would also have been a part of India by 1947-48 itself.
There's no use, people of their ilk will always follow the wrong no matter what. Trying to make sence to these andhbhakts is like "throwing stone on liquid cow dung" translated from konkani saying. Only waiting for the day they witness the horror of rotten fruits of their vile intention & just like a neighbouring country down south, go through similar conciquences.
I'm from Daman and not just goa but Daman & Diu, Dadra Nagar Haveli was also under Portuguese rule and liberated with Goa. Goa was not a state when I was a kid. My Great Grand Father was a freedom fighter.
I am Goan , but not know Goan past that how being get freedom from Portugal and join in India , thanks for wonderful information about (past, history) of goa jai hind jai bharat 🇮🇳🚩
It was very unfortunate that India had to wait for 14 years after independence to move troops to Goa because of Nehru for not supporting Goa's satyagrahis . Thanks to Open Letter for covering the dark side of Goa's independence in this video.😊❤.
Bol to aise rha jaise pura India 100 saalo se Azad tha bs Goa occupied tha ac room unlimited internet ke sth bed pr baith kr aise cmmnt likhte jaise ye rehte to turant azadi dilwa dete
Isn't it the same with POK? Even when we are right now capable of taking it back by force we are waiting for the right moment so that it will become an integral part of India. And things have currently gotten a lot favourable and and everyone knows which party is ruling today. What im trying to say is that sometimes it really takes decades to put the final piece in place.
thanks for covering about. I'm from Goa my ancestors have gone through harsh inhumane acts by the Portuguese. will surely meet when u visit Goa and will show you the temple which was destroyed by the Portuguese.
My Grand uncle ( grand fathers younger brother) was a freedom fighter for liberation of Goa. He was martyred. Shaheed Mr. Camilo Pereira. He was unmarried at the time of martyr. Today there are 2 Government schools in Goa in his memorial. One is in Ponda and other in Baina, Vasco. There is alot of history. May all the martyrs be at peace 🕊️. ❤
Please read the book ' Gantabya Ekhono Ek Sabhyata Deri' by Debarati Mukhopadhyay. Here she explained the cruelty of Portuguese in her book in very much detail.
@@RandomUser-um2zq yes what is wrong in thinking that.. if you have written a book of such importance it should've have been validated... by the way the person is a literature student who wrote a fictional novel .... so I am not surprised that she isn't recognised...
I lived in the UK for few years and met many goans. Most of them acquired Portuguese passport through a Portuguese law loophole and moved to UK as Britain was s part of EU. These were mostly anglos with Pereira, Fernandez, Dias etc surname. They naturally support Portugal but what surprised me is that they don't like India. A person told me I'm a Goan snd not Indian
The only Indo-Portuguese (not Anglo) in Goa are Mestizo (a miniscule group - like a drop in the ocean). The people with surnames like Pereira, Fernandes, etc (non- Mestizo) are pure blue blooded native Goans. Hope this information enlightens you. Your little knowledge is offensive to the revered freedom fighters with those surnames who started the first freedom movement against the Portuguese rule. I am proud of my relatives who were freedom fighters.
@@lyndonrodrigues5030 blue blooded? You do know Goans are highly mixed aswell right the only true Goan blooded native to this land are the Kunbi and gond tribes others are all outsiders who changed the culture of Goa from ancient times.
First he got the votes CWC members not people second those were election for choosing Congress president you fool. And in elections for regularly 4 times people elected nehru as their pm😊😊
SARDAR PATEL routed NEHRU in the congress internal elections for PM post despite open support of Gandhi Later NEHRU BLACKMAILED GANDHI and took PM POSITION
@@SAFFRONINFERNO thats why education is important to get analytical skills. The elections was for party president post and nehru was already president in 1939.
Many oblivious tourists and specifically Hindus who visit the Basilica of bom Jesus that has the remains of St Francis Xavier have no idea about the kind of brutal torture that the Hindus of Goa had to face during that time for resisting to be forcefully converted to Christianity during the time when St Xavier was the arch diocese of Goa and it was carried out on the premises of where the church stands now so people need to do their research before visiting any of these places
Bruh, all the ancient kingdom forcefully coverted people to their religions, hindu kings forcefully converted them to hinduism, catholic King forecefully converted to catholicism 🥱
@@prashantnaik8273 Which Hindu King forcefully converted people to Hinduism. I don't know your source of information but it's rubbish because I think you are referring to Ashoka who converted people to Buddhism forcefully but those who reverted to Hinduism did after adi Shankaracharya made it his mission to spread the word across the country and did not happen by force but anyways what I was referring to the torture and forceful conversions that used to happen where the church is and many localities in Goa to know about their history unlike rest of the country
@@k-map224 every religion started like that , convertion to Hinduism was done way before like 5000 years ago, where you cannot find any traces , just be logical
@@prashantnaik8273 You are being illogical as you are unable to provide any proof. Hinduism spread across the far East to countries like Indonesia, Cambodia, malaysia but it was still not forcefully used to convert like the abrahamic religions that spread through violence and force. People in these countries used to accept Hinduism and Buddhism because their kings used to accept it but then abrahamic religions came in and forcefully converted them. It's the reality and few Hindus like yourself don't want to accept it because you have been brainwashed to think it's secularism but secularism means the separation of state and religion and not appeasement
It has become convenient for many Goan Christians to ignore the past atrocities of the Portuguese, especially wrt religious conversion, because that puts Christianity in a bad light. The proof lies in people who escaped from Goa to settle in the coastal region of Karnataka, as well as several temples demolished to be replaced by churches in the Portuguese era. You still have Goans who ran away with the god idols and set them up in the neighbouring states, those people still visit these relocated idols during festivals. The eyes of Goans twinkle only for the Portuguese passport which they can get which allows them easy job opportunities outside India!!
Not only Goans but Indians from every part of India have left India for good and more are leaving India for under Modi's rule and "Amrit Kaal" Gujaratis are paying agents money to illegally enter USA and Canada. You are very conveniently silent on this fact.
@@clarissiarodrigues4737 Fortunately, I am blessed with a good educational background so I do not need to pray for a portuguese passport like you guys. Unfortunately, most goans, especially those who lack in good educational skills just rely on this shortcut and are shamelessly proud about it. Fun fact: Though the Portuguese passport wielding goans feel pride in belonging to Portugal, they are incapable of even speaking Portuguese. All they use the Portuguese passport for is to get into the UK. Portugal is a pretty poor country in Europe, the locals in Portugal themselves try to get better paying jobs elsewhere such as in Germany, Netherlands and Switzerland. So what are you feeling proud of?
MrPratikPowar I hope you know that you too are a convert 🤣 should we forget that Hindus too have hurt Jains and Buddhists destroyed their temples well this is Karma for you people so don't cry.
It's actually very nice to know about Goa. Like said in the video, India in those days wasn’t exactly in a position where we could just attack easily without a significant retaliation. During the Indo - Pak war, it was thanks to the Soviet Union that we could help Bangladesh. But, in Goa's case, attacking earlier on may have lead to NATO retaliation in the form of unjust sanctions and such, which would have lead the whole nation to suffer. That would rather make the people of India hostile instead of supporting Goa if you consider the situation of our people just after Independence. As for the religious and cultural changes, those must be condemned.
I would like to correct you Open letter. At 3:46, Azad Gomantak Dal was a military organization established from the inspiration of Azad Hind Fauj and wasn't founded by Dr. Ram Manohar Lohia, who himself was an advocate of Satyagraha and did one in Margao on 18th June 1946. 18th June is celebrated as Revolution Day in Goa..
But inhe muslims ko isne maarne chor diya tha jabb Baluchistan ke raja ke offer ke baad bhi Baluchistan ko Bharat mein merge nahi kiya Parr yeh Bharat ka gadha musalman kabhi nahi samjhega😂😂😂😂
"Why did Nehru let Goa Suffer? | Goa Inquisition | Open Letter" **Introduction:** The video explores the historical context and intricacies surrounding the delay in the liberation of Goa from Portuguese rule and the criticisms levied against Jawaharlal Nehru, India's first Prime Minister, particularly by Prime Minister Modi. The narrative suggests that Nehru's reluctance to use military force was driven by a desire to maintain a peaceful image on the global stage. **Body:** 1. **Portuguese Rule in Goa (1500-1961):** - The Portuguese arrived in Goa in 1500 and ruled for 400 years, surpassing the British presence in India. - The Portuguese engaged in mass conversions, temple destruction, and enforced Christianity, influencing Goan society significantly. 2. **Activism against Portuguese Rule:** - Goa witnessed anti-Portuguese movements, with the Goa Congress Committee and Azad Gomantak Dal leading Satyagraha. - Despite local agitation, national leaders focused on ending British rule and paid less attention to liberating Goa. 3. **Nehru's Diplomatic Approach:** - Nehru's government initiated negotiations with the Portuguese government to avoid military conflict. - The diplomatic efforts faced challenges, including the intransigence of the Portuguese dictator Salazar. 4. **Global and Political Considerations:** - World War II dynamics played a role, as Portugal's neutrality gained support from the USA and NATO. - India's principled stance against aggression, as reflected in the Panchsheel Accord with China, also influenced decision-making. 5. **1961 Liberation of Goa:** - UN declaration of Goa as a non-self-governing territory in 1960 and favorable relations with the USA set the stage for India's move. - On December 18, 1961, Operation Vijay was executed, leading to the swift liberation of Goa in 36 hours. **Conclusion:** The video concludes by highlighting the criticisms Nehru faced for not liberating Goa earlier and the subsequent positive changes in relations between India and Portugal after the liberation. It underscores the geopolitical complexities, diplomatic considerations, and global dynamics that shaped the decision-making process. **Nuances and Controversies:** - The reluctance of Nehru to use military force is portrayed as a strategic decision influenced by global politics, principled non-aggression, and the fear of escalation with China. - Criticisms of Nehru's decision are presented, with Defense Minister Krishna Menon accused of misleading Nehru and an apparent disconnect between national leaders and the local Goan movements. **Terminology and Case Studies:** - Operation Vijay: The military operation conducted by India to liberate Goa in 1961. - Salazar: The Portuguese dictator whose stubbornness complicated negotiations for Goa's liberation. - Panchsheel Accord: A set of principles signed between India and China, emphasizing peaceful coexistence. This comprehensive summary provides an in-depth understanding of the historical events, political decisions, and global factors that shaped the delay and eventual liberation of Goa from Portuguese rule.
This is the difference between Congress and BJP supporters. Congress hired intellectuals to show their side of the story whereas the BJP couldn't do it and convince their version of the history.
@@millennialmind9507my English is very poor , I didn't understand your comment properly, but I just know BJP is better than congress or others party ... Jai shree ram 🚩♥️
@@rnop8432 atleast they claim to be 😅, Remember, Non left doesn't care about humanities, that's bad. But left eventually takes over humanities, that's worse
As a Pakistani history I know that Pakistan and India got independent in 1947 British ruled us, I was very shocked to hear that France and Portugal also ruled and some states of India got independent in 1954 and 1961.😢😢😢
Bangladeshis being Muslims sustained their native language and culture, but West Punjab lost it’s Punjabi identity, and got colonized with Urdu which was never even native to Punjab.
🕉 Satyameva Jayate: Truth and Honesty and Reality gets created when Good Thoughts, Good Deeds, Good Acts are allowed to achieve the small steps needed for the correct choices and correct decisions to be made. Satyameva Jayate
The way Narendra Modi, criticised Nehru on this topic, now it will be played again and again and again in Godi media & those will be consumed by common people and they will stock up some more hatred for Nehru. That's how it is going & it will be going, unfortunately. But thanks to you for highlighting the facts. There is an excellent explanation on Nehru as a PM by Adharsh Gupta of Study IQ. At some point, Adarsh said, Yes, Nehru did make so many mistakes, but at that time Nehru did not have any ideal example of running such a huge democracy alongside being involved in a few wars, witnessing drought etc. So, I think He made few mistakes, from his mistakes our present PM should learn. But they should not use his mistakes as a weapon of blame-game & election winning tool.
Lehru chicha apke chicha hain kya Jo itna ro rahe .... By the way jo khud dusron ki godi mein baithkar ghulami karte hain woh ek section of media ko godi media kehte hain 😂😂😂😂
@@technoyamraj I acknowledge both Nehru's Blunder or Failure as well as his achievements. But your sentences prove you that you're a narrow minded conservative Godi media product! Thanks!
*Mistakes should be highlighted for future benefits and to avoid repeating them and Modi criticizes Nehru only for his mistakes. Nehru ji and Gandhi ji didn't care about his own people but gives lecture to others on human rights. They had done so many mistakes that India has to suffer till now and sadly don't know when it will be over. Modi doesn't play blame game, he just highlights mistakes only for national benefits so that every Indian can remember. Keep in mind, when roots are weaker than in future everyone has to suffer .*
Mai 18 saal ka hu aur mujhe aaj tak iska koi idea bhi ni tha ki goa azad nahi hua itne saalo tak thanks to ncert history textbooks which doesn't have any information about this
This story gave me goose bumps. I hope we get to see this as a movie someday so people know and remember the story of Goa. Can you cover this more in detail about all the Vasco da Gama, conversion, the hardships of Goans more in details?
Arree ghatia before posting comments learn something about goa an then post your comments, listening to some fanatics who have no connection to goa an posting comments will only end up making a fool of yourself.
😂😂sahi hai bhai tum jaise jo unke saamne khade rehne ki aukat na rkhte ho vo bhi bologe . Sahi hai acha vaise aap kitne se jail me rhe ho nehru ji ya veer savarkar , Patel ji ki tarah . Jab unke bare me pta na ho to Kam se kam chup rho kisi ki bhi disrespect krne se koi fayda nahi hai 😅
Emotional touched by dark side.....Brighter side, at present Goan still give up Indian Citizenship to go Portugal n still 60% Goan food part of Portuguese cuisine. Goa is tourist destination, what our rest Indian come here 2 do everybody knows....
Goa is a tourist destination thanks to cheap alcohol and illegal drugs. That’s not something to boast about. And the Goans migrating to Portugal just rush off to the UK, because Portugal itself is a poor country by EU standards. And not all of them are highly qualified, they just do menial jobs in the UK. It’s one thing to be proud of working abroad because of your qualifications, but there is nothing to be proud of getting to go to Portugal in this manner!!
excellent analysis. Sardar Vallabhabhi Patel was the firm Home Minister has sent military to save jammu Kashmir to fight against Pakistan intruder after Independence save J&K as part of India.Like this Home Minister's Police Action against NIZAM regimes and joined this states to India. Sardar Vallabhabhi Patel was not alive at the time of Goa and Pondecherry.🎉🎉🎉🎉🎉🎉🎉🎉🎉🎉🎉
I need to make it clear that i am not in favour of Nehru nor Modi but to state the truth , Nehru led us through really unpredictable and unfavourable times , might be possible that he took long time to make up bold decisions but at the same time it is necessary to understand the situations that were at that time . Hadnt his decisions worked well in case of goa still today we would have criticized him for doing so. Its like we will criticize the person in any case possible.
यह वीडियो सच्चे इतिहास को प्रस्तुत करने का एक महत्वपूर्ण प्रयास है। भारतीय जनता पार्टी के नेता और कार्यकर्ता अक्सर यह कहते हुए नजर आते हैं कि भारत की आजादी के 14 साल बाद तक गोवा को मुक्त क्यों नहीं किया गया, और इस देरी का पूरा दोष पंडित जवाहरलाल नेहरू पर डालने का प्रयास किया जाता है। जबकि वास्तविकता यह है कि भारत को आजादी ब्रिटिशों से मिली थी, जबकि गोवा पर पुर्तगालियों का शासन था। नेहरू सरकार ने इस दिशा में कई प्रयास किए थे, जिन्हें अक्सर नजरअंदाज कर दिया जाता है। आपने अपने वीडियो में इन सभी कारणों का गहन विश्लेषण किया है। सामान्य जनता अक्सर इतिहास की गहराइयों से अनभिज्ञ होती है, और कुछ लोग इसी का फायदा उठाकर समाज को भ्रमित करने का प्रयास करते हैं। इसलिए, इतिहास को सही तरीके से समझने के लिए आपका यह प्रयास अत्यंत महत्वपूर्ण है। यह वीडियो अधिक से अधिक लोगों को देखना चाहिए। धन्यवाद।
I am a Goan ,studied in convent school, every word you mentioned is true. My Christian teachers were acknowledging their hindu ancestry before Portuguese came here. Also people should read a book by Dr. Tb. CUNHA "DE nationalizationof Goa" this book is not available easily.
Really amazed to see such a great piece of history, wonderfully articulated by you. Shamefully none of this was taught in the history texts during our schooling days. Hats off to you for this marvellous vdo! May you bring our more of such glorious chapters of Indian History, and may the present Govt make all efforts in re-writing our history, and thus giving back our glorious past at least to all of our future generations. Jai Hind. Bharat Mata ki jai. 👌👏👍🤩🙏🇮🇳
The supreme art of war is to subdue the enemy without fighting. A brilliant statesman can very well play the balls without firing a single shot. The enemy might be mighty with most powerful army. But it will bend its knees before tactful diplomacy.
Can you please do video before Portuguese come Goa?And what happen in Before Goa annexture ,how small mini kings fights each small kingdoms looting innocent poor people ,pls you best short story n nice . Pls do nice one.
I'm from GOA, our ancestors were very happy with Portugal rule not like RSS ruling in Goa, Portugal has captured 25 to 30 % Maharashtra land which are not Goan that the reason HINDU are in majority There is a big difference between Goan HINDU and Maharashtra HINDU
@@NailsByAsh813 dosent matter if hes a convert or not, the indians came in goa and made it a ghatti shed and the beggars in mapusa market arent taken out.
@@TroyPereira1RO Indians never came to Goa, they were already there. So keep your cheap talk to yourself. It's better than missionary shed. If you have any issues with other religions living in Goa, then you should seek residency in Portugal. 🤣🤣😂😂
@@NailsByAsh813 i did not mention hate against another religion, the problem is the government which is destroying goa,even if the land belongs to the indians, they dont know how to behave propely and come in goa and make ghattis, also im talking about ghattis (the people from other states that come in goa and are bad) the indians dont enforce strict laws, the Portuguese enforce strict laws, so basically the indians dont enforce laws that much.
@@TroyPereira1RO You are talking about my people here. I am Marathi and we are called ghattis. That's very much hateful and bigoted of you to use that in derogatory manner. Don't forget Goa is infamous for what kinda lifestyle. So if you support such wild and degenerate lifestyle, then you can't lecture others here.
I am a proud christian not because the portuguese forced me but because of the values of christianity. This is about freedom of religion. Due to this, in the present Christians in Goa are victims of the religious disputes. People should learn to distinguish between religion and politics before criticism.
Just very important historical context here . For independent India there was so much pressure from western nations for liberation of Goa. Imagine if Portuguese had 5 times the area of Goa under occupation. This was the exact case before 1739. Almost all of western Konkan coast from Vasai , thane, Bandra , till Ratnagiri were under Portuguese control .. It was great Maratha chimmaji appa the brother of great Baji Rao Peshwa who prevented this . He freed total western coast from Portuguese hands with his final victory at Vasai fort . This was the first set back Portuguese had faced in 200 years after setting foot in India . Staggering total number of 1 lakh soldiers were involved in this campaign from Maratha side . 20 thousand soldiers had died in this battle achieving important victory. Also this was coming at crucial times 1739 This is the year when north India was attacked By Nader shah . Peshwa Baji Rao wanted to intervene nader shah for ultimate battle. Preparation were also done 35 thousand army was also gathered and was waiting for other maratha armies to gather. But as fate had it bulk of Maratha army with best cannons and European trained soldiers were fighting against Portuguese wich was drawn to almost 1 year . Infact Peshwa Baji Rao had arguments with his brother chimaji appa regarding this. Ultimately Peshwa Baji Rao dropped the plan as troops couldn’t reach in time in sufficient numbers . And north India suffered brutal destruction and looting at hands of Nader shah.
Lets not forget coastal Kannada kings and queens who gave shelter to goa people when Portuguese attacked and trying to convert them. Rani Chennabhairadevi gave shelter to many immigrants thats why some of the population in north coastal region speaka konkani. But Nowadays everybody has forgotten the pepper queen Chennabhairadevi.
I am a Goan born n brought up in Goa , have gone around the world for Nine world cruisings ,being a continental chef on passenger cruise liners ,visited Lisbon, n many other places in Portugal ,n my first comment on alighting from the ship n walking in n around city of Lisboa, which is Lisbon the capital city ,so clean, dust free, no stones or pebbles or straw or sticks to be found ,so clean ,no spitting on the streets, walls, no urination on roadside, strict sense of discipline,even paupers , beggars well dressed with suit, boots tie, n a clean begging bowl with a hat on head, pleases any common man to help out with some dollars or escudos,. My first comment was ,if Portuguese were not driven away ,than our loving Goa would be shining star of cleanliness n zero tolerance of roadside strewn garbagge, thanks to all who came to Goa ,after liberation n settled n are now contributing to the dritiness n filthy stinky,slums n sites ,of which the ruling govt. is proud n a failure in keeping up the Portuguese type of cleanliness in Goa.
@@deadlytsg2792congress party always choose muslim side ,congress ne artical 5 of NATO ke wajat se Goa par attract nahi kiya ,vo log uss time me Goa ma bahot logo ko force kara convert Kara ja raha tha, hinduo ko mara ja raha tha , temple thod kar cruch banai ja raha tha , uska bad nhe Congress ne kuch nahi kiya ??? Agar vo attack karta to bahot chance tha ke croro hindu Zinda Bach jata ....
@@NailsByAsh813 excuseme you are not a victim of colonisation so don't talk extra, and am not making a mockery, first learn your history properly! Don't be an ignorant and pretend that everybody has hurt Indians and Indians are innocent, no! First educate yourself on who and what it is to be an Indian. Unfortunately most Indians don't know this.
For nehru, his image was more important than India. For Netaji, India was more important than his life. For Modi, India is more important than his life. That's the difference.
@@tonylee1868Every State Has His Chosen People who made CM of State If U Ask About a PM Then Plz Explain About. CM Regimen Is just for Cartoon Motions?
Bhai the best thing about your videos is that they are to the fact, non-biased. I may not be a Nehru supporter but the way you presented the geo-political scenario of that time, we can give him a benefit of doubt regarding his intentions. Rest there may be many mistakes done by Nehru which we reflect from current perspective but need to give room for prevailing reasonings of that time also. Very good video. All the best for many such future videos.
@@aarushpandey8013im frm manipur and many illegal immigrant are from myammar entering manipur. Kukis are getting many arms and ammunition from isreal supply
Video kaisa laga? ❤️
Ekdum Badhiyaa👍
Also make on Pakistan like geopolitics of it in a non biased way
Bakwass
Aapka konsa video hai Jo ummido pe khara nahi utar pata??? Har ek video aur topic is work everyone should appreciated. Great Work.. Keep it up..
New Topic for you
1. Misuse of RTI to pressurise govt. Servent.
2. Truth of Matrimonial Sites.
Jharkhand also........🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏
I'm a Goan and I thank you for this video. We goans sometimes feel left out from general discussion about Bharat as a whole. Our land is much more than just a party destination. We have suffered, we have struggled and we have prevailed. If you ever visit Goa feel free to say hello, I'll personally show you the real Goa. Cheers mate.
Are Christian goans aware of this history ? If so why don't they revert back to sanatan ?
@@AdrenergicSquad @AdrenergicSquad well that's a little complicated to answer. Everyone is aware of everything. On one hand there is the obvious brainwashing that has been done over the period of generations at a point where it's not a very uncommon sight to see Christians car owners having Portuguese flags on their cars. But on the other hand you need to understand that the Christians enjoyed a lot of benefits under the Portuguese. Also, we are a small state and a very prosperous state at that but over the past 20-25 years we have had massive immigration from every corner of the country which honestly our state cannot handle and this has significantly changed our society and lifestyle for the worse. This has got to a point that if you come to Goa as a tourist you might stay in Goa and go back without even meeting a single real Goan. So this also plays a role of further solidifying the pre conceived notion that Christians have about India and Portugal. As a Hindu I feel connected to dharmic roots when we think about India but I feel the Catholics feel a bit left out. Like I said it's complicated and not black and white like most things in life but that's as much I can type 😄. cheers.
Right hdtothe
Could you share your contact number?
Perfect explanation bro@@HDtothe8
Some of you maybe unaware of post liberation mass migration of Goans into Karachi. Approximately 10K Goans unhappy with Indian annexation migrated to Karachi in 1964 via passenger vessels. Due to strong relationship of Pakistan with western nation these Goans anticipated better future in Pakistan compared to India. Looking at current state of Pakistan we all can understand that they made biggest mistake of their life yet they never admit.
Sab Muslim bann gaya hoga forcefully 😂
There are many goans who gave their indian citizenship and became portugese citizen they now demand dual citizenship
@@sigma_sniper6141 Haa kuch Muslim banne par zada tar waha se America Europe bhag gaye. Kuch Jo bache hai unko waha secular show piece ke tarah rakha hai.
@@opvideocreator8469 There are many NRIs demanding dual citizenship but eventually it's all upto the intentions of their demand.
@@opvideocreator8469isiliye dual citizenship kabhi nahi Dena chahiye govt ko. In logo ki koi aastha nhi thi bharat me lekin bharat ka fayda aaj bhi uthana chahte hain
I am a konkani from Karnataka but my ancestors were from Goa. Our ancestral temples are still in Goa. We visit there few times a year. My father used to tell me how these Portugeese people tortured ur ancestors so much that many people had to run away to nearby states. You will find konkani people in Karnataka, Kerala, TN and Maharashtra. Our ancestors had to sacrifice their wealth, homes and even gods to escape. After independence from Portugeese, the newer generation rebuilt our temples and dig out our god's idols from wherever they were hidden.
I'm form Mangalore, belong to Kudubi/kunabi tribe of Goa.
Well done 👍
Portugese inquisition was also another dark Chapter in Indian history which is not much talked about.
They tortured, killed many Hindus and converted them to Christianity, destroying many temples.
Shame to our history writers hiding the torture of Indians in Goa.
Yes
Nehru biggest mistake is religious politics of muslim appeasement.
Absolutely right
#jaishreeRam
So?
@muhammedjaseemshaje ilsam spread the same way. Without lies ilsam dies.
Indigenous Goans are the most patriotic people and I had the good fortune of visiting Goa during Dussehra celebrations! All vehicles were decorated which was unique to see!
Great observation 👍🏼
@@abhishek.chakraborty Thanks Bhai 🙏
What do you mean by "indigenous goans" ?
@@srikrishnak196pindus
@@srikrishnak196There is a mass immigration of people of UP and Bihar in Goa.....in state politics government criticise these immigrants for crimes which is 100% true and is facts....most of the crimes are commited by immigrants who came their from different states cause of job opportunities from tourism...
Glad to see you sharing the dark chapter of Goa with the rest of India.
Which chapter of goan history was dark? The present or the past? As a goan Looking at what is happening in our goa today it looks like the darkest chapter of goan history is going on now.
@@Myworldisgoa really? Court of inquisition, forced conversions, ban on speaking native language, ban on singing folk songs, ban on taking bath in the morning, our temples were demolished and entire communities were forced to flee. Being a Hindu was a curse.
@@name.iz.blurryface from where you heard all this nonsense? From rss whatsApp university? Are you a goan were your ancestors present in goa during that period of time? An which folk songs were banned can you name any one folk song. Now tell me how will anybody come to know that you are having bath in the morning or night?
@@name.iz.blurryface what you know about inquisition? Can you tell me, can anybody be forcefully converted in catholic faith? This proves that you are a ghati from maharashtra who entered goa as beggars during Portuguese rule in such of employment.
@@Myworldisgoa my last name is literally Panjikar. Meaning people from Panjim. My ancestors were natives of Panjim. They had land, houses, farms etc. They were made to forcefully convert by Portuguese missionaries. They were deprived of basic needs. They had to run from Panjim leaving behind houses, farms, properties and livestock. You are being pure ignorant. Get out of the echo chamber and atleast acknowledge all the wrong that Portuguese done.
Thank you for covering this topic. My grandfather was a part of the navy support during the liberation of goa
🙏🙏🙏👍👍
EFF OHHH to ur father a pimp of invadors
@@navelimforgoa7107 seems like a Portuguese rascal is left out in india,kyun beta Portugal ka visa nhi mila kya ??
Very interesting video. Thanks for making this. So, we basically missed the bus by 1949 when Portugal became a NATO member and then had to wait for 10 years till taking military action was feasible. If we had done for Kashmir and Goa, the same we did for Hyderabad and Junagadh at the same time, the other two would also have been a part of India by 1947-48 itself.
400 years finished in 36 hours...
Shows strength of MY COUNTRY BROTHERS !♥️🔥
@user-SkmBeatsdid you understand the video??it was a Congress led govt that got goa back
How , to show strength
No balls to show the same to China
I hope your bjp government has some balls to answer china
@@navelimforgoa7107 Goa is part of India Today. Not Portugual you flithy Christian dukar
I am from Goa and can tell..we are the most peaceful state.. Don't really care about what happened in past. It is important how we progress forward..
There's no use, people of their ilk will always follow the wrong no matter what. Trying to make sence to these andhbhakts is like "throwing stone on liquid cow dung" translated from konkani saying. Only waiting for the day they witness the horror of rotten fruits of their vile intention & just like a neighbouring country down south, go through similar conciquences.
True buddy❤
You should care . You should know about your history
Those who don't care about their past are prone to make same mistakes in their future.
@@PZdw992 what rubbish are the talking? The temples are very much intact today and flourishing...
I'm from Daman and not just goa but Daman & Diu, Dadra Nagar Haveli was also under Portuguese rule and liberated with Goa. Goa was not a state when I was a kid. My Great Grand Father was a freedom fighter.
@@dobil6815 Portuguese left Dadra and Nagar Haveli much before Goa's liberation.
I am Goan , but not know Goan past that how being get freedom from Portugal and join in India , thanks for wonderful information about (past, history) of goa jai hind jai bharat 🇮🇳🚩
It was very unfortunate that India had to wait for 14 years after independence to move troops to Goa because of Nehru for not supporting Goa's satyagrahis . Thanks to Open Letter for covering the dark side of Goa's independence in this video.😊❤.
@@AashishKumar-bm5lh🤣🤣🤣 channel ka naam ha bhai jispe tu comment kr rha ha🤣🤣
Bol to aise rha jaise pura India 100 saalo se Azad tha bs Goa occupied tha ac room unlimited internet ke sth bed pr baith kr aise cmmnt likhte jaise ye rehte to turant azadi dilwa dete
Isn't it the same with POK? Even when we are right now capable of taking it back by force we are waiting for the right moment so that it will become an integral part of India. And things have currently gotten a lot favourable and and everyone knows which party is ruling today.
What im trying to say is that sometimes it really takes decades to put the final piece in place.
@@manthanpole7980POK was gifted to PORKISTAN by POPPATLAL NEHRU who went to UN
Goa was never gifted to anyone
@@tahahahaaaAZAD nahi hua tha tho ek mahatma Banke ghoom rahe hai uska kya
thanks for covering about. I'm from Goa my ancestors have gone through harsh inhumane acts by the Portuguese. will surely meet when u visit Goa and will show you the temple which was destroyed by the Portuguese.
My Grand uncle ( grand fathers younger brother) was a freedom fighter for liberation of Goa. He was martyred. Shaheed Mr. Camilo Pereira. He was unmarried at the time of martyr. Today there are 2 Government schools in Goa in his memorial. One is in Ponda and other in Baina, Vasco. There is alot of history. May all the martyrs be at peace 🕊️. ❤
This need to come on national news. There’s lot happening in Goa.
Hats off to you for making such a informative video.
Bhai, you forgot to mention the resistance against Portuguese by Indian warriors like Rani abbakka, Sambhaji maharaj and chimaji appa.
Actually ..he forgot it
Please read the book ' Gantabya Ekhono Ek Sabhyata Deri' by Debarati Mukhopadhyay. Here she explained the cruelty of Portuguese in her book in very much detail.
The writer doesn't even have a Wikipedia page. I don't believe of her writing a fictional novel or history.
@@ranadityapandey4458you'r statement makes any sense?
even tiktoker has a wiki page!
@@ranadityapandey4458 she is a Bengali writer. Please search on Google. The novel is based on research.
@@ranadityapandey4458imagine thinking that the person is a con just because that person doesn't even have a "Wikipedia Page".
@@RandomUser-um2zq yes what is wrong in thinking that.. if you have written a book of such importance it should've have been validated...
by the way the person is a literature student who wrote a fictional novel ....
so I am not surprised that she isn't recognised...
Thanks for your awesome work. Relevance, facts and commentary - 100/100.
I lived in the UK for few years and met many goans. Most of them acquired Portuguese passport through a Portuguese law loophole and moved to UK as Britain was s part of EU. These were mostly anglos with Pereira, Fernandez, Dias etc surname. They naturally support Portugal but what surprised me is that they don't like India. A person told me I'm a Goan snd not Indian
Hhhmm
Even Hindus hate each other 😂
im a goan-Portuguese and it makes sense why they dont like india, corrupt government and many more reasons.
The only Indo-Portuguese (not Anglo) in Goa are Mestizo (a miniscule group - like a drop in the ocean). The people with surnames like Pereira, Fernandes, etc (non- Mestizo) are pure blue blooded native Goans. Hope this information enlightens you. Your little knowledge is offensive to the revered freedom fighters with those surnames who started the first freedom movement against the Portuguese rule. I am proud of my relatives who were freedom fighters.
@@lyndonrodrigues5030 blue blooded? You do know Goans are highly mixed aswell right the only true Goan blooded native to this land are the Kunbi and gond tribes others are all outsiders who changed the culture of Goa from ancient times.
Good information 🙏, Hindus were divided into internal caste division,so everyone used the issue and oppressed.
Ghanta 😂
@@technoyamraj What's so funny in this huh??? 😡
@@swinil1103 nothing is funny I am just humorously negating his comment ....
Relax man go take some shower and chill 😂
Good to see this topic is took by you and maybe someone and no one else. A subscriber from Goa. ❤️🇮🇳
If Sardar Patel was the first PM which he gained maximum major votes, our borders would be different today.
First he got the votes CWC members not people second those were election for choosing Congress president you fool. And in elections for regularly 4 times people elected nehru as their pm😊😊
Pakistan had never been created and Myanmar, bhutan, sri lanka, tibet, maldives , nepal had never been separated
SARDAR PATEL routed NEHRU in the congress internal elections for PM post despite open support of Gandhi
Later NEHRU BLACKMAILED GANDHI and took PM POSITION
@@SAFFRONINFERNO thats why education is important to get analytical skills. The elections was for party president post and nehru was already president in 1939.
@@unknownboy8186 CHEW TEA.
HERE ELECTIONS WERE CONDUCTED FOR PM POSITION NOT PRESIDENT
Thank you for covering this topic my grandfather was a part of the navy support during the liberation of goa
Many oblivious tourists and specifically Hindus who visit the Basilica of bom Jesus that has the remains of St Francis Xavier have no idea about the kind of brutal torture that the Hindus of Goa had to face during that time for resisting to be forcefully converted to Christianity during the time when St Xavier was the arch diocese of Goa and it was carried out on the premises of where the church stands now so people need to do their research before visiting any of these places
@@AndWeWillNeverBeAloneAgainand no wonder why ☭ always fails almost everywhere.
Bruh, all the ancient kingdom forcefully coverted people to their religions, hindu kings forcefully converted them to hinduism, catholic King forecefully converted to catholicism 🥱
@@prashantnaik8273 Which Hindu King forcefully converted people to Hinduism. I don't know your source of information but it's rubbish because I think you are referring to Ashoka who converted people to Buddhism forcefully but those who reverted to Hinduism did after adi Shankaracharya made it his mission to spread the word across the country and did not happen by force but anyways what I was referring to the torture and forceful conversions that used to happen where the church is and many localities in Goa to know about their history unlike rest of the country
@@k-map224 every religion started like that , convertion to Hinduism was done way before like 5000 years ago, where you cannot find any traces , just be logical
@@prashantnaik8273 You are being illogical as you are unable to provide any proof. Hinduism spread across the far East to countries like Indonesia, Cambodia, malaysia but it was still not forcefully used to convert like the abrahamic religions that spread through violence and force. People in these countries used to accept Hinduism and Buddhism because their kings used to accept it but then abrahamic religions came in and forcefully converted them. It's the reality and few Hindus like yourself don't want to accept it because you have been brainwashed to think it's secularism but secularism means the separation of state and religion and not appeasement
One of my patient was a soldier from goa war.. he was telling the horrers of portugese and how they made a plan and attacked ..
It has become convenient for many Goan Christians to ignore the past atrocities of the Portuguese, especially wrt religious conversion, because that puts Christianity in a bad light. The proof lies in people who escaped from Goa to settle in the coastal region of Karnataka, as well as several temples demolished to be replaced by churches in the Portuguese era. You still have Goans who ran away with the god idols and set them up in the neighbouring states, those people still visit these relocated idols during festivals. The eyes of Goans twinkle only for the Portuguese passport which they can get which allows them easy job opportunities outside India!!
Not only Goans but Indians from every part of India have left India for good and more are leaving India for under Modi's rule and "Amrit Kaal" Gujaratis are paying agents money to illegally enter USA and Canada. You are very conveniently silent on this fact.
Don't cry u won't get Portuguese passport.. Only real goans ll get 😂🤣
@@clarissiarodrigues4737 Fortunately, I am blessed with a good educational background so I do not need to pray for a portuguese passport like you guys. Unfortunately, most goans, especially those who lack in good educational skills just rely on this shortcut and are shamelessly proud about it.
Fun fact: Though the Portuguese passport wielding goans feel pride in belonging to Portugal, they are incapable of even speaking Portuguese. All they use the Portuguese passport for is to get into the UK.
Portugal is a pretty poor country in Europe, the locals in Portugal themselves try to get better paying jobs elsewhere such as in Germany, Netherlands and Switzerland. So what are you feeling proud of?
@@clarissiarodrigues4737 even Gujrathis get
MrPratikPowar I hope you know that you too are a convert 🤣 should we forget that Hindus too have hurt Jains and Buddhists destroyed their temples well this is Karma for you people so don't cry.
It's actually very nice to know about Goa. Like said in the video, India in those days wasn’t exactly in a position where we could just attack easily without a significant retaliation. During the Indo - Pak war, it was thanks to the Soviet Union that we could help Bangladesh. But, in Goa's case, attacking earlier on may have lead to NATO retaliation in the form of unjust sanctions and such, which would have lead the whole nation to suffer. That would rather make the people of India hostile instead of supporting Goa if you consider the situation of our people just after Independence.
As for the religious and cultural changes, those must be condemned.
RSS Chaddis and their illiterate PM Feku modi doesn’t know the geopolitical situation of 1950’s just keeps barking 😂😂😂😂
Thank you for this video 🙏 love from Goa ❤
I would like to correct you Open letter. At 3:46, Azad Gomantak Dal was a military organization established from the inspiration of Azad Hind Fauj and wasn't founded by Dr. Ram Manohar Lohia, who himself was an advocate of Satyagraha and did one in Margao on 18th June 1946. 18th June is celebrated as Revolution Day in Goa..
Nehru biggest mistake is religious politics of muslim appeasement.
He himself created Pakistan for Muslims then why would he appease them, LoL😂😂
But inhe muslims ko isne maarne chor diya tha jabb Baluchistan ke raja ke offer ke baad bhi Baluchistan ko Bharat mein merge nahi kiya
Parr yeh Bharat ka gadha musalman kabhi nahi samjhega😂😂😂😂
Andhgobarbhakt
@@Hypocrisybuster1agaya Congress camel piss enjoyer
@@Hypocrisybuster1 Andh namazi
Thank you for this video 🙏 love from Goa ❤😍
bhai , i am from goa and thanks for sharing this very informative video.
"Why did Nehru let Goa Suffer? | Goa Inquisition | Open Letter"
**Introduction:**
The video explores the historical context and intricacies surrounding the delay in the liberation of Goa from Portuguese rule and the criticisms levied against Jawaharlal Nehru, India's first Prime Minister, particularly by Prime Minister Modi. The narrative suggests that Nehru's reluctance to use military force was driven by a desire to maintain a peaceful image on the global stage.
**Body:**
1. **Portuguese Rule in Goa (1500-1961):**
- The Portuguese arrived in Goa in 1500 and ruled for 400 years, surpassing the British presence in India.
- The Portuguese engaged in mass conversions, temple destruction, and enforced Christianity, influencing Goan society significantly.
2. **Activism against Portuguese Rule:**
- Goa witnessed anti-Portuguese movements, with the Goa Congress Committee and Azad Gomantak Dal leading Satyagraha.
- Despite local agitation, national leaders focused on ending British rule and paid less attention to liberating Goa.
3. **Nehru's Diplomatic Approach:**
- Nehru's government initiated negotiations with the Portuguese government to avoid military conflict.
- The diplomatic efforts faced challenges, including the intransigence of the Portuguese dictator Salazar.
4. **Global and Political Considerations:**
- World War II dynamics played a role, as Portugal's neutrality gained support from the USA and NATO.
- India's principled stance against aggression, as reflected in the Panchsheel Accord with China, also influenced decision-making.
5. **1961 Liberation of Goa:**
- UN declaration of Goa as a non-self-governing territory in 1960 and favorable relations with the USA set the stage for India's move.
- On December 18, 1961, Operation Vijay was executed, leading to the swift liberation of Goa in 36 hours.
**Conclusion:**
The video concludes by highlighting the criticisms Nehru faced for not liberating Goa earlier and the subsequent positive changes in relations between India and Portugal after the liberation. It underscores the geopolitical complexities, diplomatic considerations, and global dynamics that shaped the decision-making process.
**Nuances and Controversies:**
- The reluctance of Nehru to use military force is portrayed as a strategic decision influenced by global politics, principled non-aggression, and the fear of escalation with China.
- Criticisms of Nehru's decision are presented, with Defense Minister Krishna Menon accused of misleading Nehru and an apparent disconnect between national leaders and the local Goan movements.
**Terminology and Case Studies:**
- Operation Vijay: The military operation conducted by India to liberate Goa in 1961.
- Salazar: The Portuguese dictator whose stubbornness complicated negotiations for Goa's liberation.
- Panchsheel Accord: A set of principles signed between India and China, emphasizing peaceful coexistence.
This comprehensive summary provides an in-depth understanding of the historical events, political decisions, and global factors that shaped the delay and eventual liberation of Goa from Portuguese rule.
This is the difference between Congress and BJP supporters. Congress hired intellectuals to show their side of the story whereas the BJP couldn't do it and convince their version of the history.
@@millennialmind9507my English is very poor , I didn't understand your comment properly, but I just know BJP is better than congress or others party ... Jai shree ram 🚩♥️
@@millennialmind9507intellectual 😂
@@rnop8432 atleast they claim to be 😅,
Remember, Non left doesn't care about humanities, that's bad. But left eventually takes over humanities, that's worse
Which ai...?
As a Pakistani history I know that Pakistan and India got independent in 1947 British ruled us, I was very shocked to hear that France and Portugal also ruled and some states of India got independent in 1954 and 1961.😢😢😢
Bangladeshis being Muslims sustained their native language and culture, but West Punjab lost it’s Punjabi identity, and got colonized with Urdu which was never even native to Punjab.
very helpful for my UPSC journey thanks a lot buddy❣❣
Interesting video, Explained very well!!!
🕉 Satyameva Jayate: Truth and Honesty and Reality gets created when Good Thoughts, Good Deeds, Good Acts are allowed to achieve the small steps needed for the correct choices and correct decisions to be made. Satyameva Jayate
Unfortunately you follow none of those
Thanks a lot.This is an eye opening video and I understand most of the people are not aware of this.Best of luck for your journey ahead.
Goa thier culture religion i love .. better than others Indian state ❤️ goa india 🇮🇳
Thank you for sharing very imp information so Dat we goan ppl can share to our children..
Lots of love from goa❤❤❤❤❤❤❤
Really It was interesting to know the real story Behind Goa liberation. Many details were new to me.
Why his party always debates about past events rather than debating about present issues😢
Does it mean Modiji's criticism against Nehruji was wrong? Nice study... 👍
Very good video. We should know our history which is not shown in our NCRT history books.
Talk about the present political situation
Thanks bro shareing our goan video all India come to know Goa story an history.
6:45 Puducherry and other French ruled territories were peacefully handed over to India
Haa bhai, kitne decades takk hamare logon ka khoon chusa, maara aur mass conversion kiya aur baad mein jabb Bharat unke kisi kaam ka nahi raha, jitna chus sakte the chus liya uske baad peacefully return karr diya!!
Isse jyada peaceful koi ho sakta tha!!
Isparr toh film banni chahiye
Jo bhi bolte ho na, mere dost, toh thoda sochh karr bolo!! Agar kabhi tum kisi bade post parr gye toh tumhari baat global level parr sunni jayegi
@@AashishKumar-bm5lh andhbhakt
Happy vijaya dashami, very beautiful❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤
The way Narendra Modi, criticised Nehru on this topic, now it will be played again and again and again in Godi media & those will be consumed by common people and they will stock up some more hatred for Nehru. That's how it is going & it will be going, unfortunately. But thanks to you for highlighting the facts. There is an excellent explanation on Nehru as a PM by Adharsh Gupta of Study IQ. At some point, Adarsh said, Yes, Nehru did make so many mistakes, but at that time Nehru did not have any ideal example of running such a huge democracy alongside being involved in a few wars, witnessing drought etc.
So, I think He made few mistakes, from his mistakes our present PM should learn. But they should not use his mistakes as a weapon of blame-game & election winning tool.
Nehru biggest mistake is religious politics of muslim appeasement.
Lehru chicha apke chicha hain kya Jo itna ro rahe ....
By the way jo khud dusron ki godi mein baithkar ghulami karte hain woh ek section of media ko godi media kehte hain 😂😂😂😂
@@technoyamraj I acknowledge both Nehru's Blunder or Failure as well as his achievements. But your sentences prove you that you're a narrow minded conservative Godi media product! Thanks!
*Mistakes should be highlighted for future benefits and to avoid repeating them and Modi criticizes Nehru only for his mistakes. Nehru ji and Gandhi ji didn't care about his own people but gives lecture to others on human rights. They had done so many mistakes that India has to suffer till now and sadly don't know when it will be over. Modi doesn't play blame game, he just highlights mistakes only for national benefits so that every Indian can remember. Keep in mind, when roots are weaker than in future everyone has to suffer .*
"election winning tool"
Well these are the areas in which politics should be done.
I am from Goa ❤
Now Some Pseudo Liberal Will Cry In comments Section
Don't Care Just Ignore Them
Vande mataram
Bharat Mata ki Jai
Jai Hind 🇮🇳
Mai 18 saal ka hu aur mujhe aaj tak iska koi idea bhi ni tha ki goa azad nahi hua itne saalo tak thanks to ncert history textbooks which doesn't have any information about this
Jisme akbar ko aur aurangzeb ko mahan bataya gya hai 🙂💔
But why till date there is no ola, Uber or public transport in Goa ????
high transportaion prices, so probbaly people wont take a cab, and this is caused by high alchol prices
A part 2 of this video detailing the pre colonial and colonial history of Goa would be very informative
Goa inquisition. Dark chapter of Bharat.
Can you tell what is this inquisition an why it is called a dark chapter of Bharat? Was there anything called Bharat in the 16th century?
@@MyworldisgoaIt was. Converts like you should just shut up.
Damnnnn never knew this😮 Please keep making more videos about India's history❤❤❤
Nahru ji was 1000% Right 👍
This story gave me goose bumps. I hope we get to see this as a movie someday so people know and remember the story of Goa.
Can you cover this more in detail about all the Vasco da Gama, conversion, the hardships of Goans more in details?
Xavier bastard was the main culprit in initiating the inquisition.
Arree ghatia before posting comments learn something about goa an then post your comments, listening to some fanatics who have no connection to goa an posting comments will only end up making a fool of yourself.
That's why his body is still there unlike your ancestors who have turned to dust. You falling for such political agendas is typical.
Superb video 👍🏻👍🏻
Ye Jaankari AajTak kisi ne nahi batai thi😊
Nehru is mistake itself 😶
Kya bakwas hai..😂
😂😂sahi hai bhai tum jaise jo unke saamne khade rehne ki aukat na rkhte ho vo bhi bologe . Sahi hai acha vaise aap kitne se jail me rhe ho nehru ji ya veer savarkar , Patel ji ki tarah . Jab unke bare me pta na ho to Kam se kam chup rho kisi ki bhi disrespect krne se koi fayda nahi hai 😅
@@maanyudas7918chhodo na....kisse baat kar rahe ho aap....aajkal nehru ko bura bolne ka fashion sa hogaya hain
Nehru biggest mistake is religious politics of muslim appeasement.
@@omkarbhangle1908 truth always hurt 💔 😂
Thankyou very much 🙏 for this information students will learn from this video and they will get good 👍👍 information about history
Emotional touched by dark side.....Brighter side, at present Goan still give up Indian Citizenship to go Portugal n still 60% Goan food part of Portuguese cuisine. Goa is tourist destination, what our rest Indian come here 2 do everybody knows....
Please elaborate what rest of the Indians come to Goa for??
IT WAS KHANGRESS who changed DOMICILE LAWS in GOA to settle KATELA for VOTE BANK.
EVERYONE KNOWS IT
@@D.B.Cooper.. low alch you get it.
Goa is a tourist destination thanks to cheap alcohol and illegal drugs. That’s not something to boast about. And the Goans migrating to Portugal just rush off to the UK, because Portugal itself is a poor country by EU standards. And not all of them are highly qualified, they just do menial jobs in the UK. It’s one thing to be proud of working abroad because of your qualifications, but there is nothing to be proud of getting to go to Portugal in this manner!!
@@MrPratikPowar Portugal is still ahead of india and way better in keeping the people happy. from a goan-portuguese.
excellent analysis. Sardar Vallabhabhi Patel was the firm Home Minister has sent military to save jammu Kashmir to fight against Pakistan intruder after Independence save J&K as part of India.Like this Home Minister's Police Action against NIZAM regimes and joined this states to India. Sardar Vallabhabhi Patel was not alive at the time of Goa and Pondecherry.🎉🎉🎉🎉🎉🎉🎉🎉🎉🎉🎉
Actually goa needed a deal like macau, which wasn't possible due to Salazar
Make a video dedicatedly on the inquisition and related atrocities
Sagat Singh Rathore was the great hero of Goa war.... Portugal made him the most wanted of Portugal
Never heated this migrant name 🤣
You are a Gem brother
I need to make it clear that i am not in favour of Nehru nor Modi but to state the truth , Nehru led us through really unpredictable and unfavourable times , might be possible that he took long time to make up bold decisions but at the same time it is necessary to understand the situations that were at that time . Hadnt his decisions worked well in case of goa still today we would have criticized him for doing so. Its like we will criticize the person in any case possible.
NEHRU was a UK DIHADI
He openly said India didn't require any army and only police was enough
यह वीडियो सच्चे इतिहास को प्रस्तुत करने का एक महत्वपूर्ण प्रयास है। भारतीय जनता पार्टी के नेता और कार्यकर्ता अक्सर यह कहते हुए नजर आते हैं कि भारत की आजादी के 14 साल बाद तक गोवा को मुक्त क्यों नहीं किया गया, और इस देरी का पूरा दोष पंडित जवाहरलाल नेहरू पर डालने का प्रयास किया जाता है। जबकि वास्तविकता यह है कि भारत को आजादी ब्रिटिशों से मिली थी, जबकि गोवा पर पुर्तगालियों का शासन था। नेहरू सरकार ने इस दिशा में कई प्रयास किए थे, जिन्हें अक्सर नजरअंदाज कर दिया जाता है। आपने अपने वीडियो में इन सभी कारणों का गहन विश्लेषण किया है। सामान्य जनता अक्सर इतिहास की गहराइयों से अनभिज्ञ होती है, और कुछ लोग इसी का फायदा उठाकर समाज को भ्रमित करने का प्रयास करते हैं। इसलिए, इतिहास को सही तरीके से समझने के लिए आपका यह प्रयास अत्यंत महत्वपूर्ण है। यह वीडियो अधिक से अधिक लोगों को देखना चाहिए।
धन्यवाद।
Legends know that thumbnail has been changed 😅😄
right bro
thank you for this bhaiya
Thanks for knowing me for our History
I am a Goan ,studied in convent school, every word you mentioned is true. My Christian teachers were acknowledging their hindu ancestry before Portuguese came here. Also people should read a book by Dr. Tb. CUNHA "DE nationalizationof Goa" this book is not available easily.
Really amazed to see such a great piece of history, wonderfully articulated by you. Shamefully none of this was taught in the history texts during our schooling days. Hats off to you for this marvellous vdo!
May you bring our more of such glorious chapters of Indian History, and may the present Govt make all efforts in re-writing our history, and thus giving back our glorious past at least to all of our future generations. Jai Hind. Bharat Mata ki jai.
👌👏👍🤩🙏🇮🇳
Sarke bhava!!
You left out an essential part about how many Konkanis fled Goa and settled on the coast, now called Konkan coast.
He didn't failed Goa..he failed Bharat 😢😢😢
The supreme art of war is to subdue the enemy without fighting. A brilliant statesman can very well play the balls without firing a single shot.
The enemy might be mighty with most powerful army. But it will bend its knees before tactful diplomacy.
Not Bharat, its Akhand Bharat
@@AashishKumar-bm5lh It's Jambudweepa
Can you please do video before Portuguese come Goa?And what happen in Before Goa annexture ,how small mini kings fights each small kingdoms looting innocent poor people ,pls you best short story n nice .
Pls do nice one.
I'm from GOA, our ancestors were very happy with Portugal rule not like RSS ruling in Goa,
Portugal has captured 25 to 30 % Maharashtra land which are not Goan that the reason HINDU are in majority
There is a big difference between Goan HINDU and Maharashtra HINDU
Well, you're a convert that's why you will support Portugal!! 😂😂
@@NailsByAsh813 dosent matter if hes a convert or not, the indians came in goa and made it a ghatti shed and the beggars in mapusa market arent taken out.
@@TroyPereira1RO Indians never came to Goa, they were already there. So keep your cheap talk to yourself. It's better than missionary shed. If you have any issues with other religions living in Goa, then you should seek residency in Portugal. 🤣🤣😂😂
@@NailsByAsh813 i did not mention hate against another religion, the problem is the government which is destroying goa,even if the land belongs to the indians, they dont know how to behave propely and come in goa and make ghattis, also im talking about ghattis (the people from other states that come in goa and are bad) the indians dont enforce strict laws, the Portuguese enforce strict laws, so basically the indians dont enforce laws that much.
@@TroyPereira1RO You are talking about my people here. I am Marathi and we are called ghattis. That's very much hateful and bigoted of you to use that in derogatory manner. Don't forget Goa is infamous for what kinda lifestyle. So if you support such wild and degenerate lifestyle, then you can't lecture others here.
Bhai me prarthana kartahnu tumhara jaldi se joldi 1 milion hojaye
Without knowing a piece pf history and hating the PM who lived here 65 yrs ago is a joke.
I am a proud christian not because the portuguese forced me but because of the values of christianity. This is about freedom of religion. Due to this, in the present Christians in Goa are victims of the religious disputes. People should learn to distinguish between religion and politics before criticism.
Just very important historical context here .
For independent India there was so much pressure from western nations for liberation of Goa. Imagine if Portuguese had 5 times the area of Goa under occupation.
This was the exact case before 1739.
Almost all of western Konkan coast from Vasai , thane, Bandra , till Ratnagiri were under Portuguese control ..
It was great Maratha chimmaji appa the brother of great Baji Rao Peshwa who prevented this .
He freed total western coast from Portuguese hands with his final victory at Vasai fort .
This was the first set back Portuguese had faced in 200 years after setting foot in India .
Staggering total number of 1 lakh soldiers were involved in this campaign from Maratha side . 20 thousand soldiers had died in this battle achieving important victory.
Also this was coming at crucial times 1739
This is the year when north India was attacked By Nader shah .
Peshwa Baji Rao wanted to intervene nader shah for ultimate battle.
Preparation were also done 35 thousand army was also gathered and was waiting for other maratha armies to gather.
But as fate had it bulk of Maratha army with best cannons and European trained soldiers were fighting against Portuguese wich was drawn to almost 1 year .
Infact Peshwa Baji Rao had arguments with his brother chimaji appa regarding this.
Ultimately Peshwa Baji Rao dropped the plan as troops couldn’t reach in time in sufficient numbers .
And north India suffered brutal destruction and looting at hands of Nader shah.
Lets not forget coastal Kannada kings and queens who gave shelter to goa people when Portuguese attacked and trying to convert them. Rani Chennabhairadevi gave shelter to many immigrants thats why some of the population in north coastal region speaka konkani. But Nowadays everybody has forgotten the pepper queen Chennabhairadevi.
Most of the Goans are unaware of this History. Very Sad 😢 our ancestors face a huge atrocities and we are kept in darkness 😭😭
I am a Goan born n brought up in Goa , have gone around the world for Nine world cruisings ,being a continental chef on passenger cruise liners ,visited Lisbon, n many other places in Portugal ,n my first comment on alighting from the ship n walking in n around city of Lisboa, which is Lisbon the capital city ,so clean, dust free, no stones or pebbles or straw or sticks to be found ,so clean ,no spitting on the streets, walls, no urination on roadside, strict sense of discipline,even paupers , beggars well dressed with suit, boots tie, n a clean begging bowl with a hat on head, pleases any common man to help out with some dollars or escudos,. My first comment was ,if Portuguese were not driven away ,than our loving Goa would be shining star of cleanliness n zero tolerance of roadside strewn garbagge, thanks to all who came to Goa ,after liberation n settled n are now contributing to the dritiness n filthy stinky,slums n sites ,of which the ruling govt. is proud n a failure in keeping up the Portuguese type of cleanliness in Goa.
Nehru made these mistakes ❌
Everything that Nehru does was a mistake ✅
Nehru biggest mistake is religious politics of muslim appeasement
Watch the video bro , he didn't attack due to article 5 of NATO
@@tokitomuimuiGive an example
@@deadlytsg2792 Lol 😂 pure evidence have every where ok 😂
@@deadlytsg2792congress party always choose muslim side ,congress ne artical 5 of NATO ke wajat se Goa par attract nahi kiya ,vo log uss time me Goa ma bahot logo ko force kara convert Kara ja raha tha, hinduo ko mara ja raha tha , temple thod kar cruch banai ja raha tha , uska bad nhe Congress ne kuch nahi kiya ??? Agar vo attack karta to bahot chance tha ke croro hindu Zinda Bach jata ....
Nehru be like : Mujhe koi pyar hi nahi karta 🤦♂️
👍good video, reminding about Goa's history in a short duration 🥰
Unfortunately we still have a chapter glorifying the Portuguese in NCERT class 11...😔
There's always a positive n negative 😅 to everything
@@andreamessiasgomes7118You're laughing on such things shows that you are not at all loving and humanly. 😢😢
@@NailsByAsh813 ya your not loving n humanly either of you to type this 🥲.
@@andreamessiasgomes7118 I am not making mockery of victims of colonisation like you are.
@@NailsByAsh813 excuseme you are not a victim of colonisation so don't talk extra, and am not making a mockery, first learn your history properly! Don't be an ignorant and pretend that everybody has hurt Indians and Indians are innocent, no! First educate yourself on who and what it is to be an Indian. Unfortunately most Indians don't know this.
Wow such a heroic story, Goa what a wonderful story of freedom
For nehru, his image was more important than India.
For Netaji, India was more important than his life.
For Modi, India is more important than his life.
That's the difference.
Why he is silent on Manipur then same can be said for Modi
@@tonylee1868facts don't fit in his narrative
@@tonylee1868Every State Has His Chosen People who made
CM of State If U Ask About a PM Then Plz Explain About. CM Regimen Is just for Cartoon Motions?
Abbe godi media andhbhakt! Manipur desh ka hissa nhi hai? China ka koi aggression nhi hai?
@@ascoolasariv6969 Cry More🫣
Bhai the best thing about your videos is that they are to the fact, non-biased. I may not be a Nehru supporter but the way you presented the geo-political scenario of that time, we can give him a benefit of doubt regarding his intentions. Rest there may be many mistakes done by Nehru which we reflect from current perspective but need to give room for prevailing reasonings of that time also. Very good video. All the best for many such future videos.
Now Modi failed to save Manipur
Before commenting on manipur plz read history 😊
@@Npushpal I've that's why i commented 😊
@@sanjana9578 action was taken from indian government against Manipur criminals dont be silly puppet of people like dhruv rathee
@@sanjana9578u have not it's a clash between to local grps Manipur is not drifting from India don't use Manipur as a bell
@@aarushpandey8013im frm manipur and many illegal immigrant are from myammar entering manipur. Kukis are getting many arms and ammunition from isreal supply
Very interesting 🤔 video !! Thanks 🙏 !
I think nehru us time pai .. india ko as a aggressor nhi potre krna chahte the ..q ki recently hi india aazad hiwa tha
Thank you so much bhaiyya...
Mein dhoond raha tha uss vishay pr..