You just missed mentioning that he was wanted in India for the 2007 cinema hall bombing that killed 7 people mostly poor, and also for drug peddling and target killings. India has asked the Canadian government for his and many others' extradition. Indian teams have visited Canada many times. Even the state Government of Punjab( Sikh majority) asked Mr. Trudeau for his extradition when he visited India in 2018. The Canadian government provides a safe haven to criminals to prove how liberal they are.
What ticked me was the report which quoted an intelligence official who said that the murdered man was warned of possible threats multiple times before, which means police knew of his whereabouts. Now what is concerning is that how come the police didn't arrest the guy who had an Interpol red corner notice against him, despite knowing his whereabouts ? Guess that gives weight to Indian allegation that Canada is becoming a safe haven for criminals.
Criminal? So now he’s a criminal also? So how he’s a criminal? Just because india government is saying so? Has he ever been convicted as a criminal in court of law? The answer is a BIG NO!! Seems india government can just put labels on anyone as a criminals and terrorists to justify the killings … That makes the Indian government the real criminal organization for killing an unarmed man going to his place of worship. So it seems you want to call him a criminal so no one looks at who the real criminals are. So let’s look at facts why did Canada allow him to stay if he’s a convicted terrorist? It’s because he never was, india keeps saying he’s a terrorist and should be extradited back to india but when Canadian authorities asked for any evidence or proof of him committed of those crimes india doesn’t have anything 😂 (UAPA) Unlawful Activities (Prevention) Act where the india government arrest you put you away forever without due trial without evidence or proof all they need to say is on the basis your involvement in terrorism against the country where all your properties will be seized.
The Indian state, like many other draconian states, sees every advocate for a separate state as a terrorist. India does not tolerate free thinking or expression if it advocates a separate state. In such cases India sees advocacy as a terror threat, it fabricates evidence uses outdated laws of secessionism to define a person as a terrorist, thus putting out red notices through Interpol. In sum, indian red notices are contrived, and don't hold up in western courts generally.
Essentially what Zeihan is saying is : If Western countries fart - it is a melodious song for the whole world to enjoy. If India farts- It is the most obnoxious and unsavoury thing to have ever happened on planet earth!!! The phenomenon of Trans national elimination of enemies of state and terrorists was started by the USA and none of the 5 or 10 eyes can lecture India about this. Mr Nizzar was a wanted terrorist who had committed acts of Terrorism in India and Canada had repeatedly declined to extradite him back to India. Canada should be put in the black list of FATF for enabling International Terrorism.
And India is a safe haven for scammer call centres. RUclipsrs have found them, hacked their cameras and called indian police only to watch what looks like a tip off before the raid. Suddenly people leave, evidence is destroyed and so on. It needs to stop.
Thank you for discussing this. While an assassination by agents of another state on Canadian soil is bad, Canada should never have allowed this guy into the country in the first place, he made several bad-faith attempts to get in, and our stupid system allowed it. And, since when did Canada ever support a separatist movement in other countries? We don't take too kindly to foreign states promoting Quebec independence, so you'd think some quid pro quo would apply here. But nope, this is about the Liberal party courting votes from immigrants. If you are leaving the Old Country behind, you are supposed to leave it's problems behind too. Are you a Canadian now, or not?
Couldn't agree more...immigrants must leave old probs out. West needs to tackle this now... Khalistanis, hamas/Palestinians etc... Is not good for adopting countries or cultures. West needs new approach 1. If immigrant citizens commit major crimes, revoke citizenship. Deport if necessary. 2. Don't allow criminals / extrimists in. 3. Immigrants must become "Canadians" first.
What Quebec have to do here ? Your head polluted with something ? you scared of the french coming for you ? Cannot learn a new language ? your are limited or limiting yourself. Argue for this and you will get keep your limitations
Your system recruited the scums that escaped during the crackdown against Sikh militancy. In my mind, USA wants to keep various separatist groups alive to use it as a pressure tactic from time to time. India's stand on Ukraine issue has pissed USA a lot.
He is only a temporary canadian. He is concern with mad extermination of all minorities in India.. That is christian, muslim, or perceived as anti hindu
I struggle to comprehend why Western media and Western individuals seem to approach this issue from a single perspective. I have yet to see anyone acknowledge that before Hardeep Singh Nijjar became a citizen, numerous extradition requests from India went unfulfilled by Canada. This makes it questionable why Canada believes that the situation will be any different, especially when dealing with a designated terrorist. Furthermore, if you're uncertain about this individual's background, I would encourage you to conduct a quick Google search to understand how he recently obtained citizenship, despite being denied multiple times in the past due to false information. It's striking that no one from Canadian or Western media addresses the questionable history of this individual. 0:57 For those who assert that it took them a while to get to the bottom of this issue, I would recommend delving into the historical context and integrating that perspective into their analysis. This may lead to a better understanding of how Canada is potentially becoming a safe haven for terrorists and fugitives. If you're seeking an unbiased analysis, I'd suggest looking up "Cover Up Air India, CBC reporting," which can provide you with insights into how deeply rooted this issue is. However, if you prefer to maintain your current perspective and paint India in a negative light, that remains your prerogative.
lol western ppl see it from their own perspective. No one here gives a shit about Indias problems the core of the issue is how are foreign governments doing this on our soil and how are we letting these ppl in the first place.
@@Trambo1997your problem is you are becoming heaven for terrorists to stay. Pakistan also did that, funding terrorists against india but now getting harmed by those terrorists themselves, canada will also see this in few years
Activist is not terrorist. If they had a trial in India and found to be guilty then Canada would have sent them back but if they didn't get a trail and feared for their life, Canada has to accept them as amnesty seekers. No matter what; you don't go around assassination people in a friendly country. This man would never have made it to trail in India this man was convicted and assassinated. India hates criticism then India should never have done something so stupid. India made India look bad.
@@lilavall4735 Hmm, so this so-called activist who has videos where they're encouraging violence and spreading hate against India and its citizens. His speeches, originating from a place of worship, are laden with hostility, he offered rewards for killing politicians in India. If individuals like this are labeled activists, I wonder, in your dictionary who was Osama or Abu Bakr al-Baghdadi ? And yet again someone speaking on behalf of western values and accusing other nation, without a shred of evidence if it was government job
I was at work in Vancouver when one of the Air India suspects was arrested around the corner. From what I recall, the case was bungled and they were set free. India was furious. This time they took it into their own hands. Not acceptable to do in a sovereign country but I can understand their frustration with the Canadian justice system. This kind of thing happens all too often and we are far too lenient on criminals in general. Oligarchs, wealthy gang members and other unsavoury characters can also easily immigrate or buy property here (like in the UK).
@@TheDogGoesWoof69 Most protesters get dispersed or arrested within hours or days, the truckers protested for weeks, sounds to me like the truckers were treated preferentially.
@@johnsmyth9123 Being treated like terrorists is preferential? They literally activated their anti-terrorism powers to arrest the truckers as terrorists. Meanwhile, Trudeau partying with actual terrorists. Trudeau is yet another mini-Hitler. Screw that guy.
There is a difference between taking out a current threat and settling old scores. This extrajudicial killing was revenge. If the goal was justice, India should have snatched him and spirited him back to India for a trial. Or they could have just used a drone. 😅
They were doing it in Canada? When has the US or UK ever assassinated someone in Canada? These are third world problems they've imported. Pray for the European people's worldwide, we have dark times ahead.
This isn't the first instance of violence in Canada regarding Sikh terrorism. Air India Flight 182 was the deadliest terrorist attack in Canadian history killing 329 people. One went to jail for 5 years, the other two aquitted through the Canadian courts.
The Sikhs I know don't seem to be involved in terrorism, at least in the U.S. Some of them are jerks, but that doesn't mean anything. I know a lot of jerks that aren't Sikh.
“India unsavory authoritarian govt.” My third visit to this channel. And damn, just when I was beginning to appreciate and think this guy was well-informed, the mask falls away. Glad didn’t spend too much time on this channel. Not because he specifically trashed India, but because the “expertise” just became questionable and untrustworthy. I was here to learn. It is on “Do not recommend” list.
Don't be surprised if he's a muslim from Pakistani/Arab parents or whatever. They are fed with same "India is under dictatorship" rhetoric just bcoz a govt is there with a clear majority which just doesn't panders to these radicals and stops them from playing their favorite game of jihad. Or he's just another ignorant white dude who knows a thing or two of Asia by studying half baked facts from Western media houses and claiming to be an "expert".
@@msms3260 I didn't say opinions are facts but I agree with his opinion on how world or western countries perceive india India can make right decisions in future only when it's aware of their consequences I didn't find his tone anti india in any way but a very realistic view about india and it's relations with western bloc which is getting stronger recently due to china factor
@@KKR-bf8ku Doesn’t matter if he is anti India or not. Saying India is unsavory, and claiming Indian govt is most authoritarian sounds like un-informed opinion. Just makes me question rest of his talks, you know just like finding a strand of hair in the food. No matter, how good rest of the the food is, I am done with it at that point, and that’s just me buddy.
As a social scientist who studied South Asia for 40 years, and lives in Canada, I would like to add some context and recent history to this discussion. New Delhi has been frustrated over Canadian politicians' wooing of radical elements in the Sikh diaspora for several decades. While the Khalistan movement (for a separate Sikh homeland) is today peaceful, in the 1980s and 1990s it was extremely violent in India. I know because I was studying at a university in New Delhi at the time. The Bhindranwala faction of the Khalestan movement assassinated 20-30,000 people, mainly government servants, other religious sects, political moderates and secularists between 1980-early 1990s. They took over the Golden Temple in Amritsar, the foremost Sikh holy place, believing that the Indian government would never invade it, and carried out their terror from there. Indeed, there was a young woman from Punjab in my hostel at JNU whose parents were assassinated. Indira Gandhi eventually sent troops into the Golden Temple, and in reprisal, her Sikh bodyguards assassinated her, following which there was a terrible pogrom against Sikhs in New Delhi. Rajiv Gandhi, who succeeded his mother, pretty well ended the Bhindranwala movement, not only by repression, but also agreeing to most economic grievances that were driving the conflict (a conflict over state sharing of river irrigation). He also supported a moderate Sikh party in following elections. It appears that a significant number of Khalistani supporters emigrated to Canada, the US, and Britain. It is in these places that the Khalestan movement survives, and has been dominating some electoral ridings in Canada where Sikhs are in a majority. Canadian politicians, including Trudeau, have wooed these groups to help win elections. Many Canadian politicians attend rallies where the assassination of Indira Gandhi is celebrated in posters, etc. Granted we have free speech in Canada, but since when did Canaidan politicians support a separatust movement in another country? I don't agree with the assassination at all, and it's true that the Indian government has become more authoritarian under Modi, but India's foreign affairs have not changed that much in relation to Sikh separatism since 1980. Trudeau even invited a Canadian Sikh emigre who had been convicted in Canada of murdering a state minister from PUnjab to embassy receptions in New Delhi during his so-called 'state visit'. Another really stupid foreign policy blunder by our feckless PM. When there was a separatist movement in Quebec in the 1960s that turned violent, Justin's father, Pierre Trudeau, introduced the War Measures Act, while his very stupid son boasts that he does a better bhangra than Jugmeet Singh, and cosies up to formerly violent Sikh political activists. So: what India did was very wrong. But I understand the frustration of the Indian government trying to deal with an idiot PM who just doesn't get it that it's not ethical or right to support separatist movements in another country. This issue has been raised by India many, many times. And I don't understand how various Canadian politicians can attend rallies where posters celebrate Bindhranwala and Indira Gandhi's assassination and not know who or what they are dealing with. Although Britain and the US also have large Sikh emigre populations, you don't see politicians there cosying up to Sikh separatists. Hopefully, we will have someone more competent following our next elections.
As a Canadian, I apologise to all Indians on behalf of our government. We harboured a terrorist that threatened your sovereignty and then blamed India publicly without any proof (still waiting for that credible allegation). I’m depressed about the situation we’re in right now as a country 😔🇨🇦
As a Indian, I want to make one thing clear to Canadian people that we don't hate Canadian people at all it's just we don't like current Canadian govt, PM Justin T. and his policy to support to militant sepertist, radical extremist groups who want to distroy social harmony in India.
@Texa8 Clearly you are in Indian (maybe from Texas), its funny how you are posing as a Canadian. lol. Its ok though, we are with you. One thing we can agree upon is that Trudeau is an absolute idi-ot. By the way, your english is littered with Indian english giveaways. ;)
Forgot to mention, canada failed to provide evidence (except credible allegations). Canada forced india to believe in word of mouth (forcefully convincing india to trust on canada) Where canada's credibility index is less then 5 out of 10.. As action speaks louder than words and result speaks louder than actions.. Similarly, india also seeks for action of canada by having proof. and india not going to believe in just words by corporate controlled canadian international media. All GAP (grey area points) such as morality, manners, human rights are relative and hence defination of such keywords are expected to be interpreted by impacted country. Canada tried to own GAP by using the word (credibility) without asking india... this is how canada became dictactor in the name of freedom of speech...
Just one note- the man killed here was openly calling for assassinations of Indian diplomats among others things! He had a track record for pretty unsavoury stuff.
Canada has sadly long cozied up to the separatist movement of the Sikhs for a very long time spanning decades much to the annoyance of India Even accepting the Canadian citizenship of former violent members of the movement that had criminal pasts or suspected of such in India And this is despite Canada who once had their own separatist movement they violently had to put down, Quebec Which you don't see India trying to champion the cause of the Quebecois What India did was wrong but it does have an explanation, if only the idiotic of the Trudeau family could have recognized this fact. Because the cozying of the Sikhs and their separatists cause even goes back to Justin Trudeau's father
@@rejvaik00 Trudeaus are a footnote in leadership, you're treating it like f'in USA dynasty. No Canadian politicians have that influence. It's not like other places the premiers have the power here. Not a republic. You're applying politics that don't exist. All of this nonsense you morons spout is soap opera stuff. We have very few politicians that stay in government for more than 3 terms of 4 years and they wildly differ in stances. The idiotic take is yours.
@@slangster233 The o.p.s point was that there are many people who wanted him dead and might have been willing to act on it. The least likely to act would be the Indian government. The only evdence put forward that it was the Indian governmemt that was the culprit is Trudeau's assurance that he has seen that evidence but he can't reveal it.
That's honestly totally irrelevant. If he'd been found to have committed crimes in Canada, he would have been tried for them. Having another country swoop into a sovereign, developed, democratic nation, ignore its rule of law, and murder its citizens, is wildly unacceptable.
Btw, Noor Chowdhury the main person behind the assassination of sheikh mujibur rahman, the founding father of Bangladesh ran away and is living in canada. Bangladesh has repeatedly asked for his extradition and canada has turned a blind eye!
USA having better intel about Canadian citizens than the Canadian government may seem surprising, but really it isn't. One of the "advantages" of the five-eyes system is that if you have inconvenient domestic laws blocking surveillance of your own citizens it's so much easier to let one of your partners without any such legal impediments do it for you and then just swap data.
Apart from Canada in the Five Eyes alliance, they supported Canadians even without strong evidence because they wanted to take advantage of the situation to align India with the Ukraine issue (as the USA desired) and secure a favorable deal in the Free Trade Agreement (as the UK desired). However, they were surprised by India's actions and chose not to escalate the situation further. India is needed to counterbalance China in the long run. For the USA, it doesn't matter if the government or country is democratic or non-democratic, as long as it aligns with their strategy. We have seen this when they aligned with Pakistan and created the Taliban and in other places too
Exaclty. Our embrace of Saudi Arabia for decades, even to the extent of not holding it responsible for the 15 of 19 pilots responsible for 9/11, and instead blaming Hussein. I'm not saying either should be embraced. Just reinforcing your point that while the U.S. claims to be supporting even spreading, in times of war, democracy, even in its own border, that platitude is entirely for show among certain people who also want to claim a defense for free speech as a cover for hate.
I think India's window is closing fast. The USA is pulling out all manufacturing from China and moving as much of it as possible to Mexico under the NAFTA umbrella. India should have begged for a bigger seat at the table, like Japan did.
The problem is in thinking you can rely on India at all. They'll use you to degrade China but won't lift a finger to help you, unless they are attacked, even then it'll be, you go first. Otherwise they'll hedge their bet, buy your weapons because Russian weapons are scarce and proving to be crap. Remember the "I" in BRICS is for India and BRICS is for dedollarization. Besides India doesn't win fights against China, so brings little to the table. Investing in India is a huge mistake unless you're in love with corruption. Bribery is how you get the thing you've already paid for, done. They'll sell you out for a dollar faster than you can say Jack Sprat. And I say this liking Indians but the best of the bunch doesn't live in India and hasn't for decades. Why do you think they left?
@@protorhinocerator142 India can survive and grow alone with its domestic consumption... But, as nowadays India offering very offordable manufacturing with skilled labours its hard for capitalists to not to invest in India.. However west have learnt the lesson... THey wont dependent on only one country for sure.. India wont be big as china But certainly it will be the economy of 15-20 trillion economy.. which is more than sufficient to rule over Indian subcontinent... as India dont have the ambition of rule the whole world like USA But India want to have the soft influence in the whole world and strong dominant power in its region
Great take Zeihan, like always. Being an Indian what I can say is that Indians have a very pro-West view of the world. Indians are one of the populations that rate the US most favorably (in surveys). But this Khalistan issue has been a very emotive one. We lost a Prime Minister (Indira Gandhi), Chief Minister of Punjab, Police Chief, Army General and thousands of citizens to this terrorism and Trudeau has been sheltering and cultivating this movement, which is effectively dead in india since the last 2-3 decades.
If the khalistan movement is effectively dead in India, what's the point of the assassination? Is the "peace" in khalistan so fragile that a single guy oceans away can threaten it? Ideally India should have worked through the criminal justice system to extradite the guy. But if India wants to take a shortcut, fine. Just admit to the assassination and explain why. None of this "show me the evidence" chicken poop.
@@dcc70 the person assisinated was the key conspirator in a bomb blast in punjab that killed 6 people, on the interpol list and on the no fly list. India requested for his extradition formally from Canada multiple times.
This analysis is based on if and how the west would re-think about relations with India. But India, on multiple occasions, has been forced to re-think about relations with the west. For instance, what USA did during 1971 India pakistan war is something we will neither forget, nor forgive.
Sorry, 1971 is a closed chapter. US has among the highest ratings in India compared to most other countries. As they say, in international relations there are no permanent friends or enemies, only permanent interests.
For decades Canada has been treating terrorism lightly, going all the way back to 1970 with the FLQ Crisis when Justin’s dad, Pierre, was prime minister. Since then other nationalist organizations with a terrorist wing have been setting up shop on Canada’s soil, usually in order to have a secure base to organize and fund their organizations, but also to mount the occasional operation abroad, such as the Air India bombing. Terrorists would often leave Canada, get wounded or arrested, and Canada would work to bring the Canadian passport holders back. Most notably, a teenaged terrorist, who made bombs to kill American (not to mention, Canadian) soldiers in Afghanistan, killed an American medic who was attempting to treat his wounds after a firefight, ending up in Guantanamo only to be released into Canadian custody, who not only quickly released him onto Canada’s streets, but gave him over ten million dollars to boot. BTW, the Canadian government didn’t pay the widow of the American medic so much as a penny. Things like this tell international terrorists that Canada is the place to be.
@MyLateralThawts All Sikh terrorist bomb Air India plane and There was another bomb which exploded in airport but who were involved behind this bombing no trial and This People has a lot background criminal activities like Gang war and smuggling drugs to India and India has not country like American or Russian but our country is too much peaceful who get our independence from Britishers without any violence
Canada for terrorists & separatists UK for fraudsters & looters. Australia, now is hard on crime. But I remember this joke: Australian immigration officer - "Do you have a criminal record? " Visitor - "You still take only criminals? I thought those days were long gone! "
As an Indian, some part of me hopes that the allegations actually prove to be true. Unfortunately, no evidence has been presented so far and given the stellar record of American intelligence over the last two decades, its difficult to take anything that they say seriously!
Your mentality is why Modi has managed to turn your country into a theocracy. You are cheering for it for a false sense of pride but eventually your country will be the worse for it becoming the next Iran. It will continue on its path to become an authoritarian shithole with over a billion poor oppressed citizens. Enjoy your hate-filled ride to abject poverty.
I don't just take western intelligence at their word, but I would add that they have been significantly better starting with the call like to the week of the Russian invasion
@@calc1657: never contested that. But given that US intelligence unearthed 'credible' information about the existence of WMDs, its hard to take any claims on behalf of that quarter seriously
Hahaha 😂"... if you ever see someone jumping out of a hospital windows, it's probably an assassination... " got me rolling on the floor. Originally Putin's favorite.
What about a Bloach lady killed in Canada by Pakistani Intelligence Agency ISI …. She is a freedom fighter of Blochistan province from Pakistan Killed few months ago … why don’t Trudo shout on that murder because khalistan sikh control your government not that Baloch fighters …. Canadians Need to understand this …
As a Canadian, the decline of security intelligence and policing - competency is becoming an issue not only for canadians but her surrounding allies. Let alone the the incompetence of the current liberal government.
Not sure what you're basing the lack of security and intelligence comments on, but the Conservatives/NDP/Liberals are all in the same boat of incompetence.
I just wanted to thank everyone who responded to my comment. I"m flabbergasted that so many did, and surprised to find that so many fellow Canadians are concerned about the Liberal governments' tolerance of extremists in Canada. Justin seems determined to compromise Canada and India's security needs for the sake of a few electoral wins in Surrey and south Vancouver. I'm retired now, but still do some research and publishing. I thought I might write up an article on my personal observations in Delhi as a student, along with historical and on-line research. And then it hit me: I might end up a victim of Khalistani violence. Like Ujjal Dosanjh and others who were critical of the movement in the 1980s. So I won't publish the article, or at least not put my name on it. But I will write the article, because I feel Canada's slide towards being a safe haven for terrorists is making my head explode. But thanks agains for your varied and interesting responses. It has somewhat restored my faith in human nature. I believe diasporic politics has no place in Canadian politics, if only because those who espouse violence form 15,000 miles away never have to be accountable for their actions. It's like chasing a phantom that has no reality in between global locations, but dangerous effects in each separate geography.
The guy was wanted by interpol and extradition request was sent to Canada gov in 2019. Calling the khalistan movement non violent is bending the truth when you consider drug & human trafficking by its organizations. Not to mention the attacks on hindu temples and Indian diplomats in both Canada & UK. They have publicly threatened to blow up a sports stadium with 100k capacity this very month.
Essentially what Zeihan is saying is : If Western countries fart - it is a melodious song for the whole world to enjoy. If India farts- It is the most obnoxious and unsavoury thing to have ever happened on planet earth!!! The phenomenon of Trans national elimination of enemies of state and terrorists was started by the USA and none of the 5 or 10 eyes can lecture India about this. Mr Nizzar was a wanted terrorist who had committed acts of Terrorism in India and Canada had repeatedly declined to extradite him back to India. Canada should be put in the black list of FATF for enabling International Terrorism.
@@DAndyLord As long as you pay the fine, you can say what you want. Don't worry, the court will seize your stuff until they have enough to cover your fine.
Thanks for uploading!! 1. The guy Nijjar was a murder having blood on hand, used false identification to Canada! 2. India and Canada have extradition treaty. India's intelligence is known for its frugality when it comes to operate outside the border of India! Even to deploy lawyers, Indian govt would hesitate to spend money, that too on such criminals! 3. My view is: Trudeau is a seduced bloke under blackmail by ISI and Khalistanis and would do anything asked of him by this combine! 4. The Punjabi / Haryanvi gangster who was operating with ISI/Khalistanis has broken from them and might be the key figure in deploying his resource in Canada to eliminate Nijjar who was his companion one time!!
The line about Americans being "okay with assassination if it's done by drone, but we seem to get upset when it's done in person." Was dark but hilarious, because it's kind of true.
Or is it that the Americans don't mind at all sending an assassin in person but they prefer to publicize the drones so people focus on that and don't realize who has been killed off in person?
Essentially what Zeihan is saying is : If Western countries fart - it is a melodious song for the whole world to enjoy. If India farts- It is the most obnoxious and unsavoury thing to have ever happened on planet earth!!! The phenomenon of Trans national elimination of enemies of state and terrorists was started by the USA and none of the 5 or 10 eyes can lecture India about this. Mr Nizzar was a wanted terrorist who had committed acts of Terrorism in India and Canada had repeatedly declined to extradite him back to India. Canada should be put in the black list of FATF for enabling International Terrorism.
3min silence for those who think India is not aware about USA's friendly nature towards India for the china cause...Calculations are way ahead(obviously on all sides) of what we r watching in this video or what we can think of.. So just chill n enjoy n be informed (if u r not doing masters on international relations) A point that Zeihan missed: that Sikh man was in the no fly list(a list prepared for suspected terrorists) of USA😅
@@nishitbarodia2718I haven't seen anything other than accusations and allegations, can you provide a source for your comment about a conviction? Thanks
Peter probably forgot to mention that the person was a terrorist, and Canada government has a lot of internal politics going on at the moment. Trueadu might not be the most popular guy in Canada, and he was armtwisted to make this statement by his coalition partner. I feel other western nations don't care about Trueadu's Canada, much. Their advise to Canada would be to quell down Khalistani terrorism (which btw, has bombed a plane that killed 100s of citizens US, Canada, India etc.), rather than ranting about it in the public.
The only ones who arm-twisted him were our journalists, who learned of the story and were about to go public with it. Trudeau had to make a statement before it appeared in the newspapers. Trudeau has tried to keep Chinese meddling in Canadian elections a secret, and he's paid for it. If he was caught trying to keep an outright assassination a secret, it could have been the end of his government. And the Air India bombing happened before many of us were born. Of course no one cares about it now. Ask a 20-year-old american what they think of 9/11 and you're not going to get an emotional response.
the #3 Party in canada has a sihk as the leader. sihks have worked their way into a lot of political influence in canada. there are also close to a million of them in canada , i think.
@@ronblack7870yea sikhs got alot of voice with the help of hindu vote which is more than them in numbers and always thought of them as brothers that support base is gone forever
The Indian government's dossier on Hardeep Singh Nijjar does not accuse him of being a separatist, but of his involvement in organising several targeted killings and attempted killings in Punjab. Canada has ignored the Indian government's requests for his repatriation to stand trial for these alleged killings on the basis of the information provided by some of the actual executors of these crimes. He was a designated terrorist wanted by the Home Ministry and the National Investigation Agency. If Trudeau wants to support such operations conducted by his supporters, the Indian government will accord Canada the same status as it does to Pakistan. So you have all the capabilities for protecting this asset that you would or could not spare to anticipate what Hamas was upto.
@@levinjoseph233 No, Interpol had an alert that stated "The Indian government considers this person a terrorist" which is VERY different. Interpol didn't even have a warrant for him.
@@CedarHunt Remember the case of Air India Flight 182 which was brought down by a bomb planted by Khalistan extremists in 1985, and the guys involved were already suspects of the Canadian intelligence. Trudeau''s father Pierre had refused to extradite Talwinder Singh Parmar in 1982 and as a consequence 329 innocent lives were taken by the group which had included that terrorist. Was Nijjar an asset of Canadian intelligence such as it is? It is Trudeau who is impervious to embarrassment.
Not to mention the US and UK have done VERY similar things to folks they considered terrorists on other country's sovereign lands - for the US and UK to condemn this at all would be a tad hypocritical. That being said, it's perfectly ok for Canada to say 'hey wait a minute' when this happens on THEIR soil.
Washington Post reported that at least six gunmen and two cars were involved in the killing of this man. Does look like a shoddy attempt if this was indeed done by a state. I think it is more likely to be gang violence related with the possiblity of Indian handlers having some indirect role. Bigger question is why can't Canadian law enforcement identify the gunmen or at the very least find the two cars caught on CCTV?
It's not a shoddy attempt if they succeeded. If the Indian diplomats who coordinated the operation had enough sense to keep their mouths shut, the police may have indeed assumed it was gang violence as well.
Not exactly. They went south after the Air India bombing in the 80s and Canada's refusal to extradite suspects! Trudeau Sr. Why? to win votes in some specific electoral ridings. I know it's pathetic. It's Canada after all.
It started years ago when India decided to reduce importing crops from Canada, in an attempt to improve food security in India...supposedly. Now the plan is to end lentil imports from Canada entirely. Modi better pray hard to numerous gods for good weather for their domestic agriculture.
@@michaeldowson6988it started years ago when your govt allowed terrorists in your state and even undermine the air India bombing investigation and extradited the criminals. Good luck with nurturing snakes in your backyard.
I think the big mistake was that Trudeau went very public with this accusation and created a huge media stir and unecessary conflict with India . If you follow Canadian politics you’ll know he did this the day or day after parliament reopened and he was getting absolutely ripped apart for the botch job he’s done managing this country (I say this as a normally liberal supporting Canadian) it was very obvious to me that this was to distract from what was the media narrative of sagging liberals in the polls , a housing crisis disaster and the grocery inflation. Suddenly he made this India accusation and all that talk disappeared for a few weeks. Brilliant actually for him bad for everyone else including sikhs in India who probably don’t want more conflict stirred up .
Essentially what Zeihan is saying is : If Western countries fart - it is a melodious song for the whole world to enjoy. If India farts- It is the most obnoxious and unsavoury thing to have ever happened on planet earth!!! The phenomenon of Trans national elimination of enemies of state and terrorists was started by the USA and none of the 5 or 10 eyes can lecture India about this. Mr Nizzar was a wanted terrorist who had committed acts of Terrorism in India and Canada had repeatedly declined to extradite him back to India. Canada should be put in the black list of FATF for enabling International Terrorism.
Yeah!!! The consequences of this are NOW visible. 40 Can. Diplomats GONE. This impacts all the 10s of thousands of students who would have otherwise gone to Canadian Universities to study - the equivalent of $25B revenue if I have the number right. FTA GONE. It ALSO impacts all the other games that were being played in India. Watching the fun and the conciliatory whining that is happening now...
@@RinkaSingh Again, no one in Canada cares. No Canadians want to visit India. No student cares if Indian students come. The only one losing in this situation is India. The average Canadians cares the same for an independent Punjab as the average Indian cares about a Quebec. Where are the Indian students going to go now? The US? Get real, India has just embarrassed itself by making itself look like an immature child. How many Canadians do you think ever visit India outside of the diaspora?
@@ElGrandoCaymanoonly you boomers don't. Canada runs on these university scams. And there is nothing an insignificant, powerless country like canada can do even if India carries out 10 such incidents on canadian soil
Dear Canadians. India is 5000+km away and apart from being a nuisance these separatists have no chance of succeeding because they don’t have any support within India. However, sooner or later these separatists will become a headache for Canada. You will not be able to control them because they will continue to become more radicalized. Hope better sense prevails and you elect a leader who will not allow these nonsensical shenanigans to happen in your soil.
Elaborate? He often misses a piece of the puzzle which I realize when he talks about something I'm knowledgeable about, in this case I am certainly not so some pointers would be neat?
Essentially what Zeihan is saying is : If Western countries fart - it is a melodious song for the whole world to enjoy. If India farts- It is the most obnoxious and unsavoury thing to have ever happened on planet earth!!! The phenomenon of Trans national elimination of enemies of state and terrorists was started by the USA and none of the 5 or 10 eyes can lecture India about this. Mr Nizzar was a wanted terrorist who had committed acts of Terrorism in India and Canada had repeatedly declined to extradite him back to India. Canada should be put in the black list of FATF for enabling International Terrorism.
Video also demonstrates his lack of real geopolitics if they comes from non western countries, Zeihan thinks Canada is bigger democracy than worlds largest successful democracy India, the less he talks on India the better he can appear as intelligent
I don’t think it was unintentional that you left out the Saudis in your state sponsored murder examples. They got away with that without harm - we were considering protecting them from Iran in exchange for a local base and Israel deal. India watched that.
This is most neutral and credible discussion I came across on this topic. There are many discussions siding either India or Canada. Good job……Now one thing lot of people need to understand is, lot of countries have birth right to finger with internal matters of other countries but when India - if at all involved- does it to protect their interest it becomes issue. Pls be mindful India is changing very fast and becoming stronger to take care of their issues. We bled a lot in the past for now fault of ours at the hands of separatists groups supported by others with malicious intent. It could be for political or economical purposes. No more….we will defend our selves by all possible means.
How by becoming a rogue state? you can’t just go into another democratic country and start killing its citizens just because you feel like it, Indians talk nonsense 24/7 but they aren’t being targeted by other countries. So is now Trudeau your next target because he’s apparently supporting the Khalistan movement according to all your news reporters and your internet bots? It’s shameful what india is doing
They took out a guy who was trying to overthrow their government. That guy happened to be in a foreign country. So how is what India did to that Sikh guy any different from what we did to bin Laden, Zawahiri or Solemani? Don't misunderstand me, it wasn't the ideal outcome. The ideal outcome would have been to capture him alive and make him stand trial. Same goes for bin Laden, Zawahiri and Solemani. But if that's not possible, you got to do what you got to do to eliminate the immediate threat, feel me?
@@Archimedes1654In 2007 he was accused of being involved in killing of Hindu Priest. Involved in killing of opposition Congress leaders.Funding and pushing narco terrorism. Putting posters of Indian diplomats calling for their elimination. Has an Interpol notice and I think is also on some list of US
Essentially what Zeihan is saying is : If Western countries fart - it is a melodious song for the whole world to enjoy. If India farts- It is the most obnoxious and unsavoury thing to have ever happened on planet earth!!! The phenomenon of Trans national elimination of enemies of state and terrorists was started by the USA and none of the 5 or 10 eyes can lecture India about this. Mr Nizzar was a wanted terrorist who had committed acts of Terrorism in India and Canada had repeatedly declined to extradite him back to India. Canada should be put in the black list of FATF for enabling International Terrorism.
Overthrow would be a stretch too far. Both the opposition parties and ruling party agree on Khalistan issue actually. Thanks to them, we are united somewhere atleast😂
He was a separatist looking seeking an independent Sikh state within India. Right to self determination? Something we value in the west. The RCMP arrested him and said that the charges India laid against him weren’t strong enough of extradition. He was being accused of committing crimes in India even though he hadn’t been there for more than 20+ years? India itself was exposed in the 80s and 90s for propping up charges against Sikhs and letting police officers commit extrajudicial killings without any repercussions. 25,000 Sikhs in the 90s were picked up by the police and accused of committing anti Indian activities and shot. Comparing him to Osama Bin Laden is a joke. That man was behind planes flying into buildings. Advocating for Self determination isn’t equivalent to 9/11.
I don’t think he was an activist. He had an Interpol RCN issued against him. Furthermore he was wanted for bombing a movie theater in India back in 2007. Indian government had presented very compelling evidence against this guy but for some reason Canada would neither deport him nor prosecute him.
"Nijjar was known to be a vocal and active separatist, advocating for a designated Sikh homeland in India. Nijjar was organizing an unofficial referendum in India for an independent Sikh state at the time of this death. Sandhu said that Nijjar was known to have organized and attended extremist training camps for separatists." -- Andy Sandhu, Spokesperson, Okanagan Sikh Temple, Surrey
Actually, Canada has CSIS and the CSEC. But yeah, no doubt we do lean heavily on the massively larger and better funded agencies in the US. The same holds true for our military. Woefully underfunded because our government takes solace in the fact that the US would probably have our back in any large scale conflict. It's irresponsible and unfair, but it's a practice we seem intent on continuing.
@@billyb7119 Unless there is a perfect storm with US elections and the US makes the decision that you are on your own. Nothing is out of the realm of possibilities right now.
What does the Canadian government get when it blows up this issue? I don't see any upside for the Trudeau Government when there is a kerfuffle over the assassination of a man convicted of terrorism in India. There might be other ways to raise this issue rather than to bring it to the House of Commons.
Essentially what Zeihan is saying is : If Western countries fart - it is a melodious song for the whole world to enjoy. If India farts- It is the most obnoxious and unsavoury thing to have ever happened on planet earth!!! The phenomenon of Trans national elimination of enemies of state and terrorists was started by the USA and none of the 5 or 10 eyes can lecture India about this. Mr Nizzar was a wanted terrorist who had committed acts of Terrorism in India and Canada had repeatedly declined to extradite him back to India. Canada should be put in the black list of FATF for enabling International Terrorism.
Exactly. They could have used a ministerial note. Stating this in the House of Commons already escalates the case and makes it a major diplomatic incident.
I can tell you the Indian perspective(s) - 1. Compulsions of Canadian domestic politics (Jagmeet Singh, a known Khalistani/Khalistani sympathiser, as well as the ‘King Maker’ w.r.t. the current Canadian government has Trudeau by the balls). 2. An attempt by Canada (supported by the US) to prevent India from getting ‘too uppity’. In other words letting India know that they will use the fractures in Indian society to attempt coups when the time is right. You can form your own conclusions and judgements, but these are the two primary POVs here in India.
@@kc4276 Yeah, Canada and Trudeau are were really thinking over the past year, "H'mmm..what can we do to prevent India from getting too uppity?". Um, no sorry, India is not really on anyone's radar this past year.
As a Canadian I would rather see Trudeau shut down the Chinese police in Canada and just say the RCMP are trying to solve the (Indian terrorist) murder case.
@@nobody4u77 that means what exactly? They convicted him and he moved to canada somehow, gained citizenship. Then they decided to kill him? A foreign citizen on foreign soil? Thats what your crutch is? The Indian system is blatantly corrupt. There is no concept of free speech.
The Americans have better intelligence in Canada than the Canadian government does. As a Canadian, I can suggest that Toys R Us has better intelligence in Canada than the Canadian government does.
I find it very telling that India carried out that assassination about one week after Trudeau called them on it when he was visiting their country. That's how much respect India has for Canada. About the same amount that the citizens of Canada have for Trudeau...
The assassination was carried out months before. Canada tried to call them on it privately, then our press got a hold of the story, and then Trudeau HAD to go public. But you're basically right, we're FURIOUS that Trudeau has weakened our country so much that the Indians now think (apparently rightly) that they can walk all over us.
Thank You Mr. Zeihan-Our Global History Professor from RUclips University. You have taught me so much already. I never paid attention in school in regards to this subject. If I had a teacher like you, that may have been different. You rock.
His discussion lack major context in this case. The khalistanis that are in question were radicals and had record. Canada was asked for extradition many times not only in this case but historically many times in 30 years. Canada refused to extradite these people. Besides no what he is telling is just some words and not actual proof that india killed anyone.
zeihan is good, but it's important to also take in other sources. he mildly, in passing, accuses canadian media of being slanted here for example; to me that says more about peter than it does about canadian media. there is a very vocal minority in canada who advocate with flags that someone ought to hurry up and f*ck our prime minister, and so one might surmise that CHCH, global, ctv and cbc should reflect the more vocal knee-jerk views of the trucker contingent within our population. more like postmedia, sun media, or city tv. but news media, like anyone else, is mostly into selling advertising. they aim to put forth coverage from a perspective that most canadians can relate to because that gets more eyeballs and clicks. don't get me wrong, i appreciate zeihan, but i do so fully understanding that he's trying really hard to come across as an austere wealthy knowledgeable middle-aged white american male. and so i temper that with other viewpoints.
My guess is India doesn't want to do international assassinations anymore, while it's enjoying so much solid growth on many key areas. It's not worth smearing their name when things are steadily going well for India long-term. India isn't as reckless as China; they still have some good sense.
this was a disaster ....... but at-lest because of this west acknowledge about those radical groups otherwise they keep ignoring this problem and ya this was one of the issue there left and right didn't fight in India
@@mrgyani Nope, his party routinely loses elections. Can't say the same for Putin / Xi / Erdogan. Moreover, in India, if you're Muslim, you're LITERALLY above the law of the land. The civil laws do not apply to you. You can go to a Muslim sharia court (non-secular) and get a favorable decision. That alone should defeat anybody's argument of "IsLa MoPh ObIA". Citations: en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Uniform_Civil_Code#Current_status_and_opinions
"Assassinations are not along DeMoCrAtIc VaLuEs" : - an amarican Haha btw love your analysis i wish you would have also presented some indian pov on a guy who got killed... And his links with UN designated terrorist organisations.... But its ok ✌️
Who cares 😂😂 It's a non-white country which was called as savages by Churchill and Ugly looking people by Kissinger. It's good this is happening, because Indians will learn very well that west isn't friend of India. They are harboring terrorists groups who want split India, like they supported Pakistani dictators in the past. 😀😀
There was an Interpol Red Corner Notice against Nijjar for terrorism, murder and some other serious offences. The Indian government had shared this Red Corner Notice with the Canadian government well before Nijjar turned up in Canada. In fact, he got Canadian citizenship well after the Interpol Red Corner Notice was shared with the Canadian government. Something to ponder over here??? 😀
Regarding India not really changing in the last 70 years. We should look back at how they took the BRICS conference and turned it into the non-aligned nations
FIVE EYES could not detect the Hamas rocket attacks coming. So much for professional Intelligence Network! They can detect assasinations, but not 5000 rocket attacks!
He didn't even get into the Indian politics of it at all. He generalized about the geoplitics of the situation. Yes, he does know quite a bit about geopolitics.
He is not a Dissident, heck he is not even in politics. He is just a murderer on the run. Do some basic research on how he sneaked into Canada. It is a mystery how he even got Canadian citizenship. By all accounts he was being used as an Asset by Canada.
@@sudheerkumar4421 @sudheerkumar4421 Oooh nice... Whacking a terrorist (as proscribed by the government of the day) is playing with the big dogs. Sure the execution methodology was more than a little reminiscent of 1960s Mossad, but you can't knock it for effectiveness. Both in cost effectiveness and person erasing. They should lean into it at this point, hold a Trumpian style press conference and straight up accuse Castreau of harbouring a terrorist.
Announced today: Canada has removed most of its diplomatic presence from India (41) after New Delhi threatened to strip diplomatic immunities from Canadian diplomats in India. Previously to this India no longer will grant Canadians visitor Visas.
Yeah, cuz so many Canadians actually wanted to visit India. Just shows the Indian bureau raj to be a bunch of prats. India is so unused to criticism they melt like a toddler when caught red-handed.
@@ElGrandoCaymanoIgnorant comment! You’d be astonished at how many Canadians visit India daily (and a huge chunk of which are Indo-Canadians). India is sick of Canada siding with Sikh Terror groups who are trying to overthrow the Indian government. That is what this is about.
I must say, you have got the Indian perspective partly right. A bit of background (as a common Indian) on how we see the West. To start, two examples for you: 1. In the '71 war with Pakistan (Bangladesh was created), the US sided with Pakistan and even sent their 7th Fleet to the Bay of Bengal. We haven't forgotten that. We were ready to take on the fleet when the Russians sent their Subs and forced the US to stand down. 2. in '89 when Pakistan again initiated Kargil and we stood on the edge of a Nuclear war, the US had switched off GPS in the area. The US taught us never to trust them completely. But now times have changed and the West/US needs us to take on China and so we are the "best of friends"... We are well aware that the Western Nations will not make friends but will be allies; the "best of friends" label will change when they don't need us anymore - sadly, if one were to look at history, for some reason the US is incapable of making friends and standing by them through thick and thin, they are opportunistic. Our answer is to reciprocate so long as it suits us. Our national interest will come first. However, I also have to say, this is not really who India is. We have gone out of our way to help where we can make a difference. Our Vaccine distribution during Corona, Our evacuating citizens of other countries along with our own where we can. Our stepping up for Sri Lanka (just one example) when it was broke. We tried the same with Pakistan for many years but were slapped down and have given up now. We are happy to step up and extend our hand but there's a saying in Hindi - (translated) you can only clap with two hands. The other hand also needs to be extended. While we will be friends with the US, we will also continue to evaluate how the US treats this relationship and will respond appropriately - 😀The old saw upended: "Verify and then trust"... In the case of this man Nijjar, what you did not mention: This man was the head of a terrorist group - the Khalistan Tiger Force (the Gurdwara even put up a poster saying this). He had a bunch of murder cases on him in India. There was a red-corner notice by Interpol on him and despite that (Canada is a signatory too), Canada did nothing. In fact, they warned him of a potential attempt on him. Personally, I do not know who killed him, there are many versions floating around but as an Indian, if Indian Intelligence DID do so, I would applaud them.
Very well articulated. As per their profound belief and conviction, Only White countries on planet earth have - International rules of law and Moral authority.. Rest of the world is filled with savages who knows nothing about democracy and rules based order.
See the situation of Germany today being the ally, India does not need to become such ally that can be trashed so easily for another cause of so called great nation
In case nobody's thanked you lately for the backdrops you use - thank you!! I spent 20 years in Colorado and there are very few places that rival its beauty imo. It is a peaceful environment for some of the less 'peaceful' events you discuss. 🙂
This video is COMPLETELY FLAWED. J.J. McCullough did a BETTER ONE on the same topic. Four months back, Kevin O’Leary said in a Fox Business interview 6/23 - ‘IDIOTS ARE RUNNING CANADA’. * Canada should NOT be harboring terrorists or giving them asylum. It is similar to Pakistan giving shelter to Osama and Zawahiri. No difference. * India has not accepted the allegation and called them absurd. * NIJJAR AND OTHERS WANTED SHOULD HAVE BEEN EXTRADITED TO INDIA BY CANADA. Indian Government made multiple requests in the past and INTERPOL ISSUED RED CORNER NOTICES. They gave several signals they were unhappy with non-cooperation by Trudeau government. They have committed multiple heinous crimes including murder and continue to do extortion. * When Trudeau met the Punjab Chief Minister Amarinder Singh (another Sikh) in person in his previous visit in 2018, he handed over the dossier of the crimes of these Khalistani terrorists (including NIJJAR WHO HAS 16 CHARGES AGAINST HIM INCL. ATTEMPT OF MURDER, blowing up a movie theater with 6 dead and many injured), but NO ACTION was taken against these 'FUGITIVES'. In fact, a dinner event was canceled because the Punjab CM refused to attend because TRUDEAU'S ENTOURAGE INCLUDED A PERSON WHO WAS CONVICTED OF KILLING A MINISTER IN PUNJAB GOVERNMENT. Trudeau has been turning a blind eye to all Indian requests. * According to Indian Member of Parliament from opposition party (NOT from Modi’s party), Ravneet Singh Bittu (another Sikh) Nijjar was a close associate of those who ASSASSINATED ANOTHER PUNJAB CHIEF MINISTER BEANT SINGH (BITTU’S GRANDPA). At G20 Summit hosted by India, the Indian PM expressed concern on inaction by Trudeau. * These Khalistanis do not represent all Sikhs. Most Sikhs in India do not want Khalistan. These Khalistanis in Canada are puppets of the Pakistani Intelligence Services ISI waging war against India. They have been asking openly for the ASSASSINATION OF INDIAN DIPLOMATS AND MODI AND OTHER LEADERS. That is inciting violence and a violation of Vienna Convention. But JT and Jagmeet are siding with these terrorists. Freedom of speech does not mean promoting violence and hate towards others. By defending and harboring Khalistanis, CANADA is indirectly WAGING WAR AGAINST INDIA as a PROXY OF PAKISTAN. That is why INDIA MIGHT BE RETALIATING BY STOPPING VISA SERVICES TO CANADIAN CITIZENS globally. * Lorne Gunter from Toronto Sun said - "If people in another country were calling for assassination of Canadian leaders or destabilizing Canada, we will be mad (like Indians)". JT is a HYPOCRITE & INCOMPETENT and has made Canadians look bad globally. We did not get anything by upsetting India. * In this spat Canada is going to lose billions of dollars ($10-$12 billion per year) as fewer Indian students will come to Canada. * A Financial Post article published 9/26 'Diane Francis: Trudeau's diplomatic blunder raises questions about who's really running the show' says: "For Canadians, the question is why Trudeau did this and whether Singh is the real prime minister of Canada. Their partnership has damaged Canadians economically”. This means JT is Jagmeet's puppet. Both need to go.
We had the clapping for a Nazis in parliament, the assasination, a bill out to regulate pod casts and basically screen them for suitable levels of Canadian content, blocking legal protests, blocking natural gas development that would ultimately fuel germany with natural gas. We use immigration as a weapon etc. We're a big part of the global story.
@@luisluis5306 Same as Iraq possessing weapons of mass destruction? These are the are the same countries that green lighted an invasion for their political interest. Statements made by Trudeau are hearsay unless some convincing evidences are put forth by the Canadian investigating agencies. They need irrefutable evidence similar to surveillance videos of Saudi assassins that killed Kashoggi, or Russian assassination of Skripal in UK using Novichok before accusing a recognised government.
@@luisluis5306 Which proof ? Intelligence is not proof . Proof means you arrest someone and prove relations. There is no arrest made yet . I am 99% sure that pakistani and chinese did this killing. And trudeau is known to have good relation with CCP
They have long had this capacity. I was actually offered a job once, I declined. ...so in the grand scheme of things it is not really something we need to worry about. Indians are like Cats, they kind of do their own thing, but in general, they mean well. ...but like I said it is about providing value and being the best partner. As long as we focus on that and are not stabbing people in the back, we have nothing to worry about.
This is the best understanding. Indians don't wake up and say we will take over the world. Even you can take our history only reason India doesn't condemn Russia is because of the relation forced on us by USA's betrayal. When China and Pakistan attacked India and America also came with their navy only Russia culture guarded our cost and any country which helped us in Past you can check we never backstabbed. Loyalty is more important in cultre. We never even Invade any country. Maybe India did or maybe they did not. But in Canada for a few months, Indian embassies were targeted its on RUclips. To safeguard they might have taken this step. But in a general sense, we didn't assign any Canadian. If India did they assassinated India who ran after the bombing and came on fake passports did contract marriage and also were linked to the bomb blast as he also had interpol notice and we can agree Interpol did their due diligence. I hope Canada realises and makes some kind of test to let people into the country as Israel and Gaza show you have to worry about these immigrants protesting with Pro hamas.
Its a very open question as to whether India actually did it. The said individual was head of a gang that had assassinated the head of another gang recently and this could simply have been gang reprisal
Thing is it’s not clear if Indian government was actively involved in killing this guy or just helped facilitate it. That gang leader, Lawrence Bishnoy, killed another Khalistani in Canada during this fiasco. It might be that Indian Intelligence agents just provided that gang leader intel.
Thank you once again for stirring my rapidly deteriorating mind. As a really old man my personal concerns no longer exist and I can view as a bystander the incredibly tenuous political balance that now exists globally. Or……………has it always been like this and should our younger generation who are exposed to the rapidity of changing events inure themselves from over exposure to which they are subjected to. I fear only for the young.
As an American who just turned 69 yrs old, putting me firmly in that boomer demographic, I can assure you that the world at large has always been like this, IMO. I love reading history, and when I review the 20th century, I am often amazed at some of the events, disastrous fiascos, tragic wars and political misadventures which took place across the globe. Some I actually recalled, but others hardly made a ripple through the brief news cycle we had back then. Journalists were far more responsible back then, but the sources of information were more restrictive, and many things slipped through the cracks of the media industry. Corporate media didn't necessarily censor news, but coverage wasn't very detailed, especially of foreign events. The rise of social media and diffusion of news sources in this modern world does give us a wider range of coverage, but separating truth from propaganda is more difficult now. Everyone has an agenda it seems, but that just means you have to sort out the things that you see and hear. When you find a reliable source of info, like Peter, that gives you a starting point to find out more. But yes, the chaos of humanity has always been here. These days, we just have more ways to harm and destroy one another. In the case of India, I would hope that Mr. Modi doesn't start using those horrible tools of murder and assassination to solve internal political problems better resolved thru negotiations and compromise. Whether it's the Sikh issues or Hindu/Moslem tensions, or the endless fights with Pakistan, and now China. As the Israel vs. Palestinian flare-up shows us, problems left unresolved do not vanish or subside. They fester, and a small infection becomes gangrene, and finally, the possibility of amputation becomes reality. Any doctor will tell you that. I was twelve when the six-day war took place, and Israel made the fateful decision to occupy the land in question. There have been a few opportunities to resolve the issue. It didn't happen, and one can blame both sides for the failure to come to some final resolution, but the real cost of that stalemate is borne by the folks on the ground. And that tragedy has pulled the rest of us into the whole mess! Don't allow India and Canada to get pulled into bad relations because India cannot come to a real understanding with its Sikh brothers and sisters. Hindus and Sikhs are both great people, as I have experienced and witnessed. Don't allow these political disagreements to undermine or destroy your great nation. You are an ancient people, but a young nation. Don't fall apart on us. America is trying to hold together itself right now. Don't follow our bad example, and we'll both move forward, with a little luck. Peace...
"has it always been like this"? Yes, and definitely no. Yes to the rash of proxy wars promulgated by resentful authoritarian governments. No to the illiberal, anti-logic "weakist" brainwashing in which multiple "-isms" have been deliberately distorted into democracy-undermining reverse-isms.
From my experience as a university student the younger generations hate you, my classmates made jokes when they found out how many boomers died this year of covid. You will probably be remembered similarly to the ancient romans, depraved, morally bankrupt, selfish people that squandered the achievements of previous generations to enrich themselves and live contemptible lives. Its hard not to be cynical about it all, but whether you deserve it or not, once you become a demographic minority, those of you that are left will probably face very harsh discrimination in the future, especially in cities. This is the generation you raised I guess. Your children/grandchildren know their individual and national financial situation would drastically improve if you just died.
The problem was the temporary but strong commercial advantage of globalism a little before and after the end of the cold war plus the accompanying faith on it... There is something worst than chauvinism and radical nationalism and it is named a defeated or disrupted globalism. Brasil
I'm 70. I remember the CBS Nightly News with Walter Cronkite. My family watched that every night. And that was our daily dose of the outside world. I think the world has always been like it is now but CNN started the 24 hours a day, seven days a week news feed and others have followed. We are bathed in bad news every waking moment. It was always there, we were just blissfully unaware of it. I always try to remember the Serenity Prayer: "God grant me the serenity to accept the things I cannot change; courage to change the things I can; and wisdom to know the difference". I take it all in, do what I can in my own life and area to fix things and the rest I don't let get me down. I also express myself with my wallet and buying practices. I hate the murderous Chinese regime so I don't buy made in China; if some company puts up ads that deeply offend me I stop buying their products. What else can one do?@@garyspence2128
You cannot call for acts of aggression in your homeland and then take shelter behind your naturalised citizenship. All you are doing to your host is giving them a crime scene to cleanup if you do, and destroying years of diplomatic relations to boot.
@@1lonecanadian Not in the U.S. A death threat is a call for violence. Not so veiled threats, the same. It's terrorism pure and simple, embraced by those who once claimed they were engaged in a war on terror. And an ex-President leads and a tech mogul endorses it.
1:35 "US gov intel has better surveillance in Canada, than the Canadian gov intel" That's because most parts of the internet and many apps on the phone are locked into US intel, they have free access to all information.
It's also because Canadians have no interest in doing that kind of work. It's such an afterthought. Most Canadians are too polite to want to spy on their own people. I'm only partially kidding.
@@dixonhill1108Ignorance is bliss. The Canadian government illegally used cell phone data to track /trace people during covid. The Canadian government tracked illegally and published illegally all people who donated to GoFunMe for Trucker Convoy, and published the names on internet and papers.
US history isn't simple at all it just seems that way because you are around it a lot. A lot of insane stuff has happened in the US very fast. A way I would put it is that the US has had centuries of history in a century due to all the shakeups and cultural changes it has dealt with over time.
Speaking as someone who lives in Canada, can confirm there being a large Indian diaspora. Being real here for a moment, do you know what the biggest benefit of multiculturalism and immigration is? FOOD! I get to regularly enjoy good Indian food because of this.
Thank Mr. Zeihan for the last line instead of just taking morally righteous stand like all traditional media which at this point are just mouthpieces of the government.
Apparently, Canadian Intelligence missed the intel on Wei Hu and Karima Baloch. Or wait, Trudeau won’t be getting brownie points from Jagmeet Singh with that.
Also to add to your statement, the world’s best “5 eyes” intelligence didn’t have the intel of a N zi literally going to the Canadian parliament (should be one of the most vetted places) and getting a standing ovation 😂😂😂
3:39 India is not worried if they do stuff inside Canada or any other country..like they conducted referendum or protests inside Canada... India acted Or will continue to act (Atleast current leadership) when those rouge elements poses threat to Indian diplomats, and agents and Temples And also start to function inside India.
Thank you for the last sentence. We are doing well and will do well with or without the west. But we haven't reached that level of that unsavoury which the preaching countries have attained. So good for India is the Government got rid of Nijjar.
You just missed mentioning that he was wanted in India for the 2007 cinema hall bombing that killed 7 people mostly poor, and also for drug peddling and target killings. India has asked the Canadian government for his and many others' extradition. Indian teams have visited Canada many times. Even the state Government of Punjab( Sikh majority) asked Mr. Trudeau for his extradition when he visited India in 2018. The Canadian government provides a safe haven to criminals to prove how liberal they are.
You work for the Indian Gov or just an idiot?
❤
Good see this comment is mentioned
It's was happened in my city ludhiana.
Look at the colour of his skin and ask him his faith , you'll get the answer
What ticked me was the report which quoted an intelligence official who said that the murdered man was warned of possible threats multiple times before, which means police knew of his whereabouts.
Now what is concerning is that how come the police didn't arrest the guy who had an Interpol red corner notice against him, despite knowing his whereabouts ?
Guess that gives weight to Indian allegation that Canada is becoming a safe haven for criminals.
Criminal? So now he’s a criminal also? So how he’s a criminal? Just because india government is saying so? Has he ever been convicted as a criminal in court of law? The answer is a BIG NO!! Seems india government can just put labels on anyone as a criminals and terrorists to justify the killings … That makes the Indian government the real criminal organization for killing an unarmed man going to his place of worship. So it seems you want to call him a criminal so no one looks at who the real criminals are.
So let’s look at facts why did Canada allow him to stay if he’s a convicted terrorist? It’s because he never was, india keeps saying he’s a terrorist and should be extradited back to india but when Canadian authorities asked for any evidence or proof of him committed of those crimes india doesn’t have anything 😂
(UAPA) Unlawful Activities (Prevention) Act where the india government arrest you put you away forever without due trial without evidence or proof all they need to say is on the basis your involvement in terrorism against the country where all your properties will be seized.
The Indian state, like many other draconian states, sees every advocate for a separate state as a terrorist. India does not tolerate free thinking or expression if it advocates a separate state. In such cases India sees advocacy as a terror threat, it fabricates evidence uses outdated laws of secessionism to define a person as a terrorist, thus putting out red notices through Interpol. In sum, indian red notices are contrived, and don't hold up in western courts generally.
Essentially what Zeihan is saying is :
If Western countries fart - it is a melodious song for the whole world to enjoy.
If India farts- It is the most obnoxious and unsavoury thing to have ever happened on planet earth!!!
The phenomenon of Trans national elimination of enemies of state and terrorists was started by the USA and none of the 5 or 10 eyes can lecture India about this.
Mr Nizzar was a wanted terrorist who had committed acts of Terrorism in India and Canada had repeatedly declined to extradite him back to India.
Canada should be put in the black list of FATF for enabling International Terrorism.
Complete lie! Nijjar didn’t leave when he was 13! He was an adult!
And India is a safe haven for scammer call centres. RUclipsrs have found them, hacked their cameras and called indian police only to watch what looks like a tip off before the raid. Suddenly people leave, evidence is destroyed and so on. It needs to stop.
Thank you for discussing this. While an assassination by agents of another state on Canadian soil is bad, Canada should never have allowed this guy into the country in the first place, he made several bad-faith attempts to get in, and our stupid system allowed it. And, since when did Canada ever support a separatist movement in other countries? We don't take too kindly to foreign states promoting Quebec independence, so you'd think some quid pro quo would apply here. But nope, this is about the Liberal party courting votes from immigrants. If you are leaving the Old Country behind, you are supposed to leave it's problems behind too. Are you a Canadian now, or not?
Couldn't agree more...immigrants must leave old probs out.
West needs to tackle this now... Khalistanis, hamas/Palestinians etc... Is not good for adopting countries or cultures.
West needs new approach
1. If immigrant citizens commit major crimes, revoke citizenship. Deport if necessary.
2. Don't allow criminals / extrimists in.
3. Immigrants must become "Canadians" first.
What Quebec have to do here ? Your head polluted with something ?
you scared of the french coming for you ? Cannot learn a new language ? your are limited or limiting yourself. Argue for this and you will get keep your limitations
Your system recruited the scums that escaped during the crackdown against Sikh militancy. In my mind, USA wants to keep various separatist groups alive to use it as a pressure tactic from time to time. India's stand on Ukraine issue has pissed USA a lot.
He is only a temporary canadian. He is concern with mad extermination of all minorities in India.. That is christian, muslim, or perceived as anti hindu
BTW this nijjhar guy was most likely taken care of local khalistani gangs on behest of their ISI backers.
I struggle to comprehend why Western media and Western individuals seem to approach this issue from a single perspective. I have yet to see anyone acknowledge that before Hardeep Singh Nijjar became a citizen, numerous extradition requests from India went unfulfilled by Canada. This makes it questionable why Canada believes that the situation will be any different, especially when dealing with a designated terrorist.
Furthermore, if you're uncertain about this individual's background, I would encourage you to conduct a quick Google search to understand how he recently obtained citizenship, despite being denied multiple times in the past due to false information. It's striking that no one from Canadian or Western media addresses the questionable history of this individual.
0:57 For those who assert that it took them a while to get to the bottom of this issue, I would recommend delving into the historical context and integrating that perspective into their analysis. This may lead to a better understanding of how Canada is potentially becoming a safe haven for terrorists and fugitives. If you're seeking an unbiased analysis, I'd suggest looking up "Cover Up Air India, CBC reporting," which can provide you with insights into how deeply rooted this issue is. However, if you prefer to maintain your current perspective and paint India in a negative light, that remains your prerogative.
lol western ppl see it from their own perspective. No one here gives a shit about Indias problems the core of the issue is how are foreign governments doing this on our soil and how are we letting these ppl in the first place.
@@Trambo1997your problem is you are becoming heaven for terrorists to stay. Pakistan also did that, funding terrorists against india but now getting harmed by those terrorists themselves, canada will also see this in few years
India just had an assassination plot foiled that was meant to take place in America. They just get to assassinate anyone wherever they want?
Activist is not terrorist. If they had a trial in India and found to be guilty then Canada would have sent them back but if they didn't get a trail and feared for their life, Canada has to accept them as amnesty seekers. No matter what; you don't go around assassination people in a friendly country. This man would never have made it to trail in India this man was convicted and assassinated. India hates criticism then India should never have done something so stupid. India made India look bad.
@@lilavall4735 Hmm, so this so-called activist who has videos where they're encouraging violence and spreading hate against India and its citizens. His speeches, originating from a place of worship, are laden with hostility, he offered rewards for killing politicians in India. If individuals like this are labeled activists, I wonder, in your dictionary who was Osama or Abu Bakr al-Baghdadi ? And yet again someone speaking on behalf of western values and accusing other nation, without a shred of evidence if it was government job
I was at work in Vancouver when one of the Air India suspects was arrested around the corner. From what I recall, the case was bungled and they were set free. India was furious. This time they took it into their own hands. Not acceptable to do in a sovereign country but I can understand their frustration with the Canadian justice system. This kind of thing happens all too often and we are far too lenient on criminals in general. Oligarchs, wealthy gang members and other unsavoury characters can also easily immigrate or buy property here (like in the UK).
Yes, people who want come to the US would settle in Canada instead because the money requirement is a lot less.
Maybe that’s a way for us to get rid of the Mango Messiah- Have Trump emigrate to Toronto to hang out with his buddy the surviving Ford brother!
@@TheDogGoesWoof69 Most protesters get dispersed or arrested within hours or days, the truckers protested for weeks, sounds to me like the truckers were treated preferentially.
@@johnsmyth9123 Being treated like terrorists is preferential?
They literally activated their anti-terrorism powers to arrest the truckers as terrorists.
Meanwhile, Trudeau partying with actual terrorists.
Trudeau is yet another mini-Hitler. Screw that guy.
These Khalistanisnis and Pakistan ISI right above the state of Washington being all those drugs in the USA but blame the Mexicans.
Zeihan : what India did was unsavoury to democratic norms.
also Zeihan : US does it, UK does it, Russia does it. meh.
Can’t even repeat thing right? smh. He said “ Americans do it by drone”
There is a difference between taking out a current threat and settling old scores. This extrajudicial killing was revenge. If the goal was justice, India should have snatched him and spirited him back to India for a trial.
Or they could have just used a drone. 😅
Yep . People seem to forget groups like the Hells Angels are run by the NSA .
They were doing it in Canada? When has the US or UK ever assassinated someone in Canada? These are third world problems they've imported. Pray for the European people's worldwide, we have dark times ahead.
@@MarcosElMalo2They DID use a drone. Just happened to be breathing and have a pair of legs and arms.😉
This isn't the first instance of violence in Canada regarding Sikh terrorism. Air India Flight 182 was the deadliest terrorist attack in Canadian history killing 329 people. One went to jail for 5 years, the other two aquitted through the Canadian courts.
also India had warned Canada about the terrorists but they didn't listen
It was organised by khalistanis who now run your government. Congrats
The Sikhs I know don't seem to be involved in terrorism, at least in the U.S. Some of them are jerks, but that doesn't mean anything. I know a lot of jerks that aren't Sikh.
If India killed him He must be t*rrorist
Other hand Canadians MP's don't what Nazi people did🤣🤣🤣
Christ
“India unsavory authoritarian govt.” My third visit to this channel. And damn, just when I was beginning to appreciate and think this guy was well-informed, the mask falls away. Glad didn’t spend too much time on this channel. Not because he specifically trashed India, but because the “expertise” just became questionable and untrustworthy. I was here to learn. It is on “Do not recommend” list.
Don't be surprised if he's a muslim from Pakistani/Arab parents or whatever. They are fed with same "India is under dictatorship" rhetoric just bcoz a govt is there with a clear majority which just doesn't panders to these radicals and stops them from playing their favorite game of jihad. Or he's just another ignorant white dude who knows a thing or two of Asia by studying half baked facts from Western media houses and claiming to be an "expert".
He is right though
@@KKR-bf8ku Ok. Just FYI, opinions are not facts.
@@msms3260 I didn't say opinions are facts but I agree with his opinion on how world or western countries perceive india
India can make right decisions in future only when it's aware of their consequences
I didn't find his tone anti india in any way but a very realistic view about india and it's relations with western bloc which is getting stronger recently due to china factor
@@KKR-bf8ku Doesn’t matter if he is anti India or not. Saying India is unsavory, and claiming Indian govt is most authoritarian sounds like un-informed opinion. Just makes me question rest of his talks, you know just like finding a strand of hair in the food. No matter, how good rest of the the food is, I am done with it at that point, and that’s just me buddy.
As a social scientist who studied South Asia for 40 years, and lives in Canada, I would like to add some context and recent history to this discussion. New Delhi has been frustrated over Canadian politicians' wooing of radical elements in the Sikh diaspora for several decades. While the Khalistan movement (for a separate Sikh homeland) is today peaceful, in the 1980s and 1990s it was extremely violent in India. I know because I was studying at a university in New Delhi at the time. The Bhindranwala faction of the Khalestan movement assassinated 20-30,000 people, mainly government servants, other religious sects, political moderates and secularists between 1980-early 1990s. They took over the Golden Temple in Amritsar, the foremost Sikh holy place, believing that the Indian government would never invade it, and carried out their terror from there. Indeed, there was a young woman from Punjab in my hostel at JNU whose parents were assassinated. Indira Gandhi eventually sent troops into the Golden Temple, and in reprisal, her Sikh bodyguards assassinated her, following which there was a terrible pogrom against Sikhs in New Delhi. Rajiv Gandhi, who succeeded his mother, pretty well ended the Bhindranwala movement, not only by repression, but also agreeing to most economic grievances that were driving the conflict (a conflict over state sharing of river irrigation). He also supported a moderate Sikh party in following elections. It appears that a significant number of Khalistani supporters emigrated to Canada, the US, and Britain. It is in these places that the Khalestan movement survives, and has been dominating some electoral ridings in Canada where Sikhs are in a majority. Canadian politicians, including Trudeau, have wooed these groups to help win elections. Many Canadian politicians attend rallies where the assassination of Indira Gandhi is celebrated in posters, etc. Granted we have free speech in Canada, but since when did Canaidan politicians support a separatust movement in another country? I don't agree with the assassination at all, and it's true that the Indian government has become more authoritarian under Modi, but India's foreign affairs have not changed that much in relation to Sikh separatism since 1980. Trudeau even invited a Canadian Sikh emigre who had been convicted in Canada of murdering a state minister from PUnjab to embassy receptions in New Delhi during his so-called 'state visit'. Another really stupid foreign policy blunder by our feckless PM. When there was a separatist movement in Quebec in the 1960s that turned violent, Justin's father, Pierre Trudeau, introduced the War Measures Act, while his very stupid son boasts that he does a better bhangra than Jugmeet Singh, and cosies up to formerly violent Sikh political activists. So: what India did was very wrong. But I understand the frustration of the Indian government trying to deal with an idiot PM who just doesn't get it that it's not ethical or right to support separatist movements in another country. This issue has been raised by India many, many times. And I don't understand how various Canadian politicians can attend rallies where posters celebrate Bindhranwala and Indira Gandhi's assassination and not know who or what they are dealing with. Although Britain and the US also have large Sikh emigre populations, you don't see politicians there cosying up to Sikh separatists. Hopefully, we will have someone more competent following our next elections.
no one goona read that at least put some summary
@@surajraika7821I read the whole thing.
It was not TL, I did R it. Thanks.
ummm learn some patience and read it all..... thanks for the balanced perspective....
Best of the comments I have read so far. However I might have described Trudeau as being somewhat more than feckless.
As a Canadian, I apologise to all Indians on behalf of our government. We harboured a terrorist that threatened your sovereignty and then blamed India publicly without any proof (still waiting for that credible allegation). I’m depressed about the situation we’re in right now as a country 😔🇨🇦
Is there any proof btw that the assasination was carried out by India and not by some internal enemy??
U don't need to my brother.
As a Indian, I want to make one thing clear to Canadian people that we don't hate Canadian people at all it's just we don't like current Canadian govt, PM Justin T. and his policy to support to militant sepertist, radical extremist groups who want to distroy social harmony in India.
@Texa8 Clearly you are in Indian (maybe from Texas), its funny how you are posing as a Canadian. lol. Its ok though, we are with you. One thing we can agree upon is that Trudeau is an absolute idi-ot. By the way, your english is littered with Indian english giveaways. ;)
Forgot to mention, canada failed to provide evidence (except credible allegations).
Canada forced india to believe in word of mouth (forcefully convincing india to trust on canada)
Where canada's credibility index is less then 5 out of 10..
As action speaks louder than words and result speaks louder than actions..
Similarly, india also seeks for action of canada by having proof. and india not going to believe in just words by corporate controlled canadian international media.
All GAP (grey area points) such as morality, manners, human rights are relative and hence defination of such keywords are expected to be interpreted by impacted country.
Canada tried to own GAP by using the word (credibility) without asking india... this is how canada became dictactor in the name of freedom of speech...
Just one note- the man killed here was openly calling for assassinations of Indian diplomats among others things! He had a track record for pretty unsavoury stuff.
It's not the character in this case, it's the precedence.
Canada has sadly long cozied up to the separatist movement of the Sikhs for a very long time spanning decades much to the annoyance of India
Even accepting the Canadian citizenship of former violent members of the movement that had criminal pasts or suspected of such in India
And this is despite Canada who once had their own separatist movement they violently had to put down, Quebec
Which you don't see India trying to champion the cause of the Quebecois
What India did was wrong but it does have an explanation, if only the idiotic of the Trudeau family could have recognized this fact. Because the cozying of the Sikhs and their separatists cause even goes back to Justin Trudeau's father
@@rejvaik00 Trudeaus are a footnote in leadership, you're treating it like f'in USA dynasty. No Canadian politicians have that influence. It's not like other places the premiers have the power here. Not a republic. You're applying politics that don't exist. All of this nonsense you morons spout is soap opera stuff. We have very few politicians that stay in government for more than 3 terms of 4 years and they wildly differ in stances. The idiotic take is yours.
@@slangster233 The o.p.s point was that there are many people who wanted him dead and might have been willing to act on it. The least likely to act would be the Indian government.
The only evdence put forward that it was the Indian governmemt that was the culprit is Trudeau's assurance that he has seen that evidence but he can't reveal it.
That's honestly totally irrelevant. If he'd been found to have committed crimes in Canada, he would have been tried for them. Having another country swoop into a sovereign, developed, democratic nation, ignore its rule of law, and murder its citizens, is wildly unacceptable.
Btw, Noor Chowdhury the main person behind the assassination of sheikh mujibur rahman, the founding father of Bangladesh ran away and is living in canada. Bangladesh has repeatedly asked for his extradition and canada has turned a blind eye!
USA having better intel about Canadian citizens than the Canadian government may seem surprising, but really it isn't. One of the "advantages" of the five-eyes system is that if you have inconvenient domestic laws blocking surveillance of your own citizens it's so much easier to let one of your partners without any such legal impediments do it for you and then just swap data.
In the business world we call that consulting. Outsource the decision making so it isn’t your fault if there are negative consequences. 😅
Next thing you know the British are putting together dossiers for you on your own party's candidates!
American intelligence has prevented a few terrorist attacks in canaduh
Canadians have no interest in intelligence agencies, not even on the radar of something we'd ever work to support.
Exactly.
Apart from Canada in the Five Eyes alliance, they supported Canadians even without strong evidence because they wanted to take advantage of the situation to align India with the Ukraine issue (as the USA desired) and secure a favorable deal in the Free Trade Agreement (as the UK desired). However, they were surprised by India's actions and chose not to escalate the situation further. India is needed to counterbalance China in the long run. For the USA, it doesn't matter if the government or country is democratic or non-democratic, as long as it aligns with their strategy. We have seen this when they aligned with Pakistan and created the Taliban and in other places too
Exaclty. Our embrace of Saudi Arabia for decades, even to the extent of not holding it responsible for the 15 of 19 pilots responsible for 9/11, and instead blaming Hussein. I'm not saying either should be embraced. Just reinforcing your point that while the U.S. claims to be supporting even spreading, in times of war, democracy, even in its own border, that platitude is entirely for show among certain people who also want to claim a defense for free speech as a cover for hate.
I think India's window is closing fast.
The USA is pulling out all manufacturing from China and moving as much of it as possible to Mexico under the NAFTA umbrella.
India should have begged for a bigger seat at the table, like Japan did.
The problem is in thinking you can rely on India at all.
They'll use you to degrade China but won't lift a finger to help you, unless they are attacked, even then it'll be, you go first.
Otherwise they'll hedge their bet, buy your weapons because Russian weapons are scarce and proving to be crap.
Remember the "I" in BRICS is for India and BRICS is for dedollarization.
Besides India doesn't win fights against China, so brings little to the table.
Investing in India is a huge mistake unless you're in love with corruption.
Bribery is how you get the thing you've already paid for, done.
They'll sell you out for a dollar faster than you can say Jack Sprat.
And I say this liking Indians but the best of the bunch doesn't live in India and hasn't for decades.
Why do you think they left?
@@protorhinocerator142 India can survive and grow alone with its domestic consumption... But, as nowadays India offering very offordable manufacturing with skilled labours its hard for capitalists to not to invest in India.. However west have learnt the lesson... THey wont dependent on only one country for sure.. India wont be big as china But certainly it will be the economy of 15-20 trillion economy.. which is more than sufficient to rule over Indian subcontinent... as India dont have the ambition of rule the whole world like USA But India want to have the soft influence in the whole world and strong dominant power in its region
@@Shri_Hegde This is a good wisdom.
Great take Zeihan, like always. Being an Indian what I can say is that Indians have a very pro-West view of the world. Indians are one of the populations that rate the US most favorably (in surveys). But this Khalistan issue has been a very emotive one. We lost a Prime Minister (Indira Gandhi), Chief Minister of Punjab, Police Chief, Army General and thousands of citizens to this terrorism and Trudeau has been sheltering and cultivating this movement, which is effectively dead in india since the last 2-3 decades.
Some hate just never gets buried with the people it was supposed to die with.
If the khalistan movement is effectively dead in India, what's the point of the assassination? Is the "peace" in khalistan so fragile that a single guy oceans away can threaten it?
Ideally India should have worked through the criminal justice system to extradite the guy. But if India wants to take a shortcut, fine. Just admit to the assassination and explain why. None of this "show me the evidence" chicken poop.
@@dcc70 the person assisinated was the key conspirator in a bomb blast in punjab that killed 6 people, on the interpol list and on the no fly list. India requested for his extradition formally from Canada multiple times.
@@ARP1714 no. He was 9 when that bombing happened.
@@matthewmcclary7855 no. You are confusing it with the Air India Kanishka bombing. This is the Punjab cinema bombing, a different incident.
This analysis is based on if and how the west would re-think about relations with India. But India, on multiple occasions, has been forced to re-think about relations with the west. For instance, what USA did during 1971 India pakistan war is something we will neither forget, nor forgive.
Sorry, 1971 is a closed chapter. US has among the highest ratings in India compared to most other countries. As they say, in international relations there are no permanent friends or enemies, only permanent interests.
No one cares...
Very well said bro.... We will never forget and forgive.
@@chaitanyaranjan2184We are still using 1971 whenever we have self interest and to stand against USA. So it's not closed case.
excellent so when are your fam going to be leaving the West?
For decades Canada has been treating terrorism lightly, going all the way back to 1970 with the FLQ Crisis when Justin’s dad, Pierre, was prime minister. Since then other nationalist organizations with a terrorist wing have been setting up shop on Canada’s soil, usually in order to have a secure base to organize and fund their organizations, but also to mount the occasional operation abroad, such as the Air India bombing. Terrorists would often leave Canada, get wounded or arrested, and Canada would work to bring the Canadian passport holders back. Most notably, a teenaged terrorist, who made bombs to kill American (not to mention, Canadian) soldiers in Afghanistan, killed an American medic who was attempting to treat his wounds after a firefight, ending up in Guantanamo only to be released into Canadian custody, who not only quickly released him onto Canada’s streets, but gave him over ten million dollars to boot. BTW, the Canadian government didn’t pay the widow of the American medic so much as a penny. Things like this tell international terrorists that Canada is the place to be.
@MyLateralThawts All Sikh terrorist bomb Air India plane and There was another bomb which exploded in airport but who were involved behind this bombing no trial and This People has a lot background criminal activities like Gang war and smuggling drugs to India and India has not country like American or Russian but our country is too much peaceful who get our independence from Britishers without any violence
Canada for terrorists & separatists
UK for fraudsters & looters.
Australia, now is hard on crime.
But I remember this joke:
Australian immigration officer - "Do you have a criminal record? "
Visitor - "You still take only criminals? I thought those days were long gone! "
This is the case for Bangladesh as well.
Canada gave safe haven to a terrorist who killed Mujeeb Rehman (Father of Bangladesh). He walks freely there.
These Western Governments are Ganging up to Force India 🇮🇳 into Submission 😒
CIA setup this whole Rig to manipulate Indians Foreign Policy 😒😒
As an Indian, some part of me hopes that the allegations actually prove to be true. Unfortunately, no evidence has been presented so far and given the stellar record of American intelligence over the last two decades, its difficult to take anything that they say seriously!
Your mentality is why Modi has managed to turn your country into a theocracy. You are cheering for it for a false sense of pride but eventually your country will be the worse for it becoming the next Iran. It will continue on its path to become an authoritarian shithole with over a billion poor oppressed citizens. Enjoy your hate-filled ride to abject poverty.
I don't just take western intelligence at their word, but I would add that they have been significantly better starting with the call like to the week of the Russian invasion
The guy killed was an international terrorist and wanted by Interpol.
There's a difference between intelligence and the political uses of intelligence. It's important to grasp the distinction.
@@calc1657: never contested that. But given that US intelligence unearthed 'credible' information about the existence of WMDs, its hard to take any claims on behalf of that quarter seriously
Hahaha 😂"... if you ever see someone jumping out of a hospital windows, it's probably an assassination... " got me rolling on the floor. Originally Putin's favorite.
He forgot Putin's newest one - getting the target high on drugs/vodka, then giving him a grenade to play with.
Defenestration is a centuries old tradition from Tsarist Russia.
Assassination is the wrong word to use Mr Zehan. Killed or neutralized is a better word to use. A man of your class should know that. 😂
@@satishkumarkn1164 Yeah because assassination has the word "ass" two times in it. Not very classy
uh no it isnt defenstration as a famous practice started in prague
prague is not anywhere near russia.
any other ass pulls you want to make.@@SBCBears
What about a Bloach lady killed in Canada by Pakistani Intelligence Agency ISI …. She is a freedom fighter of Blochistan province from Pakistan Killed few months ago … why don’t Trudo shout on that murder because khalistan sikh control your government not that Baloch fighters …. Canadians Need to understand this …
As a Canadian, the decline of security intelligence and policing - competency is becoming an issue not only for canadians but her surrounding allies. Let alone the the incompetence of the current liberal government.
Everything under Trudeau sadly is failing our military and intelligence is just being exposed more quickly.
Not sure what you're basing the lack of security and intelligence comments on, but the Conservatives/NDP/Liberals are all in the same boat of incompetence.
CSIS seems to still be OKAY but we need to seriously revamp our military and policing. And elect a new government.
Voting for a guy called "Justin" is a crime unto itself. Justin is only being himself😂
Imagine if tables are turned and India supports Quebec supporters and eggs them on in Canada to separate
I just wanted to thank everyone who responded to my comment. I"m flabbergasted that so many did, and surprised to find that so many fellow Canadians are concerned about the Liberal governments' tolerance of extremists in Canada. Justin seems determined to compromise Canada and India's security needs for the sake of a few electoral wins in Surrey and south Vancouver. I'm retired now, but still do some research and publishing. I thought I might write up an article on my personal observations in Delhi as a student, along with historical and on-line research. And then it hit me: I might end up a victim of Khalistani violence. Like Ujjal Dosanjh and others who were critical of the movement in the 1980s. So I won't publish the article, or at least not put my name on it. But I will write the article, because I feel Canada's slide towards being a safe haven for terrorists is making my head explode. But thanks agains for your varied and interesting responses. It has somewhat restored my faith in human nature. I believe diasporic politics has no place in Canadian politics, if only because those who espouse violence form 15,000 miles away never have to be accountable for their actions. It's like chasing a phantom that has no reality in between global locations, but dangerous effects in each separate geography.
Zeihan’s videos are so devoid of any reality that they make a fun watch.
I just love this word *Credible Alligation*
😂😂I haven't heard *Credible Proof* word😂😂😂😂
The guy was wanted by interpol and extradition request was sent to Canada gov in 2019. Calling the khalistan movement non violent is bending the truth when you consider drug & human trafficking by its organizations. Not to mention the attacks on hindu temples and Indian diplomats in both Canada & UK. They have publicly threatened to blow up a sports stadium with 100k capacity this very month.
Attacks on Hindu temples is another thing found out to be falsified. This is all Godi media RSS propoganda.
Essentially what Zeihan is saying is :
If Western countries fart - it is a melodious song for the whole world to enjoy.
If India farts- It is the most obnoxious and unsavoury thing to have ever happened on planet earth!!!
The phenomenon of Trans national elimination of enemies of state and terrorists was started by the USA and none of the 5 or 10 eyes can lecture India about this.
Mr Nizzar was a wanted terrorist who had committed acts of Terrorism in India and Canada had repeatedly declined to extradite him back to India.
Canada should be put in the black list of FATF for enabling International Terrorism.
Also when you consider it's past. They were ultra-violent in the 1980s and 1990s.
In Canada it’s easy to say anything about anyone… unless you use the wrong pronouns.
no you can do that too, you just have to say sorry afterwards
Ya! What he said ya tranny... sorry bud.
In Canada we can use whatever pronoun we want, we're just considered rude if we don't use someone's preferred pronoun. As it should be.
@@DAndyLord As long as you pay the fine, you can say what you want. Don't worry, the court will seize your stuff until they have enough to cover your fine.
@@DAndyLordare you guys taking the license of a psychiatrist because he refuses to use the preferred pronouns?
Moon landings and political assassinations....welcome to "The Game", India.
I had a good laugh.
Next step is invasion of Sri Lanka?
INDIA supports Russia
@@JattaPunjabTha Don't care who asked.
@@JattaPunjabTha Ok. Then pack up and get out of Silicon Valley. 🙄🙄
Thanks for uploading!!
1. The guy Nijjar was a murder having blood on hand, used false identification to Canada!
2. India and Canada have extradition treaty. India's intelligence is known for its frugality when it comes to operate outside the border of India! Even to deploy lawyers, Indian govt would hesitate to spend money, that too on such criminals!
3. My view is: Trudeau is a seduced bloke under blackmail by ISI and Khalistanis and would do anything asked of him by this combine!
4. The Punjabi / Haryanvi gangster who was operating with ISI/Khalistanis has broken from them and might be the key figure in deploying his resource in Canada to eliminate Nijjar who was his companion one time!!
The line about Americans being "okay with assassination if it's done by drone, but we seem to get upset when it's done in person." Was dark but hilarious, because it's kind of true.
😅
That is not true. The US enjoyed killing Osama bin Laden point blank.
Or is it that the Americans don't mind at all sending an assassin in person but they prefer to publicize the drones so people focus on that and don't realize who has been killed off in person?
Essentially what Zeihan is saying is :
If Western countries fart - it is a melodious song for the whole world to enjoy.
If India farts- It is the most obnoxious and unsavoury thing to have ever happened on planet earth!!!
The phenomenon of Trans national elimination of enemies of state and terrorists was started by the USA and none of the 5 or 10 eyes can lecture India about this.
Mr Nizzar was a wanted terrorist who had committed acts of Terrorism in India and Canada had repeatedly declined to extradite him back to India.
Canada should be put in the black list of FATF for enabling International Terrorism.
3min silence for those who think India is not aware about USA's friendly nature towards India for the china cause...Calculations are way ahead(obviously on all sides) of what we r watching in this video or what we can think of.. So just chill n enjoy n be informed (if u r not doing masters on international relations)
A point that Zeihan missed: that Sikh man was in the no fly list(a list prepared for suspected terrorists) of USA😅
you can go on the no fly list for having any court cases or pending charges. it is not only for terrorists. but you people love to lie.
Getting on the no fly list requires very little suspicion.
Also, he was perhaps the only plumber in Canada who does drilling job with an AK-47 😁.
Dude no need for excuse, India cold-blooded killed this guy cause your country is strong now. Moral was never part of the equation in geopolitics.
@@nishitbarodia2718I haven't seen anything other than accusations and allegations, can you provide a source for your comment about a conviction? Thanks
Peter probably forgot to mention that the person was a terrorist, and Canada government has a lot of internal politics going on at the moment. Trueadu might not be the most popular guy in Canada, and he was armtwisted to make this statement by his coalition partner.
I feel other western nations don't care about Trueadu's Canada, much. Their advise to Canada would be to quell down Khalistani terrorism (which btw, has bombed a plane that killed 100s of citizens US, Canada, India etc.), rather than ranting about it in the public.
The only ones who arm-twisted him were our journalists, who learned of the story and were about to go public with it. Trudeau had to make a statement before it appeared in the newspapers. Trudeau has tried to keep Chinese meddling in Canadian elections a secret, and he's paid for it. If he was caught trying to keep an outright assassination a secret, it could have been the end of his government.
And the Air India bombing happened before many of us were born. Of course no one cares about it now. Ask a 20-year-old american what they think of 9/11 and you're not going to get an emotional response.
the #3 Party in canada has a sihk as the leader. sihks have worked their way into a lot of political influence in canada. there are also close to a million of them in canada , i think.
One man's terrorist is another man's freedom fighter
@@ronblack7870yea sikhs got alot of voice with the help of hindu vote which is more than them in numbers and always thought of them as brothers that support base is gone forever
That guy was declared terrorist, involved in assassination of State Chief Minister, and had Red Corner notice from Interpol.
The Indian government's dossier on Hardeep Singh Nijjar does not accuse him of being a separatist, but of his involvement in organising several targeted killings and attempted killings in Punjab. Canada has ignored the Indian government's requests for his repatriation to stand trial for these alleged killings on the basis of the information provided by some of the actual executors of these crimes. He was a designated terrorist wanted by the Home Ministry and the National Investigation Agency. If Trudeau wants to support such operations conducted by his supporters, the Indian government will accord Canada the same status as it does to Pakistan. So you have all the capabilities for protecting this asset that you would or could not spare to anticipate what Hamas was upto.
Indias accusations have about as much weight as Chinese accusations. No wonder Canada didn't hand him over.
@@CedarHunt you wrong the Interpol lists him as a terarosit
@@levinjoseph233 No, Interpol had an alert that stated "The Indian government considers this person a terrorist" which is VERY different. Interpol didn't even have a warrant for him.
@@CedarHunt Remember the case of Air India Flight 182 which was brought down by a bomb planted by Khalistan extremists in 1985, and the guys involved were already suspects of the Canadian intelligence. Trudeau''s father Pierre had refused to extradite Talwinder Singh Parmar in 1982 and as a consequence 329 innocent lives were taken by the group which had included that terrorist. Was Nijjar an asset of Canadian intelligence such as it is? It is Trudeau who is impervious to embarrassment.
Not to mention the US and UK have done VERY similar things to folks they considered terrorists on other country's sovereign lands - for the US and UK to condemn this at all would be a tad hypocritical. That being said, it's perfectly ok for Canada to say 'hey wait a minute' when this happens on THEIR soil.
Canadian here just east of Ottawa Ontario Canada.
Thank you for all these videos
Washington Post reported that at least six gunmen and two cars were involved in the killing of this man. Does look like a shoddy attempt if this was indeed done by a state. I think it is more likely to be gang violence related with the possiblity of Indian handlers having some indirect role. Bigger question is why can't Canadian law enforcement identify the gunmen or at the very least find the two cars caught on CCTV?
India paid local gang members to do the hit. They tried recruiting people several times.
I love WaPo.
"Democracy dies in darkness."
It doesn't matter what you think. It matters what you can prove. And the intelligence points directly to the Indian gov't.
Smart boy.
It's not a shoddy attempt if they succeeded. If the Indian diplomats who coordinated the operation had enough sense to keep their mouths shut, the police may have indeed assumed it was gang violence as well.
Good analysis 🎉🎉
... another way to conclude, "Even if we don't like it, India will be just fine."
Relations between Canada and India started going south the day Trudeau visited India wearing his indian clown suit. 😂😅
Not exactly. They went south after the Air India bombing in the 80s and Canada's refusal to extradite suspects! Trudeau Sr. Why? to win votes in some specific electoral ridings. I know it's pathetic. It's Canada after all.
The guy took a terrorist with him, a wanted terrorist if that isn't the biggest diplomatic insult I don't know what is.
It started years ago when India decided to reduce importing crops from Canada, in an attempt to improve food security in India...supposedly. Now the plan is to end lentil imports from Canada entirely.
Modi better pray hard to numerous gods for good weather for their domestic agriculture.
@@michaeldowson6988it started years ago when your govt allowed terrorists in your state and even undermine the air India bombing investigation and extradited the criminals. Good luck with nurturing snakes in your backyard.
@@michaeldowson6988 Waheguru is with India. You need not to worry
I think the big mistake was that Trudeau went very public with this accusation and created a huge media stir and unecessary conflict with India . If you follow Canadian politics you’ll know he did this the day or day after parliament reopened and he was getting absolutely ripped apart for the botch job he’s done managing this country (I say this as a normally liberal supporting Canadian) it was very obvious to me that this was to distract from what was the media narrative of sagging liberals in the polls , a housing crisis disaster and the grocery inflation. Suddenly he made this India accusation and all that talk disappeared for a few weeks. Brilliant actually for him bad for everyone else including sikhs in India who probably don’t want more conflict stirred up .
Essentially what Zeihan is saying is :
If Western countries fart - it is a melodious song for the whole world to enjoy.
If India farts- It is the most obnoxious and unsavoury thing to have ever happened on planet earth!!!
The phenomenon of Trans national elimination of enemies of state and terrorists was started by the USA and none of the 5 or 10 eyes can lecture India about this.
Mr Nizzar was a wanted terrorist who had committed acts of Terrorism in India and Canada had repeatedly declined to extradite him back to India.
Canada should be put in the black list of FATF for enabling International Terrorism.
Don't worry of the Sikhs here. We know who's who and let us make it certain that we don't see these terrorists as Sikhs.
Yeah!!!
The consequences of this are NOW visible. 40 Can. Diplomats GONE. This impacts all the 10s of thousands of students who would have otherwise gone to Canadian Universities to study - the equivalent of $25B revenue if I have the number right. FTA GONE. It ALSO impacts all the other games that were being played in India.
Watching the fun and the conciliatory whining that is happening now...
@@RinkaSingh Again, no one in Canada cares. No Canadians want to visit India. No student cares if Indian students come. The only one losing in this situation is India. The average Canadians cares the same for an independent Punjab as the average Indian cares about a Quebec. Where are the Indian students going to go now? The US? Get real, India has just embarrassed itself by making itself look like an immature child. How many Canadians do you think ever visit India outside of the diaspora?
@@ElGrandoCaymanoonly you boomers don't. Canada runs on these university scams. And there is nothing an insignificant, powerless country like canada can do even if India carries out 10 such incidents on canadian soil
Dear Canadians. India is 5000+km away and apart from being a nuisance these separatists have no chance of succeeding because they don’t have any support within India. However, sooner or later these separatists will become a headache for Canada. You will not be able to control them because they will continue to become more radicalized. Hope better sense prevails and you elect a leader who will not allow these nonsensical shenanigans to happen in your soil.
Peter on Nations Abilities to Assassinate People: "Obviously the Brits are pretty good at that as well..." I wanna hear more about THAT!
You've never watched a Bond film? Lol
007 lol...
Mostly Northern Ireland.
So many key points are missing. This is one video where I think Zeihan has not studied enough.
Elaborate? He often misses a piece of the puzzle which I realize when he talks about something I'm knowledgeable about, in this case I am certainly not so some pointers would be neat?
Essentially what Zeihan is saying is :
If Western countries fart - it is a melodious song for the whole world to enjoy.
If India farts- It is the most obnoxious and unsavoury thing to have ever happened on planet earth!!!
The phenomenon of Trans national elimination of enemies of state and terrorists was started by the USA and none of the 5 or 10 eyes can lecture India about this.
Mr Nizzar was a wanted terrorist who had committed acts of Terrorism in India and Canada had repeatedly declined to extradite him back to India.
Canada should be put in the black list of FATF for enabling International Terrorism.
Video also demonstrates his lack of real geopolitics if they comes from non western countries, Zeihan thinks Canada is bigger democracy than worlds largest successful democracy India, the less he talks on India the better he can appear as intelligent
I don’t think it was unintentional that you left out the Saudis in your state sponsored murder examples. They got away with that without harm - we were considering protecting them from Iran in exchange for a local base and Israel deal. India watched that.
He left out the biggest example- USA with the likes of Bin Ladin, General Soleimani, Al Zarqawi and so many others.
@@artman12no he didn’t
@@rustyshackleford4761what about the Intel every knows but can't be made public by Trudeau himself
@@artman12typical fed
@@dimeobladewhat?
This is most neutral and credible discussion I came across on this topic. There are many discussions siding either India or Canada. Good job……Now one thing lot of people need to understand is, lot of countries have birth right to finger with internal matters of other countries but when India - if at all involved- does it to protect their interest it becomes issue. Pls be mindful India is changing very fast and becoming stronger to take care of their issues. We bled a lot in the past for now fault of ours at the hands of separatists groups supported by others with malicious intent. It could be for political or economical purposes. No more….we will defend our selves by all possible means.
How by becoming a rogue state? you can’t just go into another democratic country and start killing its citizens just because you feel like it, Indians talk nonsense 24/7 but they aren’t being targeted by other countries. So is now Trudeau your next target because he’s apparently supporting the Khalistan movement according to all your news reporters and your internet bots? It’s shameful what india is doing
They took out a guy who was trying to overthrow their government. That guy happened to be in a foreign country. So how is what India did to that Sikh guy any different from what we did to bin Laden, Zawahiri or Solemani? Don't misunderstand me, it wasn't the ideal outcome. The ideal outcome would have been to capture him alive and make him stand trial. Same goes for bin Laden, Zawahiri and Solemani. But if that's not possible, you got to do what you got to do to eliminate the immediate threat, feel me?
Specifically, what crime did he commit? Who did he murder? What did he steal? What specifically did he do to deserve death?
@@Archimedes1654In 2007 he was accused of being involved in killing of Hindu Priest. Involved in killing of opposition Congress leaders.Funding and pushing narco terrorism. Putting posters of Indian diplomats calling for their elimination.
Has an Interpol notice and I think is also on some list of US
Essentially what Zeihan is saying is :
If Western countries fart - it is a melodious song for the whole world to enjoy.
If India farts- It is the most obnoxious and unsavoury thing to have ever happened on planet earth!!!
The phenomenon of Trans national elimination of enemies of state and terrorists was started by the USA and none of the 5 or 10 eyes can lecture India about this.
Mr Nizzar was a wanted terrorist who had committed acts of Terrorism in India and Canada had repeatedly declined to extradite him back to India.
Canada should be put in the black list of FATF for enabling International Terrorism.
Overthrow would be a stretch too far.
Both the opposition parties and ruling party agree on Khalistan issue actually. Thanks to them, we are united somewhere atleast😂
He was a separatist looking seeking an independent Sikh state within India. Right to self determination? Something we value in the west. The RCMP arrested him and said that the charges India laid against him weren’t strong enough of extradition. He was being accused of committing crimes in India even though he hadn’t been there for more than 20+ years? India itself was exposed in the 80s and 90s for propping up charges against Sikhs and letting police officers commit extrajudicial killings without any repercussions. 25,000 Sikhs in the 90s were picked up by the police and accused of committing anti Indian activities and shot. Comparing him to Osama Bin Laden is a joke. That man was behind planes flying into buildings. Advocating for Self determination isn’t equivalent to 9/11.
thank you from England Peter. your work is greatly appreciated.
I don’t think he was an activist. He had an Interpol RCN issued against him. Furthermore he was wanted for bombing a movie theater in India back in 2007. Indian government had presented very compelling evidence against this guy but for some reason Canada would neither deport him nor prosecute him.
"Nijjar was known to be a vocal and active separatist, advocating for a designated Sikh homeland in India.
Nijjar was organizing an unofficial referendum in India for an independent Sikh state at the time of this death. Sandhu said that Nijjar was known to have organized and attended extremist training camps for separatists."
-- Andy Sandhu, Spokesperson, Okanagan Sikh Temple, Surrey
India has RAW
U.K. has MI6
US has CIA
Israel has Mossad
Canada has OSIFG(Open source Info from google)
🤣😂😂😅😅🤣🤣🤣
Actually, Canada has CSIS and the CSEC. But yeah, no doubt we do lean heavily on the massively larger and better funded agencies in the US. The same holds true for our military. Woefully underfunded because our government takes solace in the fact that the US would probably have our back in any large scale conflict. It's irresponsible and unfair, but it's a practice we seem intent on continuing.
You can't leave out Pakistan's ISI from that list. They even roped in Indian and American diplomats in their counter-intelligence apparatus.
@JasbirSingh-zj1fg ISI is quite useless, they are just a low level branch of the CIA
@@JasbirSingh-zj1fg lol 🤣
@@billyb7119 Unless there is a perfect storm with US elections and the US makes the decision that you are on your own. Nothing is out of the realm of possibilities right now.
What does the Canadian government get when it blows up this issue? I don't see any upside for the Trudeau Government when there is a kerfuffle over the assassination of a man convicted of terrorism in India. There might be other ways to raise this issue rather than to bring it to the House of Commons.
Essentially what Zeihan is saying is :
If Western countries fart - it is a melodious song for the whole world to enjoy.
If India farts- It is the most obnoxious and unsavoury thing to have ever happened on planet earth!!!
The phenomenon of Trans national elimination of enemies of state and terrorists was started by the USA and none of the 5 or 10 eyes can lecture India about this.
Mr Nizzar was a wanted terrorist who had committed acts of Terrorism in India and Canada had repeatedly declined to extradite him back to India.
Canada should be put in the black list of FATF for enabling International Terrorism.
Exactly. They could have used a ministerial note. Stating this in the House of Commons already escalates the case and makes it a major diplomatic incident.
I can tell you the Indian perspective(s) -
1. Compulsions of Canadian domestic politics (Jagmeet Singh, a known Khalistani/Khalistani sympathiser, as well as the ‘King Maker’ w.r.t. the current Canadian government has Trudeau by the balls).
2. An attempt by Canada (supported by the US) to prevent India from getting ‘too uppity’. In other words letting India know that they will use the fractures in Indian society to attempt coups when the time is right.
You can form your own conclusions and judgements, but these are the two primary POVs here in India.
How did Canada "blow up' the issue? Did you comment without watching the video?
@@kc4276 Yeah, Canada and Trudeau are were really thinking over the past year, "H'mmm..what can we do to prevent India from getting too uppity?". Um, no sorry, India is not really on anyone's radar this past year.
As a Canadian I would rather see Trudeau shut down the Chinese police in Canada and just say the RCMP are trying to solve the (Indian terrorist) murder case.
Indian "Terrorist" ? What exactly makes him terrorist?
@@ts9271 he is convicted in india .
@@nobody4u77 that means what exactly? They convicted him and he moved to canada somehow, gained citizenship. Then they decided to kill him? A foreign citizen on foreign soil? Thats what your crutch is? The Indian system is blatantly corrupt. There is no concept of free speech.
As a Canadian, you should ask your PM for the proof. 😂😂
First of all your not Canadian, your another Indian stooge sitting in india 🇮🇳 who doesn’t even know United States doesn’t have a PM 😂
The Americans have better intelligence in Canada than the Canadian government does. As a Canadian, I can suggest that Toys R Us has better intelligence in Canada than the Canadian government does.
Y'all still have Toys 'R' Us?
Canada has great intelligence, but JT chooses to ignore it.
The best kind of intelligence is the intelligence you never hear about.
Don’t be so quick to denigrate Canada
@@Whatmeister apparently you haven't been paying attention to the Liberal comedy hour, which went into production in 2015.
I find it very telling that India carried out that assassination about one week after Trudeau called them on it when he was visiting their country. That's how much respect India has for Canada. About the same amount that the citizens of Canada have for Trudeau...
or for India.
The assassination was carried out months before. Canada tried to call them on it privately, then our press got a hold of the story, and then Trudeau HAD to go public. But you're basically right, we're FURIOUS that Trudeau has weakened our country so much that the Indians now think (apparently rightly) that they can walk all over us.
You have your dates wrong.
The assassination occurred months before G20. What are you talking about
Nijjar died in June. 2 months before Turdeau said anything on the floor of his parliament.
Thank You Mr. Zeihan-Our Global History Professor from RUclips University. You have taught me so much already. I never paid attention in school in regards to this subject. If I had a teacher like you, that may have been different. You rock.
he talks out his back end too.
His discussion lack major context in this case. The khalistanis that are in question were radicals and had record. Canada was asked for extradition many times not only in this case but historically many times in 30 years. Canada refused to extradite these people.
Besides no what he is telling is just some words and not actual proof that india killed anyone.
zeihan is good, but it's important to also take in other sources. he mildly, in passing, accuses canadian media of being slanted here for example; to me that says more about peter than it does about canadian media. there is a very vocal minority in canada who advocate with flags that someone ought to hurry up and f*ck our prime minister, and so one might surmise that CHCH, global, ctv and cbc should reflect the more vocal knee-jerk views of the trucker contingent within our population. more like postmedia, sun media, or city tv. but news media, like anyone else, is mostly into selling advertising. they aim to put forth coverage from a perspective that most canadians can relate to because that gets more eyeballs and clicks. don't get me wrong, i appreciate zeihan, but i do so fully understanding that he's trying really hard to come across as an austere wealthy knowledgeable middle-aged white american male. and so i temper that with other viewpoints.
@@bas-tn3umso EXACTLY a professor.
oh youre a leftist we have to question him just not any socialist policy or belief.
got it.@@apagoogootwo7552
Why was Hardeep nijjar soooo important to the Canadian government?????? Why ?????
My guess is India doesn't want to do international assassinations anymore, while it's enjoying so much solid growth on many key areas. It's not worth smearing their name when things are steadily going well for India long-term.
India isn't as reckless as China; they still have some good sense.
this was a disaster .......
but at-lest because of this west acknowledge about those radical groups
otherwise they keep ignoring this problem
and ya this was one of the issue there left and right didn't fight in India
Lol, India under Modi? He is on the lines of Putin & Erdogan..
@@mrgyani Nope, his party routinely loses elections. Can't say the same for Putin / Xi / Erdogan.
Moreover, in India, if you're Muslim, you're LITERALLY above the law of the land. The civil laws do not apply to you. You can go to a Muslim sharia court (non-secular) and get a favorable decision. That alone should defeat anybody's argument of "IsLa MoPh ObIA".
Citations: en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Uniform_Civil_Code#Current_status_and_opinions
@@mrgyanifor example? How trudeau is even better bdw?
@@watanabe00738 Trudeau is definitely not better.
"Assassinations are not along DeMoCrAtIc VaLuEs" : - an amarican
Haha btw love your analysis i wish you would have also presented some indian pov on a guy who got killed... And his links with UN designated terrorist organisations.... But its ok ✌️
Who cares 😂😂
It's a non-white country which was called as savages by Churchill and Ugly looking people by Kissinger.
It's good this is happening, because Indians will learn very well that west isn't friend of India. They are harboring terrorists groups who want split India, like they supported Pakistani dictators in the past. 😀😀
I tell everyone about your daily updates. Keep them coming!
There was an Interpol Red Corner Notice against Nijjar for terrorism, murder and some other serious offences. The Indian government had shared this Red Corner Notice with the Canadian government well before Nijjar turned up in Canada.
In fact, he got Canadian citizenship well after the Interpol Red Corner Notice was shared with the Canadian government. Something to ponder over here??? 😀
Regarding India not really changing in the last 70 years. We should look back at how they took the BRICS conference and turned it into the non-aligned nations
So the Canadian Govt is not interested bringing culprits to justice when they claim know who did it! There were several men/cars on video!
they dont know, they think india did it, but have zero evidence which can be used legally.
FIVE EYES could not detect the Hamas rocket attacks coming. So much for professional Intelligence Network! They can detect assasinations, but not 5000 rocket attacks!
Thank you for the informative video. I like the beautiful backdrop!
Thanks for the content Peter, keep em coming.
Thanks for the analysis, good job.
Thank you for covering this!
Just to let u know there was no stamp of approval from any country . Couldn't find any official statement.
Been waiting for this.
Thank you, Peter.
an american talking abt an indian domesttic issue....u clearly think tht he has the understanding to talk abt this? seriously???
@@sudheerkumar4421 Assassinating a Canadian citizen is not an "indian domesttic (sic) issue".
He didn't even get into the Indian politics of it at all. He generalized about the geoplitics of the situation. Yes, he does know quite a bit about geopolitics.
@@sudheerkumar4421 Your "domestic issue" stops being domestic when the matter happens inside our countries.
@@j.erickson8571 canada is a domestic issue in india...
First thing I check on when I wake up every morning is this channel 🤘
Well if you can't whack a dissident living abroad, can you even get into the superpower conversation?
not just a dissident but a most wanted terror suspect...
lol stfu interpol exists genius@@sudheerkumar4421
He is not a Dissident, heck he is not even in politics. He is just a murderer on the run. Do some basic research on how he sneaked into Canada. It is a mystery how he even got Canadian citizenship.
By all accounts he was being used as an Asset by Canada.
😂😂😂 good one 👍
@@sudheerkumar4421 @sudheerkumar4421 Oooh nice... Whacking a terrorist (as proscribed by the government of the day) is playing with the big dogs.
Sure the execution methodology was more than a little reminiscent of 1960s Mossad, but you can't knock it for effectiveness. Both in cost effectiveness and person erasing. They should lean into it at this point, hold a Trumpian style press conference and straight up accuse Castreau of harbouring a terrorist.
Nailed 👏
Announced today: Canada has removed most of its diplomatic presence from India (41) after New Delhi threatened to strip diplomatic immunities from Canadian diplomats in India. Previously to this India no longer will grant Canadians visitor Visas.
Yeah, cuz so many Canadians actually wanted to visit India. Just shows the Indian bureau raj to be a bunch of prats. India is so unused to criticism they melt like a toddler when caught red-handed.
@@ElGrandoCaymanoIgnorant comment! You’d be astonished at how many Canadians visit India daily (and a huge chunk of which are Indo-Canadians). India is sick of Canada siding with Sikh Terror groups who are trying to overthrow the Indian government. That is what this is about.
"As a Canadian" for the next 100 comments 🤦♂️
I must say, you have got the Indian perspective partly right. A bit of background (as a common Indian) on how we see the West.
To start, two examples for you:
1. In the '71 war with Pakistan (Bangladesh was created), the US sided with Pakistan and even sent their 7th Fleet to the Bay of Bengal. We haven't forgotten that. We were ready to take on the fleet when the Russians sent their Subs and forced the US to stand down.
2. in '89 when Pakistan again initiated Kargil and we stood on the edge of a Nuclear war, the US had switched off GPS in the area. The US taught us never to trust them completely.
But now times have changed and the West/US needs us to take on China and so we are the "best of friends"... We are well aware that the Western Nations will not make friends but will be allies; the "best of friends" label will change when they don't need us anymore - sadly, if one were to look at history, for some reason the US is incapable of making friends and standing by them through thick and thin, they are opportunistic. Our answer is to reciprocate so long as it suits us. Our national interest will come first.
However, I also have to say, this is not really who India is. We have gone out of our way to help where we can make a difference. Our Vaccine distribution during Corona, Our evacuating citizens of other countries along with our own where we can. Our stepping up for Sri Lanka (just one example) when it was broke. We tried the same with Pakistan for many years but were slapped down and have given up now.
We are happy to step up and extend our hand but there's a saying in Hindi - (translated) you can only clap with two hands. The other hand also needs to be extended. While we will be friends with the US, we will also continue to evaluate how the US treats this relationship and will respond appropriately - 😀The old saw upended: "Verify and then trust"...
In the case of this man Nijjar, what you did not mention: This man was the head of a terrorist group - the Khalistan Tiger Force (the Gurdwara even put up a poster saying this). He had a bunch of murder cases on him in India. There was a red-corner notice by Interpol on him and despite that (Canada is a signatory too), Canada did nothing. In fact, they warned him of a potential attempt on him.
Personally, I do not know who killed him, there are many versions floating around but as an Indian, if Indian Intelligence DID do so, I would applaud them.
Very well articulated.
As per their profound belief and conviction, Only White countries on planet earth have - International rules of law and Moral authority..
Rest of the world is filled with savages who knows nothing about democracy and rules based order.
See the situation of Germany today being the ally, India does not need to become such ally that can be trashed so easily for another cause of so called great nation
Really good commentary...
In case nobody's thanked you lately for the backdrops you use - thank you!! I spent 20 years in Colorado and there are very few places that rival its beauty imo. It is a peaceful environment for some of the less 'peaceful' events you discuss. 🙂
I agree! I watch in part because of the scenery and I like how the seasons change throughout.
“There’s good in this world mr Frodo! And it’s worth fighting for” vibe for sure 😂
@@KW-hk2jd We need to cobble together a montage video showing backgrounds, locations, and timelines.
And Again Peter has the BEST backdrop for his Lecture! 1st Place!
Has Canada shared the source and information with India?
no.
Good narrative building. Good luck.
Thank you Mr. Zeihan for taking the time to post about this.
He should have taken more time to reasearch the issue and know the facts 1st. Huh
This video is COMPLETELY FLAWED. J.J. McCullough did a BETTER ONE on the same topic.
Four months back, Kevin O’Leary said in a Fox Business interview 6/23 - ‘IDIOTS ARE RUNNING CANADA’.
* Canada should NOT be harboring terrorists or giving them asylum. It is similar to Pakistan giving shelter to Osama and Zawahiri. No difference.
* India has not accepted the allegation and called them absurd.
* NIJJAR AND OTHERS WANTED SHOULD HAVE BEEN EXTRADITED TO INDIA BY CANADA. Indian Government made multiple requests in the past and INTERPOL ISSUED RED CORNER NOTICES. They gave several signals they were unhappy with non-cooperation by Trudeau government. They have committed multiple heinous crimes including murder and continue to do extortion.
* When Trudeau met the Punjab Chief Minister Amarinder Singh (another Sikh) in person in his previous visit in 2018, he handed over the dossier of the crimes of these Khalistani terrorists (including NIJJAR WHO HAS 16 CHARGES AGAINST HIM INCL. ATTEMPT OF MURDER, blowing up a movie theater with 6 dead and many injured), but NO ACTION was taken against these 'FUGITIVES'. In fact, a dinner event was canceled because the Punjab CM refused to attend because TRUDEAU'S ENTOURAGE INCLUDED A PERSON WHO WAS CONVICTED OF KILLING A MINISTER IN PUNJAB GOVERNMENT. Trudeau has been turning a blind eye to all Indian requests.
* According to Indian Member of Parliament from opposition party (NOT from Modi’s party), Ravneet Singh Bittu (another Sikh) Nijjar was a close associate of those who ASSASSINATED ANOTHER PUNJAB CHIEF MINISTER BEANT SINGH (BITTU’S GRANDPA). At G20 Summit hosted by India, the Indian PM expressed concern on inaction by Trudeau.
* These Khalistanis do not represent all Sikhs. Most Sikhs in India do not want Khalistan. These Khalistanis in Canada are puppets of the Pakistani Intelligence Services ISI waging war against India. They have been asking openly for the ASSASSINATION OF INDIAN DIPLOMATS AND MODI AND OTHER LEADERS. That is inciting violence and a violation of Vienna Convention. But JT and Jagmeet are siding with these terrorists. Freedom of speech does not mean promoting violence and hate towards others. By defending and harboring Khalistanis, CANADA is indirectly WAGING WAR AGAINST INDIA as a PROXY OF PAKISTAN. That is why INDIA MIGHT BE RETALIATING BY STOPPING VISA SERVICES TO CANADIAN CITIZENS globally.
* Lorne Gunter from Toronto Sun said - "If people in another country were calling for assassination of Canadian leaders or destabilizing Canada, we will be mad (like Indians)". JT is a HYPOCRITE & INCOMPETENT and has made Canadians look bad globally. We did not get anything by upsetting India.
* In this spat Canada is going to lose billions of dollars ($10-$12 billion per year) as fewer Indian students will come to Canada.
* A Financial Post article published 9/26 'Diane Francis: Trudeau's diplomatic blunder raises questions about who's really running the show' says: "For Canadians, the question is why Trudeau did this and whether Singh is the real prime minister of Canada. Their partnership has damaged Canadians economically”. This means JT is Jagmeet's puppet. Both need to go.
Peter talking about Canada!? Must be a slow news week 😅
Think of it as talking about India.
@@AUniqueHandleName444 It was, Canada just happened to be where the "target" resided!?!
both the ukraine/russia and israel/palestine wars are in kind of a lull atm so yes it's a slow news week.
We had the clapping for a Nazis in parliament, the assasination, a bill out to regulate pod casts and basically screen them for suitable levels of Canadian content, blocking legal protests, blocking natural gas development that would ultimately fuel germany with natural gas. We use immigration as a weapon etc. We're a big part of the global story.
No one complains when James Bond kills someone -
🤣
Nine times out of ten he's stopping non-aligned aligned actors with some crazy plot for world domination, possibly involving space lasers.
And he gets to sleep with their wives/girlfriends after that.😅😅Some guy.
@@stephenderry9488😂😂😂
Good report, thanks - Z
Did Canada provide any proof yet ?
Watch Video again, the USA and UK did!
@@luisluis5306sure, we believe you😂, you come to RUclips for bull$hitting😂😂
@@luisluis5306 Same as Iraq possessing weapons of mass destruction? These are the are the same countries that green lighted an invasion for their political interest. Statements made by Trudeau are hearsay unless some convincing evidences are put forth by the Canadian investigating agencies. They need irrefutable evidence similar to surveillance videos of Saudi assassins that killed Kashoggi, or Russian assassination of Skripal in UK using Novichok before accusing a recognised government.
@@luisluis5306 Which proof ? Intelligence is not proof . Proof means you arrest someone and prove relations. There is no arrest made yet . I am 99% sure that pakistani and chinese did this killing. And trudeau is known to have good relation with CCP
@@luisluis5306 they did not. They just have intelligence which is not evidence. No one trust random intelligence
They have long had this capacity. I was actually offered a job once, I declined. ...so in the grand scheme of things it is not really something we need to worry about. Indians are like Cats, they kind of do their own thing, but in general, they mean well. ...but like I said it is about providing value and being the best partner. As long as we focus on that and are not stabbing people in the back, we have nothing to worry about.
What job .. please elaborate
Cats you knew were actually cubs. Now they’re all grown up.
@@vaibhavsaxena1084 we look forward to working with you. Cheers.
Trump backstabbed the Kurds.
This is the best understanding. Indians don't wake up and say we will take over the world. Even you can take our history only reason India doesn't condemn Russia is because of the relation forced on us by USA's betrayal. When China and Pakistan attacked India and America also came with their navy only Russia culture guarded our cost and any country which helped us in Past you can check we never backstabbed. Loyalty is more important in cultre. We never even Invade any country. Maybe India did or maybe they did not. But in Canada for a few months, Indian embassies were targeted its on RUclips. To safeguard they might have taken this step. But in a general sense, we didn't assign any Canadian. If India did they assassinated India who ran after the bombing and came on fake passports did contract marriage and also were linked to the bomb blast as he also had interpol notice and we can agree Interpol did their due diligence. I hope Canada realises and makes some kind of test to let people into the country as Israel and Gaza show you have to worry about these immigrants protesting with Pro hamas.
I was wondering about the timing of this kill, why now? what fueled their sense of urgency to do that kill?
Canada converts to the one true Religion and *everybody gets a free circumcision!!!*
Its a very open question as to whether India actually did it. The said individual was head of a gang that had assassinated the head of another gang recently and this could simply have been gang reprisal
When you want to keep growing you need to destroy enemies
It's not an open question according to Zeihan
Thing is it’s not clear if Indian government was actively involved in killing this guy or just helped facilitate it. That gang leader, Lawrence Bishnoy, killed another Khalistani in Canada during this fiasco. It might be that Indian Intelligence agents just provided that gang leader intel.
what happened to karima baloch
Thank you once again for stirring my rapidly deteriorating mind. As a really old man my personal concerns no longer exist and I can view as a bystander the incredibly tenuous political balance that now exists globally. Or……………has it always been like this and should our younger generation who are exposed to the rapidity of changing events inure themselves from over exposure to which they are subjected to. I fear only for the young.
As an American who just turned 69 yrs old, putting me firmly in that boomer demographic, I can assure you that the world at large has always been like this, IMO. I love reading history, and when I review the 20th century, I am often amazed at some of the events, disastrous fiascos, tragic wars and political misadventures which took place across the globe. Some I actually recalled, but others hardly made a ripple through the brief news cycle we had back then. Journalists were far more responsible back then, but the sources of information were more restrictive, and many things slipped through the cracks of the media industry. Corporate media didn't necessarily censor news, but coverage wasn't very detailed, especially of foreign events. The rise of social media and diffusion of news sources in this modern world does give us a wider range of coverage, but separating truth from propaganda is more difficult now.
Everyone has an agenda it seems, but that just means you have to sort out the things that you see and hear. When you find a reliable source of info, like Peter, that gives you a starting point to find out more. But yes, the chaos of humanity has always been here. These days, we just have more ways to harm and destroy one another.
In the case of India, I would hope that Mr. Modi doesn't start using those horrible tools of murder and assassination to solve internal political problems better resolved thru negotiations and compromise. Whether it's the Sikh issues or Hindu/Moslem tensions, or the endless fights with Pakistan, and now China. As the Israel vs. Palestinian flare-up shows us, problems left unresolved do not vanish or subside. They fester, and a small infection becomes gangrene, and finally, the possibility of amputation becomes reality. Any doctor will tell you that. I was twelve when the six-day war took place, and Israel made the fateful decision to occupy the land in question. There have been a few opportunities to resolve the issue. It didn't happen, and one can blame both sides for the failure to come to some final resolution, but the real cost of that stalemate is borne by the folks on the ground. And that tragedy has pulled the rest of us into the whole mess! Don't allow India and Canada to get pulled into bad relations because India cannot come to a real understanding with its Sikh brothers and sisters. Hindus and Sikhs are both great people, as I have experienced and witnessed. Don't allow these political disagreements to undermine or destroy your great nation. You are an ancient people, but a young nation. Don't fall apart on us. America is trying to hold together itself right now. Don't follow our bad example, and we'll both move forward, with a little luck. Peace...
"has it always been like this"? Yes, and definitely no. Yes to the rash of proxy wars promulgated by resentful authoritarian governments. No to the illiberal, anti-logic "weakist" brainwashing in which multiple "-isms" have been deliberately distorted into democracy-undermining reverse-isms.
From my experience as a university student the younger generations hate you, my classmates made jokes when they found out how many boomers died this year of covid. You will probably be remembered similarly to the ancient romans, depraved, morally bankrupt, selfish people that squandered the achievements of previous generations to enrich themselves and live contemptible lives. Its hard not to be cynical about it all, but whether you deserve it or not, once you become a demographic minority, those of you that are left will probably face very harsh discrimination in the future, especially in cities. This is the generation you raised I guess. Your children/grandchildren know their individual and national financial situation would drastically improve if you just died.
The problem was the temporary but strong commercial advantage of globalism a little before and after the end of the cold war plus the accompanying faith on it...
There is something worst than chauvinism and radical nationalism and it is named a defeated or disrupted globalism.
Brasil
I'm 70. I remember the CBS Nightly News with Walter Cronkite. My family watched that every night. And that was our daily dose of the outside world. I think the world has always been like it is now but CNN started the 24 hours a day, seven days a week news feed and others have followed. We are bathed in bad news every waking moment. It was always there, we were just blissfully unaware of it. I always try to remember the Serenity Prayer: "God grant me the serenity to accept the things I cannot change; courage to change the things I can; and wisdom to know the difference". I take it all in, do what I can in my own life and area to fix things and the rest I don't let get me down. I also express myself with my wallet and buying practices. I hate the murderous Chinese regime so I don't buy made in China; if some company puts up ads that deeply offend me I stop buying their products. What else can one do?@@garyspence2128
You cannot call for acts of aggression in your homeland and then take shelter behind your naturalised citizenship. All you are doing to your host is giving them a crime scene to cleanup if you do, and destroying years of diplomatic relations to boot.
Free Speech means free speech, not free speech when convenient.
@@idleishde6124 free speech is not without its consequences. Call for violence, and you will get some...for free.
They did do the biggest terrorist attack on aviation from Canada. So these militants are terror plotter.
@@1lonecanadian Not in the U.S. A death threat is a call for violence. Not so veiled threats, the same. It's terrorism pure and simple, embraced by those who once claimed they were engaged in a war on terror. And an ex-President leads and a tech mogul endorses it.
1:35 "US gov intel has better surveillance in Canada, than the Canadian gov intel" That's because most parts of the internet and many apps on the phone are locked into US intel, they have free access to all information.
It's also because Canadians have no interest in doing that kind of work. It's such an afterthought. Most Canadians are too polite to want to spy on their own people. I'm only partially kidding.
@@dixonhill1108Ignorance is bliss. The Canadian government illegally used cell phone data to track /trace people during covid. The Canadian government tracked illegally and published illegally all people who donated to GoFunMe for Trucker Convoy, and published the names on internet and papers.
Moral of the Story
.
Don't Harbour terrorists against fellow democracy.
.
If democracy means anything to the West, that is.
The more I learn about other countries, ( just read Bhindranwale wiki in part) the more astonished and appreciative of how simple our US history is.
Simple? Simply twisted and getting more so by the daay.
@@izzytoons compared to?
The Usa is barely 400 years old..here in India we have buildings older than that. So it goes without saying..
@@izzytoons Read a book.
US history isn't simple at all it just seems that way because you are around it a lot. A lot of insane stuff has happened in the US very fast. A way I would put it is that the US has had centuries of history in a century due to all the shakeups and cultural changes it has dealt with over time.
I would love to hear more about your opinion on the liberty of the Canadian press !
Speaking as someone who lives in Canada, can confirm there being a large Indian diaspora. Being real here for a moment, do you know what the biggest benefit of multiculturalism and immigration is? FOOD! I get to regularly enjoy good Indian food because of this.
Isn't getting a cookbook easier than giving up your country to aliens?
Hah, I use the same argument when people tell me about "diversity" food.
We've also had great Terror Parades as well. Enjoy your multiculturalism in 15-20 years at this pace. Canada might well turn out to be North Venezuela
@@minuteman4199they are not giving their lands to aliens, they are giving it to khalistani terrorists who are much worse than aliens
The food is great, but I'm less enthused about the housing crisis and sectarian violence
This sort of thing is just totally unacceptable. There's just no way to make it "ok."
Thank Mr. Zeihan for the last line instead of just taking morally righteous stand like all traditional media which at this point are just mouthpieces of the government.
Well apparently it seems like 5eyes has intel on "plumber" but totally missed hamsa when it screwed up Israel good luck with 5eyes intel 😂
There were warnings to Israel but for some reason they didn't give it much attention. That's the big scandal
Apparently, Canadian Intelligence missed the intel on Wei Hu and Karima Baloch. Or wait, Trudeau won’t be getting brownie points from Jagmeet Singh with that.
Also to add to your statement, the world’s best “5 eyes” intelligence didn’t have the intel of a N zi literally going to the Canadian parliament (should be one of the most vetted places) and getting a standing ovation 😂😂😂
3:39 India is not worried if they do stuff inside Canada or any other country..like they conducted referendum or protests inside Canada...
India acted Or will continue to act (Atleast current leadership) when those rouge elements poses threat to Indian diplomats, and agents and Temples And also start to function inside India.
it was not india. it was western powers that did it.
Thank you for the last sentence. We are doing well and will do well with or without the west. But we haven't reached that level of that unsavoury which the preaching countries have attained. So good for India is the Government got rid of Nijjar.