J.D. Vance compared Sino-American diplomacy: We have built a foreign policy of hectoring and moralizing and lecturing countries that don't want anything to do with it. The Chinese have a foreign policy of building roads and bridges and feeding poor people.
Remember circa 2020 when they said China was 2 to 5 genarations behind in chips which would take decades for them to catch up, they found out quick that it is really on their heels behind when Huawei came out with their phone powered by a 7nm chip.
You need a lot more than what they did in response to sputnik. In the 1960s, the United States had the biggest industrial system in the world. The investments made in the late 1950s and early 1960s was to accelerate what was already there. They did not have to rebuild anything. The United States of the 1960s had the best educated labor force in the world. These skillful people took years to develop. The United States of the 1960s had the most innovative system in the world. Remember Bell Lab? Bell Lab practically invented the information age. The United States of the 1960s had very little debt. They could spend as much money as necessary to improve the human capital. At that time, many big companies provided a lot of technical training to their employees because they knew the employees would stay and that training would provide a return on investment. Many of these elements are gone. Today, schools are busy fight culture wars. Many school districts are "graduating" subpar students. Universities are outrageously expensive. Companies do not train people not only because they care first and foremost the quarterly profit, also because people move. Human capital is the most important factor and that takes time. It takes years to develop welders, machinists, electricians. Is there any politician interested in these long term, boring issues? What you need is a total orientation of the country. There is no true reform without a lot of wealthy and privileged people getting hurt, their wealth diminished. Can the United States summon the national will to do it?
At this point, their politicians are more likely to collapse the economy just to embarrass the political party in power. If there's one thing that Chinese history has shown, it's that the biggest threat to any political establishment is the OTHER political faction. The US can't have a national revival while half their media at any time is screaming that the president is literally the devil.
USA don't seem to understand thst during the cold war, USA was not alone against Soviet. They had help from China but this time China is on the other side and thus lose the brain. I don't see usa will grow without the brain from China
Remember also the US was so dominant at that time because the rest of the world was still rebuilding from WW2. It was inevitable that balances would change again. Being willing to accept not being able to dominate everyone else doesn't mean US quality of life had to drop... That is purely domestic problems that has caused that.... Many of which you listed.
This is a very good analysis. What is concerning for the US is that majority of the viewers are not Americans, they are probably watching Netflix or Superbowl. They won't know what hit them and probably don't care.....
The American mantra now to stay number one is the supposed ' superiority in innovation'. But there's no real argument why such an overwhelming majority of Chinese STEM engineers (compared to the numbers in the west) won't be at least as inventive as their western counterparts. After all major early inventions are Chinese and for a great part it's western suppression of the past centuries that kept a lot of countries, China included, from flourishing.
I used to work for nVidia. The best engineers I worked with were either white or Chinese (sorry about my political incorrect opinion). I have yet to meet one single good Indian engineer. Most of them were good talkers. That is probably why we see so many Indians in politics now. In China, engineers run the country.
Early Chinese inventions are grossly overstated. Japanese study from a few years ago showed that almost all inventions in human history have happened in the west, over the last 200 years. The British isles alone account for something like half of all inventions.
@@jacobzindel987 the keyword is last 200 years. The Chinese attributed the loss to the barbarian ruling of the Northern minority over 90% of Han population.
The speaker should advise how to improve the economy of the west without using sanctions n printing money. Should have industry that improve life instead of taking human life.
#2 is higher than #1, you should embrace it. Besides, you should experience being not a bully and superpower for your own sake. Trust me no pain, no gain. May be you will come to realize all efforts to maintain your hegemony for all the decades is futile and useless. May be you will mature up and learn the lessons of knowing what true kindness means along with many other virtues other countries enjoy. Good luck in your path to downhill.
If they're not so bent on imposing itself to the world and turn its efforts and money to improving itself, there's a bigger possibility that they can compete with the chinese. As long as their purpose is world domination, it hastens their fall from grace.
Do Americans want to be World No. 1 weapons manufacturers? Do Americans not want to enjoy peace so that can pursue prosperity n happiness MORE THAN being a World No. 1 Weapons manufacturing country?
They might as well be the the no. 1 in weapon manufacturing factoring how much bigger their defense budget than the next 10 nations, but still they fail in that one.
China don't go to war for Resources! It helps countries to make money for their resources and obtain great infrastructure as well, helping it's people with transport, employment and boosting their economy. China also supplies the best technology to these countries and eduction which in turn lifts them out of poverty. China also give coutries long term low interest rates for easy lone repayments. China brings people together and does not divide people and conquer races like the colonial West has always done! Thankfully The West is Finished. 🙏🏻
"How much China is going to grow, is a less interesting question, than how China chooses to grow." Aaditya Mattoo (Chief Economist of The World Bank East Asia & Pacific - 2023.
The US lost its superpower status in 1971 when President Nixon suspended the convertibility of the U.S. dollar to gold, effectively ending the Bretton Woods system. The US can no longer keep its commitment to exchange gold and the US dollar at a fixed rate of $35 per ounce. It was financially exhausted by spending on the Space program, the Great Society program, and the Vietnam War. A nation's power is based on its economic strength. The last time the US had a positive trade balance was in 1975, according to the U.S. Trade Balance report for 1970-2023. The US is now the world's largest debtor, reflected in its net international investment position (NIIP) of -$14.3 trillion. In comparison, China (including Hong Kong) is the world's largest creditor with a NIIP of $4.3 trillion. The last time the US had a positive NIIP was in 1988. The US incurs an additional debt of 10 billion dollars and a trade deficit of 3 billion dollars daily. David Goldman suggests borrowing more money to fund a moonshot program to solve its 35 trillion dollar debt problem.
"The US lost its superpower status in 1971" I'd argue that the US lost the FOUNDATION upon which its superpower status was built. The country coasted along as a superpower for decades past that time, and is in the process of discovering that it is no longer the superpower it once was. Most are still in denial, however.
The space program and welfare is not why the US cannot balance its budget. It cannot do it because it wants to keep its empire but want to maximize its companies' profits.
4:48 Except at a higher price because of the extra transfer cost, investment, logistics and additional profits to cover the risk. Major manufacturers in South East Asia do not want the transfer from China because they know the orders will return to China as soon as the policy changes again. The increase from 800B to 1.2T is because of the higher prices for the same amount of goods.
Yes maybe China is progressive... But beyond china's gigantic success is also the gigantic violation on human rights..Gigantic Lies of the Communist PLA. The Gigantic Propaganda Lies from their PLA Media Gigantic Violatior in encroaching inside neighboring countries water EEZ.. sending other countries lot of huckers & Spy's, destroying the marine biology &steeling fish and other resources from its neighboring Countries... Manipulating other countries Economy to gain Power.. Donot forget...the Communist China donot respect Human rights. Ex. 1child policy & 1china policy.. They Donot have Religious freedom.. Don't have freedom of speech. The Media news & information are controlled by the Communist They Don't have government transparency. And they Refuse to follow International Law
When you survey all empires in history, whether they be in Europe, Middle East or China, once the empire starts to decline, there has never been one case that the empire could fix its problems and rise up again.
@@HappyOx99 Another secret of China's continuous progress is its journey of multiple revolutions, so called mandate of heaven and ability of the Chinese civilization to absorb foreign ideas and its ability to assimilate foreign subjects to become Chinese. Today there are two billion Chinese and Chinese influenced citizens around the world. No other civilization has achieved such widespread adoption by other nations.
I find it very amusing. This is a right wing organisations utube. Right wing philosophy, is what decided that education, is for the individual. Therefore, that individual had to pay, often through loans. To be educated, in order to, do things that a country needs, in order to develop. If you want more engineers, scientists , doctors etc. Then train them and everybody else, free of charge. Your right wing, everything, must create profit for the shareholder, mentality. Is what has stuffed up your economy.
An old building that's about to collapse is worried that the new building beside it is getting taller than them. The old building should instead spend time and money to strengthen their own pillars first.
They worry that their 10 storey old building will be outshined by the brand-spanking 20 storey building next door that they want to solve their problem by sabotaging the foundation of their next door building.
Correct regarding Taiwan. Taiwan is an insular island with a small population and one of the lowest fertility rates in the world. Its economy is dominated by exactly one sector-chips fabrication, which is currently being re-shored to Japan, S Korea, Germany, Malaysia, and the US.
The gloom and doom china stories say China will dwindle to 800 million in 50 years (as if the chinese will just do nothing to solve it lol), but let's say that will happen, that is still a figure that is larger than the G7 population combined. China will be left with young people with heavy automation and AI technology. They have no problem when talking about workforce.
He is very sharp in his own way but he is not fully aware of the technical breakthrough happening around us as of now. With 5G a lot factories can get automated, as he said in his experience with Huawei, if a dozen workers can work in a factory making ten of thousands of equipment, the same thing can be made in textiles and many other industries, with 6G or 7G bigger things will happen
US need a population to support the advanced economy which needs more emphasis on STEM. However its difficult to achieve because of DEI and progressive ideology. It's easy to be labeled as racist to explore any policy necessary to improve the education system
In every corner of the world and in every epoch of history, the men and women of every culture deserve each other. Where men subjugate women physically, women ravage them psychologically. Permit me to call this conjecture “Spengler’s Universal Law of Gender Parity.” -David Goldman, 2004.
Mr. Snowman advised a défense centric manhattan’s or Apollo project, a gigantic project centred around défense aka military: just a question how can he guarantee this will work? How long will this process be? To leap frog China that means China stand still or going slower? Betting on a chance that will have to be absolutely successful based on the belief that America is more innovative than China? Just so US can be number one? Number one in what? If this lead to number one in society satisfaction and happiness I am all for it. If this keeps US number one in being hegemony so what?
Now each nation may be living in different cabins, but all the cabins are confined in the same boat with a time-ticking nuclear bomb. Any strategy aiming to rock the others' cabins is a self-destructive one.
J.D. Vance compared Sino-American diplomacy:
We have built a foreign policy of hectoring and moralizing and lecturing countries that don't want anything to do with it. The Chinese have a foreign policy of building roads and bridges and feeding poor people.
The current foreign policy was born out of an arrogance and pride that never bothered to consider the needs and conditions of the other party.
David Goldman is one of the few Chinese experts in the West who understands the fall of the West and the rise of China.
Yes. He is 00% pro American - but he doesn't let that fog his ability to see clearly. I can respect someone like that.
they are keenly aware of it but didn't say it loud. where you think "Pivot to Asia" came from?
@@Amidat - he is 100% pro American. But the pre-requisite of that is understanding reality.
Hey China, how dare you develop and defend yourself against us?
But africa sooooo rich😂 you stole our resources😂😂😂. Complex of victim. Think about it.
John kirby would say "china's self defence is incredibly concerning"
overcapacity in self-defense
LOLX, you are right, friend
American military encircling China must cost some pretty dollars, and the Chinese, how much does it cost to send that spy balloon?
20 years to catch up with Nvidia? It's more like 5 years!
Maybe 3
@@ksneoh3572 Your number is closer to the truth... watch 2025.
Remember circa 2020 when they said China was 2 to 5 genarations behind in chips which would take decades for them to catch up, they found out quick that it is really on their heels behind when Huawei came out with their phone powered by a 7nm chip.
Agree.
You need a lot more than what they did in response to sputnik. In the 1960s, the United States had the biggest industrial system in the world. The investments made in the late 1950s and early 1960s was to accelerate what was already there. They did not have to rebuild anything.
The United States of the 1960s had the best educated labor force in the world. These skillful people took years to develop. The United States of the 1960s had the most innovative system in the world. Remember Bell Lab? Bell Lab practically invented the information age. The United States of the 1960s had very little debt. They could spend as much money as necessary to improve the human capital. At that time, many big companies provided a lot of technical training to their employees because they knew the employees would stay and that training would provide a return on investment.
Many of these elements are gone. Today, schools are busy fight culture wars. Many school districts are "graduating" subpar students. Universities are outrageously expensive. Companies do not train people not only because they care first and foremost the quarterly profit, also because people move. Human capital is the most important factor and that takes time. It takes years to develop welders, machinists, electricians. Is there any politician interested in these long term, boring issues?
What you need is a total orientation of the country. There is no true reform without a lot of wealthy and privileged people getting hurt, their wealth diminished. Can the United States summon the national will to do it?
At this point, their politicians are more likely to collapse the economy just to embarrass the political party in power.
If there's one thing that Chinese history has shown, it's that the biggest threat to any political establishment is the OTHER political faction.
The US can't have a national revival while half their media at any time is screaming that the president is literally the devil.
USA don't seem to understand thst during the cold war, USA was not alone against Soviet. They had help from China but this time China is on the other side and thus lose the brain. I don't see usa will grow without the brain from China
Remember also the US was so dominant at that time because the rest of the world was still rebuilding from WW2. It was inevitable that balances would change again. Being willing to accept not being able to dominate everyone else doesn't mean US quality of life had to drop... That is purely domestic problems that has caused that.... Many of which you listed.
❤Precisely well said and well REASONED. Your exegesis is RIGHT and EXACT.
Don’t see how it’d be possible to put the genie back into the bottle
US waste money on war
more than +40 wars since the rise of civilization.
Wrong concept: China itself is a global south country. China doesn’t need to have a long march to global south.
yeah, China wants you to believe that.
This is a very good analysis. What is concerning for the US is that majority of the viewers are not Americans, they are probably watching Netflix or Superbowl. They won't know what hit them and probably don't care.....
Exactly
9.@@petergreen5337
The American mantra now to stay number one is the supposed ' superiority in innovation'. But there's no real argument why such an overwhelming majority of Chinese STEM engineers (compared to the numbers in the west) won't be at least as inventive as their western counterparts. After all major early inventions are Chinese and for a great part it's western suppression of the past centuries that kept a lot of countries, China included, from flourishing.
❤Precisely well said and well OBSERVED.
A lot of that mantra has extremely strong racism undercurrents.
I used to work for nVidia. The best engineers I worked with were either white or Chinese (sorry about my political incorrect opinion). I have yet to meet one single good Indian engineer. Most of them were good talkers. That is probably why we see so many Indians in politics now. In China, engineers run the country.
Early Chinese inventions are grossly overstated. Japanese study from a few years ago showed that almost all inventions in human history have happened in the west, over the last 200 years. The British isles alone account for something like half of all inventions.
@@jacobzindel987 the keyword is last 200 years. The Chinese attributed the loss to the barbarian ruling of the Northern minority over 90% of Han population.
The speaker should advise how to improve the economy of the west without using sanctions n printing money. Should have industry that improve life instead of taking human life.
well he said to increase federal spending in innovation and tech
❤well said and well OBSERVED.
#2 is higher than #1, you should embrace it. Besides, you should experience being not a bully and superpower for your own sake. Trust me no pain, no gain. May be you will come to realize all efforts to maintain your hegemony for all the decades is futile and useless. May be you will mature up and learn the lessons of knowing what true kindness means along with many other virtues other countries enjoy. Good luck in your path to downhill.
If they're not so bent on imposing itself to the world and turn its efforts and money to improving itself, there's a bigger possibility that they can compete with the chinese. As long as their purpose is world domination, it hastens their fall from grace.
Do Americans want to be World No. 1 weapons manufacturers?
Do Americans not want to enjoy peace so that can pursue prosperity n happiness MORE THAN being a World No. 1 Weapons manufacturing country?
America can hardly manufacture reliable weapons. 😂😂😂😂
@sandponics You never show the Americans your money or you'll never see it again. 🤑🤑🤑🤑
They might as well be the the no. 1 in weapon manufacturing factoring how much bigger their defense budget than the next 10 nations, but still they fail in that one.
Why can’t his narrative be, let us work with the Chinese for mutual benefits and humanity good?
❤welcome to the PROBLEM
White USians treating other races and peoples as equal and to cooperate in good faith for all man kind?
hahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahaha
💯👍
He represents the fear of the « unknown « especially given how the east was viewed as an alien and distrustful place, in literally all western minds
China don't go to war for Resources! It helps countries to make money for their resources and obtain great infrastructure as well, helping it's people with transport, employment and boosting their economy.
China also supplies the best technology to these countries and eduction which in turn lifts them out of poverty. China also give coutries long term low interest rates for easy lone repayments. China brings people together and does not divide people and conquer races like the colonial West has always done! Thankfully The West is Finished. 🙏🏻
"How much China is going to grow, is a less interesting question, than how China chooses to grow."
Aaditya Mattoo (Chief Economist of The World Bank East Asia & Pacific - 2023.
people should stop this offensive terminology ''the global south'' just use the term ''the rest of the world'' for goodness sake..
Amazing how now development is seen as a conspiracy
John kirby would say: "china's development and self-defense are incredibly concerning"
The US lost its superpower status in 1971 when President Nixon suspended the convertibility of the U.S. dollar to gold, effectively ending the Bretton Woods system. The US can no longer keep its commitment to exchange gold and the US dollar at a fixed rate of $35 per ounce. It was financially exhausted by spending on the Space program, the Great Society program, and the Vietnam War. A nation's power is based on its economic strength. The last time the US had a positive trade balance was in 1975, according to the U.S. Trade Balance report for 1970-2023.
The US is now the world's largest debtor, reflected in its net international investment position (NIIP) of -$14.3 trillion. In comparison, China (including Hong Kong) is the world's largest creditor with a NIIP of $4.3 trillion. The last time the US had a positive NIIP was in 1988.
The US incurs an additional debt of 10 billion dollars and a trade deficit of 3 billion dollars daily.
David Goldman suggests borrowing more money to fund a moonshot program to solve its 35 trillion dollar debt problem.
"The US lost its superpower status in 1971"
I'd argue that the US lost the FOUNDATION upon which its superpower status was built. The country coasted along as a superpower for decades past that time, and is in the process of discovering that it is no longer the superpower it once was. Most are still in denial, however.
The space program and welfare is not why the US cannot balance its budget. It cannot do it because it wants to keep its empire but want to maximize its companies' profits.
4:48 Except at a higher price because of the extra transfer cost, investment, logistics and additional profits to cover the risk. Major manufacturers in South East Asia do not want the transfer from China because they know the orders will return to China as soon as the policy changes again. The increase from 800B to 1.2T is because of the higher prices for the same amount of goods.
China is becoming biggest money lender and America is the biggest borrower in the world
❤Exactly
Not anymore !
More noticeable, China had NOT purchase US Debt since 2018. China Peggie Bank is close to USA.
Yes maybe China is progressive...
But beyond china's gigantic success is also the gigantic violation on human rights..Gigantic Lies of the Communist PLA.
The Gigantic Propaganda Lies from their PLA Media
Gigantic Violatior in encroaching inside neighboring countries water EEZ.. sending other countries lot of huckers & Spy's, destroying the marine biology &steeling fish and other resources from its neighboring Countries...
Manipulating other countries Economy to gain Power..
Donot forget...the Communist China donot respect Human rights. Ex. 1child policy & 1china policy..
They Donot have Religious freedom..
Don't have freedom of speech.
The Media news & information are controlled by the Communist
They Don't have government transparency.
And they Refuse to follow International Law
Barbarians? The west has been behaving that badly?
When you survey all empires in history, whether they be in Europe, Middle East or China, once the empire starts to decline, there has never been one case that the empire could fix its problems and rise up again.
Yup. Murica is fading. Civil war 2.0 a certainty. Already well divided on everything. Not coming back, sorry!
contrary for Bharatiya civilization ,it is decline again grow up like a child.
Except China which has risen and fallen multiple times.
@@snsshorts In China's 5000 year of history, her rises and falls were through changes of dynasties.
@@HappyOx99 Another secret of China's continuous progress is its journey of multiple revolutions, so called mandate of heaven and ability of the Chinese civilization to absorb foreign ideas and its ability to assimilate foreign subjects to become Chinese.
Today there are two billion Chinese and Chinese influenced citizens around the world. No other civilization has achieved such widespread adoption by other nations.
Too true. Chyna very good at waiting. And waiting.
I find it very amusing. This is a right wing organisations utube. Right wing philosophy, is what decided that education, is for the individual. Therefore, that individual had to pay, often through loans. To be educated, in order to, do things that a country needs, in order to develop. If you want more engineers, scientists , doctors etc. Then train them and everybody else, free of charge. Your right wing, everything, must create profit for the shareholder, mentality. Is what has stuffed up your economy.
Keep dreaming, we’ll be #2 very soon …
It was interesting until the end when he proposed: "let's throw money at it".
An old building that's about to collapse is worried that the new building beside it is getting taller than them. The old building should instead spend time and money to strengthen their own pillars first.
They worry that their 10 storey old building will be outshined by the brand-spanking 20 storey building next door that they want to solve their problem by sabotaging the foundation of their next door building.
Interesting analogy....
Wow. How descriptive❤
He assumed that America would change and improve.
Correct regarding Taiwan. Taiwan is an insular island with a small population and one of the lowest fertility rates in the world. Its economy is dominated by exactly one sector-chips fabrication, which is currently being re-shored to Japan, S Korea, Germany, Malaysia, and the US.
Barbarians indeed, this bloke oozes racism and superiority.
He is Orthodox Jewish
“So-called global south” no respect
Out innovate the Chinese?
He is having his best wet dream
don't need young workers, young robots can do the work, cheaper. this guy is hopelessly out of touch.
The gloom and doom china stories say China will dwindle to 800 million in 50 years (as if the chinese will just do nothing to solve it lol), but let's say that will happen, that is still a figure that is larger than the G7 population combined. China will be left with young people with heavy automation and AI technology. They have no problem when talking about workforce.
He is very sharp in his own way but he is not fully aware of the technical breakthrough happening around us as of now. With 5G a lot factories can get automated, as he said in his experience with Huawei, if a dozen workers can work in a factory making ten of thousands of equipment, the same thing can be made in textiles and many other industries, with 6G or 7G bigger things will happen
Why hate being number 2? Let the best team, country be the number 1 so that the world can be a Peaceful Planet.
Wow! Bartender, give me a double, please...
It's not a long march It ran easy short march because the global north had neglected them for a few decades.
This video is negative to China.
Freedom of navigation in Cuba Guam Alaska Hawai Diego Garcia Guantanamo bay Okinawa Aukus NATO pacific expansion US army base station
thank you
*CHYYYNA!!! CHYYYNA!!! CHYYYNA!!!*
You're already nr. 2. War economy. Sanction exports. 🤣🤣🤣
So did you care when you came knocking on China's door for trade?
US need a population to support the advanced economy which needs more emphasis on STEM. However its difficult to achieve because of DEI and progressive ideology. It's easy to be labeled as racist to explore any policy necessary to improve the education system
The problem started long before DEI. That said. DEI is one of the things that will make a course correction impossible for the US.
The only way to get along is to copy the copier
Dr. Goldman is looking more like a distinguished scholar gentleman.
In every corner of the world and in every epoch of history, the men and women of every culture deserve each other. Where men subjugate women physically, women ravage them psychologically. Permit me to call this conjecture “Spengler’s Universal Law of Gender Parity.”
-David Goldman, 2004.
Mr. Snowman advised a défense centric manhattan’s or Apollo project, a gigantic project centred around défense aka military: just a question how can he guarantee this will work? How long will this process be? To leap frog China that means China stand still or going slower? Betting on a chance that will have to be absolutely successful based on the belief that America is more innovative than China? Just so US can be number one? Number one in what? If this lead to number one in society satisfaction and happiness I am all for it. If this keeps US number one in being hegemony so what?
Why worry if Huawei needs 20 years to catch up with nvidia? 🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣
吹哨子壯膽？！！
Low quality comparison. Those two are totally different companies. Just like saying Siemens needs 20 yrs to catch up with Dji.
😃👍🇧🇷🇷🇺🇮🇳🇨🇳🇿🇦➕️👍😁
Why are you helping Pakistan??...its totally not worth it😅
Now each nation may be living in different cabins, but all the cabins are confined in the same boat with a time-ticking nuclear bomb. Any strategy aiming to rock the others' cabins is a self-destructive one.
He can read ant papers for lttle money 😂
😂😂😂😂
US waste money on war
Those money goes to the ruling elites & co.😅