EAM Jaishankar on Why INDIANS Are So SUCCESSFUL in USA: ruclips.net/video/WhGCiVYuweI/видео.htmlsi=33PeiI2G3JD3KGgq CJI Chandrachud Explains Why SAME-SEX Marriages CANNOT be Recognised in India: ruclips.net/video/FdtHbFWrOaY/видео.html&ab_channel=Statecraft
Guys she's not pointing fingers on India. She started with their shares of women security problems in Germany. She just wanted to know, what is India doing about it.
@@themaskedman5954 Brother ! That doesn't justify sexual harassment in India. We know that 90% of the cases go unreported because of social norms and few cases were forced to be taken back by the victim for the reputation of her family. And the problem is not just the sexual harassment, but the victim blaming.
@@Inflorescence321 By the way India is not an exception here many even in many western countries so many harassment cases are not reported properly for various reasons There are surveys for that so west is not better than us in any way so they need to shut up first
@@themaskedman5954 Not every family or neighbour blames the victim but most of them does. You don't need evidence but common sense to know that it has been a cultural norm. 😒
@@Inflorescence321 over 75% of R*pe is unreported in USA Refer data from NCVS and RAIIN So don't try to show India as a bad nation Even if you include unreported estimates still India will perform much better than West, Africa etc Also this is not only true for sexual harassment but also for homicide etc So India is much better than west Nobody is justifying rap*st rascals Many Indians are just pointing out west has no right to teach anyone
I studied and lived in Germany for 5 years. A girl in my student dorm was raped. No one knew, the uni covered it up and the only information we got were random flyers stuck on the main door saying "keeps doors closed after 10PM". I got to know because I was friends with her.
Which your Kindly mention it and The University name! Keep Your Door Closed That's the University Ans? Meaning Girl Was Rape inside her Own University 😢
This happens in a lot of universities in the US along with other crimes and even terror incidents. The schools feel it is bad for business so they hush up the incidents. They scrub it from local news so it doesn’t give the school a bad reputation otherwise people will not spend big money to send kids.
So men are just suppose to believe that they are the culprit because the women said so? The law are already against men in india and remember, the societal backlash the men goes through when going through false charges. It is high time when women are called out.
@@ShwetabhSenpailol 74% false? In a country where the rape victim is shamed Nd blamed. From baby girls, to tourists, to dogs, no girls is safe in India. Because real men protect. But Indian men like you are cry babies
Comment section is thebest reflection of the mindset of ppl . As an Indian women i say no matter which country it is women safety should be taken seriously . To all those Indians who are pointing out german flaws i think we should have this attitude that its our problem or in your case its more . We should be trying our best to improve our society . I we can talk about this case on international level ,so when a particular country is pointed out ppl will feel ashamed that it is destroying our country image
Then u need to b honest about ur topic. R u able to pinpoint where this issue is arising from? Where r d stats?? Where’s d research?? Do u understand d issue? There r many guesses and suggestions as to what’s d solution, but where’s d hard data?? Where r d rallies to demand data? How do u expect solutions without data?? Where’s d accountability??
@@JinniSong newspapers print fake news dozen times a day. Where’s d hard data and multiple peer reviewed researches that have been vetted and hashed over at least a few decades??
Even I'm asking you as a woman and explaining this to you within the boundaries of our country. Unfortunately, rapes happen everyday in every state of our country, then why highlight rape cases only from UP and ignore rape cases from other states? In the recent Kolkata case, my Bengali friends are literally commenting on our FB posts, "please don't highlight this case, it ruins image of our state." I have heard similar comments whenever we highlight rape cases from other states whenever I post rape cases from other states. So, this video is no different. It's about hypocrisy. If you are saintly, tell me why highlight rape cases only from UP just because it's a political hub, & completely ignore rape victims from other states? Just like you are asking the above gentleman, did you ever bother to read local news from every state & see that rapes happen everyday in all across India, but ya racism towards north in more important than safety of women for other states who don't want to "ruin image" of their state and hide crimes in their own state.
@@JinniSong India ranks 95th in rape rates and has had DOZENS OF MAJOR INFLUENTIAL FEMALE POLITICIANS despite being a mere 75 yo country. America has been a democracy for 300 yrs and has never had a female president even once in 300 yrs.
It's the executive 's fault , judiciary doesn't take care of policing .Police is the one that can prevent crime before they happen , judiciary comes much later and if u wanna decrease crime u have to stop them before they are committed.
yall crying and saying germany should look at themselves first" that does not change the fact that OUR PROBLEMS EXIST and deflecting won't change it WHETHER or not the other countries have it worse for women doesn't matter AS long as we have it bad for them we need to take accountability and change and make the conditions better
But then u r being dishonest because problems never occur in vacuum. World stats and norms r extremely relevant. U don’t get to outright dismiss facts.
nobody asked a german to talk abt problems in india. we can deal with our problems. and given the fact that we have least rape rates in the world, shows we are doing pretty good. we should instead talk about male suicide rates from fake rape cases.
@@RojaJaneman I think you clearly didn't get what I was trying to say, whatever the stats say and let me tell you the stats for women safety is far worse in India then in Germany, but despite of all of that greater intio in one doesn't mean to avoid our existing problems, even if the stats had hypothetically stated that Germany was worse if we have it bad we got to make it better instead of being ignorant and arrogant
Luckily our FM is more mature than the comment section. Acknowledges the work that needs to be done, and has a realistic view of where we are what, and what concrete steps have been taken, instead of being defensive.
People defending india even after the kolkata case , the jharkhand bije incident , and so , so many more cases, is exactly why it ll never be better. You all will realise the day it happens to women in your family...
What about man who built the world women live in we dont live in women world they live in our world so they should listen to us and follow our rules otherwise tell them cry
Why Europeans/westerners have never ever compensated or apologized for far greater crimes they have committed against women & Children in India/Asia, Americas & Africa??!!
India is not sibnificantly more dangerous for women than Europe. Rape is 10 times as common in Europe per capita than in India. It is just that rape receives a lot more outrage from the public and politicians in India when it happens, so it gets a lot of coverage in Europe. In Europe rapes do not not provoke the same level of reporting or provpke the same level of outrage.
*for Indians, Germany has more crimes than india.. But Their media don't highlight it on their TV but German media DW news does highlight India's to prove India still a bad place for women for its German audience..the above women is one of them* *Repeating again German govt figures prove that Germany got more rapes than india for its very less population*
@@shaihazher Of course it gets reported to the police more often in Europe. It just doesn't get reported in the newsmedia so often. Because rape is not such a big thing there.
🇮🇳 We don't need criticism from any European or western or any other selfish, narcissistic country. India has there own people and mainly intellectual and policy makers to solve that. We don't need any fu** country's advice or concern. There are problems in every society.and India is working on their simultaneously. So keep ur fuc*** criticism in yourself.
@@rajkumarvishwakarma478 Teach boys to respect women, not harass them or demean them. That is basic at individual level u can do to ur sons or nephews or students etc.
People are forgetting she is just asking what are we doing about female safety and that is indeed a good question. It's not about pointing finger at each other or decide in what authority this lady asking this question or happens in Europe 10 time worse it's just about taking accountability.
Not true. Although rape is a huge crime, it doesn't get that much media attention in the West and in Europe, Infact most cases are not even registered. Here in India since people are culturally very sensitive, it becomes a huge issue India wide and gets huge media coverage for weeks and even months. We have had so many Women leaders in our country, CMs and even PM and President. In the West they still have not got one women leader yet, that shows the level of male domination in the West. The main reason behind Indian chaotic lifestyle is because, India being a very old country doesn't have planned townships and cities, The western countries have only planned cities and towns. They allocate only a certain number of households with all necessary security that meets the security standards and allow people to live only to that limit. They always have a strict police to people ratio etc. We have none of those and still have a much lesser rape count compared to their countries. Now that's purely a culture achievement we have. That being said, every type of crime is slowly on the rise in the recent years, due to all the mixed culture. We need to have stringent laws to tackle these newer issues.
That is a load of BS!! Where is the scientific proof & study??!! Per capita crimes in India, despite having a load of illegal peaceful from Pakistan/Bangladesh, are the lowest as compared to the west!!
Patriotism is one thing, and accepting reality is another thing. Women don't feel safe in India anymore due to the high number of crimes against women, even in broad daylight. The quality of life in Germany is far better than India's best cities. Every Indian girl studying and living in Germany has admitted that they feel much much safer after coming here. Even our foreign minister Dr.Jaishankar's son, migrated to the US. Sad reality 🤷♂️
I have to admit, Germany is way better at handling justice. As an Indian male, I’d feel a lot safer there than in India, where false cases against men can really mess things up. suspects get treated fairly and with proper protocols
Prostitution is legal is Germany and it is a billion dollar industry there. After 14 yrs parents do not take care of kids in Germany. So they do not know who is right person. First Germany has to clean its house before pointing towards India. I lived in Europe for 3 years so I know their culture also very well.
This is a very defensive and ridiculous response. You may not support Prostitution. But as you have yourself said it is legal in their country, and therefore women are doing that by individual choice. How can you compare this with gang rapes, violence against women, dowry deaths, etc. that take place in India. Are you genuinely saying the women are wanting to be gang-raped and burnt to death for not paying in dowry in India, by choice? It is precisely because of people with your kind of attitude that India remains such a backward & primitive country. Can you also explain why there is such a vast difference between North India and the other parts of India. Why do all these gang rapes, dowry deaths, etc. mostly happen only in North India? Why are women in India treated so much better in other regions such as South India and North East India? Why is your capital city Delhi called the Rape Capital of the world by everybody? There has to be a reason.
You,Sir, I think are in possession of a remarkable and amazing mind that within a short period of 3 years has managed to understand the culture of a country. Kudos 👏. I am sure you can comprehend the sarcasm here.
Germany has a significantly higher rape rate per capita compared to India. According to NationMaster, Germany's rape rate stands at 9.4 incidents per 100,000 citizens, ranking 24th globally ¹. In contrast, India's rape rate is 1.8 incidents per 100,000 citizens, which is five times lower than Germany's rate ¹. It's essential to note that India has been characterized as one of the countries with the lowest per capita rates of rape. However, the National Crime Records Bureau reported 31,677 rape cases in 2021, with Rajasthan recording the highest number of rapes among Indian states ². *Rape Rates Comparison:* - _Germany:_ 9.4 incidents per 100,000 citizens ¹ - _India:_ 1.8 incidents per 100,000 citizens ¹ Keep in mind that rape rates can vary significantly across different regions within a country. For instance, in India, Rajasthan had the highest rape rate, while Nagaland, Tamil Nadu, and Bihar had the lowest rates. That said, yeah India needs to improve law enforcement sector, but let's not make it like Only India has this problem.
@@Death__0R@pe is less reported in India. Moreover, many r@pe cases in India are not recognized as r@pe. Europe has much wider definition of r@pe as compared to India
@@Death__0R@pe is less reported in India. Moreover, many r@pe cases in India are not recognized as r@pe. Europe has much wider definition of r@pe as compared to India
@@vp-lv6yk kuch bhi bakwas kr rha h , India m fake rape cases bhi reported hote h smjhe ,ek ka example to mere relative pr bhi tha jo 80 year old the even wo walk bhi nhi kr skte the bed pr hi pade rehte the un pr rape ka charge lagaya tha .
Law is not the problem. Politicians and corruption does not allow the current law to take its own logical progression. Until polity is fixed, new laws will suffer the same fate not only for women but all citizens .
when a girl child gets educated, she stands fr her right, equality, self esteem, educates her next generation... the list goes on. Hence that is one of the key aspects. The answer was f acceptance and also speaks about centuries of tradition and prejudice....he also gave the work that is being done.... I can clearly see our society is changing with each generation... but agree miles to go...
@@rkdash2006 all good but still the problem is with the men starting from how they are brought up as boys. I have seen many women stand up for themselves with no result or at most very slight results - acrually imdian men behave very badly wven with foreign white women that i am sure are good in standing up for themselves. I would chip all the men especially the north indians that have been corrupted by arab moghul blood
@@rkdash2006 Not really. Not in the case of at least 95% "educated" women. That is obviously not a. Negligible number. That is the reality, not ideal case. Boys should be taught manners, should be raised as human beings who respect every other human being, valuing their opinions, acknowledging talent, developing equal skills, sharing household chores(very important) etc. That is a huge responsibility on evey parent in every household, regardless of the social, economic class or differences. As long as parents value boys more, instilling in them a sense of superiority from a young age, no effort in sending girls to school make any significant difference. In todays scenario, educated women have to take extra burden of taking care of family and earning. It affects their career performance also.
This question should be specifically asked to that worthless CM of WB...A corrupt politician, who needs to be investigated for using a Hindu name and fooling people at random!!
*for Indians, Germany has more crimes than india.. But Their media don't highlight it on their TV but German media DW news does highlight India's to prove India still a bad place for women for its German audience..the above women is one of them* *Repeating again German govt figures prove that Germany got more rapes than india for its very less population*
well Mr dutta i agree but you should be proud of your lineage that they stood up against this CM and the disgusting act BUT if you have ever lived in Haryana as i did ,or its neighbouring states then you would have a different opinion about the culture which instills to subjugate women. What happened in Hathras ,Unnao ?
I am from India and I resigned from my full-time job due to the poor level of safety and lack of proper security at my workplace. I can strongly say our Prime Minister has done literally nothing for woman safety.
@@Zaheed-ip8mpPM takes credit for every good thing happening in this country. This is what PM can do(or modi can do). And blatantly blames public for wrong things.😂
Wow, very nice mam come out and see how females are treated raped in other countries it's easily pinpointed on government. How many of them have come and complained Also, fake complaints have logged, and small boy children will be raped Before we point fingers at others as public what we have done In ever place ever sector this issue is there did you raise the voice or done anything easily we escape from situation we don't want to do anything and just think and blaming on modi or any government Shame on people
Its so disappointing to see the people justifying and overlooking the reality of Indian Society by blaming Germany Bro, first see your own country. And this is for both Germany and India.
conviction rate of rapists in germany is less than 1%. (india 32%) unreported rape cases is 90%. (india 54% in 2014. in 2024 it's likely close to 0) false rape cases in germany is 2-8%. (india 74% false rape cases) germany has more monthly rapes than yearly rapes in india despite havinig 1/20x of indian population.
What an honest response by FM. I wish the West would do the same and introspect. Also a prof of economics asking a FM - not on statecraft, not on economics, but on women safety. Not easy to miss the agenda here..
What's the issue here ? when a balatkr happens in every 15 min "officially" and many underlying variables propagate indian men to do the same then yes it needs to be talked about.
Very recently A rape victim from Germany has been jailed for LONGER than her rapist got, after she texted him and called him a 'pig' and a 'freak', after he reported her for 'offence'. The 20 year old German rape victim woman sent messages to a man who’d taken part in the gang rape calling him a “disgraceful pig” - and incredibly, the woman was given a harsher sentence than the rapist. She's just one of 140 people being investigated over hate crimes for messaging the rapists, reportedly none of whom was of German origin.ruclips.net/video/U0JwdynCj4Q/видео.htmlsi=-CPCs7WAla74rLOD
Wow indian men are so defensive in comments firstly the issue doesn't even concern you, also merely pointing out a flaw of a country doesn't mean she is saying that india is the worst or something she is just highlighting certain issue which was in news not months ago.
but I have seen comments where Indian women being defensive,telling truth about their stay in foreign,men accepting safety of women in india,indian women bashing indian men in comments,indian men and indian women bashing jai shankar for smart lie.
Women issue is a Worldwide Issue... Only Good but also Brave Men can fix this..Someone will have to sacrifice either Lust or Desire ❤❤JAI BAJRANGBALI G❤❤
Germany has a significantly higher rape rate per capita compared to India. According to NationMaster, Germany's rape rate stands at 9.4 incidents per 100,000 citizens, ranking 24th globally ¹. In contrast, India's rape rate is 1.8 incidents per 100,000 citizens, which is five times lower than Germany's rate ¹. It's essential to note that India has been characterized as one of the countries with the lowest per capita rates of rape. However, the National Crime Records Bureau reported 31,677 rape cases in 2021, with Rajasthan recording the highest number of rapes among Indian states ². *Rape Rates Comparison:* - _Germany:_ 9.4 incidents per 100,000 citizens ¹ - _India:_ 1.8 incidents per 100,000 citizens ¹ Keep in mind that rape rates can vary significantly across different regions within a country. For instance, in India, Rajasthan had the highest rape rate, while Nagaland, Tamil Nadu, and Bihar had the lowest rates. That said, yeah India needs to improve law enforcement sector, but let's not make it like Only India has this problem.
At the same time, Modi government allowed Brij Bhushan Singh, a MP to stay on in the party even after the police chargesheeted him for molestation of the country's young wrestlers, including a minor. Now his son was given a party ticket. Then, rapists of Bilkis Bano were freed from jail and garlanded by BJP workers under his leadership. So, pls don't curry-coat tales of woman empowerment. The signal he has sent is that only political affiliation matters.
Case lagane se koi criminal nahi ho jata Aise toh me bhi Rahul khan pe case kar sakta hu Aur Vaise vhi sach sabke samne a gaya ki Vinesh sirf politics kar rahi thi for congress
Govt is not responsible for everything, whole society needs to come forward to tackle these evils which have been persistent for centuries. As many great personalities refer:- Change starts from individuals.
The government is responsible for implementing polices/awareness and police know? I know society needs to step in and do something about it... But that doesn't mean the government just says oh it's social cause we are nobody here... Awareness should be incorporated in curriculum, public awareness and tough punishments are all key to solve this in my opinion... And for fuck sake teach guys what should and shouldn't considered crime against women, like stalking, comment passing, less respect for women overall, all should be dictated to other part of the society why it's all on women to be blame like what she was wearing, what time was it, where was she going... when such incident happens. See what happened in Kolkata, people are n't blaming the Govt? Due to their incompetency of handing and raising cases in WB.
I so like it how Jaishankar responds to the point, without cheery coating, accepting the issues we have (just like how it is there in other countries, but always we get questioned) and the work done, the work in progress and what we are going to do in future to address these problems. To do that, the current incumbent govt and its leaders need to stay in power. As people of this country, we need to pick the right set of leaders to ensure this effort continues.
Well the reality is, as per UN reports, more registered or unregistered r*p* cases occur in the USA than in India. Then also, look at the population of India, it's much higher than America and the UK combined. One has to look at the crime/r*p* rate per capita.
You are right. The atrocities done to the Indian people, especially the women during the Indian Congress Party ruled by Antonio Maino Vinci, an Italian Lady from 2008 for ten continues years was totally horrific. The BJP administration is trying to empower the women.
Germany has a significantly higher rape rate per capita compared to India. According to NationMaster, Germany's rape rate stands at 9.4 incidents per 100,000 citizens, ranking 24th globally ¹. In contrast, India's rape rate is 1.8 incidents per 100,000 citizens, which is five times lower than Germany's rate ¹. It's essential to note that India has been characterized as one of the countries with the lowest per capita rates of rape. However, the National Crime Records Bureau reported 31,677 rape cases in 2021, with Rajasthan recording the highest number of rapes among Indian states ². *Rape Rates Comparison:* - _Germany:_ 9.4 incidents per 100,000 citizens ¹ - _India:_ 1.8 incidents per 100,000 citizens ¹ Keep in mind that rape rates can vary significantly across different regions within a country. For instance, in India, Rajasthan had the highest rape rate, while Nagaland, Tamil Nadu, and Bihar had the lowest rates. That said, yeah India needs to improve law enforcement sector, but let's not make it like Only India has this problem.
It was a best arrangement in those days when women had many children. Women were confined to home and around for that reason. Bias was bioroduct of that system and not an exclusive system in itself. Today society is changing so fast that it is getting more and more biased against men.
Exactly said, compared to its neighbors, India has seen major progress for women, it is in this major growth, we forgot to put guardrails, enhance security and educate men better.
conviction rate of rapists in germany is less than 1%. (india 32%) unreported rape cases is 90%. (india 54% in 2014. in 2024 it's likely close to 0) false rape cases in germany is 2-8%. (india 74% false rape cases) germany has more monthly rapes than yearly rapes in india despite havinig 1/20x of indian population.
*for Indians, Germany has more crimes than india.. But Their media don't highlight it on their TV but German media DW news does highlight India's to prove India still a bad place for women for its German audience..the above women is one of them* *Repeating again German govt figures prove that Germany got more rapes than india for its very less population*
Germany has a significantly higher rape rate per capita compared to India. According to NationMaster, Germany's rape rate stands at 9.4 incidents per 100,000 citizens, ranking 24th globally ¹. In contrast, India's rape rate is 1.8 incidents per 100,000 citizens, which is five times lower than Germany's rate ¹. It's essential to note that India has been characterized as one of the countries with the lowest per capita rates of rape. However, the National Crime Records Bureau reported 31,677 rape cases in 2021, with Rajasthan recording the highest number of rapes among Indian states ². *Rape Rates Comparison:* - _Germany:_ 9.4 incidents per 100,000 citizens ¹ - _India:_ 1.8 incidents per 100,000 citizens ¹ Keep in mind that rape rates can vary significantly across different regions within a country. For instance, in India, Rajasthan had the highest rape rate, while Nagaland, Tamil Nadu, and Bihar had the lowest rates. That said, yeah India needs to improve law enforcement sector, but let's not make it like Only India has this problem.
The most important thing is to identify the issue and willing to rectify it. And., we Indians are working together to bring the change to our society for good.
@@snehab7676 conviction rate of rapists in germany is less than 1%. (india 32%) unreported rape cases is 90%. (india 54% in 2014. in 2024 it's likely close to 0) false rape cases in germany is 2-8%. (india 74% false rape cases) germany has more monthly rapes than yearly rapes in india despite havinig 1/20x of indian population.
The guys who is being defensive to this questions, JaiShankar himself acknowledged this in his answers in this video! Your patriotism is going against JaiShankar here!
conviction rate of rapists in germany is less than 1%. (india 32%) unreported rape cases is 90%. (india 54% in 2014. in 2024 it's likely close to 0) false rape cases in germany is 2-8%. (india 74% false rape cases) germany has more monthly rapes than yearly rapes in india despite havinig 1/20x of indian population.
??? jaishankar handling it well doesn't make the question any less disgusting and disrespectful. it's literally a propaganda to paint india's image in certain way. nobody asks these questions with diplomats of us uk france etc despite them having 10-100x more rapes than india
@@goat5944 bcoz they consider gy rp and marital rp is also rp but in india it's not a rp , Marital rp is a culture and 99.1% cases unreported jate hain use bhi dekh le....koi chachundar hi kahega ki india jyada safe hai europe se...
*for Indians, Germany has more crimes than india.. But Their media don't highlight it on their TV but German media DW news does highlight India's to prove India still a bad place for women for its German audience..the above women is one of them* *Repeating again German govt figures prove that Germany got more rapes than india for its very less population*
@@AbhimanyuMS-m1x according to some report, 30% of German women faced harassment issues at their workplace. So no, Germany isn't completely safe for women at their workplace.
Here in India crime against women happens on a large where its not just the common man of criminal mind is involved but the police also as well as the politicians involved .
A great diplomate he answer the question with utmost sensitivity while not openly denying the issue that persist but also not amplifying that as if it happens only India.
... conviction rate of rapists in germany is less than 1%. (india 32%) unreported rape cases is 90%. (india 54% in 2014. in 2024 it's likely close to 0) false rape cases in germany is 2-8%. (india 74% false rape cases) germany has more monthly rapes than yearly rapes in india despite havinig 1/20x of indian population.
India is a vast, dence and diverse country, tackling with crime in India is a every day challenge for Indians. Every European knows who is responsible for crime against women.
5 gangr@pe in paris but none of western media covered it but when there was one r@pe in India whole west started crying which type of media is this????
I agree in India at work at streets gets harrassed, stalked, victomised, we r talking about normal middle class women. culprit have to pay 2000 and gets bail.
People, we are not able to ask our govt. Atleast let people from other countries ask questions to our govt. Lets not supprt our govt in all these issues. Let our Jaiishankar face such slaps.
why? rtrd have you ever seen same embarassing questions being asked to diplomats of any other country despite every other country having higher rape rates than india?? this is propaganda. USA hasn't had a single female president in it's 300 yr old democracy yet it preaches on woman oppression in india.
no. him handling it well doesn't make her question any less disrespectful. why doesn't she ask such questions to countries like usa uk with 100x rapes of india?
Thank goodness, for once, an Indian politician didn't harp on metaphorical tokens, like how we treat Indian women as God in Indian society, and how our president and prime minister have been women before other countries. We need intelligent ministers and politicians with empathy for public issues, not political idealogues who feed their ego with power. Good on Jaishankar for that response, and admitting to the problems we face.
conviction rate of rapists in germany is less than 1%. (india 32%) unreported rape cases is 90%. (india 54% in 2014. in 2024 it's likely close to 0) false rape cases in germany is 2-8%. (india 74% false rape cases) germany has more monthly rapes than yearly rapes in india despite havinig 1/20x of indian population.
As the interviewer is a white skin lady, she should first have asked this question of USA, Britain, Sweden, Germany, etc. etc. before asking it of India. They all out number India in this ghastly crime. Check with the statistics put out by their own organisations with high credibility. Having said that, no matter where, even one rape in a seven billion population is one too many.
Those countries record every single rape incident separately. Eg: a child was repeatedly raped by a someone over several years will have each rape counted individually whereas here in South Asia it is lumped into 1 statistic.
I liked about Mr. Jaishankar ji is that he did not dodge the question and also he admitted that yeah we have problems. Accepting that we have issues, is the first step towards solving it. Although I think he dodged women safety in the answer but he rightly said its due to centuries of oppression, habits and mindset which is the real issue and this can not be changed suddenly but punishment for rape is not proportionate with the crime in India. It's not powerful enough to stop the incidences.
Instead of going all defensive he actually answered the question. Women face hardships and struggles in all societies, but that shouldn't matter, all that matters is what we do for the women in our society atleast. And hence it was nice that he answered it directly.
Germany has a significantly higher rape rate per capita compared to India. According to NationMaster, Germany's rape rate stands at 9.4 incidents per 100,000 citizens, ranking 24th globally ¹. In contrast, India's rape rate is 1.8 incidents per 100,000 citizens, which is five times lower than Germany's rate ¹. It's essential to note that India has been characterized as one of the countries with the lowest per capita rates of rape. However, the National Crime Records Bureau reported 31,677 rape cases in 2021, with Rajasthan recording the highest number of rapes among Indian states ². *Rape Rates Comparison:* - _Germany:_ 9.4 incidents per 100,000 citizens ¹ - _India:_ 1.8 incidents per 100,000 citizens ¹ Keep in mind that rape rates can vary significantly across different regions within a country. For instance, in India, Rajasthan had the highest rape rate, while Nagaland, Tamil Nadu, and Bihar had the lowest rates. That said, yeah India needs to improve law enforcement sector, but let's not make it like Only India has this problem.
because they are poor and we are a developing nation dont compare with countries bring measures to solve the issue and create a society for women - think like human
They don't know where these countries are situated.They know them when there are political turmoil in those countries.Genaral knowledge of people living in western countries are very poor.
@@ajith.giove069 so by your logic in a poor underdeveloped nation it's acceptable to do crime against women right ?🤨 and it's only the developed and developing countries job to take care of these things Crime against women is one of the global issue stop limiting it to few countries now it's upto u to either take this advice or not
Please stop arguing about other countries...it is not OK anywhere for woman to have an unsafe environment...if she is asking the question to Indian EAM why will she talk about other countries? Also nobody can deny that India is unsafe for woman...and I am an Indian woman saying this....
*for Indians, Germany has more crimes than india.. But Their media don't highlight it on their TV but German media DW news does highlight India's to prove India still a bad place for women for its German audience..the above women is one of them* *Repeating again German govt figures prove that Germany got more rapes than india for its very less population*
I live in Germany and women are generally safe here. Realized in 2 years of staying here that general idea of people here is to not sexualize body parts. I never felt pervert gaze from german guys here like I felt growing up in India. I really love my India more than anything but truly feel we should accept the problem and try to collectively work on it. Having so much hope from next generation.
@@shortsbydipali May be because German girls in general are more attractive than Indian girls. Regarding rapes the only thing I can fault Indian society for is making rape a stigma for a girl which should not be the case. This is the reason Indian rapes get so much media coverage. The reality is rapes are not so uncommon anywhere else in the world. It's just that anywhere else there's not so much hue n cry over this.
@@PankajKumar-ej5dt cheap mindset. It's not about attraction, even physically disabled or just women in common get grasped, rapist don't care about how attractive they are.
I am indian women,good question laday. Upbringing of sons in India by their parents is one of the reason.giving so much of importance to male make them superior against other gender
Germany has a significantly higher rape rate per capita compared to India. According to NationMaster, Germany's rape rate stands at 9.4 incidents per 100,000 citizens, ranking 24th globally ¹. In contrast, India's rape rate is 1.8 incidents per 100,000 citizens, which is five times lower than Germany's rate ¹. It's essential to note that India has been characterized as one of the countries with the lowest per capita rates of rape. However, the National Crime Records Bureau reported 31,677 rape cases in 2021, with Rajasthan recording the highest number of rapes among Indian states ². *Rape Rates Comparison:* - _Germany:_ 9.4 incidents per 100,000 citizens ¹ - _India:_ 1.8 incidents per 100,000 citizens ¹ Keep in mind that rape rates can vary significantly across different regions within a country. For instance, in India, Rajasthan had the highest rape rate, while Nagaland, Tamil Nadu, and Bihar had the lowest rates. That said, yeah India needs to improve law enforcement sector, but let's not make it like Only India has this problem.
In India in olden times, women actually were fully empowered and on equal status with men. It was only after the foreign invasions that things changed. Because for these invaders women were 'commodities' to be exploited. Therefore we were forced to impose certain restrictions on them. Unfortunately these conditions following the invasions persist even today and therefore the current issues.
But unfortunately, he did not address the question of safety. Women and the families of women would themselves be sending their girls out to explore the if not for the fear. A small village girl moved out her parents house to work in a city and to earn her living, but she was eventually harassed and raped to death, the culprit was the son of the ruling government's son, who are still protected by the government of Uttrakhand (a region in India). How can we ensure the safety of women in such a corrupt society where politicians and judiciary are on sale for money.
Exactly. In our countries atleast ppl get justice without public protest, here if culprit is influential they go free. Only after media made some noise the person ws arrested if their was no media or ppl didnt protest the person wold not have been arrested also. Its easy to tamper with evidence and bribe the police and ruin the case it never happens in europe. Even in hatras case all 4 pppl were let free by court coz of lack of evidence that girl will never get juictice after such horrivble crime.
Because she must ask this question from Germany govt that Why they have more higher rape rate than India, they are trying to degrade India in World level but want to save image of Their own #rapi*st, Indian must acknowledge this thing but today misinformation & hate against India is common thing in Europe
why aren't same "simple" questions ever asked to diplomats of countries with 10x to 100x rapes than india despite having 1/5 to 1/20 of indian population?
A French pensioner went on trial Monday for allowing scores of strangers to rape his wife after he drugged her, in a case that has horrified the country. Fifty men, recruited online, are also being tried in the southern city of Avignon alongside the main suspect, a 71-year-old former employee at France's state-owned power utility company EDF
Never face a reality, instead just keep offering excuses after excuses. This guy is as good as his boss, everywhere you go, always talk about moon, spend 10-15 years in the govt fooling people and then enjoy the retirement.
I remember why women use to vote for jayalalitha because in her time , gangsters and politicians all are afraid to keep hands on any girls or women or kids. She would unleash hell to these people. I still miss her.. whatever her issues with corruption, I have never cared about those things because she protected us and all women know that thats why she got a big women voter base. One time, we even know that she saved one of the rajini's girls from a gang that time she and rajini were like an enemy but after that event , rajini behaved differently with her. Unfortunately, no male politician can do it because they are backstabbers when it comes to women rights, they will never get women base of votes like jayalalitha because we can see clearly, they dont care. Just dont care...
We indians are proud of our foreign minister Mr Jai Shankar !!He always make all indians head High !! Always absolutely true line by Jai Shankar !! Jai Hind !!❤🇮🇳💞🙏💐👍🇮🇳
What's there to be proud of? Did the parents of the rape victim in Kolkata get justice? Do you even know what's happening all over India? How many actually get justice? Do your research please ...
The American would be wondering whether their children would be back from school. There’s a good chance of them getting short in the school premises itself.
Jaishanker himself was forced to marry his Japanese interpreter after he violated her chastity and she complained to Japanese foreign ministry during his post in the 1990s. His uncles M K Narayan and M K Bawdrawkumar helped him preventing diplomatic meltdown.
@@ritwik5774 Then I don't think you have visited Indian villages. In Indian villages it's much bigger crime than urban centres. There are honor killings in villages on this matter. And you're saying these things go unreported. And If it goes unreported then this is not a rape at all. This is adultry.
Germany has a significantly higher rape rate per capita compared to India. According to NationMaster, Germany's rape rate stands at 9.4 incidents per 100,000 citizens, ranking 24th globally ¹. In contrast, India's rape rate is 1.8 incidents per 100,000 citizens, which is five times lower than Germany's rate ¹. It's essential to note that India has been characterized as one of the countries with the lowest per capita rates of rape. However, the National Crime Records Bureau reported 31,677 rape cases in 2021, with Rajasthan recording the highest number of rapes among Indian states ². *Rape Rates Comparison:* - _Germany:_ 9.4 incidents per 100,000 citizens ¹ - _India:_ 1.8 incidents per 100,000 citizens ¹ Keep in mind that rape rates can vary significantly across different regions within a country. For instance, in India, Rajasthan had the highest rape rate, while Nagaland, Tamil Nadu, and Bihar had the lowest rates. That said, yeah India needs to improve law enforcement sector, but let's not make it like Only India has this problem.
@@Death__0indian police discourage rapes being recorded. Also rapes spanning a long period is counted as 1 rape in india whereas every individual rape is recoded as a separate incident in Germany. You are seriously stupid of you think India accurately reports rape statistics.
conviction rate of rapists in germany is less than 1%. (india 32%) unreported rape cases is 90%. (india 54% in 2014. in 2024 it's likely close to 0) false rape cases in germany is 2-8%. (india 74% false rape cases) germany has more monthly rapes than yearly rapes in india despite havinig 1/20x of indian population.
conviction rate of rapists in germany is less than 1%. (india 32%) unreported rape cases is 90%. (india 54% in 2014. in 2024 it's likely close to 0) false rape cases in germany is 2-8%. (india 74% false rape cases) germany has more monthly rapes than yearly rapes in india despite havinig 1/20x of indian population.
India is still a developing country and will continue to evolve. We need to constantly learn and improve cultural, social and economic our stances for everyone especially for women however, while doing that, we have gone too far when it comes to laws where it is the exact opposite. Things will improve and needs time.
Yes, the Bilkis Bano convicts were garlanded by your party members when they were granted parole. The Hatras victim was cremated without a postmortem. And Sanjhi Ram was given 10 years for rape and murder of a 8 year old girl. Thank you very much sir.
First time i am watching that people are asking the relevant question ...if any body saying this is unbiased question but you thinking what you want making in this society. If you raising this type of quetion one day we are solving this type of problem.
Germany has a significantly higher rape rate per capita compared to India. According to NationMaster, Germany's rape rate stands at 9.4 incidents per 100,000 citizens, ranking 24th globally ¹. In contrast, India's rape rate is 1.8 incidents per 100,000 citizens, which is five times lower than Germany's rate ¹. It's essential to note that India has been characterized as one of the countries with the lowest per capita rates of rape. However, the National Crime Records Bureau reported 31,677 rape cases in 2021, with Rajasthan recording the highest number of rapes among Indian states ². *Rape Rates Comparison:* - _Germany:_ 9.4 incidents per 100,000 citizens ¹ - _India:_ 1.8 incidents per 100,000 citizens ¹ Keep in mind that rape rates can vary significantly across different regions within a country. For instance, in India, Rajasthan had the highest rape rate, while Nagaland, Tamil Nadu, and Bihar had the lowest rates. That said, yeah India needs to improve law enforcement sector, but let's not make it like Only India has this problem.
So you want to compare India with the WORST countries, so that you can say we are Better than them, just to satisfy your ego? Please RAISE your benchmark. Look up to those countries which are BETTER than us and try to raise our standards to match theirs. You can either compare yourself to Losers to feel good about yourself OR you can compare yourself with Achievers to raise your own standards.
saying atleast to show some concern them too,.. when you work for 99% your own country women, atleast 1% for women around the world , a simple voice atleast with a smile on face!?
@@divyas1114 , you are right. India should implement the “ One Nation, One Law “ to be compared to other Democratic and secular nations. Is this okay by you? Please, do elaborate and not hide in your burrow now
conviction rate of rapists in germany is less than 1%. (india 32%) unreported rape cases is 90%. (india 54% in 2014. in 2024 it's likely close to 0) false rape cases in germany is 2-8%. (india 74% false rape cases) germany has more monthly rapes than yearly rapes in india despite havinig 1/20x of indian population. .
Not only women but men are also unsafe in India because of Gender biased law.Law should be gender neutral for everyone whether it's men or women or Transgender.There are lots of cases in India where women are misutilising the law against men like false dowry cases,false sexual harrasment cases,false domestic violence cases,false rape cases, extortion of money in the name of alimony.Where women are self independent financially still she is extorting money from her husband.Theae are the issue that need to be resolved by bringing Gender Neutral law.
Every body should understand, in the Europe prostitution is legalised and free sex is very common but in India the social structure is diffferent, prostitution and free sex is restricted. Further 140 crore population had complex problems. The foreign media also making bad propaganda.
So you are saying that since free sx is restricted, therefore the men cannot control themselves and they harass/r@pe? People like you should stop making excuses for your own Loose character.
For once, I appreciate the Western journalist for being respectful while asking the question. Her tone and manners are very respectful. It shows that she genuinely cares about the issue rather than just using the issue to perpetuate racial stereotypes. Equally, Jaishankar acknowledged the problems in India and empathized with her concern. The tone and demeanour often matters too, not just the substance when you ask someone a question. BBC could never get such an answer because they are always looking for a fight to act like some crusaders.
ntg abt that question was respectful. it was a propaganda to set a narrative. no one asks such question to any other diplomat. literally no one. and this is despite us uk france germany having 10-100x more rapes than india.
In Germany, in a population of 8.5 Cr, 16,000 cases of rape were reported. In India, in a population of 140 Cr, 29000 cases of rape were reported. This woman is mentally sick❤
many india wont be reported and i lived in germany for 3 years ..germany is more safe for women and india is not instead of saying something please accept it and solve the issue...ask women around u once how many if them are feeling safe in india ..?
@@ajith.giove069 I studied and lived in Germany for 5 years. A girl in my student dorm was raped. No one knew, the uni covered it up and the only information we got were random flyers stuck on the main door saying "keeps doors closed after 10PM". I got to know because I was friends with her.
@@ajith.giove069On New Year's Eve 2015, hundreds of women were mobbed and sexually assaulted during celebrations in the western German city of Cologne by peaceful migrants 😂
india is safest country for women on the planet. conviction rate of rapists in germany is less than 1%. (india 32%) unreported rape cases is 90%. (india 54% in 2014. in 2024 it's likely close to 0) false rape cases in germany is 2-8%. (india 74% false rape cases) germany has more monthly rapes than yearly rapes in india despite havinig 1/20x of indian population.
Smriti Irani worked really hard when she was Education Minister of India for rural girls. Due to her efforts we have more rural girls in Schools than boys, which in reality was other way around. Main issue for girls not going to school was not having Toilet, especially for girls who started having periods. Such small thing no government of India never paid attention. Smriti, even doing great work at ground level, she was PR nightmare for BJP due to trolling and she was removed from her ministry.
Germany have 12% rape rate and India have 1.81% , India is more safe than rapi**st germany, we know how to protect our own nation, a country with more higher rape rate than India is lecturing India
conviction rate of rapists in germany is less than 1%. (india 32%) unreported rape cases is 90%. (india 54% in 2014. in 2024 it's likely close to 0) false rape cases in germany is 2-8%. (india 74% false rape cases) germany has more monthly rapes than yearly rapes in india despite havinig 1/20x of indian population.
Absolutely valid question..have all the indians getting angry at her ...have youll forgotten kolkata?? No wonder there is no justice for women in india
In people who enrol in medical colleges I find in India girls dominate boys by 4:1 ratio. It's hard to find boys in excess of 20%.This trend is there for past 8-9 years now. This will reflect in society as the doctors post graduate. Also in food and cosmetics industry (I know of one Indian very large MNC having its office in Peenya Bangalore having more than 90 % girls employed. Soon men will have to fight for equal share in society.
R. Stastics in India is 1.8/100,000. Correcting for under-reporting, as per NCRB data which projects it at 71%, it gives us around 7/100,000 So, even after correction for under-reporting taking higher side of the mark (i would argue it would he nearer to 50%), not correcting under-reporting for other Nations & no taking into account the Ms. problem (which is rampant in Europe as well), we are still safer than 95% of the Nations which have data of 15-200/100,000. So, all this accuation against India is merely media narrative.
Ms German lady, check your biggest corporate - SAP. The CTO himself misbehaved with women and was fired. SAP in India also has too many of these cases (mainly in frustrated overworked teams) and they refuse to take complaints
EAM Jaishankar on Why INDIANS Are So SUCCESSFUL in USA: ruclips.net/video/WhGCiVYuweI/видео.htmlsi=33PeiI2G3JD3KGgq
CJI Chandrachud Explains Why SAME-SEX Marriages CANNOT be Recognised in India: ruclips.net/video/FdtHbFWrOaY/видео.html&ab_channel=Statecraft
Get ur facts right mate, IT'S ENSHRINED AS 3RD GENDER and it's WORLDS ONLY.
Pls indian officials try to answer for question that woman unsafe In India why..
Guys she's not pointing fingers on India. She started with their shares of women security problems in Germany. She just wanted to know, what is India doing about it.
Why don't she ask such questions to other EU country
@@themaskedman5954 Brother ! That doesn't justify sexual harassment in India. We know that 90% of the cases go unreported because of social norms and few cases were forced to be taken back by the victim for the reputation of her family. And the problem is not just the sexual harassment, but the victim blaming.
@@Inflorescence321
By the way India is not an exception here many even in many western countries so many harassment cases are not reported properly for various reasons
There are surveys for that so west is not better than us in any way so they need to shut up first
@@themaskedman5954 Not every family or neighbour blames the victim but most of them does. You don't need evidence but common sense to know that it has been a cultural norm. 😒
@@Inflorescence321 over 75% of R*pe is unreported in USA
Refer data from NCVS and RAIIN
So don't try to show India as a bad nation
Even if you include unreported estimates still India will perform much better than West, Africa etc
Also this is not only true for sexual harassment but also for homicide etc
So India is much better than west
Nobody is justifying rap*st rascals
Many Indians are just pointing out west has no right to teach anyone
I studied and lived in Germany for 5 years. A girl in my student dorm was raped. No one knew, the uni covered it up and the only information we got were random flyers stuck on the main door saying "keeps doors closed after 10PM". I got to know because I was friends with her.
Wth😢💔💔💔Is it true??? U mean to say that many cases are shoved under the carpet in this manner in that country??
Which your Kindly mention it and The University name! Keep Your Door Closed That's the University Ans? Meaning Girl Was Rape inside her Own University 😢
Was she Indian?
This happens in a lot of universities in the US along with other crimes and even terror incidents. The schools feel it is bad for business so they hush up the incidents. They scrub it from local news so it doesn’t give the school a bad reputation otherwise people will not spend big money to send kids.
True, many western countries have this hush culture and news about this also doesn't get as much TRP or clicks on articles as it gets in India.
Plz dont defend india in these topic as indian take it in our heart # Justice
to all rape victim and there family.
Another Indian and I stand with you.
And justice for those 74% of men and thier family in rape cases that turn out to be false
So men are just suppose to believe that they are the culprit because the women said so? The law are already against men in india and remember, the societal backlash the men goes through when going through false charges. It is high time when women are called out.
@@ShwetabhSenpaiLack of Integrity. Both men and women has no integrity, what to do?
@@ShwetabhSenpailol 74% false? In a country where the rape victim is shamed Nd blamed. From baby girls, to tourists, to dogs, no girls is safe in India. Because real men protect. But Indian men like you are cry babies
Comment section is thebest reflection of the mindset of ppl .
As an Indian women i say no matter which country it is women safety should be taken seriously .
To all those Indians who are pointing out german flaws i think we should have this attitude that its our problem or in your case its more .
We should be trying our best to improve our society .
I we can talk about this case on international level ,so when a particular country is pointed out ppl will feel ashamed that it is destroying our country image
Then u need to b honest about ur topic. R u able to pinpoint where this issue is arising from? Where r d stats?? Where’s d research?? Do u understand d issue? There r many guesses and suggestions as to what’s d solution, but where’s d hard data?? Where r d rallies to demand data? How do u expect solutions without data?? Where’s d accountability??
@@RojaJaneman do you read newspaper ? Stats are available online . It's not the prblm of one country .
@@JinniSong newspapers print fake news dozen times a day. Where’s d hard data and multiple peer reviewed researches that have been vetted and hashed over at least a few decades??
Even I'm asking you as a woman and explaining this to you within the boundaries of our country. Unfortunately, rapes happen everyday in every state of our country, then why highlight rape cases only from UP and ignore rape cases from other states?
In the recent Kolkata case, my Bengali friends are literally commenting on our FB posts, "please don't highlight this case, it ruins image of our state." I have heard similar comments whenever we highlight rape cases from other states whenever I post rape cases from other states.
So, this video is no different. It's about hypocrisy. If you are saintly, tell me why highlight rape cases only from UP just because it's a political hub, & completely ignore rape victims from other states?
Just like you are asking the above gentleman, did you ever bother to read local news from every state & see that rapes happen everyday in all across India, but ya racism towards north in more important than safety of women for other states who don't want to "ruin image" of their state and hide crimes in their own state.
@@JinniSong India ranks 95th in rape rates and has had DOZENS OF MAJOR INFLUENTIAL FEMALE POLITICIANS despite being a mere 75 yo country. America has been a democracy for 300 yrs and has never had a female president even once in 300 yrs.
It's the Indian judiciary that is failing to serve India the most.
Exactly 💯 💯
Exactly
yes and no
@@otakuhunter4817 it's the lowest hanging fruit
It's the executive 's fault , judiciary doesn't take care of policing .Police is the one that can prevent crime before they happen , judiciary comes much later and if u wanna decrease crime u have to stop them before they are committed.
yall crying and saying germany should look at themselves first" that does not change the fact that OUR PROBLEMS EXIST and deflecting won't change it WHETHER or not the other countries have it worse for women doesn't matter AS long as we have it bad for them we need to take accountability and change and make the conditions better
yes...
The people who claim those are sore losers who have been blue pilled by our govt into thinking like that.
But then u r being dishonest because problems never occur in vacuum. World stats and norms r extremely relevant. U don’t get to outright dismiss facts.
nobody asked a german to talk abt problems in india. we can deal with our problems. and given the fact that we have least rape rates in the world, shows we are doing pretty good. we should instead talk about male suicide rates from fake rape cases.
@@RojaJaneman I think you clearly didn't get what I was trying to say, whatever the stats say and let me tell you the stats for women safety is far worse in India then in Germany, but despite of all of that greater intio in one doesn't mean to avoid our existing problems, even if the stats had hypothetically stated that Germany was worse if we have it bad we got to make it better instead of being ignorant and arrogant
Luckily our FM is more mature than the comment section. Acknowledges the work that needs to be done, and has a realistic view of where we are what, and what concrete steps have been taken, instead of being defensive.
Boy he sure stammers on this issue of equality.
People defending india even after the kolkata case , the jharkhand bije incident , and so , so many more cases, is exactly why it ll never be better. You all will realise the day it happens to women in your family...
Such cases don’t define the entire country
@@Zaheed-ip8mp no, the hundreds of interviews of women you can find online saying they have atleast had one molestation or assault does.
@@selenophile5256 hundred out of 1.4 billion is a lot right 😂😂
@@Zaheed-ip8mpzaheed is angry and is defending rap cases .. 😂😂 typical
@@COYSfootball7751 Low iq abdool can’t come up with an articulate argument 😂
Womens safety should be a topic to discuss everywhere ....india please do something 😢
What about man who built the world women live in we dont live in women world they live in our world so they should listen to us and follow our rules otherwise tell them cry
Then get real stats. Who’s d culprit? Where r thousands of phd research papers? How r u gonna find solutions without data??
yourself do something, always asking government and other people to do something, shame on you
Why Europeans/westerners have never ever compensated or apologized for far greater crimes they have committed against women & Children in India/Asia, Americas & Africa??!!
India is not sibnificantly more dangerous for women than Europe. Rape is 10 times as common in Europe per capita than in India. It is just that rape receives a lot more outrage from the public and politicians in India when it happens, so it gets a lot of coverage in Europe. In Europe rapes do not not provoke the same level of reporting or provpke the same level of outrage.
*for Indians, Germany has more crimes than india.. But Their media don't highlight it on their TV but German media DW news does highlight India's to prove India still a bad place for women for its German audience..the above women is one of them*
*Repeating again German govt figures prove that Germany got more rapes than india for its very less population*
Rape gets reported more often in europe
@@shaihazher Good joke. I often go through Europe news.. It's not the case you want to represent here
@@shaihazher Of course it gets reported to the police more often in Europe. It just doesn't get reported in the newsmedia so often. Because rape is not such a big thing there.
@@PankajKumar-ej5dt I think your last statement says it all
Why people in india cant take criticism
She raised a very valid point
Indians in comment section busy in whataboutism
Most of the Indian people in the comment section accepting the case didn't you see??
What should we do with criticism, if we don't have solution for zero rape cases?
🇮🇳
We don't need criticism from any European or western or any other selfish, narcissistic country.
India has there own people and mainly intellectual and policy makers to solve that.
We don't need any fu** country's advice or concern.
There are problems in every society.and India is working on their simultaneously.
So keep ur fuc*** criticism in yourself.
@@rajkumarvishwakarma478 Teach boys to respect women, not harass them or demean them. That is basic at individual level u can do to ur sons or nephews or students etc.
@@hi-oj1jh is there zero r@p€s in the countries where women are respectd and boys are well mannered and Parenting is very good?
People are forgetting she is just asking what are we doing about female safety and that is indeed a good question. It's not about pointing finger at each other or decide in what authority this lady asking this question or happens in Europe 10 time worse it's just about taking accountability.
Just to admit it. It is dangerous for single woman travelling alone in India.
No it isn’t and you’re Chinese lol
China has a huge human trafficking problem especially when it comes to North Korean women
Not only India but also in the world 🌎
Not true. Although rape is a huge crime, it doesn't get that much media attention in the West and in Europe, Infact most cases are not even registered. Here in India since people are culturally very sensitive, it becomes a huge issue India wide and gets huge media coverage for weeks and even months. We have had so many Women leaders in our country, CMs and even PM and President. In the West they still have not got one women leader yet, that shows the level of male domination in the West. The main reason behind Indian chaotic lifestyle is because, India being a very old country doesn't have planned townships and cities, The western countries have only planned cities and towns. They allocate only a certain number of households with all necessary security that meets the security standards and allow people to live only to that limit. They always have a strict police to people ratio etc. We have none of those and still have a much lesser rape count compared to their countries. Now that's purely a culture achievement we have. That being said, every type of crime is slowly on the rise in the recent years, due to all the mixed culture. We need to have stringent laws to tackle these newer issues.
That is a load of BS!! Where is the scientific proof & study??!!
Per capita crimes in India, despite having a load of illegal peaceful from Pakistan/Bangladesh, are the lowest as compared to the west!!
Patriotism is one thing, and accepting reality is another thing. Women don't feel safe in India anymore due to the high number of crimes against women, even in broad daylight. The quality of life in Germany is far better than India's best cities. Every Indian girl studying and living in Germany has admitted that they feel much much safer after coming here. Even our foreign minister Dr.Jaishankar's son, migrated to the US. Sad reality 🤷♂️
It depends on where someone is in Germany or India. Some places are far safer than others within the same country.
I have to admit, Germany is way better at handling justice. As an Indian male, I’d feel a lot safer there than in India, where false cases against men can really mess things up. suspects get treated fairly and with proper protocols
@@ShwetabhSenpai India has a problem with false accusations against men.
Which states and cities in India do you think have the best law and order.
@@AnAn___ State cities where suspects are treated fairly as suspects and with proper protocols
@@ShwetabhSenpai Asking you the question.
Rule of law in West Bengal is particularly bad.
Prostitution is legal is Germany and it is a billion dollar industry there.
After 14 yrs parents do not take care of kids in Germany. So they do not know who is right person. First Germany has to clean its house before pointing towards India.
I lived in Europe for 3 years so I know their culture also very well.
This is a very defensive and ridiculous response. You may not support Prostitution. But as you have yourself said it is legal in their country, and therefore women are doing that by individual choice. How can you compare this with gang rapes, violence against women, dowry deaths, etc. that take place in India. Are you genuinely saying the women are wanting to be gang-raped and burnt to death for not paying in dowry in India, by choice?
It is precisely because of people with your kind of attitude that India remains such a backward & primitive country. Can you also explain why there is such a vast difference between North India and the other parts of India. Why do all these gang rapes, dowry deaths, etc. mostly happen only in North India? Why are women in India treated so much better in other regions such as South India and North East India? Why is your capital city Delhi called the Rape Capital of the world by everybody? There has to be a reason.
You,Sir, I think are in possession of a remarkable and amazing mind that within a short period of 3 years has managed to understand the culture of a country.
Kudos 👏.
I am sure you can comprehend the sarcasm here.
They might have a problem, does not dilute the urgency of India’s attitude towards women. Be honest and self reflect instead of being insecure
Just google which country has the most prostitutes....china and india in close compitition....none come close 🤦
I know Germany is called a brothel hub of Europe
Its not only government's responsibility but each individual's and each society's responsibility to fight with these issues.
Totally!
Germany has a significantly higher rape rate per capita compared to India. According to NationMaster, Germany's rape rate stands at 9.4 incidents per 100,000 citizens, ranking 24th globally ¹. In contrast, India's rape rate is 1.8 incidents per 100,000 citizens, which is five times lower than Germany's rate ¹.
It's essential to note that India has been characterized as one of the countries with the lowest per capita rates of rape. However, the National Crime Records Bureau reported 31,677 rape cases in 2021, with Rajasthan recording the highest number of rapes among Indian states ².
*Rape Rates Comparison:*
- _Germany:_ 9.4 incidents per 100,000 citizens ¹
- _India:_ 1.8 incidents per 100,000 citizens ¹
Keep in mind that rape rates can vary significantly across different regions within a country. For instance, in India, Rajasthan had the highest rape rate, while Nagaland, Tamil Nadu, and Bihar had the lowest rates.
That said, yeah India needs to improve law enforcement sector, but let's not make it like Only India has this problem.
@@Death__0R@pe is less reported in India. Moreover, many r@pe cases in India are not recognized as r@pe. Europe has much wider definition of r@pe as compared to India
@@Death__0R@pe is less reported in India. Moreover, many r@pe cases in India are not recognized as r@pe. Europe has much wider definition of r@pe as compared to India
@@vp-lv6yk kuch bhi bakwas kr rha h , India m fake rape cases bhi reported hote h smjhe ,ek ka example to mere relative pr bhi tha jo 80 year old the even wo walk bhi nhi kr skte the bed pr hi pade rehte the un pr rape ka charge lagaya tha .
let us not defend undefendables, work conditions and laws need to improve with respect to women in India
Law is not the problem. Politicians and corruption does not allow the current law to take its own logical progression. Until polity is fixed, new laws will suffer the same fate not only for women but all citizens .
india is probably safest country for women in the world
The problem is not of women going to school or work. The problem is the guys that need to be thought manners and be less ignorant
when a girl child gets educated, she stands fr her right, equality, self esteem, educates her next generation... the list goes on. Hence that is one of the key aspects. The answer was f acceptance and also speaks about centuries of tradition and prejudice....he also gave the work that is being done.... I can clearly see our society is changing with each generation... but agree miles to go...
@@rkdash2006 all good but still the problem is with the men starting from how they are brought up as boys. I have seen many women stand up for themselves with no result or at most very slight results - acrually imdian men behave very badly wven with foreign white women that i am sure are good in standing up for themselves. I would chip all the men especially the north indians that have been corrupted by arab moghul blood
@@rkdash2006 Not really. Not in the case of at least 95% "educated" women. That is obviously not a. Negligible number. That is the reality, not ideal case. Boys should be taught manners, should be raised as human beings who respect every other human being, valuing their opinions, acknowledging talent, developing equal skills, sharing household chores(very important) etc. That is a huge responsibility on evey parent in every household, regardless of the social, economic class or differences.
As long as parents value boys more, instilling in them a sense of superiority from a young age, no effort in sending girls to school make any significant difference.
In todays scenario, educated women have to take extra burden of taking care of family and earning. It affects their career performance also.
@@souparnika9457due to some guys doing these things u shouldn’t generalise it to everyone is ur father manner less ? Is your brother mannerless?
@@souparnika9457
That is a stupid argument. Rape is a crime. It is not bad manners.
This question should be specifically asked to that worthless CM of WB...A corrupt politician, who needs to be investigated for using a Hindu name and fooling people at random!!
*for Indians, Germany has more crimes than india.. But Their media don't highlight it on their TV but German media DW news does highlight India's to prove India still a bad place for women for its German audience..the above women is one of them*
*Repeating again German govt figures prove that Germany got more rapes than india for its very less population*
Religion has nothing to do with that. Its the mentality.
Religion has nothing to do with that. Its the mentality..
But u forget UP
well Mr dutta i agree but you should be proud of your lineage that they stood up against this CM and the disgusting act BUT if you have ever lived in Haryana as i did ,or its neighbouring states then you would have a different opinion about the culture which instills to subjugate women.
What happened in Hathras ,Unnao ?
I am from India and I resigned from my full-time job due to the poor level of safety and lack of proper security at my workplace. I can strongly say our Prime Minister has done literally nothing for woman safety.
What can the pm do
@@Zaheed-ip8mpPM takes credit for every good thing happening in this country. This is what PM can do(or modi can do). And blatantly blames public for wrong things.😂
Wow, very nice mam come out and see how females are treated raped in other countries it's easily pinpointed on government. How many of them have come and complained
Also, fake complaints have logged, and small boy children will be raped
Before we point fingers at others as public what we have done
In ever place ever sector this issue is there did you raise the voice or done anything easily we escape from situation we don't want to do anything and just think and blaming on modi or any government
Shame on people
lmfao bullshit
@@mm-vg1ld lying doesn't make pm responsible. india has least rape rates in the world.
Its so disappointing to see the people justifying and overlooking the reality of Indian Society by blaming Germany
Bro, first see your own country. And this is for both Germany and India.
No one is justifying anything.
conviction rate of rapists in germany is less than 1%. (india 32%) unreported rape cases is 90%. (india 54% in 2014. in 2024 it's likely close to 0) false rape cases in germany is 2-8%. (india 74% false rape cases) germany has more monthly rapes than yearly rapes in india despite havinig 1/20x of indian population.
are u rtrded? don't u see propaganda? have u ever seen any other diplomat being asked such a nonsensical question openly? they only do it with india.
What an honest response by FM. I wish the West would do the same and introspect.
Also a prof of economics asking a FM - not on statecraft, not on economics, but on women safety.
Not easy to miss the agenda here..
What's the issue here ? when a balatkr happens in every 15 min "officially" and many underlying variables propagate indian men to do the same then yes it needs to be talked about.
Very recently A rape victim from Germany has been jailed for LONGER than her rapist got, after she texted him and called him a 'pig' and a 'freak', after he reported her for 'offence'.
The 20 year old German rape victim woman sent messages to a man who’d taken part in the gang rape calling him a “disgraceful pig” - and incredibly, the woman was given a harsher sentence than the rapist.
She's just one of 140 people being investigated over hate crimes for messaging the rapists, reportedly none of whom was of German origin.ruclips.net/video/U0JwdynCj4Q/видео.htmlsi=-CPCs7WAla74rLOD
@@otakuhunter4817so? a EAM can do here?
@@otakuhunter4817kuchh bhi 🤷
She is a woman and it's a woman's issue.
Wow indian men are so defensive in comments firstly the issue doesn't even concern you, also merely pointing out a flaw of a country doesn't mean she is saying that india is the worst or something she is just highlighting certain issue which was in news not months ago.
but I have seen comments where Indian women being defensive,telling truth about their stay in foreign,men accepting safety of women in india,indian women bashing indian men in comments,indian men and indian women bashing jai shankar for smart lie.
Because 99% of us are normal people trying to live while you idiots are obsessed with calling us such names
again sweeping generalization at its finest 😂.
@@user-ig-gg26j stop getting offended and behave so that indian women don't say stuff like rhis
Women issue is a Worldwide Issue... Only Good but also Brave Men can fix this..Someone will have to sacrifice either Lust or Desire ❤❤JAI BAJRANGBALI G❤❤
Why should men bother?, women are so equal to men isn't it?, let them deal with it. The universe is 100% unsafe for men, I see no man crying over it.
Finallt someone asked the right question from Jai Shankar😂😂😂
@@bumblebee6886 She is asking Jai Shankar why Germany is the BROTHEL of Europe.....what a clown female.
@@bumblebee6886, yes and it from a lady whom is not even an Indian citizen worries about Indian women, instead of her nations.
Germany has a significantly higher rape rate per capita compared to India. According to NationMaster, Germany's rape rate stands at 9.4 incidents per 100,000 citizens, ranking 24th globally ¹. In contrast, India's rape rate is 1.8 incidents per 100,000 citizens, which is five times lower than Germany's rate ¹.
It's essential to note that India has been characterized as one of the countries with the lowest per capita rates of rape. However, the National Crime Records Bureau reported 31,677 rape cases in 2021, with Rajasthan recording the highest number of rapes among Indian states ².
*Rape Rates Comparison:*
- _Germany:_ 9.4 incidents per 100,000 citizens ¹
- _India:_ 1.8 incidents per 100,000 citizens ¹
Keep in mind that rape rates can vary significantly across different regions within a country. For instance, in India, Rajasthan had the highest rape rate, while Nagaland, Tamil Nadu, and Bihar had the lowest rates.
That said, yeah India needs to improve law enforcement sector, but let's not make it like Only India has this problem.
At the same time, Modi government allowed Brij Bhushan Singh, a MP to stay on in the party even after the police chargesheeted him for molestation of the country's young wrestlers, including a minor. Now his son was given a party ticket. Then, rapists of Bilkis Bano were freed from jail and garlanded by BJP workers under his leadership. So, pls don't curry-coat tales of woman empowerment. The signal he has sent is that only political affiliation matters.
Case lagane se koi criminal nahi ho jata
Aise toh me bhi Rahul khan pe case kar sakta hu
Aur Vaise vhi sach sabke samne a gaya ki Vinesh sirf politics kar rahi thi for congress
As a indian woman i m thankful to her 🙏🙏🙏
Govt is not responsible for everything, whole society needs to come forward to tackle these evils which have been persistent for centuries.
As many great personalities refer:- Change starts from individuals.
The government is responsible for implementing polices/awareness and police know?
I know society needs to step in and do something about it... But that doesn't mean the government just says oh it's social cause we are nobody here...
Awareness should be incorporated in curriculum, public awareness and tough punishments are all key to solve this in my opinion... And for fuck sake teach guys what should and shouldn't considered crime against women, like stalking, comment passing, less respect for women overall, all should be dictated to other part of the society why it's all on women to be blame like what she was wearing, what time was it, where was she going... when such incident happens.
See what happened in Kolkata, people are n't blaming the Govt? Due to their incompetency of handing and raising cases in WB.
I so like it how Jaishankar responds to the point, without cheery coating, accepting the issues we have (just like how it is there in other countries, but always we get questioned) and the work done, the work in progress and what we are going to do in future to address these problems. To do that, the current incumbent govt and its leaders need to stay in power. As people of this country, we need to pick the right set of leaders to ensure this effort continues.
Well the reality is, as per UN reports, more registered or unregistered r*p* cases occur in the USA than in India. Then also, look at the population of India, it's much higher than America and the UK combined.
One has to look at the crime/r*p* rate per capita.
You are right. The atrocities done to the Indian people, especially the women during the Indian Congress Party ruled by Antonio Maino Vinci, an Italian Lady from 2008 for ten continues years was totally horrific. The BJP administration is trying to empower the women.
Germany has a significantly higher rape rate per capita compared to India. According to NationMaster, Germany's rape rate stands at 9.4 incidents per 100,000 citizens, ranking 24th globally ¹. In contrast, India's rape rate is 1.8 incidents per 100,000 citizens, which is five times lower than Germany's rate ¹.
It's essential to note that India has been characterized as one of the countries with the lowest per capita rates of rape. However, the National Crime Records Bureau reported 31,677 rape cases in 2021, with Rajasthan recording the highest number of rapes among Indian states ².
*Rape Rates Comparison:*
- _Germany:_ 9.4 incidents per 100,000 citizens ¹
- _India:_ 1.8 incidents per 100,000 citizens ¹
Keep in mind that rape rates can vary significantly across different regions within a country. For instance, in India, Rajasthan had the highest rape rate, while Nagaland, Tamil Nadu, and Bihar had the lowest rates.
That said, yeah India needs to improve law enforcement sector, but let's not make it like Only India has this problem.
@@Satanreincarnation-zg6sl the rape is more common now during BJP rule
@@M-UltraInstinct😂😂
Centuries of Prejudice, Attitude and habits..Well said Mr. Jaishankar..
It was a best arrangement in those days when women had many children. Women were confined to home and around for that reason. Bias was bioroduct of that system and not an exclusive system in itself. Today society is changing so fast that it is getting more and more biased against men.
Ttue, well addressed
Exactly said, compared to its neighbors, India has seen major progress for women, it is in this major growth, we forgot to put guardrails, enhance security and educate men better.
@@krishna81mare men in Other 'progressive' countries less educated too?
Or the security Is very bad there?
conviction rate of rapists in germany is less than 1%. (india 32%) unreported rape cases is 90%. (india 54% in 2014. in 2024 it's likely close to 0) false rape cases in germany is 2-8%. (india 74% false rape cases) germany has more monthly rapes than yearly rapes in india despite havinig 1/20x of indian population.
Modi government started giving free bicycles for girl child attending schools... just one of the schemes which increased girl attendances in schools!
*for Indians, Germany has more crimes than india.. But Their media don't highlight it on their TV but German media DW news does highlight India's to prove India still a bad place for women for its German audience..the above women is one of them*
*Repeating again German govt figures prove that Germany got more rapes than india for its very less population*
I think it was first started by then TN government
🤣
@@starX7995, 🤣🤣🤣🤣!
Germany has a significantly higher rape rate per capita compared to India. According to NationMaster, Germany's rape rate stands at 9.4 incidents per 100,000 citizens, ranking 24th globally ¹. In contrast, India's rape rate is 1.8 incidents per 100,000 citizens, which is five times lower than Germany's rate ¹.
It's essential to note that India has been characterized as one of the countries with the lowest per capita rates of rape. However, the National Crime Records Bureau reported 31,677 rape cases in 2021, with Rajasthan recording the highest number of rapes among Indian states ².
*Rape Rates Comparison:*
- _Germany:_ 9.4 incidents per 100,000 citizens ¹
- _India:_ 1.8 incidents per 100,000 citizens ¹
Keep in mind that rape rates can vary significantly across different regions within a country. For instance, in India, Rajasthan had the highest rape rate, while Nagaland, Tamil Nadu, and Bihar had the lowest rates.
That said, yeah India needs to improve law enforcement sector, but let's not make it like Only India has this problem.
The most important thing is to identify the issue and willing to rectify it.
And., we Indians are working together to bring the change to our society for good.
I don't see it happening
@@snehab7676 conviction rate of rapists in germany is less than 1%. (india 32%) unreported rape cases is 90%. (india 54% in 2014. in 2024 it's likely close to 0) false rape cases in germany is 2-8%. (india 74% false rape cases) germany has more monthly rapes than yearly rapes in india despite havinig 1/20x of indian population.
The guys who is being defensive to this questions, JaiShankar himself acknowledged this in his answers in this video! Your patriotism is going against JaiShankar here!
conviction rate of rapists in germany is less than 1%. (india 32%) unreported rape cases is 90%. (india 54% in 2014. in 2024 it's likely close to 0) false rape cases in germany is 2-8%. (india 74% false rape cases) germany has more monthly rapes than yearly rapes in india despite havinig 1/20x of indian population.
??? jaishankar handling it well doesn't make the question any less disgusting and disrespectful. it's literally a propaganda to paint india's image in certain way. nobody asks these questions with diplomats of us uk france etc despite them having 10-100x more rapes than india
@@goat5944 bcoz they consider gy rp and marital rp is also rp but in india it's not a rp , Marital rp is a culture and 99.1% cases unreported jate hain use bhi dekh le....koi chachundar hi kahega ki india jyada safe hai europe se...
Are women safe at work in Germany?
*for Indians, Germany has more crimes than india.. But Their media don't highlight it on their TV but German media DW news does highlight India's to prove India still a bad place for women for its German audience..the above women is one of them*
*Repeating again German govt figures prove that Germany got more rapes than india for its very less population*
Yes
@@AbhimanyuMS-m1x according to some report, 30% of German women faced harassment issues at their workplace. So no, Germany isn't completely safe for women at their workplace.
@@Pain-zd5uo I did not say they are completely safe, I said they are better than India.(I used the word 'yes' just to generalise)
@@AbhimanyuMS-m1x you need to ask a German about it to know the reality.
Here in India crime against women happens on a large where its not just the common man of criminal mind is involved but the police also as well as the politicians involved .
A great diplomate he answer the question with utmost sensitivity while not openly denying the issue that persist but also not amplifying that as if it happens only India.
A great diplomat who answers nothing😂
...
conviction rate of rapists in germany is less than 1%. (india 32%) unreported rape cases is 90%. (india 54% in 2014. in 2024 it's likely close to 0) false rape cases in germany is 2-8%. (india 74% false rape cases) germany has more monthly rapes than yearly rapes in india despite havinig 1/20x of indian population.
India is a vast, dence and diverse country, tackling with crime in India is a every day challenge for Indians. Every European knows who is responsible for crime against women.
Jaishankarji this is not about habits, this about all women in India .
5 gangr@pe in paris but none of western media covered it but when there was one r@pe in India whole west started crying which type of media is this????
I agree in India at work at streets gets harrassed, stalked, victomised, we r talking about normal middle class women. culprit have to pay 2000 and gets bail.
People, we are not able to ask our govt. Atleast let people from other countries ask questions to our govt. Lets not supprt our govt in all these issues. Let our Jaiishankar face such slaps.
True if foreign countries do something india will have to do something 💀
why? rtrd have you ever seen same embarassing questions being asked to diplomats of any other country despite every other country having higher rape rates than india?? this is propaganda. USA hasn't had a single female president in it's 300 yr old democracy yet it preaches on woman oppression in india.
Love the honesty of the man. He doesn't wear a mask. Problems acknowledged are problems half solved.
Instead of speaking Stat and blaming game, he gave the root cause from his analysis.
no. him handling it well doesn't make her question any less disrespectful. why doesn't she ask such questions to countries like usa uk with 100x rapes of india?
Our Indian woman far better than that of Germany 🇮🇳😎🇮🇳
Thank goodness, for once, an Indian politician didn't harp on metaphorical tokens, like how we treat Indian women as God in Indian society, and how our president and prime minister have been women before other countries. We need intelligent ministers and politicians with empathy for public issues, not political idealogues who feed their ego with power. Good on Jaishankar for that response, and admitting to the problems we face.
conviction rate of rapists in germany is less than 1%. (india 32%) unreported rape cases is 90%. (india 54% in 2014. in 2024 it's likely close to 0) false rape cases in germany is 2-8%. (india 74% false rape cases) germany has more monthly rapes than yearly rapes in india despite havinig 1/20x of indian population.
As the interviewer is a white skin lady, she should first have asked this question of USA, Britain, Sweden, Germany, etc. etc. before asking it of India. They all out number India in this ghastly crime. Check with the statistics put out by their own organisations with high credibility. Having said that, no matter where, even one rape in a seven billion population is one too many.
😂
So what you’re basically saying is that you are a racist
So you’re basically a rac ist
Those countries record every single rape incident separately. Eg: a child was repeatedly raped by a someone over several years will have each rape counted individually whereas here in South Asia it is lumped into 1 statistic.
Yea obviously this German lady is trying to be racist lol
I liked about Mr. Jaishankar ji is that he did not dodge the question and also he admitted that yeah we have problems. Accepting that we have issues, is the first step towards solving it. Although I think he dodged women safety in the answer but he rightly said its due to centuries of oppression, habits and mindset which is the real issue and this can not be changed suddenly but punishment for rape is not proportionate with the crime in India. It's not powerful enough to stop the incidences.
This problem can not be solved by talking smart .
Instead of going all defensive he actually answered the question. Women face hardships and struggles in all societies, but that shouldn't matter, all that matters is what we do for the women in our society atleast. And hence it was nice that he answered it directly.
Rape is very common in European countries too…. It is not specific to India…. She should check those statistics and ask her country politicians too
no
@@tcltv-ei2eu, yes, it is. Are you trying to hide your tendencies?
Germany has a significantly higher rape rate per capita compared to India. According to NationMaster, Germany's rape rate stands at 9.4 incidents per 100,000 citizens, ranking 24th globally ¹. In contrast, India's rape rate is 1.8 incidents per 100,000 citizens, which is five times lower than Germany's rate ¹.
It's essential to note that India has been characterized as one of the countries with the lowest per capita rates of rape. However, the National Crime Records Bureau reported 31,677 rape cases in 2021, with Rajasthan recording the highest number of rapes among Indian states ².
*Rape Rates Comparison:*
- _Germany:_ 9.4 incidents per 100,000 citizens ¹
- _India:_ 1.8 incidents per 100,000 citizens ¹
Keep in mind that rape rates can vary significantly across different regions within a country. For instance, in India, Rajasthan had the highest rape rate, while Nagaland, Tamil Nadu, and Bihar had the lowest rates.
That said, yeah India needs to improve law enforcement sector, but let's not make it like Only India has this problem.
@@Death__0 rape is not reported in india says the same report
@@Death__0 typical indian brain
Yes this issue should be looked into in any Society not just Germany or India🙋.
Afghanistan Bangladesh Pakistan pe koi nahi bolta sabko bharat se hi prblam he.
because they are poor and we are a developing nation dont compare with countries bring measures to solve the issue and create a society for women - think like human
They don't know where these countries are situated.They know them when there are political turmoil in those countries.Genaral knowledge of people living in western countries are very poor.
@@ajith.giove069 so by your logic in a poor underdeveloped nation it's acceptable to do crime against women right ?🤨 and it's only the developed and developing countries job to take care of these things
Crime against women is one of the global issue stop limiting it to few countries now it's upto u to either take this advice or not
Please stop arguing about other countries...it is not OK anywhere for woman to have an unsafe environment...if she is asking the question to Indian EAM why will she talk about other countries? Also nobody can deny that India is unsafe for woman...and I am an Indian woman saying this....
@@AmandaFlorance-h8v, what are your suggestions to make it safer for the women in India?
Happens all around the world. Sad
Germany is also very unsafe ,do we give Gyan?
*for Indians, Germany has more crimes than india.. But Their media don't highlight it on their TV but German media DW news does highlight India's to prove India still a bad place for women for its German audience..the above women is one of them*
*Repeating again German govt figures prove that Germany got more rapes than india for its very less population*
I live in Germany and women are generally safe here. Realized in 2 years of staying here that general idea of people here is to not sexualize body parts. I never felt pervert gaze from german guys here like I felt growing up in India. I really love my India more than anything but truly feel we should accept the problem and try to collectively work on it. Having so much hope from next generation.
@@shortsbydipali May be because German girls in general are more attractive than Indian girls. Regarding rapes the only thing I can fault Indian society for is making rape a stigma for a girl which should not be the case. This is the reason Indian rapes get so much media coverage. The reality is rapes are not so uncommon anywhere else in the world. It's just that anywhere else there's not so much hue n cry over this.
@@PankajKumar-ej5dt cheap mindset. It's not about attraction, even physically disabled or just women in common get grasped, rapist don't care about how attractive they are.
Bro germany is far better when it comes to women safety
I am indian women,good question laday.
Upbringing of sons in India by their parents is one of the reason.giving so much of importance to male make them superior against other gender
He should have asked her if she had taught her sons to respect women....that's where the correct attitude is learnt....
Respect every one not just women!!
And especially dose who deserves.
Germany has a significantly higher rape rate per capita compared to India. According to NationMaster, Germany's rape rate stands at 9.4 incidents per 100,000 citizens, ranking 24th globally ¹. In contrast, India's rape rate is 1.8 incidents per 100,000 citizens, which is five times lower than Germany's rate ¹.
It's essential to note that India has been characterized as one of the countries with the lowest per capita rates of rape. However, the National Crime Records Bureau reported 31,677 rape cases in 2021, with Rajasthan recording the highest number of rapes among Indian states ².
*Rape Rates Comparison:*
- _Germany:_ 9.4 incidents per 100,000 citizens ¹
- _India:_ 1.8 incidents per 100,000 citizens ¹
Keep in mind that rape rates can vary significantly across different regions within a country. For instance, in India, Rajasthan had the highest rape rate, while Nagaland, Tamil Nadu, and Bihar had the lowest rates.
That said, yeah India needs to improve law enforcement sector, but let's not make it like Only India has this problem.
Yes respect...everyone irrespective of gender.... And we need to be concern about fake rape case
@@Death__0yes india is the absolute safest country in the world for women. Whereas many many German women get raped and murdered all the time.
@@Anurag-mc3ul Thank You bro I have seen a lot of fake rape cases near my locality, law and respect should be gender neutral not just for women
In India in olden times, women actually were fully empowered and on equal status with men. It was only after the foreign invasions that things changed. Because for these invaders women were 'commodities' to be exploited. Therefore we were forced to impose certain restrictions on them. Unfortunately these conditions following the invasions persist even today and therefore the current issues.
But unfortunately, he did not address the question of safety. Women and the families of women would themselves be sending their girls out to explore the if not for the fear. A small village girl moved out her parents house to work in a city and to earn her living, but she was eventually harassed and raped to death, the culprit was the son of the ruling government's son, who are still protected by the government of Uttrakhand (a region in India). How can we ensure the safety of women in such a corrupt society where politicians and judiciary are on sale for money.
Exactly. In our countries atleast ppl get justice without public protest, here if culprit is influential they go free. Only after media made some noise the person ws arrested if their was no media or ppl didnt protest the person wold not have been arrested also. Its easy to tamper with evidence and bribe the police and ruin the case it never happens in europe. Even in hatras case all 4 pppl were let free by court coz of lack of evidence that girl will never get juictice after such horrivble crime.
I dont know why yall want to attack Germany over a womans simple question.
Because she must ask this question from Germany govt that Why they have more higher rape rate than India, they are trying to degrade India in World level but want to save image of Their own #rapi*st, Indian must acknowledge this thing but today misinformation & hate against India is common thing in Europe
why aren't same "simple" questions ever asked to diplomats of countries with 10x to 100x rapes than india despite having 1/5 to 1/20 of indian population?
A French pensioner went on trial Monday for allowing scores of strangers to rape his wife after he drugged her, in a case that has horrified the country. Fifty men, recruited online, are also being tried in the southern city of Avignon alongside the main suspect, a 71-year-old former employee at France's state-owned power utility company EDF
Brilliant, Articulate, WellInformed EAM JaiShankar ji🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏
Never face a reality, instead just keep offering excuses after excuses. This guy is as good as his boss, everywhere you go, always talk about moon, spend 10-15 years in the govt fooling people and then enjoy the retirement.
quite literally nothing he said was an excuse u rtrd. what did u want him to say? what reality?
I remember why women use to vote for jayalalitha because in her time , gangsters and politicians all are afraid to keep hands on any girls or women or kids. She would unleash hell to these people. I still miss her.. whatever her issues with corruption, I have never cared about those things because she protected us and all women know that thats why she got a big women voter base. One time, we even know that she saved one of the rajini's girls from a gang that time she and rajini were like an enemy but after that event , rajini behaved differently with her. Unfortunately, no male politician can do it because they are backstabbers when it comes to women rights, they will never get women base of votes like jayalalitha because we can see clearly, they dont care. Just dont care...
EAM we love you too 🙏
Love u for all the uh hmmm ahh😅😅
She is right but all the people who are pointing at Germany regarding this first look at India and then tell
Great response by EAM jaishankar
You know...to be honest...you know....etc etc
Because India changed by a western culture
We indians are proud of our foreign minister Mr Jai Shankar !!He always make all indians head High !! Always absolutely true line by Jai Shankar !! Jai Hind !!❤🇮🇳💞🙏💐👍🇮🇳
What's there to be proud of? Did the parents of the rape victim in Kolkata get justice? Do you even know what's happening all over India? How many actually get justice? Do your research please ...
The American would be wondering whether their children would be back from school. There’s a good chance of them getting short in the school premises itself.
Jaishanker himself was forced to marry his Japanese interpreter after he violated her chastity and she complained to Japanese foreign ministry during his post in the 1990s. His uncles M K Narayan and M K Bawdrawkumar helped him preventing diplomatic meltdown.
Can you explain more please what you are saying . I wanna know more what the case here ….
@@ranfak he's bullshitting like all the liberals and communists of india.
Brij Bhushan is still roaming free. Women can not go to police station without fear in India. Lot of atrocities against women even by Indian police
Wrong answer. Per capita rapes in India is much less than Europe. It's just that rape is such a big thing here that it becomes major news.
In india majority of rapes dont get reported
@@ritwik5774 Then I don't think you have visited Indian villages. In Indian villages it's much bigger crime than urban centres. There are honor killings in villages on this matter. And you're saying these things go unreported. And If it goes unreported then this is not a rape at all. This is adultry.
Germany has a significantly higher rape rate per capita compared to India. According to NationMaster, Germany's rape rate stands at 9.4 incidents per 100,000 citizens, ranking 24th globally ¹. In contrast, India's rape rate is 1.8 incidents per 100,000 citizens, which is five times lower than Germany's rate ¹.
It's essential to note that India has been characterized as one of the countries with the lowest per capita rates of rape. However, the National Crime Records Bureau reported 31,677 rape cases in 2021, with Rajasthan recording the highest number of rapes among Indian states ².
*Rape Rates Comparison:*
- _Germany:_ 9.4 incidents per 100,000 citizens ¹
- _India:_ 1.8 incidents per 100,000 citizens ¹
Keep in mind that rape rates can vary significantly across different regions within a country. For instance, in India, Rajasthan had the highest rape rate, while Nagaland, Tamil Nadu, and Bihar had the lowest rates.
That said, yeah India needs to improve law enforcement sector, but let's not make it like Only India has this problem.
@@Death__0indian police discourage rapes being recorded. Also rapes spanning a long period is counted as 1 rape in india whereas every individual rape is recoded as a separate incident in Germany. You are seriously stupid of you think India accurately reports rape statistics.
conviction rate of rapists in germany is less than 1%. (india 32%) unreported rape cases is 90%. (india 54% in 2014. in 2024 it's likely close to 0) false rape cases in germany is 2-8%. (india 74% false rape cases) germany has more monthly rapes than yearly rapes in india despite havinig 1/20x of indian population.
Unlike Germany, prostitution is NOT legal in India😂
How many countries protest or show rage on rape as we do in India. Unlike other countries we raise our voice against rape
Actually they dont give a shit about rape they just want a drama and want brothels in india like germany in the name of feminism
conviction rate of rapists in germany is less than 1%. (india 32%) unreported rape cases is 90%. (india 54% in 2014. in 2024 it's likely close to 0) false rape cases in germany is 2-8%. (india 74% false rape cases) germany has more monthly rapes than yearly rapes in india despite havinig 1/20x of indian population.
India is still a developing country and will continue to evolve. We need to constantly learn and improve cultural, social and economic our stances for everyone especially for women however, while doing that, we have gone too far when it comes to laws where it is the exact opposite. Things will improve and needs time.
Yes, the Bilkis Bano convicts were garlanded by your party members when they were granted parole. The Hatras victim was cremated without a postmortem. And Sanjhi Ram was given 10 years for rape and murder of a 8 year old girl.
Thank you very much sir.
and pedophiles were elected as president in america
First time i am watching that people are asking the relevant question ...if any body saying this is unbiased question but you thinking what you want making in this society. If you raising this type of quetion one day we are solving this type of problem.
Jai Hind Jai Bharat 🇮🇳🙏🏼🙏🏼🙏🏼🙏🏼🙏🏼🇮🇳🇮🇳🇮🇳🇮🇳🇮🇳🇮🇳🇮🇳
A woman was shot dead for exposing her feet toe in a country. These guys are very afraid to atleast mention that incident.
The bullies only try to bully the ones that they think are weaker than them.
Germany has a significantly higher rape rate per capita compared to India. According to NationMaster, Germany's rape rate stands at 9.4 incidents per 100,000 citizens, ranking 24th globally ¹. In contrast, India's rape rate is 1.8 incidents per 100,000 citizens, which is five times lower than Germany's rate ¹.
It's essential to note that India has been characterized as one of the countries with the lowest per capita rates of rape. However, the National Crime Records Bureau reported 31,677 rape cases in 2021, with Rajasthan recording the highest number of rapes among Indian states ².
*Rape Rates Comparison:*
- _Germany:_ 9.4 incidents per 100,000 citizens ¹
- _India:_ 1.8 incidents per 100,000 citizens ¹
Keep in mind that rape rates can vary significantly across different regions within a country. For instance, in India, Rajasthan had the highest rape rate, while Nagaland, Tamil Nadu, and Bihar had the lowest rates.
That said, yeah India needs to improve law enforcement sector, but let's not make it like Only India has this problem.
So you want to compare India with the WORST countries, so that you can say we are Better than them, just to satisfy your ego?
Please RAISE your benchmark.
Look up to those countries which are BETTER than us and try to raise our standards to match theirs.
You can either compare yourself to Losers to feel good about yourself OR you can compare yourself with Achievers to raise your own standards.
saying atleast to show some concern them too,.. when you work for 99% your own country women, atleast 1% for women around the world , a simple voice atleast with a smile on face!?
@@divyas1114 , you are right. India should implement the “ One Nation, One Law “ to be compared to other Democratic and secular nations. Is this okay by you? Please, do elaborate and not hide in your burrow now
Are Indian women safe in Germany and London. So many racist comments about them in both places…
Really?
But Indian women will still blame Indian men lol
I don't know these days every other country is worried about Indians living in India where as we are good in india
Even Jaishankar daughter doesn’t feel safe in India, then he talks about safety for Indian women, what a funny!,😂😂
conviction rate of rapists in germany is less than 1%. (india 32%) unreported rape cases is 90%. (india 54% in 2014. in 2024 it's likely close to 0) false rape cases in germany is 2-8%. (india 74% false rape cases) germany has more monthly rapes than yearly rapes in india despite havinig 1/20x of indian population. .
Not only women but men are also unsafe in India because of Gender biased law.Law should be gender neutral for everyone whether it's men or women or Transgender.There are lots of cases in India where women are misutilising the law against men like false dowry cases,false sexual harrasment cases,false domestic violence cases,false rape cases, extortion of money in the name of alimony.Where women are self independent financially still she is extorting money from her husband.Theae are the issue that need to be resolved by bringing Gender Neutral law.
Every body should understand, in the Europe prostitution is legalised and free sex is very common but in India the social structure is diffferent, prostitution and free sex is restricted. Further 140 crore population had complex problems. The foreign media also making bad propaganda.
So you are saying that since free sx is restricted, therefore the men cannot control themselves and they harass/r@pe?
People like you should stop making excuses for your own Loose character.
For once, I appreciate the Western journalist for being respectful while asking the question. Her tone and manners are very respectful. It shows that she genuinely cares about the issue rather than just using the issue to perpetuate racial stereotypes. Equally, Jaishankar acknowledged the problems in India and empathized with her concern. The tone and demeanour often matters too, not just the substance when you ask someone a question. BBC could never get such an answer because they are always looking for a fight to act like some crusaders.
ntg abt that question was respectful. it was a propaganda to set a narrative. no one asks such question to any other diplomat. literally no one. and this is despite us uk france germany having 10-100x more rapes than india.
Germany must face this issue in future, wait for it , because you don't focus cause of this type of mentality.Your answer is in your country now
Everybody safe near me promise
this guy lies when he opens his mouth. but in clever way.
This guy only beats round the bush😅
He’s the master of slithering & evading questions in a polite & articulate way
2:07 lies like a clever with AI generated women 👀
quite literally nothing he said was a lie
We need to increase the safety measures for women. We got a lot of problems that need resolutions.
He still not answering her questions 😅😅😅 diverting the actual question
In Germany, in a population of 8.5 Cr, 16,000 cases of rape were reported.
In India, in a population of 140 Cr, 29000 cases of rape were reported.
This woman is mentally sick❤
In india rapes are underreported especially in rural areas
many india wont be reported and i lived in germany for 3 years ..germany is more safe for women and india is not instead of saying something please accept it and solve the issue...ask women around u once how many if them are feeling safe in india ..?
@@ajith.giove069 bro even 70% of cases not reported in German. And 75% cases reported in india are false report by Indian government
@@ajith.giove069 I studied and lived in Germany for 5 years. A girl in my student dorm was raped. No one knew, the uni covered it up and the only information we got were random flyers stuck on the main door saying "keeps doors closed after 10PM". I got to know because I was friends with her.
@@ajith.giove069On New Year's Eve 2015, hundreds of women were mobbed and sexually assaulted during celebrations in the western German city of Cologne by peaceful migrants 😂
Safest country for women's are Pakistan 🇵🇰 according to german journalist 😮
issue of women are deeply rooted in indian culture.
india is safest country for women on the planet.
conviction rate of rapists in germany is less than 1%. (india 32%) unreported rape cases is 90%. (india 54% in 2014. in 2024 it's likely close to 0) false rape cases in germany is 2-8%. (india 74% false rape cases) germany has more monthly rapes than yearly rapes in india despite havinig 1/20x of indian population.
Smriti Irani worked really hard when she was Education Minister of India for rural girls. Due to her efforts we have more rural girls in Schools than boys, which in reality was other way around. Main issue for girls not going to school was not having Toilet, especially for girls who started having periods. Such small thing no government of India never paid attention. Smriti, even doing great work at ground level, she was PR nightmare for BJP due to trolling and she was removed from her ministry.
Reason simple. Be honest. Germany is cold and India a tropical nation. Ofcourse Indian Judicial systems and laws r Rotten
Nothing is fucking wrong with the laws ,it's executive's terrible policing in question
Germany have 12% rape rate and India have 1.81% , India is more safe than rapi**st germany, we know how to protect our own nation, a country with more higher rape rate than India is lecturing India
conviction rate of rapists in germany is less than 1%. (india 32%) unreported rape cases is 90%. (india 54% in 2014. in 2024 it's likely close to 0) false rape cases in germany is 2-8%. (india 74% false rape cases) germany has more monthly rapes than yearly rapes in india despite havinig 1/20x of indian population.
Shameless Jaishankar should accept the women by mainland India is brutal against women, accept the shame
Absolutely valid question..have all the indians getting angry at her ...have youll forgotten kolkata?? No wonder there is no justice for women in india
In people who enrol in medical colleges I find in India girls dominate boys by 4:1 ratio. It's hard to find boys in excess of 20%.This trend is there for past 8-9 years now.
This will reflect in society as the doctors post graduate.
Also in food and cosmetics industry (I know of one Indian very large MNC having its office in Peenya Bangalore having more than 90 % girls employed.
Soon men will have to fight for equal share in society.
so sad that men are so incompetent
yes I was at Sdm Hospital in Bengaluru, almost all student Doctors was ladies
R. Stastics in India is 1.8/100,000.
Correcting for under-reporting, as per NCRB data which projects it at 71%, it gives us around 7/100,000
So, even after correction for under-reporting taking higher side of the mark (i would argue it would he nearer to 50%), not correcting under-reporting for other Nations & no taking into account the Ms. problem (which is rampant in Europe as well), we are still safer than 95% of the Nations which have data of 15-200/100,000.
So, all this accuation against India is merely media narrative.
Ms German lady, check your biggest corporate - SAP. The CTO himself misbehaved with women and was fired. SAP in India also has too many of these cases (mainly in frustrated overworked teams) and they refuse to take complaints