Did you know if you don't kill them you can just keep coming back hogtied her and loot her while she's washing dishes. Her brother lover will start shooting you but won't kill you. Ride away come back. She has 2 dollars and three silver jewelry. Zero bounty to Robb them never any witness . 😊
@@BandidFourLife now here's what's going to happen I'm going to answer your question very truthfully meaning I'm doing it right now and I'm going to tell you what happened please try to stay away from the thought of not believing what I'm telling you because I'm not over praising this damn game.... here it goes... the facts.... would you believe that NOTHING DIFFERENT happened at all in the storyline or in gameplay if you take both to the pit .... now what's next ? you're going to continuously keep asking the same question and purposely ignoring that I just told you the answer ...
9:14 the look on Authur's face is the best in the game. The complete shock and realizm along with the eyes shifting back and forth looking at them both. Lol
@@tilted_axis9819 I absolutely love that small detail they put in. Out of all the hundreds of details in that game, that one is priceless and I busted out laughing when I seen it.
If you kill Bray while he is greeting you on the porch, Tammy will chase you. If you stay just ahead of her she will chase you all over the map. She chased me all the way to Annsburg and back down to Emerald ranch. Then i got bored and shot her.
What’s really interesting is that almost ALL encounters and missions in this game are like this. Even if it’s just a matter of stalling, shooting your pistol randomly in the air, or doing some random thing that has nothing to do with the mission… there’s often dialogue prepared for those scenarios. Even after a mission, sometimes, the stranger will react to things you do if you hang around. Skinning animals or looting bodies will invoke acknowledgment. Doing things in the wrong order. It’s just wild. I’m on my 6th playthrough, and I’m still finding different outcomes to events, no matter how menial or minor.
Thats a lie ... The game is scripted to play out one way Every time .... Your misleading people into thinking the game gives different options and as far as the dialogue goes it's literally the same negative and positive response😂 nothing unique about that this game has a lot of restrictions for being called a free roam game
@@JoeyGambella There are definitely missions and encounters that can be finished in different orders/ways. The outcome is usually the same but the game isn't trying to be An immersive sim like Prey or Deus Ex. RDR2 still delivers in creating a world to immerse in.
@@JoeyGambellaI most definitely know random encounters aren't an actual choice, That wasn't my argument. It's what transpires between the start and end of it. There's plenty of evidence on youtube that clearly show that the dialogue/actions can change in a mission or encounter depending on how you deal with it. I really wouldn't call myself dedicated or even a massive Rockstar fan. I do realize this games story is linear driven and nothing like Fallout New Vegas. I loved the story though. Agree to disagree there lol.
@@JoeyGambella I honestly could not give two shits about historical accuracy or all that other stuff but I can understand why someone would though. I might not have worded what I was trying to point out but this video of all the different possible Abeerden Pig Farm scenarios is what I'm referring to. ruclips.net/video/rdYkE-l8Sc0/видео.html
I think my favourite detail is the simple fact that they already had three plates set. It goes further to prove that they’ve done this to many people as they already had it set up and were counting on someone showing up.
This is why this game is so amazing. They create so much depth by having dialogue that 99% of players will never actually hear. Your choices always feel meaningful
I always wondered what the deal was with the butcher of Rhodes. The weapon smith talks often about the questionable meat that the butcher sells but I could never figure out what to do with that information
oh, and BTW - TagBackTV did some deep dives a few years ago on a ton of these encounters. He had like 10 episodes on these freaks alone lol - definitely covered most of what you found. I'm telling you about him because his back catalog of testing RDR2 is so good there may be inspiration there for you for some future content
absolutely amazing how much depth there is in this encounter, theres a lot of dialogue here Ive never heard. also I guess practically everyone knows this but this place is the only way Im aware of to transfer Arthur's money to John in the Epilogue, come here right at the end of the game, get drugged and robbed, and dont get your money back, then you can go back as John and find the place deserted but all Arthurs money will be behind the picture. the only detail I know about this pace that wasn't in the vid is that there's a weird inaccessible stash of what look like jewellery boxes under the floorboards upstairs. you can see them but you cant get to them to pick up, as far as I know
appare in un evento casuale del gioco, esce da un cespuglio e ti chiede di liberarlo dalle catene ai piedi. Se lo liberi ti da questa informazione. È grazie a lui che ho scoperto questa casa haahah @@Sburato
You can opt to leave this for your penultimate mission and leave all your money for John in the Epilogue. Sell all you have before starting it to max out what you leave to John.
@sehajgill3320 No sell them at the fence first then go to the Pig Farm. After you wake up go back and kill them and look at the painting just inside the door but dont touch it. Then you can go back and get all your cash as John.
I’m on my 2nd ever play through, literally just did this event not long ago, now I’m so sad 😭 Sorry, John. Hopefully I’ll remember this trick on my 3rd run of the game 😂
My first play through I never found these siblings. It’s crazy how much work rockstar put into dialogue that possibly would have never been found by players. They really put so much into this game. Greatest game of all time.
Idk why, but I've always been tickled by the way Arthur says "I found some bones, in an armoire, what's that about?" I'm not sure what it is about it, but his delivery of that line always makes me crack up.
Actually. Once you talk to them on the porch and they go inside. You can walk into the side door and loot the money box. 60.00. But you can go back out and run to the first tree on the hill behind the house and the money box will be refilled. You can do this over and over until you have as much cash as you want without playing out the scenario in the house. Then you can come back later in the game to stash money for john. But john cant pay his house off with it. He has to do the missions with sadie to pay off the bank. By then he's got the blackwater heist money. And not much to spend it on.
You can also let this encounter for right before the last mission where Arthur dies. If you do so and let them rob you, you can come back later as john and claim the money from behind the picture.
I wonder what would happen if you ate with them with no money on you. RDR almost always has dialogue prepared for specific scenarios, so it would be interesting to see if anything different happened.
If you go to the top of the stairs and turn right, you'll uncover a loose floorboard close to the staircase itself. Inside are what look like several jewelry boxes but you can't collect them.
@@Lowclasswarrior778 That's pretty damn odd. My old account on a DB forum was "LowClassSaiyan." Not to mention that you also have a picture of Tullece. What a coincidence.
Ofcourse. Arthurs comment to the food "Its good. Different" and Brays "This meat is so tender" gives that away. Human meat is said to taste very different from others to our taste buds and is very soft and tender.
The attention to detail in this game is incredible... i could tell u how many times I was freaked out about how realistic and detailed small minor skits in the game was...
I've had the game for years but had been focused on online, just now on my first story mode playthrough. I've met the camping guy on my way to the trapper, but haven't stopped by the pig farm yet. Probably been close many times stealing wagons but haven't triggered this...now I'm not sure if I want to. This game is truly immersive and and amazing...enjoyed watching!
Strangley enough I've never met the guy warning about them. I've beat this game well going on 3 times now. This game is truly a masterpiece.. Only bad part is Arthur dying 😔
What I’m really surprised about is Arthur not asking where the meat came from for the stew? Momma? As far as the Benders go none of them were related to one another so there was no insest involved but a sad end to anyone staying with them.
The Morningstar steamboat was originally intended to serve as a floating casino. Evidence of this can be seen in the "Life in the West" pre-release trailer, and also in the dialogue exchanged between John Marston and Elizabeth Thornton during the Stranger mission "The Wronged Woman", wherein she says "I knew his frequenting that gambling boat would be the death of him." However, the Korrigan serves this purpose in Red Dead Redemption 2 and there's even an advertisement for the boat at the docks in Blackwater - the ferry hails from here to several other destinations, which could indicate that Rockstar retconned this cut element in using the Korrigan.
@@tayyan378 he’s still there lol. I’m trying to get the Missouri Fox Trotter from the horse photo mission. Then I still have a mission with Javier and the train robbery with John etc. I’ve never played this before but I love it and don’t want it to end.
Let pig farmers rob you late in chapter 6. Then go back as John in Epilogue. And reclaim your money behind the picture of mamma. It’s better than loosing it.
Definitely One of the most disturbing random encounters in RDR2, probably just as disturbing or maybe a little less so compared to Edmund Lowry Jr. Either way the Aberdeen’s are freaks.
On my last playthrough as Dark Arthur, I just started robbing the house while Tammy was getting ready. Int he end, Bray got mad and tried to throw me out at gunpoint. I chopped them up with my trusty machete instead of shooting them. Who's the pycho now, eh?
Bro not even lying, I know exactly how Arthur feels being invited to someone’s home you’ve never been to and feeling super uncomfortable. Cause it happened to me when I was invited to a Mormon church and then was invited to a Mormon family home for dinner and it was the scariest house I’ve ever been too. They had a fake severed human head behind there fence in the backyard 😳😳😳
I wonder what happens to Tammy after you threw her in the pit and walk away. Like revisiting the pit a few days later. Is there a decomposing corpse of Tammy or does she just despawn? Someone here that tried this?
I watched this video yesterday and I was amazed in all the things you can do, I just went back there and killed them without trying to hog tie them or anything. Today as i was passing by I saw the house and decided to enter and you can see that the place is trashed and some furniture is missing. Another thing I want to mention is that there is a way to get in the locked room through the windows. You just need to shoot the window frame and you can easily get in, the locked box is there and it has some money in it. Hope this helps.
so there's just one thing i never see in all the thousand people covering the aberdeen farm and it's what would happen if you just hogtie Tammy and bring her to the closest sheriff before Bray intervenes
I did this, while a deputy? And I got in trouble for "kidnapping" her.. I did kill Bray tho, but he's quite spry for a big fellow! Hard to imagine NOT killing him and still surviving urself.. Hes a quick shot too..
@@savannahpaige3670 I got mistaken for "kidnapping" a thief in an alleyway in Saint Denis one time. I was gonna take him to the police station, but I guess it was enough to just intervene lol
There’s a real story in Australia about the woman who killed her boyfriend .they lived Aberdeen and she worked at a pig farm she cut him up and made dinner with him to serve and set the table I don’t remember who the plates were for .
@@cain666there's literally nothing to learn when you're getting frame to look like something but everyone in the world could easily hate and get paid so good for it
There’s also a connection between the couple and the Rhodes butcher. Try shooting at the couple then have them follow you to Rhodes. Just don’t let them get to close to you or shoot you or your horse too much.
What about all the jewelry stashed under the floorboards upstairs? If u crouch down along the banister by the stairs in the same room as the bones,u can flip up a board revealing what looks like jewelry boxes u can't grab. Always wanted to know why this is there. Let me know.
You can get some additional dialogue by stealing from them. Tammy wont mind if you go through her dresser draws, You can take a couple canned goods from downstairs and the big guy will be ok with it. But take to much and he will tell you to leave the house.
11:31 "That's what Pa used to say." That was the first line that creeped me out. For whatever reason, I am so desensitised to incest among siblings at this point.
“Fun” Fact: If you read the names of the Bender Family's(Aberdeen Pig Farm in Rdr2) victims you can find the name Abigail Roberts killed in December 1872.
I like how you can make a lot of money with Arthur and then get yourself robbed by these inbred hillbilly siblings in the final chapter, to just come back as John and find the home empty and take all that cash from behind the picture, that they took from our boy. That's a decent move to immediately feel free to get whatever you want from the start as John and don't have to hustle for your life until getting Micah's money at the end.
This was amazing!!! I had absolutely no idea that Rockstar put THIS much detail into the pig farm. I'm about to do a third play through, and I can't wait to try all if these
It definitely seems to be loosely based on the Bender family. Although, unlike in the game here, the Benders were a Germanic family of four (Ma, Pa and the two siblings) and the brother and sister were said to be very attractive. There are some people that speculate that the murderous Kelly family were the same people simply using different names. But there's no real concrete evidence to back this up. In fact, there were actually several supposed run ins with the Benders after they went on the run, but none of these could be verified either. In many of these claims some of the family members either eventually ran into the law or ran into bandits and were killed as a result. It's not clear as to what really happened to them. Or perhaps they got away with their crimes.
When i found the place in online and saw there was a mission inside i whistled my horse and rode like i never had before. In story mode, after the first drink from their mix, i got up and blew both of them away with my shotgun. Worst part is Arthur certainly ate human flesh there.
I wondered if this was based in the Bloody Benders. I was driving one day through Kansas and got tired. I pulled over at a historic placard near Big Hill KS. It was about the Benders and they lived near that marker. It kind of freaked me out so I was wide awake and left. 30 some years later I’ve never been back. I talked to everyone about it just didn’t feel like driving out of the way to go see it again.
I love Rockstar games. They add small little encounters and depth, to the gameplay and story. I used to ask my mom for this game so much when I was 8. Now I have the game now that I’m slightly older, I have seen this encounter in chapter 2 and 3
The first part is never something I see missed tbh. I feel like everyone finds that, he's basically right next to the main road. Not even back behind trees. But some good ones here for sure
Just so you know, you dont have to go through the encounter to get the money in the secret room. You can go anytime, just the door is locked, so blow out the window to the right of the door and you an crawl through and get the money from the safety box
I haven’t gone into the house yet, they invited me in but I just rode off. Next time I went by, I stood on a barrel or something outside the window big boy is writing by. Unfortunately he doesn’t/didn’t notice me. I’m hoping to save Arthur’s $$ for John in the end, but I’ll most likely just go in blasting. 😂🤷🏽♂️
RUclips is trying to shadowban my videos. See the newest one here: ruclips.net/video/PQ3ohA6RIhc/видео.htmlsi=EkguwBlIjmi_qA6Y
Did you know if you don't kill them you can just keep coming back hogtied her and loot her while she's washing dishes. Her brother lover will start shooting you but won't kill you. Ride away come back. She has 2 dollars and three silver jewelry. Zero bounty to Robb them never any witness . 😊
@@wicked639 cool
Shadow ban? I doubt it. I was recommended this video without searching for it.
What happens if you take both to the pit?
@@BandidFourLife now here's what's going to happen I'm going to answer your question very truthfully meaning I'm doing it right now and I'm going to tell you what happened please try to stay away from the thought of not believing what I'm telling you because I'm not over praising this damn game....
here it goes... the facts....
would you believe that NOTHING DIFFERENT happened at all in the storyline or in gameplay if you take both to the pit ....
now what's next ? you're going to continuously keep asking the same question and purposely ignoring that I just told you the answer ...
I always use this encounter to save my money for epilogue is really fun seeing John asking for a loan when having like 10k in his pocket
Me too 😂😂😂❤
Wish I knew this trick
weird in my first playthrough i still had the 13k that i had with arthur before the epilog
Yeah I'd normally have 50k w this trick and john still getting a loan doing bounties saying he's broke even tho I bought everything for him.
i don’t need the money, i need the arthur 😢
9:14 the look on Authur's face is the best in the game. The complete shock and realizm along with the eyes shifting back and forth looking at them both. Lol
Him realizing what’s going on and that he needs to get out as fast as possible. The absolute face of “Ahhh shit, what have I gotten myself into.”
@@tilted_axis9819 I absolutely love that small detail they put in. Out of all the hundreds of details in that game, that one is priceless and I busted out laughing when I seen it.
Im so amazed at Arthurs VA having to record thousands of lines for encounters some people will never find
His face is amazing
Yeah its used for a lot of memes lol.
If you kill Bray while he is greeting you on the porch, Tammy will chase you. If you stay just ahead of her she will chase you all over the map. She chased me all the way to Annsburg and back down to Emerald ranch. Then i got bored and shot her.
Same happens if you do it the other way around
😂😂😂😂😂 damn
Complete nightmare fuel
🤣🤣🤣😭☠️
Lmao I saw a video of someone else playing on here but that person shot her instead and her brother literally chased arthur all over day and night 😂😂
Arthur's complete shock face to how messed up the aberdeen family are is so hilarious its like oh damn what did i get myself into 😂
That look made me laugh when he found out they was brother and sister
Had me dying haha.
But then he sits back down and drinks
Arthur’s face when he realized that they are brother and sister is hilarious
This is beautiful for people in alabama
What’s really interesting is that almost ALL encounters and missions in this game are like this. Even if it’s just a matter of stalling, shooting your pistol randomly in the air, or doing some random thing that has nothing to do with the mission… there’s often dialogue prepared for those scenarios. Even after a mission, sometimes, the stranger will react to things you do if you hang around. Skinning animals or looting bodies will invoke acknowledgment. Doing things in the wrong order. It’s just wild.
I’m on my 6th playthrough, and I’m still finding different outcomes to events, no matter how menial or minor.
I’m on my sixth or seventh playthrough. About 700+ hrs total and I’m still finding new things in the game. It’s crazy great greatest game ever
Thats a lie ...
The game is scripted to play out one way
Every time ....
Your misleading people into thinking the game gives different options and as far as the dialogue goes it's literally the same negative and positive response😂 nothing unique about that this game has a lot of restrictions for being called a free roam game
@@JoeyGambella There are definitely missions and encounters that can be finished in different orders/ways. The outcome is usually the same but the game isn't trying to be An immersive sim like Prey or Deus Ex. RDR2 still delivers in creating a world to immerse in.
@@JoeyGambellaI most definitely know random encounters aren't an actual choice, That wasn't my argument. It's what transpires between the start and end of it. There's plenty of evidence on youtube that clearly show that the dialogue/actions can change in a mission or encounter depending on how you deal with it. I really wouldn't call myself dedicated or even a massive Rockstar fan. I do realize this games story is linear driven and nothing like Fallout New Vegas. I loved the story though. Agree to disagree there lol.
@@JoeyGambella I honestly could not give two shits about historical accuracy or all that other stuff but I can understand why someone would though. I might not have worded what I was trying to point out but this video of all the different possible Abeerden Pig Farm scenarios is what I'm referring to. ruclips.net/video/rdYkE-l8Sc0/видео.html
I think my favourite detail is the simple fact that they already had three plates set. It goes further to prove that they’ve done this to many people as they already had it set up and were counting on someone showing up.
Also notice how they don't pour drinks for themselves.
@@theyellowmeteorthat’s what I look for, if someone pours a drink and doesn’t drink it I’d be suspicious
They didn't even try to cover it up saying something like "Mama always said have a place ready for strangers"
This is why this game is so amazing. They create so much depth by having dialogue that 99% of players will never actually hear. Your choices always feel meaningful
it's funny if you keep opening the armoire, because arthur continues to act startled everytime he opens it
lmao
I guess short-term memory loss is a very rare side effect of advanced TB.
I found this out on my most recent playthrough. After the first few times it just felt like he was being sarcastic. Haha.
They are also friends with the butcher in Rhodes, if you take one of them there, the butcher will attack you. I wonder where he got all his meat LOL
I always wondered what the deal was with the butcher of Rhodes. The weapon smith talks often about the questionable meat that the butcher sells but I could never figure out what to do with that information
@@Grivianthen again the gunsmith in question keeps a guy in his basement, what a town
@@slimesp1derat least the dudes alive and not possibly being sold to people as meat
I guess someone got a bit too curious. I mean how the heck you found that out 😂
@@xXBattle_Taco12XxI’d rather be eaten tbh. That kid had a whole nightmare life.
Another detail is that you can't lift the fat guy after killing him because he's too heavy
You cant lasso him either
Encounters likes this makes this game the more realistic. Rdr will never be beaten.
GTA 6
@kratos56015wdym not confirmed the actor himself who played as Michael said “be patient” responding a question in a video like a week ago
Its confirmed
There is even legit leaked beta footage of it somewhere on youtube (if Rockstar didnt put it down)
@kratos56015 GTA 6 is absolutely confirmed. Industry insiders estimate it will come out spring of 2025.
RDR3 is a definite. I just hope they keep the main focus on single player. But I think k there’s lots to learn about the online aspect of RDR2.
from a frantic "shorts" upload schedule to researched, edited & narrated videos.... LOVE what you are doing with the channel!
oh, and BTW - TagBackTV did some deep dives a few years ago on a ton of these encounters. He had like 10 episodes on these freaks alone lol - definitely covered most of what you found. I'm telling you about him because his back catalog of testing RDR2 is so good there may be inspiration there for you for some future content
absolutely amazing how much depth there is in this encounter, theres a lot of dialogue here Ive never heard. also I guess practically everyone knows this but this place is the only way Im aware of to transfer Arthur's money to John in the Epilogue, come here right at the end of the game, get drugged and robbed, and dont get your money back, then you can go back as John and find the place deserted but all Arthurs money will be behind the picture.
the only detail I know about this pace that wasn't in the vid is that there's a weird inaccessible stash of what look like jewellery boxes under the floorboards upstairs. you can see them but you cant get to them to pick up, as far as I know
Shoot the floor boards then u can get them
There’s also a prisoner that if you free he tells about a pig farm with heaps of loot
I met him too, then I shot him 😊
@@michellebaker8921lmao same
Dove si trova questo prigioniero?
@@Sburatorandom encounter, shoot his shackles and he MIGHT snitch, he has trillions of robberies
appare in un evento casuale del gioco, esce da un cespuglio e ti chiede di liberarlo dalle catene ai piedi. Se lo liberi ti da questa informazione. È grazie a lui che ho scoperto questa casa haahah @@Sburato
I just love Arthurs Face when he heard about them two being siblings. Its just so relatable after hearing such crazy informations...
"For all I know, you're a thief and a killer, but I can tell you're a good man"
Dude the game is just begging us to rob that guy
You can opt to leave this for your penultimate mission and leave all your money for John in the Epilogue. Sell all you have before starting it to max out what you leave to John.
I wish I knew this before doing this encounter
@sehajgill3320 No sell them at the fence first then go to the Pig Farm.
After you wake up go back and kill them and look at the painting just inside the door but dont touch it.
Then you can go back and get all your cash as John.
I’m on my 2nd ever play through, literally just did this event not long ago, now I’m so sad 😭 Sorry, John. Hopefully I’ll remember this trick on my 3rd run of the game 😂
I started blasting when the drink suddenly showed effects on the screen after 1 drink
Me as well! 😂
Did u still get robbed or nah
@@nathantheplayer4185blasting means shooting he started shooting them
arthurs face when he realizes is so funny dude
My first play through I never found these siblings. It’s crazy how much work rockstar put into dialogue that possibly would have never been found by players. They really put so much into this game. Greatest game of all time.
Idk why, but I've always been tickled by the way Arthur says "I found some bones, in an armoire, what's that about?" I'm not sure what it is about it, but his delivery of that line always makes me crack up.
Actually. Once you talk to them on the porch and they go inside. You can walk into the side door and loot the money box. 60.00. But you can go back out and run to the first tree on the hill behind the house and the money box will be refilled. You can do this over and over until you have as much cash as you want without playing out the scenario in the house. Then you can come back later in the game to stash money for john. But john cant pay his house off with it. He has to do the missions with sadie to pay off the bank. By then he's got the blackwater heist money. And not much to spend it on.
this fr? i jus got to the aberdeen farm n im not sure what to do i’ve read a bunch of different things
Wait I never found a money box where’s it at?
“WHERE ARE YOU TAKING ME?”
“Somewhere you ain’t gonna like.”
I know this is months later but YES I wish Arthur/John could've said this. Karma is a bitch, ain't it Tammy?
WHAT ARE YOU GOING TO DO WITH ME?
“SomeTHING you ain’t gonna like”
@@Kelley_0900 “oH nOoOo…”
@@QHalvorson”OH YEAH”
You can also let this encounter for right before the last mission where Arthur dies. If you do so and let them rob you, you can come back later as john and claim the money from behind the picture.
Omg. Thanks
Oh gee thanks for the fucking spoiler. Phukin 🤡
Yeah and if you do the cheats before saving Jack you can save John 9 million there
The look on Arthur's face is the most "im thinking rn" face ever
9:17 Arthur’s face is either confusion, fear, or both.
I love fact you are not using clickbait modded rdr2 thumbnails and just get to the point
W channel
Anything in this pig farm is still better than the swamp guy that blows out my Arthur's back!
😂😂😂
HE DOES WHAT TO ARTHUR???? WHICH GUY???
@@mileth2235 There a swamp dude that knocks you out, similar to these 2 pig farm fellers, but its implied that he's overly friendly.
@@mileth2235 his names sonny and he lives in a blue house in the swamps of the bayou
@@mileth2235 He is gay
17:37 okay the way Arthur jumped down those stairs got me howling 😂😂
To get in the secret room after the encounter. Shoot the glass on the window with a shotgub. Once its mostly gone you can just enter by climbing in.
Quale finestra? Dove si trova questa stanza?
@@SburatoIt’s at the side of the main house, on the left as you face the main building. If you try the door, it’ll be locked.
If you just walk up to any NPC with your lasso out and press O it will automatically tie them up without you having to actually catch them from afar.
Duh everybody knows this 🙄 weirdo
I wonder what would happen if you ate with them with no money on you. RDR almost always has dialogue prepared for specific scenarios, so it would be interesting to see if anything different happened.
They are cannibals, you would have been eat.
They still steal 20$ I think somehow
If you go to the top of the stairs and turn right, you'll uncover a loose floorboard close to the staircase itself. Inside are what look like several jewelry boxes but you can't collect them.
Qualcuno è riuscito a prenderli?
@@Sburatonot those, unfortunately
True. I guess it was only added to show that's what the couple were doing with the belongings of people they killed.
@@12227UserNamefancy seeing you here
@@Lowclasswarrior778
That's pretty damn odd. My old account on a DB forum was "LowClassSaiyan." Not to mention that you also have a picture of Tullece. What a coincidence.
I still think they be serving "human stew".
they're friends with the butcher in Rhodes, and it's said by npc's that the meat he sells is oddly suspicious lol
Ofcourse. Arthurs comment to the food "Its good. Different" and Brays "This meat is so tender" gives that away. Human meat is said to taste very different from others to our taste buds and is very soft and tender.
@@papakeno1105 I would try some negroid meat then
15:20 this had me cackling 😭the switch between menacing and kindness was hilarious
The attention to detail in this game is incredible... i could tell u how many times I was freaked out about how realistic and detailed small minor skits in the game was...
Make sure you get the loot in the side room attached to the house. You can't get in there from inside the house
The door was locked for me
@@franksaddictionhas to be during the encounter itself
I've had the game for years but had been focused on online, just now on my first story mode playthrough. I've met the camping guy on my way to the trapper, but haven't stopped by the pig farm yet. Probably been close many times stealing wagons but haven't triggered this...now I'm not sure if I want to. This game is truly immersive and and amazing...enjoyed watching!
Strangley enough I've never met the guy warning about them. I've beat this game well going on 3 times now.
This game is truly a masterpiece..
Only bad part is Arthur dying 😔
@@MODZGAMINGYTBro maybe he is in Chapter 5 or someting
@eliasghb Not sure what that has to do with anything but okay 🤨
@@MODZGAMINGYT Spoiler
@@eliasghb I met him in chapter 2
What I’m really surprised about is Arthur not asking where the meat came from for the stew? Momma? As far as the Benders go none of them were related to one another so there was no insest involved but a sad end to anyone staying with them.
I love how you can see Arthur at 9:15 slowly connecting the dots
The Morningstar steamboat was originally intended to serve as a floating casino. Evidence of this can be seen in the "Life in the West" pre-release trailer, and also in the dialogue exchanged between John Marston and Elizabeth Thornton during the Stranger mission "The Wronged Woman", wherein she says "I knew his frequenting that gambling boat would be the death of him." However, the Korrigan serves this purpose in Red Dead Redemption 2 and there's even an advertisement for the boat at the docks in Blackwater - the ferry hails from here to several other destinations, which could indicate that Rockstar retconned this cut element in using the Korrigan.
I died when I saw Arthur’s face once he realized they were siblings 🤣
You can actually get the loot from the secret room if you blow the window open with dynamite or bullets
you can get the secret room to unlock if you let the big guy invite you inside
Arthur’s face when he realized they are family was hilarious 😂😂 he was a 100% disgusted
Anyone else stay in chapter 2 and just roam and hunt/collect etc and do storyline missions very sparingly?
My first time playing and on chapter 2 .but all i donis side missions. Says 42% 😂 i cant help it i play all adventure games like this
@@ThaSenseiMayne same. I do it with this and Skyrim especially.
Same, I love doing every little thing in these kind of games!
yep and I leave Micah sitting in strawberry jail
@@tayyan378 he’s still there lol. I’m trying to get the Missouri Fox Trotter from the horse photo mission. Then I still have a mission with Javier and the train robbery with John etc. I’ve never played this before but I love it and don’t want it to end.
Let pig farmers rob you late in chapter 6. Then go back as John in Epilogue. And reclaim your money behind the picture of mamma. It’s better than loosing it.
Definitely One of the most disturbing random encounters in RDR2, probably just as disturbing or maybe a little less so compared to Edmund Lowry Jr. Either way the Aberdeen’s are freaks.
I think it’s even more disturbing!
Thats why I skipped it lol
It saddens me how much love went into this game, then was abandoned for corporate greed.
Greed is killing the gaming industry..... actually no the entire world at this pont
On my last playthrough as Dark Arthur, I just started robbing the house while Tammy was getting ready. Int he end, Bray got mad and tried to throw me out at gunpoint. I chopped them up with my trusty machete instead of shooting them. Who's the pycho now, eh?
I had such a bad gut feeling about these two that I left before even touching my plate lol
Bro not even lying, I know exactly how Arthur feels being invited to someone’s home you’ve never been to and feeling super uncomfortable. Cause it happened to me when I was invited to a Mormon church and then was invited to a Mormon family home for dinner and it was the scariest house I’ve ever been too. They had a fake severed human head behind there fence in the backyard 😳😳😳
Damn there's some sick and twisted people where you're from.
I wonder what happens to Tammy after you threw her in the pit and walk away. Like revisiting the pit a few days later. Is there a decomposing corpse of Tammy or does she just despawn? Someone here that tried this?
I was wondering that too
I suppose she'd escape? Afaik everyone that's hogtied manages to escape after a minute or so of being left alone
@@marliesstorm7181 soooo, after my 3th playtrough I tried this. She just despawns...
Nah she just disappears and the pit is in default mode
Didn't expect so many details in just 1 mission. I took the witch to their victim's grave and burned her with molotov
I watched this video yesterday and I was amazed in all the things you can do, I just went back there and killed them without trying to hog tie them or anything. Today as i was passing by I saw the house and decided to enter and you can see that the place is trashed and some furniture is missing. Another thing I want to mention is that there is a way to get in the locked room through the windows. You just need to shoot the window frame and you can easily get in, the locked box is there and it has some money in it. Hope this helps.
I like how he's such a tub of lard to the point you can't lasso him
so there's just one thing i never see in all the thousand people covering the aberdeen farm and it's what would happen if you just hogtie Tammy and bring her to the closest sheriff before Bray intervenes
I did this, while a deputy? And I got in trouble for "kidnapping" her.. I did kill Bray tho, but he's quite spry for a big fellow! Hard to imagine NOT killing him and still surviving urself.. Hes a quick shot too..
@@savannahpaige3670 I got mistaken for "kidnapping" a thief in an alleyway in Saint Denis one time. I was gonna take him to the police station, but I guess it was enough to just intervene lol
I literally cannot believe I watched this entire thing. Sick. The Bloody Binder Family, that's wild.
Superb !!! Loved learning new dialogue !!! Thanks RedDB 😊😊👍🏻👍🏻
omg now I want to go back and bring them the body that was on top of Arthur, just to see what they'll do
Holy shit I didn't even think about doing that, that's incredible! I wonder if Rockstar considered that hypothesis
I literally did this yesterday they don't even acknowledge it 😢
@@natedoggm89 fuckkk... Thanks for trying it out though, my save was lost a long time ago
There’s a real story in Australia about the woman who killed her boyfriend .they lived Aberdeen and she worked at a pig farm she cut him up and made dinner with him to serve and set the table I don’t remember who the plates were for .
I remember that too, the plates of "food" was for his kids, she must have really hated him or them.
I had NO idea how much more there was if you left and came back. Just, wow. That journal was intense.
I had that camper encounter one time! As soon as he said that he could tell I wasn't a bad man I blew his leg off with a shotgun. 😂
You're evil. I just robbed his camp. Like, four times. He is a slow learner.
@@cain666 Sounds like a VERY slow learner 😂
@@cain666there's literally nothing to learn when you're getting frame to look like something but everyone in the world could easily hate and get paid so good for it
There’s also a connection between the couple and the Rhodes butcher. Try shooting at the couple then have them follow you to Rhodes. Just don’t let them get to close to you or shoot you or your horse too much.
What even happens?
What happens?
What happens brother?
cuéntanos hermano que pasa
Nothing happens
Just tried it
Yes i know im naive
I like to think this whole encounter is inspired by the opening scene of the last episode of season one of True Detective.
What about all the jewelry stashed under the floorboards upstairs? If u crouch down along the banister by the stairs in the same room as the bones,u can flip up a board revealing what looks like jewelry boxes u can't grab. Always wanted to know why this is there. Let me know.
You can grab them.
Its probably the parents rings and jewelry if they had any
20:20 The way Arthur moved he was like "Well no shit." 😂😂😂
You can get some additional dialogue by stealing from them. Tammy wont mind if you go through her dresser draws, You can take a couple canned goods from downstairs and the big guy will be ok with it. But take to much and he will tell you to leave the house.
Great Video again! BTW how did you get that Vest?
No its legend of the east vest you need to complete all challenges to get it
This is honestly the only game where you can replay it like 6 times and find new things that change the playthrough
11:31 "That's what Pa used to say." That was the first line that creeped me out. For whatever reason, I am so desensitised to incest among siblings at this point.
Desenstised?
@@Haven28 As in, I see it so much in media that it just doesn't shock me anymore.
9:15 is probably the most I've ever had to laugh in this game
It’s not a mission it’s a random encounter
“Fun” Fact: If you read the names of the Bender Family's(Aberdeen Pig Farm in Rdr2) victims you can find the name Abigail Roberts killed in December 1872.
Arthur and/or John's thousand yard stare when they realize they're brother and sister is one of the funniest moments in the game.
I like how you can make a lot of money with Arthur and then get yourself robbed by these inbred hillbilly siblings in the final chapter, to just come back as John and find the home empty and take all that cash from behind the picture, that they took from our boy. That's a decent move to immediately feel free to get whatever you want from the start as John and don't have to hustle for your life until getting Micah's money at the end.
I woke up in the pig pit without any clothing!
This was amazing!!! I had absolutely no idea that Rockstar put THIS much detail into the pig farm. I'm about to do a third play through, and I can't wait to try all if these
This is amazing. My next playthrough im going low honor Arthur and im definitely going to try all these outcomes
20:00-You dont have to leave them alive to get this interaction.
It definitely seems to be loosely based on the Bender family. Although, unlike in the game here, the Benders were a Germanic family of four (Ma, Pa and the two siblings) and the brother and sister were said to be very attractive. There are some people that speculate that the murderous Kelly family were the same people simply using different names. But there's no real concrete evidence to back this up. In fact, there were actually several supposed run ins with the Benders after they went on the run, but none of these could be verified either. In many of these claims some of the family members either eventually ran into the law or ran into bandits and were killed as a result. It's not clear as to what really happened to them. Or perhaps they got away with their crimes.
The work put into this game is insane
When i found the place in online and saw there was a mission inside i whistled my horse and rode like i never had before.
In story mode, after the first drink from their mix, i got up and blew both of them away with my shotgun. Worst part is Arthur certainly ate human flesh there.
You can hogtie npc without throwing a lasso to them, just rush to him/her (press B/O) then hogtie(B/O)
i don't think you can hogtie the dude, i think he's too fat
Body odour
I think it was human meat from previous visitors. Arthur said it’s different lol
My impression was they were feeding their guests the flesh of previous guests…..
The look on Arthur's face when he finds out they are brother and sister at 9:16. LOL
I wondered if this was based in the Bloody Benders. I was driving one day through Kansas and got tired. I pulled over at a historic placard near Big Hill KS. It was about the Benders and they lived near that marker. It kind of freaked me out so I was wide awake and left. 30 some years later I’ve never been back. I talked to everyone about it just didn’t feel like driving out of the way to go see it again.
It’s crazy how rockstar put so much time into the details, and knew every possibility that the players would try. What a masterpiece
BRUHH THE FACE OF ARTHUR REALSING IS TOO GOOD
Makes the Lady even more sexy
I love Rockstar games. They add small little encounters and depth, to the gameplay and story. I used to ask my mom for this game so much when I was 8. Now I have the game now that I’m slightly older, I have seen this encounter in chapter 2 and 3
Lmao I just replayed this part having remember what happened before, and instantly molotoved them both 😂😂
All of Arthur’s expressions and reactions in this sequence are proof he’s one of the funniest characters when the game isn’t depressing
The first part is never something I see missed tbh. I feel like everyone finds that, he's basically right next to the main road. Not even back behind trees. But some good ones here for sure
You appear to have a fortune to rival Leviticus Cornwall.
10:48 "Two bullets what's the worst that can happen?"
Im about to do 2nd run through. 1st one was high honor. 2nd one will be an alternate reality.
Just so you know, you dont have to go through the encounter to get the money in the secret room. You can go anytime, just the door is locked, so blow out the window to the right of the door and you an crawl through and get the money from the safety box
I haven’t gone into the house yet, they invited me in but I just rode off. Next time I went by, I stood on a barrel or something outside the window big boy is writing by. Unfortunately he doesn’t/didn’t notice me. I’m hoping to save Arthur’s $$ for John in the end, but I’ll most likely just go in blasting. 😂🤷🏽♂️
The best cut scene is this one where Arthur’s eyes go back and forth between them with a “WTF” look on his face.