Greetings from #yeg, Dr. McGill! I love how he keeps coming back to evidence-based practice and individual pattern recognition over simplistic silver-bullet pathogenesis. I'm just graduating from an acupuncture program and this speaks to how we've been trained to look at health. So much to learn in this space.
I admire Stu’s research, but it may only be pertinent after ruling out the Derangement (McKenzie terms). He talks poorly about McKenzie but does not practice this himself. If he did then he would know that symptomatic responses alone are not the only thing that matter. There are also motion, strength, and nerve tension baselines. 1 “floppy push up” may hurt more. But the increased pain does not remain more than a few seconds. 20-30 repetition may cause the pain to feel better. It also may not, but motion and nerve tension is improved…symptoms are likely to follow in a few days. Stu does not address repeated motions. Stu does not address temporary increases of pain that improve motion, strength, and nerve tension over time. Stu does not address the lateral component of a derangement (McKenzie terms). Extension may not work. It may make pain, motion, and nerve tension worse. In those cases a lateral shearing move as he calls it- Side Glide for McKenzie trained people- will likely work better. It may result in decreased pain, and increased motion over time. Other moves may also need to be tested. Stu’s research is only valid if you take these things off the table. It is an inconvenient truth.
Dr. Stuart McGill is such a legend. So eloquent talking about it.
Thank you for this!
🙌🙌
Greetings from #yeg, Dr. McGill!
I love how he keeps coming back to evidence-based practice and individual pattern recognition over simplistic silver-bullet pathogenesis. I'm just graduating from an acupuncture program and this speaks to how we've been trained to look at health. So much to learn in this space.
How do i get in touch with the whiplash doctor
Appreciate the professionals using our models. :) Thank you
I admire Stu’s research, but it may only be pertinent after ruling out the Derangement (McKenzie terms). He talks poorly about McKenzie but does not practice this himself. If he did then he would know that symptomatic responses alone are not the only thing that matter. There are also motion, strength, and nerve tension baselines. 1 “floppy push up” may hurt more. But the increased pain does not remain more than a few seconds. 20-30 repetition may cause the pain to feel better. It also may not, but motion and nerve tension is improved…symptoms are likely to follow in a few days. Stu does not address repeated motions. Stu does not address temporary increases of pain that improve motion, strength, and nerve tension over time.
Stu does not address the lateral component of a derangement (McKenzie terms). Extension may not work. It may make pain, motion, and nerve tension worse. In those cases a lateral shearing move as he calls it- Side Glide for McKenzie trained people- will likely work better. It may result in decreased pain, and increased motion over time. Other moves may also need to be tested.
Stu’s research is only valid if you take these things off the table. It is an inconvenient truth.
Thank you for sharing your opinion!!
I don't think you fully understand the mcgill method.
@@mikemacdonald7778what do you think I’m misunderstanding so I may learn. I use Stu’s stuff along when patients are not derangements.
Ca 10 00 facet led