Purani movie " Seema " mein Manna de ka gaana - tu pyar ka sagar hai aur Rafi sahab ka gaana - kahan ja raha hai tu...Bhale hi Manna de ji ko classical gaane mein Rafi sahab se zyada maharat hasil thi, lekin khas baat to ye hai ki play back singing me Rafi sahab se koi bhi singer chahe Mannade ji rahe hon zyada apna maqam nahi bana saka
@@josephalbert8441 are yaar aap hame nahi jante ho, musalman log humko kahte hain ki tum mazhab se bahar ho, mai kiski maanu aaki jisne mujhe dekha hi nahi, ya jisne mujhe dekha hai
Shanker Jaikishen + Mohommad Rafi Saheb...the most ever lethal combination. No one before them , no one after them. Arijit singh and company...suun lo 🤗🤗🤗🤗🤗🤗🤗🤗
I always felt that Manna Da sang semi-classical better than Rafi Sahib. But to my surprise, I saw an O.P. Nayyar interview where he is talking about one of his semi-classic songs, a duet sang by both the singers, and he was full of praise for Rafi Sahib and said, "see how relaxed he is in this song compared to the other singer". Well, I guess, us laymen do not know all the nuances of the classic singing.
Ruk se zara nakab aur gham utha ne ke liye both songs of Rafi sahab are beutiful hit and outstanding for ever where manna Dey songs not so successful Rafi is a sun where no light doesn't exist
Music Director SHRI SANKAR JAIKISAN were a greatest Musician of the FILM INDUSTRY as well as Singers Shri Mannade sir, Shri Mohammed Rafi Sir both were also the great Singers of that time So don't Think who are the best but no doubt both were great in their Situation. THANKS SIR.♥️🙏🙏
Both were great singers no doubt. However Rafi Saheb was the biggest male playback singer and Manna Dey saheb also mentioned this in his interviews that nobody could take Rafi saheb's place. In Mere Huzoor also , Rafi saheb was the main singer and he sang all the romantic songs for both Jeetendra and Raj Kumar.
Well we all know that Rafi Saheb & Manna D j were both top singer's.but Rafi Saheb,s voice suited all hero,s were Manna de,s voice was limited suited to many hero,s.at last Rafi Saheb,s voice was 100 % better then Manna de ji voice
Manna Dey saheb ek behtreen classical singer hain magar Raj Kumar ji ko un ki awaz match nahi kar rahi۔ Raj kumar ji ko screen per dekh kar Ragi Saheb ki awaaz yaad aa jaati hai۔
ओ पी नैय्यर के बारे मे भी कोई किस्सा बताये खासकर उनकी जो बी आर चोपड़ा से अनबन हुई थी नया दौर फ़िल्म के प्रीमियर के समय उसके बाद दोनों ने कभी साथ मे काम नही किया
Please throw more light on classical duet sung by Mohammad Rafi and Mannà dey the song is Man ki pyaas bhujaane aayi film name I think Kalpana music SJ
“Pooja” film me Rafi Saab kya classical gaya tha, Krishna Chonkar ke sath. Shankar Jaikishan ke music me. Aap suniye, kya gaya Rafi Saab. “Room jhoom ke bajao”.
❤ aapka Mohammed Rafi ke sath manna de ka compare karna mujhe achcha nahin Laga manna dene 500 geet hi gaye honge jindagi ke safar mein lekin Mohammed Rafi ne 26000 Geet Gaye Hain to aisi agar dekha jaaye to mahan gayak to Mohammed Rafi hi sabit hue Na
Full classical me Rafiji Manna De se compete nahi kar sakte thhe, jinhone Bhimsen Joshi se jugalbandi ki thi Basant Bahar me. Durbhagypurn hai ki unki prathiba ka purn upyog nahi hua, sirf classical type aur comedy songs unhe mile.
Ye gaana pahle rafi sab ko diya gYa Rafi sab gate gate ruk gaye aur kaha Ye gana agar manna dey gayenge to acha rahega sh jai ne man li unki baat Phir manna dey ye gaaya Hum ne suna hai Sach hai kya
TARAH TARAH KI VARIETY TO SIRF RAFI SAHAB KE PASS HI HAI KISHORE SAHAB KE YHAN KUCH VARIETY THY MANNA SAHAB MUKESH SAHAB TALAT SAHAB EK AAWAZ KE ACCHE GAYEK THEY FILM BASANT BAHAR SHANKER JAI KISHAN BHIM SEN JOSHI SAHAB KE SATH MANNA DAY SAHAB SONG KETKI GULAB JUHI CHAPAK BN YE KOI MAMULI BAAT NAHIN NAME SUN KR HI DHILA PD JAYEGA GAYEK
Your content is not very impressive. What is your object to make this episode, I failed to understand. As a listener, we enjoy good lyrics and it's presentation during the Golder era of the Indian film industry. I don't know, why some content creators bring such issues, like who is the best or better? It is an individual choice. Your scripting is very poor and you fumble many times. Your research is also primitive. I am viewing your vdo and a subscriber to your channel. My observations apply to many of your vdos. I don't find very great information in your content. It is average and easily accessible on the net. I appreciate your efforts and do not want to discourage you. But to improve further, you should take extra efforts to make your shows more informative with, narrative, history, investigation and some gossip too to make it more lucid.😊🌹👍
Md sang the song composed by bengali poet kaji naajurul Islam, copied by s d & was easy to expose because of bengali thoughts as like when Mr sang of Bahadur Shah & Mirza Ghalib was easy to expose. In my opinio had Mr sang the song would have been more better to be like as well other songs as Mr was the perfect singer to had been the right choice. Don't think that I don't like Md but truly say that Md was greatest for ever if I am not wrong.
जो कहना है वो छोङ कर बाकी सब आप कह रहे हैं..मेरे हुजूर फिल्म की बात करनी है तो वहीं करो,बाकी बीस फिल्मों की बात घुसा कर वीडियो लम्बा करने की कोशिश कर रहे हो,शंकर जयकिशन की बात उन्हीं तक रखना चाहिये,बाकी बकवास है
“Pooja” film me Rafi Saab kya classical gaya tha, Krishna Chonkar ke sath. Shankar Jaikishan ke music me. Aap suniye, kya gaya Rafi Saab. “Room jhoom ke bajao”.
Magical singers.....
Rafi sahab nd Mannadey sahab....kiya memorable songs ka ziker kiya ap ney....maza agia.....
Nice clip
Rafi sahab ko mera Salam Namashkar Sat Sat Naman Allah Hafiz hai ji ❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤
@@lallitasingh616 hamne apke comments Rafi sahab ke liye bahut baar dekhe hain, bahut achchha laga, apko mera salaam
Apko bhi bahut bahut salam dher saari duayen ♥️
Purani movie " Seema " mein Manna de ka gaana - tu pyar ka sagar hai aur Rafi sahab ka gaana - kahan ja raha hai tu...Bhale hi Manna de ji ko classical gaane mein Rafi sahab se zyada maharat hasil thi, lekin khas baat to ye hai ki play back singing me Rafi sahab se koi bhi singer chahe Mannade ji rahe hon zyada apna maqam nahi bana saka
Both great singers ,, 🙏
@@vijayakrishnannair yes
Tĥoda mazhabi soch se bahar niklo yaar rafi sahab muslim nahi hote to itni tarif nahi krte ghum phir ke rafi me atak jaate ho
@@josephalbert8441 are yaar aap hame nahi jante ho, musalman log humko kahte hain ki tum mazhab se bahar ho, mai kiski maanu aaki jisne mujhe dekha hi nahi, ya jisne mujhe dekha hai
khud mannade ne kaha. tha rafi se koi nahi jeet sakta.😊
Shanker Jaikishen + Mohommad Rafi Saheb...the most ever lethal combination. No one before them , no one after them. Arijit singh and company...suun lo 🤗🤗🤗🤗🤗🤗🤗🤗
Rafi sahab best song
Mohd Rafi is best Manna Dey also good
Shankar Jaikishan ne sabhi singer ko nyaa diye hain
My all time favourite
I always felt that Manna Da sang semi-classical better than Rafi Sahib. But to my surprise, I saw an O.P. Nayyar interview where he is talking about one of his semi-classic songs, a duet sang by both the singers, and he was full of praise for Rafi Sahib and said, "see how relaxed he is in this song compared to the other singer". Well, I guess, us laymen do not know all the nuances of the classic singing.
Ruk se zara nakab aur gham utha ne ke liye both songs of Rafi sahab are beutiful hit and outstanding for ever where manna Dey songs not so successful Rafi is a sun where no light doesn't exist
Shankar Jaikishan ji ne jo sangeet diya woh lajawaab hai
Shanker Jaikishan Mahan Sangeethkar Hai kushi Ke Gane Ho Dukh Ke Gane Classical Gane Ho Pura Talent Lagake Gana Banathe Hai
Both rafi sahib n manna de were excellent singers, the only difference in them is the voice quality.Rafi sahib voice is sweeter n younger
Lata.rafi.jaisa.koie.gayk.nahi.hua
Music Director SHRI SANKAR JAIKISAN were a greatest Musician of the FILM INDUSTRY as well as Singers Shri Mannade sir, Shri Mohammed Rafi Sir both were also the great Singers of that time So don't Think who are the best but no doubt both were great in their Situation.
THANKS SIR.♥️🙏🙏
Dono hi gane bhahut khubsurat hai Sameer Kolkata.
Both were great singers no doubt. However Rafi Saheb was the biggest male playback singer and Manna Dey saheb also mentioned this in his interviews that nobody could take Rafi saheb's place. In Mere Huzoor also , Rafi saheb was the main singer and he sang all the romantic songs for both Jeetendra and Raj Kumar.
Manna Da got award for his song, and Music was scored under Raag Darbari.
Subhash - USA
❤ DHANYAWAD ❤
रफी साहब और मन्ना डे दोनो ही धुरंधर गायक थे।दोनो के लिए भगवान से प्रार्थना है।
@@ArunKumar-tk3xb you are absolutely right, dear.
Rafi sab Manna dey. Sab beautiful duet in Sacchai music by Shankar jaikishan
Excellent sir 👍💐
Thank you so much. Keep watching
I ever like the rafijl and as l listion.mandaji in this movi l donot know whom to say best.
Mohammd Rafi sahabkis 12:18
Rafi sahib bhi ustad baray ghulam Ali say seekhnay howay thay
Well we all know that Rafi Saheb & Manna D j were both top singer's.but Rafi Saheb,s voice suited all hero,s were Manna de,s voice was limited suited to many hero,s.at last Rafi Saheb,s voice was 100 % better then Manna de ji voice
Manna Dey got national award for this.
"दुनिया मुझे सुनती है और मैं मन्ना को",ये रफी साहब का कहना है
Jii
मन्ना दा ने भी कहा था जो रफी कर सकते हैं वह हम नहीं !
Both are great
Shankar jaikisan was a school of music
Rafi sahab best singer koi mukabla nahi
Bas Kami he Bharat Ratn ki vo bahut pahle hi mil Jana chahiye tha lakin afsos
Absolutely right
SIR FARAZ SIR AAJ BHI MAN ROTA HAI MAHAN AATMAO KE LIYE
Manna Dey saheb ek behtreen classical singer hain magar Raj Kumar ji ko un ki awaz match nahi kar rahi۔ Raj kumar ji ko screen per dekh kar Ragi Saheb ki awaaz yaad aa jaati hai۔
ओ पी नैय्यर के बारे मे भी कोई किस्सा बताये खासकर उनकी जो बी आर चोपड़ा से अनबन हुई थी नया दौर फ़िल्म के प्रीमियर के समय
उसके बाद दोनों ने कभी साथ मे काम नही किया
Ji
Please throw more light on classical duet sung by Mohammad Rafi and Mannà dey the song is Man ki pyaas bhujaane aayi film name I think Kalpana music SJ
We have made a program
नाचे मन मोरा इतना हाई पिच का गाना में रही साहब का इंप्रेशन ठराव आवाज का टेक्सचेटर कमल का 2 गाने में 2 तरह की आवाज।
“Pooja” film me Rafi Saab kya classical gaya tha, Krishna Chonkar ke sath. Shankar Jaikishan ke music me. Aap suniye, kya gaya Rafi Saab. “Room jhoom ke bajao”.
Aap antara ya mukhra jaroor suna diya kare
Ji
❤ aapka Mohammed Rafi ke sath manna de ka compare karna mujhe achcha nahin Laga manna dene 500 geet hi gaye honge jindagi ke safar mein lekin Mohammed Rafi ne 26000 Geet Gaye Hain to aisi agar dekha jaaye to mahan gayak to Mohammed Rafi hi sabit hue Na
No comparison is made
Please faraz bhai saira banu ji ki aur koi story par episode banayeh please
आप क्या कहना चाह रहे समझ नहीं आ रहा
Rafi very very better than manna
Manna Dey the king of classical songs❤❤❤❤❤
Full classical me Rafiji Manna De se compete nahi kar sakte thhe, jinhone Bhimsen Joshi se jugalbandi ki thi Basant Bahar me.
Durbhagypurn hai ki unki prathiba ka purn upyog nahi hua, sirf classical type aur comedy songs unhe mile.
Ye gaana pahle rafi sab ko diya gYa
Rafi sab gate gate ruk gaye aur kaha
Ye gana agar manna dey gayenge to acha rahega sh jai ne man li unki baat
Phir manna dey ye gaaya
Hum ne suna hai Sach hai kya
TARAH TARAH KI VARIETY TO SIRF RAFI SAHAB KE PASS HI HAI
KISHORE SAHAB KE YHAN KUCH VARIETY THY MANNA SAHAB MUKESH SAHAB TALAT SAHAB EK AAWAZ KE ACCHE GAYEK THEY
FILM BASANT BAHAR SHANKER JAI KISHAN BHIM SEN JOSHI SAHAB KE SATH MANNA DAY SAHAB SONG KETKI GULAB JUHI CHAPAK BN YE KOI MAMULI BAAT NAHIN
NAME SUN KR HI DHILA PD JAYEGA GAYEK
Aap kehena keya chaata hai ?
आप नहीं जानते कि जरूरत से ज्यादा बोल रहे हैं?😊
Faraz Sahab Namaskar ki jagah Aadab kiyun nahi Karter Namaskar ka Matlab samajhte ho. Mai tum hare samne jhukta hoon
Manna Dey sahab bhi classical music ke master the
Your content is not very impressive. What is your object to make this episode, I failed to understand.
As a listener, we enjoy good lyrics and it's presentation during the Golder era of the Indian film industry.
I don't know, why some content creators bring such issues, like who is the best or better?
It is an individual choice.
Your scripting is very poor and you fumble many times. Your research is also primitive.
I am viewing your vdo and a subscriber to your channel. My observations apply to many of your vdos. I don't find very great information in your content. It is average and easily accessible on the net.
I appreciate your efforts and do not want to discourage you. But to improve further, you should take extra efforts to make your shows more informative with, narrative, history, investigation and some gossip too to make it more lucid.😊🌹👍
Are bhai pishle janam mai ek tan 2 beju bawarathe
Md sang the song composed by bengali poet kaji naajurul Islam, copied by s d & was easy to expose because of bengali thoughts as like when Mr sang of Bahadur Shah & Mirza Ghalib was easy to expose.
In my opinio had Mr sang the song would have been more better to be like as well other songs as Mr was the perfect singer to had been the right choice. Don't think that I don't like Md but truly say that Md was greatest for ever if I am not wrong.
Funny post . Your intention is just to create a controversial post.
जो कहना है वो छोङ कर बाकी सब आप कह रहे हैं..मेरे हुजूर फिल्म की बात करनी है तो वहीं करो,बाकी बीस फिल्मों की बात घुसा कर वीडियो लम्बा करने की कोशिश कर रहे हो,शंकर जयकिशन की बात उन्हीं तक रखना चाहिये,बाकी बकवास है
Garaz Aadab Salam karne ko Sharam lag ti hai kya
“Pooja” film me Rafi Saab kya classical gaya tha, Krishna Chonkar ke sath. Shankar Jaikishan ke music me. Aap suniye, kya gaya Rafi Saab. “Room jhoom ke bajao”.