Это видео недоступно.
Сожалеем об этом.

Rebel Yell: Europe's Biggest U.S. Civil War Reenactment​

Поделиться
HTML-код
  • Опубликовано: 4 июн 2019
  • Every year, hundreds of people from across Europe and North America converge on a military base in Germany to re-fight a battle from the U.S. Civil War. There's cavalry, artillery, soldiers, and civilians, with meticulous attention to detail right down to the last button.
    Originally published at - www.rferl.org/a/us-civil-war-...

Комментарии • 382

  • @Zazz_Blammymatazz
    @Zazz_Blammymatazz 4 года назад +295

    It's surreal seeing Europeans reenact the US Civil War. But, as an American, I also find it flattering.

    • @normajeanmorrissey2903
      @normajeanmorrissey2903 4 года назад +2

      Pleasr read my note about Europeans who fought and now reenact! Norma Jean Morrissey

    • @cheshire4856
      @cheshire4856 3 года назад +3

      Same.

    • @SStupendous
      @SStupendous 3 года назад +6

      @@normajeanmorrissey2903 You really don't need to put your name on your comment, it's there already.
      -StupendousWillStudios

    • @AeussersteKraft
      @AeussersteKraft 3 года назад +5

      Not really surprising. E.g. every tenth Union soldier was a German immigrant. Even today there exist some family ties. Back then a lot of these German-American soldiers saw in the American civil war a continuation of their failed revolutions against European monarchies in 1848/49, because they thought that birth should not define one's fate.

    • @SStupendous
      @SStupendous 3 года назад +1

      @@AeussersteKraft Every 10th was also a Black. Don't know where these facts come from. It was descended from immigrants in general, not actual immigrants, or specifically Germans.

  • @jamiesnack
    @jamiesnack 5 лет назад +340

    It's super cool seeing Europeans interested in my country's history, i love reenactment!

    • @fidgetylamb8133
      @fidgetylamb8133 4 года назад +8

      “Our” country’s history

    • @vlogmancsa8453
      @vlogmancsa8453 4 года назад +8

      @Fidgety Lamb now it’s starting to sound like Russia 🤔

    • @Benjamin-1776
      @Benjamin-1776 4 года назад +2

      Fidgety Lamb, you don’t know English too well do you?

    • @Benjamin-1776
      @Benjamin-1776 4 года назад +3

      Norma jean Morrissey, it’s history, other people can be interested in history from different countries. I find it better for them to be interested in our history than to make fun of our country, which many Europeans do.

    • @normajeanmorrissey2903
      @normajeanmorrissey2903 4 года назад

      @@Benjamin-1776 Great perspective! Norma Jean Morrissey

  • @rabbisoros7811
    @rabbisoros7811 3 года назад +97

    As a reenactor I find this both confusing and very cool at the same time

  • @sats2407
    @sats2407 Год назад +43

    Union sdiers speaking German is actually accurate

    • @PaulTippit-kn1fj
      @PaulTippit-kn1fj 4 месяца назад +4

      Lots of Deutsch. A Confederate company from Texas was made entirely of German speakers and fought in the Rio Grande valley in New Mexico.

    • @zvezda4701
      @zvezda4701 19 дней назад

      1848 UNION GANG ARISE

  • @West_Coast_Mainline
    @West_Coast_Mainline Год назад +13

    Dang, the European confederate reenactors are wearing the high quality uniforms

  • @maxasaurus3008
    @maxasaurus3008 9 месяцев назад +10

    As a bona-fide American Civil War re-enactor I’m tickled pink those boys are out there! They look great!

  • @johnnychaos152
    @johnnychaos152 5 лет назад +109

    It's kind of sad when Europeans have more interest in American history than Americans do! I've been a reenactor here in the States since 1992 and we used to have THOUSANDS of folks show up at events across the country. We used to get invited regularly to do presentations for schools and what not. These days the numbers drop a little more each year and it's blasphemy to even consider bringing schools into it. A large part of that is due to the youth just not having any interest. They teach nothing of it in school except for the slavery aspect and if it's not on a computer screen then it's evidently just stupid. Another huge reason is that political correctness has taken its toll. I portray soldiers from both sides but I can't put on the gray uniform these days without someone calling me a racist. I had ancestors that fought on both sides and I've researched them in great detail. For the record, my Confederate ancestor was a dirt poor dock worker and could barely afford to feed his family much less own slaves. He lived in Virginia and joined the Army to keep his wife and children from starving and being homeless. Anyway, now we have almost as many protesters showing up as we do reenactors and sadly there's been two events recently that were canceled due to bomb threats. I've been to Germany before and I'd love to find my way back someday to participate in a reenactment.

    • @smhmay1973
      @smhmay1973 5 лет назад +10

      It's a shame reenactors can't be turned loose on those protesters. They wouldn't be so brave then. Thank You for what you do.

    • @nohrii023
      @nohrii023 4 года назад +8

      I thought it is the opposite. NW Reenactors got a maximum of 7,000 actors on the field, it was 2013 in Leipzig (1813 Völkerschlacht) and you guys in america had 5x more in Gettysburg.

    • @blackcatproductions4533
      @blackcatproductions4533 4 года назад +7

      Im a son of the confederate and this is so true. My 13 year old peers do not understand the meaning of the grey uniform and call me racist for recalling my heritage. These liberals have ruined my school system. I once allowed my great grandfather, the son of a confederate (my great great grandfather) to come into school and teach the class about the war and old portraits we have. Kids have been bullying me calling me a racist no good pig who deserves to end up like my great great grand daddy, in a hole dead. I have been threatened and told to not come to school anymore. It saddens me how ignorant people can be towards the confederacy. The war was not fought for slavery but rather to split into our country. The battles at Kennesaw and Chattanooga have resided and no longer happen due to the liberal agenda.

    • @warweasel2832
      @warweasel2832 4 года назад +2

      You realize most young people don't get more than two or three days off a year? Not to mention the cost of putting together a historical uniform and rifle, as well as a plane ticket and hotel room every. I personally know many people that would LOVE to participate, but they can barely make ends meet as it is.

    • @fidgetylamb8133
      @fidgetylamb8133 4 года назад +1

      I’m 16 years old and I want to be part of an reenactment. Man that would be awesome. And such an experience

  • @nohrii023
    @nohrii023 4 года назад +47

    Aaah. This is what my Corporal of the 45th NY talked about... And I missed it... because of napoleonic reenactment event.

    • @atune2682
      @atune2682 4 года назад

      noohri bist dus haha?! :D

  • @confederatewarrior3820
    @confederatewarrior3820 3 года назад +22

    I love re-enactments, especially of the civil war. I’m from London but I really do hope they do some other here.

  • @jonathanjonnylightning718
    @jonathanjonnylightning718 4 года назад +20

    I have to give all respect to europe on this one. I honestly didnt think you guys gave a shit about American history but in reality we have to hand it to you guys we wouldnt be a country without you. Thanks to Spain, Italy, England, France, Russia amd the imigrants from Ireland, Germany, Scotland.

  • @rc59191
    @rc59191 3 года назад +33

    Makes me happy seeing Europeans reenact our history. Met a guy from the UK that reenacts my 3rd great grandpas unit the Pennsylvania Bucktails. Wish more of my generation would get involved in reenacting they should give you a free year of college for every year of reenacting or public service as an incentive.

    • @definitely_not_Hirohito
      @definitely_not_Hirohito 2 месяца назад

      Folks can't just hand out free college, especially to get you to do a hobby.

    • @rc59191
      @rc59191 2 месяца назад

      @@definitely_not_Hirohito teaching history isn't a hobby

    • @definitely_not_Hirohito
      @definitely_not_Hirohito 2 месяца назад

      @@rc59191 Reenacting/ Living History IS a hobby.

    • @rc59191
      @rc59191 2 месяца назад

      @@definitely_not_Hirohito believe whatever you want to dude

    • @definitely_not_Hirohito
      @definitely_not_Hirohito 2 месяца назад

      @@rc59191 Dude, I'm a reenactor and I assure you it's not a job, it costs thousands of dollars. That's a large part of why not that many young people are in it.

  • @russellwilliams3209
    @russellwilliams3209 2 года назад +6

    One thing that is repeatedly missed or ignored when reenacting the civil war in America is the fife and drum, so to hear it here is amazing! Very well done!

  • @robertsilva8097
    @robertsilva8097 4 года назад +124

    You can have the Confederate flag in German but not the other flag

    • @ben9262
      @ben9262 3 года назад +4

      lol

    • @benozzy003
      @benozzy003 3 года назад +10

      Ya they even tried to melt down a church bell bc it was commissioned by the natzis and had a swastika on it

    • @rc59191
      @rc59191 3 года назад +32

      I'm so sick of people comparing the Swastika flag to the Confederate flag. The Confederacy wasnt carrying out mass genocide or murdering their way across a continent murdering everyone that wasnt Aryan. More crimes and atrocities were committed under the US flag but that's ok.

    • @decaturdavis5192
      @decaturdavis5192 3 года назад +9

      One was the lead cause of a mass extermination and one fought for state rights. I will say the church bell should stay. It’s history. And you can’t erase history. But you can keep a Nazi flag from flying. And I do agree with that one.

    • @youllneverknow_123
      @youllneverknow_123 3 года назад +1

      @@rc59191 with ya brother

  • @bzeak1121
    @bzeak1121 2 года назад +5

    Y'all are amazing. I love seeing fellow reenactors anywhere. And y'all do it so well. Great job and keep it up!
    Brad Zeak
    Sergeant
    8th FLA Co. G

  • @Jack-ff2zs
    @Jack-ff2zs 3 года назад +11

    I left my love, my love I left a sleepin' in her bed.
    I turned my back on my true love when fightin' Johnny Reb.
    I left my love a letter in the holler of a tree.
    I told her she would find me in the US Cavalry.

  • @republicoftexas1861
    @republicoftexas1861 2 года назад +2

    As an American Civil War reenactor that reenacts in America, I highly respect those A.C.W reenactors in Europe.

  • @jeffreymcintire8273
    @jeffreymcintire8273 2 года назад +3

    As an American reenactor of the American Civil War who's been on MANY campaigns and anniversary battles I can honestly say I'd love to come to Europe sometime and fall in with ya'll.

  • @1stminnsharpshooters341
    @1stminnsharpshooters341 4 года назад +1

    Very nicely done pards ... Looks like a great time under canvas and in ranks. Hello from a fellow reenactor; *LIKED* and *SUBBSCRIBED*

    • @1stminnsharpshooters341
      @1stminnsharpshooters341 4 года назад

      Passing along a personal invitation to join our groups Facebook page at facebook.com/1St.Minn.Sharpshooters

  • @normajeanmorrissey2903
    @normajeanmorrissey2903 4 года назад +5

    The Rebel Yell☆☆ I read that the Confederate army has Stonewall Jackson to thank for it! The story I read was that immediately before Jackson led his men into a battle he told them to, "Yell like the furies!" What they did became the Rebel yell!!+ I watched a Gettysburg 50th north & south reunion. Someone asked some very old johnny rebs to do the yell. Even though a little of the ferociousness was lost w/ age, it was still pretty intense! It was amazing to watch these elderly,yet brave gentleman meet in peace and harmony after all those years!♡My love and respect to all, north & south Norma Jean Morrissey

    • @normajeanmorrissey2903
      @normajeanmorrissey2903 4 года назад +1

      TO ALL CIVIL WAR BUFFS: To all who love Civil War stories and GWTW, our lovely lady and great actress is "gone with the. wind". At the age of 104 Olivia De Havilland or "Melanie" has passed away, dying in sleep in Paris, France. She was the last surviving cast member from the movie. Norma Jean Morrissey☆

  • @jamesrichardson3322
    @jamesrichardson3322 2 года назад

    Great you guys took interest in our history, you guys look good. Great job!!

  • @johnbattle7518
    @johnbattle7518 4 года назад +16

    This is actually accurate, maybe not the location but the nationalities who fought, many people do not know but there was even, Chinese vets.

    • @rdiddyspace1708
      @rdiddyspace1708 2 года назад

      yep one in the union army killed at Gettysburg.

  • @kennethsmith6848
    @kennethsmith6848 4 года назад +12

    I often wonder if the Europeans knew anything about America civil war. It great to see stuff like this on RUclips.

    • @normajeanmorrissey2903
      @normajeanmorrissey2903 4 года назад

      I was curious about the presence of so many soldiers from around the world fighting in the Civil War. Were they being patriotic for their new country? Was it to obtain a job they couldn't find. elsewhere? I suspect it was both. One comment I will add, there were no black confederates, no way, no how. NJM

    • @shapurthegreat7542
      @shapurthegreat7542 4 года назад +2

      Norma jean Morrissey false there were black confederate soliders

    • @normajeanmorrissey2903
      @normajeanmorrissey2903 4 года назад

      @@shapurthegreat7542 No, black Confederates. Why would you engage in battle, people who wanted you to have your freedom! fighting alongside others who want to continue your enslavement! That makes absolutely no damn sense, The only organized army of black men was United States Colored Troops and before that black sailors. BY the time Jefferson Davis thought slaves in army & navy might work, Lee was maybe 2 weeks from surrender. Case of too little, too late! Just never happened! You have heard of the "Lost Cause"? This was "Never found a cause!" Norma
      JEAN MORRISSEY

    • @normajeanmorrissey2903
      @normajeanmorrissey2903 4 года назад

      @@shapurthegreat7542 Read my texts. Only black soldiers were United States Colored Troops, 180,000 strong about 10% of Union forces. By the time Jefferson Davis thought it might be a.good idea to use slaves in combat, it was mid to end of March 1865. Lee surrendered April 9,1865 Get real there was no time to train, no money to outfit them, no motiva-tion on their part to fight! Why should they fight? For freedom they had already been given? I think not!! You need to do more research S.G. Norma Jean serious history student☆☆☆☆

    • @feeline1120
      @feeline1120 2 года назад +1

      We must learn all about it in Germany if we want to do the Abitur (graduating high school). But yes the focus lies more on the American Revolution, were we also need to know the most important battles etc. It’s a lot.

  • @jacob270597
    @jacob270597 5 лет назад +28

    Does anyone know how to get in contact with those organising this event? seems like i can't find any website or contact information on this reenactment event

    • @tramlink8544
      @tramlink8544 4 года назад

      same here, had any luck im keen on joining

    • @normajeanmorrissey2903
      @normajeanmorrissey2903 4 года назад

      Does anyone know of Civil War reenactment groups around here? Considering Atlanta history, I would hope there are.some groups. I would love to " be" a doctor or nurse with a group. I certainly am qualified! Do they still have the Nancy Hart Militia in LaGrange GA.?Norma Jean Morrissey

    • @davidfunkhouser516
      @davidfunkhouser516 3 года назад

      Yeah I am in Switzerland and would love to get involved.

    • @TheVieregg
      @TheVieregg 3 года назад

      We do this every year... because of corona in 2021 in September (03. - 05. September 2021). Yor will find informations at www.cw-reenactment.org

    • @definitely_not_Hirohito
      @definitely_not_Hirohito 2 месяца назад

      ​@@normajeanmorrissey2903I'm sure Atlanta has some, and I'll look. Also, you don't have to only be a nurse if you wish to be a soldier, reenactors don't segregate to be accurate, so you can have blacks in grey because obviously it's not REALLY 1863 and many women fought anyway. We all know about women sneaking in but one NY Zouave Regiment had female soldiers that were officially nurses but often fought in the same ranks as men.

  • @benson1914
    @benson1914 7 месяцев назад +2

    As an American who in recent years sees a lot of hate and generalizations about my country, most of which are completely valid while others not so much, I’m flattered that some Europeans show interest in the United States history As many Americans are fascinated with European history.

  • @mdr1396
    @mdr1396 4 года назад +8

    Its awesome to see Europeans taking such an interest in the ACW. Most people never stop to realize that a good majority of those who fought in the war werent American born, they were immigrants. European families were just as affected by the war as American families were, north and south. I dont think a lot of Europeans today really realize that theres a high chance that they actually had ancestors who immigrated to the states who ended up fighting in the war.

    • @TorianTammas
      @TorianTammas 4 года назад

      MDR All Americans are immigrants.

    • @normajeanmorrissey2903
      @normajeanmorrissey2903 4 года назад

      How many immigrants fought because of a feeling of patriotism or was patriotism the result of a steady paycheck of $13.00/month. Norma Jean Morrissey

    • @anoncrazynonevilgooddecent7631
      @anoncrazynonevilgooddecent7631 3 года назад

      False, most that fought in the American Civil War were American born and raised

  • @stalhandske9649
    @stalhandske9649 3 года назад +3

    "No war needs one man but every man one war."

  • @pqcha5437
    @pqcha5437 2 года назад +2

    If only America would reenact Napoleonic Wars on a grand scale here

  • @cloneofethan
    @cloneofethan 3 года назад +2

    Agreed it is very cool to see Europeans this interested in American history

  • @jesse-ll3dh
    @jesse-ll3dh 11 месяцев назад +1

    My great great grandpa fought at the battle of Shiloh in 1982.

  • @atune2682
    @atune2682 3 года назад

    very interesting!
    thanks for sharing!
    best regards! :D

  • @wild_west_hippie
    @wild_west_hippie 3 года назад +2

    Some of their kits are better than guys here in the states

  • @poopsiedoodlesp8506
    @poopsiedoodlesp8506 4 года назад +7

    reenactment is so much fun! But the older the era the more expensive the gear :(((((

    • @normajeanmorrissey2903
      @normajeanmorrissey2903 4 года назад

      I am an R.N. I have done a great deal of teaching. I am also studying the Civil War. I would love to do medical/nursing reenactments. I live in Gwinnett county, GA. Anyone need a great teacher? Norma Jean Morrissey

    • @normajeanmorrissey2903
      @normajeanmorrissey2903 4 года назад

      P.Doodle, Does anyone rent equipment? Just a thought! Instead of being in combat, could you do something medical or with quartermaster? Again, just a thought! I think you would rather be a soldier! Yes? Me? I'm a female and a nurse. I'd love to do a doctor or nurse role. What I would love to do is lecture/ teach/demonstrate. Another idea, buy an item w/ someone. Cut cost. Norma Jean Morrissey-History Lover

  • @rebel_drop_troop7715
    @rebel_drop_troop7715 4 года назад +4

    I wish they talk more about this stuff today reenacting in America is dying out that makes me very sad I’m only 17 but it makes me sad to see less and less union and confederates show up to Gettysburg every year. I want to become a teacher so I can educate youth on this war and this amazing hobby it also looks like I’ll be going to Germany

    • @normajeanmorrissey2903
      @normajeanmorrissey2903 4 года назад

      Biscuit plays : I am proud that you feel the way you do about educating future generations. Go for it! Start now! Chose a Civil War topic that interests you. Learn all you can about it. It can be a major battle, several people, both sides, medical people like Dr. Jonathan Letterman! (that's what I like- I am an R.N.), soldiers who were actually women, or Native Americans-most were Confederates-they owned slaves! Look up a man named Ely Parker U..S. army officer, lawyer, U.S. Grant's assistant who wrote the terms of surrender/ Appomattox to which General Lee agreed. Also
      Native American!! There are so many interesting subjects to research/study. I also study Titanic & other ships of the era as well as the wild west (1865-18!95!) I always have data floating around my brain! I love it!
      Good Luck, Norma Jean Morrissey

    • @selennemartinez4855
      @selennemartinez4855 3 года назад

      @ricky carroll oh gosh forget about those confederate monuments i am glad they are being taken down; you can still teach about the racism behind the civil war!

    • @selennemartinez4855
      @selennemartinez4855 3 года назад +1

      @@normajeanmorrissey2903 read about how blacks were given less pay ($10/mo - $3 [clothing deductions] but whites given $13/mo with no clothing deductions), not even allowed to enlist until 1863, etc....

  • @k.s.7034
    @k.s.7034 4 года назад +7

    I feel bad for the Irish. First the potato famine, then fighting a civil war for a foreign country. They pretty much got shafted by god.

    • @normajeanmorrissey2903
      @normajeanmorrissey2903 3 года назад +1

      KS our Civil War was divisive and deadly: 750,000 lost in battle and to disease! Today. I have heard that would be 4 million! What I am leading up to is the fact that many Irish famine victims came here not only to escape starvation but knowing (maybe praying) they were likely to find work. They did! It was with Uncle Sam! Union soldiers were paid $13/month which supported some immigrant families! Not the best job you say? Many lost their lives just like other Union soldiers. For many, they had a great sense of pride. Not only had they become new citizens in a great land, they now had the opportunity to defend it against the abomination of slavery! Other men did seek and find jobs in construction and on railroads. Were soldiers afraid? Going into battle? Of course they were! But they were thankful for the opportunity to become part of this country and help their families at the same time. Norma Jean Morrissey☆Historian in Training☆☆☆

    • @AeneasGemini
      @AeneasGemini 3 года назад

      @@normajeanmorrissey2903 "For many they had a great sense of pride" yes, and I'm sure for equally many they had a great sense of dread. Imagine being forced to fight in a horrifying war just so your family doesn't starve to death, that's extortion that borders on slavery imo.
      Don't even get me started about citizens in a new land, the amount of racial abuse that the Irish had to take from Americans in the early periods was abysmal. Happy to let them die for your cause, but not happy to treat them like equals, what a fascinatingly disturbed attitude.
      How happy you must be to so easily gloss over the worst parts of your own history

  • @connormacleod7010
    @connormacleod7010 3 года назад +4

    If this is going to be in Europe and you have Confederate soldiers in Europe they should have some women wearing Southern Belle dresses from South Carolina speaking with a Southern accent

  • @tomweaverling1366
    @tomweaverling1366 4 года назад +4

    Some of these dudes have good impressions.

  • @kwts7595
    @kwts7595 3 года назад

    I wonder if they do the orphan brigade that is what my greatgreat Great grandfather he was in the civil war for the confederates and his unit suffered the most casualties of the war and they where also the only confederate unit from Kentucky

  • @YankeeRebel1348
    @YankeeRebel1348 Год назад

    Thats so cool. Never knew that and lived there for 2 years.

  • @chippledon1
    @chippledon1 4 года назад +11

    Let's try a reenactment of the Battle of Waterloo in, say, Indiana perhaps!!

    • @normajeanmorrissey2903
      @normajeanmorrissey2903 4 года назад +1

      Who will play Napolean? HE MUST BE SHORT!

    • @SStupendous
      @SStupendous 3 года назад +2

      Nah a better comparison would be the battle of Dybbol in St. Louis

    • @SStupendous
      @SStupendous 3 года назад +3

      @@normajeanmorrissey2903 He was actually above average height. He LOOKED short next to the Old Guard because of their big hats.

    • @nilsbachellery6939
      @nilsbachellery6939 3 года назад

      waterloo is overrated go for austerlitz instead

    • @leetheflea4096
      @leetheflea4096 3 года назад

      Trafalgar in Death Valley

  • @SLG-jt1rd
    @SLG-jt1rd 3 года назад +2

    im glad they enjoy our history

  • @mookie861
    @mookie861 4 месяца назад

    the red and white armband the germans are wearing... ive never seen that on a confederate uniform before-anybody have a source?

  • @zpy-nq7wv
    @zpy-nq7wv Год назад +1

    PROUD OF Y'ALL! DEO VINDICE !

  • @newenglandpatriot4069
    @newenglandpatriot4069 4 месяца назад +1

    Here are these Germans reenacting battles in my country, and I'm on the other side dreaming of doing Napoleonic. Weird world.

  • @robertsilva8097
    @robertsilva8097 4 года назад +2

    You had the Irish Brigade in the Confederacy he also had a few soldiers from China

    • @jonathanjonnylightning718
      @jonathanjonnylightning718 4 года назад

      A lot of Mexicans were in the Confederacy even a General was a Mexican.

    • @normajeanmorrissey2903
      @normajeanmorrissey2903 4 года назад +2

      You are right about Chinese, German,French and other ethnicities taking part in the Civil War. I think that many (can't give you numbers) joined the service for the $13,/month, steady meals and medical care they received. For many this was the only job available to them because they were different! Over the years those differences no longer matter. Now, we are all Americans☆☆☆ Norma Jean Morrissey

    • @normajeanmorrissey2903
      @normajeanmorrissey2903 4 года назад

      @@jonathanjonnylightning718 Have you ever heard of Confederate General Stand Watie or "Degataga"? He was full blooded Cherokee Chief. He was a formidable and respectable leader of Cherokee soldiers. Read about him!☆☆Norma Jean Morrissey-history lover

    • @bastipro1333
      @bastipro1333 3 года назад

      @@jonathanjonnylightning718 the first confederate Asians are Filipinos they’re enlisted in Louisiana estimated about 1,200 to 10,000 joined and some of them were categorized Chinese(alot of them have Chinese ancestry and surnames or look like one) or mexican(same goes with the chinese)

    • @anoncrazynonevilgooddecent7631
      @anoncrazynonevilgooddecent7631 3 года назад

      There was no Chinese in civil war u lier or almost no Chinese mayb like 100 or less Chinese out of like 5 million ore more men lol

  • @TheOldBlackShuckyDog
    @TheOldBlackShuckyDog 3 года назад

    Oh God lads, come on, we got our own history you know.

  • @artiviste
    @artiviste 4 года назад

    where is it

    • @Bob-vx9xh
      @Bob-vx9xh 4 года назад

      Je ne sais pas mais.je veux voir ça aussi ^^

  • @averagetexan9930
    @averagetexan9930 3 года назад

    Eyyy there playing yellow rose of Texas at 2:44 ,strange song to hear outside of Texas

  • @ClarksonsinUSA
    @ClarksonsinUSA 4 года назад

    Cool...........

  • @sterbi9722
    @sterbi9722 4 года назад

    And I hear guys saying there’s no reason to reenact world wars in America or other countries because of inaccurate locations

    • @normajeanmorrissey2903
      @normajeanmorrissey2903 4 года назад +1

      Inaccurate location yes. That doesn't mean that actions, happenings outcomes of battle can't be the same! You get out of the experience what you put in to it!! Norma Jean Morrissey

  • @yeyonge
    @yeyonge Месяц назад

    I mean there were many many germans, french, polish and italians fought in the Civil War.

  • @JohnnyRebKy
    @JohnnyRebKy 4 года назад +15

    I thought Europeans couldn’t have guns lol. Very cool though, glad to see their having a great time! Amazing how this war effects the whole world, even today

    • @tramlink8544
      @tramlink8544 4 года назад +10

      well we swiss get free current standard issue rifles from the govt... :p long live the Swiss Confederacy :D

    • @SomeGunNerd
      @SomeGunNerd 3 года назад +2

      In most countries muzzle-loading guns like these are regulated differently from more modern weapons.
      In the US, they're not even considered guns at all.

    • @fantasy9917
      @fantasy9917 3 года назад

      You typically need a licence, which isn't hard to get. We just don't sell guns next to chewing gums and beer.

  • @pjakobsen
    @pjakobsen Год назад

    it’s a hobby that Monte Python would love to make fun of

  • @TheNightWatcher1385
    @TheNightWatcher1385 Год назад

    I’m curious how an American conflict got popular as a re-enactment era of choice for some in Europe.

  • @thebernice6062
    @thebernice6062 2 месяца назад

    Seeing Germans in old-timey dress reminds me of seeing the Amish in Ohio and Indiana when I was young.
    I don't get the appeal, but I'm glad they're interested in our history.

  • @Claymore1014
    @Claymore1014 Месяц назад

    This is cool, like pretty awesome cool.

  • @TheRunoben
    @TheRunoben 2 месяца назад

    Why

  • @haraldisdead
    @haraldisdead Год назад +1

    They didn't use the term "union" during the war, at least, not in that sense. It was "The North, " or "The United States."

    • @phenom...
      @phenom... 7 месяцев назад

      Union was absolutely used to refer to the Northern states

    • @haraldisdead
      @haraldisdead 7 месяцев назад +1

      @phenom... it "absolutely" wasn't.
      It is used in Autobiographies by important people referring to that time, but those texts were written decades later. Primary sources to not use the term "union" in that way. It was simply the United States

    • @phenom...
      @phenom... 7 месяцев назад

      @@haraldisdead You are correct sir

  • @AFRIKAKORPSsss
    @AFRIKAKORPSsss 2 года назад

    Damn it, but this is all more interesting than the War of Right to play!).. It's great that people have hobbies and a reason to spend time!.. Yeee yeee!

  • @connormacleod7010
    @connormacleod7010 3 года назад +2

    The army of Northern California is going to head to there and help our fellow Confederate soldiers the South will rise again

    • @SStupendous
      @SStupendous 3 года назад +2

      Nevermind Calif was a Unionist state?

    • @johnwood8441
      @johnwood8441 3 года назад +2

      California was for the Union you moron

    • @SStupendous
      @SStupendous 3 года назад +2

      @@johnwood8441 exactly XD

    • @connormacleod7010
      @connormacleod7010 3 года назад

      @@SStupendous there is over 5,000 Confederate soldiers people from California you had over 5,000 from California in the Confederate Army I even know my history

    • @connormacleod7010
      @connormacleod7010 3 года назад

      @@SStupendous when people head from California to the army of Northern Virginia they put on a Ledger that they were from California

  • @28ebdh3udnav
    @28ebdh3udnav 3 года назад +1

    Why people in Europe understand
    American history better than most Americans is disturbing.....

  • @thehistoryspotonyoutube7424
    @thehistoryspotonyoutube7424 2 года назад +1

    The real biggest reenactment is in Gettysburg with 7,000 reenactors not 100

  • @haraldisdead
    @haraldisdead Год назад

    I'm not surprised they take interest. It was the best war.

  • @rhett1029
    @rhett1029 Год назад +1

    I think it’d be funny if a American showed up. What a lot of Americans don’t realize a part of what made the Civil War such an interesting subject and such a tragedy is most Americans including myself can trace ancestors to both sides of the war

  • @leetheflea4096
    @leetheflea4096 3 года назад

    This would be like Americans reenacting the Crimean War or something, but in all seriousness respect

  • @jtm726
    @jtm726 3 года назад

    I'm confused... what the hell,are the unionists and Confederist troops are doing in the U.K.

  • @OddballGaming140
    @OddballGaming140 Год назад +1

    Oh wow I surprise that Europe were fascinated with the American Civil War. I thought they would be more favor of the British Civil War (some reenactments are held) and perhaps the French revolution

  • @BarbellThor
    @BarbellThor 3 месяца назад

    Really wish we charged lines like that here in the US.

  • @Paches92-
    @Paches92- 4 года назад +1

    3:03 George RR Martin

  • @LorenRyburn-hx8gi
    @LorenRyburn-hx8gi 10 месяцев назад

    Mystify one's self w/ hum a n extra ordinary vocalizer

  • @michelleseymour7534
    @michelleseymour7534 9 месяцев назад

    As a kid I watched my dad several times a year reenact battle on actual historic battleground in Arkansas. Watching Europeans do it is just weird.

  • @EJ160E
    @EJ160E 4 года назад +15

    “GERMANS LOVE THE CONFEDERATE STATES OF AMERICA!” -Norm McDonald

  • @Kioley123
    @Kioley123 Месяц назад

    Europe is litered with actual battlefields and these people recreate battles a ocean away.

  • @holzmann-
    @holzmann- Год назад +1

    The South should've won.

  • @LorenRyburn-hx8gi
    @LorenRyburn-hx8gi 10 месяцев назад

    agan aganizing organizer voice stroy den ary finder Binder

  • @billybobjohnadamjoe
    @billybobjohnadamjoe 3 года назад +2

    Comparably, the Second Sleswig War (that happened near the tail end of the Civil War) saw breech loaded artillery and rifles. A stark difference from the muzzle-loading of inferior weapons that went on in America.

    • @mr.medioker5
      @mr.medioker5 3 года назад +1

      Breach loading cannon's and other technically advanced weapons were used during the civil war. The use of trains and telegrams during the war influenced many European officer's and commanders most notably Helmuth von Moltke.

    • @h.w.barlow6693
      @h.w.barlow6693 Год назад

      We has Ironclad warships, gatling guns, breech loaders since the 1850s. Too bad Europeans couldn't own firearms back then or now.

  • @skankydanky9737
    @skankydanky9737 4 года назад +1

    Pretty accurate other than the rebels playing a union army song

    • @Captain_Frank_Abagnale
      @Captain_Frank_Abagnale 4 года назад +4

      They played the Bonnie Blue Flag. That’s about as Confederate as it gets, save for playing Dixieland.

    • @normajeanmorrissey2903
      @normajeanmorrissey2903 4 года назад

      I read that one of Lincoln's favorite songs was "Dixie" Norma Jean Morrissey

    • @SomeGunNerd
      @SomeGunNerd 3 года назад

      @@Captain_Frank_Abagnale Especially the chorus.
      "Hurrah, hurrah, for Southern rights hurrah! Hurrah for the Bonnie Blue Flag that bears a single star!"

  • @afriendlyrebel5709
    @afriendlyrebel5709 4 года назад +1

    Their ancestors participated in US civil war back then.

    • @LePoilu
      @LePoilu 4 года назад

      No

    • @afriendlyrebel5709
      @afriendlyrebel5709 4 года назад

      @@LePoilu Some of 'em, yes.

    • @LePoilu
      @LePoilu 4 года назад

      A Friendly Rebel yes some of them

    • @ortho4252
      @ortho4252 3 года назад

      @@LePoilu yea there were mercenaries

  • @scottydu81
    @scottydu81 2 года назад

    Mine eyes have seen the glory of the coming of the Lord!
    He is trampling down the vintage where the grapes of wrath are stored!
    He hath loosed the fateful lightning of His terrible swift sword:
    His truth is marching on!

  • @dceufan
    @dceufan 4 года назад +1

    1:07 Christian Loscher, a German Confederate. Where are the German Union soldiers 😆

    • @normajeanmorrissey2903
      @normajeanmorrissey2903 4 года назад

      TO REENACTORS IN EUROPE: I AM CURIOUS AS TO WHY YOU WOULD REENACT BATTLES THAT TOOK PLACE IN THE CONFEDARATE STATES & UNION STATES OF AMERICA? IS THERE A CONNECTION- BETWEEN CIVIL WAR & EUROPE THAT I AM MISSING? FILL ME IN!☆ NORMA JEAN MORRISSEY

    • @normajeanmorrissey2903
      @normajeanmorrissey2903 4 года назад

      Why are there Union or Confederate Civil War reenactors in Germany, France, England or other Europian countries. I am puzzled as to why they would reenact U.S. history???? Norma Jean Morrissey

    • @normajeanmorrissey2903
      @normajeanmorrissey2903 4 года назад

      There are no German Confederates, German Union soldiers or even anymore Nazis come to think of it! When you reenact you are presenting a point of view. You are acting out so to speak!You are not really those people. You are presenting that point of view and teaching others to understand the other man's side. Norma Jean ☆☆☆☆

  • @marahallvalesquez5059
    @marahallvalesquez5059 4 года назад +7

    2019 there still fighting the civil war...

    • @normajeanmorrissey2903
      @normajeanmorrissey2903 4 года назад

      I am curious as to why you say this. I think there are white people who would like to see Jim Crow laws still in effect,! we do have KKK groups fortunately in less than half our states with membership in thousands,not millions!!¹ I an saddened to say some have "junior KKK" groups. KKK was started by angry Confederates in December, 1865. Men who couldn't let go! "Lost Cause" believers! Their 1st "Grand Wizard" was Nathan Bedford Forrest, Confederate Guerilla (partisan) General. Historians consider him one of the Civil War's best officers. Forrest was named Grand Wizard of the Klan because he was known by all as the "Wizard of the Saddle". What is interesting about him is his apparent "turn around" after the war.,1875. He resigned from the Klan, and spoke often and positively about black people, esp related to black rights! Personally, I believe he found God!♡♡ 1877, he died from Diabetes complications. Since then he has been honored by many. I can't decide if the honors are for the General who fought with Lee, or the man who learned to love and respect his black brothers.♡♡Norma Jean Morrissey-lover of history and forgiver of Forrest (please read his bio., truly interesting man

  • @PalmettoNDN
    @PalmettoNDN 4 года назад

    Way more coordinated during fire than American reenactors.

  • @sloanchampion85
    @sloanchampion85 5 лет назад +10

    Go get em Johnny Rebs !!!!!!

    • @normajeanmorrissey2903
      @normajeanmorrissey2903 4 года назад

      Explain! They didn't stand a chance because there weren't enough of them. As General Lee ( a man I admire) lost each brave young-some teenagers!man to an amputation or death, he lost 2 to infectious illness. As the war went on, Lee had fewer and fewer replacements. PLEASE DON 'T TELL ME THAT DAVIS & LEE had many blacks to utilize. Saying "go get'em johnny reb" to a group of slaves wasn't gonna cut it!!!!!!!!!!!!!
      "It was.a very sad time with even sadder things happening! I study it , really the people so l can understand how those people could act the way they did, do the things they did to one another. Only by studying times like the Civil War can we hope to avoid them again! Unless we learn from the past, we are destined to repeat it!☆☆☆☆ Norma Jean Morrissey Studier of great history

  • @joetrader1942
    @joetrader1942 Год назад

    Wtf? In Europe?

  • @sylviaj270
    @sylviaj270 2 года назад

    I wonder how did they get interested in the American civil war.

  • @telesniper2
    @telesniper2 4 месяца назад

    Huh? Don't you have Napoleonic war reenactors instead? Maybe Franco Prussian war reenactors?

  • @nanotech1921
    @nanotech1921 Год назад +2

    I mean the US reeinacts European battles all the time, only fair lol

  • @polishherowitoldpilecki5521
    @polishherowitoldpilecki5521 4 года назад

    Very interesting if they did napoleonic wars. They could actually use their borders.

    • @normajeanmorrissey2903
      @normajeanmorrissey2903 4 года назад

      A bit of trivia: In attempt to keep soldiers food fresh, Napolean tasked his.chef with the job
      Do you know how he.did it? He put food in cans so it would last longer!! That is a true story! Norma Jean Morrissey-history lover I truly love history trivia! You would be surprised at the stories I know! One last example, General Stonewall Jackson taught a Sunday school class. For only slave children! It was against the law☆☆NJM

  • @anthonykirsch6482
    @anthonykirsch6482 11 дней назад

    hurrah

  • @featheranimations2798
    @featheranimations2798 10 месяцев назад

    This is extremely weird seeing this as an american

  • @TheRunoben
    @TheRunoben 2 месяца назад

    They’re not American or have American ancestors, so why

  • @dceufan
    @dceufan 4 года назад

    Hearing Germanic language with a Union or Confederate uniform perplex me. But no doubt Europeans and/or their offsprings participated on both sides of the Civil War. I say this ... we should re-enact the Hundred Days War in the United States. 😂 #Waterloo

    • @SavolaxMitsu
      @SavolaxMitsu 3 года назад

      Union army was many All-German unit, like 29th, 46th, 5th germans rifles and 52nd New York, 12th and 17th Missouri, 9th and 107th Ohio regiments.
      24th, 43rd and 82nd Illinois, the 32nd Indiana, the 9th and 26th Wisconsin and the 74th and 75th Pennsylvania regiments.

    • @PaulFrank52ndNY
      @PaulFrank52ndNY 3 года назад

      @@SavolaxMitsu nearly 200.000 German Immigrants or people with German heritage served in the Union Army. At the End of 1862 the Union Army had to standardize the command language to english because so many regiments gave orders in their first language like german or italian.

  • @lolshark99b49
    @lolshark99b49 3 года назад

    lol

  • @Jack-ff2zs
    @Jack-ff2zs 3 года назад +2

    I wish I was in the land of cotton old times there are not forgotten look away look away look away dixieland

  • @kubusicek
    @kubusicek 4 года назад +3

    Yeeeeeeeeehaaaaaaaaaaaaw

    • @normajeanmorrissey2903
      @normajeanmorrissey2903 4 года назад

      Maj.genKubus, Is that a cowboy yeehaw or "rebel yell"? Also, do you want to hear some old rebels do the rebel yell? Find video of the 50th Gettysburg-blue & grey reunion. They asked a group of very old rebs to give the yell. I'm sure it wasn't as ferocious as it was in 1863, but it was pretty darn good! Did you know that they also had a 75th reunion! As you might have guessed not as many attended!☆☆☆Norma Jean Morrissey/Civil War buff

    • @normajeanmorrissey2903
      @normajeanmorrissey2903 4 года назад

      Is that the closing line for a.new country song? NJM

    • @kubusicek
      @kubusicek 4 года назад

      @@normajeanmorrissey2903 cowboy yeehaaw, iam Union Fan.

    • @normajeanmorrissey2903
      @normajeanmorrissey2903 4 года назад

      @@kubusicek who is your favorite singin' cowboy? I have many, I will pick one: Merle Haggard!♡♡ A favorite song? Actually 2! "Three Wooden Crosses" and "This is the Last Cowboy Song". Don't know it? Listen! It's like a mini-history lesson! Norma Jean

    • @normajeanmorrissey2903
      @normajeanmorrissey2903 4 года назад

      @@kubusicek what is your most favorite country song ever? I know it's kind of hard to answer. I might pick "Arlington",or "Holes in the floor of Heaven". Maybe. "The little Girl", how about Brad Paisley's, "He Didn't Have to Be", Good bet on, "Who's Gonna Fill Their Shoes" by the Possum! If a song really tells a story, it lives in my ♡ always. Those I have listed are among the great ones. There are so many, many more. Those above always make me cry!♡♡ What songs do you love? Tell me! I would like to know. Norma Jean Morrissey

  • @theo1856
    @theo1856 3 года назад

    Its weird they should just stick to their own stuff, everyone should be engaged in their own culture

  • @Ghastly_Grinner
    @Ghastly_Grinner 4 года назад +1

    Well...would have been nice if y'all would have actually lent us a hand

    • @normajeanmorrissey2903
      @normajeanmorrissey2903 4 года назад +2

      Who should have lent you a hand? British helped Confederacy? They did! Built ships among other things! Norma Jean Morrissey

    • @Ghastly_Grinner
      @Ghastly_Grinner 4 года назад

      @@normajeanmorrissey2903 Selling ships aint helping at the time the UK owned Canada and a Big fleet could have ran the blockade at their leisure

    • @normajeanmorrissey2903
      @normajeanmorrissey2903 4 года назад

      @@Ghastly_Grinner In spite of their deniall, Great Btitain did make ships for the Confederacy. How many, I can't find that info. What I do know is that they would build a basic ship with no armaments or any thing that appeared "war like"on it. THe Confederate NAVY would add the guns. THE ships were ready to go! I don't know but would like to,was Queen Victoria aware of this treachery?? I don't think it was Prince Albert. He died 12/14/61 Norma Jean Morrissey-history lover♡

    • @normajeanmorrissey2903
      @normajeanmorrissey2903 4 года назад

      @@Ghastly_Grinner Please explain! Are you talking about the Civil War and help given to the Confederacy by Great Britain? Norma Jean Morrissey