Plot twist: Original captain crash landed on At attin, kills original supervisor and assumes the identity. Reason the captain is alive after all this time is hes a droid.
@@davidlutz2242 Nah fam i bet Wims daddy somehow Escaped and told those Pirates where the planet is Before being killed when returning to the planet with the pirate. dink donk?
The supervisor tower reminds me of the tower on Koboh in Jedi Survivor. In Survivor they used Zee, a High Republic droid, to help use the tower to travel to a hidden galaxy. The At Attin security droids remind me of the blue droid you rescue from underground in Survivor as well.
I believe the ship has been there too long for the captain to still be in charge, but that assumes he lives as long as us. A longer living spiecies - or a droid/AI is also possible - as well as maybe a hybrid. Perhaps a human with cybernetics that has to swap out the human part every so often with their consciousness transferred to the new host via the cybernetics. Perhaps eliminating or imprisoning the previous consciousness of the host. So they have to prepare the new human every so often. And they will not only have to save their planet or their friend.
Anyone notice that the statue looked like The father character? Or What if he was the pirate who was looking for At Attin and became an analyst to look over the money and his son. Which is why he was so calm when they took off and when the parents were waiting for answers from the supervisor.
Btw, there is similar statue in the background when the kids are on their way to school. But it has a head and it’s Neels species, plus his species is on the mural looking like a king or chancellor !! Check it out!
At Attin survived all the wars that plagued the Galaxy. Even if the supervisor is a pirate, keeping the people out of the turmoil and living in a prosperous "utopia" isn't at all bad.
Don't think Jod is from Alde. He says his homeworld smells like ashes or something. Don't think Alde smells much of anything these days. Hope that the captain is not the supervisor, bit of a shame if it's the case. It would kinda erase any backstory from the old repu and why those planets have been singled out at the time (experiment or whatever)and why this particular planet is still going "strong" compared to the others. Finally, the ship did crashland, (it was upside down when the kids discovered it) so something went wrong at the time, like a possible mutiny and the former captain was killed. Have to say, on a story telling POV it seems more interesting to have the Captain dying upon arriving on this fable world after searching for it presumably for a very long time because of the consequences of his actions (murdering his crew for greed), and if it's inspired by Stevenson's book ... Well, Flynt is dead by the time of the story.
I feel like that ship crashed thousands of years before the event of this story. The captain would have to been another species, a droid or someone who found a way to prolong life perhaps
#JustStarWars -- I suspect we've already seen this Pirate extraordinaire... possibly in some statue on the surface or reference or otherwise in the first episodes.
At Attin went from feeling like a cozy suburban neighborhood full of mundane people living in peace. To a dystopian nightmare that forces conformity and discourages any kind of independent thinking.
I think Wims fathers the captain and the missing link to the whole thing. Not one person has suggested that yet except me so I expect some kind of a prize if I'm right
😂…that’s funny! But in all seriousness I bet you are on to something when it comes to Wims dad. He’s made some faces that gave the impression that he knows more than he’s saying so far.
I think money management and old Republic credits is a major reason it was one of the nine jewels of the old republic, but I believe the real worth and great work are the children. If the old republic was run by Jedi as protectors of the peace through the force, they would need a school system to find younglings. So my theory is all nine jewels were testing grounds for possable "sensitives" for possable Jedi membership after order 66 the kids would now be harvested to be either those "Sith cops" that hunt down Jedi or even worse like Grogu they are to be used to bring back ol' Gnarly nubs and be harvested of the metacloreians to bring us to... "Somehow, Palpatine returned." He could have paid a Pirate crew to kill the 8 other jewels but saved the best one for himself. I think the Captian was force sensitive and felt great guilt at the fall of the other worlds with so many children when he found the last he couldn't do it because he was actually born on one of these worlds or was told to by his employer to leave the last for himself and as a reward he could stay as long as he never left. And got caught and banished with his ship and bot lost until...
When they talk to SM-33 again, he mentions how the captain made the ship crash because of a mutiny - the crew was doubting the treasure and legend. It's possible no one survived the crash, right?
Anyone considered it’s an order 66 survivor? The Jedi should have known of these 9 jewels and a Jedi on the run might go looking for At Attin and destroying any evidence along the way.
As much as I want to find out who or what the supervisor is. It whoudnt be a bad idea for them to leave it at a cliffhanger so we all are like wtf who I'd it or something like that then season 2 we all are back to finish the first season and just hope we get another great season.
Hey, even Firefly eventually got Serenity - the cast is so talented there might eventually be a movie someday, but hopefully there are many more seasons first.
That would be a mistake that Disney has made before (Ahsoka, The Acolyte). They have to learn the skill of providing a complete and satisfying story with each season, not just make the first season a set-up for a hoped-for second season. If people are not satisfied by the first season (which would be indicated by frequent re-watches of the first season), it makes the second season unlikely.
I hope that Lego or the HASLAB comes out with an Onyx Cinder with the kids and Jod and SM33 included with the ship. I can’t imagine why they wouldn’t make this, especially with it being a story about kids having an adventure. Seems like a no-brainer for those companies as far as making a ship for it. 🤷🏻♂️
It was a boring episode really. First I thought they landed on the wrong side of At Attin (beyond a barrier) and had a Logan's Run moment or something. Obviously they couldn't get through the barrier from their side.
Fern will be the captain's descendant. Be better if it was Neel, but Disney is still on the girl boss kick. She had to yield to Jod. Her being related to the captain will be Disney's way to make her win
Because an order to “forget” is not the same thing as “erase”. The droid was ordered by the old captain not to retrieve the memory from its memory archive. The new caption reversed that order with a new command to “remember” or retrieve that memory.
But it's parked! The door was locked, power was off, just like the vintage (but dusty) old cars that are suddenly discovered in an elderly person's garage after being forgotten for fifty years
I agree. People who have secrets to keep continue all their lives to cover them up deeper and deeper. There would have been so many security droids around that area that nobody would have been able to get to the ship unobserved, and anyone who did would _disappear._
Can’t say I remember no At Attin
That’s definitely the line of the show!
Underrated channel. Watched theory from the beginning and stupendous and I feel you can hit those heights
The Captain will end up being one of the parents of the children.
Plot twist: Original captain crash landed on At attin, kills original supervisor and assumes the identity. Reason the captain is alive after all this time is hes a droid.
I think it's Wims father and he's the key to the whole thing
Mate its Hondo Ohnaka my man
@@davidlutz2242 Man its Hondo Ohnaka
@@davidlutz2242 Nah fam i bet Wims daddy somehow Escaped and told those Pirates where the planet is Before being killed when returning to the planet with the pirate. dink donk?
@@davidlutz2242this would make perfect sense.
Pirates want the treasure and droids aren’t exactly obsessed with treasure.
The supervisor tower reminds me of the tower on Koboh in Jedi Survivor. In Survivor they used Zee, a High Republic droid, to help use the tower to travel to a hidden galaxy.
The At Attin security droids remind me of the blue droid you rescue from underground in Survivor as well.
I'm kinda hoping a Vault-Tec sort of backstory. Several planets with exactly the same setup and resources, but every planet is an experiment 😁
I would love that!!! The vaults are my favorite piece of fallout and seeing a planet sized version sounds amazing!!
I believe the ship has been there too long for the captain to still be in charge, but that assumes he lives as long as us. A longer living spiecies - or a droid/AI is also possible - as well as maybe a hybrid. Perhaps a human with cybernetics that has to swap out the human part every so often with their consciousness transferred to the new host via the cybernetics. Perhaps eliminating or imprisoning the previous consciousness of the host. So they have to prepare the new human every so often. And they will not only have to save their planet or their friend.
What if the rodent in SM-33 's eye is the captain?
I thought this too! He keeps hanging around despite all of the opportunities for him to get lost
That’s the captain lol
I wondered about this too!
Great guess
Neels Dad may be the supervisor, or his ancestors where the originals and maybe ur right. The captain might of take control from the blue elephants
Anyone notice that the statue looked like The father character? Or What if he was the pirate who was looking for At Attin and became an analyst to look over the money and his son. Which is why he was so calm when they took off and when the parents were waiting for answers from the supervisor.
Btw, there is similar statue in the background when the kids are on their way to school. But it has a head and it’s Neels species, plus his species is on the mural looking like a king or chancellor !! Check it out!
SM-33 seems more like Long John Silver than Jod does
Agreed, and Long Lohn Silver wanted to retire on Treasure Island without anyone following.
This show is fantastic. I like your analysis
At Attin survived all the wars that plagued the Galaxy. Even if the supervisor is a pirate, keeping the people out of the turmoil and living in a prosperous "utopia" isn't at all bad.
When approaching the planet they quite clearly think it looks exactly like their home. Not just at the city level.
Don't think Jod is from Alde. He says his homeworld smells like ashes or something. Don't think Alde smells much of anything these days.
Hope that the captain is not the supervisor, bit of a shame if it's the case. It would kinda erase any backstory from the old repu and why those planets have been singled out at the time (experiment or whatever)and why this particular planet is still going "strong" compared to the others. Finally, the ship did crashland, (it was upside down when the kids discovered it) so something went wrong at the time, like a possible mutiny and the former captain was killed. Have to say, on a story telling POV it seems more interesting to have the Captain dying upon arriving on this fable world after searching for it presumably for a very long time because of the consequences of his actions (murdering his crew for greed), and if it's inspired by Stevenson's book ... Well, Flynt is dead by the time of the story.
The most fun fans have had guessing the mystery in a while.
I feel like that ship crashed thousands of years before the event of this story. The captain would have to been another species, a droid or someone who found a way to prolong life perhaps
Perhaps the great surviving captain pirate is I, Hondo Ohnaka!...or perhaps not. We shall see!!
No way Jod is from Alderaan. Alderaan blew up. It would not smell like anything
#JustStarWars -- I suspect we've already seen this Pirate extraordinaire... possibly in some statue on the surface or reference or otherwise in the first episodes.
The mystery Captain IS the Supervisor on At-Attin
At Attin went from feeling like a cozy suburban neighborhood full of mundane people living in peace.
To a dystopian nightmare that forces conformity and discourages any kind of independent thinking.
I think Wims fathers the captain and the missing link to the whole thing. Not one person has suggested that yet except me so I expect some kind of a prize if I'm right
‘Hear ye’ Here ye!’
😂…that’s funny! But in all seriousness I bet you are on to something when it comes to Wims dad. He’s made some faces that gave the impression that he knows more than he’s saying so far.
I think something related but he seeing the ship gives me the impression at least not the mystery captain
It’s been said
The pirate ship was buried and old, waaay older than Whim's father.
I think money management and old Republic credits is a major reason it was one of the nine jewels of the old republic, but I believe the real worth and great work are the children. If the old republic was run by Jedi as protectors of the peace through the force, they would need a school system to find younglings.
So my theory is all nine jewels were testing grounds for possable "sensitives" for possable Jedi membership after order 66 the kids would now be harvested to be either those "Sith cops" that hunt down Jedi or even worse like Grogu they are to be used to bring back ol' Gnarly nubs and be harvested of the metacloreians to bring us to... "Somehow, Palpatine returned."
He could have paid a Pirate crew to kill the 8 other jewels but saved the best one for himself.
I think the Captian was force sensitive and felt great guilt at the fall of the other worlds with so many children when he found the last he couldn't do it because he was actually born on one of these worlds or was told to by his employer to leave the last for himself and as a reward he could stay as long as he never left. And got caught and banished with his ship and bot lost until...
Utopias tend to be hamster cages relying on everyone being a satisfied cog in the wheels and not upsettign the balance ;)
When they talk to SM-33 again, he mentions how the captain made the ship crash because of a mutiny - the crew was doubting the treasure and legend. It's possible no one survived the crash, right?
I remember a more civilized time on RUclips when thumbnails didn't feel the need to add circles and arrows
Fantastic explanation. Many thanks.
Seems there's just so much more to uncover, I can't see it all taking place in just the 2 final episodes
Anyone considered it’s an order 66 survivor? The Jedi should have known of these 9 jewels and a Jedi on the run might go looking for At Attin and destroying any evidence along the way.
60 years was long ago but we still have lots of people who are 70 years old
Wim's father is the former pirate captain...
Maybe his great grandfather?
7:33 I wish I had grown up in a bedroom like that
The real mystery is, how did Neel not hit that???
As much as I want to find out who or what the supervisor is. It whoudnt be a bad idea for them to leave it at a cliffhanger so we all are like wtf who I'd it or something like that then season 2 we all are back to finish the first season and just hope we get another great season.
Hey, even Firefly eventually got Serenity - the cast is so talented there might eventually be a movie someday, but hopefully there are many more seasons first.
That would be a mistake that Disney has made before (Ahsoka, The Acolyte). They have to learn the skill of providing a complete and satisfying story with each season, not just make the first season a set-up for a hoped-for second season. If people are not satisfied by the first season (which would be indicated by frequent re-watches of the first season), it makes the second season unlikely.
@kirkdarling4120 idk I must be an outlier I like how the acolyte set up Darth plagueis at the end idk tho.
The Captain is Omega!
What if there's a whole network of alien worlds out there and we on Earth are being kept in the dark similarly to At Attin?
I hope that Lego or the HASLAB comes out with an Onyx Cinder with the kids and Jod and SM33 included with the ship. I can’t imagine why they wouldn’t make this, especially with it being a story about kids having an adventure. Seems like a no-brainer for those companies as far as making a ship for it. 🤷🏻♂️
There is an Onyx Cinder set with Jod and the kids out, not sure if SM-33’s in it though mate 🤔
@@JustStarWars Well…now don’t I feel like a moron! 🤪. Sorry about that, I should’ve just looked before assuming. I’ll check it out, thank you! 🙏👍
they should ask the "warriors" 33 saw if they have traded with pirates
I think At Attin history have similarities with Australia's Formation
It was a boring episode really. First I thought they landed on the wrong side of At Attin (beyond a barrier) and had a Logan's Run moment or something. Obviously they couldn't get through the barrier from their side.
Andor
Skeleton Crew
Mandolorian
Ashoka
Book of Bobba
Obi-Wan
Acolyte
Fern will be the captain's descendant. Be better if it was Neel, but Disney is still on the girl boss kick. She had to yield to Jod. Her being related to the captain will be Disney's way to make her win
Tell me if I’m wrong but….. Jude law=long john silver, old capt= captain flint and cm33= bizarro world billy bones
Oh wow. Who’s gonna be Ben Gunn?
SM-33 is obviously Smee from Peter Pan
If you order a robot to forget something, how can they remember it later?
Because an order to “forget” is not the same thing as “erase”. The droid was ordered by the old captain not to retrieve the memory from its memory archive. The new caption reversed that order with a new command to “remember” or retrieve that memory.
I think wims dad is the captain
Wimms Dad is the captain that's why Wim is different or his mom might have been could be a female captain
nooo If the old Capitan was still alive he would have hunted down the ship so the truth does not get out
But it's parked! The door was locked, power was off, just like the vintage (but dusty) old cars that are suddenly discovered in an elderly person's garage after being forgotten for fifty years
I agree. People who have secrets to keep continue all their lives to cover them up deeper and deeper. There would have been so many security droids around that area that nobody would have been able to get to the ship unobserved, and anyone who did would _disappear._
HONDO OHNAKA
the dad knew right away where the ship was so idk seems weird
The original captain is probably long dead
What if the captain is a yoda species
First comment, great video!🎉
Thank you 🤩
I really love this show. Like I'd rather have Bane and Vader shows but this is still fun AF.
The captain is Hondo
Has no one talked about Cloned Worlds? Clones anyone?
winner winner chicken dinner
I think wim's dad is the pirate
that would be an amazing pivot
Or a great grandfather
That ship was buried for ages. How could Wim's dad still be alive if he was the pirate captain?
@enadegheeghaghe6369 if its any relationship to whim it would have to be a great x2 or 3 grandfather
good video, except that strong bri-ish accent