Inside And Out - Steve Hackett at NJPAC - Feb. 17, 2017
HTML-код
- Опубликовано: 15 окт 2024
- "Inside and Out", as Steve notes in his concerts, is the song which didn't make it onto the LP "Wind & Wuthering".
To note, LPs produced for popular music in the '50s, '60s and '70s had a finite amount of (groove) space to cut songs onto a side of vinyl. 20 Minutes per side was about average at the time. Anyone who tried to record an LP onto cassette - and there were MANY of us - can tell you on LP would usually fit onto one side of a 90 minute cassette tape.
Anyone who followed Art Rock in the 70s, and Genesis in particular, know that groups like Genesis pushed the limits of how much information could be cut into a single LP. Genesis' 'Wind & Wuthering' came in at approximately 50 minutes, nearly bucking the 52 minutes that engineers at Columbia had devised in the early 1950s
(See: en.wikipedia.o...)
It's not clear to me the record was cut with a smaller stylus however the sound on this LP, as well as "A Trick of the Tale" were pressed cleanly with relatively low surface noise.
Alas, three cuts did not make Wind & Wuthering.
(See: en.wikipedia.o...)
They can still be found on the web in their studio form in various formats.
Here of course is the live version of "Inside and Out" as performed at the NJPAC, February 2017.
Just discovered this - what a beautiful song - such a pity it didn't make it onto an album. Another one that could have been written for Nad - and the musicianship is brilliant - nice to see Nick Beggs on base 😁
I was at this show! I'm happy somebody caught it on video. It was a real highlight to see and hear this song being performed live, especially since I never thought it would happen!
Genesis did perform this live on their Wind and Wuthering tour. I’ve heard the recording here on RUclips . It is awesome.
It’s a shame that I forgot the ways of Genesis. Listening to it growing and then forgetting about it. However it’s nice that someone filmed this so I can look back at the show that brought back not only my childhood, but also my love for genesis!
This over ‘Wot Gorilla’ every time. Beautiful.
Very good version of that great song from the EP in 1977.
If the person shooting it had known the song, presumably we wouldn't have been focused on the bass player doing not very much during the ******* iconic keyboard solo
He's been playing this one live for a while now that I'm aware of. The song didn't make Wind & Wuthering yet one has to recall in the days of 33 1/3 vinyl, Genesis was one of only a few groups that would pack 50 minutes of music on an LP.
This was Steves' last song w/Genesis. The B Side of Spot. Remember that EP? Blue Vinyl 🙂
The vocals are more than fine. You guys are hard on Nad for no good reason. Relax and just enjoy a wonderful Genesis song. A forgotten gem.
Heyyy! I miss Phil on this!!!
Really? His strained Falsetto destroyed it!!
+andrew price Strained falsetto? Who are we talking about here? The guy on this video was clearly not staying in tune, unlike the original recording of this piece (with Collins singing).
Didn't know he has been playing this one live. Thanks !
Great! Thank you for posting, Gimmeanidicanuse.
Not the same experience without Phil at lead vocals.
Somebody please explain to me how this is not much better than You’re Own Special Way….
Because Tony said so
This is where a harmony by Amanda Lehmann could have added a little flavor.
Love it. Great memories. Looking forward to seeing this on the tour.
Inside and Out stands out in the genesis catalogue as a rare tribute to other bands : steves solo is obviously paying tribute to the other guitar steve of another big prog band ..and the end is pure Who!
merci Steve pour ta compo
This is great. He does a good job on vocals. But the Steve Hackett trademark finger picking is transcendent.
Big mistake in not including this on Wind & Withering.
Would have needed an EP to go with the LP. Not sure what song would have been worth cutting.
big mistake too in not including Voyage of The Acolyte on Trick Of The Tail for an 2 albums like The Lamb , just imagine , for me Voyage is the best Album Prog ever
Replace it with Your own special way
@@gimmeanidicanuse There was an EP issued. Spot The Pigeon contained this cut as the finale. The other tunes were Match Of The Day and Pigeons.
I love this song!!!😊
Wow, something off of spot the pigeon which I still have!
un génie était né .... merci Steve
Wonderful....
All this wind and wuthering talk, love it last jacket album, sounds a little like yes
Awesome synth solo. Let's show the bass player instead!
clinke2007 Totally agree, always been a fav of mine since the EP was released. Great to see it live on the tour at Oxford.
Yes, that was my bad. Using a small Canon PowerShot from the back row of balcony.
include on W&W in lieu of "Your Own Special Way" (no offense, Mike) and it just might've been their greatest album.
"Love the dropped octave of " Never the same as before.." much more calming/sinister.. Phill Collins squealing/stangulato falsetto at this point killed it for me
andrew price Phil’s vocals were WAY better on this song.
@@choppersquonk FOR SURE they were.
Nad's vocals are sound, the recording is duff but its better than nothing, Thanks for posting.
Welcome. Recorded with a simple Canon point and shoot cam, heh, from the last row in the balcony. Happy it came out well as it did. Apologies for taking long to acknowledge.
Great job!!! But, not one camera angle of the keyboard solo???!!!
I'll have to watch again. Using one cam I generally try to capture all band members for a good length of time. Some are more available and accessible from my angle than others. Sorry to miss this one.
Hogweed !!! Steve genius
Too bad the vocals don't make it in this version
I hate be critical of Nad as I've heard him do better. Still the song is amazing.
@@gimmeanidicanuse It's almost like he's got a mental block about singing Phil's stuff. Someone who sings Pete's stuff so well shouldn't have such a hard time with Phil's.
what did he say about Phil in the dvd ?
This should have made the record instead of "Your Own Special Way".....
Steve Compose create my god
Gorgeous! I'm sure to rile up some haters over this, but....There are some songs on "W&W" that are outright classics, and there are some I could do without. This could have easily replaced Mike's lame "Your Own Stupid Way." on side one. Or, even though I like it a lot, "Wot Gorilla" is just an extended jam of the second-to-last piece of "One For the Vine," "Inside and Out" could have replaced either song to round out side one. It really stood out when I listened to the 3-song EP and would have found a beautiful home on "W&W." Oh well, what Tony says, GOES (apparently)! No wonder Steve left in disgust. Glad to know their animosity has eased over the years but Tony, admittedly, was "a dick" to Steve, and was "a dick" about a lot of other things during this period (1976-1977). However, I agree with the others that "Please Don't Touch" WAS NOT good enough to be included here. "Inside and Out" however, WAS!!!
What a nice forgotten relic to revisit. Vocals are dreadfully off key and show tuney rather than vulnerable, likeable Phil, but great to hear Steve reproduce this live in an otherwise solid performance.
NEVER THE SAME AS BEFORE
from the EP 'MATCH OF THE DAY'
Spot The Pigeon you might say :D
Yes, from the EP Spot the Pigeon
Mike Rutherford is Mike :)
Interesting how they need two keyboardists to do what Tony Banks does....Banks is the best. Nav’s vocals a little pitchy on this song...
cette chanson aurait due etre sur l album Wind And Wuthering , c est une farce comparé a une autre que jene nommerai pas loololo just a joke loloololo anyway Steve a prouvé que ses compos étaient supérieur
Jean-Francois, Merci pour votre commentaire. Beaucoup de sens cette chanson devrait avoir été sur l'album. Dans ce temps c'était la technologie difficile pour diriger n'importe quelle longueur 50 minutes passées. Quelle chanson tomber est la question. Espérez que ma traduction est bonne.
Sounds cold, distant and flat, like everyone is trying to lay back and play quiet. Genesis is about extreme dynamics. I saw steve live a few years ago and it was a great setlist but i felt the same thing as on this footage, no dynamics
I know a lot of fans loved Wind and Wuthering but for me, Phil's influence on the band was edging Steve's stuff out too much.
Singer is appalling, end of.
Singer sounds a lot like Phil Collins.
Te gusta Hawkvind?