Love those old time historical movies ... including this one, Khartoum, Zulu, the Four Feathers, the older Erol Flynn India films, the films based on the Horatio Hornblower book series . .. even the newer Sharpe TV series.
No-one has mentioned Cleopatra, so I will... there are various versions, the best and most famous of which stars Elizabeth Taylor, of course... but there's also a charming British version with Vivian Leigh in the starring role based on a script by Noel Coward, if memory serves...
One of my life lessons came from this movie. I don’t remember the exact words, however, when Charlton Heston’s character declared that when a man becomes a father, he is now responsible, for all children are his….or something close. I have striven to uphold that challenge as a man, a father, and a professional Army officer. This video is awesome, thank you for your excellent storytelling.
And all the incidents, except the mutiny, were real events involving different British Gunboats. No American ones at all. We had 26, the Americans, 6. Gunboats on the Yangtze is an excellent book.
Since we are on the subject of The Boxer Rebellion , there were only two men who received the VC during the conflict Lewis Halliday of the Royal Marines and Basil Guy, midshipman. They both have awesome stories.
59 Americans received the Medal of Honor for services in the Boxer rebellion. Including, John Daily, one of only two Americans to ever have gotten two Medals of Honor. Over time, about 50% of the Medal of Honor recipients got it posthumously.
@@raywhitehead730 Chris mentioned a U.S. soldier of the 14th.Inf.Regiment bugler Calvin (Pearl) Titus scaling the wall to effect the U.S.Army contingent's entry of the city. Calvin Titus for his actions on that day (Aug.14,1900) would receive the Medal of Honor. Authorized on the 11-th of March 1902, presented to Titus on the 11-th of June 1902 by then President Theodore Roosevelt. Incidently his receipt of the Medal of Honor rewarded him an automatic appointment for a military academy. He was in the 1st summer as a cadet of West Point when the 26-th President placed the Medal of Honor around his neck on the parade ground of West Point. The story goes that fellow cadet 2-yrs. senior to cadet Titus, a cadet by the name of Douglas MacArthur (future Gen.MacArthur), came to congratulate his underclassman saying " I'd give my immortal soul for one of those ". His award presentation closed the celebration of West Point's 100th anniversary celebration that day in that year.
Yes. This is the first I've heard of anyone talk about 55 Days at Peking, I quite like it myself. It's from that era of movies where even if they're not exactly documentary levels of accurate, they're at least rollicking fun. And of course that can spawn someone's interest in the real thing, 55 Days at Peking is actually what got me interested in the Boxer Rebellion.
Thanks. Another outstanding video. I never would have guessed the historical link between the films, "The Sound of Music" and "55 Days in Peking." I always loved the film because of its storytelling as a high art, with it's star studded cast including John Ireland , Leo Genn, Flora Robson and Paul Lucas in supporting roles. Seeing films like this in my youth prompted me to learn the actual history of this incredible tale. Thanks again!
I find Herbert Hoover's background during the siege to be interesting. Many Presidents have or had military backgrounds serving in our military, whereas Hoover didn't have a military background he did take part as a civil engineer helping with the fortifications around the city, thus giving him some military experience despite never serving in America's military.
Caught in China during the Boxer Rebellion (1900), Hoover displayed his gift for humanitarian rescue by organizing relief for trapped foreigners. He drew on his China experience in 1914, when he helped Americans stranded in Europe at the outbreak of World War I. For the next three years, he headed the Commission for Relief in Belgium, overseeing what he called “the greatest charity the world has ever seen” and exhibiting impressive executive ability in helping to procure food for some nine million people whose country had been overrun by the German army. So skilled was Hoover’s performance that Pres. Woodrow Wilson appointed him U.S. food administrator for the duration of the war. Relying primarily on voluntary cooperation by the American public, Hoover won wide support for “wheatless” and “meatless” days so that as much of the nation’s agricultural output as possible could be sent to soldiers at the front. Recognized by war’s end as the “Great Engineer” who could organize resources and personnel to accomplish extraordinary acts of benevolence, Hoover was the natural choice to head the American Relief Administration. The ARA sent shiploads of food and other life-sustaining supplies to war-ravaged Europe-including Germany and Bolshevik Russia during the famine in that country in 1921-23. The outreach to Soviet Russia garnered Hoover much criticism, but he defended his actions on humanitarian grounds, saying, “Twenty million people are starving. Whatever their politics, they shall be fed.” < > BRITANNICA
I remember quite well the film 55 Days In Peking. It was for a young man a treat but not as sweet as the true factual account of the incident in which it is based upon. As one who has relatives in U.K and the U.S. I am exceedingly proud of the military heroism of those noble nations. It is a pity; however, to remember the aftermath of that little violent war. My heart goes out to the Chinese who suffered in the hands of both Boxers and The Relief Force. Once again thank you Sir for a riveting and brilliant video lecture on the subject of The Boxer Rebellion. I eagerly await your your next offering.
Great telling of the 55 day siege of the legations in Peking 😀 Though you omitted to mention the Australian involvement by George Ernest (Chinese) Morrison (“Morrison of Peking”)The Times Correspondent in Peking. Wholes books have been written of Morrison’s exploits as Doctor, adventurer, Journalist and advisor to the Chinese government in his later years. Morrison was a brave and engaged defender. He led groups of defenders to rescue Christians outside the walls and was wounded during the siege. Morrison survived the siege (despite his employer The Times printing his obituary) and received, as did several other civilians, a Peking Siege Medal.
First rate as ever and another fascinating but neglected part of history. The Siege of Peking by Peter Fleming (Ian’s brother) got me throughly engaged with this. Now many more will be enthused by your excellent video.
The book "The Boxer Rebellion" by Miranda Carter is a tremendous work. I started to describe why I think so but there's just so much to appreciate about this book! Highly recommend this book to anyone interested in the Boxer Rebellion. Edit: I'm sorry I credited the wrong author. The correct author for this book is Diana Preston.
@@tmorganriley I am so sorry! I'm mixing up my authors. The correct author is Diana Preston and the publication date is 1999 in the UK and 2000 in the US. The title is correct as stated above. In addition there's a descriptive notation on the front cover that reads: "The Dramatic Story of China's War on Foreigners That Shook the World in the Summer of 1900"
Nice one Chris I would love to see you do a history of the 2nd Battalion Royal Leicestershire Regiment, my father, Sergeant Arthur Clarke served in that regiment from 1940 to1945, starting with "The First Advance to Bengazi, then Crete, Syria, the Western Desert and Burma before going to Germany as part of the occupation force.I always loved his description of the Bengazi Advance which he described as abren carrier and two 3ton trucks," We pulled up outside Bengazi, a fortified Town surrounded by minefields, with concrete gun emplacements and while the officer was looking through his binoculars, the Italian flag was lowered, and the white flag raised" The evacuation from Crete, "During the morning a message was received saying at nightfall take to the hills, every man for himself, later that day a further message was received, hold your positions, the navy is coming to take us out" 2 destroyers and a cruiser but don't know which they were, but do know the cruiser was hit by stukas and had to return to Crete where it was beached.
One of my favorite parts of the movie “55 Days. . .” Is the part where the relief forces finally arrived, and the greetings exchanged when soldiers of the same nation among the defense and relief forces occur. What a contrast between the western forces and the Japanese forces in this regard!
WOW! I just discovered your channel and I LOVE IT! I just happened to watch the film, "55 Days At Peking" last night and hungrily devoured your documentary on the subject this morning. I'm both a history and a film buff. Being a huge fan of many of the historical wide screen epics of the 1950's and '60's I have always taken great pleasure in learning more about the true facts of a war or incident or period in history after viewing films involving those wars or incidents or periods. Your channel gives me, more or less, customized documentaries which do just this. I love your narration along with the excitement in your voice and the obvious joy you get from creating these videos. OH, if only history could be taught in such a way in high schools. I have subscribed with great joy and I give you my many thanks for providing such valuable content. Now I'm off to watch your two videos re General Gordon, since "Khartoum" is another one of my favorite films. All the best and keep those vids coming.
I loved this film as a kid and it encouraged me to model the Boxer conflict in one of my gaming projects last year. I was always fascinated by the international composition of the coalition and especially by the Japanese involvement. Yes please to opium war videos - certainly not Britain’s finest hour, amongst many
My grandfather was stationed in India in 1900 and his regiment was moved to the east coast to board ship for China, but the emergency was ended and they went back to quarters. I met an older English lady at a company I were I worked whose uncle was in the taking of Peking and came home a lot richer than when he left, looting I'm sure.
Thanks for another history lesson Chris! This one was indeed a lesson for me. A very interesting and nuanced story. I will definitely look at this film a very different way from now on. And the "Sound of Music" too
Thank you, Chris, the more I watch your video's the more I realized I needed to have paid closer attention to the subject when in history class at school. Thanks for another brilliant telling, Cheers.
Excellent telling of a now little remembered historical event. It's so interesting that the historical characters identified go on to play such other important parts. Also, like many of the film comparisons, let's keep in mind this is a drama, not a documentary.
My great grandfather was only 17 when he took part in the relief of Peking. He actually joined the Marines just before his 15th birthday. Lying about his age to escape poverty. He went on to become a Royal Marine gunner. He was posted to one of the battleships on the China station, just before the rebelion started. His service records show he took part in the disarming the Taku Forts. Before taking part in the relief of Peking. Needless to say his medals are cherished by the family.
My dad was a friend of Chuck as he liked to be called My dad was breaking horses for the movie The Savage when Dad was done with the string of horses. A man came over to him with a beer,and they to trailer and drank their beer with other actors 🎥🎥🎥
I wonder if Arthur MacArthur III's experience with Admiral Seymour's relief column influenced his brother Douglas's famous maxim about never fighting a land war in Asia.
Arthur MacArthur was the father of Douglas MacArthur. They were the only father, son duo to both be awarded the American Medal if Honor. Arthur got his clearing a charge in the American Civil War. Douglas lead a long, charmed military carrier: receiving his Medal of Honor in WW2. But Douglas had been nominated for a Medal of Honor 40 years, before that.
@@raywhitehead730I am a MacArthur fanboy myself in many regards, I was saddened to read West Point dismissed its old motto “Duty, Honor, Country” recently, which had been derived from MacArthur’s post-‘retirement’ speech. However, MacArthur’s MOH shouldn’t be held in the same esteem as other MOH recipients. After all, MacArthur wrote the citation himself. Nonetheless, MacArthur didn’t necessarily wish to get bogged down in conventional land warfare in Asia. As harsh as it may sound to our modern sensibilities, if MacArthur had been allowed to nuke China, less human beings would have suffered in totality, and a Chinese Communist state would have never materialized, millions would have been saved from starvation, and 5ere is a legitimate chance China would be a Christian nation. So Harry T. , was MacArthur really wrong now that we know what we know?
Dan Daly, one of the most legendary US Marines in the history of the Force earned his first Medal of Honor at the legation quarter. He held his position overnight with a machine gun. He held through the night alone as his compatriots tried to get back to him. They were unable to return til morning. When they heard the gun go quiet in the night they thought Dan had died. When they arrived in the morning they found 200 dead boxers and Dan leaning against the defensive wall. He ended up receiving another Medal of Honor during the invasion of Haiti. He should have gotten a third in WW1 but the paper pushers didn't like the idea of someone getting it 3 times. Ended up changing the rules to only allow it to be awarded once.
yeah i was bothered that his exploits didnt even get a mention in this vid... i guess he just didnt fight hard enough, hold out long enough and kill enough enemies.. *alone*.. im kidding, im sure this history chap had his reasons.. whatever, fat electrician did a good vid on him, even if its more comedy + history than dry history.. you'd think he would be mentioned though..
@@johnwright9372 that is interesting but Dan is a US Marine not UK. The Medal of Honor is a US award which at the time could be given as many times as it was earned.
Absolutely yes! I recall being taught about it in Year 11 History - my father was my teacher that year - and we joked that when a store of opium was burned all the druggies gathered downwind to "watch."
Thank you! I asked for a video about this siege some time back and you promised to make one, and so you have. Very interesting for me, especially so because I am a fan of the film. Again, sir, thank you.
My country Australia was still a collection of colonies,which were keen to help Great Britain. The colonies sent naval contingents and reservists as the bulk of the colonies were involved in the Boer war, and they arrived a bit late for major combat. They mainly did police,guard, and restoring civil order duties,6 died of illness,while they were away Australia became a federal commonwealth ,this alliance sure didn't last as these nations were involved in bitter wars in the following decades
Greetings from a new subscriber in Indonesia. Thank you for this well researched and well presented video, delivered fluently and clearly in a jolly English accent
Thank you for another great video. I did see this film when it came out. I also studied the Boxer Rebellion at school. All the best from Sydney Australia 🇦🇺
My Gt Grandfather served in the Royal Navy out of the China Station during the Boxer Rebellion and was in Tientsin for some time. I don't know what he observed in his time in China but he apparently told anyone who would listen afterwards to forget about anyone else, the Chinese not to be trusted.
@@evaristus4821He was serving in the Royal Navy running supplies to Tientsin from Hong Kong in aid of the international expedition to relieve the diplomatic quarter in Beijing. He went where the boat/ship he was serving on was ordered. If all you’re trying to do with your comment is cheap point-scoring take it elsewhere. This is a history, warts and all, channel not revisionist to suit an agenda.
Understand that the video has to end after covering the capture of Peking. The subsequent events were actually very interesting. The German General Waldersee took over the 8 Nation control after the Peking battles and the Chinese were un-cooperative to the foreigners in being reluctant to supply food and essentials to the occupiers, while the 8 Nations refused to drop the demand to arrest and try the Empress Dowager. The stand off was only ended by the effort of a famous prostitute called Sai Jin Hua who happened to be the former 2nd wife of the past Chinese Ambassador to Berlin and she had personally met Kaiser Wilhelm and Waldersee years before and she could speak German. Sai and Waldersee managed to strike a deal to end the occupation and unsurprisingly Sai was never thanked by both Empress Dowager and the 8 Nations and she passed away destitute in the 30s.
Thanks for this fascinating documentary Chris. My great Grandfather was involved in this conflict having run away from home to join the marines in 1897 at the age of 17 (he lied about his age). He was on the HMS Barfleur and then HMS Centurion and I believe was then part of Admiral Seymour's failed rescue mission. My grandma often mentioned about how her father was involved but it's only now I'm learning more. Thanks again.
On a tour of China, I asked the guide, where the Legations were when we were in Beijing. We were in Tienamin Square, the Forbidden City adjacent ( Royal family location?). The guide pointed to a massive building marked with Chinese govt insignia........ " Over there!" . The Boxer Rebellion didn't seem part of the curriculum of this propaganda tour:))) I confess I did view the area in the narrative of "55 Days"... than perhaps actual history... but it was hard to get much of an answer. The guide didn't appear allowed to deviate from the script?:)))
This was not the only Colonial War film for Niven either - one of his first major roles in Hollywood was in The Charge Of The Light Brigade with his good friend, Errol Flynn!!
@@jadger1871 no but most of the 1937 version is actually set in India!! I suggest you watch it OR at least read a synopsis of the film before commenting if you haven’t seen it!!
@@jadger1871 yes it was!! What planet are you on?? What on earth do you think the British Raj was then?! British Kings and Queens were also titled Emperor / Empress of India…
It's me again, Chris. Just had to watch the video again. The Boxer Rebellion is one of my favorite pieces of history. For me, this time in history has a real feeling of turning the corner from the 19th to the 20th century. I know that sounds goofy because it is a move into the new century but there's an honest to goodness feeling of dispensing with sand and sword, and adopting concrete and steel.
Hi Chris, I would appreciate hearing about the opuim wars. There was a book in the school library about it. I have forgotten the name of it as it was 50 years ago.
I’m now off to watch the film. Thank you very much for the reminder of a great film👍 it will be so much better watched now especially now I’ve watched your brilliant video😁 I will understand it a lot more than when I last watched it, 28 years ago😊👍 Great channel, thank you👍
i still occasionaly watch my copy of '55 days in Peking'. 🙂they don't make them like that anymore, eh. thx muchy for another upload, Chris (et al) 🇨🇦 😁 (sidenote: the “Edelweiss” song saga is fascinating)
@@TheHistoryChap short explanation: although Rodgers and Hammerstein wrote the tune in the late 50's for the film/play, on it's release so so many people considered it as basically a cover version of a ''beloved *classic*". to this day, most people believe that the song predates the movie. some of the 'exit interviews' of viewers lamenting the song are really quite fascinating. 😆 i'm not even sure what such mass psychosis is called 🤔
Another bit of movie trivia. The British sergeant major was played by a real sergeant major. RSM Ronald Brittain MBE. I read his biography, it's a great story. One you might want to put on your list. Cheers Ron
Very interesting story, thanks for telling it! Just one small thing: it's nice for people unfamiliar with history to mention the modern name of a city, but once that's been established once there's no need to repeat it every time you mention the historical name. It gets jarring after a while. A minimal gripe though, and as always I love how you turn historical events into a gripping story!
(At about 6:45) In case no one else has mentioned it, the Americans were commanded by Captain Bowman McCalla from the cruiser USS Newark, not by Arthur MacArthur III.
Yes, please Chris. Would be good to hear the real story of the Opium. Wars. I’ve heard a little about what happened then. However, your presentation is usually clearer, more truthful and factual. Including of course, some stories about those involved.
![Felix "Unfair" | [Stray Kids : SKZ-PLAYER]](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/Oswujxm2Ag0/mqdefault.jpg)
Love those old time historical movies ... including this one, Khartoum, Zulu, the Four Feathers, the older Erol Flynn India films, the films based on the Horatio Hornblower book series . .. even the newer Sharpe TV series.
Might I recommend the 1939 colour version of The Four Feathers, it's battle portrayals are quite well done.
You can throw in “Taras Bulba”one of my favorites including all that you mentioned..
Also El Cid with Charleston Heston.
@@karlsenula9495 “The Warlord “, The “Agony and the Ecstasy” “El CID” wow unbelievable movies,though I have admit historically dubious…
No-one has mentioned Cleopatra, so I will... there are various versions, the best and most famous of which stars Elizabeth Taylor, of course... but there's also a charming British version with Vivian Leigh in the starring role based on a script by Noel Coward, if memory serves...
One of my life lessons came from this movie. I don’t remember the exact words, however, when Charlton Heston’s character declared that when a man becomes a father, he is now responsible, for all children are his….or something close. I have striven to uphold that challenge as a man, a father, and a professional Army officer. This video is awesome, thank you for your excellent storytelling.
Thanks for watching my video and for taking the time to comment.
A priest told Heston every man is the father of every child
the priest said to him that all men are the fathers to all children
Charlton Heston, the best NRA chairman we ever have. The legacy of "From my cold, dead hand!" was totally squadered by Wayne LaPierre.
There was also a good Steve McQueen film about gun boat diplomacy - The Sand Pebbles.
Excellent film
And all the incidents, except the mutiny, were real events involving different British Gunboats. No American ones at all. We had 26, the Americans, 6.
Gunboats on the Yangtze is an excellent book.
Great movie
One of my all-time favorites.
@@ak9989It is an excellent film and holds a place in my heart as my dad's favorite.
Since we are on the subject of The Boxer Rebellion , there were only two men who received the VC during the conflict Lewis Halliday of the Royal Marines and Basil Guy, midshipman. They both have awesome stories.
59 Americans received the Medal of Honor for services in the Boxer rebellion. Including, John Daily, one of only two Americans to ever have gotten two Medals of Honor. Over time, about 50% of the Medal of Honor recipients got it posthumously.
@@raywhitehead730 Dan Daley
Should have had a third in ww1, but politicked down to navy cross
@@raywhitehead730 Chris mentioned a U.S. soldier of the 14th.Inf.Regiment bugler Calvin (Pearl) Titus scaling the wall to effect the U.S.Army contingent's entry of the city. Calvin Titus for his actions on that day (Aug.14,1900) would receive the Medal of Honor. Authorized on the 11-th of March 1902, presented to Titus on the 11-th of June 1902 by then President Theodore Roosevelt. Incidently his receipt of the Medal of Honor rewarded him an automatic appointment for a military academy. He was in the 1st summer as a cadet of West Point when the 26-th President placed the Medal of Honor around his neck on the parade ground of West Point. The story goes that fellow cadet 2-yrs. senior to cadet Titus, a cadet by the name of Douglas MacArthur (future Gen.MacArthur), came to congratulate his underclassman saying " I'd give my immortal soul for one of those ". His award presentation closed the celebration of West Point's 100th anniversary celebration that day in that year.
Thanks for watching my video & for your information
Yes.
This is the first I've heard of anyone talk about 55 Days at Peking, I quite like it myself. It's from that era of movies where even if they're not exactly documentary levels of accurate, they're at least rollicking fun. And of course that can spawn someone's interest in the real thing, 55 Days at Peking is actually what got me interested in the Boxer Rebellion.
Thanks for watching my video
Thanks. Another outstanding video. I never would have guessed the historical link between the films, "The Sound of Music" and "55 Days in Peking." I always loved the film because of its storytelling as a high art, with it's star studded cast including John Ireland , Leo Genn, Flora Robson and Paul Lucas in supporting roles. Seeing films like this in my youth prompted me to learn the actual history of this incredible tale. Thanks again!
Glad you enjoyed it, thanks for your comments.
I find Herbert Hoover's background during the siege to be interesting. Many Presidents have or had military backgrounds serving in our military, whereas Hoover didn't have a military background he did take part as a civil engineer helping with the fortifications around the city, thus giving him some military experience despite never serving in America's military.
Caught in China during the Boxer Rebellion (1900), Hoover displayed his gift for humanitarian rescue by organizing relief for trapped foreigners. He drew on his China experience in 1914, when he helped Americans stranded in Europe at the outbreak of World War I. For the next three years, he headed the Commission for Relief in Belgium, overseeing what he called “the greatest charity the world has ever seen” and exhibiting impressive executive ability in helping to procure food for some nine million people whose country had been overrun by the German army. So skilled was Hoover’s performance that Pres. Woodrow Wilson appointed him U.S. food administrator for the duration of the war. Relying primarily on voluntary cooperation by the American public, Hoover won wide support for “wheatless” and “meatless” days so that as much of the nation’s agricultural output as possible could be sent to soldiers at the front. Recognized by war’s end as the “Great Engineer” who could organize resources and personnel to accomplish extraordinary acts of benevolence, Hoover was the natural choice to head the American Relief Administration. The ARA sent shiploads of food and other life-sustaining supplies to war-ravaged Europe-including Germany and Bolshevik Russia during the famine in that country in 1921-23. The outreach to Soviet Russia garnered Hoover much criticism, but he defended his actions on humanitarian grounds, saying, “Twenty million people are starving. Whatever their politics, they shall be fed.” < > BRITANNICA
Hoover came from Quaker stock
Thanks for your feedback
I remember quite well the film 55 Days In Peking. It was for a young man a treat but not as sweet as the true factual account of the incident in which it is based upon. As one who has relatives in U.K and the U.S. I am exceedingly proud of the military heroism of those noble nations. It is a pity; however, to remember the aftermath of that little violent war. My heart goes out to the Chinese who suffered in the hands of both Boxers and The Relief Force. Once again thank you Sir for a riveting and brilliant video lecture on the subject of The Boxer Rebellion. I eagerly await your your next offering.
Thanks for watching my video & for taking the time to comment.
Great telling of the 55 day siege of the legations in Peking 😀
Though you omitted to mention the Australian involvement by George Ernest (Chinese) Morrison (“Morrison of Peking”)The Times Correspondent in Peking.
Wholes books have been written of Morrison’s exploits as Doctor, adventurer, Journalist and advisor to the Chinese government in his later years.
Morrison was a brave and engaged defender. He led groups of defenders to rescue Christians outside the walls and was wounded during the siege.
Morrison survived the siege (despite his employer The Times printing his obituary) and received, as did several other civilians, a Peking Siege Medal.
Another interesting detail and another interesting character remembered, thanks to you.
Thanks for your feedback
First rate as ever and another fascinating but neglected part of history. The Siege of Peking by Peter Fleming (Ian’s brother) got me throughly engaged with this. Now many more will be enthused by your excellent video.
Thanks for watching my video, glad you enjoyed it.
The book "The Boxer Rebellion" by Miranda Carter is a tremendous work. I started to describe why I think so but there's just so much to appreciate about this book! Highly recommend this book to anyone interested in the Boxer Rebellion.
Edit: I'm sorry I credited the wrong author. The correct author for this book is Diana Preston.
Outstanding book indeed !
I can't find this book referenced anywhere online. Is the name / title right?
@@tmorganriley I am so sorry! I'm mixing up my authors. The correct author is Diana Preston and the publication date is 1999 in the UK and 2000 in the US. The title is correct as stated above. In addition there's a descriptive notation on the front cover that reads: "The Dramatic Story of China's War on Foreigners That Shook the World in the Summer of 1900"
@@cynthiaalver Found it. Thanks for the recommendation!
Thanks for watching my video & for sharing the book details
Nice one Chris I would love to see you do a history of the 2nd Battalion Royal Leicestershire Regiment, my father, Sergeant Arthur Clarke served in that regiment from 1940 to1945, starting with "The First Advance to Bengazi, then Crete, Syria, the Western Desert and Burma before going to Germany as part of the occupation force.I always loved his description of the Bengazi Advance which he described as abren carrier and two 3ton trucks," We pulled up outside Bengazi, a fortified Town surrounded by minefields, with concrete gun emplacements and while the officer was looking through his binoculars, the Italian flag was lowered, and the white flag raised"
The evacuation from Crete, "During the morning a message was received saying at nightfall take to the hills, every man for himself, later that day a further message was received, hold your positions, the navy is coming to take us out" 2 destroyers and a cruiser but don't know which they were, but do know the cruiser was hit by stukas and had to return to Crete where it was beached.
Thanks for taking the time to comment & for watching my video
Really enjoyed the movie when i was a kid, Heston and Niven were a good combo
Niven, was a real British hero in WW2. He was an officer in the Army.
Thanks for watching my video
One of my favorite parts of the movie “55 Days. . .” Is the part where the relief forces finally arrived, and the greetings exchanged when soldiers of the same nation among the defense and relief forces occur. What a contrast between the western forces and the Japanese forces in this regard!
Thanks for commenting & for watching my video
Another good episode. I love it how you tie events from the future, past of pop culture (movies) together.
Glad you enjoyed it.
WOW! I just discovered your channel and I LOVE IT! I just happened to watch the film, "55 Days At Peking" last night and hungrily devoured your documentary on the subject this morning. I'm both a history and a film buff. Being a huge fan of many of the historical wide screen epics of the 1950's and '60's I have always taken great pleasure in learning more about the true facts of a war or incident or period in history after viewing films involving those wars or incidents or periods. Your channel gives me, more or less, customized documentaries which do just this. I love your narration along with the excitement in your voice and the obvious joy you get from creating these videos. OH, if only history could be taught in such a way in high schools. I have subscribed with great joy and I give you my many thanks for providing such valuable content. Now I'm off to watch your two videos re General Gordon, since "Khartoum" is another one of my favorite films. All the best and keep those vids coming.
Thanks again, Chris, great research ! That was a lot of work...
Many thanks. If you enjoy my work, please do subscribe to my channel.
A very different perspective from that presented in the movie. Loved your presentation. Thanks.
One of my favorite old school movies.
If you didn't fall in love with Ava Gardner, there was something wrong with you.😉
Love this movie. Also, The Sand Pebbles with Steve McQueen is another favorite along the same historical lines.
What is a woman 🤡🌏
Well,Frank Sinatra did,and it drove him round the bend,apparently.
Thanks for watching my video
@@TheHistoryChap You're very welcome!
Enthralling video once again, Chris. And a resounding YES as you requested.
Glad you enjoyed it.
Just rewatched the film and was delighted to see another excellent presentation by Mr Green. Stellar work yet again, great channel!
Thanks for watching, glad you enjoyed my video
I loved this film as a kid and it encouraged me to model the Boxer conflict in one of my gaming projects last year. I was always fascinated by the international composition of the coalition and especially by the Japanese involvement. Yes please to opium war videos - certainly not Britain’s finest hour, amongst many
Thanks for watching my video and for your comments.
My grandfather was stationed in India in 1900 and his regiment was moved to the east coast to board ship for China, but the emergency was ended and they went back to quarters. I met an older English lady at a company I were I worked whose uncle was in the taking of Peking and came home a lot richer than when he left, looting I'm sure.
Fascinating.
Thanks for watching & for taking the time to share your family story
BB h
Yes . Thanks for the well written content too.
28:08 “The Wind and the Lion” superb movie.
Thanks for the feedback
Terrific presentation; a lot of background that was new to me.
And, definitely, yes.
Thanks for watching, glad you enjoyed my video
Thanks for another history lesson Chris! This one was indeed a lesson for me. A very interesting and nuanced story. I will definitely look at this film a very different way from now on. And the "Sound of Music" too
Thanks for watching, glad you enjoyed it.
Great work. I really enjoy your videos and find them very interesting. Thank you.
Glad you enjoy my videos, thanks for watching
Great video today thanks for what you do and keep them coming 👍
Glad you enjoyed my video, thanks for watching.
Thank you, Chris, the more I watch your video's the more I realized I needed to have paid closer attention to the subject when in history class at school. Thanks for another brilliant telling, Cheers.
Glad you enjoyed it.
Another 5 star video from the History Chap!
Glad you enjoyed it.
Great topic, you continue to amaze.
Thanks for watching , glad you enjoyed my video
Excellent telling of a now little remembered historical event. It's so interesting that the historical characters identified go on to play such other important parts. Also, like many of the film comparisons, let's keep in mind this is a drama, not a documentary.
Glad you enjoyed it, thanks for watching
Another splendid episode. Well done sir.
Glad you enjoyed it.
Yes! I thoroughly enjoyed the story of the siege of Peking. It did show the resolve of all of the nations involved. Well done, amigo.
Glad you enjoyed it. Thanks
Working through your back catalogs and came upon this gem. An excellent video packed full of interesting characters and factual detail.
Thanks for watching and your comment.
"The hills are alive with the sound of the Boxer rebellion."😄
Good one!
Thanks for your comment!
Thanks!
Thank you for your kind donation
My great grandfather was only 17 when he took part in the relief of Peking. He actually joined the Marines just before his 15th birthday. Lying about his age to escape poverty. He went on to become a Royal Marine gunner. He was posted to one of the battleships on the China station, just before the rebelion started. His service records show he took part in the disarming the Taku Forts. Before taking part in the relief of Peking. Needless to say his medals are cherished by the family.
thanks for watching my video & for taking the time to share your family story.
Yes.Also I had always known of the Boxer rebellion but had not known why it was named so, until I watched your podcast.Cheers.
Glad you found it interesting.
My dad was a friend of Chuck as he liked to be called My dad was breaking horses for the movie The Savage when Dad was done with the string of horses. A man came over to him with a beer,and they to trailer and drank their beer with other actors 🎥🎥🎥
Thanks for watching my video & for taking the time to share your family story
I have been waiting for this video... loved this movie.
Thanks for watching my video
I wonder if Arthur MacArthur III's experience with Admiral Seymour's relief column influenced his brother Douglas's famous maxim about never fighting a land war in Asia.
Arthur MacArthur was the father of Douglas MacArthur. They were the only father, son duo to both be awarded the American Medal if Honor. Arthur got his clearing a charge in the American Civil War. Douglas lead a long, charmed military carrier: receiving his Medal of Honor in WW2. But Douglas had been nominated for a Medal of Honor 40 years, before that.
Leading a charge
Thanks for watching & your feedback
@@raywhitehead730I am a MacArthur fanboy myself in many regards, I was saddened to read West Point dismissed its old motto “Duty, Honor, Country” recently, which had been derived from MacArthur’s post-‘retirement’ speech. However, MacArthur’s MOH shouldn’t be held in the same esteem as other MOH recipients. After all, MacArthur wrote the citation himself. Nonetheless, MacArthur didn’t necessarily wish to get bogged down in conventional land warfare in Asia. As harsh as it may sound to our modern sensibilities, if MacArthur had been allowed to nuke China, less human beings would have suffered in totality, and a Chinese Communist state would have never materialized, millions would have been saved from starvation, and 5ere is a legitimate chance China would be a Christian nation. So Harry T. , was MacArthur really wrong now that we know what we know?
Yes I really enjoyed watching that movie. Thank you Chris for a fascinating video.👍
Thanks for watching & glad you enjoyed my video
Dan Daly, one of the most legendary US Marines in the history of the Force earned his first Medal of Honor at the legation quarter.
He held his position overnight with a machine gun. He held through the night alone as his compatriots tried to get back to him. They were unable to return til morning. When they heard the gun go quiet in the night they thought Dan had died. When they arrived in the morning they found 200 dead boxers and Dan leaning against the defensive wall.
He ended up receiving another Medal of Honor during the invasion of Haiti. He should have gotten a third in WW1 but the paper pushers didn't like the idea of someone getting it 3 times. Ended up changing the rules to only allow it to be awarded once.
yeah i was bothered that his exploits didnt even get a mention in this vid... i guess he just didnt fight hard enough, hold out long enough and kill enough enemies.. *alone*.. im kidding, im sure this history chap had his reasons.. whatever, fat electrician did a good vid on him, even if its more comedy + history than dry history.. you'd think he would be mentioned though..
UK decorations are not awarded twice but can receive a bar with them.
@@johnwright9372 that is interesting but Dan is a US Marine not UK. The Medal of Honor is a US award which at the time could be given as many times as it was earned.
Thanks for your feedback & for watching my video
Great story
Yes please more on the topic would be appreciated
Thanks for watching my video, glad you enjoyed it.
Absolutely yes! I recall being taught about it in Year 11 History - my father was my teacher that year - and we joked that when a store of opium was burned all the druggies gathered downwind to "watch."
Thanks for taking the time to share your family story.
Thank you! I asked for a video about this siege some time back and you promised to make one, and so you have. Very interesting for me, especially so because I am a fan of the film. Again, sir, thank you.
Glad you enjoyed it.
6:26 …yes, please sir!
Thanks for your vote
Yes please 👍
Encore une excellente leçon d'histoire. Merci pour votre travail passionnant.
Thanks for watching my video, glad you enjoyed it.
My country Australia was still a collection of colonies,which were keen to help Great Britain. The colonies sent naval contingents and reservists as the bulk of the colonies were involved in the Boer war, and they arrived a bit late for major combat. They mainly did police,guard, and restoring civil order duties,6 died of illness,while they were away Australia became a federal commonwealth ,this alliance sure didn't last as these nations were involved in bitter wars in the following decades
Thanks for sharing comments.
Greetings from a new subscriber in Indonesia. Thank you for this well researched and well presented video, delivered fluently and clearly in a jolly English accent
Thanks for your support. Much appreciated.
To your question, video(s) on the opium wars, YES please
Thanks & thanks for watching my video
Brilliant work as usual thanks Chris!
Yes, for the story as well.
Glad you enjoyed it.
I always liked the Steve McQueen movie the Sand Pebbles on this subject. Kind of a long winded movie at times. But this entire thing was very scary
Thanks for watching my video
Thank you for another great video. I did see this film when it came out. I also studied the Boxer Rebellion at school. All the best from Sydney Australia 🇦🇺
Thanks for your comments, glad you enjoyed my video
My Gt Grandfather served in the Royal Navy out of the China Station during the Boxer Rebellion and was in Tientsin for some time. I don't know what he observed in his time in China but he apparently told anyone who would listen afterwards to forget about anyone else, the Chinese not to be trusted.
Thanks for sharing. He must have had some interesting stories to tell.
That advice holds true. Smart ancestor.
Don't trust a racist English man as well
What was he doing in China? Who invited him there?
@@evaristus4821He was serving in the Royal Navy running supplies to Tientsin from Hong Kong in aid of the international expedition to relieve the diplomatic quarter in Beijing. He went where the boat/ship he was serving on was ordered. If all you’re trying to do with your comment is cheap point-scoring take it elsewhere. This is a history, warts and all, channel not revisionist to suit an agenda.
Thank you for increasing my knowledge of the Boxer Rebellion. I learned a lot from your covering this.
Thanks for watching my video & for your comment.
The greatest sound you can here if besieged as a British or Commonwealth soldier is the skirl of the Pipes of the Scottish Division
*hear.
Oh, aye1
Thanks for your comment & for watching my video
Most interesting story. It's funny how characters also link to other stories in history. Thankyou so much. I'm looking forward to more.
Glad you enjoyed it & thanks for watching.
Understand that the video has to end after covering the capture of Peking. The subsequent events were actually very interesting. The German General Waldersee took over the 8 Nation control after the Peking battles and the Chinese were un-cooperative to the foreigners in being reluctant to supply food and essentials to the occupiers, while the 8 Nations refused to drop the demand to arrest and try the Empress Dowager. The stand off was only ended by the effort of a famous prostitute called Sai Jin Hua who happened to be the former 2nd wife of the past Chinese Ambassador to Berlin and she had personally met Kaiser Wilhelm and Waldersee years before and she could speak German. Sai and Waldersee managed to strike a deal to end the occupation and unsurprisingly Sai was never thanked by both Empress Dowager and the 8 Nations and she passed away destitute in the 30s.
Thanks for watching my video & for your feedback.
Thanks for this fascinating documentary Chris. My great Grandfather was involved in this conflict having run away from home to join the marines in 1897 at the age of 17 (he lied about his age). He was on the HMS Barfleur and then HMS Centurion and I believe was then part of Admiral Seymour's failed rescue mission.
My grandma often mentioned about how her father was involved but it's only now I'm learning more.
Thanks again.
Thanks for watching my video & fir sharing your family story.
On a tour of China, I asked the guide, where the Legations were when we were in Beijing. We were in Tienamin Square, the Forbidden City adjacent ( Royal family location?). The guide pointed to a massive building marked with Chinese govt insignia........ " Over there!" . The Boxer Rebellion didn't seem part of the curriculum of this propaganda tour:))) I confess I did view the area in the narrative of "55 Days"... than perhaps actual history... but it was hard to get much of an answer. The guide didn't appear allowed to deviate from the script?:)))
Thanks for your feedback
Your videos are superb. Your enthusiasm for history is infectious. Thanks for the hard work you do.
Thanks for your comments.
This was not the only Colonial War film for Niven either - one of his first major roles in Hollywood was in The Charge Of The Light Brigade with his good friend, Errol Flynn!!
The Crimean War wasn't a colonial war.
@@jadger1871 no but most of the 1937 version is actually set in India!! I suggest you watch it OR at least read a synopsis of the film before commenting if you haven’t seen it!!
Thanks for watching my video your comment.
@@seanford2358 India wasn't a colony either.
@@jadger1871 yes it was!! What planet are you on?? What on earth do you think the British Raj was then?! British Kings and Queens were also titled Emperor / Empress of India…
Another superbly narrated piece of history on one of my favourite channels 😊 - can‘t wait for the next one…
Thanks for your comment & for watching my video
Yes for the Opium Wars video(s)
Thanks.
It's me again, Chris. Just had to watch the video again. The Boxer Rebellion is one of my favorite pieces of history. For me, this time in history has a real feeling of turning the corner from the 19th to the 20th century. I know that sounds goofy because it is a move into the new century but there's an honest to goodness feeling of dispensing with sand and sword, and adopting concrete and steel.
Glad you enjoyed my video, second time around. Thanks.
Yes! Please talk about the Opium War!
Thanks for your comment.
Yay! Great to chat during the live today.
Thanks for joining in. I really do enjoy engaging with my viewers.
yes
thanks
Yes, enjoying this Peking video much..well done❤
Glad you enjoyed it, thanks for watching.
Ahhh, those were the days. “Proper” movies, with real actors…
Thanks for watching my video
Yes
thanks
Another brilliant presentation sir!!!!
Glad you enjoyed it, thanks.
YES
thanks
So excited to see this one, another brave and stirring moment in Western military history. Great job as ever.
Glad you enjoyed it.
You know it's gonna be a good video when at 3:48 there's that moustache to greet you
Thanks for watching my video
I enjoyed this video. I remember seeing the movie ages ago. History is so strange with its twists and wrinkles.
Thanks for the comment & for watching my video
Hi Chris, I would appreciate hearing about the opuim wars. There was a book in the school library about it. I have forgotten the name of it as it was 50 years ago.
thanks for watching, hope you enjoy my opium war videos.
Very well done as always 🙂
Hope all is well take care 🙂
Glad you enjoyed it.
That was really interesting especially the links to people Hoover and Von Trapp
Thank you
Glad you enjoyed it.
Yes, Please and Thank You
Nicely presented....now I'll have to source a copy of 55 Days In Peking.
its on youtube
Thanks for watching my video
Great video indeed thanks for sharing.
Glad you enjoyed it.
I’m now off to watch the film. Thank you very much for the reminder of a great film👍 it will be so much better watched now especially now I’ve watched your brilliant video😁 I will understand it a lot more than when I last watched it, 28 years ago😊👍
Great channel, thank you👍
Thanks for watching my video & for taking the time to comment.
Well done!
Thanks for watching, glad you enjoyed my video.
Thank you for this fascinating video! 👍🏻
Glad you enjoyed it, thanks for watching
I’d love you to do story surrounding “The Last Emperor”!
Thanks for watching my video, glad you enjoyed it.
Nicely presented....now I'll have to source a copy of 55 Days In Peking.
.....Yes to a video on The Opium Wars.
Thanks for watching my video.
i still occasionaly watch my copy of '55 days in Peking'. 🙂they don't make them like that anymore, eh.
thx muchy for another upload, Chris (et al)
🇨🇦 😁 (sidenote: the “Edelweiss” song saga is fascinating)
You've got my interest with your last comment.
@@TheHistoryChap short explanation: although Rodgers and Hammerstein wrote the tune in the late 50's for the film/play, on it's release so so many people considered it as basically a cover version of a ''beloved *classic*". to this day, most people believe that the song predates the movie. some of the 'exit interviews' of viewers lamenting the song are really quite fascinating. 😆
i'm not even sure what such mass psychosis is called 🤔
Love your videos!
Thanks for watching my video, glad you enjoyed it.
Still hoping for your take on the battle of Mirbat
I will add this to my ever growing list
@@TheHistoryChap Thank you very much.
Another great episode, putting the facts in place, names, and pictures of the real heroes, compared to the "swashbuckling" movie.
Glad you enjoyed it.
Another bit of movie trivia. The British sergeant major was played by a real sergeant major. RSM Ronald Brittain MBE. I read his biography, it's a great story. One you might want to put on your list. Cheers Ron
Thanks for watching my video & for the feedback
Very interesting story, thanks for telling it! Just one small thing: it's nice for people unfamiliar with history to mention the modern name of a city, but once that's been established once there's no need to repeat it every time you mention the historical name. It gets jarring after a while. A minimal gripe though, and as always I love how you turn historical events into a gripping story!
Thanks for watching & for your feedback.
Excellent thanks 👏👏yes to the opium episode 👍😁
I have done 3 about those wars.
Cracking video thanks Chris.
Glad you enjoyed it.
(At about 6:45) In case no one else has mentioned it, the Americans were commanded by Captain Bowman McCalla from the cruiser USS Newark, not by Arthur MacArthur III.
Yes, please Chris.
Would be good to hear the real story of the Opium. Wars.
I’ve heard a little about what happened then. However, your presentation is usually clearer, more truthful and factual. Including of course, some stories about those involved.
Thanks for watching my video & for your comments.