Meloni’s (Controversial) Plan to Rescue Italy - VisualPolitik EN
HTML-код
- Опубликовано: 29 окт 2022
- Join the VisualPolitik community and support us on Patreon: / visualpolitik
Finally the political earthquake in Italy has taken place. Giorgia Meloni, the candidate of the Fratelli d'Italia party, not only won the elections but her coalition with Salvini's Lega and Berlusconi's Forza Italia won a large majority. This has unleashed uncertainty and even fear among both the international media and the European Union institutions themselves.
So the question is, is Giorgia Meloni really a fascist? Is her victory a threat to democracy? What exactly are her proposals and political commitments? What could her victory mean for the country of Valentino Rossi, Enzo Ferrari and Giorgio Armani? In this video we tell you all the details.
I think we need to understand that nationalism isn't always a bad thing. If we critically examine some of the negatives of globalism (loss of several sectors of work in various countries, mass refugees inflows, and a increasing wealth inequality), we have to realize that protecting your own country does not necessarily mean you hate other people but that you want to prioritize the good of your own.
yeah but those days if you don't value MORE (not equal BUT MORE) random African immigrants over your own nationals = you are Nazi ... what a sad reality we live in.
Well said
Mass immigration is probably the only thing negative to west apart from that Globalism has helped Western civilisation more than any other part of the world
Natonalism never was a bad thing. Dont confuse nazism and nationalism
A good country should be open to global markets but also be able to preserve and promote their own, a little of healthy nationalism is important imo. Like, I did not vote for Meloni or her shit party nor her shit coalition, and I don't care for any right wing crap, but Italy has been letting foreign business buy and bastardize our industries and products, let industries flee to eastern european countries and others bring business to extra-european cheap labour, with the tacit agreement of previous right, left, center parties and that's bad.
I feel like the term "right" and "left" are way too old to describe the complex political spectrum of today's world.
Any other term would not allow people to go " our side vs the other side" in order to stop those communist or in order to stop those facists. It would not allow fearmongering.
You are right. I was thinking the same thing
It is not the term are too old but just too broad
Your correct inclusivity verses exclusivity, meist verse ourist, Black and White vs Grey and globalism verses nationalism..
I've been saying this for over a decade.
I am sure many Indians are going to discover this video today after she visited India during the G20 summit. I have often heard of her being the "rise of fascism" and whatnot, but thank you for making a proper, detailed view of what she stands for.
i think indians like fascist leaders like modi .. i mean the fascist ideology
Rise of fascism when families from your country came to Italy to be supported! They don't like work, they don't integrate, they come to Italy and have 4, 5 children each to obtain rights but they don't work a day and are completely supported by the Italian state which taxes the workers so that it can support thousands of migrants like you who take advantage of the Italian law and their goodwill! Adult girls are forced to marry their cousins, otherwise they are killed, even last year a girl was killed for this reason in Italy by her parents, then they fled to their country so as not to be received and you tell to peoplle that Meloni is Fascist! She is a strong and very intelligent woman! You male her a fascist because she won't let you make fun of her country! For that I congratulate her and consider her an example! But Meloni is not a fascist! That's what haters say!
As an Italian, Italy is ruled only on the immediate crisis and emergencies, like covid, earthquake, immigrants, war, debt, all problems in a short term without any prospective for the long period. That absence of strategy is the undoing for the country
Nah, you'll be fine. You're like Turkey, but in a more favourable position and with a more accomplished history , culture and all.
If Turks are confident they'll get through this inferno one way or another, Italia should yell and fight its way too.
Insieme....
@@subutaynoyan5372 there arent any secessions in turkey right?
Say thanks to Anglo-Americans dude...we couldn't have a vision for the future cause we are an outer colony of the dollar empire
@@jmgonzales7701 No, there are some Kurdish ethno-nationalists but they're not even representing actual Kurdish populace.
@@David-my2iz Non dire cretinate! L'Italia è uno Stato satellite degli Stati Uniti non colonia. Noi italiani abbiamo sempre avuto la possibilità di scegliere i nostri governanti. Ed è proprio quello che si deve smettere di fare.
Italy has such amazing architecture.
Well it was the greatest civiliization during its time
@@jmgonzales7701 modern Italy has little to do with ancient Rome. Apart from the geography.
That's all they got 😅
@@jdd5886 come to Italy to figure out what we have beside the architecture
@@jdd5886 racist
It's not what Meloni and her party think, it's what the Italian public think and she understands that. The same thing is happening all over Europe. The drift to the right is inevitable because the current establishment is failing to provide people the wealth and security they think is normal. We are witnessing a ground roots protest by numbers and a rejection of the established order. It's happening everywhere.
I'm in agreement,its happening in the US too. The years of massive deficits without ever a notion of how to pay it back to fuel economic bubbles disguised as "growth" on top of forced cultural consensus by technocrats within government bureaucracy is backfiring.
yep imagine people can't listen to rainbow filth anymore when thiers bills go up and fridge is empty ... yeah because at that point racism and LGBT are most important right ? Go figure :)
Urzędnicy w UE nie maja mandatu do sprawowania rządów. Nie są wybrani w wyborach są z mianowani przez grupy wpływu.. To oni decydują który naród w wyborach dokonał poprawnego ,legalnego wyboru. To jest koniec demokracji w EU. Podobnie jak było w Zymie . Prędzej wybiorą konia na sentora i dziwkę nim pozwolą na samodecydowanie ludziom..:)
You will eat zee bugs.
Uk was right wing...
You go lady..Putting the Italian people first..I wish you where here in the UK..Respect to you..👋👋👋👋👋👋👋🏴🏴🏴
no immigrants please, we don't want them
Thank you. Let Italy be Italian.
For me, Italy is one of the most important countries in the world from a cultural standpoint. It might very well be the true heart of Europe. I wish Meloni and Italy well.
No its not .... All countries are important in Europe. And with amount od imigrnats they are done
Why is that? Because of rome? The catholic church has no power anymore. I would argue that greece is the real heart of europe. It is the beginning of modern logic and western ideas. Britain and france also have good cases, as the beginnings of capitalism and democracy.
Because of the Italian people. Their culture, language, the essence of what makes Italy, Italy (a unique passionate people).
It would be a tragedy if my great grand children in the distant future visits Italy, but isn't able to experience Italy.
It's something precious that needs to be preserved.
The essence of what made Ancient Greece, Ancient Greece only exists in the past now...its gone now after the Romans, Turks, etc turned it into something else (still special, but something different from the spirit and essence of Classical Greece)
I'm from Africa, so I don't have a dog in this fight.
@@mrastronaut9078 ROME is the birth of Western civilization and Democracy. ITALY INVENTED Capitalism, Banks, Universities, even cement. And that's just for starters. Without the above the world as we know it would not exist. Italy has the #1 history achievements and inventors.
@@mrastronaut9078 do you know that both roman empire and commons period/renaissance in Italy were economically capitalistics? Britain didn't invent anything new in this area, just applied what other people has been doing for millennia
as an italian, i'm really surprised how you managed to accurately describe the messy italian politics without falling in the lazy simplification typical of foreigner opinionists.
you really know how to do your job, CHAPEAU
🤨bruh
But he forgot to say the reason why Italy hasn't been developing for more than 20 years: euro
@@itsmeandrea138 As if that was the reason
@@fra604 Una delle tante ragioni, a partire dallo smantellamento delle grandi imprese pubbliche italiane per importi di centinaia di miliardi di euro, ad arrivare alle manovre scelerate fatte tra anni '80 e '90 volte a ingrassare artificialmente il debito pubblico. Tant'è che ormai siamo diventati come un'azienda, 'non si può fare nulla' perché bisogna seguire la ferrea religione germanica della diminuzione del debito.
Le cause sono tante, e probabilmente uscire dall'UE adesso ci indebolirebbe solo, ma fidati che se non ci fossimo mai entrati saremmo un paese diverso, più prospero.
@@itsmeandrea138 Hai ragione solo per metà, gli anni '80 e '90 sono stati la svolta per il peggio. Ma nel periodo di Berlusconi avremmo potuto diventare un'economia molto migliore e riparare i danni dei decenni scorsi, il problema è che non l'abbiamo fatto ed è arrivata la crisi del 2008. Certo, l'euro ci ha impedito di usare l'inflazione, ma l'inflazione è stata un cerotto che non poteva funzionare a lungo, un cerotto usato dai nostri politici per evitare di risolvere problemi strutturali. Quei problemi sono solamente colpa della nostra classe politica, non possiamo scaricarla alla Germania o al Belgio
If only mainstream news worked as hard as this channel to be even-handed. Gives you a lot to think about. Great work as always.
They work very hard...... to deceive us, and hide the truth.
Imagine not wanting your country to be overrun by a foreígn group and because you don’t want that they call you a facíst 🤷♂️. Now look up who in Italy is responsibłe for much of the víolent críme, here is a hint, it isn’t Italians.
They are not even close to even handed, she is not radical in the slightest, just conservative
I tottaly think that she has a lot of good points. If i was Italian, i would vote for her. Greatings from Poland PL
Same, as a Norwegian
same as a Belgian, no immigration from Africans and Middle EAst people
I'm an Italian from Germany and here the media is totally hating on Meloni and the new Italian government. Obviously, their fear is that Italy is going to be more self-confident and not as devout as in the past 20 years. Germany and France do dominate the EU and they dislike the fact that someone like Italy might ask for too much.
well, this is the main problem with the EU.
not every member of this supposed "union" has the same level of equal say in political matters.
I'm a Romanian living also in Germany and the politicians of my home country are lapdogs of the EU.
foot soldiers and pawns doing whatever the EU asks them to do.
I think Hitler would be so proud of today's Germany having so much power over Europe.
Bingo, the same case with Poland and Hungary. Germans and French using the EU have been hunting conservative governments for years. Now, the left is using EU funds to starve Poland and Hungary in those difficult times.
like you said , the EU is dominated by Germany and France and before also the UK . And look at the EU - it is a disaster in every way - Eurozone is virtual bankrupt, economy is a disaster; immigration, energy ... Europe is depending on the rest of the world
@@MrRocking4ever we do not have a lot of Fossil fuels, of course we are Energy depentend on other Nations. Its a question of which cock we decide to suck in order to get them.
Well said friend,this control must end now!!
Hehe, love this channel, but hearing a British man side talk about how often the government of another country has been changing really did give me a giggle!
Oh trust me he knows the political idiocy of GB as well. Most British people do. They just can't do anything about it or don't know what to do about it. Britian is a fickle system that gets confusing by the day like most. The more you try to think of ideas the less possible it is. They need a whole new democratic republic system for anything to change in the slightest there. Too much flip flopping and lack of true leadership. Nothing to hold them in a prime focus to keep moving on an ideal. The only thing that has changed in Britain that mattered is brexit and they still haven't picked up the pieces from there. Britain is a wild ride to watch and entertains me everytime I watch it.
@@charliescene786 That's why it made me giggle. Was not commenting to disparage, just because it amused me.
I think he's a Scott. And the UK recently developed this hobby, the Italians and Israelis are the world leaders in the business of changing government's, infact Japan is probably no3.
@@adhirbose9910 Japan has been a de-facto one party state for awhile, so I don't really know what you mean.
@@nevets2371 true, but the no of government's? Bdw, which political party did the last 3 UK PM's belong to?
She honestly seems like a normal conservative just with a lot more passion. Her views aren't radical, her energy is.
Bravo
I just hope she stays with her current views.
In she goes back to her past, I would see it as a problem. Her promises she made this election, are quite moderate.
@@paulb6149 I hope everyone over the age of 30 does the same.
@@danielortman2534 lol
@@danielortman2534 yeah but not everyone was praising fascism in their youth years :D
Here in uk we need a Georgio …..asap
I do agree with the thought process of Meloni, the points she highlights are really genuine and must be echoing in Italian hearts, the problem with her is she is going to have mental and emotional break down, when/if she was not able to achieve what she promised and might not be able to come back.
So Italian brothers please support her and assist in reducing the debt on the country.
Also, one way we could help each is by increasing trade with many countries, sign-in FTA, collaboration on space missions basically a more engagement with rest of the world rather just Europe.
Love from India 🇮🇳
The Niger and Nigeria stuff is sooooo true. And printing currency for 14 African countries and holding 80% of their reserve in France is also true
That's just business 101 and is not like the US and UK the Twinkie twins haven't done the same thing many many many MANY TIMES BEFORE except France hasn't been quite as ruthless as those 2 have been. Simply look at India and any place in middle or South America and you'll find plenty examples dare I say sugar and banana. Damn I forgot the Silk Road "opium road"
@@Justatackit the difference is they stopped and France still continued.
You know, Fascism hate France
there some type of irony as Right tends value economy over rights, but to speak France exploitation as bad seems be of rights
Her fact about 90 pct of Nigerians not having electricity is wrong though. About 55 pct have electricity these days.
I think many people forget to mention that she recently clarified that she doesn’t want to leave the EU or the euro at all and that she even hopes the EU will be capable to act faster and more firmly in matters such as foreign policy in the future
Obviously she said she doesn't want to leave the EU since without the huge sums of money the EU is giving to Italy (Recovery Fund) the country would be in complete ruin, she is not stupid.
@@scottishfold7929 she is nevertheless right I think what she did was appeasing the far right to get just enough votes to get in the government and now she’s gonna try reforms
Well tough shit for her then, because that would imply a reform of the treaties, making the member states delegate the execution of even more sovereign capacities on the european institutions.
Now i'd personally be all for that, but the issue here is consistency: you're either against it, or you're not; there's no in between.
Scottish. As a net contributor it’s a refund
@@youtubeyoutube936 Italy contributed more than it received for long very long
Love to see Melony focuses on her people and country root values. That 's great. Hope all coubtries in EU support her. Love from Indonesia.
She kinda sucks in sine aspects and hope it doesn't turn into a wreck
Meloni.
LMAO you haven't been paying attention have you? She's clearly not fit for the role
@@c.santos1685 we had two of the worst Prime Ministers in our history: Conte and Draghi. They created social tense, destroyed italian economy, and sitting over about 1 million of covid's death. Why Meloni would be worst?
@@BusiMimmo just wait. I agree we are usually governed by m0r0ns but she's possibly even worse than the others
Im not familiar with Italian politics but when I heard the speech it sounds more like she was talking about family values and to reform the economy of Italy and the lives for Italians. Which especially with what was going on in the country you can't blame the Italians for electing her. We just have to see how things are going to manage in a couple of years.
There's no need for immigrants and LGBTQ people to be stripped of their rights, enforcing conservative values always comes to the expense of marginalized groups, she's just bad and I don't see how doing those things will ever help the economy, traditional family values have nothing to do with Italy's dumb economic choices and immigrant flows can actually be really good for the economy, she's only pushing her sick ideology
Don't judge a politician from those shouted really speeches, besides possibly not even addressed to Italians (probably some Spanish Catholic reunion or something).
I say this regardless of her actual political positions (I didn't vote for her).
Thanks for not blaming Italians (including me) who elected her, I think we are not as dumb as the MSM depict us
I mean, she just hit a bunch of talk points to rally up a crowd. That doesn’t exactly seem representative of her governing skills. It just seems like the country is gonna get worse and they are running out of ways to rally people, if they got not money, or good policies, or safety, might as well use pretty words to fluff up national pride if there is nothing good they can motivate voters with.
@@raffaelefilosofi3630Spero proprio che Lei non se ne penta.
After the flood of "peaceful" men in italy(Sicily), the bad economy, the devaluation of the euro the high inflation. There's no doubt why many of them chose right politicians
Yes
👍
No more EU. No more Euro. No more Schengen. It’s time for all European countries to separate from the EU.
It’s as if right wing politics works or something look at hungary. Compare it to Sweden, Germany, Netherlands, UK or Spain completely degenerate and deluded when it comes to immigration
World need Chinese n Israeli treatment of "peacefuls"
My God I wish she was in charge of our government in the UK.
you are crazy, far right is fascism
I think that Meloni shows a healthy dose of patriotism and economic pragmatism to make a difference. It will take a few years, but I think she is able to make a prosperous country out of the now crippled Italy. She is a strong, smart and responsible woman and mother.
BTW as Italian living in Poland....it's impossible we are getting close to anything in Poland.
The Judiciary, Constitutions and political system are so diverse that things which have been extremely messy in Poland (Rule of Law, Abortion becoming Incostitutional) in Italy are literally IMPOSSIBLE to get. The Constitutional Mechanism of balances and counterbalances is strong in Italy, not in Poland (which has a 25 years old and not so strong, constitution)
Are you sure, you lot have a Nazi as the new face of your country 🤨
Why are you living in Poland?
@@kosa9662 why not?
@@marioscalzi493 Poland is poorer on average than Italy
@@kosa9662 bo pracy w Polsce nie jest idiotyczny jak we Włoszech. I także dlatego że mogę 🤗
Wait isn't she the person that was offered 100 cows 🐮by Uganda to marry the President's son? 🤣
A deal that should not be accepted. That is a very bad deal.
Lol you’re kidding right ?
I'd rather marry the cows
@@alecsmbedzi106 haha no I wish I confirmed it 😂 it’s truee
@@ericjohnson7234 I agree,100 cows is too much.
Thank you for your reportage and research on this issue. A good example for a journalist on how to be impartial and let the people to judge by themselves. The message is clear and I thank you for your work.
I definitely like what she has to say i also an Italian citizen, and she promises to pass the laws that she has stated I will definitely vote for her in the following four years . Let’s see what she says at night time really happened in the morning 😊
Great video. Made it so much clearer to me what Meloni actually wants to do in terms of policy. Thanks!
@reality8793 No it doesnt. Georgia MELONI and her party is the best thing
Viva Italia!
How many realized that in the first video where she is giving a speech; she is speaking Spanish and not Italian?😂
Davvero?
I was wondering the same hahaha she speaks really well spanish, french and also english
I didn't vote for her, but I can understand people who did. The problem is if you always cry wolf, people are going to stop taking you seriously, that's essentially what happened with the Italian left-wing parties: all they did was tell people not to vote for Meloni else the country would turn into a fascist state again, without providing an actual manifesto of what they themselves intended to do for the country. This has been happening for far too long and people just got fed up with it.
....quite true the left don't say anything ,if they were a tast of ice cream they would be the paper around it, so many are just tired, the one that believe meloni are gonna do big change are idiot,because left-center-right suck all them,just in different way but at the same level of sucking
Yeah I am actually very disappointed in the left. But Meloni's program Is a continue smile to the ones Who does not want to pay taxes. I am so annoyed by It, I feel like a fool Just because my family pays them at this point
@@francescamazzonelli1670 vero, a me fanno incazzare alcuni nei commenti che se la prendono con la sanità o i vari servizi e non realizzano che quella roba insieme alla educazione ecc viene sempre tagliata e non siamo mai migliorati,ma anzi peggiorati,perchè? per molte ragioni ma una delle più grandi è il fatto che non c'è una più grande persecuzione verso chi non paga grandi quantità di tasse,e finisce sempre per ricevere un condono
When was the last good Italian government? I was born in 88 and I don't remember a single good Italian government that led to a better quality of life. It's all been downhill. Horrible political class.
@@francescamazzonelli1670 Not much you can do on that front in a globalist economy.
You can just write "Meloni's plan to rescue italy" and then do the same video. You write "controversial" only for right wing people.
12:52 Man she did shut down Macron really hard.
Dear Macron, Giorgia has prepaired a nice baguette for you....
I’m moving to Italy 👌👌👌👌👌🇮🇪
Finally Italians are voting for their country protect its culture which it’s one of the greatest in so many ways
I've wondered often in the last many years if there's even a single person within the liberal elite, the journalistic profession, academia or anywhere else who realizes and grasps the fact that the more frequently and casually the term "fascist" is tossed around, the less meaning it has.
I've now concluded with certainty that the answer is an emphatic NO!
And then the big problem is when the real fascists turn up, people shrug and say those other 'fascists' were not so bad when they are, in fact, faced with something quite different. Putin is about the closest that Europe has to a fascist leader, nationalistic, anti-democratic, identifying the west as the cause of Russia's ills and embracing violence as a means of keeping order and advancing goals. Within the EU Orban gets close but is not quite anti democratic enough. Real fascists disdain democracy as a source of weakness
@@gogs8166 For the most part, that's true but I don't think you even need to go that deep to understand what's going on. It's not merely a question of ideology though that's certainly part of it but it's really more a matter of cultural resentment.
Modern liberals... as opposed to classical liberals who are more in line with what we call conservatives today.... view themselves as an anointed class of people who are above everyone else and thus entitled to hold all the positions and levers of political, social and cultural power.
As a result, they feel they deserve to be, and indeed expect to be, revered and respected without reservation or question. When they don't get the reverence they feel is their birthright, they get VERY annoyed and begin to lash out.
When someone who is not of their class and clique gets a little too noisy or "uppity"... forgetting their place in the pecking order, you might say... the daggers and vitriol come out. "How DARE they??!!"
This is why you don't hear that much difference in how they talk about doctrinaire or moderate conservatives. To them, there really isn't that much difference. They are not "like" them so that, in and of itself, is sufficient justification for the vitriolic, class based hatred that is the essence of their existence.
They put on this grand show of concern about all things race and gender but the truth is they don't give a damn about any of it. All of it is just a set of tools with which to beat the "inferiors."
They are in a particularly acute stage of apoplexy at the moment because the PM of Italy is a woman and the PM of the UK is a "brown" person.... two cohorts they feel they have the exclusive right of ownership over.
@@hughjass1044 This right here. I could kiss you
It’s like how everything is “racist”
It's almost certainly a term that's become devoid of historical meaning. When people read the Godfather of the Modern Left, Herbert Marcuse, it pulls together a lot of the left's thinking of the past generation or so. The left at least here in the US stopped being "liberal" circa 1960 and went into Neo-Marxist thinking. That change probably happened a lot sooner in Europe. The fact that historical education has been so poor with regards to the 2nd World War tells me they never read about the German National Socialists and "Positive Christianity". When The Nazis wanted to yeet Old Testament scripture (even some considering the entire Old Testament itself to be tossed) and deny Nicene Christianity to eventually fuse Paganism in with the state religion (yeah, Wolfenstein and Indiana Jones were not that far off), that's not exactly affirm of Christian Tradition.
She seems more center right than anything here in the US, and at least she upholds valid election results. So I don't think she's the harbinger of fascism the media makes her out to be.
Andrew Stevens..spot on. There’s much more to this little firebrand than meets the eye.
She is proud of her working background and is a devoted mother to her young daughter.
Those who see her as a sort of wowser do not know anything about her except what main stream media spews out. I wish her the best of luck.
So true. One of Georgia’s conservative colleagues made a rather disturbing comment about Italy’s constitution created almost two centuries ago. He said It was created to ‘ not work’. Maybe there’s a little reason behind it called freemasonry?….mhm…..
You shouldn't be comparing politics in other countries to the US though.
Considering how far right the us is its obvious you think shes center right. But shes far right for europe
@@Gigachad-mc5qzThe U.S. is far right? Have you been in a coma since 2008? Hopefully not. What the U.S. has currently is a hard-left Progressive Democrat regime headed by a demented Manchurian candidate installed in 2020 and in league with Obama (who is effectively part of the shadow government). The U.S. could use someone like Meloni. She would be a very strong candidate.
Well done, Meloni cant resolve all the problems, but will make us feel more secure
She looks great, sounds great, and despite the bad press she’s been given, I’m sure she’s the prime minister Italy needs at the present time.
people said that about trump and look how that worked out
@@longshucksgaming people also used to think Germs fake and diseases were work of the devil. I guess time will tell
No, Man. Really, I’m from Italy.
I love the way she talks about family values and stands next to Mr. Bunga Bunga Berlusconi. The irony. I would keep my teenage daughter at home if i were her.
looks great ? according to ?
sounds great ? like hitler ?
the above two reason makes someone qualify as a prime minister already ?
Great analysis and information. 👏🏾👏🏾
Much more objective view than the newest one about my country, Poland (done by the previous guy who sold "Visual Politics"). Thank you for that!
I love this woman.
Best wishes for this woman 😊🙏👏👏👏
This was very informative and seemed to be a balanced explanation of Italian politics. Thank you for the video, it was very interesting.
This is balanced?😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂
"My giorgia is not a fascist. She may be a liar, a pig, an idiot, a fascist, but she is *not* a porn star!" grampa said
She sounds pretty good to me.
Very soon Italy will surpass Japanese economy.😂🤣😅
Username checks out
Happy to see decent coverage of something not so left scare tactic driven
I think this video misses a few key elements that raise concern about the potential authoritarian threat of this government, most importantly Meloni's proposal to change the constitution to a presidential model, centering a lot more power in the figure of the President. While this is not necessarily a bad thing in a vacuum (plenty of democracies around the world have presidential models) you have to understand the post-war context in which the Italian constitution was written, with the specific objective of making a return of the fascist regime unlikely. The fact that this proposal comes from this party, with its roots in neo-fascist movements, is at the very least cause for pause. You can agree or disagree with Meloni on an array of things (personally my politics is the furthest away from hers on any given topic, for full disclosure) but no matter your opinion I don't believe such sweeping changes to out constitution should be made by what is essentially a minority government. Let's not forget that despite the vast majority they have in parliament, Meloni's right wing coalition only got 44% of the vote. There are more italians who didn't vote for this government than italians who did, we just have a crap electoral law.
Our constitution is total shit. Not much to protect there. No mention to freedom and the ways to protect it. It starts on a Socialist note talking about work instead of for example ingenuity, which is really at the heart of our culture and history, and, ultimately, success.
Yes! your thought of risk is right, and then don’t let her change the constitution then.
But doubting someone who has a natural and strong believe in their country’s history, culture, moral values, nationalism and calling it rise of fascist, rise authoritarian is also wrong.
When your house is dirty and your children doesn’t clean it and let it get more dirty, then I am sure your natural and justified tendency would be to make/help/assist them clean it, so if your children think of you as authoritarian, do you care, do you say to them “no my children call the police on me because i am asking you to lets clear the mess, you made”.
@@akyyadav1065 I'm not sure I get what you're saying. The reason why people bring up fascism when talking about Meloni is that she literally started in politics in a neo-fascist party (she was a member of the youth wing of MSI, a party formed in 1946 by actual Mussolini-era fascists). It's not a random insult, it's a factual statement.
In economc policies every italian politician gets it wrong. Everyone wants to maintain the status quo and redistribute wealth to those who vote for them, there's no party of true change and reform because it would mean that many that now are living off of unproductive public spending would lose their paid place, so this is why Italy will most likely continue to decline for the next decades.
Ma tu che ne sai? Il paese è bloccato da vent'anni grazie ai radical progressist. E cmnq meloni viene dalla periferia già questo è un cambiamento. Shall we see
@@Barabba. certamente, i radical progressisti, qualsiasi cosa voglia dire. D'altronde Berlusconi è sicuramente un radical progressista no?
@@davidescristofaros2241 purtroppo è il prezzo ds pagare per avere i numeri necessari affinché si possa tentare di rimettere in pista questo sgangherato paese. E poi non mi sembra abbia tanta voce in capitolo ma fa massa.
If I didn't know her stance on migration and other social issues. I would consider her from her economic plan a socialist left. Right policies do not nationalize, they reduce government and promote free market
@@Barabba. No non hai capito. Ho detto che Berlusconi NON è un "radical progressista", quindi dire che i radical progressisti abbiano distrutto il paese quando Berlusconi ha governato per più di 10 anni e quasi portato il paese al default è non capire fondamentalmente un cazzo.
Poi Berlusconi come non ha voce? Le tv, i giornali, il potere economico come lo valuti?
Meloni is brave. And thinks outside and f the box
All of the professional politicians need to look inward at the changes happening now and stand up for the people not there self gratifying jobs
This is Italy. They change leaders like most people change socks.
Truss 45 days ,great bri
The same in UK
@@Barabba. That is not usual for Britain. Italy really has had a constant replacement of government leadership since the end of WWII.
@@shawnnewell4541 governaments fell even when 1 party had absolute majority here in Italy lol. But then again the same could be said about britain this decade....just not for 70 years
@@shawnnewell4541 in any case is a record good luck ,15 days to put the queen in the cemetery. In any case Said tanks to romans, if not may u still on the trhees
Very informative. Love how you broke it down
Had to set the video to .75 speed because of how fast you're talking :D Very informative though! (did you speed-up your talking?)
12:54 Holy shit, did I actually agree with a fascist leader for the first time in my life???
yes you did. Welcome to smart leaders smart politics.
@@ericjohnson7234 Oh thank you for trusting my intelligence but I'm afraid I'll have to disappoint you, comrade ☭
And a religious maniac too
@@Quantum_in_Java Yeah lol she sounds totally nuts
She's not Fascist, grow up !
give 'em months, they'll change sooner than you think.
Como to BRICS Italy. Best wishes. From Brazil 🇧🇷
Rich country with way to much corruption
Best wishes for our Italian brothers and sisters from Poland!
Happy to have you on our side! We hope we can make a change of rotten state of EU!
What is your goal of changing it?
Getting more money out of it while accepting less influence ? That’s not how it works.
The Eu is great imo and it needs more power.
Small states will be crushed between the blocs in the future. Only escape is to become a bloc by ourselves.
But I think in this case we did not learn from history.
No thanks!
Eus got the anti- rot treatment... It will be bye bye backsliders
EU is rotten because of countries like Poland and Hungary
I'm glad the UK left, good decision
If you don't like the EU, get tf out. You can gladly join Putin or anyone else for all I care.
I so much love this lady. She is very straight forward. Europe needs this type of leaders not hypocrites who claim to promote democracy but are destroying the world through poverty and global terrorism.
Should we fight immigration because of some obscure relationship with terrorism, then? If I'm a straight forward fascist, I'm still a fascist.
Well said!
She is incoherent
@@akulakaboom Yeah I can’t understand her. I mean, I don’t speak her language but I don’t think that matters 😂
We got really ugly and embarrassing politicians here in Italy, Meloni was among them for reasons, when I saw her elected I got a little worried, but when she started to speak like how she has done in the video it was mesmerizing, the first time in my life I almost fully agree with one of our politicians, a complete change of character, yes still aggressive but everything she said up to now is simply correct and virtuous, she is talking about very difficult problems and the parasites who provoked them.
God, homeland and family is from Mazzini not Mussolini.
I'm Italian and I don't like the equation far right = fascism.
It feeIs like it's clearly an oversimplification, but because we were on the wrong side of history we can't reply
Egypt too beautiful and so near from Italy and Greece love from Canada 🇪🇬🇨🇦🇮🇹🇬🇷
As a mediterranean I believe that Europe should be based more on the needs of Italy, Spain and Greece as culturally we are the richest
Agree 100%
Agreed 100%. However, there is that Northern European disdain for Southern Europe.
No you’re not.
@@tomchirillo1663 …I know….the ‘pig’ countries…😏
Culture doesn't run the world, $ and power does.
The Ghost of Mussolini still lingers, what a shame some Italians don't learn.
Very helpful video
what i love about the first clip on Giorgia Meloni 1:18 is that its not even the italian people, it's the SPANISH people doing a standing ovation for her ahahah
Yes she was speaking Spanish, probably at a catholic convention
@@roadrunner156almost. That was a Vox political party rally. They are vicious, disgusting politicians. Totally undemocratic, nasty practices they have. Of course they would give her a standing ovation!
I hate this woman but having lived in Italy before, I think her policies will be good for that country
Her policies cut the benefits to the poorest of families and prevented the Minister of Tourism's judicial process in which she's accused of fraud. Also, very pro-life and traditional family cutting on already low-existing aids for families.
@@charliekauffmansgirl4165 italy has a problem with too few young and the skilled ones leave, pro life makes sense immigrants without skills just drives down economic activity by undercutting low skilled Italians and driving the money into the black economy, removing tax revenues and then increasing welfare liabilities - so her immigrant stance makes sense. italy has literally no spare money except unless it slashes bureaucrats, courts etc it is way more generous to the poor than most countries. the corruption thing is frankly small compared to almost every other italian leader since pre-roman times
I m not a fan of Meloni however, she speaks foreign languages better than the pope and she’s spot on about France involvement in the Arab Spring ,
Well said Giorgia ! Now it’s time to fix things not only shout .
center-right? can we have center-center for once...? 😂
I hope she is supported as she wants to help Italy and not herself as Berlusconi did. She loves Italy. Vive Giorgia
Berlusconi help Italy? Yes, help himself to Italy - please show what he did for this country?
Go ahead Italians!! Don’t give up!
She can certainly communicate. Even an English man can understand every second word and the meaning of most of it.
Europe has so many pre ww1 and ww2 vibes right now.
Good for Italy, that's the way to go
The economic ideas sound very good, but can this be implemented?
Listening to her speech at the beginning of the video, El Duce would be proud.
🤨 el who? 🤣🤣🤣 I can't take y'all serious, meloni the nazi witch
Do you think she is wrong ?
May God Protect her everyday. She is the Voice of Italy 🙏
Italian here. Don't be so easily impressed: so far, she screamed a lot, achieved nothing, the general goods prices skyrocketed, and the poor work for lower salaries. She's too happy to be up there but totally unfit for the role of prime minister of a complex country like Italy.
You really got the complexity of the situation and explained the subtleties. Good job from Italy!
Politicians will not fool me again. All they do is talk talk talk 😁😁
She's 1000% right about Macron and Libya, and it's about time someone said it out loud.
Meloni’s position is what I expect of a conservative movement. This is coming from a liberal btw.
Most of her positions are promotion of ideology rather than forceful cornering (eg. institutional ban on abortion). Tha is what is missing in North American politics. I hope her government succeeds and acts as role model for conservative governance.
The fact is that she has never said she wants to ban abortion, as she remarked in her first presidential speech in the Chamber of Deluties
At least Meloni is not crossing that red line and stills strongly supporting Ukraine.
Why is it that you think that Russia is in the wrong for doing what they did? Now I'm not claiming to know what Russia's motivations really are but I do know it's actually true that large portions of Ukraine population wanted to be accepted back into Russia and Ukraine said no and sent in military forces to try and prevent a revolution that no news outlet in the west reported on until they edited it and then said the chaos was Russian terrorist attacks.
As a greek i like the fact that meloni strongly supports ukraine.General public seems to care more about energy prices but i think the war in ukraine is the number one political issue for europe,even though the public does not understand this. I read that italy announced a new military package for ukraine (i dont know if it is true).I will support EVERY single european government who supports ukraine.(left or right,populist,globalist,nationalist,liberal or whatever).For me it is the number one political priority atm
'at least'. you really don't know how the world works
@@Goerge-lu3ok i don t give a fuck about ukraine my business bills have bene quadruplied i was paying 1200 € for gas consumption now i have to pay 4800 for this month ,how much Will i pay for december and january ? I Will go bankrupt of the prices don t lower
@@Goerge-lu3ok general public care more about not going bankrupt you Little rat!
Never seen so many posts about Italy on line like in this days! I guess This is a first achievement of this government: let’s the world look at Italy and awaring that there is an Italian point of view that should be taken into consideration from now on!!
As an older US citizen, I would say that it’s incorrect to refer to Maloney‘s politics as fascist. What I see equates to what we once had in this country in the 1950s when Eisenhower was president, president of the greatest democracy in history.
Very informative 👏
1:17 finally a good speech
One can only hope they do succeed in starting the turn of Italys' fortune.
Really should make people think that YT news channels usually give better balance to stories than any of the legacy media.
Except the channels paid for by China and Russia
@@Minchya yes
she is the best
Thanks for a great overview.
Bro needs to brush his teeth
hope doesn't go the same way as Trussonomics
It’s the exact opposite ahaha
More countries could use her ideals
As French and with Italian origins we need Italy to come back has one of the strongest economy in Europe
Italy need to be next to France and Germany as the strongest economy in the world (Spain too)
I think Meloni is the right person to fix Italy’s economy
Much needed
If I'm honest, I'm expecting the government to collapse within 24 months given the constant shifts in what Italy wants.
That great news, in 12 months should be elections in Poland. With speeches such as these shown I the material, she would win without knowing even one word in Polish. ;)
Italy wants to be governed honestly, not as Soros or Biden wants
Ma spera al tuo di collasso, piuttosto.
Lol, the "constant shift in what Italy wants" has NOTHING to do with how long governments last in Italy. The fact that Italy's governments can't last much is ONLY because how Italy's election laws works... Governments are elected based on parties alliances, so it happens that an alliance that goes to govern lasts as long as parties with like 5 % of voting (but that are in the alliance) wants to...
@lazarus921 This happened in the past because no one party had majority and in order to form a government they had to form a coalition among parties of different political ideologies but not this time as all the three party in this Meloni's coalition are conservative and share very same political views.
Nice presentation...
❤❤❤very fairly spoken underestimation helps .
I voted for her and i hope she doesn’t disappoint me
Let’s see - historically she will have 13 months.
Since the refugee crisis was really bad from what I’ve heard from Italy I give her 24 if her plans with these camps calm the situation a bit down.
Bravo allo stupido
She will definitely disappoint you. As will all politicians. Seems like you're in need of a führer to help you organize your life.
I hope she does considering what she promised!
Give her a few months, we all know how Italian leaders are.. just a lot of gas and no results, always looking outward instead of finding solutions
If Mario Draghi hasn't managed to fix Italy's economy, I don't see how anybody can...
Mario è al servizio delle banche e non degli italiani ,is a bit different
@@Barabba. la meloni è al servizio della 'ndrangheta, its a bit different
@@Barabba. Non lo so, però è riuscito a stabilizzare l'economia europea quando era il presidente della Banca centrale europea...
Un paese non lo fixi in 1 anno di governo, quelli italiani sono problemi decennali. Inoltre Draghi non godeva di una solida maggioranza parlamentare, infatti gli erano tutti contro, da destra a sinistra, si è limitato a non fare danni, che già è tanto, annacquando i provvedimenti che ha preso.
Why would Draghi do anything for Italy lol. Someone has never heard of goldman mentality.
this channel has shifted to the right way more than italy