My opinion (im not a expert, and this is all personal preference, though I tried my best to be unbiased) Vocal: 1:Wendy 2:Lily 3:Haewon 4:Ningning 5:Seulgi 6:Winter 7:Jihyo 8:Jeongyeon 9:Sullyoon 10: Rose 11:Kyujin 12:Giselle 13:Karina 14:Nayeon 15:Jinni 16:Jiwoo 17:Joy 18:Lia 19:Bae 20:Yeji 21:Chaeryeong 22:Jisoo 23:Chaeyoung 24:Jennie 25:Mina 26:Yeri 27:Tzuyu 28:Irene 29:Sana 30:Dahyun 31:Lisa 32:Yuna 33:Momo 34:Ryujin Rap: 1:Jennie 2:Lisa 3:Chaeyoung 4:Giselle 5:Karina 6:Jinni 7:Jiwoo 8:Yuna 9:Kyujin 10:Ryujin 11:Dahyun 12:Momo 13:Yeri 14:Irene 15:Yeji 15:Joy
I respect your opinion, but Giselle and Karina are better vocalists than Rose and Nayeon? The two reach the high notes without difficulty, Giselle and Karina are rappers
@@user-jh9re7vz5q You're talking about the C5 she did in the concert in Kill This Love, right? Just to say she was only belting C5, she wasn't fully supporting it, and it was quite strained, so her C5 can't help her get into the C-rank because just supporting it once with shallowness, inconsistency, and strain does not mean she is C-, and if that's the case, then Giselle, I'm pretty sure, has also supported B4 many times, which means she is also C-. I mean, according to your logic, she is right? but in reality, she shows shallowness, and she is still inconsistent with it, not that much but still pretty inconsistent, so neither Rose nor Giselle are C- yet both of them have supported B4; Rose wasn't fully supporting C5, so leave that both of them support B4 that means their on the same level.
Things I would change is dahyun above sana because sana uses the same techniques as momo ,tzuyu above jisoo she's better then yeji jisoo and jennie she's close to Mina level and Giselle above Karina and kyujin she has a better lower register and is less shallow then Karina Giselle improved more then karina but I totally respect it if it's just your opinion (I skipped the intro sorry)
Tzuyu is not better than Jennie yet, Jennie has shallow and inconsistent support while Tzuyu is still only close to supporting, plus Jennie’s mix is better. I feel like Jennie will show her improvement before Tzuyu will be higher tho, because BP comeback is soon.
From below the top 5 6.Jihyo (jihyo and winters ranking could change depending on what you're ranking on) 7.Winter 8.jeongyeon 9.Giselle 10.Karina 11.Kyujin 12.Sullyoon 13.Nayeon 14.Jinni Nasal placement no solid registry 15.Rosé Support but stylistic except Lia and joy they just use her nasal placement + no strong register 15.Jiwoo 17.Lia 18.Joy 19.Bae Shallow support 20.Chaeyoung 21.Mina Okay technique 22.Tzuyu 23.Jennie 24.Yeji Interchangeable 25.Irene 26.Yeri 26.Chaeryeong 26.Jisoo Kinda Interchangeable but no at the same time 27.Dahyun 28.Sana 29.Lisa 30.Momo 31.Yuna Definitely last 32.Ryujin I feel like my numbering is wrong but I'm tired
No they arent, Winter is above jihyo. And Giselle is above karina and jeongyeon. Nayeon could change with jinni. And Momo is lower than ryujin and Yuna. Many specialist consider yuna even better singer than yeji in itzy..
@@555loona2 firstly Giselle is my bias she's not abive Jeongyeon Karina yes but not Jeongyeon yet, Jihyo lower register is better then Winter same with mixed so are really about say that Yuna is better then yeji because in what world Chaeryeong maybe but Yuna hell no, like I said Yuna lisa momo and sana are interchangeable since they all have bad technique and there a clear winner for them nayeon lower register is better then jinni and jinni struggles with consistency unlike nayeon
@@turtlerabbit1825 desilutional know much more about vocal :) Here the video stating that Giselle is above Karina and jeongyeon: ruclips.net/video/JR9Dx4EWhqs/видео.html
u shouldnt have opinions lol its based on fact and reality haewon is better than ningning learn to accept it just bc ningning does more high notes doesnt necessarily mean shes better whats wrong with this fandom
@@mariahlol2488 Why are you just assuming she ranked nigning higher because of high notes? She never said that; she just said, in my opinion, nothing toxic. I don't get why you are assuming.
![Eunha’s Military Service(?) and How TWICE Kept Her Going 🪖 | NAYEON VS VIVIZ EUNHA [TRICKKODE]](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/WdqijMbCmzQ/mqdefault.jpg)
Nope seeing wendy was not surprise at all. She is the best !!
taeyeon is a better singer, but yes wendy is one of top vocalists for sure
@@eirinha2287 and ailee hyolyn luna and sohyang is a better vocalist
1. Wendy
2. Lily
3. Haewon
4. ningning
5. Seulgi
6. Winter
7. Jihyo
8. Sullyoon
9. Jeongyeon
10. Nayeon
11. Kyujin
12.karina
13. Jinni
14. Rose
15. Jiwoo
16. Bae
17. Lia
18. Joy
19. Yeji
20. Chaeyoung
21. Mina/Jennie
22. Irene
23. Tzuyu
24. Lisa
25.Jisoo
26. Yuna
27. Yeri
28.Chaeryeong
30. Dahyun
31. Sana
32. Ryujin
33. Momo
this is outdated its updated now
All members on nmixx are better than yeri, mina, jennie and prob Giselle too
@@Aaron-wm4fy this is outdated. Already uploaded the new ranking
My opinion (im not a expert, and this is all personal preference, though I tried my best to be unbiased)
Vocal:
1:Wendy
2:Lily
3:Haewon
4:Ningning
5:Seulgi
6:Winter
7:Jihyo
8:Jeongyeon
9:Sullyoon
10: Rose
11:Kyujin
12:Giselle
13:Karina
14:Nayeon
15:Jinni
16:Jiwoo
17:Joy
18:Lia
19:Bae
20:Yeji
21:Chaeryeong
22:Jisoo
23:Chaeyoung
24:Jennie
25:Mina
26:Yeri
27:Tzuyu
28:Irene
29:Sana
30:Dahyun
31:Lisa
32:Yuna
33:Momo
34:Ryujin
Rap:
1:Jennie
2:Lisa
3:Chaeyoung
4:Giselle
5:Karina
6:Jinni
7:Jiwoo
8:Yuna
9:Kyujin
10:Ryujin
11:Dahyun
12:Momo
13:Yeri
14:Irene
15:Yeji
15:Joy
Lisa: the lead rapper who makes main rappers tremble in fear
Part 2 ?
Good Ranking mine is also almost same! Just some changes!!🙂
seems pretty accurate to me but was kinda surprised to see Chaeyoung and Mina above Irene & ngl expected dahyun to be much lower
+ after thinking a little bit feel unsure about Lisa being so low & Giselle ranking above Rose/Nayeon
I respect your opinion, but Giselle and Karina are better vocalists than Rose and Nayeon? The two reach the high notes without difficulty, Giselle and Karina are rappers
just bcs they're rappers doesn't mean they have to be bad singers, both giselle and karina are amazing and have a pretty good range of support
@@ifsbun__ Yes, but Karina's support range is not the same as Rose and Nayeon's. Rose is the one with the widest range, currently
@@user-jh9re7vz5q Rose doesn't have the widest range tho, they both are consistent and support Bb4 fully, so they both are D+. What's your point?
@@I.Ncan.speak.korean Yes, but Rosé is the one who has the most developed vocal technique, apart from the fact that she already has support in C5
@@user-jh9re7vz5q You're talking about the C5 she did in the concert in Kill This Love, right? Just to say she was only belting C5, she wasn't fully supporting it, and it was quite strained, so her C5 can't help her get into the C-rank because just supporting it once with shallowness, inconsistency, and strain does not mean she is C-, and if that's the case, then Giselle, I'm pretty sure, has also supported B4 many times, which means she is also C-. I mean, according to your logic, she is right? but in reality, she shows shallowness, and she is still inconsistent with it, not that much but still pretty inconsistent, so neither Rose nor Giselle are C- yet both of them have supported B4; Rose wasn't fully supporting C5, so leave that both of them support B4 that means their on the same level.
I just want to ask you, in which video Giselle support to Bb4, can you give me link, please?
ruclips.net/video/MJQNCaSgsBk/видео.html. Here u go
Things I would change is dahyun above sana because sana uses the same techniques as momo ,tzuyu above jisoo she's better then yeji jisoo and jennie she's close to Mina level and Giselle above Karina and kyujin she has a better lower register and is less shallow then Karina Giselle improved more then karina but I totally respect it if it's just your opinion (I skipped the intro sorry)
Tzuyu is not better than Jennie yet, Jennie has shallow and inconsistent support while Tzuyu is still only close to supporting, plus Jennie’s mix is better. I feel like Jennie will show her improvement before Tzuyu will be higher tho, because BP comeback is soon.
u r really inaccurate
From below the top 5
6.Jihyo (jihyo and winters ranking could change depending on what you're ranking on)
7.Winter
8.jeongyeon
9.Giselle
10.Karina
11.Kyujin
12.Sullyoon
13.Nayeon
14.Jinni
Nasal placement no solid registry
15.Rosé
Support but stylistic except Lia and joy they just use her nasal placement + no strong register
15.Jiwoo
17.Lia
18.Joy
19.Bae
Shallow support
20.Chaeyoung
21.Mina
Okay technique
22.Tzuyu
23.Jennie
24.Yeji
Interchangeable
25.Irene
26.Yeri
26.Chaeryeong
26.Jisoo
Kinda Interchangeable but no at the same time
27.Dahyun
28.Sana
29.Lisa
30.Momo
31.Yuna
Definitely last
32.Ryujin
I feel like my numbering is wrong but I'm tired
I think you forgot some people like one more person I think you forgot jisoo
No they arent, Winter is above jihyo. And Giselle is above karina and jeongyeon. Nayeon could change with jinni. And Momo is lower than ryujin and Yuna. Many specialist consider yuna even better singer than yeji in itzy..
@@555loona2 firstly Giselle is my bias she's not abive Jeongyeon Karina yes but not Jeongyeon yet, Jihyo lower register is better then Winter same with mixed so are really about say that Yuna is better then yeji because in what world Chaeryeong maybe but Yuna hell no, like I said Yuna lisa momo and sana are interchangeable since they all have bad technique and there a clear winner for them nayeon lower register is better then jinni and jinni struggles with consistency unlike nayeon
@@555loona2 Giselle better then Jeongyeon?Yuna better then yeji? Delusional
@@turtlerabbit1825 desilutional know much more about vocal :)
Here the video stating that Giselle is above Karina and jeongyeon: ruclips.net/video/JR9Dx4EWhqs/видео.html
10:42
My opinion:
Vocals:
(from about 1-15, are the vocalists that use more technical aspects of singing)
34)Momo
33)Ryujin
32)Lisa
31)Yuna
30)Dahyun
29)Chaeryeong
28)Sana
27)Tzuyu
26)Jennie
25)Irene
24)Chaeyoung
23)Kyujin
22)Yuri
21)Bae
20)Yeji
19)Jinni
18)Jisoo
17)Jiwoo
16)Mina
15)Lia
14)Giselle
13)Rose
12)Nayeon
11)Joy
10)Karina
9)Sullyoon
8)Jeongyeon
7)Jihyo
6)Winter
5)Haewon
4)Seulgi
3)Ningning
2)Lily
1)Wendy
Rap:
(only adding top 3 of each group)
Honorable mentions: Lia, Chaeryeong
18)Momo
17)Jisoo
16)Joy
15)Yuri
14)Winter
13)Dahyun
12)Irene
11)Jinni
10)Kyjin
9)Jiwoo
8)Yeji
7)Yuna
6)Chaeyoung
5)Ryujin
4)Karina
3)Lisa
2)Giselle
1)Jennie
Dance:
31)Giselle
30)Chaeyoung
29)Joy
28)Jeongyeon
27)Yuri
26)Dahyun
25)Jisoo
24)Lia (she may be a bit stiff while dancing, but i don't think anyome ranked below her on this list, wouldn't be able to learn itzys dances)
23)Tzuyu
22)Wendy
21)Ningning
20)Jennie
19)Sullyoon
18)Nayeon
17)Bae
16)Lily
15)Rose
14)Yuna
13)Winter
12)Karina
11)Sana
10)Jihyo
9)Ryujin
8)Irene
7)Haewon
6)Mina
5)Seulgi
4)Yeji/Chaeryeong
3)Jiwoo/Jinni
2)Momo/Lisa
1)Kyjin
Rap ranking is messed up :
1.JENNIE
2.LISA
3.CHAEYOUNG
4.GISSELE
5.KARINA
(TOP 5)...
Vocals
Dahyun >Lisa>Ryujin>Momo
Vocal
1. Wendy
2. Lily
3. Haewon
4. Ningning
5. Seulgi
6. Winter
7. Jihyo
8. Jeongyeon
9. Giselle
10. Karina
11. Kyujin
12. Sullyoon
13. Nayeon
14. Jinni
15. Rosé
16. Joy
17. Jiwoo
18. Lia
19. Chaeyoung
20. Mina
21. Bae
22. Jennie
23. Irene
24. Tzuyu
25. Yeji
26. Yeri
27. Chaeryeong
28. Jisoo
29. Sana
30. Momo
31. Dahyun
32. Lisa
33. Ryujin
I think Ningning’s vocal is better than Haewon’s vocal (in my opinion)
u shouldnt have opinions lol its based on fact and reality haewon is better than ningning learn to accept it just bc ningning does more high notes doesnt necessarily mean shes better whats wrong with this fandom
@@mariahlol2488 Why are you just assuming she ranked nigning higher because of high notes? She never said that; she just said, in my opinion, nothing toxic. I don't get why you are assuming.
This is the super ranking list 😂. But i like this style of ranking.. Actually showing their clips.
First