Lenin & Tsar Nicholas II - The Russian Revolution Documentary
HTML-код
- Опубликовано: 17 май 2024
- For early access to our videos, discounted merch and many other exclusive perks please support us as a Patron or Member...
Patreon: / thepeopleprofiles
Buy me a Coffee: www.buymeacoffee.com/peoplepr...
RUclips Membership: / @peopleprofiles
or follow us on Twitter! / tpprofiles
Check out our new channel People Profiles Shorts, on which we will be uploading 15 minute versions of all our documentaries, RUclips Shorts, as well as interviews with historians and extra videos. / @peopleprofilesshorts
All footage, images and music used in People Profiles Documentaries are sourced from free media websites or are purchased with commercial rights from online media archives.
0:00:00 Tsar Nicholas
01:14:27 Lenin
#Biography #History #Documentary
For early access to our videos, discounted merch and many other exclusive perks please support us as a Patron or Member...
Patreon: www.patreon.com/thepeopleprofiles
Buy me a Coffee: www.buymeacoffee.com/peopleprofiles
RUclips Membership: ruclips.net/channel/UCD6TPU-PvTMvqgzC_AM7_uAjoin
or follow us on Twitter! twitter.com/tpprofiles
Please try to do Napoléon III 🎉🎉🎉❤❤❤
😅
I have been teaching the History of Western Civilization at university level for four decades. This is one of the best presentations I have ever seen. The background video was best also. Outstanding work.
Since you are a history teacher, your approval has added a bit more to my faith that it's very factual.
Probably another lie))
Thank you.
Appreciate your commentary.
@@joeblow2069 Likewise mister)))
Alexandra was a fool and Nicholas weak. She isolated the family from everybody except for Rasputin. Neither of them had any judgement or talent for statecraft and both were wedded to autocracy "Russia loves to feel the whip - it's their nature - tender love and then the iron hand to punish and guide" her words. They led their young family to an awful death that could have been avoided.
So much information. Well presented. Makes me appreciate my Constitution and why it's worth defending. Although written long ago.
Very interesting.Thanks a lot.
And george. Turning down their request to have sanctuary in uk. Inhuman.
He was frightened to death that something similar would happen to him, especially if he obliged.
Lots of mistakes made.
Very interesting, will surely watch.
A sensible depiction of that period. Compare this to the rhetoric of our times, by some Western politicians, including those in Ukraine, portraying Russia as evil throughout all history
Since its National inception as Russia in around 1000ce, the Russian people have never known a single day of anything remotely resembling a democracy.
And they have never lived better than these days. MSM would have all believed they are still under a centrally-planned economic system.
I made a comment in response to you. Either People and Profiles or RUclips are not making it visible. Practicing centrally-planned censorship. They would have fit snugly in the payroll of Pravda.
@@jorgeponce5512 make it again.
The Russians have never lived better than over the last 10 years.
@@rathertiredofthemess2841 The Russians have never lived better than over the last 10 years.
I love the work you put out!
This channel definitely contributes to society
Thank you for this. Who decides on the adverts? There's way too many of them.
Premium
Very informative
Tsar Nicholas, what a sweet summer boy, with perfect azure eyes.... almost like his head is filled with a beautiful, empty sky, lord knows he wasn't thinking about his fellow Russians.
Do william joyce lord haw-haw.
27:20 Hmmm. I wonder what group of people they would be?
As you seem to show already know with your tiresome rhetorical bullshit, please tell us, in detail, who you mean?
All the same dna
One angry young man (Lenin) adopts theories (Marx, Engels) based on a false anthropology. And millions of people are killed or suffer as a result. Yes, ideas do have consequences.
Adopted the worst idea, in all of human history, mankind ever conceived.
Cringeee
Lenin was financed by Wall Street
Love these compilations! YOU GUYS ARE THE BEST 😊😊😊❤❤
Odessa was not part of The Ukraine in 1908 - this did not happen until the early 1920s
Exactly. It wasn't until 1918 when Lenin gave southern and eastern parts of (what is now Russia) to Ukraine.
The city of Odessa was founded In 1794 .by a decree of the Russian empress Catherine the Great. From 1819 to 1858, Odessa was a free port-a porto -Franco.
During the 19th century, Odessa was the fourth largest city of Imperial Russia, after Moscow, Saint Petersburg and Warsaw. And there was no any Ukraine.
During the Soviet period, it was the most important port of trade in the Soviet Union and a Soviet naval base.
1:26:36 they were never married to my understanding, please explain?
I often wonder what people expected of people born into royally. They were only human.
The military machine was too strong for any tsar. The fact he ruled as long as he did is amazing. Lenin looks nasty. Pokey little beady eyes.
Lenin would not have become Stalin especially since he warned against him
But Trotsky could have been a Stalin
Lol Lenin saw himself in Stalin. After all it was the plan that if socialism moved too much towards capitalism, communism would be enforced. Trotsky wanted something different, Lennin didn't live long enough and Stalin imposed exactly what Lenin wanted.
@@stephan6372We watched two different documentaries because what I watched stated that Lenin warned against Stalin and chose Trotsky instead meaning he did not want Stalin to replace him
Excellent documentary. As to what I feel about Tsar Nicholas, I feel sure that he is happy now.
In fact, all the players in this melodramatic Russian tale, gone to their happy eternal rest.
Too soppy? Well, that s Buddhism for ya!!😊
28августа 1941г.были живыми закопаны родственники дедушки Ленина и раввина Марголина возле Логойска как ехать на Гайну памятник есть. Немцы гарантировали переезд в Австралию им. Когда они пришли в пункт сбора у них забрали золота в объёме сундука, и заставили капать яму.., Спасся мальчик 6 лет. Мы с бабушкой часто тайно подходили к этому месту и бабушка плакала на коленях, и говорила, что лучше было бы, если бы жи до в (её слова) перевезли в Австралию..
Would you make a documentary on Karl XII aka. Carolus Rex of Sweden?
An error:Peter Kropotkin was an Anarchist. The narrator says that Kropotkin was intellectual forbear of Bolshevism
Do Michel Collins please
Nicholas was human, A MAN
He was also a very stupid man.
dID yUo jUsT aSsumE hiS gEndER¿
The Russian monarchy had to come to an end after the miserable defeats in WW1 and the blockade of resourceful resolutions for the economic and social problems of the Russian people. The luxurious lifestyle of the royal family was at the expense of the Russian treasury widened the gap between aristocrats and land owners and the rest of the people leading to social radicalism and hence the revolution and the end of monarchy.
Take heed western neo capitalist west
@@stop-the-greed Only neo-capitalist? what about Neo-colonialism and the Neo's that our goverment in Britain are funding and arming for a repeat of our immediate post WW1 effort to put the peasants in their place, and return to global feudalism. The autocrats are back to claim the land they consider to have been stolen from a close relative of their Monarch just over a century ago!
@@GManzi673 very true , when they said Brexit was about taking back control , this is what they meant . As you know mate . Spot on
Do Jane Austen please
Yesssss!
7:40 “Ouch”
Впервые услышала вашу правду. Если правда на стороне правды ,, как есть,,, то и суд на правдивой стороне.Никто у этих сумасшедших не проверял права на ношения оружия и заключения медкомиссии о ношении оружия. Императорская семья были неприкосновенны мировыми законами, как царская семья. Невыносимые люди эти безбожники... как тот с винтовкой в папуасии и сейчас... Командовать будут у себя дома!😢... Но помните, что будет суд, разящий как стрела, когда над головой блеснут два огненных крыла(М. И. Цветаева)
Императорская семья были необычными , святыми людьми, которые не понимали зачастую публику и невозможно было Романовых выпустить в мир без создания дистанции и телохранителей...
Tsar Nicholas II was NOT a direct descendant of King Henry VII. 👑💍🇷🇺
Historical reference.
The Rise of Ukraine.
"Out of the chaos into which Russia fell after the Revolution of the February 1917, a NEW NATION now emerges - the "Ukrainian People's Republic." "Dismembered Russia- Some of the Fragments"
"The New York Times" February 1918
Canadian scholar Orest Subtelny about this newly emerged Nation - Ukraine:
"In 1919 total chaos engulfed Ukraine. Indeed, in the modern history of Europe no country experienced such complete anarchy, bitter civil strife, and total collapse of authority as did Ukraine at this time. Six different armies..., operated on its territory. Kyiv changed hands five times in less than a year. Cities and regions were cut off from each other by the numerous fronts. Communications with the outside world broke down almost completely. The starving cities emptied as people moved into the countryside in their search for food."
Newly emerged Ukraine struggled for survival till November 1921. This turmoil resulted in the division of the newly emerged Ukraine between the Bolshevik Ukraine, Poland, Romania, Czechoslovakia. Fragments, absorbed by Poland, Romania, Czechoslovakia didn't get any kind of autonomy ever.
And only in the frame of the Soviet Union , newly emerged Nation - Ukraine was granted the Autonomy - the Ukrainian Soviet Republic was proclaimed as an integral part of the Soviet Union, created in 1922.
Artificial Construct of the Soviet Ukraine was created in place of the Historically Russian
Governorates of Russian Empire, with the strategically mostly important Historically Russian territories included in the Soviet Ukraine on the demand of Lenin,
Kharkov was founded in 1655 as a military stronghold to protect RUSSIA'S southern borderlands.
Kharkov's nodal position was enhanced in the later 19th century by the opening of the adjacent Donetsk Basin coalfield, which gave the boost for Kharkov’s own industries, especially engineering".
The whole region was developed as the industrial hub of Russian Empire, and was known as "Donbass", and there was no any Ukraine!
"Donetsk Krivorozsk Republic", with the capital in Kharkov, was proclaimed in 1917 as an integral part of the Russian Federation! Despite this, republic - its territory on the Demand of Lenin, was also incorporated, was
included in the new artificial construct of the Soviet Ukraine,
Such way Historically Russian Donbass with the historically Russian speaking population
became the part of the artificial construct of the Soviet Ukraine.
"Novorossia" was founded. by Catherine the Great in 1764. "Novorossiya", which literally means New Russia, is a historical name for an administrative area immediately north of the Black Sea, Sea of Azov and Crimea. In1802 it was devided into three governorates- the Yekaterinoslav, Kherson and the Taurida.
The name of the "Novorossia" was in use till 1917 after which it was out of usage, because by some mistirious reason it was included in the newly emerged Ukraine.
Catherine the Great's incorporation of the Crimea in 1783 from the defeated Ottoman Empire, increased Russia's power and control in the Black Sea area, and the Northern Coastal land of Black Sea, which together with Crimea was marked on the map of Russian Empire as Taurida Governorate.
Cities of Sebastopol, Odessa, Kherson Ochakov Mariupol to name a few were founded developed and flourishing in time of Russian Empire when Ukraine didn't exist.
Crimea was part of Russia until Nikita Khrushchev, decided to make a present of it to Ukrainian Soviet Republic in 1954 -it was an internal transaction,and could be seen as meaningless legally and politically, because in the Soviet times Ukraine was an integral part of the Soviet Union"..
Crimea was transfered to Ukraine, and nobody ever asked people of Crimean if they liked it, if they wanted to become part of Ukraine. After collapse of the Soviet Union in 1991 the newly emerged Nation
Ukraine wàs
established as the Anti - Russia.
Ultra Nationalist and neo Nazi unleashed the Cultural Genocide and Ethnocide of Russians on the historically Russian territories which were included in the artificial construct of the Soviet Ukraine created by Lenin century ago, after the Russian Revolution and following Civil War, It was Done on the demand of Lenin, bolsheviks, International Revolutionaries.
"Until the Soviet Union collapsed in 1991, Ukraine had never been an independent state." Ever.
" Borderland: A Journey Through The History Of Ukraine" 1999
I wonder why his mother didn't impose on him her Danish pragmatism. I think had she done so, the Bolshevik might have not taken place.
РУССКИЕ СТОЛЬКИ СТРАСТИ ДУШИ ВЕЧНЫЕ!!!!!!!!!! ДОМ РОМАНОВА
Nicholas was not a perfect Tsar, but better than the Communists
literally how
Lenin's actions led to massive upheaval and suffering. It's hard to see him as a hero when you consider the millions who suffered under his regime. What do you think?
I agree. In many ways I see that cannibalistic beast as the precursor to Hitler.
Lenin resembles hitler and arthur skargill in the energy source he manifested bringing chaos rather than harmony. I always say...its easy to wind a wild animal up. But rare is the person who can settle one. Tsar nicholas tried his best. I think a royal family...with a state governme t as uk is supposed to have is the best vehicle for democracy....if...big if...you manage to have honest m.p.s and p.m.
An uncooperative set of internal Russian opposing political parties tried to assassinate Lenin. Also, Japan, the U.S., and France joined the White Army loyal to the Tsar, in an attempt to retake Russia from the Bolsheviks. As a result, Lenin formed a powerful Red Army and increased the lethality of the police force known as the Cheka. Cooperation is always better for the formation and success of any government, new or old.
15:09
Y’all need to do a jurisprudence philosopher videos. I.e., Hans Kelsen, Dworkin, Kants, Fuller, Finnes, Rawls, etc.
Lots of detail nicely explained that I'd not been aware of or clear about concerning during those chaotic and confusing times. If nothing else, I think Lenin was sincere in his political beliefs whereas Stalin was an opportunist who built a personality cult around himself, leading to the loss of millions of innocent lives
Trying to answer your last question: violence and opression frequently are born out of fear. As Lenin was undoubtedly much more intellectually prepared than Stalin, he might eventually stay out of the development of such a totalitarian state when compared to the obsessive Stalin. But one should never forget, he was the one who layed the authoritharian initial landmarks of the Soviet Union, just like this documentary so brilliantly stated
It didn't help anyway, they talk badly about any communist leaders))). The opposition of Stalin to Lenin - this was the beginning of the scrapping of socialism in the USSR. An old bourgeois fairy tale..
Well no. Both Lennin and Trotsky wanted a period of socialism to keep foreign banks and create a wealthy state before enforcing communism. Stalin only did what Lennin would have done had he seen that the socialism they imposed was bringing about a want of monetary independence and capitalism amongst the people. Stalin chose the enforcement of radical communism to destroy any thought or want of capitalism among the people. Crushing them and binding them to nationalised factories and farms without any hopes of socialism.
@@stephan6372 The funniest thing is that "under Stalin" there was more capitalism than under Khrushchev (!) - these are collective farms, private collective farming on national land.
Lenin and Nicholas was acquainted????
Hi
Thank you for the translation , one of my best channels in RUclips ❤🎉
Бабушка за два месяца до смерти, предупредила, чтобы никогда не отпускал детей одних, особенно весной мальчиков до 14 лет, так как в Гайне жи ды му... детей.
Do Belisarius! The last Román!
1 марта бабушке чем-то ударили, жидкость в ушах была и синие ногти, 5марта умерла, хоронили, как Л. И. Брежнева, резко опустили и с грохотом вниз..
A wave of leader s then another wave of Russian leaders keep s on coming
Holy Emperor of Russian people!
Can you do More Nazi profiles fantastic work
No one Romanov was born with Russian name No one was born in Russia
APPOINTED BY GOD ? When was the ceremony? Who was there ? Was God present, and if so which one ?
So many questions, always the same answer, you simply have to trust them and GOD told them that they were in charge.
Thought Out Human History Thousands And Thousands Gods Came And Gone , God Is Mortal , But Lenin Is Immortal, He's Closer To Concept Of God , Than The God Himself
Evil, just like Stalin!
@@jennklein1917 What Would You Say About Any Number of European Kings , Whose Death Counts , Are In Multiple Times Than of Even Hitler
Way to confusing. Make your head spin
What clear eyed beautiful people the romanovs were. They seem to have a halo of light around them. They trued to evolve but radixals were too plentiful wanting instant change. What a shame tgevoeasant revolted.
I love Russia and the Romanovs 😊❤. Thank you.
The only redeeming quality of the romanovs is they were so incompetent that they helped stomp out monarchy in Europe.
You can't love the Russian Federation and the Russian Empire at the same time. It's contradictory to do so.
@@zHoody THEY don't give A fuck)))
no sense making comments there is no logical order of following some ones comment with your own reply . no threads or linkage . what nerdy" genius " designed this nonsense .
UKR
Thanks to communists for aiding in the liberation of africa.
Lot of misleading stories. No answer who did what and why?
Rest in Peace to the royal martyrs
Yes. A loss of a great bloodline. Inherited disorders aside.
The Great Imposter.
1 And it came to pass that the angel spake unto me, saying: Look! And I looked and beheld many nations and kingdoms.
2 And the angel said unto me: What beholdest thou? And I said: I behold many nations and kingdoms.
3 And he said unto me: These are the nations and kingdoms of the Gentiles.
4 And it came to pass that I saw among the nations of the Gentiles the formation of a great church.
5 And the angel said unto me: Behold the formation of a church which is most abominable above all other churches, which slayeth the saints of God, yea, and tortureth them and bindeth them down, and yoketh them with a yoke of iron, and bringeth them down into captivity.
6 And it came to pass that I beheld this great and abominable church; and I saw the devil that he was the founder of it.
7 And I also saw gold, and silver, and silks, and scarlets, and fine-twined linen, and all manner of precious clothing; and I saw many harlots.
8 And the angel spake unto me, saying: Behold the gold, and the silver, and the silks, and the scarlets, and the fine-twined linen, and the precious clothing, and the harlots, are the desires of this great and abominable church.
9 And also for the praise of the world do they destroy the saints of God, and bring them down into captivity.
- 1 Nephi 13:1-9
The Book of Mormon
Sounds like alexie was a traitor.
SORRY TO INTERRUPT YOU TANK BUT JUSTICE FOR ALL WAS NEVER WHAT YOU WERE ABOUT YOU WERE ABOUT GET WHITEY REMEMBER😂
1:11:00 +
“Could the horrors of communist rule in the 20th century have been avoided?”
What hypocrisy. The USSR is the greatest power that has existed in the entire history of mankind. It was the USSR that destroyed Nazi Germany, grinding about 80% of all divisions of the Wehrmacht and their allies. It was the USSR that sent mankind's first satellite into space! It was the USSR that sent the first man into space! It was the USSR that first explored Venus! It was the USSR that carried a good message to all humanity - “workers (proletarians) of all countries - be united!” It was in the USSR that an incredible number of peoples lived together in friendship and harmony. The USSR, socialism, communism is a utopia that humanity has not yet reached. The world is driven by imperialism, capitalism, where deception and exploitation of other people are profitable, leaving workers in poverty, while making profit. Wolf Society.
If it weren't for the fear of the monstrous, cannibalistic mass murderers like Lenin and his gang, if it weren't for the fear from the barbaric regime and ideology of the USSR, the western powers would have dealt with Hitler and his brand of human garbage in good time.