RHS Salamis (NB) - Guide 067

Поделиться
HTML-код
  • Опубликовано: 1 окт 2024
  • The battleship Salamis of the Greek Navy is today's subject.
    Next on the list:
    -B-65 class (NB)
    -Deutschland class (pre-Dreadnought)
    -G3 class (NB)
    -USS North Carolina
    -Tillman Battleship Special
    -Deutschland class (1930)
    -KMS Graf Spee
    -Tone class
    -HMS Warrior (1860)
    -IRN Potemkin
    -Hipper class
    -KMS Prinz Eugen
    -Yamato class
    -Italia class
    -Tsesarevich
    -Βασίλισσα Ολγα (Basilissa Olga)
    -Nagato class
    -Monitor Parnaiba
    -G-class destroyer
    -HMS Glowworm
    -Town class cruisers
    -USS Wichita
    -Lord Nelson class
    -Essex class
    -Slava (Pre-dreadnought)
    -USS Massachusetts
    -Pensacola class
    -HIJMS Oyodo
    -Riachuelo (NB)
    -I-19
    -HMS Ark Royal
    -ORP Błyskawica
    -USS West Virginia
    -Amagi Class
    -Tosa Class
    -Alaska class
    -Derfflinger class
    -Yorktown class
    -Tre Kronor class
    -Nelson class
    -Gato class
    -Admiralen class
    -H class (NB)
    -Greek 'Monarch' class destroyers
    -'Habbakuk' project
    -USS Texas
    -USS Olympia
    -HIJMS Mikasa
    -County class
    -KMS Tirpitz
    -Montana class
    -Florida class
    -USS Salt Lake City
    -Storozhevoy
    -Flower class
    -USS San Juan
    -HMS Sheffield
    -USS Alaska
    -USS Texas
    -USS Johnston
    -Dido class
    -Hunt class
    -HMS Vanguard
    -Mogami class
    -Almirante Grau
    -Surcouf
    -Von der Tann
    -Massena
    Specials:
    -Fire Control Systems
    -Protected Cruisers
    -Scout Cruisers
    -Naval Artillery
    -Tirpitz (damage history)

Комментарии • 67

  • @kapasvonkapas
    @kapasvonkapas 6 лет назад +68

    At the end of the day, historical circumstances spared the Greek navy from the huge cost of up-keeping a weapon of deterrence, that wasnt really needed. Averof and the two Mississippis got a second lease of life as coastal defence ships. Averof might never have survived to our day, if Salamis was delivered.

    • @neniAAinen
      @neniAAinen 4 года назад +4

      It's very questionable if 3 pre dreadnoughts are cheaper than one small super dreadnought

    • @kapasvonkapas
      @kapasvonkapas 4 года назад +2

      ​@@neniAAinen True. Certainly as far as manpower is concerned. But as Kilkis and Lemnos were gradually phased out after the mid 1930s because they were considered redundant for a deterrence against the Turkish navy, a small super dreadnought would been seen the same.

    • @commodorezero
      @commodorezero 4 года назад

      @@kapasvonkapas Then why did the Turks keep Yayuz?

    • @commodorezero
      @commodorezero 4 года назад

      @@kapasvonkapas But fueling and manning the thing long term was not free, especially given it was faster. And the German crew went home after WW1 I'm assuming, Ottomans still need to crew the thing. And if one heavy unit is even close to the same price the Salamis is a way better deal than the 2 barely semi dreadnoughts and the armored cruiser. Salamis was a much better counter to the Yayuz than the semi dreadnoughts and Avarof. And Yayuz was Turkey's only heavy unit as a result of a lot of circumstances. Lots of minor navy maintained more heavy units.

    • @kapasvonkapas
      @kapasvonkapas 4 года назад +1

      @@commodorezero I'm still not sure what is your question exactly.

  • @LordDim1
    @LordDim1 6 лет назад +116

    In the Hearts of Iron 4 alternate history mod Kaiserreich, where Germany wins WWI, the Salamis is completed by imperial Germany post war, and is eventually bought by a restored Qing Empire (which the Germans restore after an intervention in China in 1926), and turned into the flagship of the Qing navy, the battleship Wuwei

    • @Rangerage
      @Rangerage 5 лет назад +23

      They also buy some older pre-dreads at the same time for a bargain price! I designed the new navies around the world as part of the naval rework and the Qing was about the only home I could find or Salamis.

    • @sadness3337
      @sadness3337 4 года назад +2

      New Pan Asian ship(pretty much the same thing as the dds, take a existing dd from another nation change name and say it is a new ship)

    • @datadavis
      @datadavis 3 года назад +2

      Nerds

    • @akriegguardsman
      @akriegguardsman 2 года назад

      Why did they call it dreadnought in chinese?

    • @kyle_mk17
      @kyle_mk17 Месяц назад

      ​@@Rangeragewhy not Greece?

  • @brownwrench
    @brownwrench 4 года назад +12

    Suddenly I have the urge to go make a sandwich.

  • @davidgellatly1975
    @davidgellatly1975 5 лет назад +16

    Please do a video on the US Cost Guard Treasury class cutters (Campbell, Spencer, Duane, Bibb, Hamilton & Taney) Launched in 1936, some of them served for over half century through the Vietnam war. Ship for ship they were also the most successful ASW class in the US navy.

  • @patrickmcleod111
    @patrickmcleod111 5 лет назад +14

    Was America the ONLY country capable of producing naval cannons in the early 1900s?? How many times did we hear that "the ship was built in country A or country B, but the guns were built in America"? It was an ongoing theme in this video!

    • @willyjimmy8881
      @willyjimmy8881 5 лет назад +4

      Other countries could build guns, but the best guns were American.

    • @neniAAinen
      @neniAAinen 4 года назад +15

      @@willyjimmy8881 They were most definitely not. Not yet.
      They were cheaper to get than british/german ones, though.

  • @kentlindal5422
    @kentlindal5422 3 года назад +8

    Will we ever get a breakdown of her performance verse the HMAS Havarti and HMCS Rye?

  • @richardcutts196
    @richardcutts196 6 лет назад +10

    What about the guns planned for the Mackensen class Battlecruisers? Couldn't those have been used?

    • @richardcutts196
      @richardcutts196 Год назад

      I have since found out that the turrets and their barbettes for the German guns were considerably larger than the US guns. Apparently it would have required a major alteration to fit German (Krupp) guns and turrets to the ship.

  • @petros311
    @petros311 6 лет назад +18

    another nice video. do you think Drachinifel what design was better seakeeping abilities? the first with 3 turrets or the second? even with the first they were objections from the greek navy officers and the britain navy mission on greek navy that the ship was too small on the first design! the only reason they were wanted to make the battleship small as possible was cost, they feel they could not obtain the neccessary founds the make it a full super dreadnought ship.

    • @Drachinifel
      @Drachinifel  6 лет назад +12

      The first one was theoretically better for balance but being so small would probably still have had issues. The larger designhad more displacement to absorb motion so overall would have been better in rough seas despite the greater top-weight.

    • @johnivkovich8655
      @johnivkovich8655 5 лет назад +2

      What a great question.

  • @joedunlea3755
    @joedunlea3755 6 лет назад +14

    Any chance you could do a video on the R class or HMS Royal Oak?

    • @Drachinifel
      @Drachinifel  6 лет назад +6

      Joe Dunlea sure

    • @joedunlea3755
      @joedunlea3755 6 лет назад +1

      Drachinifel thank you!! Your videos are great by the way!

  • @rampantrelichunteruk666
    @rampantrelichunteruk666 6 лет назад +11

    Another super upload can't wait to see the others listed
    Top job onice again

  • @cadengrace5466
    @cadengrace5466 6 лет назад +7

    Very nicely done. Interesting and plenty of ship-porn.

  • @mikearmstrong8483
    @mikearmstrong8483 3 года назад +3

    Did I miss something? The video was entirely about a ship that, in the end, wasn't built? I thought there was a Salamis, sunk by German planes in WWII.

    • @kaymeinhold
      @kaymeinhold 3 года назад +3

      I guess you mean RHS Kilkis (formally known as USS Mississippi) sunk on April the 23rd by Stukas in Salamis Naval Base?

    • @mikearmstrong8483
      @mikearmstrong8483 3 года назад +2

      @@kaymeinhold
      Yep. I knew I had seen a picture of it sunk in port, without remembering the name. Went back to my good old fashioned hard cover sources, and there it was. I guess you know your naval history.

    • @nervun8097
      @nervun8097 2 года назад

      There have been many Greek ships called Salamis. Heck we've even made a whole class of ships called the Salamis-class

  • @klipsfilmsmelbourne
    @klipsfilmsmelbourne 6 лет назад +7

    This warship design looks better without 5th turret in the mid section between the 2 funnel

    • @scarecrow2097
      @scarecrow2097 2 года назад

      There's no 5th turret, those are lifeboats

  • @parsecboy4954
    @parsecboy4954 5 лет назад +11

    Amusingly, the pencil sketch of the ship in its imagined German guise is actually Lützow. I fixed this on the Wiki article more than two years ago, but somehow Drachinifel missed the boat on that one.

    • @Drachinifel
      @Drachinifel  5 лет назад +8

      You are correct, the picture I had labelled as Salamis was one I had saved from years ago and forgotten exactly where it had come from. Will correct at some point when I upgrade the voice-over.

    • @parsecboy4954
      @parsecboy4954 5 лет назад +2

      @@Drachinifel You got it from Wikipedia (assuming you didn't get it from the same place I did) - I had uploaded the image there several years ago without looking at it closely enough - it turned out that the journal I found it in had mislabeled the images. Somebody else on Wiki noticed the images weren't right a few years back, and we got them sorted out.

  • @DIEGhostfish
    @DIEGhostfish 5 лет назад +11

    The Salamis should be finished by UC0070, with... More than a few upgrades.

    • @Tuning3434
      @Tuning3434 5 лет назад +3

      ...and "will be jumping on White Base"

  • @chrisjung3538
    @chrisjung3538 7 месяцев назад

    Top ces vidéos sur les warship . Très intéressantes et très complètes. Dommage qu’il n’y a pas de sous-titres en français.😀

  • @Παν.Κεφ
    @Παν.Κεφ 5 лет назад +2

    Do a video with the Greek destroyer Velos

  • @jukkakopol7355
    @jukkakopol7355 5 лет назад +1

    finnish submarines.... with deepcharges

  • @juri8723
    @juri8723 6 лет назад +20

    poor Greece :( they had to fight Islam all on their own.

    • @ankawarrio9800
      @ankawarrio9800 5 лет назад +1

      Weedus first we in nato because we try to modernise and we succeded second turkey arms extreme fast its like burning ball thats because islam isint a fact

    • @johnivkovich8655
      @johnivkovich8655 5 лет назад +1

      I think you should look at pre-WW1 history in the Balkans.

  • @toddcraig6150
    @toddcraig6150 6 лет назад +1

    USS Nevada the only BB to get underway at Pearl Harbor in WW 2 what ever happened to her

    • @Drachinifel
      @Drachinifel  6 лет назад +6

      Had a pretty decent war, survived a couple of atomic bomb blasts, then Iowa failed to sink her as a target so she was ultimately put down by multiple aerial attacks.

  • @suburban404
    @suburban404 5 лет назад +2

    What are the cylindrical objects along the hull?

    • @P99AT
      @P99AT 4 года назад +4

      They could be mountings for anti-torpedo netting, but I'm not sure.

    • @babylon218
      @babylon218 4 года назад +4

      If you mean the diagonal tubes going along the hull on the sketch image, they're the booms for the anti-torpedo nets. When the ship is stationary (such as at anchor) the booms are swung out and nets hung from them to catch any torpedoes before they can impact the ship. They were surprisingly effective, but they couldn't be used while underway because the nets could get caught in the ship's propeller shafts, and torpedoes would start to incorporate special spinning blades to cut through the nets.

  • @danhammond8406
    @danhammond8406 3 года назад

    Thought it would be a salami sub...
    I'll see myself out

  • @peregrinemccauley5010
    @peregrinemccauley5010 3 года назад

    I know boats .

  • @skyportalmusic7178
    @skyportalmusic7178 3 года назад

    Jesus Loves You

  • @kennethdeanmiller7324
    @kennethdeanmiller7324 2 года назад +1

    Wtf. The ship that was built but not actually finished. And so it never had a crew so it never sailed or whatever. The battleship that was never a battleship.

  • @klipsfilmsmelbourne
    @klipsfilmsmelbourne 6 лет назад

    Queen Elizabeth class vs salamis

    • @AB-fe3eu
      @AB-fe3eu 2 года назад +1

      QE would've annihilated them lmao

  • @firstperson7602GMAIL
    @firstperson7602GMAIL 6 лет назад +11

    I wondered what happened to some of our first gen BB's. Mississippi and Idaho went to Greece. Don't know who got the worst of that deal, the BB's or the Greeks. Great videos, keep them coming!

    • @lexmaximaguy8788
      @lexmaximaguy8788 6 лет назад +9

      both were sunk by german bombers in 41 i believe.

    • @pickeljarsforhillary102
      @pickeljarsforhillary102 6 лет назад +16

      The Greeks, despite being a 3rd rate navy, actually kept very good care of their name and performed the required maintenance. The same cannot be said of the Ottomans.

    • @classifiedad1
      @classifiedad1 5 лет назад +4

      The BBs the Greeks bought weren't very good for US requirements due to their short range and poor rough-weather handling.
      Thing is, the Mediterranean isn't very big, and is (mostly) quite calm in comparison to the Atlantic Ocean which feeds it. So the fact they can't go very far isn't an issue when you'd be hard pressed to go that far because the Mediterranean isn't big, and sucking in rough weather wasn't an issue when rough weather wasn't going to be such a big issue in a place where rough weather isn't as rough.