Guestsplaining 043: Transgender Apologetics with Brandon Vogt

[@rshier8422]

❤❤three amazing Catholics whose light shines from within. Thank you for your ministry. God Bless❤❤🙏📿✝✝

[@RebbeYehoshuahLamberti]

Idolatry, a combination of Greek And Roman pagan beliefs, learned from Babylon but modified.

[@aiantenor9080]

Thank you so much for this. God bless.

[@Godsplaining]

God bless! Thank you for tuning in!

[@MargaretUIUC]

Brandon almost has enough books to be a Dominican.

[@RebbeYehoshuahLamberti]

Idolatry, a combination of Greek And Roman pagan beliefs, learned from Babylon but modified.

[@HoMegasTaxiarches]

@@RebbeYehoshuahLambertiyou should be a comedian, my friend 😂😂😂

[@fennycruz6714]

Brandon vogt... wow! A delight to see 3 of you together.

[@drewhodge]

Thanks very much to all three of you--you've shown us the right way, and the compassionate way, to approach this topic.

[@TrixRN]

Brandon’s approach is so loving. I really appreciate his advice on how to handle a situation if you’re not prepared.
I frequently watch Matt Walsh, but lately he has become strident in his tone & harsh in his words. I can understand because he feels his children are in danger, literal physical, emotional, & spiritual danger. He sees what’s happening in our culture as an existential threat & his protective instincts are aroused.

[@tactics40]

All sympathy goes out to those caught up in this issue. And interpersonal dialog should proceed just as Brandon is advocating.
However --- We should be extremely harsh with the people who are propagating this agenda. At a political level, we should be clear that if the political tide were to turn, we would be willing prosecute this as severely as any crime could be anyone who knowingly caused damage to a child's body or mind for the sake of Trans ideology.
If you don't know about him, check out Benjamin Boyce's channel. He has the best interviews of those who have reversed their 'transition'. Each of his guests are heartbreaking, and we should treat each such person with the dignity they deserve.
But may anyone who pushes a child into this crap burn in Hell forever.

[@TrixRN]

@@tactics40 I subbed to his channel after I looked at his content. Wish he would break up some of the long form vids into episodes by conversational topics like Matt Fradd does on Pints with Aquinas. Thanks for the recommendation ❤️
Yes I agree harder stance needs to be taken at the political level.

[@RebbeYehoshuahLamberti]

Idolatry, a combination of Greek And Roman pagan beliefs, learned from Babylon but modified.

[@jesipohl6717]

What is your stance on intersex people who are neither male nor female? Do you want to eradicate them? Do you believe they are evil for identifying as men or women as most Do or are assigned at birth before genetic testing?
You are all just bigots, any collateral damage is acceptable in your quest to dominate others with a faith born of fear and power over the weak.
Shame on you.

[@maryspencer4274]

Oviedo wow, probably knew my brother and family (Catholic/Baptist), both of you. I loved living in Winter Park, Oviedo and Geneva and San Pedro back when.

[@RebbeYehoshuahLamberti]

Idolatry, a combination of Greek And Roman pagan beliefs, learned from Babylon but modified.

[@lovehappiness3911]

I pray for the repose soul of Bishop O'Connell pray 🙏
Jesus please protect our priests and Pope Francis ✝

[@vtop1c]

A lot of people seem to have forgotten the proper word for the "argument from suicide". It's called emotional blackmail. People who have had narcissistic partners or family members know, that this is a very common manipulation tactic.

[@bobandkelly]

I think Fr Pine's point, if I understood it correctly, was a good one. If we think of people with dementia for example, who have no framework to be told that they are not thinking clearly or are not in reality, who actually do not benefit from being told that, ie; your husband has died and has not just gone to the store for milk -- I understand that not everyone with dysphoria will fall into this category -- but one really does not want to bring a person to face the rhe truth if they are literally not able to.
I find this a difficult spot to be in.

[@MartinMartin-bh4ke]

it really is not a difficult thing to understand.
1.
Body identity integrity disorder = the urge to have a limb removed and live as a disabled person
2.
Transgenderism = the urge to have secondary sexual traits removed and live as a disabled person
3.
Simple as

[@jesipohl6717]

Statistics show, most trans people do not have surgery or hormones nor desire them.
Affirmative care is usually anti-discrimination and anti-abuse follow-up care that helps a person come to terms with the problems they face as they come out.
Intersex people exist, are not biologically binary, yet still have gender; or do you dispute this as well. Do you just wish to eradicate biological differences too? Before trans activism intersex people would be routinely operated on by you lot at birth. It is only because of trans activists insistence on "listening to kids" that this brutal practice is now illegal in most of the world and intersex kids get to decide before puberty. In fact, as for trans kids, until puberty begins, there is no possible medical intervention anyways and my understanding as a catholic is that I come of age to define myself at 7 years old. So should we worry about the abuse and indoctrination of helpless children by catholic ideology? I trust kids personally. 7 is the age of reason.
A commitment to the church is no less serious than a commitment to ones own personhood.
You people make me sick to think that such mindless stupidity-fueled hate can exist.

[@wendyposh7714]

In addictions we know that no matter what one does not do or do not do causes a person to substance abuse. In gender dysphoria would that principle apply? How can I cause a person to commit suicide if my conscious is clear? What would be those virtues to strengthen? Fallen angels had contempt for God’s creation, human beings

[@RebbeYehoshuahLamberti]

Idolatry, a combination of Greek And Roman pagan beliefs, learned from Babylon but modified.

[@OrigenisAdamantios]

CRAZY, NOT INSANE

[@joe1940]

It's called demon possession.

[@RebbeYehoshuahLamberti]

Idolatry, a combination of Greek And Roman pagan beliefs, learned from Babylon but modified.

[@awreckingball]

Video starts at 7:07

[@margueritelangton6362]

There ARE people who's genders were misread at birth, and they are raised as the wrong gender. They often present very early, and the first thing which should be done is a genetic profile. They can often present at puberty, when the appropriate hormones are secreted. Same applies. From there the appropriate action can be taken. Taking them seriously is the first step.

[@zenuno6936]

@@livenotbylies True, also the trans narrative has contagion effect as we see from this one school in England having 70 'trans' kids, so, its not a congenital issue like that of the hermaphrodites, but of people in schools and media pushing this onto the kids.

[@marysanchez6382]

Three of my favorite men! God bless you!

[@samuelaliren870]

Cope

[@zenuno6936]

@@livenotbylies True. By hermaphrodite i was referring to those bird defects, not that there were people who could produce both gametes like some animals can.

[@MartinMartin-bh4ke]

Your entire Gender Theory ideology is based on the work of Dr. John Money a psychiatrist who experimented with David Reimer when David was a baby.
He would have David and his Brother reenact sexual positions, missionary, doggy style etc.
Totally not a Chomo, nope...
Body identity integrity disorder = the urge to have a limb removed and live as a disabled person
Transgenderism = the urge to have secondary sexual traits removed and live as a disabled person
Simple as

[@carolynkimberly4021]

What would you say to Pope Francis who parades in homosexual couples and transgender ones and openly accepts them as being compatible with the Catholic Faith?

[@johndouglas4826]

Where in his magisterium is this taught? I would also say in his non-magisterial content he has denounced this. As long as you're not saying that in his encyclicals or documents he's taught error.

[@carolynkimberly4021]

@@johndouglas4826 Francis teaches ERROR constantly. He began his pontificate signaling approval for a practicing homosexual priest couple, "Who am I to judge"? Then he wrote Amoris Latitia, an encyclical allowing couples living in adultery to receive Communion. How about his leading veneration of the pagan fertility god, Pachamama followed by allowing Chinese Communists to pick bishops. Then he signed a document with a Muslim Imam that multiple religions are the Divine Will. In Canada he again took part in a pagan smudging rite calling on the Western ancestor God's.

[@johndouglas4826]

@@carolynkimberly4021 could you quote those problematic lines within amoris latita? Pachamama is not a teaching of the magesterium so that's again personal stuff remember just because someone holds the papal office doesn't make them a saint

[@carolynkimberly4021]

@@johndouglas4826 The Pachamama was introduced at Francis' Amazonian Council, pagan dirt and plant desecrated the altar during his Mass in St. Peter's broadcasted to the world. The purpose was to teach inculturation--that the Church must learn from pagan religious rites rather than teach the Truth of the Apostolic rites. It was another showboating of the Modernist error of ecumenism -- that other religions are in themselves sources of grace. As I remember, it was page 380 that held the false teaching on adultery. Francis later doubled down by saying that what the bishops were teaching in Argentina was the correct way to interpret his teaching. Don't you read his encyclicals or even watch videos or TV? Wake up. We are stuck with a Pope who appears to be an heretic.

[@carolynkimberly4021]

@@johndouglas4826 That's exactly what I'm saying.