Better than Pink Floyd! Ukrainian housewife exceeded the legendary rock band on X Factor
HTML-код
- Опубликовано: 11 сен 2024
- Alexandrova Tatiana came to the scene of The X-Factor. Family problems left a mark on her life and closed the way onto the stage. But X-Factor 8 is a new round, a chance to return.
Will the judge get a start in a new life?
↓ More useful below! ↓
Subscribe to the Ukrainian X-Factor RUclips channel: goo.gl/GHyysh
X Factor in Facebook: / xfactorua
X Factor in Instagram / xfactorstb
This woman was incredible. See, there’s terrible, bad, average, decent, good, great, incredible, and Pink Floyd. But nobody beats Pink Floyd. Nobody.
Idk abt that but Pink Floyd’s great
Clare can't be beat, i dare to say her work on this song is the best vocal performance ever. At least for me.
Actually nobody beat Clare Torry, the original singer. This was great though,
This is the correct comment
Doesn't hit A5 and can't compare to Clare Torry... sorry, not even close.
Not a bad effort but lets remember that Claire Torrey made this up on the spot and recorded it in one take - surely the most amazing piece of improv in music history
Indeed
@@jonasfavela6909 Y'all got that right!
Yes, but the judges don't know / knew what Pink Floyd is. lol.
Torrey is ok, but find The Great Gig in the Sky - Rachel Fury
No one exceeds the legendary Pink Floyd. No one. Ever.
Straight up facts
Queen..
@@rafial1000 Lol that's subjective
The Beatles
@@First-Name--Last-Name I will concede a draw!
Nothing is better than Pink Floyd!!
Technically it's Clare Torry
Continuous bordem You definitely right ! Originals are always be the best and nothing is better than period !
Obvius
liveapk25 technically it’s a lowrey mixer gone controlled wild with her voice triggering the ride. Everyone has heard “acoustic feedback” but nobody has done it like Pink Floyd - that requires a genius or three and Bray studios.
Nothing and no one.
Считаю это произведение одним из величайших вокальных творений современности !Достойное исполнение !
This girl is pretty damned awesome and has a great set of pipes but...
No one will ever top Clare Torry's performance on Dark Side.
Try Eva Avila of Brit Floyd......think you'll be surprised!
Aucune puissance dans la voix et personne ne peut égaler Lady Clare Torry's ❤️
@@troikafloyd Eva is great but not as good as the beautiful woman from ATOM singing great gig.
She even slays Claire's pipes.
Amen to that!!
@@troikafloyd she is not as good as Clare but yes your right she is pretty damn amazing too
She sang probably the most difficult song in the world to sing and did a great performance.
Я только уже за один выбор песни,ее в финал напрямую отправил бы!
Она взяла сложную партию. УВАЖЕНИЕ !
Ну песня просто разьеб
@@МирныйвоинКазахстан☠️
It warms my heart to hear great vocals no matter where on this little planet their are . Rock and roll forever !!!
With those vocals, even her eyes changed color. Wow.
She didn't sing a word, but she hit every note. Even the notes, she didn't hit. Fantastic!
she has expressed herself....the voice is coming from the heart..
I speak no Russian, but this chick blew it out of the ball park. It may have been slightly different from the original, but she put heart and soul into it and made it her own.
I'd say a bit difficult to exact Torrys rendition. Note per note in 2 mins
Dreadful
She is a lot different from the original, but I like that rock claw in her voice. She is good! really good. Greetings from Poland.
Слушая, в т.ч Pink уже вот более 45 лет, уверен в замечательном таланте А. Татьяны и в не менее шикарном исполнении вечного и тоже гениального произведения Пинков...
Весьма посредственно,по сравнению даже с Клэр Торри,да.Но такой уж уровень Х-фактора.
Wow...God Bless this woman. Don't know her age but I give her alot of credit for tackling this solo vocal challenge. I wish i could understand their critique but I know they LOVED her.
thank you! :) I'm so tired of all the critical comments. I'd like to see THEM try to take on this song.
She did an incredible job! Truly a talented woman to be able to handle such a difficult vocal.
Duh she didnt handle shit she was horrible
She absolutely nailed it, and despite sounding simple this is an incredibly difficult to sing piece of music. Bravo !!!
She made the song her own and nailed it. Impressive!
Foi o que me impressionou também. Ela não imitou Clare Torry, mas fez sua própria leitura e interpretação.
You know, instead of whining all the time, you could appreciate her performance. And thank her for sharing this masterpiece to younger audience.
Don't be so self-entitled.
Слушая её, забыла дышать. Вот только почувствовала, сколько в ней боли....Она вся в песне, как на ладони, как оголённый нерв. До мурашек, до слёз...Просто крик души. Браво, Танюша ! Браво.......
Perfectly spoken...
Обратная сторона Луны это классика мирового рока также как и ,,Стена,, Мало кто на таких конкурсах решитса исполнить вещь из репертуара легендарных Pink Floyd.Браво!!!
Впервые захотелось копировать ссылку, и потом в тишине вечера слушать и прослушивать не один раз! Потрясающе! Девушка необыкновенная вокалистка!
Даааа!!! Был некоторый скепсис, особенно и именно по поводу ЭТОЙ нетленной вещи, любимой моей группы, но ТАК она её спела… У меня нет слов. Браво!
It was fantastic. I make it a habit of listening to Pink Floyd 2 hours a day. I love other versions, someone else’s rendition. Awesome
Тот кто слушает Пинк Флойд обычно имеет хороший жизненный опыт...Музыка для интеллекта... Девушка этот опыт имеет плюс вокал👍
ПФ слушаю этак примерно с 1980г. А на счет жизненного опыта, хороший\плохой, кто знает -))
Мне 27 сейчас. Родителям спасибо, за хороший привитый музыкальный вкус. Пинк Флойд слушаю где-то с 19-ти.
Татьяна! Если вы читаете, знайте - те чувства, которые остались глубоко в душе, уйдут. Вы достойны большего.
ОСОБЕННО с такими способностями. Вы молодец. И скажу более - вы первая из всех конкурсантов от исполнения песни которой пробрали мурашки по телу.
100% , те же чувства! Первый исполнитель, который зацепил!
It was beautiful and emotional the first time I ever heard it.
And, still is...
Well done.
That was a Good Gig in the Sky, not a Great Gig in the Sky
U mean that was a bad gig in the sky
I'd say it was an okay gig in the sky. If you don't know music, even a good one.
;)
Dean Galloway let’s hear you sing then? Expert.....
@Intelligentlittlebat I don't think Dean Galloway was trying to say HE can do better, only that this chick is not as good as Clare Torry, which I agree with.
Clare Torry is unsurpassed anyway.
The WHOLE WORLD knows and LOVES Pink Floyd in any language.♥️♥️♥️♥️
Танюша! Мир Вам и Вашей семье! Круто!!!
Я помню исполнение данной композиции в Одессе с Pink Floyd tribute - мурашки и таракашки бегали по коже. Поклонники оркестра Харди гордятся Татьяной - Умница! Желаем победы!
Отличный голос, шикарный выбор песни и крутое исполнение) Не часто Пинков берут на кастинг
Love the grit...took balls to do live! Thumbs up!
you dont dare to sing a song like that ,but she dare and she was amazing ,well done ...
Это одновременно ужас и восторг. Слушаешь, вдыхаешь, а выдохнуть не можешь! Обалдеть, как мощно и невероятно эмоционально. Пожалуйста, продолжайте.
These vocals translate so well. What a great job she did.
Крик - тоже система слов песни. У кого-то крик - голос души. Это прекрасно)))
The song began life as a Richard Wright chord progression, known variously as "The Mortality Sequence" or "The Religion Song". During 1972 it was performed live as a simple organ instrumental, accompanied by spoken-word samples from the Bible and snippets of speeches by Malcolm Muggeridge, a British writer known for his conservative religious views. When the band came to record Dark Side in 1973, the lead instrument had been switched to a piano. Various sound effects were tried over the track, including recordings of NASA astronauts communicating on space missions, but none were satisfactory. Finally, a couple of weeks before the album was due to be finished, the band thought of having a female singer "wail" over the music.
Clare Torry's vocals
As the band began casting around for a singer, album engineer Alan Parsons suggested Clare Torry, a 25-year-old songwriter and session vocalist. Parsons had previously worked with Torry, and had liked her voice on a compilation album of covers.[3] An accountant from Abbey Road Studios called Dennis contacted Torry and tried to arrange a session for the same evening, but she was initially unenthusiastic. Torry was not a particular fan of Pink Floyd, and she had various other commitments, including, she later admitted, tickets to see Chuck Berry that evening.[4] Eventually, however, a session was scheduled for the following Sunday.
The band played the instrumental track for Torry and asked her to improvise a vocal. At first, Torry struggled to divine what the band wanted, but then she was inspired to pretend that she herself was an instrument.[5] She performed two complete takes, the second one more emotional than the first. David Gilmour asked for a third take, but halfway through Torry stopped, feeling she was getting repetitive and had already done the best she could. The final album track was assembled from all three takes. The members of the band were deeply impressed by Torry's performance, but were so reserved in their outward response that she left under the impression that her vocals would never make the final cut.[6] She only became aware they were used when she saw the album at a local record store, spotted her name in the credits and purchased it.
And what a beautiful instrument she played, thank you for the accurate history lesson for some of our younger friends out there.
Rockin Atheist
I once used her voice part of the song & made a 30 minute cassette tape of her singing that. I listened to it so much the cassette stopped working.. then i discovered the "cd" & didn't have to make cassettes any more. Technology is awesome!
Rockin Atheist thanks for sharing your knowledge on the history of this song
Rockin Atheist ... the only thing you didn't mention is that she was paid standard session work fees. I believe she made something like $200 for this, good money in 1972 but Pink Floyd has made many millions off Dark Side of the Moon - and her work was unquestionably a highlight.
Lo mejor y por siempre sera Pink Floyd
Великолепно! Аж мурашки по спине. Спасибо!!!
Thank you so much for not giving up.
Только недавно пересматривала ее первое выступление на Xфакторе года 2 назад, и вот она опять здесь, снова шедеврально.
Достойно то, что она это исполнила, отдельный респект за это...браво
В этой женщине 100% есть иксфактор!!! Голос и искуство владения им просто великолепное!!! Браво Таня!!!
Олег Кудря
Her ability to mix is off the charts..chest singing and head singing at the same time essentially. It INCREDIBLY difficult and many of the greats struggle to do it. She is def. Talented. Not better than pink floyd, BUT Woman on pink floyd album was a professional singer with YEARS of singing experience and lessons.
Absolutely beautiful
Nice pipes sister! Shine on you crazy diamond ...
мощно. классно спела
круто, что прошла дальше)
посмотрела-послушала на прошлой неделе. понравилось. а потом за неделю еще 10 раз включила себе именно ту часть, где она поет! круто! и не из-за истории и соплей вокруг, а именно само исполнение! круто!!!!
Послушай оригинал и тебя будет мутить от этой жалкой пародии.
Потрясающе пронзительно улёт молодчина браво!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
Сердючка оценивает. Что он сам может? ЧУДО. 👍
She’s definitely up there…❤️
But nothing beats the original!
It´s a great performance, no doubt about it, but it´s not even close to the original.
Raúl Guzmán thank you!!
Vanetta Fields sang the original...much, much better
Wrong. It was Claire Torry.
Yes, Claire Torry and don't forget Claire Torry is white!
And don't forget Claire Torry had just had a fight with her fella, hence the anx in her voice. This womans version is bloody awful!!!
It was an "ok gig in the sky" I'd suggest listen to original.
Clare Torry's original vocal was a masterpiece, but this lady can sing too
Not Bad At All Gig In The Sky.
good for you saying this! :)
Nope..NOTHING ...NO ONE BEATS PINK FLOYD! GILMORE! 💞
I always see this, with a title saying it’s better then the original song. People get mad at the singer, I hate it. They have no appreciation, this lady sang a pretty hard song. Those notes are spot on. The amount of octaves are in this song is allot. So be respectful for gods sakes
Huge voice, great heart.
What? Come on!
She's good but not better that Clare Torry.
Plus, she'd better write some master pieces to be better than Pink Floyd!
No se que dicen, pero una canción tan universal como TGGITS puede ser reinterpretada de muchas formas, y lo que logra esta dama es una hazaña increíble, no a la altura de Claire Torry pero si hace honor a su talento. She did it.
she is beautiful....and soulful.....and beautiful.......I am from Canada and 56 years new...for over a month I have watched this video every night and it helps me relax believe it or not....this woman knows pain and it is lovely to have company......comparing to Floyd???? who cares.................this woman has IT
Anybody else from the US wonder why Ruskies consistently have the best quality, most honest (and interesting) vids on RUclips these days? like this? whether you like her talent here or not? She's got a lot more on the ball than I do.
Very well done! from the heart and at the top of her range. Fearless and amazing.
I actually thought she was pretty amazing!
Check your hearing... seriously. Somethings wrong.
@@MeanGeneSanDiego She wasn’t that bad.
@@lucija3338 Check your hearing... seriously. Somethings wrong.😲
Please listen to an original song once again you will definitely change the name of the video
2021- yes you changed the name of the video
yea, right, but c'mon this one was good, you don't know how hard this song is
@@Jimmusicpersonal title of this video before changing was "better than original"...
This was very good. This woman was game and did really well. But the original can not be bested by anyone...EVER! I applaud her efforts.
Very entertaining. Quite talented. Just short of Clare. So far, I have not heard anything coming close to Clare Torry, nothing. In life sometimes, an event occurs that you know will never repeat again, that fateful day in 1973, such an event occured. Long Live the Queen! Cheers
Great sounding voice for sure. But I've never heard any one mach Clare Torry's original.
É de arrepiar.
Simplesmente perfeito!!!!
Better than Pink Floyd? U obviously never been to a Floyd concert. Let me know when this chick sells over 100 million albums and let me hear her out play David Gilmour on guitar.
Better than Pink Floyd?? I don't think so...there's only one and that's Pink Floyd.
Vic Manuel if u think this chick was better than Pink Floyd, than u have never listened to them play not to mention they all play instruments while a, she can do is sing. While she wasn’t actually singing any hung sung by Floyd and only sung a rendition of what Clare Torry sung, she did a great job but Torry was absolutely perfect pitch on The Great Gig in the Sky.
No contest Pink Floyd was one of of the first concerts I saw in 1973 and I don't want throw shade on her effort but I'd rather see Pink Floyd again than see her !
Well put brother👍
Okay. Not good, really, fair, workable, passion, yes, it was okay, but I'm sorry, it was not Pink Floyd.
Not even close! Fan of Floyd since the beginning! How could anyone say this is better?????
Truly amazing....gave me massive goosebumps...loved it.
Good but the hairs on the back of my neck did not stand straight up.
Молодчина
After listening to the original for all these years I've only just discovered it was sung by Claire torry.she gave the world something very special that will outlive us all...
Nothing is better than Pink Floyd,
I repeat NOTHING IS BETTER THAN PINK FLOYD ❤
Искренне и круто!Спасибо Татьяна!
2:54 the moment he knew when the drum is begin... I know he's the only one that noticed this is Pink Floyd 👏👏
мурааашки! по всему телу огромные мурашки! Татьяна, выбрасывайте остатки любви к тому, кто ее не заслуживает и живите полной счастливой жизнью! радости вам!
Why would anyone even TRY to cover this song?
Thats 'cause lots of people get big heads when some random passerby says "wow, great, you could be a star!"
Brit floyd
Its worth a try. Gotta stay humble somehow
Plenty of great covers. Relax.
Lilian Xemenes, Both McBroom sisters, Vivianne Donner, Eva Avila, Rachel Fury and Angela Cervantes ALL do pretty well...
I think the thing that makes the original version so special is it doesn’t seem contrived. This one is just that contrived
For all the snobbish haters, the original singer was NOT Pink Floyd. It was Clare Torry, a sessions vocalist who did that piece and it was assembled from her three takes! She was paid $200 and wasn’t a fan of Pink Floyd. For this girl to pull this off with no several takes and mixing is an extremely talented thing. I would put her right in the same talent as Clare Torres and that taking nothing from either one to do it.
Здорово.....
Very good but not better. Nice clickbait.
Le Perique no kidding.and it was pink Floyd back up singer that did that part,not pink Floyd
Clare Torry was a session singer, not a back up singer. In 2004, she sued Pink Floyd and EMI for songwriting royalties on the basis that her contribution to "The Great Gig in the Sky" constituted co-authorship with keyboardist Richard Wright. Originally, she was paid the standard flat fee of £30 for Sunday studio work. In 2005, an out-of-court settlement was reached in Torry's favour, although the terms of the settlement were not disclosed. All releases after 2005 carry an additional credit "Vocal composition by Clare Torry" for the "Great Gig in the Sky" segment.
Check out the female singer for the tribute band Brit Floyd, I will never say anyone was better than Clare Torry but Brit Floyd comes as close as you can get to being equal.
Sam Brown FTW!
Steve O and don't forget about Rachel Fury while they were on tours! Amazing performance, same level as Clare Torry.
I do not know what this was about...but, I liked it!
No one does the big gig in the sky better than Pink Floyd, the original singer, then my fav combo Rachel Fury Durga Mcbroom and Margaret Taylor
Она просто талантище. Чувствуют гармонию.немного есть погрешности.но это слышит только музыкант с обсалютным слухом.❤❤❤ну а в целом кайф.
Трудно осознавать , что сердючка (данилко) может оценивать , что либо из репертуара Pink Floyd.
100%
а шо не так с пинк флойдом?...займись серьёзно своим осознанием...или нада шото решать!!!
Воистину не понятно, что может соображать в музыке этот кривляка-трансвестит!
Он оценивает участника, а не пинк флойд.
Конечно не сравнить с оригиналом, но смело и совсем не плохо.
Я почемуто уверен, что Моцарта, Бетховена, Баха тоже играют не совсем похоже на оригинал....
Pink Floyd ушел в вечность.... И занял место среди Моцарта, Баха и Бетховена...
Сильно...
Pink Floyd is more than a voice, Pink Floyd is the Music of Generations. But the voice of this woman is good.
did someone say this was better than the og or sumn? why are all the top comments like “not as good as Pink Floyd!”? Intended or not, it’s a little toxic, SHE KILLED IT
3 women that did this in the concert in the sky were just phenomenal!!
She’s good but has few high notes???
ОБАЛДЕТЬ !!! .......Сколько в голосе боли , переживаний.... .
Хочу бачити у прямих ефірах.Чудовий вокаліст!Удачі!
Wow. Holly Jesus. The lung power and voice. Incredible 😲 😊
Wow! I love this, but especially at the 3:26 mark when this lioness roars. Just awesome!
A nice performance. I do however feel it missed the raw emotion of the original. Her control isn't as good as Claire Torries, but kudos for trying it. Nowhere to hide there!
Clare Torry.
There is no denying this woman has raw talent. That is a given. The question is, is she better than Clair? The answer is a resounding, "Hell, to the, No!" Go listen to the original and you see, talent that is not, raw!
БРАВО !!!
I give her an A for effort, however, nobody has ever sung it better than Clare Torry. Bianca Antoinette did a very admirable rendition.
Nothing can be better than Pink Floyd